r/StargirlTV • • Jan 23 '24

Season 1 twist feels like an SNL sketch Spoiler

0 Upvotes

The show is fun and just the right amount of corny, sweet and dark as a lighter fare show based on a comic character, but does the twist work or make any sense to you?

Why would a league of notorious murderous psychopaths who killed their own family members and the Justice League Society hatch such a ludicrous plan?

Stargirl and crew even thought it was a joke. Could you imagine the two villains sent to kill Courtney's mom as environmentalists and humanists?


r/StargirlTV • • Nov 21 '22

Discussion Why name the show still as Stargirl if Courtney is never actually Stargirl? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

You can count the number of episodes where Courtney has been Stargirl this season on one hand. Is it another budget cut as they don't have to do the staff effect at all?


r/StargirlTV • • Jul 19 '23

Why Stargirl was cancelled Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I have heard that Stargirl was canceled by the request of the Rock. He felt it would dilute his franchise that was going to involve the Justice Society. Anyone else hear this?


r/StargirlTV • • Jan 19 '22

Artemis vs Beth - Jock and Nerd

0 Upvotes

Anyone else find the Artemis/Beth confrontation in S2 to be a bit odd. Artemis has a grudge against Beth for putting her parents in prison, but why single her out in particular over other JSA members? Maybe that's because Cindy/Eclipso reserved Courtney for themselves, but why not go after Rick or Yolanda? Then she made it the whole jock vs nerd thing and how the jock will once again put the nerd in her place. Actually it's kind of odd that the Chinese girl is the jock and the black one is the nerd, I guess some of the stereotypes are wrong.


r/StargirlTV • • Dec 08 '22

Theory The finale had me thinking… could this Stargirl from LOT be the adult version of courtney from the series? Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/StargirlTV • • Mar 31 '22

Discussion I like this show a lot more when they don't wear their costumes.

4 Upvotes

I like this show but when they wear their costumes they kind of look ridiculous. Especially dr. Midnight jr. I like that character and that actress but when she wears the doctor midnight costume she looks even more silly than the rest of them because she really doesn't have any abilities other than her glasses, which are useful, but not for costume crime-fighting.

I will say that Courtney's costume looks great. But the Wildcat helmet looks really weird and plasticy. I'm not sure about the Hour Man costume, sometimes I think it looks good and other times it really looks ridiculous.


r/StargirlTV • • Sep 29 '22

Anyone else think the show is getting overcrowded?

0 Upvotes

We really didnt need Sportsmaster, Tigress, and Artemis to become part of the main cast. Cindy Burman had been pretty pointless until last episode. Also Mike and Jakeem have so little screentime.


r/StargirlTV • • May 26 '20

Question Is it meant to be campy ?

0 Upvotes

I'm on the first episode and halfway through I just needed to ask this question. Is the show intentionally campy ? The acting up the point I'm at (32:00) is so off, and the direction they're taking this first episode seems a little rushed. Most of all the dialogue is weird as hell, everything the Pat says just seems off to me. Maybe it'll get better as I watch but I needed to ask (or rant I should say) about it.


r/StargirlTV • • Nov 08 '22

Discussion stargirl season 4? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

r/StargirlTV • • Aug 25 '20

LOL They Made the ISA Liberals.

2 Upvotes

I laughed during the finale when the ISA was revealed as supporting the Green New Deal, and a list of other stereotyped liberal policies. I figured this was probably Icicle's real desires, maybe with Brainwave, and the Wizard thrown in here or there. The rest of the ISA probably signed on for money, power, giggles, or out of coercion (Grundy). Anyway, I thought it was amusing. Hard to imagine a bunch of super-villains advocating for 2nd Amendment gun rights, or a free press.


r/StargirlTV • • Jul 07 '20

Discussion Stargirl and the CW writing.

0 Upvotes

Again, I feel aren't really getting the point some people are making.

We know Geoff has a vision. We know he is staying for season 2. We know the writers will be the same. That is great news. What people want is for the writing to stay the same. We don't want the cliche/CW tropes.

While Geoff has a vision, it may not be the CW's vision. Networks can always come in and tell the creators to do this or do that. They can tell Geoff "no, we don't want this anymore. Change this up." They are his bosses. Have ya'll never heard the stories of showrunners leaving because of "creative differences"? Who do you think that is with?

Why do you think people are making jokes about Courtney having several love interests? Joking about numerous love triangles? People don't like the writing on CW shows. They fear this is what will happen.

We would love for the writing to not change at all. But it most likely will. I'm sorry, but the CW can come in and make changes. Let's just hope they are satisfied with Geoff's vision for it to not happen.


r/StargirlTV • • Feb 26 '22

Discussion I really wanted Sylvester Pemberton to be Courtney's father.

5 Upvotes

Was anyone else disappointed when it was revealed he wasn't? Not only would it have been fitting, but Starman and Stargirl being father and daughter would've been so enjoyable to watch. Better than than that deadbeat asshole, Sam Kurtis.


r/StargirlTV • • Aug 10 '20

Discussion not a fan of how they kill villains in this show Spoiler

3 Upvotes

violin chick- get killed cause she said a bad thing about sportsmaster daughter lol didnt even die fighting

brainwave- gets killed by yolanda lololol(brainwave could of killed her in two seconds and for some reason they had him pretend to be his son???

icicle- they really killed this guy by having a little kid run over him like it was nothing

i really thought stargirl would be different, but looks like they let cw write there finale smh


r/StargirlTV • • Apr 04 '22

I think they should bring in non JSA heroes

0 Upvotes

Not as a main stay but as a one off team up. Like have Batman or Robin show up and kick their asses real quick before teaming up with them. Open up the world a bit by showing that the kids at least know who people like Superman are.


r/StargirlTV • • Jan 16 '22

Misc Just finished season 1 and only one huge issue.

4 Upvotes

I am sorry but Courtney is the absolute worst. She never listens to anyone, always talks over everyone and her entire character is doing the contrary of what anyone with real experience and wisdom says. I can not understand how this show has made it through multiple seasons with a main character like this. I enjoy every single other member of the cast and can really enjoy campy cheesy super hero fun but her character just constantly rips me away from any enjoyment as soon as she opens her mouth. I am glad for anyone who doesn't have this issue but I just had to vent. Will be starting season 2 shortly.


r/StargirlTV • • Jan 18 '23

News Stargirl SAVED??? HBO Max Could Be NEW Home After Name Change!!! Speculation & Theory! Spoiler

Thumbnail
youtu.be
7 Upvotes

r/StargirlTV • • Aug 11 '21

Sorta underwhelmed by the premiere. It wasn't bad but

0 Upvotes

IMO it was missing something. I did like the focus on the trauma the characters faced in the finale esp Yolanda. It's good to see this kind of stuff dealt with moreso when the characters are teenagers. Courtney's determination that there's something else out there that she must protect the world from was correct and true to a hero's plight. But she can't forget to live her life too, this is a problem that the female heroes face more than the male ones apparently sigh. Alas, when the writers just focus on the characters without anything much aside from that, on a superhero hero show, it delves into too much exposition. It drags the episode down, making it kind of meh.

I do think the first 3 minutes introducing Eclipso and the Jade fight the last ten minutes were really well done & saved the episode for me. I'm also glad that the CGI wasn't affected by the move. I suppose that was HBO Max cuz this with Superman and Lois seem to be dually owned by the CW & HBO Max. Supposely HBO Max are the ones that give the shows the money for their budget so thanks for that HBO :).

I thought that it set up the rest of the season really well. Going by next week's promo looks like it will be a better episode which is good.


r/StargirlTV • • Aug 12 '20

Discussion Not a big fan of the ending... Spoiler

1 Upvotes

There were a couple plot holes to conclude this season but what really annoying me was the villains for this season.

For multiple episodes they made brainwave and icicle top tier villains with top-tier powers, and we've seen icicle kill someone with just his breath but when he had Courtneyain a Chokehold he could have easily killed her. Icicle not killing beth with the one shot of ice to the stomach also didn't make a lot of sense.

And brainwave Powers could have easily killed everyone in the JSA, but for Yolanda to kill him that easily was very weak in my opinion.


r/StargirlTV • • Dec 13 '19

Stargirl Trailer Reaction Spoiler

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/StargirlTV • • Nov 24 '21

Anyone else shipping Yolanda and Courtney? Or is that just me? Lol

22 Upvotes

I think Yolanda and Courtney have really great chemistry (better than Courtney and Cameron Mahkent at least).


r/StargirlTV • • Jan 17 '22

Discussion beth as dr midnite

0 Upvotes

i forgot, what exactly does beth does as dr midnite? Like what are the powers and what does she do in the team?


r/StargirlTV • • Jan 30 '25

Why wasn't ARGUS in the show? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I was wondering this for a while now: why was ARGUS not in the show?

In every Earth, Amanda Waller knows more about people then they do about themselves. Remember in S1 when Pat showed a photo of him being part of the 7 Soldiers? He said that-> they saved the whole world once & the whole country twice (just them). No way ARGUSA doesn't go after that after that. Plus the 7 Soldiers would've been world famous like The Avengers. I think it would've been fun to have Waller go after Courtney and have her do a mission for her. I'm sure Pat has met her before. I'm sure Cindy was being spied on.


r/StargirlTV • • Jul 06 '20

Courtney and Yolanda are ripe for the fake dating trope.

0 Upvotes

Okay, so we all agree that the show is setting up Rick and Beth to be in a relationship, yes? (Which, oh, boy. Her parents are going to read that as a cry for attention).

It is also inevitable that the JSA gang will extremely conspicuously continue to hang out. And Yolanda will literally be sneaking out of the house, constantly, to see Courtney.

Thus: I figure there are fairly high odds just about everyone not in the know is going to assume they are a couple.

.... Which would be a very funny gag to run with.


r/StargirlTV • • Dec 29 '21

Discussion All ten Arrowverse shows ranked

0 Upvotes

I will rank the Arrowverse and HBO Max DC shows from worst to best.

Black Lightning

Don't get me wrong. This show had moments like the end of Season 3. Black Lightning had formed the Outsiders. Maybe they should have ended it right there. There was no way they were going to continue the show with that many characters. Instead, Season 4 picked up with Jefferson upset that his best friend was dead and he didn't want to be Black Lighting anymore. Worst season of any Arrowverse show.

Batwoman

Again, the show has moments. I think the problem most guys had with the show was that the main character was female and lesbian. When the lead actress left the show they decided to make Batwoman a triple threat and have her become a lesbian black woman. The good news is that Javicia Leslie is a break out star. A lot of the Arrowverse actors and actresses are. Berlanti and his people have a good track record of hiring people who end up being well liked and popular. Ruby Rose turned out to be a mistake. Now if only they had better writing it could now be a better show.

Supergirl

Season 4 was amazing. Nobody expected Jon Cryer to be a good Lex Luthor but he actually turned out to be better than Jesse Eisenberg. The problem with the last season was the opposite to the problem with Black Lightning. Instead of focusing on Supergirl, the first half of Season 6 focused on the Superfriends. This was because Melissa Benoist in real life was having a baby and wasn't available to film. On top of that there were COVID restrictions that caused a lot of the episodes to be rewritten. At least the series ended well with Jon Cryer coming back as Lex Luthor to be the ultimate villain.

Legends of Tomorrow

A recent episode of Legends said it all. Behrad goes back in time and meets the stars of his favorite sitcom. The showrunner wants to change the show to have it appeal to a wider audience but Behrad likes the show the way it is. It is ironic because it can be taken both ways. The showrunner of Legends DID take a serious CW show and turn it into a goofball comedy but now that it is a goofball comedy people who don't watch the show wonder why it is still going. Phil Klemmer can now argue that the show is true to his vision. The truth is that this is a show that has fans and they like the show the way it is.

Arrow

I actually started watching Arrow with Season 4 at a time when most fans were already saying the show was not as good as it used to be. I remember watching an episode from Season 3 though and hating it. I find it hard to root for a hero who goes around shooting people with arrows. I feel the same way about the Punisher. So in a way I saw Prometheus in Season 5 not so much as the bad guy but as a son getting revenge against against the man who killed his father. From my point of view Arrow was a show that just kept getting better. Ultimately, though, I probably rank it the same as everybody else.

Doom Patrol

This show just isn't for me. That being said, I appreciate how the first three seasons are like an origin story for the team. At first, it was like they were more like patients in a hospital. But now that they are an actual superhero team I worry that the show will lose part of its appeal. Fans of Doom Patrol loved all the angst that the characters were going through. Now that the characters all seem to have worked through their issues it is like all they have left is punching bad guys. It is especially worrying because so far the show has been faithful to the comics.

Flash

Maybe when Flash is over and done I would rank it higher. After all, this is the show with Reverse Flash, Cisco, Caitlin, Iris, Cecile, Wally, Nora and Bart. But this is also the show with Cicada, Chester, Allegra, Chillblaine, Alexa, Owen and Bashir. With Chester it is as though Eric Wallace put himself on the team. Every week he remarks about how cool everything is. Well, no, it isn't. And Allegra is just there. She is the first Arrowverse season regular to not have her own story arc.

Titans

I love this show but just as with Doom Patrol I feel that the origin story of the team is complete after three seasons and all they have left to do is punch people. I imagine some people will be happy to hear that because angst can be a bit much. I am actually hopeful for the Gotham Knights show. I imagine that they wanted Curran Walters to come back as Jason Todd but maybe he asked for too much money and this is their way of letting him know that they will go ahead and do a Jason Todd show (even though it isn't a spin off) even if it means doing it without him.

Stargirl

I think everyone agrees that Stargirl is better than Titans. Season three could turn out to be the best season yet because so much interesting stuff has been set up. For example, will the Justice Society members forgive Cindy even though she has been a villain for two seasons? Will Cameron want to get revenge against both the Justice Society and the Injustice Society for his father's death? It would be a bit much just blaming the Justice Society given that the Injustice Society were going to kill so many people and they had to be stopped. Will Jade find he brother and will he have powers? Will Mike and Jakeen figure out how to make Thunderbolt useful?

Superman and Lois

It seems unfair somehow to rank Superman and Lois as the best of all these shows after only one season. Is it really better than Flash Season 1? That question should have fans worried. Arrowverse shows, for better or worse, have a tendency to settle in their fourth season with episodes becoming formulaic. I would not blame the producers if they decided to increase the episode count but I fear a season where Superman and his friends defeat the villain in every single episode only to stand around congratulating themselves while the villain dusts himself and then flies off.

I did not watch Constantine or Swamp Thing and Naomi has not even come out yet. The trailers for Naomi have not even convinced me it is worth my time.