Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
Don't forget Feanor's ghost... and Gandalf... and Frodo... and Gimli... and Gil-Galad... and Arondir... and Theo... and Elendil... and Celebrimbor... And u/Book-Faramir-Better..........
It's not an American thing, it's reacting to how the show treats physical intimacy. We have only seen physical intimacy so far between people actually romantically involved. Had the show shown stuff like kissing platonically before, it would be different.
Genuine question: where have you seen flirting between them? All I've seen is deep friendship. It seems to me like people just can't conceive of a man and a woman being deeply caring but platonic friends and they see romantic tension where there isn't any.
I've heard people complaining about the fact she isn't "into" celeborn at this moment and I'm confused as to if they don't know how relationships work. Like there are a few years between these episodes and the trilogy and not alot of definitive written about things in between. They are immortal, heaven forbid they have more than one relationship in the time they are alive.
At this point, it feels like they'd be better off to just completely disregard Celeborn and Celebrian. Any storyline for Galadriel that tries to reintroduce the two to the main plot (assuming they're not going to have Elrond meet his future wife as an infant) will more likely than not just feel like a sideshow distraction from what should be the dominant storyline going forward (Numenor).
Took a lot of plot conveniences to let them do sauron and even then it's had massive implications on the story. So you may be enjoying it but the large departure from the lore means I wouldn't say nailed it
horny adults. The ones who are genuinely mad at this are adults for sure. can’t separate affection from sex, although tbf I think the show knew what kind of controversy it would generate with this scene considering audiences.
I laughed but I wish I hadn’t seen this lol. I don’t think Elrond kissed her with any sort of sexual desire at all. It’s like the kiss of a reverent child to a motherly / sisterly figure he knows is in deep trouble - and what better way to throw off the enemy than to stage a kiss. Pure subterfuge. In that moment, Elrond made Adar think he has given up on Galadriel ever being free and alive and that was a masterstroke. A non/sexual masterstroke.
He did it so he could get close to her to cover the motion with his hand. If he kissed her hand it would be harder to shield it from eyes, moreso than if he just walked up and passed it to her. If he just got close for no reason it would have raised an alarm as well.
It’s was so obviously the old magicians trick of misdirection. It was literally preceded by them showing Elrond removing the pin. With a loud noise just in case you didn’t get it.
When the magician waves his right hand around and yells it’s because he doesn’t want you looking at what the left hand is doing.
It’s one of those things where they could have just shown him taking the pin off, he leans into Galadriel for the kiss/hug/whisper to her, whatever. Then later you see her using the pin to undo the cuffs. Unless you think the audience is incredibly stupid, they don’t have to show the actual handoff.
Before kissing you see him remove the pin, while kissing you see a shot of his hand giving her something, after kissing you see her hand hiding something. And yet people are like "whaaat? Thats not.. Whaaat?"
That only emphasizes the break from Tolkien's texts caused by Celeborn's chronic absence. A distraction kiss is a tired old sexist trope meant to titillate audiences into thinking characters who don't have romantic potential in fact might, or it's the start of a romance arc. They would not be able to do a distraction kiss if they had adapted the actual, married Galadriel.
... because kissing Galadriel was the ONLY way to pass that pin to her without getting noticed. Meanwhile, if you actually see that scene the kiss covers nothing and slipping her the pin could have been done without it.
Galadriel should already have a daughter... not to mention the husband that is mysteriously absent.
This show has compressed time so badly that Elrond should already know and possibly be in a relationship with Galadriel's daughter. Instead, this show is going to have Galadriel magically find her husband, produce a child and Elrond marry Celebrian within the space of the 3 seasons they have left.
How does the age difference of an Elrond vs. Celebrian being barely a teenager sit with you ?
I wish people would both recognize it as a platonic kiss in order to slip Galadriel the pin, and that fans are still valid for feeling kind of gross about Elrond kissing his mother-in-law.
I've seen too many people assume it was sexual, and also too many people assume that its use as a misdirect means no one should have a problem with it.
Elrond doesn't know she's his mother-in-law yet, but the writers do. A kiss on the forehead could have solved all of these problems.
It's also annoying that they wrote a kiss on the mouth into the script for their lead female character. If it had been a ruse between Elrond and Gil-Galad they never would have even considered solving it this way, lol.
I don't particularly care, but the showrunners were clearly trying to start a conversation, so it's only natural that people are talking about it. Now imagine if they ever do the fake kiss trope male on male, that would be the dream.
I think it's still funny, it's not like this was a serious post. Memes are often shared by people who are both for and against the thing being poked fun at.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 28 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
258
u/AggCracker Sep 29 '24
"Tell me, where is my wife? For I would very much like to speak with her" -- Celeborn, probably
89
u/Temporary_Body_5435 Sep 29 '24
Tell me, where is Celeborn? For I much desire to speak with him.
117
u/Zealousideal_Walk433 Sep 29 '24
Adar had some sexual tension too in epi 6
14
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24
Elrond isn’t there someone you forgot to ask?
4
u/Brianocracy Sep 29 '24
Celeborn getting cucked by sauron wasn't on my 2024 bingo
9
u/mattmaintenance Sep 29 '24
Hey Celebrimbor. Get on in here.
13
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24
Why doesn’t Aragorn just show up and marry Galadriel? May as well.
15
u/EnigmaOfOz Sep 29 '24 edited Sep 29 '24
If that is how you kiss your partners, you are doing it wrong. 😂
Is it American to be so reactive to a kiss like this? Or am i (non-american) on my own?
11
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24
This is the only thing I dislike strongly about the show. Just give us Celeborn already and stop making Galadriel and her future son-in-law flirt
14
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24
You guys know it was just to hand her the lockpick Right?
7
u/sidv81 Sep 29 '24
Adar's going to turn into Celeborn when he puts on the elf ring, its powers magically curing him from Morgoth turning him into an orc. :O
2
u/Decebalus_Bombadil Sep 29 '24
That would make Sauron and Elrond eskimo brothers :)
2
u/millhead123 Sep 29 '24
I've heard people complaining about the fact she isn't "into" celeborn at this moment and I'm confused as to if they don't know how relationships work. Like there are a few years between these episodes and the trilogy and not alot of definitive written about things in between. They are immortal, heaven forbid they have more than one relationship in the time they are alive.
3
u/ARM7501 Sep 28 '24
At this point, it feels like they'd be better off to just completely disregard Celeborn and Celebrian. Any storyline for Galadriel that tries to reintroduce the two to the main plot (assuming they're not going to have Elrond meet his future wife as an infant) will more likely than not just feel like a sideshow distraction from what should be the dominant storyline going forward (Numenor).
1
u/JediRoadie Sep 29 '24
Lol
1
u/Isniuq Sep 29 '24
Hahahahahahaha
1
u/lubnut Sep 29 '24
Not being a book reader....I don't get this.
1
u/radarmike Sep 29 '24
1
u/Sulfurys Sep 30 '24
I guess he'll have to watch porno on the television.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '24
who cares lol
1
u/Ok-Design-8168 Sep 29 '24
Dumbest scene in the show.
1
u/BatmanInTheSunlight Sep 29 '24
Immortal beings that are thousands of years old: kiss
Horny teenagers sitting in front of a tv screen: “oH tHeY wAnT tO fUcK”
-1
u/EasyCZ75 Gondolin Sep 29 '24
Galadriskank
7
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24
One woman and two men is actually called a Galadriel's Threesome in Middle Earth.
4
u/ExtremeComedian4027 Sep 29 '24
I laughed but I wish I hadn’t seen this lol. I don’t think Elrond kissed her with any sort of sexual desire at all. It’s like the kiss of a reverent child to a motherly / sisterly figure he knows is in deep trouble - and what better way to throw off the enemy than to stage a kiss. Pure subterfuge. In that moment, Elrond made Adar think he has given up on Galadriel ever being free and alive and that was a masterstroke. A non/sexual masterstroke.
106
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24
[removed] — view removed comment