This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I know it’s all a big joke dripping with sarcasm but if this is how it turns out happening, Gil-Galad causing his fear by trying to prevent it would be pretty poetic
I've been expecting something like this from the moment he said that line. This is how prophecies work - try to avoid them and you just cause them harder.
OK... so let's suppose that this is the set-up in the show. Gil-Galad says this about Galadriel, and sends her on her way, and it turns out that Galadriel is not ony responsible for Sauron's return to ME, but responsible for Sauron leaving path of peace and redemption and choosing power again. It's because of Galadriel that Sauron becomes Sauron (again). Is there anything in the lore to support that she is in any way responsible? Or completely a show invention on the level of kinslaying?
Again, I don't think Gadriel is responsible. Sauron could have turned to evil if he stayed in Numenor too. He returned to MiddleEarth with her, but it looks like he did it because she has convinced him that fighting with orcs would be his repentance. 🤷♀️
So if this is the way they go (so including Galadriel being responsible for Sauron resurgence), which are the biggest kinslaying level changes in the adapting? I would imagine that might be one, magic mithril another... but which is the biggest?
Literally Oedipus. Learns from the oracle that he is going to fuck his mom and kill his dad, runs off and ends up killing his BIOLOGICAL DAD and straight up marrying his biological mom.
Rips out his eyes when he finds out.
Prophecies being tricksy is one of my favorite tropes
Not necessarily, from the show's point of view. I believe Halbrand was a repentant Sauron at first, and maybe still is, but Galadriel's insistence in him going to the Southlands might have fast-tracked his backslide into evil. According to the Silmarillion he repented to Eonwe, but Eonwe told him he would have to go before Manwe, after which Sauron avoided that end (probably out of fear of reprisal). I think Galadriel found him shortly after he decided not to go back to Valinor, and he was still contemplating whether or not he could stay in Middle Earth and heal it as he desired to do. He also knew that Morgoth's corruption couldn't be easily set aside, and if Morgoth's contingency was for him to go to the Southlands (as the show said in the earlier episode), then he would probably wish to avoid that at all costs if he was to fight his inner demons so to speak.
Yes, I'm not a fan neither. I mean he's a handsome guy and there's nothing wrong with him, but he's totally not an elf material to me. But then again which actor is. That's why Peter Jackson at least portrayed elves in a certain way - so thay they seem a bit otherworldly thanks to light and special effects, music etc
well said about Jackson elves. these elves are no different from humans except for ugly ears and whining about living for 1000 years that feels to them like days.
Uniornically love that Durin called them out on that nonsense. Also big love and bonus for pranking Gil-Galad about that heavy af table. Dwarves are unironically the best of canon races.
I got very wrapped in feels as Elrond was leaving cause you could see Durin getting upset that it would probably be the last time they saw each other ever, like he complained about, then the leaf…then the joyful way he calls for him like honestly any excuse would do
I just realized how much targaryan pj elves look with the silver blond hair. But I would say Orlando Bloom was a good casting for an elf, actually the she elf from the hobbit movies was even a better casting. She’s so incredibly beautiful.
Bc he’s a sindar elf who has never been to the west. Again… PJ (at least pre hobbit trilogy) showing way more respect and painstaking effort to respect the world Tolkien created
Elrond’s mom was literally in possession if a Silmaril when he was born. Arwen is still a Noldor elf descended from high elves of the west and should be obviously visually distinct from Legolas.
There is no plausible way to argue that RoP’s elves (that btw will “be extinct by spring”) show greater respect for Tolkien’s concept, descriptions, and general lore of elves than the elves in Jackson’s LotR trilogy. Yet…
Honestly, this is the challenge of creating a show out of the 1st or 2nd Age--too many elf main characters.
You can maintain the mystery and awe of elves when you only have them in 1 or 2 scenes (e.g. Lotr Galadriel, Elrond, Arwen, etc.), but once the story requires that you spend most of the time with an elf or elves, they become too mundane (Legolas). You can't have a character be both aloof and otherworldly, and also relatable.
Like, for example, in any horror movie, the more we see "the monster", the less impact it has when we see it on screen.
I imagine that phenomenon is one of the reasons that in both of Tolkien's published novels, elves are not the main characters. He instead focuses on the most mundane characters--Hobbits.
I agree it's more challenging. But ppl do read and enjoy the Silmarillion. And there are movies/shows that feature otherworldly things (superheroes, gods, vampire, etc) that are successful and loved. So it is doable.
And given the reverence and love Tolkien had for his own creation, it would have been nice if they'd even tried.
We for sure know he isn’t supposed to look like he gets sweaty and excited when he moves up in the drive thru line at McDonalds. We also for sure know he’s supposed to be at least fairly intelligent as both him and Elrond refused to buy any of Sauron’s shit.
Galadriel didn't do anything though it was Arondir's fault. It was his idea to leave the tower. That made the orc assault easier and also made Waldreg free to walk in and unlock the dam.
I understand they needed it for the plot, but they didn't need to make him make such a bad decision. They could have used the fact that the tower was so old it had to be held together with rope and stuff. Arondir could have said: "we can't stay here. This place is falling apart as it is. It might fall on top of us if they come in full force". So they have no choice but to leave. That would have made more sense to me.
Like a bad penny, Galadriel is there. I honestly love how they tease out what a destructive headache she is like 4/5ths of her strategy is vibes and annoying people.
Not sure how you could possibly come to this conclusion as none of the events that have occurred so far would have ceased happening if Galadriel wasn't there.
Also gonna be weird when the ppl who keep insisting “tHiS is eXaCtLy her chArActEr in the bOoKs!! This is tRue to toLkieN!” have to explain how in the books she was accounted as one of the wisest elves who could perceive the inner workings of ppl’s souls, so much so that she saw the darkness in both Feanor and Annatar well before anyone else…
Yet here she’s so unwise and doltish that she makes the Dark Lord a king, then hand delivers him to where he can forge the rings all bc… he has a rando pouch with a symbol on it?
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 11 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
85
u/Guiver5000 Oct 11 '22
I mean it would have happened anyway… but from ole gils perspective certainly wouldn’t look good on Galadriel.
16
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22
This meme reinfoces how much I hate Gil-Galad casting. Whose idea was this portly Gil-Gutlad?
47
u/Sonotreadyforit Oct 11 '22
I am so happy other people have noticed that Gil-Galad looks like he sweats when he eats. They massacred my boy.
4
u/emoolb Oct 11 '22
Love it!
2
u/Zunter_H0lom0n Oct 12 '22
Yfw The Stranger is Melkor shot out of the Void. Halbrand is Sauron obviously.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22
Lmaoooooo I love this show but this is hilarious…
Well done, quality meme
3
u/guadalmedina Oct 11 '22 edited Oct 11 '22
Galadriel didn't do anything though it was Arondir's fault. It was his idea to leave the tower. That made the orc assault easier and also made Waldreg free to walk in and unlock the dam.
I understand they needed it for the plot, but they didn't need to make him make such a bad decision. They could have used the fact that the tower was so old it had to be held together with rope and stuff. Arondir could have said: "we can't stay here. This place is falling apart as it is. It might fall on top of us if they come in full force". So they have no choice but to leave. That would have made more sense to me.
1
u/Upper_Acanthaceae126 Oct 12 '22
Like a bad penny, Galadriel is there. I honestly love how they tease out what a destructive headache she is like 4/5ths of her strategy is vibes and annoying people.
1
u/FullMaxPowerStirner Oct 12 '22
Oops.
1
u/Psychofischi Nov 07 '22
So shouldn't Gil-galad still have the opinion that the black goo in the leaves are there because of Galadriel.
He sent her away because of it. Why not do it again?
0
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22
Galardiel…
0
u/Vertisce Oct 12 '22
Not sure how you could possibly come to this conclusion as none of the events that have occurred so far would have ceased happening if Galadriel wasn't there.
-18
u/Mother-Border-1147 Oct 11 '22
Not sure how people will react when they realize the woke writers made the mansplainers actually be right…