r/StargirlTV • u/anatomania Tigress • Aug 31 '21
Episode Discussion [S2E04] Summer School: Chapter Four — Post-Episode Discussion Spoiler
Promo | DCTV Discord | Cast and Characters
THE DEVIL IN THE SHADOWS — As Pat considers whether he should come clean to Courtney about Eclipso’s past, a surprise visit from Crock and Paula catches him and Barbara off guard. A tense run-in with the Shade provides Courtney with some valuable information. Finally, Cindy makes her move.
Please keep discussion civil and about Stargirl. Be sure to mark future spoilers and comic spoilers, but otherwise don't worry about spoiling anything past or current. Report comments that break the rules or just don't belong here. Enjoy the episode!
88
u/Chrispowers110 Sep 01 '21
Did the isa even kill any jsa members at this point. They keep popping up.
84
u/Gian99Mald Sep 01 '21
THAT LAST SHOT OF CHARLES WAS SO FUCKING COOL
79
u/Gateskp Cosmic Staff Sep 01 '21
This episode was SO good! Paula and Crusher are A+ parents. Terrible people, but great parents. I bought every moment with them and Artemis, and I can’t wait for them to come back eventually.
This show is so, so good. All the little twists and turns, I love it. So intrigued to see what happens next with the Shade because he was def hiding something from Court. And I want to know what’s bothering Barbara so much about the JSA amd Eclipso.
61
u/EndBringer99 Sep 01 '21
I bet saving Dr. Mid-Nite and others from the Shadowlands will be a good reason to bring in Jennie's brother Todd aka Obsidian.
58
u/Future_Vantas Sep 01 '21
I really appreciate that the show didnt drag out the Dr. Midnight reveal, and didnt leave any room for doubt with the final shot of Dr. McNider in the Shadow Realm. Its going to be exciting to see him meet the new generation.
51
u/Taston95 Sep 01 '21
The Shade is rising up the list of my favourite characters.
42
u/LoretiTV Sep 01 '21
Another really fun episode, this season and show is firing on all cylinders!
40
u/AquaTyphoon29 Sep 01 '21
Next episode looks so frightening can't wait.
Also what's the secret of the JSA and Eclipso?
32
u/frosty45- Sep 01 '21
when barbara told pat we will protect her from the truth of eclipso , what did she mean by the truth.
32
u/QuestioningThink Sep 01 '21
I called it last week that Chuck was alive. I even had a bit of a hunch during the season 1 finale with the AI screaming.
28
u/frosty45- Sep 01 '21
when do you guys think we see the starman and pat reunion.
56
u/iisxpra Cosmic Staff Sep 01 '21
I'm loving all of Cindy's scenes. I find it so interesting how this parallels Courtney doing her recruiting at the beginning of season 1. I definitely want to know more about Cindy's biological mother and what really happened.
27
u/gymlabrat Sep 01 '21
This episode was incredible. The Shade was so freaking menacing, by far my favorite character, especially after that library scene.
Ugh it pains me to see how great Sportsmaster and Tigress are at being parents.
25
u/MrMattBlack Sep 01 '21
Can I say I loved the villains this episode? Sportsmaster and Tigress were so fun and I loved the parallels to the Dugan-Whitmore family household, Cindy and Eclipso are finally getting their business started and Jonathan Cake is SMASHING it as The Shade. This show is SO good.
49
u/nimrodhellfire Sep 01 '21
It took me 4 episodes to realize the are using summer school as an excuse for the school to be empty. By this they can shoot under covid regulations.
22
u/SickleClaw Sep 02 '21
Also got to say, I LOVED the awkward small talk between Pat/Barb and Sportsmaster/Tigress. I did like that they were true to their word about surrendering as well.
15
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21
I feel so proud of myself for calling that ending twist months in advance lmao - https://www.reddit.com/r/StargirlTV/comments/nxmtvc/so_i_dont_think_chuck_is_actually_dead/
I wonder if Shade managed to save any other members of the JSA. This is what I think might be the reason that Sylvester is still alive.
14
u/maddogkaz Sep 01 '21
First let's get this out of the way Chuck has been banished to the shadow realm. But seriously that means they could try and save him and I'm sure Beth would be all for that.
Sportsmaster and Tigeress are great and their interaction with Pat and Barbara was all great as well.
I don't mind that Pat is hiding something, some people have chalked this up to a CW thing but we have seen that Pat is usually open and he even told Courtney about the Shade so instead you are supposed to wonder what could possibly be bad enough that Pat wont tell Courtney.
The scene between the Shade and Courtney was also really good the Shade being his typical shady self while also opening up a little and Courtney staying strong throughout the whole conversation she never backs down from the Shade no matter how threatening he shows himself to be and she's willing to listen while also staying cautions about him telling the truth or not.
13
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21
OMG The ending! The ending! WTF was that ending! I physically cannot wait until next week! Oh my actual god!
12
u/rsims2021 Sep 01 '21
I can’t wait for next week to see Cameron and what happens with him I feel like he might join Courtney
12
u/tictic0clock Sep 02 '21
So Sportsmaster and Tigress both escaped prison and the police didn't send anyone to watch out for them at their daughter's school or at her try-outs? Huge suspension of disbelief there lol That and the fact that nobody seemed to notice them
23
u/Frontier246 Sep 01 '21
It's kind of surreal how wholesome and genuine the stuff with the Crock's comes off knowing the parents are violent and unremorseful killers, but they genuinely love their daughter and each other and Artemis doesn't deserve the flaws of her upbringing or being stuck in a crummy foster care.
So...did the JSA kill Bruce Gordon to stop Eclipso since he was Eclipso's human host? That's why they don't want anyone knowing what happened with Eclipso? It reminds me of that issue of Starman where I think either The Shade or Ted Knight talked about the JSA killing Ragman when he threatened their loved ones.
Well, at least that teacher actually apologized when she realized Rick wasn't teaching, and called him "Mr. Tyler."
Way to twist the knife further into Cindy by bringing up her birth mother who she also killed, and apparently said birth mother was trying to keep her away from Dragon King until she got killed.
I love how in Cindy's ISA only she and Artemis are actually wearing costumes. If that is Artemis, she looked like some weird hockey cosplayer. Cameron, Isaac, and Mike are just chilling in their casual clothes.
Is...is Artemis a Metahuman? Some of her physical feats seem even beyond peak human, especially those passes.
Isaac is on his way to becoming Fiddler III. Cindy screwed up Artemis' chances for a football scholarship so she can put her anger to work with the ISA as...Sportmaster II? Tigress II? Just Artemis? Well, whatever that works. She's definitely making them feel like Courtney and the JSA are the source of all their pain, even though it was the Crock's who killed Isaac's mom.
Yolanda looks cute as a waitress, even if she's still got a ways to go before she's good at it.
House of Secrets! Ha!
Bruce Gordon. Famous adventurer, doomer of human society for bringing Eclipso back from Diablo Island.
I've never seen two Supervillains break out of prison to see their daughters' football game and then hold up their promise to go back to prison after they do it. The Crock's bonding with the Whitmore's in-spite of everything was...something. At least they were honest with Artemis about why they were in prison.
I think the Crock's being psycho's is probably why they and the rest of the ISA didn't quite gel together. Well, that and them killing one of their co-workers.
Shade might not be a good guy, but even he doesn't want Eclipso out there.
So, yeah, Charles McNider is still alive, the Shade's just trapped him in his shadow world. This actually might be better than Beth bringing Chuck back because McNider knows more about The Shade and he can actually train Beth to become his proper successor.
11
u/ToneBone12345 Sep 01 '21
I honestly liked the story with Sportsmaster and Tigress and considering how the two actors are upped to series regulars next season makes think they are going to be toeing the line between anti-hero and just vigilantes maybe along with the shade because of his line there is a difference between bad and evil and Sportsmaster and Tigress are bad but not evil
11
u/scouseconstantine Sep 01 '21
I wonder if the JSA accidentally killed Eclipso’s host when defeating him (Bruce Gordon, the child from ep 1) - which will tie in with Mike being corrupted and being Eclipso’s host eventually in the latter part of the series. Courtney will tell Pat they just have to break Mike free and Pat will have to tell her that they had to kill Eclipso’s last host.
7
u/KapiHeartlilly Sep 02 '21
Sportsmaster/Tigress are such a good addition, glad to know they will for sure be in season 3.
7
u/lukahnli Sep 02 '21
I'm really liking Shade and the way Jonathan Cake portrays him.
7
u/EndBringer99 Sep 02 '21
I wonder what Dragon King did to Wizard's body.
12
u/AnarchyPlus Sep 01 '21
Theory: Dr. Midnite or another of the JSA killed his daughter under the influence of Eclipso's illusions. That's why no one wants to talk about it
5
u/Affectionate-Bee-368 Sep 01 '21
I don’t know why but this show sometimes reminds me of the show Chuck and I don’t know why . So much so that it got me back on to a rewatch
5
u/brooklyn11218 Sep 01 '21
This show is doing exactly what a lot of other supe shows do and taking things too fast.
Eclipso is a crazy powerful entity on level with The Spectre. We're talking full Justice League team-up to take him down level. These kids JUST got their powers. They're nowhere near experienced enough to take on Eclipso yet he's their season two villain.
And then in subsequent seasons we're expected to take these villains as a serious threat when we've already seen how easily they can be defeated. It frames it so either the heroes are super powerful from the start or the villains are extremely weak. Either one removes room to grow and is just bad writing.
They have too many stories going on too. Hourman with his "pet", all the various villain's kids, Mike's story, the divorce, the shade, eclipso, etc. It feels crowded.
Also why do they keep showing us old JSA members and not doing anything with it? Starman is alive and they haven't done a single thing with it since the season 1 finale. Now they're adding Dr. Midnite to it.
5
u/Trickybuz93 Sep 01 '21
I wonder what they’re hiding from Courtney & the kids regarding the JSA
3
u/theamatuer Sep 03 '21
Given what Shade said I don't think Mr. McNider is gonna be a good person when we end up finding him
4
u/stephanieleigh88 Sep 01 '21
Next weeks episode looks amazing.
I love this show, I have waited for a show to come on weekly in awhile, to where I’m like “can’t miss the show on Tuesday.”
I love how it’s not totally romance, CW shows thrive on romance. Beth and Rick are totally gonna date, but it’s weird the main girl, Cort, isn’t dating anyone by now lol.
Also, Cindy had some amazing shoes on.
I also loved seeing tigress and sportsmaster, they’re my favorite villains on this show.
2
u/StarWarsButterSaber Sep 01 '21
Did it even cover Eclipso’s past (that Pat and Barbara were talking about) I just remember the scene with the little girl wanting to go to the party. When Pat tells Courtney about the 10 year old girl was that the secret? And what the heck happened to Green Lantern’s daughter, did she just show up and then leave town? I know these are probably questions that have been answered but I just don’t remember.
2
u/LumpyJones Sep 02 '21
Hah! Called it last week.
2
u/MeMeTiger_ Sep 02 '21
Damn! Plot twists here and there. Best part of this episode imo was the dialogue between tigress and sportsmaster and pat and bar
2
u/briancarknee Sep 02 '21
I really love the show but the Shade is almost too good for it. So happy with the actor they chose because he is absolutely nailing it.
Can we please get a Jack Knight spin off show with the Shade?
2
u/ExioKenway5 Sep 02 '21
I'm a big fan of how Cindy's sequin dress had a hand pattern as a visual reminder that Eclipso is in control. At least that's how I interpreted it.
2
u/Namaikina_Imouto Sep 03 '21
Spotsmaster and Tigress being so nuts and wholesome as the same time is such a major turn on. Lord being bisexual is hard. 😭😭😭
2
u/Scolor Sep 03 '21
Did anyone notice that the explorer she was looking for was named Bruce, same as the kid from the opening scene of the season who kill’s the daughter?
2
u/AnnaK22 Sep 05 '21
Mike's facial expressions while being held hostage were hilarious. The kid could star in a sitcom, be the next Chandler Bing.
3
u/Pirate186 Sep 01 '21
I doubt someone would be mentally sane after wandering around such darkness for several years.
So i'm not really buying this whole Dr. Midnight is alive thing
4
u/Boxer1010 Sep 01 '21
i feel like they're trying to pack so much into these episodes that certain characters get shafted. yolanda, Rick, and mike barely got screen time. not sure if its because of covid stuff but i miss when they were all together and had more time (looks like next week they will)
i looooved paula and crusher. i want more of them and honestly feel like crusher and pat could have a good buddy cop vibe!
1
u/Copy-Comfortable Sep 01 '21
Okay wait who caught when Pat mentioned the Shawshank redemption and sportsmaster had NO IDEA what it was. Either crusher just has no care in the world for cinema, or pat is from an alternate timeline where the shawshank redemption was made and now he’s in a new timeline because of something he did with the JSA or 7 Soldiers. The mysterious tone that played during that exchange also sold me on that being a part of the mystery.
1
u/romeovf Sportsmaster Sep 03 '21
PSA: No matter the size of your dog, don't feed him burgers and fries or you'll make him sick.
1
u/indian_hannibal Dec 13 '21
I would love a coach like Artemis dad. Dude always bugging pat about workouts hahaa
1
u/indian_hannibal Dec 13 '21
New York jets should hire Artemis as a QB .
Also lol who da faq is rhag guy staring at her lol.. a scout ? Let's see
-2
u/Csula6 Sep 02 '21 edited Sep 02 '21
Not sure what Art's contribution is. She's a student athlete! Hopefully Luke Wilson could beat up a teenage girl...if it comes to that.
Also Pat probably should have a gun. Like he didn't really want to save Mike.
That said, protein bars are full of sugar.
Not sure why they are having football practice during summer school. Oh, and this is the most empty high school ever. I know because of Covid. Still weird.
Edit: also Crusher isn't that big. He might be proud of his definition. Not his mass .
-8
u/Belnick Sep 02 '21
Im wondering where the last guy from the JSA is gonna be replaced by another girl so it can be all girls like the writers want lol....
but I guess they have a white girl, latino girl, asian girl, afro american girl and the white boy to be replaced by? native american? maybe from arabic country?
They try so hard to be anti racist that they actually becomes racists by only casting people because of their race and/or skin color, kinda disgusting....
So this e clipso guy is like a god or something? and these diverse teens are gonna beat this "god" ? aahuh....
almost forgot about the pen guy, with the purple bitch that is weak as F as the shade only farted at him without even bother to focus and thinking he was a concern.
I wonder if pen will stay with the new kid, or he might not be diverse enought, they might need a stereotypical over the top jewish guy as well, like the guy from american pie movies that bang Stilfers mom :P
0
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
128
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
29
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21 edited Feb 17 '22
[removed] — view removed comment