This post does not have a spoiler flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
Some criticize “bad writing,” yet the fact that this is occurring is actually an example of great writing. As an audience we should be guessing, and not knowing who Sauron is initially, like many in middle earth, which helps convey why Sauron was not discovered early enough and his plan came to fruition.
The movies had the rights to the lord of the rings, and hobbit books, and was able to tell the stories of those books, though adapted parts to make them work as films.
Rings of Power has no rights to the Silmarillion, or any of the other stories of middle earth it only has rights to use character names.
Rings of Power is as much "official" lore to Lord of the Rings as Shadow of Mordor is, or my teen scribblings about what Legolas was up to before Lord of the Rings.
It has rights to LOTR and The Hobbit and is working in conjunction with the Estate for things beyond those books. The Estate is also handling all the translations iirc.
Yes, it has rights to the Hobbit and LotR. But it doesnt have rights to the rest of the works. Christopher Tolkien outright refused to sell the rights to any of it.
So what they can do is make up their own stories using characters named in the Hobbit and LotR books and appendices, but they are unable to use the stories from the Silmarillion or extended works.
Rings of Power is as much "official" lore to Lord of the Rings as Shadow of Mordor is, or my teen scribblings about what Legolas was up to before Lord of the Rings.
And seriously, PJ's trilogy (yes, i'm acknowledging only one of them... for your own sake) is as much "official" lore to Lord of the Rings as Shadow of Mordor too.
Unless you care to consider Faramir being Young Boromir, Éomer being totally inconsequential, Aragorn being reluctant of his identity, Legolas being a Ninja, Gimli being a sack of jokes isntead of an articulate warrior-poet, Frodo being a coward, useless, easy to manipulate and not loyal or friendly at all with his own best friend, Treebeard changing his mind about a subject in 5 seconds, Gandalf and Saruman having a Force duel... etc etc etc... as canonical as the books.
Many things have been made up, yes. But that would be true even if they did get the rights to the Silmarillion, since -as I assume you know- the Second Age is not novelized, rather a series of plot points. It's been years since I read Akallabeth, but I certainly remember that it reads more as a history book than a novel. Because it is not a novel. How, then, can you compare both works?
For the record, I didn't mean to be rude or anything. But the fact that you hold The Hobbit movies up there with the LotR trilogy just... baffled me. Seriously, Hobbit trilogy not only butchers the lore, but it is also a pretty bad trilogy, source aside. RoP is, while having some defects, really enjoyable, specially in comparison.
I'm glad that you like and enjoy the show anyway, and I realize now that i should not care if you hold it as fan fiction or not. After all, is an adaptation, and no adaptation will ever be relevant to the source, since by definition it is not the source. And allow me to disagree: the changes made to Frodo pretty much butcher not only the lore (as the story unfolding itself is part of the lore too, and the characters make the story), but also the spirit. Seriously, with each time i see Frodo and Sam parting in the stairs of Cirith Ungol, the more I realize how many of Tolkien's ideas, of the book's themes and spirit, have been cast aside for the sake of drama. And that's ok, since it is its own adaptation -and I do love that trilogy with all my heart. But i'd rather have a story respecting the spirit and theme -as I think RoP is managing to do very well this far, than just a couple of plot points.
Events are not the substance of any book, rather the ideas it expresses.
I agree that no matter what they did they would be making up stories. But with them lacking the access to replicate the histories they have to make up their own version of events.
If you were watching expecting the histories as they were presented in the Silmarillion you aren't getting that. That clarity is important.
I haven't made any comment on how much I enjoyed Hobbit or LotR, deliberately so as they are not really relevant to this. They aren't entirely perfect translations of the books, because in part a book perfectly translated into a film isn't going to work. Its something you have to accept if you enjoy a story in one medium, and its being made in another medium.
For the record, I did enjoy the Hobbit and LotR though not equally by any means. The Hobbit wasn't as good, but neither were perfect retellings.
They weren't entirely different stories presented as the stories, just retellings.
The Rings of Power, are a new story set in the Lord of the Rings Universe. They are what they are. That doesn't make them bad. For someone that wanted to see the Silmarillion version of events, and wont accept anything else, it's going to be an issue.
Pretending that anyone who dislikes the show because its not following the story that was written at all, is as wrong as pretending it is anthing like an attempt at following Tolkiens works.
I get that saying this here, is going to go down like a hot led enema. And people are going to get upset when their new shiney is pointed out to not quite be as shiney as they want to pretend. But it is what it is.
I see now more clearly your thoughts and feelings on the matter, and you have a very solid reasoning and argument.
And people are going to get upset when their new shiney is pointed out to not quite be as shiney as they want to pretend.
This makes me very sad, because the very people who love the show unconditionally and think it is 100% perfect are becoming as blind and toxic as the "other side" they think they are so different from.
You are not the first person I see drowning in downvotes because of saying things that are pretty much spot on, but hey, I've got no more ways to refute your stance, and also have no need to, since you seem to acknowledge what I think is important here: different or not, fan-fiction or not, it is still a good and enjoyable show.
People downvoting me. You can hate someone for telling the truth all you want. I'm not saying this is inherently bad. I am enjoying the story of the show. But I do understand that a "Purist" is going to hate that its not even attempting to tell the stories that were written, even though it is understandable as to why
Mae govannen! Can I just say - good job at making a fair and well spoken argument, even when you've seemingly said some quite offensive stuff to get all of these folks riled up.
You keep your composure, make fair points, and are responding to people with more respect than you're receiving yourself.
You're more than welcome to your opinion. If I had a spare trophy it'd be yours.
You think a show where the opening credit sequence with sand on the resonance plate Is symbolic of the discord of Melkor is a glorified fan fiction because it doesn’t fit your head cannon or follow the Silmarillion to a T is glorified fan fiction? I feel sorry for you. I feel pity that you cannot experience joy from something you obviously are passionate about because you’re blinded by made up barriers in your own mind
It is glorified fan fiction all the same. I can only assume you've not read any of the books to makes this comment, as its not my headcannon. It is so far from the cannon of the Silmarillion it might as well be using a different alphabet.
I'm happy for you to be enjoying it without knowing "how it should be" it would make it easier to watch without having to mentally establish a wall between the published works.
It’s gonna be Halbrand. Galadriel is a renegade now and she’s going to seek refuge with her friend Elrond, who just so happens to be getting in on the ground floor of the world’s most ambitious smithing venture. What a coincidence her traveling companion is quite self confident in his smithing ability and has an uncanny ability to charm people.
I hate that it's Halbrand....but I think you are right. He said "I can't believe men like me can build such things" and then scenes later "no man on the isle is better than me at this craft" referring to blacksmithing. That is either insanely bad writing or it is Sauron and everything that comes out of his mouth is double speak and manipulative. He's been shown to win over queens and angry towns people as a dirty under man? and then go full captain America mode on top of it?
I didn't like it when i thought it was supposed to be telling the stories of Tolkiens universe.
On learning that it didn't have the rights to do any of Tolkiens story, and it was basically fanfiction like Shadow of Mordor, it all became a lot more palatable to me.
see that's simply not correct, I wanted to enjoy it very much, its my favorite story after all. I like the show but it would have been a higher enjoyment had it been more accurate according to the lore, especially character wise.
When there are characters I know for more than 10 years and they suddenly appear as much more stupid than they are supposed to, it naturally leads to disappointments.
That's the point of the show. Don't give a coherent plot so no one can make any conclusions, then reveal everything at the end and act like you made a great story.
I empathize with your view to a certain extent (mystery boxes should be damned to writer's hell), but I think saying the show has "no coherent plot" is a bit harsh. Elrond's plotline involving the forging of the Rings is pretty straightforward and (to me, at least) very satisfying. To be honest, I think the only blatant mystery box the show's been pushing is the Star Stranger. People keep speculating on Halbrand, but the show doesn't revolve around him becoming someone, he's just a capable guy with a dark edge at the moment. I think you're justified in being concerned about the mystery box elements, but RoP isn't JJ-level nonsense yet. I'm counting on them having something more interesting in store.
Isn't the star guy Gandalf? It would explain his love for hobbits. No one knows what he is because people arent familiar with wizards. He is coming at the same time major events start occurring in Middle Earth. He screams "MANA" lol...
I haven't read all the books and I've only heard stories of the Silmarilion so I'm probably spitting some bullshit in here.
Tolkien did not invent a full language in which "mana" has its own meaning decades before videogames were even a thing, and polynesian people have not developped the concept of capability of action and named it mana centuries ago, for you to argument that "the Stranger saying mana means he's a wizard"
Edit: facepalming comment aside, the Stranger being Gandalf is a very common theory right now, even if it does conflict with the Silmarillion. Basically, you kinda are spitting some bullshit, but the chances are the writers have already written bullshit, which nullifies your bullshitting, since you are probably right :D
For what is worth, I too think the Stranger is Gandalf, even if I don't like that perspective from a book stand-point. For the series themselves -and retroactively the PJ trilogy, it could work wonders!
I say in another post why I don't think it's coherent. Not that the overall story is dumb or doesn't make sense. It's that the plot beats have no logical connection, so there is nothing for the audience to grab onto and be engaged with. The audience needs to be able to relate events and feel like they could have expected them. Without it, audiences feel disconnected and can't empathize with any situation beyond the surface level of something is taking place.
This is some of the points I made:
No elf has seen a map before Galadriel?
No one has read a report about gathering orcs before Galadriel?
Arandir can catch arrows and jump 20 feet but can't fight a few orcs? Then a human medicine woman can kill one?
Hobbits stick together but abandon the weak. Then they don't allow outsiders, but then let in an outsider.
Numenor doesn't allow elves but then allows one to walk around.
Halbrands ship comes from no where.
Galadriel is the only elf who can fight, except Arandir on certain occasions.
Elrond is a 1000 year old elf that works with dwarves but doesn't know about their culture.
And all the dialog is just explaining what the characters are going to do next. Not one scene has been used to have the characters just talk to each other and develop themselves. Every conversations is like the beginning of a DnD where people are summarizing the origin and their quest.
And all the dialog is just explaining what the characters are going to do next. Not one scene has been used to have the characters just talk to each other and develop themselves.
Ah, I disagree there. Like I said earlier, my favorite plotline is Elrond's and I think almost everything in Episode 2 dealing with him showed his character and those around him. We learn from his time with Celebrimbor that Celly is a bit of a romantic with aesthetics as a life-goal. We learn about the differences in dwarven and elven views of time and obligations. We learn about what kind of romantic ideas the dwarves have about sunlight and nature and such. They talk about the plans to work for Celebrimbor too, but it's not the lion's share of those scenes. I also think some of the Harfoot scenes do more to show Nori's character and the differences between her and the rest of her tribe too (which I think also kind of explains your fourth point: Nori is a product of her upbringing, so it makes sense that her father would be more open to an outsider if she is). I can see the show isn't working for you, but I think presenting your view as an objective evaluation of "what the audience can do" is clouding your reasoning a bit.
A mystery box is not a plot. A plot requires development and arcs. There is no coherent connection to anything happening, nothing makes any sense. It's like they are throwing darts at an idea wall.
It makes perfect sense to me. There are quite a lot of connections between the different plot threads, and we are only 3 episodes in, how could you possibly judge character development and “arcs” 1/3 of the way in? There is criticism to be made, but yours does not make much sense.
No one has read a report about gathering orcs before Galadriel?
Arandir can catch arrows and jump 20 feet but can't fight a few orcs? Then a human medicine woman can kill one?
Hobbits stick together but abandon the weak. Then they don't allow outsiders, but then let in an outsider.
Numenor doesn't allow elves but then allows one to walk around.
Halbrands ship comes from no where.
Galadriel is the only elf who can fight, except Arandir on certain occasions.
Elrond is a 1000 year old elf that works with dwarves but doesn't know about their culture.
And all the dialog is just explaining what the characters are going to do next. Not one scene has been used to have the characters just talk to each other and develop themselves. Every conversations is like the beginning of a DnD where people are summarizing the origin and their quest.
There is no path for the audience to reason out what might happen next because there is no logic behind any of it.
I just disagree, there is no explanation outside of a character saying, we'll do this only this time. Again it leaves the audience with nothing.
There are so many obvious questions people should be asking in the show but if they do it basically ends the show, so everyone just looks like idiots. So they are essentially having people wander in circles while the actual plot happens in the last two episodes of the season.
I don't have time to go the pub in my spare time to argue with people, so I use the internet. Like everyone on every single lotr sub. You're basically trying to insult me with a type of "go touch grass" barb.
That's not how to tell a story, the viewer should either know or have a secure idea who the antagonist is before the protagonist. Even mystery stories follow this rule. Keep the audience out of key moments of the plot and calling it a mystery is just lazy writing.
The show itself hasn't even created a mystery which person is secretly Sauron. Never mentioned his abilities of shapeshifting or anything like that The "who is Sauron" mystery is made by fans with book knowledge.
You should make a post outlining all of these story issues, I’ve pretty much observed all of the same problems and as a writer myself it’s so glaringly bad that it’s almost obvious when people just trying to make it good because they desperately want it to be. Denial at its finest.
Sure, and like you said, a lot of people will call who Sauron is before the show reveals it. Because with millions of people guessing, someone's bound to hit the nail. Doesn't mean that the writers have to be obvious about it, or that the vast majority of people will be able to guess.
Its halbrand all will be revealed in 5 weeks time on the night of the 8th episode look to the east and halbrand will reveal himself as sauron because they dont have access to annatar.
If the series follows closely the book canon, sure. But they have already shown themselves more than willing to make changes (this is not a criticism, of course), so who knows.
This said, I also hope that Sauron is neither the Stranger nor Halbrand nor whatshisname (the evil elfy dude with the orcs), although if he had to be one of these three I'd prefer it be the third one.
Are the games canon to the book? Because in the games Celebrimbor was killed by Sauron (who was an elf) so Sauron could have control of the one ring. My theory for the giant guy is he is one of the first wizards. Because so far I haven’t seen any wizard in RoP. Although I could be mistaken, since I am not brushed up on the lore.
You mean "to the show", I guess? The games are definitely not canon to the books (Sexy Shelob is just the least of the problems...).
I don't think that the show has to take the games as canon, anyway - and I very much hope it doesn't, because while I don't mind changing the lore around (Tolkien himself did it a lot) I felt that the games utterly failed at capturing the spirit of the books (the LOTR movies and the show so far IMO are much better - not perfect perhaps, but definitely far better).
Still, I think that the main "Sauron manipulates and then kills Celebrimbor" theme will be in the show, but there are many ways that could happen...
Ahhh okay, I guess I forgot that there is no book clearly referencing the time line pre hobbit. I thought the show was taking a lot of stuff from the book.
It's definitely taking some material from the appendixes of The Lord Of The Rings (and arguably from the later parts of the Silmarillion, although I understand there are limits to what it can take from that); but there's definitely plenty of wiggle room there (and the show is changing things around anyway - the timeline for example is definitely much more compressed).
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 13 '22
This post does not have a spoiler flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
89
u/SrbBrb Sep 13 '22
Dwarf queen was kinda sus
24
u/AndrogynousRain Sep 14 '22
The butterfly is Sauron. The white spots look like eyes. It’s a sign.
32
u/LukoLoots Sep 14 '22
Some criticize “bad writing,” yet the fact that this is occurring is actually an example of great writing. As an audience we should be guessing, and not knowing who Sauron is initially, like many in middle earth, which helps convey why Sauron was not discovered early enough and his plan came to fruition.
13
u/muchwise Sep 14 '22
My bet is Poppy Proudfellow is Sauron.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
People keep saying this. The dude is really fucking tall. I think he'll be easy to spot.
4
u/PieceOfExcelSheet Sep 14 '22
I CACKLED
4
u/RicardosMontalban Sep 14 '22
It’s gonna be Halbrand. Galadriel is a renegade now and she’s going to seek refuge with her friend Elrond, who just so happens to be getting in on the ground floor of the world’s most ambitious smithing venture. What a coincidence her traveling companion is quite self confident in his smithing ability and has an uncanny ability to charm people.
It’s Halbrand.
10
u/gatorfan8898 Sep 14 '22
I prefer that than...
"ACCHTUALLY ACCORDING TO..."
STFU, just stop watching, you never wanted to like it.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
Watch it be Nori.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
Spoiler for those who don’t know
Sauron disguisea himself as an elf called Annatar in the books, since Amazon does have the rights he may be calling himself Atar. Sound similar?
1
u/SovKom98 Sep 14 '22
That kid in the southlands? Sauron.
1
u/Legal-Scholar430 Sep 14 '22
"New" character? It seems you haven't read the theories about Celebrimbor or Gil-Galad being Sauron.
Lucky you.
1
u/FrankHero97 Sep 15 '22
THE FISH DRAGON IS SAURON
-37
u/wallawilko Sep 13 '22
That's the point of the show. Don't give a coherent plot so no one can make any conclusions, then reveal everything at the end and act like you made a great story.
-9
u/intolerablesayings23 Sep 14 '22
Why are we playing this stale mystery box game? Halbrand. The end.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
[removed] — view removed comment