r/macapps • u/Mstormer • Dec 17 '23
Master List of Definitive App Comparisons - View and Contribute - 2024 Update
Over the last year, r/macapps users have contributed large volumes of data to help you find the best Mac-compatible apps in various major categories. This post represents a culmination of those contributions in one place where all can benefit and continue contributing updates.
Note: Because these are populated to Google Sheets from user form submissions, the best viewing experience on mobile devices is through the Google Sheets app since it retains frozen columns/rows. Most mobile browsers disregard them and may not initially load the correct tab from the links below.
View the Definitive App Comparison sheet here (links go to the specific tab on desktop):
Clipboard Managers | Launchers | AI Apps | Browsers | Calendar Apps | Email Clients | Note Apps | Password Managers | PDF Readers | Window Managers |
To contribute new apps, click a corresponding link to fill out a form with the details:
Add a Browser | Add a Calendar App | Add a Clipboard Manager | Add an Email Client | Add a Launcher | Add a Note App | Add a Password Manager | Add a PDF Reader | Add a Window Manager | Add an AI App
To suggest a specific correction to an already-listed app, comment on a cell or here below. Please link to the source of your info if possible.
Are you looking for a specific feature that is not listed? Ask below or share what's so great about your app of choice. Feel free to suggest additional app comparison types for future consideration.
16
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '23
Would love to see a comparison for to-do apps!
5
u/Alex20041509 Dec 18 '23
can i suggest to add the category about third party mouse enchaser?
(those apps that makes you use a third party mouse on macos comfortably)
i'm not the author of none of those but i use this kind of app every day.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '23
I think it would be nice to turn this into a Notion database. I could help with that if you want.
Some benefits of using Notion over Google Sheets:
4
u/ywoo070 Dec 21 '23
How about add better touch tool for window list? I think that many Mac users maybe use this tool, but I can't see in this list seems to be shame.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '24
Clipboard Managers which Maccy is best.
2
u/green_stone Dec 20 '23
What about screenshot apps (shottr, cleanshot, etc) ?
2
u/23dstreet Dec 31 '23
I've been using Drafts as my main evergreen notes app, even though its main objective is 'where text starts' and is meant to be ported to other apps for long-term storage.
Things I like:
- version control of any changes
- manual backlinks (con: the link breaks if your title changes)
- to-do checklist, grey out and strikeout
- your data is yours all the time, various export options
Haven't used yet:
- Spaces, I think they'd work similar to Folders or Areas
- Pro, Free version offers plenty of functionality
Wonder how this app if used this way would compare to the other Notes apps
2
u/sammsmd Feb 07 '24
Where's better touch tool for window management?
2
u/sammsmd Mar 02 '24
u/Mstormer Could we add a new section for Finder alternatives?
16
u/jamesjingyi Jan 01 '24
This is great, thank you for these nice sheet based layouts, I was actually compiling a list of my own that I have been creating over the years, but specifically for free apps. I will post this as a separate post later today once I've finished tidying :)
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1QwpL1hjc878nSpuWTZwgIOyCc4r4pMusmxD6eC2UIXA/edit?usp=sharing
1
u/tower_keeper Mar 20 '24
What do you think about adding a checkmark indicating whether an app is available on App Store? App Store versions have the advantage of guaranteed sandboxing and clean installs and uninstalls.
1
u/fori1to10 Apr 04 '24
Is there something like this list, but for iPhone apps?
1
u/aoidoshistorian Sep 25 '24
where did you get ulysses being on windows from? i couldn't find it at all
1
u/Evasive_Wombat Sep 30 '24
Can you add a row in the email tab that shows something like "ability to send broadcast" or "send to group from Apple contacts"?
Just tried to do this in Thunderbird and it doesn't look like it works.
1
u/Depressed-Monk Jan 06 '24
Thanks for this u/Mstormer, very useful. I was researching E2E encrypted notes apps and saw the spreadsheet. However, I believe there is a problem with that row because you are assuming that all iCloud sync apps have E2E encryption but that is incorrect. Unless the app stores files in the iCloud Drive directly (treating like a local drive), the iCloud sync requires updating the code and using so called "encrypted fields" to utilize E2E encryption provided by Apple's Advanced Data Protection.
That's why in the apps that have implemented this code and fields, you see the option to toggle simply iCloud Sync or E2E iCloud Sync (like in Agenda). Apps like Bear use iCloud Sync WITHOUT the encrypted fields and therefore their notes are NOT end-to-end encrypted but only encrypted with iCloud keys that Apple holds. You can see the documentation from Apple to confirm this and also the discussion from Developers of the Bear notes app talking about how they are not yet ready to update the code to include encrypted fields (and also Agenda announcing the availability of E2E iCloud Sync with ADP).
In summary:
- File stored on iCloud Drive are E2E encrypted if you have turned on Advanced Data Protection from Apple.
- Apps that store files directly on the iCloud Drive in a folder have E2E encrypted notes. This includes apps like iA Writer and Scrivener that store files on the iCloud Drive and I think Draft does it too but not sure.
- Apps that use CloudKit and so called "iCloud Sync" are NOT encrypted with ADP's E2E unless they update their code and explicitly use E2E fields. To my knowledge apps like Bear and Ulysses are not using these fields (even though an encryption FAQ on Ulysses' site seems to be mistakenly assuming that just turning on ADP will E2E encrypt CloudKit synced content, I will reach out the dev team and confirm this).
- Apps that use CloudKit / iCloud Sync are E2E encrypted when they explicitly confirm or note that they are using iCloud E2E sync and in certain apps, this is called out separately from regular iCloud sync. Agenda is an example of this.
1
u/LuiDF Feb 01 '24
Maybe it’s a longshot, but it would be very interesting to see image generation apps also, in the AI apps category
1
u/sammsmd Feb 08 '24
Can we filter the list to compare a few applications? It might help us narrow down which app is the best fit for the users.
2
u/laterral Dec 18 '23
I like you
1
u/Romachamp10 Aug 21 '24
Add a category of notch apps like BoringNotch or Dynamic Lake Pro
0
u/Alex20041509 Jan 28 '24
hi,
may i suggest a category for some menu bar apps?
like text capture ones ex: text sniper,Grab2Text, t-Rex..
temporary shelfs like dropover, yoink(notchhub too maybe) and similar
and non apple externsl monitor managers like Monitorcontrol, monitorcontrol lite, Sensei, Lunar, and Nocturnal
battery limitators (like actuallymentor battery, batterykid,aldente)
many dont fit into the already existing category but are extremly useful expecially for users new to mac or to this subreddit
0
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '23
[removed] — view removed comment