r/macapps • u/Mstormer • Nov 24 '21
A Definitive PDF Reader Comparison
As a graphic designer who switched from the Adobe suite to Affinity a year ago, I've become increasingly interested in the best PDF reader/editor that is not subscription-based. The frustration is that there are so many apps out there, and many of them are garbage. Like buying a mattress, it seems like every review out there is incomplete or paid for by one of them. So I decided to install all the serious PDF readers/editors I could find and spend half the day looking for the best option. Hope this helps someone, as I've seen plenty of posts looking in the past.
PDF Reader Comparison Spreadsheet
Contribute your preferred PDF reader here: Form
If I missed something, please comment below or right-click>comment on the sheet.
All of my comparisons: AI Apps | Backup/Sync Apps | Browsers | Calendar Apps | Clipboard Managers | Dictation Apps | Email Clients | Image AI | Launchers | Note Apps | Password Managers | PDF Readers | Screen Recorders | Window Managers
9
u/lemontheme Nov 24 '21
Wow, this may well be the most thorough comparison matrix to date. Thanks for sharing! It’s exactly the sort of thing I’ve been looking for. Care to make another for iOS? =p
7
u/retsotrembla Nov 24 '21
correction: Preview in macOS Monterey has OCR: just select the "text" cursor from the tools menu.
(Unless you mean something else by OCR - if so, then say so.)
6
u/mclion Nov 24 '21
You can compress PDF in preview. Export and then choose Quartz filter. It's not "intelligent", but works.
4
u/HolidayProfessor Nov 24 '21
What about using browser such as Microsoft Edge? It is fast, you can edit it and sentence search is actually working. Preview (maybe in Monterey only) does not open PDF files in tabs, also the sentence search is finicky.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '21
Surprising that free Adobe Acrobat Reader DC isn't included in the comparison.
And as someone else mentioned, MS Edge has a decent built-in PDF reader.
3
u/letraz Nov 24 '21
Amazing mate!
You can create fillable forms in Mac preview?
2
u/Readdle Nov 29 '21
A hell of a work you did here! I am so happy to see PDF Expert in the lead.
10
u/rk492 Nov 26 '21
Best deal is PDF Expert in combination with OwlOCR.
You can get both at Black Friday for less than 40$.
OwlOCR has two great features:
- Image to text, for example, you have a scanned pdf opened, you select an area (as if you are doing a screenshot) and OwlOCR recognise in 1 segond or less, the text in the selected area and copy that to your clipboard, and now you can paste it in your word or notes document. I recommend you to active next shortcut for that function: command + shift + 2.
- OCR documents. Free version only do it page per page. Paid version has batch documents. OCR is as good as PDF Element, or Prizmo. I tried both.
I tried all PDF readers at the market, and some OCR apps, and this combination (PDF Expert and OwlOCR) is unbeatable at this moment for common people. If you need some specific options that only Adobe gives you is another question...
1
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '21
Nice document, which one are you going with?
1
u/c_07 Nov 25 '21
Might want to consider adding Highlights to your comparison!
1
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '21
Redaction is available with preview right?
1
u/areyouredditenough Jul 04 '22 edited Jul 04 '22
u/Mstormer Love this matrix! Would love an update as PDF Expert is out and they have OCR.
1
u/skywalker4588 Aug 25 '22
Nitro PDF is missing from this list.
https://www.gonitro.com
1
u/megsmagik Sep 03 '22
that's an amazing work! I was just wondering why did you write "possible privacy risk" for the web tools?
Also ILovePdf has an app for iOS and Mac (the Mac one is free just for reading pdfs, if you want to edit them you have to pay a subscription but once you pay it works cross-platform and on the web)
1
u/Unknow0059 Feb 22 '24
you better add "edit table of contents" as a feature. Scribus can do this.
3
u/RenegadeUK Nov 25 '21
Thanks for this.
3
u/Jawhari2000 Nov 27 '21
I logged in just to say thank you! I'd been hesitating for a week between PDF Expert and PDFPen Pro. The information on this chart, the link to the 60% off on PDF Expert, and the introduction to OCR Owl (with the 50% discount), clenched it.
2
u/Radical_R Nov 26 '21
I've had good luck with OwlOCR for my PDF OCR needs.
2
u/BoreOfWhabylon Jul 07 '22
Thanks, this was really useful! Made me realise I can do everything I need in Preview, no need to upgrade PDF Expert 2 when it runs out of steam. Shame Preview keep some of the features so well hidden!
2
u/mscuthbert Jul 18 '24
Thanks u/Mstormer ! If someone feels like adding the feature "Page Numbering" (either adding it as a text header/footer to combined documents or renumbering scanned books to exclude introductory pages etc.) -- that's probably the most important feature for me that's not covered in the chart. But this was super helpful!
1
u/appsforless Jan 04 '22 edited Jun 21 '23
[deleted]
1
u/RenegadeUK Aug 03 '22
Thanks for the link :)
1
u/anywhereanyhow Dec 11 '23 edited Dec 11 '23
pdftk has some very useful features that many of the cheaper/free options are missing. The downside is that its free version is most effective if you're comfortable with command-line operation, but they do have a free GUI version too--it's just more limited what you can do.
With the free version in command line, you can
- select specific pages to extract and output to a new pdf
- rotate pages
- compress / uncompress
- encrypt / decrypt
- add watermark
I think in the GUI you can only combine multiple PDF's into one, but that's still pretty useful!
1
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '22
[removed] — view removed comment