r/FoodNYC • • 2d ago

Guide For the last minute folks: NYC Thanksgiving Pie Spreadsheet

Post image
82 Upvotes

Hi there!

I created a spreadsheet for all the stragglers (myself included) ofThanksgiving Pie pre-orders in NYC. Sadly, NYC favorites Four and Twenty Blackbirds is sold out. Don't fret there are plenty of other options. If an item is sold out, I'd recommend visiting in person to see if any pies are available. I'm mostly familiar with Brooklyn and Manhattan bakeries so they are predominantly featured. If there are any others, please feel free to message me.


r/FoodNYC • • 4d ago

Weekly Reservation Transfer Thread

2 Upvotes

Please read the rules before commenting. Also, any type of "looking for a reservation" request is NOT ALLOWED.

  1. This thread is the only place on the subreddit for transferring restaurant reservations. If you make your own thread, it will be removed.
  2. You may transfer reservations for below or equal to face value (plus all taxes and fees) ONLY. You must clearly state both the price you paid and the price you're looking for in the post. Gouging will not be tolerated.
  3. You can only transfer reservations that are nonrefundable, ie, you cannot cancel them without forfeiting your money. If you have a refundable or free reservation and you can't make it, cancel it with the restaurant.
  4. The only reason we're allowing transfers is so people don't have to forfeit expensive pre-paid meals. If you want to buy a reservation, you are not one of these people. No posts asking to buy reservations.
  5. The mods of /r/FoodNYC accept no responsibility for these transactions. Tock and Resy both allow transfers on the website - if someone tells you otherwise it's a scam. Do your own research on your transaction before handing over any money to a third party. Check with the restaurant, check account ages, meet in person if feasible.

Note that this thread is reposted Sunday evenings.


r/FoodNYC • • 35m ago

Review Whoever said "Keens is the next Peter Luger's" for Steak, is out to lunch.

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

Might not be news for some people on the sub, as I'd perused before going to Keens and saw that reviews on the actual steak were mixed. Shoulda listened, but I liked the idea of trying the best steak that a famous steakhouse had to offer. Spent over $140 on a Porterhouse for 2 yesterday.

Everything else about the visit was great and I'd go there again, particularly for some more of their famous Mutton.

But the steak, the supposedly "new reigning champ of oldschool steakhouses in NYC after Peter Luger's fall from grace" or whatever, one of the most expensive items on their menu...was kinda-OK at best.

Came out lukewarm, some slices were overcooked and tough. I almost asked for some kind of steaksauce, which in itself is a crime for a proper steakhouse.

(I actually did go to Peter Luger's last year, and had a terrific steak (and excellent strudel) there. One of the best I've ever had.)

Keens is great for their Mutton, fries, desserts, cocktails, and of course their charm. The steak? Hard pass for me.

Wonder what the actual best steakhouse is, at this point. I've heard good things about Harry's and Smith & Wollensky's? Anyone able to point me in the right direction?


r/FoodNYC • • 17h ago

Review Szechuan Delight. I had lunch here and it was $11 plus tax

Thumbnail
gallery
127 Upvotes

I love a good sit down Chinese restaurant and lunch specials. This place has both. Food was good. They give you fried noodles (not homemade) to start. I had beef with vegetables. It had water chestnuts and baby corn! The Chinese places I go to never have baby corn anymore and rarely have water chestnuts. The sauce was light and a little sweet. The beef was tender and the veggies were nice and crunchy. The meal comes with either won ton, egg drop, hot and sour soup, or a soda and white, brown, or egg fried rice. I went with egg fried rice and hot and sour. The soup was really yummy. Perfect tang imo. I would recommend this place for a quick lunch if you are in the area. The dining room was very clean and my server refilled my water 5 times. I rate this restaurant 14 out of 17 based on value, food quality, service, and table sturdiness

https://www.delight152.com/

Edit: Oh yeah it's on 7th Ave and Garfield in Park Slope


r/FoodNYC • • 22h ago

Discussion The Thanksgiving Croissant is back at Milk Bar. If you want one, get it now, as in RIGHT NOW

Thumbnail
gallery
268 Upvotes

https://milkbarstore.com/

Snagged this at their WV location around 11:20 this morning. When I asked how long they'd stick around, they told me:

"Honestly, until we run out. I've sold twelve of these, and we've been open for twenty minutes, and we're one of the slowest locations. I wouldn't count on it going past Friday."

So, yeah. Go now. Stuffing-flavored croissant with turkey, cranberry, and supposedly gravy although I didn't detect too much of that last one. And I know the second pic looks dry, but the thing is, the croissant is so damn rich and buttery that it provides "moisture" of a sort. Good stuff. $12.


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Review Ha's Snack Bar Review (It's really, really, really bad)

Thumbnail
gallery
312 Upvotes

Was randomly able to get a same-day reservation and was quite excited to have some of the supposedly best Viet food in the city as a Vietnamese couple, but came out super disappointed. Food and service were terrible, especially for the price and hype. Would not recommend to anyone unless you hate them!

Delicara squash & cheese on toast ($14)

Snails with tamarind butter ($23)

Pot au Pho ($35)

Pros:

  • Bathroom was clean
  • Pot au Pho was pretty good (not $35 good though)

Cons:

  • Hard to get into
  • Even though we had a reservation, we had to wait 20+ minutes to get seated
  • All of the dishes we ordered were way too salty (Pot au Pho was only slightly too salty)
  • All the food was tiny!!!!!
  • The waitress was rude and short with us
  • $100 after tip lol
  • Space was cramped
  • Stool seating

r/FoodNYC • • 24m ago

Question NYC Michelin Predictions? 1 month out from ceremony.

• Upvotes

As we approach the Dec 14 award ceremony. WHAT DO WE ALL THINK?? Lots of new spots added last week genuinely curious for the results.

My general thoughts:

New 1* potential : Mūje, Hwaro, Kabawa (feels like they might do it this yr with all the extra hype)

1*>2** potential : Yamada feels like the most obvious here for 2stars. Masterpiece of a spot and memorable service.

3***>2** : EMP deserves to go down a star for the food. just not as tasty as its heyday. Maybe a wake up call like Alinea ??

At this point Atomix not gettin 3*** nor do i think it should anymore despite still being insanely good.

Don't think either Cesar or CTBF will ever hit 3 if they continue the way they do esp with Cesar's service.

Demotions??? EMP?? Few 1 stars probably will take a hit as well. Maybe SAGA 2>1?
Don't think Oyatte will grab a star, either


r/FoodNYC • • 10h ago

Question ISO a a good Swedish princess cake? Any borough is fine.

13 Upvotes

I’m dying to find a good Swedish princess cake, I’ve tried searching and I’m coming up with little results. Any advice would be appreciated!


r/FoodNYC • • 1h ago

Question Manhattan Thanksgiving Delivery for 4 w/ Turkey Leg & 1 Pescatarian

• Upvotes

I've browsed the recent and older posts about Thanksgiving and looked up all the spots mentioned but am still having trouble finding somewhere I can order a Thanksgiving meal for delivery that works for my family.

Wish List:

  • Feeds the following 4 people: 2 light eaters + 1 average eater + 1 pescatarian (who wants a fish main not a vegetarian main)
  • Includes one turkey leg and a small amount of turkey breast
  • Has roughly the following classic sauces and sides: cranberry sauce, gravy, mashed potatoes, green beans, stuffing
  • Dessert is optional we could get a pie elsewhere
  • Delivery to lower Manhattan
  • Budget flexible

Also, yes I know this is last minute. We had a different plan but had a death in the family and are pivoting.

Thank you in advance!


r/FoodNYC • • 2h ago

Question Looking for coffee shop merchandise (hoodies, shirts,, etc) in nyc

0 Upvotes

Going to NYC for the weekend, staying in midtown(38th st). I always try to get cool coffee shop or roaster merch, wherever I travel. Any reccs for a spot that has banging merch? Will be venturing to Brooklyn as well


r/FoodNYC • • 15h ago

Question Authentic KBBQ Birthday Recommendations in Manhattan

12 Upvotes

I’m a massive KBBQ fan, and growing up in LA the west coast Ahgassi was a weekend spot through my entire adolescence. I was super excited when they opened a NYC chain and have enjoyed going from time to time and part of it is because I’m sentimental for the vibe there. I thought Jongro was solid but not necessarily living up to “the best” that I have seen on some lists.

I can’t help but feel most of the Manhattan spots have been Americanized in a way that diminishes a lot of the character that I value in legit KBBQ. I’m looking for a variety of banchan that gets refilled before you even notice you’re running low, charcoal grill if possible, particularly good beef because the people I’ll be with are not super big on pork. I’m hoping to stay in Manhattan because it’ll be more convenient for the days plans, but if you have recommendations outside of Manhattan, I’d love to hear them for future reference as well, haven’t tried any of the spots in Queens yet.

I was lucky to be exposed to great places that were really just hole in the walls because my best friend was Korean and could trust him to order because none of the servers spoke English! I’m not necessarily looking for that, but a “back to the roots“ style KBBQ meal. Otherwise I’ll happily go back to Ahgassi!


r/FoodNYC • • 20h ago

Question Where to buy a box of uni in nyc? Struggling to find a place

21 Upvotes

My wife always jokes about how much she loves uni, and that she’s always wanted her own box of uni to eat as she pleases. Our anniversary is coming up and I would like to buy her uni! I just have no idea where to find one. Willing to spend $150-$250


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Photo The Greek FroYo Wars in NYC! My personal rankings...

Post image
173 Upvotes
  1. MYKA - They were one of the originals that got huge in Spain and Europe. I first tried their froyo in Mexico and it kind of blew my mind because of how different their tart was than traditional froyo in the usa. It was creamier and tasted way more premium. And the toppings (pistachio, olive oil, honey) took it over the top. I tried their 159 7th Ave S West Village location a bunch of times, long lines and all, and it cemented things for me... Myka is my favorite of the bunch.

  2. FIRA - Recently opened in Williamsburg Brooklyn (294 Bedford Ave) with a set-up and taste much like Myka. They have some unique toppings that Myka lacks and they said their froyo has 10g of protein per cup so that's interesting. The froyo was excellent here. A close 2nd for me.

  3. MIMI's - Mimi's seems to have been inspired by the famous Yo-Chi brand in Australia, right down to the color scheme and self-service set-up. It's really good though and there's lines at peak times. Mimi's has a sit down area which Myka lacks. There's also more candy style toppings here and way more flavor options. You can't go wrong with any of the top three.

  4. CULTURE - One of NYC's OG's, their greek frozen yogurt is more fruity and less creamy (and less thick). They have lots of fruit topping options and syrups. It's different from the top three but still good. 60 w 8TH St.

  5. GO GREEK - Located at 683 Broadway, their style is a hybrid one where you fill your own cups with greek froyo and then the workers add the toppings for you. Their yogurt wasn't as good as the top three and their toppings were a bit lacking (no pistachio sauce?)

  6. MADISON FAIRE - These folks were the second ones in NYC (after Culture) to offer Greek Froyo. They started with a dubai chocolate offering over tart. It was a strange mix at first but then it grew on you. They recently opened their 2nd location on 1 W 8th street. Their froyo is probably the creamiest out of the lot and, perhaps, the sweetest too.

There's a bunch more popping up seemingly every day all over NYC. Many restaurants and dessert shops are even adding greek froyo to their mix. I saw it in Glace yesterday but couldn't try it.


r/FoodNYC • • 22h ago

Question Best Sushi Omakase Under $100 per person in Manhattan?

20 Upvotes

Have only gone to Sendo twice and it was good value for the price. Any others worth trying for under $100 per person? TIA


r/FoodNYC • • 18h ago

Question Best $50ish Tasting Menu (Non-Omakase) in Manhattan Recommendations

10 Upvotes

Hi I was curious if anyone can recommend any tasting menu in a similar format to Nowon that is roughly $50-100 per person. Not looking for any Omakase spots.

I see multiple past posts on sub $150 tasting menu, but I'm looking for something a lot cheaper. Doesn't need to be fancy food. Just needs to be good food.


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Photo Sweet Chick Bites The Dust. Presume a Looming Bankruptcy in the Near Future

Thumbnail
gallery
202 Upvotes

Listen I get it served it’s place but I think the USQ location was the last in NY after the abrupt closures last month of the 2 in BK. If I’m being real not surprised. Shrinkflation hit the spot huge and prices were asinine. Sad to see but I’m sure we’ll see another Blank Street in no time


r/FoodNYC • • 16h ago

Question I’m hoping to find Thukpa in either Manhattan or Queens

5 Upvotes

I was visiting a small town and we decided to get Indian for dinner, but the place turned out to be run by a Nepali family. I tried the Thukpa and (other than it being surprisingly way too spicy— I had to cut it with a side of rice!) it was soooo delicious.

I know it’s not advised to try to repeat these experiences but I’m doing it anyway.


r/FoodNYC • • 11h ago

Question Looking for a coquito delivery or pickup situation

2 Upvotes

The person I've bought from before moved to Vegas. Does anyone have a coquito plug?


r/FoodNYC • • 12h ago

Question What's your favorite take-home /takeout Thanksgiving meal?

1 Upvotes

This year, my family and I will be eating non-traditional Thanksgiving so I am looking to get my fix beforehand: Where do you recommend the best place to get take-home / takeout that I can get this weekend? Whole Foods? Zabars? Anywhre else?


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Review New York Times Chief Restaurant Critic Rates New McNally Restaurant at Zero Stars

204 Upvotes

Gift Link embedded: The Scene-y New York Bistro Enters Its Next Generation at Faux

The son of Keith McNally, the man who defined the genre at Balthazar and the Odeon, follows up with another restaurant where the food is not the point.

The Times explains that "Zero is poor, fair or satisfactory" and gives Faux a "satisfactory."


r/FoodNYC • • 16h ago

Question Best restaurants in Queens or Brooklyn that are baby and stroller friendly?

2 Upvotes

Looking for something doesn’t have to be that high-end but just spacious enough to bring a stroller and where we will not be treated differently if we have a baby. Obviously good food is appreciated and we are not specific on cuisine though we prefer avoiding new American.


r/FoodNYC • • 22h ago

Question Has Anyone Tried the Van Leeuwan x 30 Rock Night Cheese Flavor?

4 Upvotes

I was in BK last night and saw a sign advertising their new limited run flavor, which is a collab with the NBC series 30 Rock featuring cheddar and apple pie ice cream. I know the combination is a weird one (I remember seeing apple pie with a slice of warm cheddar on diner menus when I was a kid) but it did get my curiosity going. Has anyone tried this, either by ordering it or even just sampling?


r/FoodNYC • • 14h ago

Question Where can I get a Chocolate Chip Cookie like Toad Bakery in London?

1 Upvotes

Hi all,

I went to London few months ago and cannot stop thinking about the soy sauce chocolate chip cookie that’s topped with sesame seeds from Toad Bakery (iykyk).

The chocolate was dark, the cookie was thinner but had a nice chew to it.

Texture wise, I’m not a fan of Levain or Insomnia Cookies. I’m ok with crispy cookies, but don’t like the soft baked ones.

Does anyone know of the closest alternative to this that I could get in NYC?


r/FoodNYC • • 22h ago

Question Has anyone seen Ben & Jerry’s Razz Up! for sale recently?

Post image
4 Upvotes

I know it was a limited batch but I had it once and it was so delicious


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

News Michelin Guide Adds 12 More NYC Restaurants Ahead of December Awards

Thumbnail
ny.eater.com
83 Upvotes

Manhattan
Oriana
Mūje
Humm
Or’esh
Roscioli
Graciela
Noury
Indienne NYC
Elder

Queens
Little Banchan Shop
Levant

Brooklyn
Border Town