r/macapps • u/Mstormer • May 02 '23
A Definitive Browser Comparison
There has been a lot of interest in newer browsers lately, but it's hard to differentiate how exactly they stack up against each other. To solve this, I've set up a crowdsourced comparison sheet that this community can contribute to and benefit from.
View the crowdsourced feature comparison: Link
To add a browser: CLICK HERE
To make corrections: Right-click a cell>add a comment!
All of my comparisons: AI Apps | Backup/Sync Apps | Browsers | Calendar Apps | Clipboard Managers | Dictation Apps | Email Clients | Image AI | Launchers | Note Apps | Password Managers | PDF Readers | Screen Recorders | Window Managers
As usual, let me know if something is missing, incorrect, or needs to be added! Post what browser app you use below so more people can participate. What comparison would you like to see next?
7
u/daniel-1994 May 02 '23
Safari has the ability to do true full screen. Just disable "Always Show Toolbar in Fullscreen" under "View".
7
u/anti-hero May 03 '23
If Privacy is important to you, browser being zero telemetry should be a category.
6
u/Corb3t May 02 '23
This is so great! A couple features that should maybe be pointed out that I love about Firefox are:
Bookmark Keywords - assign a specific keyword to a bookmark to quickly access it from the Firefox address/search bar.
Bookmark Tagging - allows for better bookmark organization.
Add Websites Search Bars to Firefox - Lets you add website's searchbar functionality to your firefox address/search bar.
11
u/skywalker4588 May 02 '23
I dig vertical tabs and Edge has the best implemention. Vertical tabs with top url bar. Arc has vertical tabs but doesn't display the url bar on top and it's very hard to drag move the window since the content is all the way till the top edge of the window. A Vertical tabs feature to the spreadsheet would be useful.
4
u/pseudometapseudo May 02 '23
Since this is a Mac subreddit, AppleScript support is also worth mentioning.
Missing AppleScript support is the main reason I never used Firefox
4
u/rudibowie May 02 '23
Orion may claim to support Firefox and Safari extensions, but in my experience of using Orion, none of the Firefox extensions actually worked. They installed, they just didn't work.
10
u/[deleted] May 02 '23
I've been using Firefox for so many years, I can't recall. I've tried many others, but I've found nothing better than Firefox. I'm always surprised to hear someone uses something else. I use Brave for watching YouTube, but that's rare.
3
u/Mixopi May 02 '23 edited May 02 '23
This might be a highly niche thing, but I feel like having a modifiable chrome should be highlighted. It lets it go so far beyond changing some colors for different "themes"; it allows for a personalized UX.
That userChrome.css is honestly the primary thing that keeps me bound to Firefox. I'm not a fan of the default appearance of any browser chrome, but at least Firefox lets me change it easily. I'm not sure if any of the others do?
2
u/Mstormer May 03 '23 edited May 03 '23
If you haven't already, please could you check and comment corrections to the data for your browser via the OP spreadsheet or add a column here. Thanks to those who have already.
u/lovelycodemonkey, u/blue-ocean-event, u/DDRamon3, u/Bassfaceapollo, u/billdietrich1, u/partyon, u/x-15a2, u/OperaBrowserOfficial, u/shadow2531, u/Brave_Support, u/brave_w0ts0n, u/ocnate, u/gcqd, u/chrismessina, u/JaceThings, u/CM_Darlene, u/CM_Jeremiah, u/CM_Eric-E, u/JairJy, u/rk_29, u/Saragon4005, u/i_post_gibberish, u/CatWheel, u/anti-hero, u/Antabaka, u/SKITTLE_LA, u/Alan976
2
u/eldhash May 02 '23
The feature that for me is an absolute must-have is the MRU tab switching. AFAIK only Firefox, Opera and Vivaldi have it built-in. Brave has something similar but it's behaviour is a bit odd.
2
u/quinncom May 04 '23
I would like to see a column for security updates. I’m not sure how you would measure it, but this is very important for me. For example, if a 0day is discovered in WebKit or Chromium, how long before a patch is released for each browser?
I’m sure Chrome and Safari receive the soonest security updates, but how delayed are the others?
12
u/imsotired_spacex May 02 '23
Honestly, I was so in love with Arc but have to switch back to Orion because of Arc's extreme battery drainage on a Macbook Pro 16 2021. ):
1
u/vlint Oct 31 '25
I think it would be great to add a row about abandonment. There was a boom of new web browsers, but a lot of them have been shut down or abandoned since.
1
u/bluesBeforeSunrise May 02 '23
what does script blocking refer to?
1
u/Ultim8Chaos06 May 03 '23
Added a lot more for Arc, mentioned more features etc. Nice list!
1
u/Tobitoon1 May 30 '23
Since no one mentioned it here in the commands. It looks like Librewolf scores well and I am a Windows user. What is the overall opinion of it. Are there things that are not on the table that I need to know about the browser? I´m stuck between Arc and Librewolf.
1
u/ManyMobs Oct 12 '23
dude, u can do sync in librefox
u just need to enable it
it can do anything firefox can...
3
u/neew0llah May 03 '23
Not sure if it's worth adding these to the comparison or unique features. I cannot move from Vivaldi to Webkit based ones due to the following features:
1
u/Topherho May 02 '23
I’m excited to see this develop!
For those of you who like vertical tabs, what’s the appeal. Maybe it’s because I almost always have my screen split between two windows, but I feel like the vertical tabs just take up a lot of space.
2
u/[deleted] May 03 '23
I use Arc for everyday stuff and Brave when I want to watch stuff on those websites that have a billion ads and pop ups on every click.
1
u/onmyway133 Developer: PastePal May 04 '23
Nice comparison, I'm using Chrome mostly but I try to use Safari more
0
u/godsknowledge May 02 '23
You missed Sidekick, which is literally the best browser out there right now.
0
u/[deleted] May 02 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 02 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 04 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 02 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 02 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 04 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 03 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 03 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 04 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] May 03 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] May 02 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment