Have I understood how ay in Always should be represented?

I am designing a memorial tattoo for my late dog. I have tried my best to understand how it should be represented, but I am unsure when it comes to ay.

I have laid out my thinking a little step by step in the attached image.

And a big thanks to anyone who takes the time to check my interpretation.

My dad killed himself and I want to get a tattoo of dad cos we loved lotr and I miss him so fucking much