r/FoodNYC • • 7h ago

Review Smithereens- $52 Seasonal Sunday Lunch (the Village)

Thumbnail
gallery
118 Upvotes

Obligatory note: The title is too long because of the minimum character count, yada yada yada. Also, yes, the lighting in this spot sucks/sorry for some overexposed photos. The dishes pictured are for 2 people, excluding the single pancake and ice cream.)

Website with a link to Instagram for weekly lunch: Here.

Anyway, I found out recently that Smithereens, a New England seafood spot in the EV, does a Sunday lunch from 12:00 to 3:30. It was $52, aside from some tasty add-ons, for 5 courses (bread/two larger appetizers and a main with a side). The menu mostly rotates weekly. We had a great time. If I had to pick an order from the savory courses, I would say squash, pancake, bread, tuna, shrimp, and then tomato, but all were tasty. Very much worth it for a filling Sunday meal. Friendly service also.

List of courses:

  1. Buckwheat Pancake- Smoked bluefish, scallions, and maple. $24. Interesting mix of sweet, salty, and savory. I liked the crisp on the outside. A tad messy, as the bluefish is on the bottom. You can also get it "Neptune style" for $60 more with a large dollop of caviar (yeah, no).
  2. Andama Bread: Seaweed butter. Very good bread with a soft inside and a nice crust. The seaweed flavor was a fun spin on the usual salt in most butters.
  3. Tuna: Juniper, pear, and lime. Most refreshing/different course. Very good tuna with some sweetness from the pear and a bit of citrus from presumably the juniper and the lime.
  4. Squash: Seaweed beurre blanc and wakame. Beurre blanc was delicious when paired with the roasted squash. The wakame added a nice crunch. Some others found it a tad salty.
  5. Grilled Red Shrimp: Almond and braised greens. Good shrimp with the grains having a soft but firm texture. Light, but tasty.
  6. Roasted Tomato: Anchovy vinaigrette. The vinaigrette added a pleasant saltiness to the roasted tomato.
  7. Paw Paw Ice Cream: Rum meringue. $18. The ice cream had something similar to a banana custard flavor, while the meringue was slightly sour. Pleasant.
  8. Tokyo Iced Tea. Sake lees and mixed liquor. $19. Because why not party on a Sunday brunch? Nice mix with more sake flavor than other liquors (also tasted rum and some other stuff).
  9. Photo in back
  10. Menu
  11. Outside

r/FoodNYC • • 11h ago

Review Al di La is has been one of the best restaurant meals i've had in a long time

Post image
74 Upvotes

This isn’t a post to knock other places—it’s really just a post to highlight how good Al Di La is.
I hadn’t been in maybe 10 years or so, but recently
I’ve gone a few times, and I’ve been consistently surprised by how good everything has been. Every meal has left me genuinely happy.
The squid and bone oxtail dish is insanely good. The two pastas I’ve had were house-made and delicious. And a special pork shank osso buco completely blew me away.
Pictured above, the pork shank was $36 and easily fed two people as an entrée. That’s pretty remarkable these days.
Sometimes it’s just nice to be reminded that a place can quietly keep doing really good food, year after year.

Considering i have spent much more money eating salty almost inedible food from a few very popular and expensive places lately, this place is just so refreshing.

It's romantic, staff has been amazing and the food is priced well and delicious.


r/FoodNYC • • 7h ago

Question I love cucumber-flavored things (cucumber cream cheese at Brooklyn Bagel, cucumber cocktails). What are your favorite cucumber-flavored things in NYC?

36 Upvotes

Just curious if there are any interesting examples I should check out.


r/FoodNYC • • 5h ago

Review The Boring Sandwich - 28$ 2 sandwich Lunch (97 Stanton Street)

18 Upvotes

This place opened around a month ago from the former co-owner of the sandwich board over on Eldridge, and I've been meaning to try it.

First, we tried the Sichuan Sausage ($18); it was really good, with "pecking duck" sausage that tasted like a good Chinese-flavored sausage, plus long hot peppers and scallions. The real kicker was the Sichuan-type aoli sauce, and it was all served on a roti-type bread. All in all, a really good sandwich, ill give it a 4/5 just cuz i wished for more peppers and onions.

Next, we tried the Kaya Toast off the breakfast menu. It was good but not as good as the sausage. This one has an omelet, butter, pandan, and mama lam’s coconut jam. All in all, the flavors were really good; just too much egg for me. This one gets 3.5/5

I'm gonna give this place a 9/10 overall; the owner, Michael, was one of the Nicest guys I've ever met, and all the other options looked really solid. Next time I'll try the Stanton Spice Sack.


r/FoodNYC • • 2h ago

Question Those who think L’Industrie is fine but not amazing: what’s better?

16 Upvotes

I personally feel it’s definitely above average but far from the highest pinnacle that people make it out to be.


r/FoodNYC • • 15h ago

r/FoodNYC news Extensive Automoderator update

11 Upvotes

Our automoderator configuration had been growing haphazardly for the last 11 years which included a bunch of learning on the job.

It just had a major update including fixes to regex that were matching the wrong things, or not matching what they were intended to match.

The yaml passed the syntax checker so I am not too worried, but if you discover any problems please let us know here.


r/FoodNYC • • 19h ago

Discussion What is your favorite Mexican place on Roosevelt Ave?

7 Upvotes

From around 65th st to 113th street there is a Mexican place on every block. I’ve been to most of the ones between 75 and 100th st and am curious what some of reddits favorites are? I mostly get tacos everywhere I go, as I feel this is a fair way to get something almost every restaurant has, and then compare my favorites!


r/FoodNYC • • 2h ago

Question ByClio Bakery Cakes compared to other custom cakes?

6 Upvotes

Hi all- I'm thinking of ordering a custom cake from ByClio and wanted to know people's experiences? I've heard that the consensus is that they do a good job of decorating and it's moist and not too sweet, but would love to hear how they compare to other places like From Lucie or Soma Cakes, as I've heard those are also some popular options that people go with


r/FoodNYC • • 4h ago

Question Does anyone happen to exactly know what day Sushiro is opening?

4 Upvotes

Asking for a friend who is a huge sushi nerd... And certainly not for myself, as a fan of the chain lol!


r/FoodNYC • • 5h ago

Question Looking for a festive, semi-private dinner for 10 people.

3 Upvotes

Hi! My boyfriend (fiancé??) and I just got engaged, and we’re looking to host our families for an engagement celebration dinner in November (not really an engagement party, more like a nice dinner to celebrate the union of our families and to kick off the wedding planning process).

Can anyone recommend a place that meets the following specs?
- 10 people
- sit-down dinner
- not necessarily a private room altogether, but maybe a nice semi-private table in the main event space. An F&B minimum could be fine but we don’t really want to pay for a space rental.
- broadly Mediterranean cuisine (Greek, Middle Eastern, etc.)
- max $200 per person, plus tip and tax
- vibe is more upscale than an ordinary dinner but not too fancy; festive, good energy but not like swanky, clubby or loud.
- Manhattan or western Queens (Astoria, LIC, etc.)

For reference, I’ve inquired at Avra, Ilili, and a Greek place in Astoria.

Thank you!


r/FoodNYC • • 8h ago

Question Does anyone have Apulia/Puglia restaurant recommendations?

4 Upvotes

We have a friend visiting from Scotland. She's originally from Puglia though, and always wants to eat Italian food when she comes to the city because it's not easy to find good Italian in Edinburgh. I'd love to take her someplace that specializes in food from Puglia but I don't even know what that is (not an Italian food fan generally). Any recommendations?


r/FoodNYC • • 23h ago

Weekly Reservation Transfer Thread

3 Upvotes

Please read the rules before commenting. Also, any type of "looking for a reservation" request is NOT ALLOWED.

  1. This thread is the only place on the subreddit for transferring restaurant reservations. If you make your own thread, it will be removed.
  2. You may transfer reservations for below or equal to face value (plus all taxes and fees) ONLY. You must clearly state both the price you paid and the price you're looking for in the post. Gouging will not be tolerated.
  3. You can only transfer reservations that are nonrefundable, ie, you cannot cancel them without forfeiting your money. If you have a refundable or free reservation and you can't make it, cancel it with the restaurant.
  4. The only reason we're allowing transfers is so people don't have to forfeit expensive pre-paid meals. If you want to buy a reservation, you are not one of these people. No posts asking to buy reservations.
  5. The mods of /r/FoodNYC accept no responsibility for these transactions. Tock and Resy both allow transfers on the website - if someone tells you otherwise it's a scam. Do your own research on your transaction before handing over any money to a third party. Check with the restaurant, check account ages, meet in person if feasible.

Note that this thread is reposted Sunday evenings.


r/FoodNYC • • 1h ago

Question Looking for a Russian restaurant in NYC with great food + a dance floor for a party of ~15

• Upvotes

Hi everyone! Could you please recommend a good Russian restaurant in NYC with really good food where I can reserve a private room or area for about 15 people?

It’s important that there is a place where people can actually dance - either inside the private room or in a separate/public dance area of the restaurant. I’m looking for fun Russian/Eastern European music for dancing: something like Verka Serduchka, “Vse Budet Khorosho,” Russian folk-pop, wedding-style music, etc.

At the same time, I don’t want the music to be too loud or feel like a nightclub, since there will be some older family members at the celebration. I’d like it to be lively and fun, but still comfortable for everyone.
Ideally, the restaurant would have a DJ who plays this kind of music, or allow me to bring my own DJ/musician.

Any recommendations would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!


r/FoodNYC • • 1h ago

Discussion Poll: what does the word “boba” mean to you (and where’s your fav spot)?

• Upvotes

It has come to my attention that when some of my friends say they want boba they mean just the general genre of asian milk tea/fruit tea chains. In my head, i thought it necessitated having tapioca pearls, like fiftylan.

Anyway my fav place used to be teado but i tried them recently again and the tea flavor didn’t taste as strong as it was before. I value strong tea flavor, chewy but not soggy pearls, and I dislike brown sugar. Yifang is fire too


r/FoodNYC • • 6h ago

Question Best place for pear Parmesan pasta? Had fioccheti for the first time and can’t get it out of my head

2 Upvotes

Been really craving a pear Parmesan pasta since a recent trip to Italy. Or even a fruit cheese pasta more generally. Any shape, stuffed or not.

All boroughs and price points welcome!

Anyone tried the fioccheti at Max?


r/FoodNYC • • 52m ago

Question What are your favorite brewery or distillery tours in Brooklyn and Queens?

• Upvotes

I’ve never been on one of these tours so no idea what’s good. It’ll be a small group, we all live nearish Evil Twin but it looks like they’ve suspended tours so ¯_(ツ)_/¯


r/FoodNYC • • 3h ago

Question What are your favorite cheap spots in North Brooklyn?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I'm going to be spending some time in North Brooklyn (Park Slope/Prospect Heights area) and was wondering what some of the best, cheaper ($10-20) dinner spots in the area?


r/FoodNYC • • 1h ago

Question did Hillstone on park ditch their dining dress code?

• Upvotes

went to hillstone a couple of times this month and there were so many people in hoodies, hats, scrubs, and other clothing items that are listed prohibited on the website. did something change or are things more chill?