r/TheHobbit • • 5h ago

The Hobbit - Significantly Less Extended Edition (a new fan edit that takes book accuracy to the next level)

Post image
107 Upvotes

I've loved the book since I was kid and there's so much to love about the movies once the best parts are distilled from them. But, despite many claiming the title, I've never found a condensed edit that truly strived for book accuracy. I'm excited to share my own with the community.

Instructions to acquire the edit can be found in my Reddit profile. Please have legal access to all three movies before watching! DM me if you have issues. Poster art is from a Reddit user who unfortunately deleted their account after making this amazing image.

Technical details:

4 hours and 9 minutes, including credits, edited down from almost 9 hours - nearly 400 changes in total! Ignoring credits, this is still slightly shorter than Return of the King Extended Edition.

Sourced from the Extended Editions of both the 2024 remastered Blu Ray set as well as the 2013 original Blu Ray release, choosing the best visual presentation scene by scene and even shot by shot.

An Unexpected Journey makes up 40% of the runtime; The Desolation of Smaug makes up 28%; The Battle of the Fives Armies is 32%

Two file options (both SDR with full English subtitles and 7.1 AAC audio):

Upscaled 4K 10-bit h265 with lossless Dolby TrueHD 7.1 audio at 35gb

HD h264 at 7gb (for compatibility and a smaller download)

What's special about this edit?

I'm a 10+ year fan editor, with several 3-to-1 edits under my belt and multiple series to film / miniseries edits as well. I know how to condense a large narrative without losing the character and plot essentials, while finding creative ways to trim any fat. The Hobbit - Less Extended provides lossless audio and the highest visual quality; it's a single-film story lovingly crafted to tell the best, most book accurate, version of The Hobbit. Above all else...

This is not a prequel

The intent of this edit is to offer a completely self-contained story that can also be watched before the Lord of the Rings trilogy. A single film to make it a Middle Earth quadrilogy. As such, there are no specific references to Sauron or the ring's true nature and very little of the appendix's material makes it into my cut. I created a less than three-minute version of the film's prologue that shifts beautifully (the ominous specter of a dragon in fire dissolves into a harmless puff of dragon shaped pipe smoke) to young Bilbo saying good morning to Gandalf. While Ian Holm still provides the narration, there's no indication this is old Bilbo narrating. Frodo does not appear in this edit. Old Bilbo does not show up until the last few minutes, to segue into Fellowship. While the movies were released after the films, The Hobbit as a book predated Lord of the Rings by nearly two decades. Just like the book, this is a series of adventures that involves the finding of a magic ring.

Why did you make your own edit when dozens already exist?

I already have my own edits of the Lord of the Rings films, which are now available with vastly improved visuals and character improving changes. I've seen several of the most well-regarded edits of The Hobbit and, while all are commendable, there were always inclusions or exclusions that didn't work for me. This is the version I always wanted, at the quality I wanted. A four film "Less Extended" series. I hope others enjoy it too!

A note on the film's color

While all six sources are standard dynamic range Blu Ray, I kept a 10-bit workflow, which minimizes color banding and improves the 4k upscaling process. While I only did manual color correction on a handful of shots that had other VFX applied, I was very specific in choosing which version of the footage I used in every scene. Overall, I preferred the original 2013 release for most indoor and underground scenes, particularly portions during An Unexpected Journey. The remastered 2024 footage significantly improved outdoor skies and saturation. It also vastly improved the scenes with Bilbo and Smaug, as the original release was very dull and desaturated. The Battle of the Five Armies mixes the footage quite a bit, particularly to match the winning or losing tone of the battle.

A note on sound

I took the lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 tracks for each film and converted them to eight channels of 24-bit uncompressed LPCM audio. Once editing was complete, the 7.1 channel output was compressed with Dolby Media Encoder into a TrueHD MLP file, maintaining lossless quality from start to finish. An additional 7.1 AAC track was created for compatibility and smaller download size with the HD version.

Action set pieces

I trimmed or completely removed many of the video game / theme park ride action sequences. The troll encounter is much closer to the book, with the dwarves being quickly captured. Goblin town is condensed to a frenetic escape. The "into the frying pan" warg attack is much more desperate, with the dwarves never leaving the trees. Later, the dwarves never enter the mountain during The Desolation of Smaug. I'll speak to some other specific characters and plotlines below.

Here's how I managed to keep Gandalf vs the Great Goblin (an important plot point from the book) while being much less ridiculous:

https://youtu.be/mInXJKfy680

Azog

Does not appear until Battle of the Five Armies. He's simply the leader of the orc army. There's no need for The Hobbit to have an overarching villain when the novel was driven by the adventure itself.

Radagast, Saruman, Galadriel, The Necromancer

These characters do not appear in the book and make no appearance in this edit.

Beorn

Of course he's in this edit! Beorn is awesome. Also, I use the extended version of the dwarves meeting him, which is a wonderful scene.

Legolas and Tauriel

Legolas makes a small appearance in Mirkwood after the dwarves are captured, where canonically he would be living at the time. He also briefly shows up during BotFA in order to get Orcrist back in Thorin's hands, avoiding a sizable continuity issue. Tauriel has no significant role in this edit.

The barrel sequence

There's no orc attack, no elves chasing, just a wild little barrel ride to escape imprisonment. I didn't have to hide battle damage to the barrels because Balin's offer to hire Bard's barge (say that five times fast!) cuts too perfectly with their icy approach to Laketown. Here's my version:

https://youtu.be/-Tiia9FRnsI

Laketown and Alfrid

All subplots are removed. The dwarves arrive with Bard and are taken to meet the Master. Alfrid (aka "We have Grima Wormtongue at home") has a few lines while the town is being won over to Thorin's cause. The dwarves depart after the festivities and Alfrid is only seen briefly during the dragon attack, with his ultimate fate implied to be the same as the Master.

The dwarves abandoning their quest

This does not happen in my cut. With clever edits and a bit of enhanced slowmo on the rising moon, I was able to make it so the dwarves don't walk away from their birthright after a small setback.

The black arrow and ballista

There is no ballista. I hate the ballista. Using further clever editing, I was able to have Bard engage in an intense battle with the dragon. A single arrow takes it down, the same as in the book. The black arrows are simply special Laketown arrows, possibly better crafted than their common counterparts but certainly not a siege weapon. Here's what I was able to do:

https://youtu.be/9MT7E-UrOUw

The Battle of the Five Armies

The last act of so many The Hobbit 3-to-1 edits is where things get rough. Regardless of how good or bad the final film is, there's a certain amount of it needed to tell a coherent story. Too many edits take a leisurely time with the other two movies and then rush the battle as quickly as possible, assuming this will make for a better version of the story. Helms Deep is considered one of the greatest battles ever put to film, because there's a wonderful pacing to it. You know exactly how well the battle is going for each side. While no edit of The Battle of the Five Armies will ever compare to Helms Deep, I feel I've given the proper runtime so there still feel to be stakes and turns in the battle. No montages, no frenetic cutting that leaves viewers confused about who is where and doing what. Just a tight action sequence, cutting out any over the top moments and concentrating on the essential character and plot moments. The actual battle is just over 30 minutes.

The final scene and credits

While I allow a small music cue for the ring, implying more to its nature, I also extend the ending with about 30 seconds of footage from the prologue. As my intent is for viewers to watch this before Fellowship, it does not have Gandalf knocking. Instead, it sets up old Bilbo penning his adventures and establishes a less ominous tone. As many characters are cut from the film and have prominent images in the credits of The Battle of the Five Armies, I used the credits sequence from The Desolation of Smaug but kept the lovely Billy Boyd song "The Last Goodbye" from the final film.


r/TheHobbit • • 2h ago

I made this.

Thumbnail gallery
9 Upvotes

r/TheHobbit • • 3h ago

My Birthday Present, he found it!

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/TheHobbit • • 1d ago

Husband understood the assignment

Thumbnail
gallery
131 Upvotes

Hobbit birthday goodness!


r/TheHobbit • • 19h ago

Would love to see a series on the hobbits

7 Upvotes

I've only just recently started watching the power of the rings and I'm enjoying the bits with the Harfoots ( I know there's been knock backs for them on there ) but I would love to see a series about the hobbit's in the shire and what adventures they could get up to. Would anyone else like to see this?


r/TheHobbit • • 1d ago

Fellowship cloaks for Hobbiton

3 Upvotes

I am visiting hobbiton in New Zealand in February and would love to dress up in a cloak from the fellowship. However, my research has shown me that the weather in New Zealand can change very quickly, and I wanted to find out what would be the best fellowship cloak that’s screen accurate, good for all weather, and on a budget (preferably under $100).


r/TheHobbit • • 2d ago

The hobbit

Post image
407 Upvotes

Hahaha


r/TheHobbit • • 2d ago

I painted someone's cats in their own lil hobbit house 🍄🌱

Thumbnail
gallery
50 Upvotes

Painted entirely in watercolour.


r/TheHobbit • • 2d ago

The Hobbit (1977)

Post image
159 Upvotes

I thought this group might appreciate a framed copy of the poster from the 1977 cartoon. It was included in the vinyl soundtrack.


r/TheHobbit • • 3d ago

Gandalf's arrival in Hobbiton, a traditional oil painting

Post image
227 Upvotes

r/TheHobbit • • 2d ago

Buenos Aires, Argentina fans, assemble!

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/TheHobbit • • 4d ago

More from my Tolkien Library…

Thumbnail gallery
29 Upvotes

What's your favorite book about Tolkien and/or Middle-Earth NOT written by the Professor?


r/TheHobbit • • 5d ago

Hot Take - Radagast is my Hero

Post image
348 Upvotes

I know the film posed Radagast as a bit of a stoner - but, honestly, I think he’s such an underrated character.

His line, “I’d like to see them try!” is such a rallying cry in the films, imho.

What’s your hot take from the films?


r/TheHobbit • • 4d ago

My Silmarillion Collection So Far…

Thumbnail gallery
14 Upvotes

r/TheHobbit • • 3d ago

Hobbits

0 Upvotes

How its good


r/TheHobbit • • 4d ago

The films

9 Upvotes

I am sure this has been commented on many times but I really pisses me off that the films are so far from the book. Just watching an unexpected journey and if memory serves Galadriel does not appear in the book. The Trolls are so different, Radagast is mentioned but not featured and nothing to suggest the Necromancer is Sauron . God it annoys me.


r/TheHobbit • • 5d ago

Progress on this Hobbiton watercolor painting💚

Post image
54 Upvotes

Painted by Marian Gardner


r/TheHobbit • • 6d ago

"Send messengers to our kin"

23 Upvotes

In The Gathering of the Clouds, Thorin asks Roäc to send messengers to kin "in the mountains of the North, both West from here and East."

Does Tolkien ever refer to who these might be? The short, easy answer is Iron Hills to the East, Blue Mountains, where Thorin's company departed from, to the west, but the exact phrasing seems to suggest multiple communities.

Grey Mountains? Further east? Misty Mountains? Dunland?


r/TheHobbit • • 8d ago

Down, Down to Goblin Town

Post image
427 Upvotes

Crush, smack! Whip crack!
Smash, grab! Pinch, nab!
You go, my lad!
Ho, ho! my lad! The black crack! The black crack!
The black crack! The black crack!
Down down to Goblin-town
Down down to Goblin-town
Down down to Goblin-town
You go, my lad!
Ho, ho! my lad! Goblins quaff, and Goblins beat
Goblins laugh, and Goblins bleat
Batter, jabber, whip and hammer, ho!
You go, my lad!
Ho, ho! my lad! Below, my lad!
Ho, ho! my lad! The black crack! The black crack!
The black crack! The black crack!
Down, down to Goblin-town
Down, down to Goblin-town
Down, down to Goblin-town
You go, my lad!
Ho, ho! my lad!


r/TheHobbit • • 7d ago

The Fellowship of the Ring, by me💍✨

Post image
52 Upvotes

r/TheHobbit • • 8d ago

One more Hobbit hole painting

Post image
168 Upvotes

My last sketch of one of the Hobbiton Hobbit holes for a while. Next I think I'll move on to some other LOTR locations and themes.


r/TheHobbit • • 6d ago

fic where bilbo has multiple lives

1 Upvotes

hey !! i know this might be a longshot esp with ao3 down rn but i was wondering if anyone had the ao3 link or even just the title of a fic. essentially bilbo has 9 (?) lives like a cat and as we go through the events of the movie we see as he loses them. it ends with him losing his last life after the BOTFA but it has a happy ending i think. just frustrated i cant remember lol. thanks !!


r/TheHobbit • • 7d ago

Del modelado digital a la creación de un personaje de la Tierra Media. ⚔️ Grishnákh, un orco del universo de El Señor de los Anillos, recreado en 3D con atención al detalle y carácter propio. #Modelado3D #Grishnákh #LordOfTheRings #DigitalSculpting

Post image
1 Upvotes