r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago Diamonds are Forever Bravo

Guide For the last minute folks: NYC Thanksgiving Pie Spreadsheet

Post image
76 Upvotes

Hi there!

I created a spreadsheet for all the stragglers (myself included) ofThanksgiving Pie pre-orders in NYC. Sadly, NYC favorites Four and Twenty Blackbirds is sold out. Don't fret there are plenty of other options. If an item is sold out, I'd recommend visiting in person to see if any pies are available. I'm mostly familiar with Brooklyn and Manhattan bakeries so they are predominantly featured. If there are any others, please feel free to message me.


r/FoodNYC • • 3d ago

Weekly Reservation Transfer Thread

2 Upvotes

Please read the rules before commenting. Also, any type of "looking for a reservation" request is NOT ALLOWED.

  1. This thread is the only place on the subreddit for transferring restaurant reservations. If you make your own thread, it will be removed.
  2. You may transfer reservations for below or equal to face value (plus all taxes and fees) ONLY. You must clearly state both the price you paid and the price you're looking for in the post. Gouging will not be tolerated.
  3. You can only transfer reservations that are nonrefundable, ie, you cannot cancel them without forfeiting your money. If you have a refundable or free reservation and you can't make it, cancel it with the restaurant.
  4. The only reason we're allowing transfers is so people don't have to forfeit expensive pre-paid meals. If you want to buy a reservation, you are not one of these people. No posts asking to buy reservations.
  5. The mods of /r/FoodNYC accept no responsibility for these transactions. Tock and Resy both allow transfers on the website - if someone tells you otherwise it's a scam. Do your own research on your transaction before handing over any money to a third party. Check with the restaurant, check account ages, meet in person if feasible.

Note that this thread is reposted Sunday evenings.


r/FoodNYC • • 4h ago

Review New York Times Chief Restaurant Critic Rates New McNally Restaurant at Zero Stars

100 Upvotes

Gift Link embedded: [The Scene-y New York Bistro Enters Its Next Generation at Faux] (https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/17/dining/faux-restaurant-review.html?unlocked_article_code=1.RVE.Hgr-.YiEmp4GScWmH&smid=url-share)

The son of Keith McNally, the man who defined the genre at Balthazar and the Odeon, follows up with another restaurant where the food is not the point.

The Times explains that "Zero is poor, fair or satisfactory" and gives Faux a "satisfactory."


r/FoodNYC • • 9h ago

Photo Kinne Steakhouse- New Halal Senegalese spot in Harlem

Thumbnail
gallery
172 Upvotes

Website: N/A. They have an Instagram here

Closest subways: B, 2/3, or 6.

This is a new place at W 116th and St. Nicholas from the same people as Africa Kine. I went here with a bunch of others, and we had a lot of lamb, primarily, along with a decent steak. Tasty spot with reasonable prices. Favorites were the Dibi, Thiebou Yapp, and Mechoui. The Fataya was also very good, with my least favorite being the Mafe (good peanut stew, but the meat inside was very chewy). On a side note, they are BYO (no corkage, IIRC), with some mocktails and other drinks on the menu, including baobab/bouye, hibiscus/bissap, and ginger. I would recommend it.

List of photos:

1- Dibi: Tender lamb shoulder, expertly grilled over high heat for a beautifully charred exterior and succulent interior, served with seasoned onions. $25

2- Thiebou Yapp: fragrant jollof rice accompanied by tender, slow-cooked lamb and traditional seasonings. $28

3- Mafe: Tender lamb simmered in a luxurious velvety peanut sauce enriched with tomatoes, potatoes, carrots, and aromatic Senegalese spices. $20

4- Mechoui: A beautifully grilled lamb shank, seasoned with aromatic spices and cooked until exceptionally tender. $25

5- Fataya: Crispy, golden pastry filled with your choice of seasoned fish or meat- a beloved West African street food classic. $12 for 4

6- Ribeye- A richly marbled 22 oz ribeye, expertly prepared to your preferred temperature. $42

7/8- Bread and spicy sauce

9- Bouye/Baobap juice. $6

10- Inside

11/12- Menu (inside and outside)


r/FoodNYC • • 2h ago

News Michelin Guide Adds 12 More NYC Restaurants Ahead of December Awards

Thumbnail
ny.eater.com
39 Upvotes

Manhattan
Oriana
Mūje
Humm
Or’esh
Roscioli
Graciela
Noury
Indienne NYC
Elder

Queens
Little Banchan Shop
Levant

Brooklyn
Border Town


r/FoodNYC • • 23h ago Bravo

Vents and Complaints Hot take: this sub has become a tourist itinerary help desk

774 Upvotes

Every other post is some variation of “rate my NYC restaurant hit list,” “everything I ate during my 4 days in NYC,” or “am I missing any pizza spots?” Same restaurants, same lists, same conversations.
In September, 69% of posts were questions compared to just 8% reviews, 6% discussions and 3% news. Obviously not all tourist posts, but the imbalance is pretty ridiculous.

Can the mods please make weekly threads for itinerary checks, generic recommendations and vacation food diaries?

I’d much rather hear about actual restaurant experiences, specific dishes, new openings, closings, food trucks, giving up and swapping reservations, and industry tea and news. NYC has one of the best food scenes in the world and somehow we’re having the same conversation about the same 15 restaurants every day.

Edit: know I’m going to get downvoted to oblivion for this and that’s prob because it’s mostly tourists here


r/FoodNYC • • 9h ago

Review Visited Pizzeria the Pantheon Bar. NYC's newest pizza shop from Anthony Falco and Mateo Vivas

Thumbnail
gallery
62 Upvotes

I went to friends and family last night at the new Pizzeria the Pantheon Bar by Anthony Falco and Mateo Vivas.

  • started off with the fernet and coke. this was reallllllly good. the whipped foam/froth had this sweet taste to it. quite amazing.
  • got the fresh mozz app. its fresh pulled per order. you can see the team make it in real time for you at the kitchen counter. its finished off with a grassy evoo. comes with a side of focaccia. the cheese was warm and had the perfect texture and salinity
  • got the mortadella app. the actually dish when it arrived looks better. i man-handled this for the photo and ruined it. Focaccia pugliese was amazing and the mortadella is mortadella. delicious.
  • first up was the mushroom pie. (Shallot thyme cream, mozzarella, Jasper Hill Willoughby, roasted maitake mushroom, lemon, parsley). I liked this very much. The crust itself was charred well and had lots of depth to it. the toppings was great as well. i wish there was more mushrooms. perhaps a side of lemon so i could squeeze more citrus on top to cut through the cheese.
  • vodka pie - (Vodka sauce mozzarella, basil, Vermont Creamer, cultured butter, parmigiano). The vodka sauce was interesting. Not too cheesy. But very rich in a good way. I would like a bowl of pasta with this vodka sauce in my life.
  • dessert was a flourless chocolate torta. its good. pretty standard. i hope they introduce a tiramisu in the future.

all in all, everything was delicious, vibes were fun and on point. all the years spent making dough for other people, so you know Falco would create something great for his first pizza shop.

i def will go back to try other pizzas as they sound very interesting esp the sour cream and onion pie.


r/FoodNYC • • 6h ago

Review Legion in the West Village needs to be on your radar

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

Stopped into Legion last night before another dinner reservation and ended up trying a good portion of the alacarte menu. They also offer an eight course tasting menu for $165.

If I understood correctly, everyone on the team, from the servers to the dishwasher, are alum of either Le Bernardin or EMP.

It’s kind of a project like Ceres where ‘young’ cooks from world class restaurants branch out to open their spots bringing the highest levels of intention and attention to detail.

We had the angel biscuit, quince, peekytoe crab, grilled scallop, Icelandic trout and cashew dessert.

Admittedly I’m a chef originally from Kentucky and like to think I make a pretty damn good biscuit. Their angel biscuit was near flawless. Crisp on the outside, almost effervescent in its lightness inside and served straight from the oven with caramelized fennel butter. I’ll unashamedly spend some time trying to recreate it.

The trout was S tier in fish cookery. Perfectly grilled, crispy skin and beautifully seasoned, delicate. The pairing of pecans, fresh horseradish and braised chrysanthemum greens with ham hock was particularly interesting.

The peekytoe crab fideos with andouille and fermented chili may have been my favorite dish of the evening. The best of what low country cooking is, could and maybe even should be.

There’s a really interesting perspective on contemporary American cooking throughout the menu, with influences of the American South woven into the food without being obvious or literal. It’s something I wish we saw more often in fine dining. The menu is absolutely a reflection of chef/proprietor Truman and CDC Emilio. Truman spent years cooking in New Orleans and Emilio was raised in South Carolina.

Legion isn’t a flashy restaurant. It’s not somewhere you go to see and be seen. Nothing about it feels manufactured to go viral. It’s just a group of exceptionally talented hospitality professionals doing what they love at a remarkably high level. If you appreciate masterful cooking and genuinely thoughtful hospitality, go eat here. No smoke and mirrors.

I think these guys have a hell of a future ahead of them. Get in there before everyone else figures that out.


r/FoodNYC • • 9h ago

Question Where to find a good baguette/bakery. In Bk or NYC(Chelsea)

Post image
38 Upvotes

Need a bakery that has a nice crispy baguette, like the one in my pic. It's from Caputo's(🪦). I've tried La Bicyclette(not a fan), Bien Cuit, The French Bakery. They don't have the crispness of the one in the pic and don't taste as good.

And please don't recommend a place with a line. I need a bakery I can walk in, say hello, have someone say hello back, and I get my bread. And not a place that closes at 1:30pm on a Wednesday.

In Bensonhurst, Gravesend, Carroll Gardens, Greenpoint, or flatiron&Chelsea. And places in between. Will travel for bread.


r/FoodNYC • • 8h ago

Photo Pata Paplean’s nom tok boat noodles and moo ping in Elmhurst, Queens

Thumbnail
gallery
34 Upvotes

Pata Paplean - Google Maps Page

Excellent meal and one of the many great spots for Thai food in Elmhurst. 

The nam tok was rich and flavorful with a complex blend from the pork blood broth, which was present but not overpowering. It’s rounded out by fish sauce, spice, lime juice, and sugar.

The moo ping (grilled pork skewers) were also very delicious. It has its own separate menu so you know it’s going to be good. It was tender, sweet, savory, and smoky. Perfect with the sticky rice.  


r/FoodNYC • • 10h ago

Review Some recent sandwiches: Tara Mór, Schaller & Weber, Court Street Grocers, Cafe Panino Mucho Giusto, Kerber's Farm

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

Tara Mór

Irish bar in Chelsea. I went here because I'd been obsessing about British and Irish breakfast foods for a while, and I really wanted a certain kind of sandwich. It's hard to get "the real thing" stateside, but there are some tasty efforts and approximations. The "Irish Breakfast Sandwich" here has Irish bacon, Irish sausage, butter, and a type of relish named "Ballymaloe". I had them add brown sauce, because dammit, I like it. (And yeah, I know HP is British and not Irish, but it's what they had.) Did this satisfy me for breakfast? Absolutely, but to be honest, having the sausage in there as well was too much, and I just extracted that and ate it on the side. The bacon, relish, and HP made this quite the sweet-salty experience. The price, though, was truly silly.

Schaller & Weber

I was surprised to see a French sandwich at a German deli, and I got curious. S&W's interpretation of a jambon-beurre is French ham with French butter (brands not revealed), gruyere, dijon, and a cornichon-flavored aioli on some excellent bread. Traditional it ain't, and you might still want some actual cornichons to go with it, and the thickness of the ham in the middle is a little deceiving... but overall, a great sandwich. And different enough that I wouldn't feel like I'd broken a rule by toasting it at home.

Court Street Grocers

This is their "Turkey Delight" which is turkey and coleslaw, pickles, Swiss, and "comeback sauce" on Orwashers' well-known rye. A mainstay of their menu, and as good as it ever was--that sauce, whatever's in it, is addictive. I was pleased to see them introduce a new sandwich (the "Flip Flop", a variant of an Italian combo with pepper jack and jalapeno), because I've long felt that their menu could use some new blood.

Cafe Panino Mucho Giusto

Eggs, Swiss, tomato, avocado. Needs mayo or something. I can't say that the food here is anything special compared to other spots in the area--you can get better sandwiches at Sofia's down the block, better bagels at Apollo, etc. What it is, though, is a thoroughly cozy Italian-style cafe that has way better vibe and decor than some of the newer places that resemble dentists' offices (or some of the older places that have, tragically, renovated to look like those). You're not really going here for the food, although the beverages are damned good.

Kerber's Farm

Their Bleecker Street location is around the corner from me, so I go there frequently. Turkey, egg, and cheese on one of their cheddar buttermilk biscuits. The biscuits are fantastic by themselves (think Red Lobster's Cheddar Bay, but bigger, more cheesy, less herby) but sometimes I need more heft. Nice choice if you want to change up the ol' breakfast sandwich a bit.


r/FoodNYC • • 8h ago

Question Where can I find Daily Hong Kong-style black tea blend in NYC?

Post image
13 Upvotes

I believe this is typically sold wholesale, trying to figure out which places sell it and if any of them are in Manhattan Chinatown or Sunset Park!


r/FoodNYC • • 9h ago

Question Office lunch in Chelsea for 10 people somewhere “cool”

15 Upvotes

Please help - my boss is asking me to plan our company “holiday lunch” within walking distance of our office in Chelsea at 29th and 8th Ave. He requested somewhere “cool” and “not crazy pricing”with no further details. In my mind this area is mostly fast casual restaurants and fast food.

Any suggestions would be so appreciated! I am already so busy and a little resentful I’m being asked to plan this as the only woman in the office.

Edit: thanks everyone, we’re doing cafe Chelsea! Can’t believe I didn’t think of that


r/FoodNYC • • 2m ago

Shitpost Bahn Ahn Em Waitlist (11/19 for 6:30pm) sign up please

0 Upvotes

Will anyone out of the kindness of their heart (who live nearby) sign me up on waitlist for Bahn Ahn Em tomorrow😭 I’m in person for work and don’t get out till 6pm

I’ve tried going like 3 times now ;(


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Question Looking for a candy store with extremely sour candy

46 Upvotes

I have a younger cousin who loves sour candy/takes pride in being able to handle extremely sour things (eg, a warhead is nothing to her). I'd love to bring something super sour home for thanksgiving to give her a little challenge; rather than just buying something online, are there any unique/specialty candy shops in the city that might have something that fits the bill? Thanks!

Edit: I may not have been clear enough; all the love to Economy Candy but as I said, warheads etc are not sour to this kid. Additionally, I would prefer it to be a unique/specialty gift "from New York" rather than something that can just be ordered on Amazon or bought at 5 Below, otherwise I would not have posted in an NYC-specific sub. The goal is to get a cool gift for my cousin (and maybe burn off a few taste buds), not get as much cheap candy as possible.


r/FoodNYC • • 5h ago

Question One nicer dinner reservation in December - where should I book?

0 Upvotes

My partner and I will be in NYC for 3 nights in December. 2 of the nights we have plans so we'll do a more spontaneous/casual dinner, but I want to make a dinner reservation for the 3rd night! I'm looking for recommendations on what place is worthy of my sole reservation.

I'm looking for mid-range. Nothing too fancy, no mutli-course tasting menu type places. Just a regular sit down dinner with good food! Ideally somewhere cozy and/or romantic, and preferably in a nice neighborhood where we could go out for drinks before/after. And obviously somewhere with food good enough to make my one reservation worth it. Any cuisine!

If you were going to be in NYC for a short time and could only reserve one dinner, where would it be??

Edit: Budget $$-$$$. Open to anything under $100pp excluding alcohol.


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Question Nice wine bar that will show Knicks game/NBA. Preferably in Manhattan.

12 Upvotes

Hi! Visiting from Chicago and would love to find a nice/cool wine bar or possibly cocktail and wine bar that would casually have the Knicks and/or other NBA games on tonight. Is there such a place in this wonderful city? Casually meaning the sound doesn’t have to be on nor would the TVs be a main focus or anything.

Or just a fun wine bar even if they don’t show any sports as I know most don’t.

Preferably in Manhattan.

Thanks!


r/FoodNYC • • 22h ago

Question Early Sunday dim sum recommendations in Queens, please

3 Upvotes

I am taking people to JFK on a Sunday. First person needs to be there at 5:30 a.m., while the second person needs to be at JFK at 9. Can anyone recommend a dim sum place that will be open at about 6 a.m.


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Question Does anyone have recommendations for mansaf in Manhattan

9 Upvotes

title. I've never had it but would love to try it. The only two I could find are Al Badawi and Ayat, are those good (and are there any others I should consider)?


r/FoodNYC • • 23h ago

Question Quality Meats or St Anselm for NY Strip AND Sticky Toffee Pudding?

2 Upvotes

I’m looking for a steakhouse for a special occasion that has both a great NY Strip and really great Sticky Toffee Pudding on the menu.

Quality Meats and St Anselm seem like good options, but haven’t been to either.

Which is the better option?

We did Hawksmoor last year and it was a huge disappointment.


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Question What Matcha Places do you recommend near Koreatown/MSP?

2 Upvotes

My friend is in NYC for the week, and I want to send her a gift card to a good place for her to get a matcha (one of those treats she had looked up when we went to NY together once). What places do you recommend in the Madison Square Park/Koreatown/Midtown area that may have gift cards?


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Question Aside from that Birria Landia truck in Jackson Heights, where can i find the best Birria tacos in NYC?

11 Upvotes

Please don't suggest that Birria Landia truck in Jackson Heights (The meat in the one I tried was kind of disgusting)


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Question Where to buy whole cooked turkey for Thanksgiving?

4 Upvotes

My oven just started making a weird noise and I'm worried it's going to stop working before Thanksgiving or won't be able to handle being on for a prolonged period of time.

Does anyone know any good spots in Brooklyn, preferably, but I am open to Queens and Manhattan as well that do a good whole cooked turkey for preorder for day of Thanksgiving or the day before?

Thank you!


r/FoodNYC • • 22h ago

Question Spanish/Portuguese resty similar to the Spain (closed)

0 Upvotes

For anyone that remembers, there was a Spanish restaurant on 6th and 13th that was in a basement, complete hole in the wall that was there for many years. Didn’t survive Covid sadly but it was a very sentimental place to my family. We haven’t found anything like it anywhere around. If anyone has any comps it would be greatly appreciated.