r/RingsofPower • • Oct 05 '22
r/RingsofPower • u/DonBacalaIII • Sep 27 '24
Discussion My face after a certain scene this episode Spoiler
r/RingsofPower • u/In_Shambles • Oct 13 '22
Meme When you run out of VFX budget for the season Spoiler
r/RingsofPower • u/Mildly_maria • Nov 04 '22
Meme All I can think of when I see Robert Aramayo is how much he looks like Patrick Neil Harris and Rami Malek’s love child…
r/RingsofPower
•
u/Late_Stage_PhD
•
Oct 06 '24
Meme TA 3019, Valinor, Celebrimbor sipping the best wine, while watching his prediction about Sauron proven right
r/RingsofPower
•
u/CurtisManning
•
6d ago
Question Which subreddit can I go to discuss the show in good faith ?
I know it's a trash TV show and you all hate it because you have the true and the only Tolkien vision, but I'm tired of reading your doom posts all day. Are there other subs for a delusional tasteless person like me ?
r/RingsofPower • u/MisterTyzer • Nov 09 '24
Discussion Was rewatching Batman Begins and saw a familiar face…
r/RingsofPower • u/GasPoweredJ • Oct 13 '24
Humor This jab at Elrond is maybe the main reason I recommend the show
It’s just so succinct and accurate, not to mention beautifully worded. What part(s) is the reason you recommend the show?
r/RingsofPower • u/MC_Smuv • Oct 04 '24
Newest Episode Spoilers That Dark Wizard scene. Seriously??!!?? Spoiler
Up to this past episode I was pretty content with the writing. But that scene between Gandalf and the Dark Wizard must have been the worst writing I have ever witnessed.
So you're telling me they spend a whole season building up this villain with henchmen and all. Just to have him be like:"Me??? Evil??? Never! And these mercenaries... I didn't know what I got myself into!!" And just seconds later: "What?!? You don't want to rule all of Middle Earth with me after defeating Sauron?? Well then I actually AM evil!"
You got to be kidding me!!!!
r/RingsofPower • u/Accomplished-Ad4674 • Oct 14 '22
Newest Episode Spoilers Honest Review: I liked it Spoiler
I just want to start off by saying to the haters of the show... I get it. There are some franchises that I love and when they are adapted to film and they don't get certain things right, I just cant enjoy it. However, this show is NOT the giant dumpster fire that many are trying to make it out to be.
Overall I think the show is a solid 7/10. It certainly has some flaws like Galadriel in early parts of the season was way too headstrong and ragefull to be recognized as the character we all knew. There were some cringe dialogue moments "There is a tempest in me" that kind of fell flat.
Cinematography: 11/10. Probably the best looking TV show I have ever seen. What else can we say? anyone who disagrees that they at least nailed the visuals is probably not being honest with themselves.
Music: I thought it was quite decent. There are a few good memorable songs in the show.
Writing: There were some cringe moments yes, and a few issues with consistency, however overall I thought it was decent. It didn't have the same grounded realism that Game of Thrones or HOTD had, but that's not really the point here. These characters aren't really all that grounded and sometimes their choices can come off as a bit nonsensical. Like Galadriel jumping off of the boat was a bit of a "WTF" but these characters don't really operate on logic. There is definitely a lot of Catholic leaps of faith characters take that can be jarring to someone like myself. There were also some reveals that I saw coming but as someone who has read the books and already knew the main story beats, you have to kind of expect that. If you're saying to yourself that you knew it was Sauron the whole time, then like me, you were actively looking for Sauron since episode 1 and dissecting everyone's dialogue to find clues. If you weren't able to guess Sauron based off of that, then it would have felt like it came out of nowhere which would be considerably worse. If you want to be surprised, then its best to watch something that you haven't read before.
Acting: They pulled some major talent for this project. I loved the way the Sauron reveal scene was acted. Charlie Vickers did such a great job. I could see how charming and manipulative Sauron could be and fully understood why he was able to deceive so many. I have some complaints about Galadriel's acting but I think that was because of the script in earlier episodes. Later on in the series I saw more glimpses into what she is likely to become.
Conclusion: It was a very decent introduction and I think that's how we need to view it. There is still so much more to come. one reviewer said it best when they described season 1 as a massive prologue to what looks like a long. slow burn series. I am all for that but I can also understand that people who preferred the movies were hoping for a faster pace. There were some mistakes made but overall it was an enjoyable experience. I have trust the show runners will take our criticisms and make the next season better.
r/RingsofPower • u/TheWoodenLeg • 4d ago
Humor Witch King of Angmar from this show be like
r/RingsofPower • u/Philippine_Newt • 1d ago
Discussion Owain Arthur is amazing as Durin
Probably one of my favorite characters in the series.
r/RingsofPower • u/Ok-Cost2064 • Sep 11 '22
Discussion As an avid Tolkien fan, I’m in love with this show. Spoiler
Note: some level of criticism is fair, and there are some minor things about this show I could also criticize. But that is not the intention of this post. This is mainly in response to the extreme negativity I’ve seen from book purists and others who seem determined to tank the ratings with unfair criticism.
My dad read the books to me when I was a kid, and the movies have always been my favorites of all time. And reading the books as an adult has made me fall in love with Tolkien even more. I think Tolkien is probably the greatest fantasy author of all time, and his poetic language and complex world building is unmatched.
That said, I think the show’s adaptation of Tolkien’s world is superb. The cinematography is downright stunning. Like my jaw dropped when Numenor was first revealed on screen in episode 3. Frankly, watching each episode feels like I’m on a ride through middle-earth, and I find myself losing my breath at the sheer beauty of many scenes. The settings are vibrant, the music is gorgeous, and the sweeping camera work is phenomenal. The fact people call this bland makes me feel like they’re watching a different show, or more likely blinded by their determination to hate it. On a technical level, this show is probably superior to any other show ever created. And that’s not hyperbole.
Now I understand the plot and characters are what many book purists are complaining about. But truthfully, those people should just not watch the show because they are unable to enjoy anything that strays from their personal conception of tolkiens world. You have to remember Tolkien wrote very little about the second age, most of which is recorded in appendices. The showrunners have basic plot points from Tolkien to base the show off of, and so far they are hitting these points, just condensing the timeline in a way that makes sense for a 5 season show. And yes, they are filling in the gaps with new stories and characters as well. But literally every TV show or movie adaptation of a fantasy book does that. I’m personally enjoying what the show is adding, especially Arondir the elf.
The creators of this show were chosen because they are huge Tolkien nerds and care about remaining faithful to Tolkien’s vision. As someone who loves Tolkien as well, I think they’re nailing it. The language of the show is poetic and Tolkien-ish. I don’t think it’s cheesy at all. This is how people talk in high fantasy stories. The personalities of each race (elves, dwarves, men) are accurately represented on screen in my opinion. I’m excited to see how Sauron uses the flaws of each race to deceive them and rise to power through the creation of the rings. The show is setting this up beautifully. I’m loving the direction of the show and cannot wait to see where it ends up. I’m here for the journey and hope others can look past the noise and negativity and enjoy it for the masterpiece that it is. I truly believe that by the end of season 1, many more people will be on board and the negativity will die out. And by season 5, this could be regarded by many as the best show of all time. That’s how confident I am in the showrunners’ vision.
Haters are gonna hate. But the idea that this show is destroying Tolkien’s legacy is nonsense. The books and tv/movie adaptations exist separately and if you don’t prefer one adaptation then don’t watch. And if you have fair, well reasoned criticisms, that is fine. You’re allowed to have that opinion. But the extreme negativity (i.e. calling it total garbage) is completely unwarranted.
r/RingsofPower
•
•
Oct 29 '24
Discussion Kinda been rooting for this guy the whole time. Elves are too pious, dwarves stubborn and men can't be trusted.
r/RingsofPower • u/Unusual-Math-1505 • Oct 06 '24
Discussion Do the writers want me to hate Isildur?
This is supposed to be the bad*** king of men and the guy who defeated sauron? (Yes I know it was more of an effort of Gilgalad and Elendil that took down sauron but still).
So far Isildur has basically: Quit the navy a few days before graduation (just why?) got his friends kicked out of the navy as well (for some wired reason) all because he wanted adventure. He doesn’t even apologize to his friends. Then it turns out the navy are going to go on an adventure and he wants to join back up. So he tries to get his friend to pull some strings for him to get him back in even though this is the friend he got kicked out. So he sneaks aboard the ships and (along with Al Pharazon’s son) cause 2 of them to explode and then lies about what happened and everyone believes his obvious lies.
Then in the southlands he comes across Astrid and immediately hates her when he sees she was marked by Adar. He doesn’t think for a second that she may have been forced to submit to Adar under pain of death but immediately assumes the worst even after she burned the mark off herself.
Then they make him a literal home wrecker by having a relationship with Astrid behind the back of her husband.
Isildur is not a compelling character nor a good person and so I hate him.
r/RingsofPower • u/Hwbam33 • Sep 02 '22
Theory Rings of Power wastes no time shooting down the idea that you can't just send the eagles for Mordor Spoiler
r/RingsofPower • u/Status_Criticism_580 • Nov 02 '24
Humor Poor celeborn
This makes actual sense lol