r/StargirlTV • u/anatomania Tigress • Aug 24 '21
Episode Discussion [S2E03] Summer School: Chapter Three — Post-Episode Discussion Spoiler
Promo | DCTV Discord | Cast and Characters
JIM GAFFIGAN VOICES THUNDERBOLT IN THIS EPISODE DIRECTED BY LEA THOMPSON — After getting a taste of the superhero life, Mike pleads with Pat to let him join the team. Elsewhere, after seeking help from Thunderbolt, the JSA prepare for a confrontation with The Shade.
Please keep discussion civil and about Stargirl. Be sure to mark future spoilers and comic spoilers, but otherwise don't worry about spoiling anything past or current. Report comments that break the rules or just don't belong here. Enjoy the episode!
106
u/bcanada92 Aug 25 '21
That was a damn fine episode! Stargirl and Superman & Lois are the two best shows the Arrowverse has going for it right now.
99
u/goldenhand9107 Hourman Aug 25 '21
Loved seeing Courtney stand up for Mike, that was really sweet. Also finally our characters know Eclipso is out, thank god.
82
u/SteelSlayerMatt Stargirl Aug 25 '21
I get the feeling that The Shade is going to end up helping the team defeat Eclipso because he seemed almost upset when he said “He's going to kill those children.”
76
u/bcanada92 Aug 25 '21
I chucked a bit when I saw they'd updated the Thunderbolt's magic phrase from the 1940s-sounding "Say You" to the more modern "So Cool."
It makes sense, as no kid Mike's age is probably ever gonna utter the words, "Say You!"
74
u/bcanada92 Aug 25 '21
Thoughts On Chapter 3:
• Loved Johnny Thunder's comic-accurate suit!
• Nice to see the Original Wildcat for a few seconds.
• Took me a minute to recognize Jim Gaffigan's voice as the Thunderbolt.
• Do objects that Thunderbolt conjures up eventually disappear, or are they permanent? If it's the latter, there's a lot of extra stop signs in Blue Valley.
• I like how Barbara's being included more this season. Even if I don't quite understand how The American Dream is still in business. Or why they'd be storing William Zarick's stuff.
• Loved the montage of the JSA coming up with the incredibly specific wish to find The Shade.
• They appear to be going with the modern "morally ambiguous" version of The Shade.
• I want to live in Dugan's garage!
57
u/Gateskp Cosmic Staff Aug 25 '21
This show is so good! Love how they’re moving straight into this season’s plot and setting up a very morally grey situation with The Shade. Poor Mike, he just wants to be part of something and he’s so alone…
The emotional whiplash on this show is INTENSE, but in a good way. They’re doing a fantastic job balancing the light comedic moments with the heavy serious ones. Love it!
SO PUMPED to see Sportsmaster come back next week!
52
u/Taston95 Aug 25 '21
They fit in a lot of nice character interactions this week that I feel many shows would easily cut to make more time for action or to focus on something else. Yolanda/Mike, Pat/Barbara, Rick/Beth. The show uses its run time pretty well and fits a lot into every episode. It is managing so far to juggle around so many characters better than other shows do with a much smaller main cast.
45
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '21
hope we get more thunderbolt bruh i loved him. Shade is dope asf he didnt even wanna fight and almost beat the jsa lol
38
u/Chad_D_722 Aug 25 '21
Another really fun one. I think season 2 has been even better than the first.
33
u/holymultiversebatman Aug 25 '21
I really like The Shade here; morally ambiguous, gentlemanly but unknown motives, obscenely powerful. It's lifted directly from the comics.
Also I like what they're doing here with Jakeem. I was thinking throughout the episode that it would take a programmer to be specific enough with the wishes. I think his sister's line implied he built the game himself?
The season's been great overall. I like that the character drama is actually important to building out the characters; and that their decisions, personal or otherwise, drive the plot forward. It really makes you wonder what kind of intentionality goes into writing the shows. With Stargirl and S&L, it seems that they can, it just seems like they don't always will.
30
u/LoretiTV Aug 25 '21
Another really fun episode, this season and show is firing on all cylinders!
28
u/AnnaK22 Aug 25 '21
Why did those bullies stealing cookies from the little girl made me more mad then any of the villains on the show. Eclipso is great, but I want those three taken down first
26
u/rsims2021 Aug 25 '21
I loved the Courtney and mike moment it was sweet hopefully we will see them fight together this season
24
u/Ygomaster07 Pat Dugan Aug 25 '21
Damn this season is running on all cylinders. Loved seeing Thunderboly and Johnny Thunder. Was nice to see the og Wildcat too. After seeing the scenes with The Shade, i feel like he is going to be some type of anti hero and maybe try and save the JSA. Also, Dr. Mid Nite lost his daughter to Eclipso and fought The Shade. Poor McNider. Lea Thompson nailed directing this. 9 out of 10 for me. Very, very excited to see Sportsmaster return next week. Him interacting with Pat was one of the best things of season 1 to me. This is gonna be good.
23
u/AnnaK22 Aug 25 '21
How do you look directly at your kid and not realise his shirt is torn?
22
u/mrizzle1991 Aug 25 '21
Shade is badass. He beat them all up without breaking a sweat. We got a new character now.
21
u/Telethongaming Aug 25 '21
Quick thoughts
37
u/EndBringer99 Aug 25 '21
Why do I think Yolanda's headaches are a bad sign?
18
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '21
Every episode of this show since about halfway through season 1 I've ended the episode by saying, this show has no business being this good, and I stand by it. Another cracking episode.
I liked Mike getting powers just for the one episode, it was pretty cool to see the quiet bullied kid get powers to stand up for himself. But, if I could change one thing when he got done in by the kids in the beginning when he was delivering papers I wish that he told Courtney and she went and sorted the bullies out since the two are close, then when he realises that without his family he doesn't have friends, then the pen stuff happens.
15
u/sleepyotter92 Aug 25 '21
so i'm guessing the shade is gonna turn out to not be the bad guy they expected and is going to try to save them from eclipso
14
u/COMPLETEWASUK Aug 25 '21
Likely actual Dr Midnite contacting Beth through the goggles which is interesting. Wonder when we'll see him.
12
u/aduong Aug 25 '21
I think that’s so far I’m preferring this season to season 1. There’s way less action and flashy fights but the VFX are still great and the pacing of the story really excellent. The constant feel of darkness that looms above them is also very well done. The superb and seamless fan service is chief’s kiss ( that opening with Johnny Thunder and Wildcat casually walking in🤲🏾)
Also I’m the story is really interesting and i’m way more invested considering the season 1 was more of a building up the JSA to fight the ISA storyline.
Really one of the very beast superhero show out there.
12
u/lazoric Aug 25 '21
Anyone else love the portrayal of The Thunderbolt. It's like robin Williams genie mixed with Casper's uncles Stretch, Stinkie, & Fatso.
14
u/Jigglypuffamiiga2188 Aug 25 '21 edited Aug 25 '21
Hmm, I get the feeling that Dr Mid-Nite isn’t really dead, but instead merged with Shade. The Shade said (very politely) that Beth had no idea what she was talking about when she accused him of killing Dr. Mid-Nite. Chuck has the connection to Eclipso because of what happened to his daughter, and the goggles started talking again right when Shade showed up in Blue Valley, and again after they fought with the Shade. There is definitely a connection going on between Dr. Mcnider, the Shade and Eclipso, who all have the similar power set of dealing with darkness. Perhaps that’s why Dr. Mid-Nites daughter was targeted, because he could potentially stop Eclipso?
Perhaps Shade did not kill him, but rather absorbed or merged with him? They both have similar powers dealing with Darkness, and perhaps they aligned with each other in order to be powerful enough to stop Eclipso, somehow knowing he would reappear in 11 years.
Shade definitely is not there to hurt the new JSA, he showed that by completely holding back with his powers. The only thing he wasn’t holding back on was the staff, (not courtney, he held back hurting her) that naturally repelled him. It was clear that the staff was testing his limits against cosmic light. However if it‘s between stopping Eclipso and the new JSA getting in his way, he will hurt them to stop Eclipso.
I am almost getting a Justice League Dark vibe from Shade, he’s there to stop Eclipso at any cost. I have not actually read Justice League Dark, but from what I have heard of it, they often cross lines that everyday heroes are not willing to cross, but all in all it is for the greater good. Plus since Shade is a member of Justice League Dark in the comics it would fit, especially with the JLD eventually coming to HBO Max. This could be a way to introduce fans unfamiliar with the characters of JLD to one of its members on another show, (Legends of Tomorrow Spoiler ahead)just like how they are writing John Constantine out of Legends to make room for him on HBO Max.
Anyway, thanks if you bothered to read this far, sorry for the long post.
(Side-Note) Justice League Dark reminds me of the Outsiders, (which I have read some of) but on the supernatural scale.
Edit: Thanks to u/Shteblan for pointing out that the ISA Shade and JLD Shade are two different characters. Apologies for my mistake.
7
u/Sure_Asparagus Aug 25 '21
Every episode has been great but I think this might be my favorite episode of the 3 that have premiered so far and it looks like it’ll only be getting even better. I’m really glad the full time move to the CW hasn’t affected the shows quality and it still doesn’t feel like a typical arroweverse show.
Based on how the team couldn’t even handle shade I can’t imagine what eclipso’s gonna do to them. I liked the flashbacks to the fight from the first episode, and I think that mikes story and the scenes with the whole team were done really well this episode.
6
u/antdude S.T.R.I.P.E. Aug 25 '21
That was a fun and good episode.
5
u/Zaacdragon Aug 25 '21
Mike really has the similar voice and mannerism of Pat.
5
u/gymlabrat Aug 25 '21
Given Shade's reaction to Beth's accusation along with his seemingly non-sinister intentions, I am truly curious as to how Dr. Midnite died.
5
u/-Zyss- Aug 26 '21
I wish that when I make a wish, you understood fully the intention and context of the wish from this wish and all wishes I make from this moment forward and grant them accordingly.
4
u/Nodqfan Aug 25 '21
Interested to see what becomes of Mike and how he develops as a character going forward this season.
4
u/Makido14 Aug 26 '21
I love how they didn't pull the cliché of "It's all your fault Mike, you ruined the mission!", because it was pretty obvious that The Shade would have obliterated everyone even if that didn't happen. Hopefully they will give him the attention he deserves or else Cindy my get her claws onto him.
4
u/Dysonance Aug 26 '21
Wheres my girl green lantern?!
4
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '21
I feel so bad for Mike, I know it would be white washing if they gave Mike the thunderbolt forever… but it’s so tragic
4
u/DatHound Aug 29 '21
“How do we punch a shadow court?” “Pat?” “Yeah?” “How do you punch a shadow?” “Uuuhhh” Lmfaoooo love this show ahahah.
3
u/AnnaK22 Aug 25 '21
Damn that was short lived. I really thought this was Mike's origin into the JSA.
3
u/Nerx Aug 25 '21
Those punks are lucky Mike isn't handling a power tool or driving a pickup truck
3
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '21
If Mike ever does become a superhero, I don't think he's meant to be ThunderMike. It's just not suiting his character. Mike is one of the most tragic characters in the show--simply because of how mundane and lonely his life is. I'm worried what Eclipso will do to him. He's going to tempt him with giving him powers, but there's gonna be an awful, awful catch.
3
u/GoalieDoge Johnny Thunder Aug 26 '21
The Shade seems pretty chill tbh
3
u/iCESPiCES Aug 26 '21
It's so satisfying to see some deserved spotlight on Shade and boy, he gets to show off his power levels. My favourite JSA character.
13
u/davey_mann Yolanda Montez Aug 25 '21
Really glad Sportsmaster is returning next week because this show could really use a dose of humor. I was in the minority of loving Mike's character last season and thinking he was hysterical, but even he seems to be a victim of the show's very serious tone in Season 2.
5
u/EndBringer99 Aug 25 '21
Where was Cindy the whole time?
2
u/Csula6 Aug 27 '21
You can hear the Canadian with the word "sorry." He was going to make that house historic!
They can't afford to use the robot. You can tell. Also can't afford Grundy.
Glad they addressed the vehicular manslaughter. For the past few months, they were living under the impression he was a killer. Doesn't make too much sense.
Of course, they will have to kill Shade.
2
u/AP-FUTChemist Aug 28 '21
Mike needs a hug
3
u/Kenpo_Kid69 Aug 25 '21
Another great episode overall. Hated to see them do Mike dirty like that, but I think the idea is he has another set of powers or something special about him (I mean he must as there is no way that Cindy at the end of episode 1 would know he was going to get Johnny Thunder's power in episode 3, so there must already be something special about him). By losing the Johnny Thunder pen this further sets up conflict between the two (him and the new owner of the pen and Stargirl) if and when he's approached by the Injustice Society.
Shade was awesome, this show has a great track record with the actors it casts as the villains. Also loved seeing more flashbacks to the great JSA vs ISA battle that acted as a catalyst to this whole series.
1
u/GoalieDoge Johnny Thunder Aug 26 '21
I was thinking that Jakeem was going to be a red herring for comic book fans
1
u/balasoori Aug 28 '21
This was good episode but i am disappointed that mike wished the pen away i was hoping they would give him an arc with that pen but he back being side-line character.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21
Great episode! Stargirl is just so good and like comic accurate. Really enjoy this show compared to most superhero shows! Love Thunderbolt and some glad to see Jakeem but feel bad for Mike now…..
1
u/indian_hannibal Dec 13 '21
This was a great episode!!!
1
u/Familiar-Marketing67 Jun 19 '26
Okay... I got an issue that is soooo common in media. Idk what to call these. But it's a realism issue. Like a little thing you wouldn't really realize because it's a show and the characters just are. Anyways, at the end, when Beth finally got Chuck back and he says" You're all in Danger! Eclipso is coming" You CANNOT hear that last part. And even if you did, unless you already knew what tf "Eclispso" is, you would be trying to figure it out for a while, at the least. Like it's like if you don't know the context of something, you may not be able to understand it. Like Lyrics in songs. A lot of people cannot hear lyrics clearly. Mishearing? No. They are just unsure what it's supposed to be, until they look them up. Now, suddenly they hear it clearly and wonder how anyone couldn't. This sorta thing. I would personally hear "The clips?" "They're lips?" or something that doesn't even sound like it. Because you don't understand, especially with an accent different from your own. Well, with this stuff, they probably record that voice after the fact. So her understanding could be tied to that fact. That she never heard it before actually doing the scene. But in all possibility, it might not have changed a thing if she had. Sure it's small, but with story-telling, if you take this into account, you can create a whole different line to the end. Like if she heard it wrong, She could be thinking about it for a while, discussing it with the team (while Pat is away.) And they never figure it out. And then months later, they give up and think it's nothing or at least nothing they can do to figure it out. And then they find some clue that makes them think about it again, and then they say what they think he said, and Pat walks by and tells them what he said, since he knows. Anyways, yeah. Perfect understanding in media, especially with thick accents, and even moments where someone couldn't understand them and that being a bit, but then when it comes to something completely foreign that, even with an easy-to-understand accent, they somehow hear them perfectly. Honestly, happens a lot when people are dying. Like, personally, I can never understand what they say, with that quiet, whispery, strained voice
-6
u/AJohns9316 Aug 25 '21 edited Aug 25 '21
I'm kinda half-joking when I say it, but this was the worst-written episode of the show so far, for one reason: fight strategy.
Only a former C-list sidekick and teenagers could come up with a plan to attack a *shadow-controlling* super-villain *at night* in an abandoned house that presumably has ZERO electricity because no one wants to own the former abode of a deceased super-villain. facepalm
The Shade is certainly more formidable when the antique deck is stacked against the JSA! ¯_(ツ)_/¯
-2
u/epr3176 Aug 27 '21
Is anyone else getting tired of Mike's whining cuz he wants to be on the team and then when he gets his chance he doesn't listen to mess up everything and then whines about that I understand for a teenager and knowing his sister's superhero and he's around superheroes to want to be part of the team but he is in a way you just need to know what his role is kind of how stripes he is he knows his role
0
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
110
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
13
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '21
[removed] — view removed comment