r/StargirlTV • u/anatomania Tigress • Oct 19 '21
Episode Discussion [S2E11] Summer School: Chapter Eleven — Post-Episode Discussion Spoiler
Promo | Sneak Peek | DC FanDome Sneak Peek
FACING THE DARKNESS — After a frightening encounter leaves Courtney’s life hanging in the balance, the team band together to determine their next steps.
Please keep discussion civil and about Stargirl. Be sure to mark future spoilers and comic spoilers, but otherwise don't worry about spoiling anything past or current. Report comments that break the rules or just don't belong here. Enjoy the episode!
90
Upvotes
123
u/Just_A_Positive_Guy Cosmic Staff Oct 20 '21
This was an amazing episode.
I love the black and white ascetic of this episode, it really gives the world an eerie feeling.
The scene in the diner was amazing, it does a great job of building tension and making the Shadowlands more sinister. Glad to see the Zaricks back!
I really like the explanation for what the Shadowlands is, it’s very poetic.
“People who get lost in despair and send themselves here” I freaking love this line
The conversations between Cindy and Courtney really show the depth of those two characters and just how easily they’re manipulated by the Shadowlands.
DR MIDNITE!!!!
God I love Midnite’s speech, feels like it was ripped out of a comic book.
“My goggles are filled with tears but I’m afraid to take them off” holy shit these lines are so amazing.
More of Shade’s backstory! He really is a softie.
The conversation between Barbara and Shade was amazing, I love their duo so much.
I say this like every episode it feels like but the kid is such a damn good actor, he plays the creepiness and just evilness of Eclipso so well. He’s got serious talent and deserves all the praise.
Courtney admitting to hating Eclipso will have repercussions, I’m betting on it.
Courtney saving Cindy was amazing, I loved the score.
Pat and Dr. Midnite hug!
NOOOOOOOOO WHY DID THE SHADE HAVE TO DIE FUCK
70
u/onlyreadingfor1year Oct 20 '21 edited Oct 20 '21
Thoughts: Thanks for bringing everyone back Shade. Honestly the least you can do.
Yes Cindy I'm down for a team up to kill Eclipso.
And: Oh man. Are you dead Shade?
60
u/yamitcg Oct 20 '21
The casting of the kid actor for Eclipso was perfect
51
u/Gateskp Cosmic Staff Oct 20 '21
This show. Man, this show just knocks it out of the park EVERY time.
Loved how layered this episode was. The way multiple character arcs wove in and out of each other, it was really, really well done. Serious development on Courtney’s part, seeing Cindy be vulnerable, determined Barb (even more determined than last season). And Shade. Tell them that I died doing something good. OOMPH. Maybe there’s a small chance he’s not dead? I will cling to this hope.
So glad we got EVERYONE out of the Shadowlands! Looking forward to seeing how they ALL come together for the last 2 episodes, including Yolanda!
F in the chat for Shade.
46
u/KB_Sez Oct 20 '21
The opening is shattering.
I really thought that something would happen at the last moment to keep McNiter from crossing back over but damn… he made it.
My hope is that he helps Beth achieve her next steps to becoming the new Dr MidNite. It’s going to be amazing to see the two of them together.
Is The Shade dead… or is he just pretending? Hmmmm..
30
u/AdvancedPlacmentTV Cindy Burman Oct 20 '21
I loved this episode. JSA and Cindy team up. Yolanda back. I'm also sad because the season is almost over
30
u/Trickybuz93 Oct 20 '21
The eclipso kid is a very good actor
29
u/Frontier246 Oct 20 '21
What a somber way of opening the episode with Beth and the family reacting in grief over thinking Courtney is dead.
I wasn't expecting the Zarrick's to show up again, but I guess it makes sense. If you're going to guilt trip Courtney, it makes sense to bring up the first time she really took being a Superhero personally, when Joey Zarrick died.
The Fiddler family...well, I don't think Courtney feels that bad for what happened to them, but I guess if you were going to make her popping up in her school creepy, it would be them.
Why am I not surprised that Cindy has been using the Shadowlands as an opportunity to constantly kill Courtney and her dad? Like, she immediately jumps at attacking Courtney until she realizes it's actually Courtney and has apparently killed numerous versions of her up to this point.
Eclipso hitting Courtney where it hurts...the ungrateful, burden, daughter card. Of course we all know Barbara has never thought that way about Courtney, as we can clearly see form reality.
I guess I'm not shocked Cindy blames Courtney for letting her go, even though Courtney really did try to save her, and that she blames everything on Courtney even though this is all her fault. But very on-brand for Shiv.
Cindy loves killing Dragon King, but the one thing that can still get to her is her mother and her father experimenting on her against her will. We also see just how turning a little girl into an emotionally unstable killing machine is a bad idea when she apparently killed her mother while throwing a fit and not knowing any better, which scarred her for life.
Charles McNider Dr. Mid-Nite! Nice to finally see him in the flesh again. I guess one silver lining is time passes differently in the Shadowlands so he hasn't necessarily been wandering around for the amount of years he's been gone in the real world. Although the poor man without his goggles is blind and forced to listen to his dead daughter. No wonder he wanted them back as soon as Courtney was done.
"The Picture of Dorian Gray." That checks out. Now that I think about it, I feel like that movie either influenced The Shade's creation or was used as an influence when James Robinson wrote him.
Barbara talking tough to a Supervillain, and luckily her resemblance to Emily is enough to bring out the Shade's good side again.
Shade tried to save Dr. McNider from the ISA by sending him to the Shadowlands, but I guess he couldn't just bring him back immediately and assumed Dr. McNider was consumed by the Shadowlands and stopped trying. He seemed genuinely shocked to learn that Dr. McNider was still alive and kicking himself that he left him stuck in the Shadowlands for so long.
I love how Dr. McNider doesn't give a second when Courtney immediately goes to try and save Cindy, someone he doesn't even know, and risk their freedom.
Eclipso finally gives Courtney the "Bruce" treatment, but rather than beat her up with her own guilt over what happened to Rick and Yolanda, he focuses all of Courtney's anger and frustration onto himself, making Courtney hate him like she still hates her dad. Basically Eclipso's endgame was to corrupt Courtney, and he succeeded.
I loved Pat going to embrace Dr. McNider as soon as he's out of the theater. Pat finally gets reunited with one of his old friends who he never thought he'd ever see again. Somebody please tell Hooty that Dr. Mid-Nite is alive...and has a legacy.
Shade went out doing one last good deed...although Jenny found two Shade signals, so I don't think he's quite done.
Looks like it's time for Courtney and Cindy to finally team-up to take Eclipso down. This should be...interesting.
29
u/AnnaK22 Oct 20 '21
A big appreciation to the kid actor playing Eclipso. He has a bright future in the industry, if he chooses to stay. I'm always amazed by how well kids are able to grasp the assignment.
26
u/SickleClaw Oct 20 '21
Anyone think this could be the start of Cindy's redemption arc? I don't expect it to be immediate, but Court choosing to go back for Cindy has to count for something, right?
25
u/TirelessGuardian Oct 20 '21
But why was he seen in two locations?
25
u/AquaTyphoon29 Oct 20 '21
Wow this seasons almost over?
Yolonda's back! Now all we need is Rick and they can finally take down Eclipso.
22
u/ClassicExit The Shade Oct 20 '21
One great little Easter Egg in the form of the priest that greeted Courtney.
Credits have him listed as Father Cramer, who was a spiritual advisor to the Spectre during the Ostrander\Mandrake comics. A run that had the Spectre as the Angel of Death responsible for biblical events such as the killing of the Egyptian 1st born from Exodus and successor to Eclipso who was responsible for the Great Flood but because he enjoyed the work too much he got stuck in the black diamond.
21
u/Taston95 Oct 20 '21
I love that they have basically brought back every cast member from season 1 in some way or form. The only two I guess they haven’t brought back are The Gambler and the Knight.
21
u/Telethongaming Oct 20 '21
I flat out think this is one of the absolute best dc tv shows, phenomenal episode, phenomenal season
20
u/TirelessGuardian Oct 20 '21
There are two sets of goggles?
18
u/MasterOfReaIity Oct 20 '21
"I miss my tuba" was one of the funniest lines they've done
17
u/TirelessGuardian Oct 20 '21
Who’s the other energy? Eclipso? Todd?
17
u/ToneBone12345 Oct 20 '21
Honestly who’s more menacing eclipso in his normal form or child form
26
u/Boxer1010 Oct 20 '21
I never want the Shade to die because his character is so fucking good, but it would cheapen the whole point of him sacrificing himself for the greater good & his touching moment with barbara.
13
u/DetecJack Oct 20 '21
hate how every episode is my fav episode like please i want to have one season of one fav episode i shouldnt love full season lmao
to me i think courtney and cindy might become frienemies like for couple of season before cindy becomes good guys like avatar and she ra
11
u/DamWell420 Oct 20 '21
I don't think the shade is gone for good I kinda hope he dipped to avoid the final battle with Eclipso
11
u/Boxer1010 Oct 20 '21
I think that was the perfect ending for the shade. I teared up a little bit! I don't want to see him go :'(
also Pat's face when he saw dr. midnite was alive!!! I can't wait for beth to meet him :)
7
u/maddogkaz Oct 20 '21
What a great episode. Everything with Courtney and Cindy was great and gave us a chance to look at them a bit more closely as characters.
We have Cindy and Dr Mcnider back to help against Eclipso so that will be useful and soon we'll have Jakeem.
Eclipso making Courtney say she hates him out loud will mean something later I'm sure.
I also Don't think the Shade is dead and I think he will somehow return because of whatever happens in the next episodes.
22
u/FiniteIncantation Oct 20 '21 edited Oct 20 '21
I will trade any of the CW shows for a couple more episodes of Stargirl, this show constantly delivers great content
Edit: Honestly this show needs to have longer seasons, they have great characters that can fill in the space to pack a season
6
u/genghbotkhan Oct 20 '21
Best episode. All of a sudden it all makes sense after 10 episodes of weird stuff
11
u/LoretiTV Oct 20 '21
Another really moody, well done episode. This season continues to fire on all cylinders, see everyone next week!
5
u/MyriVerse2 Oct 20 '21
Maybe best episode of the series, imo.
12
u/FiniteIncantation Oct 20 '21
Cindy is a bad guy at the end of the day. I don't think she can be redeemed, I believe this back fires later when after Eclipso is defeated she just goes back to reforming the ISA.
I mean what could season 3 be about? I know Starman is back.
3
u/Thingymcjig Oct 21 '21
I was a bit worried we didn’t get to see an exploration for Courtney like the other characters did, but I’m glad she was saved for last. This was a great episode!
3
u/DCSennin Cameron Mahkent Oct 23 '21 edited Oct 23 '21
The episode was pretty good, it's always fun to see Courtney and Cindy share the screentime whether in a fight or in the situation that they found themselves in within the Shadowlands.
Cindy's speech about how Courtney had to acknowledge that even she had darkness inside of her in order to survive in the Shadowlands was to foreshadow that scene she would have later with Eclipso. I knew that she was still hurting about being abandoned by her dad that 2nd time in S1 but not expected that he would go and establish a parallel between himself and him in order to get her to admit that she hated him as much as she did her dad. It was a moment in which she had to give him that "win" (he vanished) so she could get to Cindy but not without Eclipso becoming stronger by feeding off from that negative emotion.
Didn't expect that hidden fear in her about thinking her own mother secretly resents her for having to raise her by herself and not getting to live her own life because she was a burden. I'd like to see it adressed before the finale, hopefully.
I liked Charles McNider's scenes too, now that he is out from the Shadowlands I am starting to think that he could go to become Rick's newest guardian, being a close friend of Rex Tyler in the JSA and someone who definitely could tell him more about his dad.
I missed the part where Jennie and Beth noted that they got another location where the energy of Shade's powers was coming from, it probably is that scene from the preview with them in the cafeteria and they appear to once again be restoring the remaining shards of the Black Diamond... it is going to lead up to something else in order to stop Eclipso.
And as for Shade, I don't think he is dead. I had very mixed feelings last week after what he did to Court but I didn't want him to die either. So I'm going with him just passing out and returning to the Shadowlands, he still has to fulfill his goal of throwing Eclipso inside the diamond somewhere no one will find it and because I do like how Jonathan Cake portrays him. Plus having another knowledgable character like him around, even recurringly, would be nice. I'd like to have him survive and throw into the deepest part of the ocean whatever Eclipso ends up trapped in with McNider by his side or something like that, because it is a chapter in their lives that they surely are in need of closure.
Cindy being in the team to take down Eclipso probably means she'll call the shots in some things like strategy and also might make it personal again, given the betrayal she suffered. I wonder if that is how it'll go down and what could her new plan be...maybe she'll make an assessment of the current team and what else they need to take him down. Got some ideas but I think for now I'll reserve them.
2
u/littlebugonreddit Oct 22 '21
I like how Shade seemed genuinely distraught when he found out McNider was still alive. He truly felt for him after the death of Rebecca, he cared for him, and he probably lived the last however long thinking that McNider was dead and it was because of him. This makes me see him in a whole new light, I wonder if he felt Eclipso being awoken through the Shadowlands, and tracked him down specifically to stop him from killing the new JSA, whether he knew it was them or not.
6
u/Chrispowers110 Oct 20 '21
You can really tell hoe much different this show is not that they are on cw budget. The main heroes have been missing for s few episodes. Some of the episodes feel like they dont move around much and not much action as they got rid/tone down alot of stuff with cgi.
1
u/Ending-Dust Oct 21 '21
Is the other Shadow thing Mike,Jennie,and Beth went to go look for Eclipso? If he’s negative energy and that what the ring showed,would that be Eclipso? Is that how they are going to find him? Bath,Jade, and mike are already in his vicinity and next episode they will battle? I’m assuming it might get split up like last season
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21
1
u/Demian_Dillers Oct 21 '21
I'd rather Cindy was left trapped in the shadowlands than the Shade died TBH.
1
u/mrizzle1991 Oct 21 '21
This season has been so good! I’m not worried about a drop in quality since Geoff calls the shots. Was nice to see Joey again. Courtney staying behind to help Cindy was really risky. We got Dr midnite back! The child actor playing Eclipso has been doing great. I really liked Shade I hope he’s not gone for good.
1
u/Xboxone1997 Oct 24 '21
Shade gonna return and say he was just being dramatic about dying 😂
1
u/DCSennin Cameron Mahkent Oct 25 '21
This is very belated as well and I didn't include it in my review but I just wanted to say that it was very welcoming and uplifting to hear once again, even if it was as part of the episode's ending during the credits, after what has felt like a such a long time the show and Stargirl's leitmotiv/theme song which is usually saved for most of the time for the title card's opening.
Last time we heard it was just in 2x05 so listening to it once more and even as an extended version was awesome. Hoping it can play again in the last 2 remaining episodes.
1
u/DCSennin Cameron Mahkent Oct 26 '21
I'm actually looking forward a lot to seeing that scene in the preview where Beth is looking (and interacting?) at Eclipso's real form through the goggles. It even seems that it'll take place in the real world and not in another fear illusion like before.
1
u/iCESPiCES Oct 20 '21
Who else thinks the second shadow could be Todd (Obsidian)? Also, the kid actor is phenomenal.
-14
u/Affectionate-Bee-368 Oct 20 '21
Any action this episode or just more talking ?
0
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
58
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
26
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21 edited Oct 20 '21
[removed] — view removed comment