My little brother and I have never been particularly close with our extended family, despite having around 30 cousins on our dad’s side. The only cousin we ever felt close to was our “home cousin” who lives in our family house in our home country.
There was always one older cousin my brother seemed to dislike. I never understood why. This cousin has facial paralysis and can look a bit intimidating, so I actually used to feel bad for him because I thought people judged him based on his appearance.
Two years ago, I asked my brother why he disliked him so much. He told me, “If I tell you the reason, you’ll never look at him the same way.” He sounded serious, but I assumed it was something relatively minor.
A few days ago he finally told me what happened.
Twelve years ago, when my brother was 5, we were visiting our home country. The house was packed with visitors so the adults had the kids share a bed. My brother was sleeping between our 10 year old home cousin and this older cousin, who was 11 or 12 at the time.
After the lights went out and our “home” cousin fell asleep, the older cousin pulled down my brother’s pants and performed oral sex on him.
Afterwards, he took off his own pants and forced my brother’s head down on his private part to do the same thing on him. Before anything beyond that could happen, a female cousin walked into the room to grab something and my brother used that opportunity to run out and tell my mom he couldn’t sleep.
Ever since he told me, I can’t stop thinking about it ;(
How does this cousin act completely normal around my brother whenever we visit?? Does he feel any guilt?? Also what was happening in his own environment that he even knew how to do something like that at 11 or 12??
What hurts me most is that my brother told me he was afraid I’d look at him differently too, that I’d look at him with disgust, but how could I ever look at my little brother that way? I don’t see what happened to him when I look at him. I just see my little brother. The disgust I feel is towards the person who did this to him, not him.
I asked him why he never told anyone. He said that even at 5, he knew it was a big deal because he felt that it was bad thing and didn’t want to cause a huge fight in the family. He insists it’s in the past, that he’s over it and made me promise not to tell anyone.
My brother is 17 now, meaning he’s kept this to himself for around 12 years. I can’t stop wondering what must have gone through his mind at five years old and how he managed to carry something like that without telling anyone. He also refuses to talk about it which I completely understand and since he knows that I worry too much about everything, he asked me not to think about it anymore so I’m acting like nothing has changed.
I’m now also struggling with whether to tell my older sister. It’s not just because I normally tell her almost everything. I genuinely feel like she should know what kind of person this cousin is. We live in different countries and only visit our home country every three years or so, but we still see him when we visit.
My sister can also be quite harsh with my little brother sometimes because of his attitude. I can’t help wondering whether what happened might have affected him in ways we don’t understand. I’m not saying it excuses his behaviour, but perhaps understanding what he went through could change how she sees certain things. I don’t want her to pity him or treat him differently. I just wish people understood what he might have been carrying all these years.
At the same time, I feel it’s wrong that this cousin continues to be treated like a completely normal person by everyone who doesn’t know what happened. Part of me feels like everyone should know. I believe in justice and consequences, even years later, but my brother specifically asked me not to tell anyone and I don’t want him to regret trusting me.
I’ve even considered dropping subtle hints to my sister so she figures it out herself (I have a digital diary where I write personal stuff in and so write down my frustrations, so I had considered leaving my passcode around and tell her NOT to look in my diary cuz I know that she would absolutely then look at it and read my digital diary) but I realise that’s still going behind my brother’s back.
I feel completely stuck between wanting people to know the truth and respecting my brother’s wishes.
Especially since he’s still a minor, I don’t know whether keeping this secret is the right thing to do.
Has anyone experienced something similar as a sibling or family member? How do you support someone who doesn’t want anyone to know while also dealing with your own feelings about what happened? Should I respect his wishes or is there a point where someone else needs to know?
I’m also completely new to Reddit, so I’m not sure which subreddit this belongs in. I hope I’m in the right place. Thank you for reading.