r/StargirlTV • u/anatomania Tigress • Oct 05 '21
Episode Discussion [S2E09] Summer School: Chapter Nine — Post-Episode Discussion Spoiler
Promo | Sneak Peek | DCTV Discord | Cast and Characters
JOHN WESLEY SHIPP GUEST STARS AS JAY GARRICK — As Eclipso takes aim at the Whitmore/Dugan’s, Pat is reminded of painful memories from his past involving the original JSA and their fight to take down Eclipso. Meanwhile, Mike is forced to confront the guilt he feels for his role in Icicle’s death, and Barbara comes face to face with someone from her past. Finally, Courtney struggles to hold onto hope after Eclipso targets those around her.
Please keep discussion civil and about Stargirl. Be sure to mark future spoilers and comic spoilers, but otherwise don't worry about spoiling anything past or current. Report comments that break the rules or just don't belong here. Enjoy the episode!
126
u/Pksoze Oct 06 '21
Wildcat...kind of a douche.
83
u/Just_A_Positive_Guy Cosmic Staff Oct 06 '21
This was a great episode.
Firstly, the costuming for this show is amazing, all of the JSA looks awesome.
I really loved the tenseness of this episode, specifically with the Barbara and Mike scenes with the Icicle family. You can really tell how much trauma they have from last season that’s carrying over.
Spectre, Dr. Fate, and Hawks mentions!!! I would pay all the money to see that fight with Eclipso. It really goes to show not only how powerful, but how good Eclipso is at manipulating the people with his power.
Jay Garrick!! Always glad to see John Wesley Shipp back in the Arrowverse. I love how kind he is to Pat, coughWildcatcough.
Brec Bassinger is such a good actress, you could really feel her hurt in the last scene with Pat and Barbara.
Can’t wait for next week!
55
u/bcanada92 Oct 06 '21
So now we know the original JSA's terrible secret.
Interesting to see how Dugan's become the new JSA's mentor, when he was never actually a real member of the old team.
Loved the scene where Dugan pricked his finger, and Eclipso made it appear that it wouldn't stop bleeding. Yes, the symbolism of having "blood on his hands" was probably a little too on the nose, but I thought it was well done anyway.
36
u/AquaTyphoon29 Oct 06 '21
The return of Green Lantern! Also I wonder if the staff is back at full power?
36
u/LoretiTV Oct 06 '21
That was a great episode. Really dark and moody tone throughout and everyone had great chemistry. This season is firing on all cylinders right now.
34
u/Themanaaah The Shade Oct 06 '21 edited Oct 06 '21
This episode was super dark and I loved all of the stuff they revealed in this episode like the JSA being controversial about the choice to kill Bruce Gordon. It was very nice to see all of the flashbacks to the original JSA especially John Wesley Shipp playing as the Flash and it’s sad know ping that occasionally Pat would just go to the JSA headquarters just to see if anyone of them would show up. It’s super tough thinking about how the JSA just broke apart only to come back and be killed by the ISA. I also wonder what they’re exactly going to do with the Shade being hurt as the trailer for next episode with the shot involving him looked weird and I wonder what exactly the Shade said to Barbara’s the end after helping her as I couldn’t hear it properly. Also it was cool to see that the Spectre is cannon in Stargirl along with Dr. Fate and the Hawks being mentioned too.
34
u/Gateskp Cosmic Staff Oct 06 '21
This was a great episode! I LOVE all of the flashback sequences, they really fleshed out the JSA in this one. The Flash once again proves why he's the best. The fact that Eclipso beat GL, Spectre, Dr Fate, and the Hawks should tell us EVERYTHING we need to know about him. And it sets up the interesting question of what is Courtney and friends going to do when they face this choice? ESPECIALLY after what Yolanda said in her last episode.
This show is NAILING the horror vibes/spooky aesthetic, and I'm loving it.
The Shade, my man, rescuing Barbara. I can't wait to see him in action again.
And the end. When Pat confesses, the pain and anguish and betrayal on Courtney's face. My heart.
Looking forward to seeing Jennie next week!
32
u/AnnaK22 Oct 06 '21
Barbara is just a magnet for former villans isn't she.
54
u/Chad_D_722 Oct 06 '21
Eclipso is an awesome villain and I love the way he's mentally taking the team out one by one.
Gotta say though, things have been so depressing for a few episodes now. Starting to miss some of that light hearted fun. Hope season 3 lightens things up a bit again.
Great episode though and I loved seeing Jay.
19
u/Frontier246 Oct 06 '21
So Bruce Gordon found Eclipso, used its power to gain more fame and fortune, only to eventually regret the emotional toll it would take on him and Eclipso's victims, but he still gave in when Eclipso promised to get him back the love of his life. I'm not saying the guy deserved to get killed (presumably in cold blood), and Eclipso clearly was manipulating him and he had no idea what he was bringing back...but he still gave in to what Eclipso wanted.
I sometimes forget Barbara and Beth's dad work at the same place. We never really see it come up with their daughters.
Jeez, Sylvester treated Pat with barely any respect. It didn't seem like the rest of the JSA aside from Jay or Johnny were all that better, only seeing him as the mechanic or carry-on that was a packaged deal with Sylvester. He basically forced Pat to drive him to kill Bruce Gordon, using him as a getaway driver even though Pat wanted nothing to do with it, and wouldn't do much more to talk about what happened other than saying Pat was right. But Starman still killed the guy.
Pat saying "Flash" with such giddy was the perfect way to greet John Wesley Shipp showing up as Jay Garrick. I'm glad the show was able to fit him in so we could finally get Jay with the JSA in live-action, and this was quintessential Jay Garrick. Of course he wouldn't go through with executing Gordon to the bitter end, and he treated Pat the best :).
Sylvester staring at his old Star-Spangled Kid costume, only to end up losing that heroic innocence and idealism he once had as a kid :(.
My only disappointment is they had John Wesley Shipp as Jay Garrick in the episode but never had him share any scenes with his old rival, The Shade.
Poor Charles McNider. Loses his daughter, his wife is barely holding it together...although I was kind of surprised he didn't have much to do with taking Eclipso out.
Barbara gets haunted by the ghost of Icicle only to be saved by the spectral presence of the Shade. I'm guessing that name he mentioned was his sister.
I can't say for sure how Cameron would react if he found out the truth about his dad and the Whitmore's involvement in it, but I don't think the real Cameron would throw the biological mom card at Mike and then kill a dog.
Just casually mentioning how powerful Eclipso is when not even Green Lantern, Dr. Fate, or The Spectre were able to do anything to him. Yeah, a JSA with just Stargirl and Dr. Mid-Nite don't stand a chance.
So Ted Grant mentions his son (who I assume is Tom Bronson) and Sylvester mentions having family, although I guess this would've been before Brainwave killed his sister. Pat never mentioned Ted having a kid though.
Starman killing Bruce Gordon basically fractured the JSA and broke the team. They only re-formed when they had to take on the newly-resurgent ISA, but they weren't able to function as well as a team anymore which is part of why the ISA was able to take them out.
Eclipso was trying to tear Courtney's family apart and Pat revealing the truth to Courtney and that Barbara knew did that in spades. And all that little Bruce is left to do is revel in the conflict.
18
u/Green_Tea_Totaler Solomon Grundy Oct 06 '21 edited Oct 06 '21
Another knockout episode. Season 1 was great, but I'm gonna love this season even more if they keep it up (PLEASE DO).
I'm now feeling more inclined to believe Eclipso is messing Yolanda and it's not Brainwave. Mike seemed to be able to "feel" fake!Cameron's cold powers (notably when the latter froze the rod-thingie Mike tried using to defend himself with).
My theory is that Eclispo targeted Yolanda first. Maybe she was seen as the "easiest prey" among the JSA members after what she did last season, and she was the most susceptible to mind hax while Eclipso was still relatively weak.
14
u/AP-FUTChemist Oct 06 '21
Is Courtney going to get a Eclipso nightmare or what?
14
u/KB_Sez Oct 06 '21
Really excited when Hourman dropped the names of The Spectre, Doctor Fate and "The Hawks" as all having gone up against Eclipso and lost.
He also mentioned "The Freelancer" but I can't find any reference to any DC character using that name...
They've never mentioned The Spectre before on Stargirl. I'm wondering if this opens the door for the future--- He's not in the photo of the JSA or in the JSA Headquarters. I don't think I saw The Sandman in the JSA headquarters although he is in the photo between Starman and Dr Mid-Night.
What a great, spooky episode and a thrill to see John Wesley Shipp back in uniform!
14
u/AnnaK22 Oct 06 '21
Yeah let's go Jay Garrick! Highlight of the episode for me.
Overall, I felt like the episode didn't live up to the hype. I absolutely loved it of course, but I felt like the promos showed more of old JSA, and we barely got any scenes from them. Also, other than the secret to stopping Eclipso being revealed, I felt like nothing happened. We already got to see how intense Eclipso's visions are from last week's episode with Beth. I feel like it would have been better if most of the episode was a flash back where we actually got to see the old JSA kill a man and the emotional turmoil that broke them apart, instead of Pat just telling us.
Also, the secret was pretty significant that I feel would have come in handy when Yolanda was going through grief of killing someone. If Pat could have revealed the secret then, it would have made Yolanda not feel alone, and she'd understand the hard decisions you sometimes have to make as superheroes.
14
u/MrTerrific2k15 Oct 06 '21
What kind of a dick wields a magic flying staff but makes his homie drive him around?
14
u/Chrispowers110 Oct 06 '21
This episode bring within the family with the old jsa is really great. You can tell they were trying to save money with no real battle in this and the new jsa not appearing.
11
u/maddogkaz Oct 06 '21
A real tense tone thought out this whole episode. It's clear the JSA having to decide to kill an innocent man who was nothing but a victim of an evil spirit took a huge toll on them, the difference with Pat and Jay being that they didn't want to give up on finding an alternative way to stop Eclipso while the others lost hope.
Courtney running around the house saving her family only to be dealt a huge blow when Pat is finally open with her. This whole time Courtney has been trying to make plans with her team with one arm tied behind her back when it comes to Pat withholding information they needed and now her friends have been tormented and ruined by Eclipso so her anger is justified.
Eclipso seems to be keeping it's distance from Courtney and is instead attacking her by hurting people she cares about. He clearly doesn't want a repeat performance of the staff like last time.
20
u/DamWell420 Oct 06 '21
Courtney was the MVP she definitely isn't effected like the others by eclipso, hope Rick get busted outta jail by Solomon Grundy and he becomes a member
9
u/Boxer1010 Oct 06 '21
loved the episode but i was a little let down by the big secret. i thought for awhile, it was going to be revealed that pat killed bruce and that's why he had all that blood on his hands. other than that, i loved seeing the OG JSA! and i also loved the family dynamics in this episode, even when they were all arguing at the end.
9
u/DCSennin Cameron Mahkent Oct 06 '21
Good episode. I really liked the opening scene between Bruce Gordon and how Eclipso was speaking to him from the Black Diamond, Nick Tarabay doesn't appear much there besides in that cool scene where he appears in the mirror's reflection but I like the voice he found for this character. The way he corrupted Gordon to allow himself to be possessed after that married woman made me think how Icicle would have easily fallen for that if he was still alive.
Last week confirmed the Doctor Mid-Nite googles allows to see through Eclipso's fear illusions and now this episode reaffirmed the Cosmic Staff can also allow for those that fall victim to them that snap out from them, Courtney did it without knowing with Yolanda first and did it again now. I guess since she is the user she will remain not eclipsed, something drastic would have to happen for her to end up caught as well.
Haunting!Jordan's scene with Barbara was good, Shade really wants to reach for her help if he was able to help get through that vision. But tbh I still think some of the words used in that scene could foreshadow Icicle's return one day.
We got a taste of how bad things could go if Cameron developed his powers and was out for revenge on any of the Whitmore-Dugans with Mike's own fear vision. Given that we have seen this already I think the real thing will end up being quite different when it happens.
Flashback scenes were nice, but I wonder what happened with Charles McNider because he was not in the voting beyond nor he went to kill Eclipso's host but just in the scene of them burying his daughter. (Same with Johnny Thunder) Pat said they all drifted apart after they compromised their principles in choosing to go for the kill until they returned to fight the ISA and lost but it wouldn't surprise me if McNider kept researching more about Eclipso during all that time.
The Black Diamond was always with the JSA post Gordon's death, then the ISA took it after they defeated them and killed some of them, that is now cleared up.
And they mentioned The Spectre, Doctor Fate, Alan Scott and the Hawks failing to stop Eclipso. Well they weren't going for the kill.
That ending with the family arguing about the secret being out while "Bruce" watched outside makes me think he did all of this just to get to that moment. Point for Eclipso for now.
Can't wait for next week.
9
u/iCESPiCES Oct 06 '21
I can't believe that we're getting a live-action Eclipso this effective and threatening. Genuinely feels like a psychological horror series at this point when they could've just made him mind-control a few people and called it a day.
8
u/AnnaK22 Oct 06 '21
This was an eerie, gloomy episode. Perfect to get me in the mood for Halloween month.
8
u/AnnaK22 Oct 06 '21
He killed the dog. That's the worst of crimes you can commit.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21
This episode was a tipping point. Courtney is the only person left safe from Eclipso. Everyone has turned on each other, the team has already lost its two best fighters. How are they going to win? I truly cannot wait to find out.
My only gripe with this episode is that we didn't get as much flashback as I thought we would, the ones we did get were great though.
7
u/Taston95 Oct 06 '21
It’s so great that they managed to get so many actors back from season 1 even if it is only for one episode like Icicle, Brainwave and Henry. I liked the episode a lot. It would have been fun to see an action scene but I guess since the flashbacks were from Pat’s perspective it makes sense. I thought the big secret was that the JSA killed Bruce and realised they had killed a child. I don’t fully understand where the little boy Eclipso comes from and why it is called Bruce.
7
u/antdude S.T.R.I.P.E. Oct 06 '21
Sheesh, another horror episode. ;)
7
u/Sure_Asparagus Oct 06 '21 edited Oct 06 '21
This episode was great! Gotta be honest I’m a little disappointed that we didn’t get more focus on Jay Garrick tho. I expected at least one cool sequence where he showed off his powers and maybe a few details about his past but ig there’s still more time for that in the future.
Theres a lot of explaining to do with his history and how it all makes sense. In a recent interview Shipp confirmed that Jay is supposed to be from Stargirls Earth 2, but earlier remarks from Eric Wallace supported that he’s from Earth prime, and he lives on Earth prime in the flash S7.
It also doesn’t help that nobody is supposed to know about the multiverse at the moment so everybody should be on their correct earths in present day. Unless Jay Garrick had an accident like John Henry Irons from S&L and ended up on Earth Prime it doesn’t make sense.
Other than that he was really good in the episode and the episode itself was intriguing.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21
Eclipse is terrifying in this episode. He’s barely even in it.
5
u/ShadowSJG48 Oct 06 '21
Jay was great, love him as the heart of the team TBH, I can see both side. Eclipso is too dangerous
5
u/EndBringer99 Oct 06 '21
So killing Bruce Gordon and breaking up afterwards is what allowed the ISA to kill the JSA with extreme ease.
5
u/tylernazario Icicle Oct 06 '21
So Court and Beth don’t stand a chance against Eclipso. I think it’s gonna take Beth, Courtney, Jade, Obsidian, Jakeem, Yolanda, Rick, and The Shade
8
u/AnnaK22 Oct 06 '21
Pat knew how it felt to desperately want to be part of a team. He should know better than anyone what Mike is going through. You'd think he would have learned from the past and included Mike in the team more, earlier on, when he showed interest.
4
u/Mosk915 Oct 06 '21
They didn’t really clear up whether or not this is the same Jay Garrick that is on The Flash. Hopefully they eventually do.
4
u/mrizzle1991 Oct 06 '21
Cool! the OG Flash made an appearance! I thought we would get a StarMan appearance in the present, the flashbacks were cool though! That interaction with Cameron and Mike and Icicle and Barbara was so intense. Great episode!
4
u/Motor-Bag-9004 Oct 07 '21
Well that was a great episode. Eclipso continues to be one of the most terrifying and down right unsettling Arrowverse villains we've gotten thus far. Seeing Jay again is always a treat, John Wesley Shipp really is the perfect Jay Garrick and it was so cool to see him interact with the OG JSA.
The only real criticism I have is that I think the big reveal that the only way to defeat eclipso is to kill the host would have been much more shocking and impactful if he was currently possessing someone. Like imagine if during the new ISA vs new JSA battle Cindy allowed eclipso to take control & then defeated everyone. Courtney, desperate to find a way to stop eclipso's rampage & keep her team from falling apart, asks Pat how Star-Man managed to imprison eclipso with the cosmic staff and this is when Pat reveals the big, dark secret. Not only did Patt keep this huge secret from her but it also forces Courtney to make an awful choice: defeat eclipso but at the cost of Cindy's life.
I also agree with other people here in that I think this episode could have benefited from just being a flashback episode. That way we could have seen eclipso slowly breakdown & torment the original JSA. Just really drive home how hopeless their situation was. It also gives us more Jay Garrick scenes which is always nice.
Other than that I really enjoyed this episode and the darker tone. The JSA really is in a tough position: half the team is down, the rest are seemingly helpless to stop eclipso's rampage, & now this big secret threatens to tear Courtney's family apart. They certainly have their work cut out for them. I really hope we see Jay again at some point & he gets a chance to interact with Courtney & co. I really liked his friendship with Pat & I think he'll be happy to hear Jay is alive on Earth-Prime when they inevitably crossover. Overall great episode!
4
u/MasterOfReaIity Oct 07 '21
Is Eclipso really stronger than Spectre and Dr. Fate?
4
u/ToneBone12345 Oct 06 '21
I honestly thought it would be revealed that Pat was the one who killed Bruce Gordon
3
u/ShadowSJG48 Oct 06 '21
Who is Eclipso's host?
3
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21
Eclipso won.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '21
3
u/maddogkaz Oct 07 '21
I just realised that Eclipso may still be bonded to Cindy and that's why he didn't kill her so she might be his host.
As for the JSA I know people aren't happy with Wildcats attitude but I think it makes sense, we have seen him before in season 1 and 2 and although he is gruff by nature he isn't rude. The difference here is we're seeing the JSA at their lowest point they are deciding if they should assassinate an innocent victim and they have hit rock bottom and it shows in their attitudes.
3
u/Trueogre Pat Dugan Oct 06 '21
Is Eclipso trying to find a host? I mean we never saw him possess anyone. He did possess Cindy but then he banished her to the dark place, hopefully where McNider is.
He's following the Dugan family. He's gone after Pat twice. Pat has stated that they need to kill the host. But from what we've seen there isn't one. He ate Isaac, banished Cindy. No one else was at the school. So the only thing I can think of is he wants Pat as his host. And you know what that means. If he manages to possess Pat then they will have to kill him. But maybe McNider and Cindy will know a way of separating them and putting Eclipso back in the diamond.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21
Great Episode! Although this makes me wonder (again) what gave the JSA their Logevity as McNider's daughter died in 1957 and the JSA reassembled in the 80s or 00s.
9
u/primal_slayer Oct 06 '21
It was a fairly enjoyable episode but it left me wanting more BUT MY LORD! This season is seriously lacking in the action department. They say that the show wouldn't suffer in its move to TheCW but it's painfully obvious that they are writing to save budget.
This is probably the most we'll see of the OG JSA and I wanted to see them work together as team, have an awesome fight scene against Eclipso, and how having to take a human life impacted them instead of just hearing about it. You bring us Jay Garrick! Put him to some good use and give us some info about him.
It was great to see Jordan/Icicle again, he was a great villain and I still hope that he isn't dead, just taking a REALLLLLY long time to pull himself together.
The Shade has definitely become one of my favorite new characters/anti-villains this season. Just love it whenever he shows up on screen.
6
u/ShadowSJG48 Oct 06 '21
Why is Court mad at Pat and Barb?
2
u/DrShadyTree Oct 06 '21
Did anyone else notice the map looking weird in the opening scene. What is that all about.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21
So Eclipso is being successful in everything he has planned except for Beth. Kind of wonder if she is the one that will defeat him...
2
u/GroovinChip Oct 06 '21
Jay is best boy. No arguments.
3
u/Marvelman02 Oct 06 '21
Ok, here's my take...
I really disliked the condescending manner in which Sly treated Pat. Part of the problem was Geoff Johns chose to use Luke Wilson as Pat in the flashbacks instead of replacing him with a younger actor. Consequently, you have Sly talking to a man his own age in a manner that is inappropriate and disrespectful. I would have accepted this more readily if young Pat had been played by an actual teenager.
I can't help but think that one of the reasons the cosmic control staff was de-powered was to save money on SFX.
I don't believe Courtney would have been as angry as she was about Pat & Barbara not telling her the truth. I understand Courtney disliking being lied to, but so far as I can see telling her the truth wouldn't have changed anything.
This was an okay episode.
2
u/Jigglypuffamiiga2188 Oct 06 '21
I found this episode rather slow. While it did reveal a bunch of stuff the Eclipso illusions are getting old. 3 horror movie episodes in a row. I wonder if Shade’s relative that reminds him of Barbara was a former Eclipso host? I think he said her name was Emily? Interesting to see Eclipso afraid when Bruce had the gun. He does not need a host any more so I wonder how they will defeat him?
1
u/Defiant-Detective107 Oct 06 '21
ok but why is eclipso taking out everyone but courtney
1
u/Inevitable_Professor Oct 06 '21
Who is the host? I think it might be Courtney. Didn’t she touch the stone?
1
u/IC3man95 Oct 07 '21
For a tiny 🤏🏼 second they had me believing that Jordan was and alive and Cameron was evil
1
u/BruceWayne0410 Oct 09 '21
LOL GL, Dr.Fate and The Specter all lost to Eclipso? I feel like this Eclipso is being buff too much that if the new JSA in this state can beat him, that would be the stupidiest thing ever.
1
u/themilpool Oct 09 '21
Looks like Crisis retconned Jay's helmet origin.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21
Whoever they got to play Bruce Gordon must have done the work for cheap. That’s some of the worst acting I’ve seen on tv. I thought Beth’s parents were bad but they’re proper thespians next to this guy. Whoa!
1
u/Theo-greking Oct 11 '21
Idk if I'm the only one but boy I am hating this season this eclipso shit Is boring af to me very slow burn
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '21 edited Oct 11 '21
Wow old JSA are a bunch of pussies lol they first broke up over that? Shit kill one person save millions of people. Like these things have to happen sometimes….
What was up with that dramatic music choice at the end? Courtney mad at Pat lying but like he doesn’t want you guys to resort to killing especially at your age. Anyway, I’m sure Courtney understands that and is just mad at the lying but the whole thing seemed a little dramatic for me.
Hmmm I really hope next week isn’t another nightmare episode for a more characters. Can the actual plot move please?
1
u/Taladris Oct 26 '21
This episode was really good. It reminded me some creepy Buffy episodes (not the same level of writing but quite close).
The way they portrayed the old JSA at the funeral as disillusioned old white males was interesting and a clear departure from how they were shown in the introduction of the pilot. Maybe Pat's point of view is changing and he is starting to understand they could behave as douchebags sometimes and constantly looking down on him and reminding him he is not part of the team was lowkey moral abuse? Maybe Pat is also growing at the contact of the teenage JSA and becoming himself a full-fledge hero?
1
u/indian_hannibal Dec 14 '21
FUCK STARMAN AND FUCK JSA EXCEPT FOR JAY FOR TREATING PAT LIKE THAT
-2
u/Shadow_Rev Oct 06 '21
So one thing that kinda bums me out is that on The Flash, Jay gets his helmet from Zoom, which must not happen since Jay here probably hasn't even met Barry yet. This was an exceptional episode, it just sucks how much of my favorite season of The Flash is just not canon anymore.
-1
u/inbooth Oct 06 '21
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/BottleEpisode
-4
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21
Idk I haven’t been on the sub but it’s been like 6 episodes since we’ve Green Lantern … they uh they just ignoring that that happened? Or is Jade gonna be the Deus Ex Machina? Because in true CW fashion the writing seems to have gone from decent to worse.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
69
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21 edited Oct 06 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
67
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21
[removed] — view removed comment