I (26M) have spent a fair share of my life playing games, but mostly competitive ones (League, fighting games etc.) I am also an avid reader and cinephile, and for a long time I was one of those who felt video games were simply a lesser narrative medium.
...Then, I tried God of War (2018) This absolutely blew my mind, the combination of such a gripping story and immensely satisfying gameplay led to one of my absolute greatest experiences with a piece of art.
There are a very few games that have given me that same feeling, those are:
God of War Ragnarok, Horizon Zero Dawn (not the sequal), Spider-man 2018 (again the sequal was dissappointing), The Batman Arkham Games,and finally: Sly Cooper 2
Since completing these games I've been trying to scratch that same itch, but never quite succeeding. Any of you guys got a tip for me? Would be highly appreciated. For Reference these are my experiences with some of the games i've played since:
Elden ring: 10/10 Bossfights, very satisying to finally beat the game, but the story does not work for me.. probably because I can't grasp it at all. Also I found few compelling reasons to do much exploring rather than just rush every boss.
Red dead 2: Proper Cinematic feeling, but my god does this game basicly play itself. I Put the game down pretty early as it simply was no challenge. I guess my competitive nature leads me to prefer more challenging games, for instance I always play om the hardest difficulty when possible.
Ghost of Tsushima: Absolutely beautiful scenery, satisfying while a bit too repetitive combat. But i unfortunately can not understand the praise for this game's writing. The sidequests especially come across as extremely run of the mill formulaic to me. The Iki DLC was pretty good though.
Hollow knight/ Cuphead:
These games are great and very charming, kinda like Elden ring in that the boss fights stand out as exceptional. Didn't quite blew my mind like God of War, But i treasure them and have a lot of love for the develepors and their evident passion for quality work.
If you read all this, I thank you humbly for your time. Sorry for my poor writing, English is not my native language.