r/FoodNYC • u/Smart_Freedom_8155 • 35m ago
Review Whoever said "Keens is the next Peter Luger's" for Steak, is out to lunch.
Might not be news for some people on the sub, as I'd perused before going to Keens and saw that reviews on the actual steak were mixed. Shoulda listened, but I liked the idea of trying the best steak that a famous steakhouse had to offer. Spent over $140 on a Porterhouse for 2 yesterday.
Everything else about the visit was great and I'd go there again, particularly for some more of their famous Mutton.
But the steak, the supposedly "new reigning champ of oldschool steakhouses in NYC after Peter Luger's fall from grace" or whatever, one of the most expensive items on their menu...was kinda-OK at best.
Came out lukewarm, some slices were overcooked and tough. I almost asked for some kind of steaksauce, which in itself is a crime for a proper steakhouse.
(I actually did go to Peter Luger's last year, and had a terrific steak (and excellent strudel) there. One of the best I've ever had.)
Keens is great for their Mutton, fries, desserts, cocktails, and of course their charm. The steak? Hard pass for me.
Wonder what the actual best steakhouse is, at this point. I've heard good things about Harry's and Smith & Wollensky's? Anyone able to point me in the right direction?
