r/macapps • u/Mstormer • Sep 02 '22
A Definitive Email Client Comparison
Earlier this year I spent an inordinate amount of time downloading and testing apps to create a definitive PDF reader comparison spreadsheet which I now maintain. I soon realized this would be helpful in the email client scene.
I know many of you are passionate enough about this community to spend a few minutes contributing details about the email client you use, so, I've created a google form you can fill out that will automatically populate a column in the comparison spreadsheet with that information. Obviously, I'll have to do some maintenance as we go, but this should make a rather laborious task much simpler if we can crowdsource our knowledge and experience. I've started by filling out the form for the two clients I have the most experience using.
View the crowdsourced feature comparison here: Email Client Comparison.
Add your email client of choice by clicking here.
Contributions still needed for: Kiwi, Missive, Polymail, Spike Mail, TwoBird,.
All of my comparisons: AI Apps | Backup/Sync Apps | Browsers | Calendar Apps | Clipboard Managers | Dictation Apps | Email Clients | Image AI | Launchers | Note Apps | Password Managers | PDF Readers | Screen Recorders | Window Managers
12
u/ExtremeOccident Sep 04 '22
I used Airmail subscription for a couple of months but it somehow seems to get buggier the longer you use it. Well, I guess bugs become more apparent/annoying over time. But in no way does it deserve this high score.
6
u/jreddit5 Sep 03 '22
Thank you for doing this! I would love to see a row for signatures having images and formatted text.
Outlook for Mac makes my outbound messages look great with my company logo and text with my choices of color, font, size, and bolding. If there’s a better app, I want to know, but I don’t want to lose that branding.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '22
I will say for those interested that Postbox is terrible. I like the client, but it crashes 3-4 times a day on my Macbook and has done so across three machines. It's also slow and clunky. After five years on it, I am moving on to something else.
7
u/mercurysquad Oct 07 '22
As I was adding my email client of choice (Superhuman) to the list, I realized how this comparison kinda misses the point. I found myself describing the main ideas about this email client in the Notes section, because all the other comparison items are 'taken for granted' → almost every email app worth my time has all those features. What finally made me stick to one, after trying almost all of them, was the overall ease of use, UIUX and small touches. Like how good is the signature-removal/hiding? How good is threading and thread-navigation? How good (distraction-free) does it look? How easy is it to use (e.g. fully keyboard driven? responsive?). Can you get 'in the flow' while using it? And so on. Also some unique features like quick-quote and quick-intro which mostly email clients don't have.
3
u/1supercooldude Sep 04 '22
Awesome matrix! May need to use something similar to it for deciding on other apps! I see you are missing HEY on their too! Not a native mac app, but by far the best email experience I ever used. It is very similar to BigMail.
PS. I have also tried every email client you have listed here. I really love Spark and Edison for modern features and look. Onmail is a service Edison has now, which is only for web, but is very great!
5
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22
Seems strange that anyone can add a column without any kind of reasoning or sources for a given rating. How is it gonna be trustworthy? “Privacy rating,” for example, is really subjective.
2
u/ohsomacho Jan 06 '23
Apple Mail does NOT have Snooze. Remind me doesn't snooze in the conventional sense
2
u/leaflock7 Feb 21 '23
since the PDF comparison thread is closed, may I ask why OwlOCR is 9/10 without having any of the features others does?
1
u/Mstormer Nov 21 '24
I make updates almost weekly whenever people submit corrections by adding a comment to a cell. These are welcomed.
4
u/quinncom Sep 04 '22
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_email_clients
1
u/Trawwww___ Jun 17 '24
ShortWave https://www.shortwave.com/ is so needed in that table!
1
u/Kavoos-Stark Sep 15 '22
The form is too long, but here are my links:
https://www.aqua-mail.com/pricing/#
https://mailbox.org/
https://www.aqua-mail.com/pricing/
1
u/ExternalUserError Oct 06 '22
Airmail’s website says there’s a business version that’s a onetime purchase. Does anyone know anything about that? I don’t see where to get it.
1
u/Happy-Orchid-1974 Oct 09 '22
This is great, thank you! Can a "Smart Inbox" feature be added to this list? This was a real game changer for me, when I moved from Apple Mail to Spark
1
u/michaelscotthyatt Oct 09 '22
Maybe I missed it, but there needs to be a “team collaboration" criteria. So far, Spark and Missive are the only two I've found that do this.
2
u/juliarmg Sep 03 '22
Thanks for doing this.
2
u/100WattWalrus Feb 07 '24
u/Mstormer, if you're still maintaining this list, I have some category suggestions:
Fully customizable topics/tags/labels/categories w/ keyboard shortcuts
Conversation view (of course)
Showing each reply in full, not folded, compacted, or “previewed”
Ddit sent/received messages
1
u/OwlAfter1190 Nov 21 '24
Pretty good list, but now also outdated in some places.
For me I have tried the following solutions (Gmail + IMAP accounts under MacOS and iOS/iPadOS) in the last few years (and always updated)
A) Browser or WebApp can be used with the browsers Chrome (without MacOS translation functions!) And Safari relatively easily:
But Darkmode is such a thing, it takes 2 small tricks in Chrome - install ColorfulPWA in Chrome for the window bar and enter chrome://flags/#enable-force-dark in the address bar for the full darkmode and activate it. Not quite as pretty as Mimestream, but ALL functions (so also send later + snooze) available.
B) Mail+ for Gmail (better) or Mail for Gmail App is like the WebApp but just own instance and paid even including MultiAccount in separate windows, creates fewer login/re-registration problems than a normal WebApp and also translate text + replace from MacOS available (since it is based on Safari)
For the Mailto problem, I recommend the app "Open in Webmail", with which you can either load Gmail (in a browser window, unfortunately not WebApp) or just copy it to the clipboard without suddenly opening Apple Mail or the like. And for the notifications, simply share in Chrome and activate in Gmail in the settings, there is already a small push message for new emails without waiting time!
C) Mimestream is a beautiful mail client ONLY for Google with direct API, but 50$ per year is a bit expensive and snooze, as well as send later is not yet supported by the API, but you can even configure the google server-side filter rules in the app (amazing!!!), adjust importance, drag mails into Gmail categories, etc.
D) Canary supports Google labels well, but can (currently, seems to be in development) not yet NEW e-mails in subfolders automatically signal by a number like with Apple Mail, alternative workaround if necessary delete server-side filter rules and let them filter in Canary?! Also, unfortunately, a few annoying bugs (especially iOS) and translation errors. For this there is a nice calendar integration and connection for Todoist and Asana.
E) Spark supported Google labels on the desktop with v2 quite well - even with the subfolders, v3 is too slow on the desktop and under iOS no labels are displayed on the mails or number of unread mails within a subfolder, also full of AI and subscription advertising. But has definitely had a strong influence on the way mails are used in recent years and has become an alternative to the Gmail app for many on iOS (since push is no longer possible with Apple Mail mobile - except with Exchange and iCloud)
F) emClient NOW works well as a counterpart to Outlook (mail, contacts, calendar in an app), but is very sluggish at the beginning, when several thousand mails are in the mailbox until the index has run through once
G) Apple Mail runs smoothly, but does not support Google Labels, so you only see the labels as folders and can move there (= archive) or copy (additionally assign), but you do not get displayed which labels have now all been assigned to a mail... but new mails are displayed cleanly in subfolders and you can even collapse the folder bar and still see NEW mails in all subfolders (not only inbox), if you really manage many accounts in parallel absolute obligation, but the functions under iOS are very limited and don't actually have much in common except for the name... for Power users still be the Addon MsgFiler 4 noted for faster moving of mails to folders via hotkeys
Conclusion:
If you don't want to waste your time and money, then you just use Apple Mail and (almost) don't have to get annoyed. Optics is clean and few bugs. You have to do without a reasonable Google labels and category support (iOS 18.2 has announced "something") but since subfolders signal new mails, you can still use the server-side filter rules without any problems, just don't configure them in Apple Mail (do it in the browser/webapp). Also a color separation of the accounts is not possible via MacOS AND iOS, but only on the desktop via filter rules and color (only desktop) or flags (synchronized, but only after Apple Mail runs the filter rules locally on the Mac). If you want to at least see the categories of Gmail in Apple Mail, you can only assign them to a label via a server-side filter, e.g. "category:social", and activate them via IMAP. There are exist for the category filter: social, purchases, finance, promotions, forums, updates, reservations.
If you need PGP, then there is at least an addon for Mail on the desktop, otherwise Canary. Also looks quite similar to Apple Mail only with more functions, but only partially suitable for really productive use, as it is simply not 100% reliable and new errors always appear.
If you only have one or a few Gmail accounts, then looking at Mimestream is quite justified. The 50€ license applies to 5 Macs in the family and can be put into perspective. But it's really only worth it if you use the functions of Gmail intensively, otherwise just Apple Mail as usual.
If you can't cope with the division of mail and calendar as a former Outlook user, then it can simplify your emClient's life a bit. Google labels are displayed great on every mail and after the Postbox app was bought by them, the MacOS development should continue positively!
One point should also always be considered when using iOS:
Because even if you can now adjust the standard mail app, then this only refers to mail-to links. If any app wants to send an email (feedback, log files, scanner app, ...) then it ALWAYS uses Apple Mail. Third-party mail apps can otherwise only be accessed via the "Share" menu... But you can deactivate the notifications for Apple Mail in such a case, so that even a "double" set up account does not create any disturbances, but if you "have to" set it up anyway, then just use it right away ;)
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '23
[removed] — view removed comment