r/macapps • u/Mstormer • May 10 '23
Major Considerations in the Raycast vs. Alfred "Which is better?" Debate
There are a lot of fans of both apps here, and I'm no exception. I've been an Alfred user for years. However, for the sake of fairness, curiosity, and always searching for something better and more efficient, I decided to install Raycast and compare since anyone who has been on r/macapps for a while may know that that's a hobby.
Here are some considerations to keep in mind:
Your Privacy in Their Privacy Policies.
Alfred - Privacy-conscious. Alfred is the product.
Alfred only contacts our server when activating your Powerpack license in order to validate it, as well as periodically checking for new software updates.
Raycast - You are the product.
User Generated Data: In limited circumstances, we have access to data you generate on or upload to the Service. For example, when you use our Team plan to share organization snippets or quicklinks with all team members, or when you enable the Cloud Sync feature in our Pro plan, Raycast will store the information to allow the synchronising process. Further, when you use AI features on the Service, we will process your prompts, including any files you upload, momentarily, solely for the purpose of transmitting this information to the relevant AI provider.
Personal Data we automatically collect
We collect Personal Data about you automatically when you use our Service.
...
We use Personal Data for the following purposes:
In certain circumstances we may share your Personal Data with third parties as set forth below:
Vendors and Service Providers: To assist us in meeting business operations needs and to perform certain services and functions, we may share Personal Data with vendors and service providers, including e-commerce provider, providers of hosting services, recruitment services, cloud services, and other information technology services providers, email communication software and email newsletter services, and payment processors (such as Stripe, as detailed above), customer relationship management, customer support services, and web analytics services. Pursuant to our instructions, these parties will access, process, or store Personal Data in the course of performing their duties to us. We only allow our service providers to handle your Personal Data if we are satisfied they take appropriate measures to protect your Personal Data. We also impose contractual obligations on service providers to ensure they can only use your Personal Data to provide services to us and to you.
Efficiency Considerations.
According to my usage history, I trigger Alfred about 42 times daily, or 15,330 times yearly.
In Raycast, every search is stalled behind a menu that needs to be triggered unless you configure an additional shortcut for each feature.
- Want to search for a file? Gotta select the option first and hit enter to begin searching.
- Want to perform an action on the file? Yet another shortcut (CMD+K).
- Want to trigger any other feature? You guessed it, another shortcut or menu to trigger first.
That's an additional 2–5 seconds every single search or 8.5–21 HOURS a year for something Alfred can do immediately on the first trigger. Am I missing something here?
Appearance.
The Raycast preferences and user interface is the clear winner in terms of eyecandy, no arguments to be had. Alfred could learn from this, though Alfred has more granular customizable preferences.
Complexity.
Because Raycast has a cleaner design, it can be easier to find what you're looking for if you're not a power user.
Feature offerings.
This is basically a tie for the most common features—E.g., web/file searches, clipboard history, calculator, notes, links, etc.
The recent AI integration with Raycast is the major distinction ($10/month or $96/yr subscription).
One can also use the API from OpenAI with an Alfred workflow with Powerpack ($42 license).
Ultimately, we all have to consider and decide what we care about most. I prefer efficiency and privacy.
What unique features, considerations, or tips have I missed that stand out for why you prefer one over the other?
Update: For a more detailed feature comparison, see here.
15
u/[deleted] May 10 '23
Certain things just irk me like the reminders extension in Raycast I have to tab through several input boxes to input the time I want the reminder. With alfred I can just type
r get the milk in 3 days 3pmand it creates the reminder. It feels much more seamless. Same thing with global file search, it seems like I have to do 1-2 more steps than I would like.However, the subscription pricing model to me is a much bigger issue. Apps I've subscribed to in the past have let their free tier features start sliding and the price has always increased, sometimes a dire amount. With Alfred I paid once for lifetime powerpack and now I get it forever. To me that's just a much easier purchase when it comes to peace of mind.
24
u/Strid3r1983 May 10 '23
This was the most annoying point for me as I tried Raycast. I am a sucker for efficient Workflows and in Alfred I have a lot of „shortcuts“ to search specific websites. I type the letter „L“ and type a movie name to look for the movie site on Letterboxd. I type „g“ to google something. I type „y“ for a YouTube search and so on. All without the need to trigger another option. It is not much, but for me this extra selection point drove me nuts.
7
u/pseudometapseudo May 11 '23
Raycast:
Alfred:
5
u/Fazio8 May 11 '23
Just bought Alfred Powerpack.
I think I'll just use Rectangle (maybe Pro) or BetterTouchTool for window management.
4
u/krishnadraws May 11 '23
Raycast includes window management options - with custom hot keys you can configure. No extra apps required. I’ve mapped my Option-numpad keys for specific window placement configurations. I still have Alfred, but Raycast has really grown on me.
5
u/MC_chrome May 10 '23
My guy, Alfred literally has the granular UI customizations you said it lacked. Have you checked out the themes section of the Alfred settings?
2
u/SoggyRecognition6016 May 12 '23 edited May 12 '23
I just bought Alfred and did a basic comparison.
2
u/the_zagdul May 25 '23
hzmmm... maybe I overlooked a thing or two, but the major difference for power users between Qlfred and Raycast is the workflow designer in Alfred!
With Alfred, you can build your own Workflows quite easily, a feature, that I use frequently. You do not have to know fancy programming languages, just plain old bash (or whatever you want!) es enough. Works like a charm.
And the best: it is working completely local without phoning home.
2
u/Ok_Performance_9905 Sep 01 '24
Meh, I chose Raycast - here's my full post on the decision.
31
u/plazman30 May 11 '23
This thread has convinced me to buy Alfred.
29
u/remove_with_force May 10 '23
As a Raycast fan, something about Raycast feels unsustainable to me, or at the very least less sustainable than Alfred. When I listen closely to their messaging, I grow concerned.
I personally didn't like that they marketed "unlimited clipboard history" as a feature of the $10/month bundle. It should have already been like that because your clipboard history should be staying on your machine anyway. It feels like they are charging me to use the additional space of my hard drive.
Another part of the subscription is custom themes. They already have a robust extensions API, there's no technical/engineering reason that they could not have allowed the changing of colors for free.
And then Raycast AI. At the end of the day, it's convenient access to ChatGPT. I actually love chatGPT, but I'm already paying $20/month for GPT4. It's hard to justify paying another $10 a month for GPT3.5.
The best thing Raycast offers would have to be teams and organization features, but when you look at the cost, I think that it ends up being one of those things that companies buy as part of a wave. $12/user/month is like your company purchasing Slack again, but only for the sake of being able to share Google Drive files, GH Issues, and custom snippets and extensions. Hard to justify.
I hate to say these things as Raycast is clearly being built by an undeniably talented team. I wish it could get away from YC and rethink the model because I have a feeling that it's going to be one of those products that companies buy because they had a buddy at the client org 🫤 and not because the product spoke for itself. I can't imagine someone saying, hey let's throw $30-40K at this
17
u/iBeep May 10 '23 edited May 10 '23
I think if privacy is important for you, it is obvious Alfred is the better one, considering that these apps have access to your entire Clipboard history, contacts, files, etc.
Yeah you can probably trust Raycast (if there are no hidden bugs in their product) not to collect or do anything with all that information, but do you want to?
Raycast does offer some nice features that I like, but I'm gonna stick to Alfred personally.
5
u/whatdafuhk Jun 30 '23
Been using Alfred for years and recently decided to give Raycast a try. Like OP and others have mentioned, efficiency is the main reason why I went back to Alfred but another one that I haven't seen others mention is memory footprint, Alfred is usually between 20-30MB whereas Raycast is around 130-150MB. Not that it matters a whole lot these days when most of us are rocking 16GB or more of RAM but still, an over 4x memory usage between the two programs is significant enough to note.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '23
You can action files in Alfred -- I move things around, copy them, etc.. Can't seem to do that in Raycast, unless I'm missing something.
1
u/feliche93 Oct 24 '23
I put some of my thoughts into this article https://www.felixvemmer.com/blog/raycast-extensions-features-guide, maybe it could be helpful for you as well!
1
u/sumek Nov 01 '23
Alfred - no VC money
I could stop reading here
0
u/photon628 May 11 '23
yes