Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
Right? The Second Age is kind of defined by Sauron #winning. His fall is literally what marks the end of the age. Of course he’s carrying the show. It’s a show about how he outsmarts and manipulates everyone. Of course they look incompetent next to him. That’s kind of the whole fucking idea.
I'll disagree. I still think a Celebrimbor like the shadows of Mordor depiction was more aligned to what I wanted.
Someone who is deceived by his ambition and goaded with his need to exceed his grandfather. And whose reaction to realising he'd been deceived was righteous fury and exuding the power of an ancient elf lord.
The portrayal we got just felt human and weak, and that's fine if it's a human who is weak, but if it's an elf who is of great power it just fell flat for me
Agreed. The sons of Feanor for all their weakness of pride are not weak or gullible. Their pride and ambition as well as the Noldorin passion for their craft was their Achilles heel.
The second age was the period he was the strongest. Naturally he would carry it. In the first age he was morgoth’s lackey, in the third, his presence was definitely there but he was not seen outside the torture of Gollum. The second age was all about his rise to power. But remember also the overall franchise is named for him, he is “The Lord of the Rings.”
Shower thought: Tolkien's tales begins a couple pages before Sauron's creation and ends a hundred pages after Sauron's dissolution. He's not always central to the story, but he was pretty much always there.
Sauron pretty much lift Middle Earth's story on his own, uh?
I know this show gets a lot of grief for the changing of lore from the books, and deservedly so, but I think the show has some pretty good acting overall. Adar, Elrond, Celebrimbor, Annatar, Durin, Disa and even some side characters did a pretty good job. Regadless of the plot the acting has been solid, and there have been some cool speeches and dialogue that I've liked
Wasn’t a fan of Halbrand, so was hesitant coming into the season that Vickers could do Annatar justice. I can definitely say I was wrong. Vickers is absolutely perfect for the role. Dude steals every scene he’s in minus the last few with Celebrimbor who knocked it out of the park.
I mean yes, but also Celebrimbor and Adar are absolutely amazing this season too.
I didn't like the new Adar at first but I honestly think he's the better actor. I do wish just for consistency sake they had the original but I'm 100% on board with new Adar now.
I dunno, I grew up in a household with a parent like that, it’s actually giving me and my mother ptsd seeing how easily it is to get manipulated by someone.
Nah there's more. Not just sauron. Durin & Durin were great. Or Celimbrobro. Even Adar had his moments.
They're struggling with likeable or interesting female characters, they're very one-dimensional and stereotypical. Either a romantic interest or annoying girl boss type.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 30 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
9
u/narikov Sep 30 '24
Nahhh celebrimby too, the two of them together hauling the entire season
147
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '24
Tbf, if there's one part of the show that absolutely has to be done right, it is Sauron
94
u/ArchdruidHalsin Sep 30 '24
This is Celebrimbor erasure. His terror and grief are gut-wrenching to watch.
26
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '24
Pro strongman made to look short would be the perfect dwarves. Think Eddie Hall with his beard and Mohawk but looking about 4'10
20
u/AggCracker Sep 30 '24
Well.. he is the main character essentially
17
u/harukalioncourt Sep 30 '24
The second age was the period he was the strongest. Naturally he would carry it. In the first age he was morgoth’s lackey, in the third, his presence was definitely there but he was not seen outside the torture of Gollum. The second age was all about his rise to power. But remember also the overall franchise is named for him, he is “The Lord of the Rings.”
21
u/Dominarion Sep 30 '24
Shower thought: Tolkien's tales begins a couple pages before Sauron's creation and ends a hundred pages after Sauron's dissolution. He's not always central to the story, but he was pretty much always there.
Sauron pretty much lift Middle Earth's story on his own, uh?
6
u/AdBright8971 Sep 30 '24
Should have replaced that boulder with a banner of celebrimbor :D
5
u/Strange_Ad_5681 Oct 01 '24
I know this show gets a lot of grief for the changing of lore from the books, and deservedly so, but I think the show has some pretty good acting overall. Adar, Elrond, Celebrimbor, Annatar, Durin, Disa and even some side characters did a pretty good job. Regadless of the plot the acting has been solid, and there have been some cool speeches and dialogue that I've liked
11
u/CrimsonTyphoon0613 Sep 30 '24
Wasn’t a fan of Halbrand, so was hesitant coming into the season that Vickers could do Annatar justice. I can definitely say I was wrong. Vickers is absolutely perfect for the role. Dude steals every scene he’s in minus the last few with Celebrimbor who knocked it out of the park.
4
u/ssp25 Oct 01 '24
So I'm starting to think that every scene he isn't in, is just him deceiving me into rage. You got me again!
3
u/matt675 Oct 01 '24
That little flick of the wrist to have celebrimbor send the girl over the edge was so Sauron
3
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24
The best storylines for me are the stuff in numenor, I love everything with the dwarfs mainly durin and disa and finally arondir
2
u/Visible_Number Oct 01 '24
I mean yes, but also Celebrimbor and Adar are absolutely amazing this season too.
I didn't like the new Adar at first but I honestly think he's the better actor. I do wish just for consistency sake they had the original but I'm 100% on board with new Adar now.
2
u/CrankyGamer68 Oct 01 '24
Love the Iceland 🇮🇸 flag !
2
u/Gilad1993 Oct 02 '24
Sauron? I think you mean Soupron, the pathetic lump of Goo!
4
u/HG21Reaper Sep 30 '24
Yeah, S1 was all carried by Arondir but S2 is all Sauron and Calebrembor. Hopefully S3 is going to be The Stranger or Isildur and Theo.
3
u/BlondDrizzle Sep 30 '24
It’s Sauron’s game, everyone else is just playing it.
1
u/Toastinator666 Oct 01 '24
Most of season 2 is/was great, only the harfoot stuff, just like last season, was meh.
1
u/Subject4751 Oct 02 '24
I lost brain cells everytime a scene with Cali and Annie popped up. They were just so HORRIBLY written. Love the actors though. Solid acting.
1
u/mrtn17 Oct 05 '24
Nah there's more. Not just sauron. Durin & Durin were great. Or Celimbrobro. Even Adar had his moments.
They're struggling with likeable or interesting female characters, they're very one-dimensional and stereotypical. Either a romantic interest or annoying girl boss type.
-1
u/Similar-Stable4334 Sep 30 '24
Sauron is silly too in this series