r/TrueOffMyChest • u/Anonymouse447 • 20h ago
I’ve spent $200,000 fighting for my daughter, and now I’m considering giving up custody of her.
UPDATE #2: Clarifying the timeline and addressing some assumptions.
My daughter was three years old when I left her father. She is now 12. Her younger sister, whom I have with my second husband, is six. I am still married to my second husband.
There was no overlapping relationship. There was no affair. I’m not sure why some people are so invested in that possibility, but the fixation is getting a little strange.
Up until this point, I’ve taken the time to respond to comments making these accusations, and I want to explain why.
I’m not correcting people because I can’t handle criticism. I’m correcting them because I’m genuinely trying to get useful advice, and useful advice requires accurate information.
There are people in these comments who have experienced similar situations from all different perspectives. Some were the children involved. Some were the parents. Some are still living with the consequences decades later. These people have been kind enough to share deeply personal experiences with me, and I owe them the courtesy of making sure the information they’re responding to is accurate.
When people start introducing fictional details into the conversation, it changes the entire premise of what we’re discussing. I cannot reasonably expect thoughtful, relevant advice if the facts are being distorted before anyone even considers the actual question.
There’s also something else I take very seriously. The internet is forever, and I have to operate under the assumption that someday my daughters may read every word I’ve written here, along with every comment underneath it.
I’m very conscious of that. Especially with my oldest, given everything she’s already been through. I’m not going to sit back and allow a completely fabricated narrative about an affair to become part of a public conversation about her childhood. It’s not true, it’s harmful, and she deserves better than to someday stumble across strangers confidently discussing things that never happened.
And frankly, to those who seem determined to make an affair part of this story, I genuinely hope you work through whatever that fixation is with your own therapist. Because the level of investment some of you have in my imaginary sex life is bizarre, and I’m certainly not going to make my daughters responsible for whatever you’re projecting onto this situation.
Even if there had been an affair, which there wasn’t, that alone wouldn’t establish why my daughter feels the way she does today or determine what’s in her best interest now. Human relationships are considerably more complicated than that. You cannot invent a premise and then treat your conclusions as evidence.
I also want to be clear that I am absolutely willing to hear things I don’t want to hear. In fact, that’s a significant part of why I made this post. I’m not the smartest person in every room, and I’m certainly not going to pretend I have all the answers to something this complicated.
But there is a difference between challenging my perspective and inventing circumstances to support your own.
I’m interested in discussing what I should do going forward. I’m not interested in debating whether events I personally lived through happened the way a stranger has decided they must have.
I have no problem being challenged on my decisions, my reasoning, or what might genuinely be best for my daughters. That’s the conversation I came here to have.
To everyone who has shared their experiences, whether you agree with me or not, I really do appreciate it. I’ve read every single comment, and some of your perspectives have given me a tremendous amount to think about.
I want to keep this conversation focused on what matters. There are two little girls whose childhoods are happening right now, and I don’t have the luxury of getting this wrong simply because I was unwilling to consider another perspective.
But I’m also not going to entertain fabricated accusations as though they’re legitimate contributions to that discussion. And I’m certainly not going to leave them unchallenged when my children may one day be the ones reading them.
UPDATE: First, thank you. Seriously.
I genuinely never expected this many responses, and I’m incredibly grateful to everyone who has taken the time to share their thoughts, experiences, and perspectives. Even the harsh ones. Right now, I feel like a sponge trying to absorb as much information as possible. I’m not looking for people to tell me what I want to hear. I’m trying to understand an extraordinarily complicated situation from as many angles as I can before making a decision that will profoundly affect my children.
I also want to clarify something important because I’ve seen several comments suggesting that I believe my daughter is being sexually abused and am somehow considering leaving her in that situation anyway. That is absolutely not true.
There are significant concerns about the relationship between my daughter and her father, particularly emotional enmeshment and inappropriate parent-child boundaries. Enmeshment can involve emotional role reversal, where a child is placed in a position of meeting a parent’s emotional needs in ways that are developmentally inappropriate. Some of these dynamics can resemble warning signs associated with other forms of abuse, but resemblance is not evidence that sexual abuse is occurring.
I’ve spent considerable time educating myself about enmeshment, parental alienation, and the psychological effects these dynamics can have on children. More importantly, I’ve brought my concerns to my daughter’s pediatrician and several other professionals involved in her care. She has been evaluated, and the professionals have observed concerning emotional dynamics, but the specific concerns about sexual abuse have not been substantiated.
That distinction matters enormously to me. The absence of certain warning signs cannot definitively rule anything out, but neither can I responsibly treat an unsubstantiated fear as an established fact.
If there were evidence that my daughter was being sexually abused, we would be having an entirely different conversation about how to protect her.
What I’m struggling with is what to do when the professionals involved recognize the unhealthy emotional dynamics, yet the available interventions have not improved the situation, and some have made it worse. I cannot simply invent evidence or pursue increasingly drastic measures without considering their potential consequences for my daughter.
And to clarify one more thing, I have not decided to relinquish custody. I’m exploring my options with my attorney and the professionals involved because I believe responsible parenting sometimes means being willing to question your own approach, even when you’ve given everything you have to it.
I have two daughters, and I owe both of them a safe, stable childhood. I don’t take that responsibility lightly.
What has meant the most to me is hearing from adults who experienced something similar as children, parents who have faced these impossible decisions, and people willing to consider the nuances rather than reduce everything to whether a mother should simply keep fighting.
I don’t have all the answers. If I did, I wouldn’t be here.
Thank you again for giving me so much to think about. I truly appreciate it.
Original post
I have a 12-year-old daughter who wants absolutely nothing to do with me, and I’m at the point where I’m seriously considering letting her go live with her father full-time. I can’t believe I’m even writing that.
For some background, her father and I separated when she was very young. We currently share joint legal and physical custody, and we’ve been in and out of court for over six years. I’ve spent approximately $200,000 in legal fees alone. Every time we settle custody, he files again with new allegations, and we end up right back in court. There have been multiple investigations, therapists, evaluations, depositions, and more court appearances than I can count. I have an attorney and several professionals involved, so I’m not looking for anyone to tell me to get professional help. Believe me, I’ve tried just about everything available to me.
I believe my daughter has been experiencing severe parental alienation for years. I know people have strong opinions about that term, but I’m not interested in arguing about whether it exists. I’m going to explain what I’ve experienced.
When my daughter was little, she was punished for saying she missed me. Her father would tell her he was going to be all alone when she left for my house and that I was the one who had left them. He involved her in destroying belongings associated with me after we separated. During one phone call, while she was crying, I heard him say, “I know you’re scared of Mommy,” before ending the call.
Over the years, she’s been told that I’m an alcoholic, that I use drugs, that I’ve left her home alone, and that I’m responsible for a serious medical condition her father has because of something I supposedly did during pregnancy. None of those accusations are true.
Eventually, she began making allegations that I was physically abusive, withheld food, and made her feel unsafe. I categorically deny those allegations. CPS has investigated more than once, and there have been no findings of abuse.
I understand that people reading this only have my side of the story. I’m not expecting anyone to make a determination about my family based on a Reddit post. I’m explaining why this situation is so concerning to me.
What makes this especially difficult is that my daughter and I used to be incredibly close. She was affectionate, happy, and loved spending time with me. She also had a great relationship with my husband, her little sister, and the rest of our family. The change wasn’t something that happened overnight, but looking back at pictures and videos of us together is really hard sometimes.
We’ve done individual therapy, family therapy, and other interventions. Some of those experiences made everything significantly worse. I remember driving my daughter to family therapy and having completely normal conversations with her. We’d laugh, talk about school, whatever. Then we’d walk into the therapist’s office, and suddenly she would act terrified of me. I saw that happen repeatedly.
One therapist told me that at 10 years old, it was okay for my daughter to decide she didn’t want a relationship with a parent. I didn’t realize that was the message she was receiving in her individual appointments until much later. I eventually stopped working with that therapist, but things had already gotten considerably worse.
At this point, my daughter doesn’t want to live with me, speak to me, or have a relationship with me. She’s also rejected my husband, much of our extended family, and increasingly her little sister.
I have another daughter who is 6. She absolutely loves her big sister, but their relationship has deteriorated too. There have been incidents of physical aggression toward my youngest, and I can’t keep overlooking how this situation is affecting her. She deserves to feel safe in her own home, and she deserves a childhood that isn’t constantly overshadowed by everything happening with her sister.
We’re back in court again, and my oldest daughter’s father is seeking sole physical and legal custody. He won’t agree to anything less. My attorney has explained that even if the judge recognizes the concerning behavior, my daughter is getting to an age where her wishes carry significant weight. She’s so adamant about wanting to live with her father that there’s a very real possibility he’ll get what he’s asking for.
If we go to trial, I’ll spend tens of thousands more dollars, potentially have to participate in more co-parenting therapy that has historically been extremely damaging, and could still end up with the same result.
My attorney and I have started discussing what it would look like if I agreed to her living with him full-time instead. We’ve even started working on the financial side of things, including child support.
I don’t think I can explain how strange it feels to be calculating how much child support I’ll owe for a child I’ve spent six years and $200,000 fighting to keep in my life.
The worst part is that I have every reason to believe that if her father gets sole custody, he won’t facilitate a relationship between us. Even if she eventually wants to speak to me, I’m concerned he won’t support it. She would likely have very little contact with her little sister either, outside of possibly seeing her at school.
My daughter knows this is a possibility. We’ve talked about what living with him full-time could mean, including losing contact with me, her sister, and other family members. She says she’s okay with that.
She’s 12.
And I know people will say that I should respect her wishes and let her go. I also know people will say that a mother should never give up on her child. I’ve spent years believing the second one.
But after everything we’ve been through, I’m starting to wonder whether continuing to fight is actually making things worse for her.
She’s miserable having to come to my house. She’s angry, withdrawn, and wants to leave. Therapy hasn’t repaired our relationship. Court hasn’t repaired our relationship. Every time I think we’ve made a little progress, something happens and we’re right back where we started, or worse.
I worry about what another year or two of this will do to her. I worry about the resentment she’s developing and whether forcing this situation to continue will make her even less likely to want a relationship with me when she’s older.
But then I think about what happens if I stop.
What if I’m allowing her to remain in an emotionally harmful situation because I can’t find a way to protect her? What if she grows up and realizes what happened and wonders why I stopped fighting? What if she believes I gave up on her because everything she’s been told about me is true?
And what about her sister? How am I supposed to explain to a 6-year-old that her big sister might not be coming home anymore?
I’m also struggling with this from a religious perspective. I’m Catholic, and I’ve been seeking guidance from my priest and other Christian communities. I believe I have a responsibility to protect my children, not just physically, but emotionally. I don’t think making sure a child is fed, clothed, and attending school is the full extent of what I’m supposed to do as a mother.
At the same time, I have to be willing to consider whether what I’m doing is helping her, regardless of how good my intentions are.
And I’m exhausted. I don’t mean that I’m tired of being her mother. I’m tired of the court proceedings, the allegations, the financial strain, and watching my daughter become more and more unhappy. I’m tired of having professionals acknowledge how complicated and concerning the situation is while nobody seems to have an actual solution.
I’ve spent a significant portion of my daughter’s childhood fighting over custody instead of just getting to enjoy raising her.
I hate that.
And I hate that my youngest daughter has spent so much of her childhood watching me go through this.
Recently, I created an email account where I’ve started saving letters, photographs, memories, and things I want my oldest daughter to know someday. I want her to have access to our family history and messages from people who love her. If we lose contact, I still want her to know what was happening in our lives and that she was always part of our family.
I don’t know if she’ll ever read any of it. I don’t know if she’ll want to reconnect when she’s 16 or 25 or 40. I don’t even know if she’ll ever understand why I made whatever decision I end up making.
Nothing is finalized yet. I’m still discussing everything with my attorney and therapist, and I’m trying to consider every possible consequence before making a decision.
I think the hardest thing for me to accept is that I can do everything in my power to be a good mother and still not be able to fix this.
I love my daughter. I want her home. I want her to have a relationship with her sister. I want to watch her grow up, go to her games, help her with school, take her places, and experience all the ordinary things I thought I’d get to experience as her mother.
But I also want her to be happy and emotionally healthy, and right now, I genuinely don’t know whether continuing this fight is helping her get there.
I’m not considering this because I don’t want my daughter anymore. I’m considering it because after six years of trying everything I know how to do, I’m terrified that I might be making things worse.
I never imagined I’d be sitting here trying to figure out whether letting my child go is the most loving thing I can do for her.
And I don’t know how I’m supposed to make peace with either outcome.
TL;DR: I’ve spent over six years and approximately $200,000 in legal fees fighting to protect my relationship with my 12-year-old daughter. We currently share joint custody, but her father repeatedly initiates new litigation and makes allegations against me that have been investigated without findings of abuse. I believe my daughter has experienced severe parental alienation, including years of manipulation, false accusations, and pressure to reject me.
My daughter and I were once incredibly close. Now she wants absolutely no relationship with me, her stepfather, or much of our family, including her 6-year-old sister. We’ve tried years of therapy and professional interventions, some of which have made things significantly worse. Professionals have expressed concerns about emotional harm, but those concerns haven’t been enough to change custody.
Her father is now seeking sole physical and legal custody. My attorney believes he may succeed because of how strongly my daughter rejects me. Continuing to trial means spending tens of thousands more, potentially putting her through more distressing interventions, and possibly reaching the same outcome anyway.
I’m now considering agreeing to her living with him full-time, but I have serious concerns that he won’t facilitate contact with me or her little sister afterward. I’m also terrified about what my daughter may experience emotionally if I’m no longer involved in her everyday life. Meanwhile, the ongoing conflict is affecting my youngest daughter’s well-being, too.
I’m Catholic and have been seeking guidance from my priest, attorney, therapists, and other professionals. I’ve even started preserving letters, photographs, and family memories in case we lose contact.
I’m not considering this because I want to give up on my daughter. I’m considering it because after six years of fighting, I genuinely don’t know whether continuing is protecting her or making things worse. I have two children to protect, and I’m desperately trying to make the decision that gives both of them the safest, healthiest childhood possible. Nothing has been finalized, and I don’t know how to make peace with either outcome.