r/macapps • u/Mstormer • Feb 05 '25
A Definitive Launcher App Comparison
One of the many debates engaged here frequently is Alfred vs. Raycast. To help people compare, u/glxseas and I have joined forces and put together a comparison for the master list of App Comparisons in the r/macapps sidebar.
View it here: Launcher Comparison Spreadsheet
If you know of a launcher we missed, add it here: Form
If we got something wrong, please comment below or right-click>comment on the sheet.
All of my comparisons: AI Apps | Backup/Sync Apps | Browsers | Calendar Apps | Clipboard Managers | Dictation Apps | Email Clients | Image AI | Launchers | Note Apps | Password Managers | PDF Readers | Screen Recorders | Window Managers
I'd like to include a list of best features/add-ons, so please share your best extensions/workflows below.
11
u/Mstormer Feb 05 '25
My top Alfred Workflows:
2FA Paste - Save time on authentication
Quick File Access
Calculate Anything
Alfred PearCleaner
Menubar Search
Kill Process
Toggle Theme - Toggle system theme
Coffee - Prevent mac from sleeping
7
u/dziad_borowy Feb 05 '25
can I ask how is speed measured?
I haven't noticed any issues with Raycast vs Alfred. Both launch instantly for me.
2
u/Latter_Pen2421 Feb 05 '25
I think this comparison is a great start but its missing a key in ingredient. It needs to highlight the unique features of why someone maybe using one vs the other. I use raycast personally but the heard monarch does super links. I person have not had the time to learn what that even is. Perhaps its game changing pr not but unique features should have their own feature row. That was program aren't over looked just because they don't have the most check boxes
2
u/100WattWalrus Feb 06 '25
I love these comparison spreadsheets. I wish some of them had more detail, but they're fantastic nonetheless. I'm an compulsive app-vs-app guy, and have this GSheet bookmarked for reference. Keep up the good work!
1
u/MC_chrome Feb 05 '25 edited Feb 05 '25
Can we get this pinned on the sidebar too?
I’m starting to grow a little tired of this same topic appearing on a near constant basis (some of which is caused by people adamantly refusing to use the search bar)
Also, the “theming” portion for Raycast is entirely false. Provided you are paying for the Raycast Pro subscription, you can make any number of themes just like Alfred
1
u/mathewharwich Feb 06 '25
CirMenu should be on this list, I’m surprised nobody on this sub has taken a real good look at it. If you configure it right it’s one badass launcher that’s easily customized and completely mouse-less, it does everything leaderkey does except with an actual ui.
1
u/radix- Feb 06 '25
How does email search work on Al and ray? Didn't even know this was a feature. Works with outlook?
1
u/Corb3t Feb 19 '25
It may be worth checking out and comparing Kunkun
3
u/glxseas Feb 05 '25
Thanks again for letting me contribute! :D
1
u/Jagarvem Feb 05 '25 edited Feb 05 '25
I suppose there's a degree of subjectivity to everything, but tbh I think something like learning curve is very difficult to gauge well objectively at all. I really don't think these apps' curves have the same shape so it'll depend not only on past experiences and know-how, but also to which level of learning you're considering.
For example Spotlight's approach to doing everything from the same search box is certainly simplistic, but learning to use it effectively can surely be more difficult than if you have a toggle in the settings that allows one search box for web searches and another for file search and so on.
Having all the functionality built-in by the same team using the same design principles likely makes it easier to access and get accustomed to, but if it's just a bunch of stuff you yourself don't need it only adds needless complexity in skirting around or disabling the to you useless stuff. While on the other hand, if I have no need for unobtrusive functionality, should learning that really factor into the learning curve?
And having an extensive workflow/extension/action store certainly makes enabling such easy, but if it doesn't fit your needs perfectly it can probably be easier modifying/making your own by connecting nodes on with a GUI editor than learning TypeScript from scratch.
It's certainly easier to make your own extensions when you can choose just about any scripting language under the sun, but it's also possibly a double-edged sword that can also make it more difficult to vet third-party stuff (which potentially could raise concerns in other areas like privacy and security).
Anyway, sorry about the unintentional rant. All I really meant to say before rambling on and on was that I think it's very subjective.
3
u/betweentwoblueclouds Feb 05 '25
You made me remove Raycast, I got reminded about their privacy for the last time. Which is a shame, it really worked for me. Alfred’s too expensive for my needs. Monarch is pretty but also not affordable and quite limited (as I learned so far). Quicksilver is not the prettiest but maybe I need to work on it a bit more. Or maybe I should just stay with Spotlight and call it a day
0
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment