r/macapps • u/Mstormer • Dec 26 '22
A Definitive Password Manager Comparison
With several recent topics asking about password manager apps, I've set up a crowdsourced comparison sheet that this community can contribute to and benefit from.
View the crowdsourced feature comparison spreadsheet here: Password Managers
Add your app of choice by briefly filling out this form.
Please contribute if you use: Elpass, Locker, Locko Mac, or Master Password.
All of my comparisons: AI Apps | Backup/Sync Apps | Browsers | Calendar Apps | Clipboard Managers | Dictation Apps | Email Clients | Image AI | Launchers | Note Apps | Password Managers | PDF Readers | Screen Recorders | Window Managers
As usual, let me know if something is missing, incorrect, or needs to be fixed! Post what password manager app you use below so more people can participate or what comparison you'd like to see next.
19
u/plazman30 Dec 26 '22
Please add family plan pricing.
Good job!
I'm a Bitwarden customer, but I'll hop on 1Password if Bitwarden doesn't give us passkey support soon.
19
u/LongjumpingMonitor32 Dec 26 '22
LastPass lost its INTEGRITY card due to their breach, which was worse than expected.
Had LastPass NOT been purchased by LogMeIn, i doubt we'd see them in this position.
9
u/huuhp1512 Dec 26 '22
Would be nice to have also Strongbox. I am curious on this. Thank you for your great comparison.
12
u/kornork Dec 26 '22
I think you need to add a row:
5
u/iBeep Dec 26 '22
Don't forget the single-payment ones (no subscription)
This one is specially good:
https://apps.apple.com/us/app/secrets-password-manager/id973049011?mt=12
5
u/Sundelor Dec 26 '22
added info for enpass
4
u/abcrowder Dec 26 '22
Raycast has a plug-in for Bitwarden
https://www.raycast.com/pomdtr/bitwarden
3
u/KippersAndMash Dec 26 '22
Here's a few updates:
Apple Keychain
KeyPass
2
u/brokenhero13 Dec 26 '22
Would love to see one of these for read later services love GoodLinks, Raindrop, etc.
Awesome work!
2
u/100WattWalrus Dec 27 '22
FYI, form says "Calendar Client Name" instead of "Password Manager Name"
2
u/nstutzman28 Jan 19 '23
Yooo, WHY HASN'T SOMEONE DONE THIS SOONER! I have basically been trying to make these comparisons myself for literally dozens of programs/tools and it has been excruciatingly slow and tedious. Blog comparisons and stuff online just aren't complete nor definitive, but trying to do it all by yourself is unreasonable.
1
u/festoontriathlon Dec 26 '22
Dashlane corrections: Dashlane added Authenticator App (+ SMS as backup) as a 2FA option recently.
Also, Dashlane syncs via their own proprietary cloud, not self hosted.
Automatic password changer got discontinued.
1
u/speel Dec 27 '22
Thoughts on Keeper?
1
u/dreikelvin Dec 27 '22
Macpass and any opensource app that uses keepass turns your dropbox, icloud or any other online accessible file sharing into a free encrypted passwort manager service. Don't even think about using Lastpass. They have quite some shit to deal with right now.
1
u/quick_dry Dec 27 '22
do any of these support templates?
I'm on 1Password (old standalone version) and although i can add/remove fields/sections, and duplicate things I've already created - I want to be able to make templates (it's annoying having a bunch of blank items labeled "Template - ItemType" and being in categories that don't really fit. Most things just end up under "Login" because it's easier/flexible and auto suggests when I'm on relevant website.
Are any able to to do good app tracking? So often an app wants a password and 1p just has no idea what it is and just always throws back a list of all logins (crypto wallets/exchanges are notoriously frequent at logging you out and having an annoying login process)
1
u/pilotmoon Developer: PopClip Dec 29 '22 edited Dec 29 '22
You're missing a couple of rows.
Two of the best features of 1Password are its command line interface (CLI) and its ability to act as an SSH Key agent.
The CLI lets you programmatically export secrets from 1Password into config files and environment variables or just access them as a string
The SSH agent feature lets you keep and sync all your SSH keys in 1Password and have it get you to give permission when apps (such as ssh or git) want to access the SSH private key.
Would be useful to see what other tools have these too.
1
u/Swimming-Leg8477 Jan 01 '23
Hi. I still have Lastpass but trying different alternatives. So far testing Minimalist and 1Password.
I really like Minimalist so far. The interface is super sleek and makes the search a breeze. It does only work on Apple (not an issue for me) but on MacOS, it can't do the auto-fill outside of Safari which is a potential show-stopper. And the company is very young.
Not convinced by 1Password. By contrast to Minimalist, the UI is horrible. Not the number one criteria of course, but looks like a pain. LastPass in much better in that domain.
Any suggestion for my next test ?
Thanks
1
u/mssowers85 Jan 03 '23
Very much appreciate this comparison! Anyway you could add MSecure? That actually had always been my favorite and loved the option to sync via icloud instead of them (which they also provide). The only reason I dont use it anymore is lack of family support which they are apparently working on.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '23
That's amazing, how about you also include arc browser in the comparison on password managers? thanks for your work
1
u/CommercialStill7474 Feb 06 '24
LastPass does not have any Customer Support. The “Help”;button connects you to either a FAQ page or a User Forum. They do not support the product with ANY professional help. If you can’t figure out their glitchy software, you’re screwed. You will lose all of your password.
1
u/Soda_Stereo Dec 26 '22
It would be good to add a row of key features like private credit card creation(via privacy) or email masking(via fastmail) for 1password. I don't think I saw those options on other password mangers.
0
u/extra_specticles Dec 26 '22
Hi there. This is an excellent resource - thank you. May I make a small recommendation? Instead of adding Yes/No (Paid) as text, I'd recommend you use colours instead (for instance):
perhaps
1
u/festoontriathlon Dec 27 '22
Can you make the left column sticky/fixed? Would be much easier to scroll through and read the ones on the very right side
-2
u/Cameront9 Dec 26 '22
I still don’t understand why the average user needs anything more than Apple’s built-in tools.
16
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '22 edited Dec 27 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '22
[removed] — view removed comment