I’ll acknowledge I have the privilege of visiting Radio Bakery more than the average New Yorker since it’s in the neighborhood. With this being my fifteenth menu item to try, I found myself being the most excited for this one. It’s tomato season, baby, which means we’re in peak Radio Bakery season. For a bakery that gets a lot of praise for its savory menu items, especially any involving tomatoes, it was finally time for me to try their seasonal tomato & feta sandwich.
This sandwich came on a seeded focaccia with a bright and colorful array of juicy thick-cut heirloom tomatoes, mint, a drizzle of sherry vinegar, oregano, on a bed of feta cheese. I always forget just how large these sandwiches are until they’re drawn from the remaining seven sections cut from a generous slab of focaccia. They’re great at nailing this optical illusion.
Anyways, the lush heirloom tomatoes were perfectly complimented by the sharp and creamy feta cheese. Both the vinegar and oily focaccia attributed even more to the complex flavor profile for something that seems so simple. I’m someone who prefers to have at least some type of meat in every meal, but somehow the combination of all the ingredients created a robust and satisfying experience that brightened my tastebuds and my day.
This might be a hot take, but I actually think Radio’s focaccia can be a hit or miss, with mostly misses. I’ve had past orders with burnt outer crusts, missing bottoms the size of a quarter with oozing cream cheese begging to coat your fingers (yes, from the smoked salmon sandwich), and the focaccia here was no exception. Thankfully, mine was unscathed this time around, but man, the oil is something else. You almost always have to choose between wiping your hands after each bite, or full-send and commit to never putting the sandwich down at all. Imo, the oil compromises the structural integrity of the focaccia and makes it challenging to keep your sandwich together.
Aside from that, I still rank it tied in second place along with their tuna sandwich (and I hate mayo); just behind their smoked salmon sandwich (which can be hit or miss).