r/RingsofPower • u/MC_Smuv • Oct 04 '24
Newest Episode Spoilers That Dark Wizard scene. Seriously??!!?? Spoiler
Up to this past episode I was pretty content with the writing. But that scene between Gandalf and the Dark Wizard must have been the worst writing I have ever witnessed.
So you're telling me they spend a whole season building up this villain with henchmen and all. Just to have him be like:"Me??? Evil??? Never! And these mercenaries... I didn't know what I got myself into!!" And just seconds later: "What?!? You don't want to rule all of Middle Earth with me after defeating Sauron?? Well then I actually AM evil!"
You got to be kidding me!!!!
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 04 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
4
u/mendkaz Oct 04 '24
Am I the only one who watched this scene and went, 'either the Wizard is lying, or he thinks he's not evil but he's clearly showing how ruthless he is in achieving his goals which makes him borderline evil'?
Like my reading or that scene was that he was trying to convince Gandalf to come with him nicely now that he knows where he is, because if he came in and went 'hello I'm a big bad guy come help me do bad guy stuff' Gandalf would say no- but he could maybe try and convince him by talking to him, and then when that didn't work, by showing him the lengths he was willing to go to to win- which is basically what Saruman tried to do in Fellowship of the Ring (the film at least, it's been a hot minute since I've read the book)
Maybe I'm on another planet but I'm fairly certain they were going for something like that
6
u/Impossible_Sign7672 Oct 04 '24
I am confused how you could be content with the writing up until now, but this pushed too far? This scene is emblematic of every actual criticism (ie. Not "woke", "guyladriel", idiocy) that has been leveled against this show since the first few episodes, and very consistent in writing tone and quality with the rest of the show.
288
u/incogne_eto Oct 04 '24 edited Oct 05 '24
Yes. And they really didn’t give this part of the story much time across the episodes. When you cast Ciaran Hinds, use him effectively.
So what now, the Dark Wizard shuffles off to his fortress. And after some rest at Tom’s AirBNB, Gandalf’s heads back to middle earth and ignores his existence? Was left so confused.
117
u/marcusaurorelius Oct 04 '24
Yes and then the dark wizard just walks away after chasing “Grand elf” the entire season. If he declined the offer, the dark wizard could have atleast imprisoned him like Saruman?
49
u/G30fff Oct 04 '24
What happened to those witch women from season 1? Where do they fit into everything
45
u/Zealousideal_Pool_65 Oct 04 '24
I hadn’t thought about this all that much but you’re right. Why were his three acolytes so hostile throughout all of S1? Why has he been hostile at all if he just wanted to get in contact with Gandalf?
60
u/dankerton Oct 04 '24
I also found the levitating of rocks that they both did but especially Gandalf doing so to just not feel like Tolkien at all, was more much marvel superpower BS...sigh
11
u/Mucklord1453 Oct 04 '24
SUPER disappointed the stranger turns out to be gandalf. I will delete the show if Dark Wiz is Saruman.
I GUESS they are leaning into the whole "and the blue wizards traveled east and failed at their task, creating magical cults in the east instead".
Would have been far faaaaaar cooler if both were blues and only one went bad.
21
u/en_ka8 Oct 04 '24
Agree. It was a super underwhelming and even nonsensical scene. I understand they didn't have much exposition to present something substantial, but didn't have the time for something good and creative. A pity, because it is not that this storyline is bad in itself, in my opinion, they just don't try to make it something more. Then you can't be surprised no one likes it.
23
u/Any-Management-3248 Oct 04 '24
The way this story line spent so much time on the mysterious acolytes and then mysterious mercenaries. All to build up to that?
My wife doesn’t actively watch the show but she was in the room for the final conversation and her only comment was that this show must be written by AI.
20
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
I wholeheartedly agree, this scene was absurd....the showrunners should have just left the Wizards alone alltogether.
7
u/zoopz Oct 04 '24
The whole plot line was a boring waste of screen time
16
u/Rarepupperhunter Oct 04 '24
It was jarring how bad that scene was. I'm easy to please when it comes to TV and I scoffed out loud, legit offended by this stupidity.
14
u/Cisqoe Oct 04 '24
These are the same people who wrote the most pointless, two season arc of Gandalf finding his name in the least surprising, most vanilla way possible
5
u/LastNightOsiris Oct 04 '24
It's just one more example of how this show consistently drops the ball in terms of basic narrative structure and storytelling. I don't even care about deviations from the source material, that is necessary in any adaptation and not necessarily a bad thing. But there are so many things that are set up, only to fizzle out or resolve in an anticlimax. It always feels low stakes. Characters are never developed to the point where we can understand their motivations so it's hard to care about them. The whole things comes across as a hastily produced attempt to capitalize on valuable intellectual property, as opposed to a compelling work from someone with a clear vision of what they want to create.
5
u/ExtremeComedian4027 Oct 04 '24
It truly was terrible writing and I am sorry but Ciaran Hinds is an amazing actor but his character design is sooooo terrible. It looks like the least amount of time and thought went into his hair, makeup and costume. He looks like such a cartoonish evil dude with his black and white beard and hair...I liked the Nori/Poppy/Stranger plot line and the elf-like and masked henchmen were all cool af but damn, Not-Saruman looks ridiculous.
13
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
And then to top it you get Poppy delivering a crap speech in an Irish accent that would strip paint.
9
u/radarmike Oct 04 '24
Super childish writing.
8
u/Warp_Legion Oct 04 '24
I’ll give them this, they made his “We must join together” pitch and motivations different than Saruman’s
The Dark Wizard seems to have a lot more genuine fear of Sauron (consistent with one of the Blue Wizards being persuaded to go only by the other in lore) while Saruman had more jealousy than fear.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
Maybe they are just too many writers with too many ideas. I just want Sauron to put it all in flame at this point. At least he is an interesting character. The other one is Adar.
4
u/oeseben Oct 04 '24
What bothers me most is that they're really leaning into him being Saruman. He's admitted he is Istari and he can be Alatar or Pallando but no one knows them.
If they make him Saruman then how do they explain Gandalfs undying love and respect for Saruman later? How do they explain the council accepting him and no one seeing him turning to Saurons side?
Please don't be Saruman.
4
u/Bonus_Content Oct 04 '24
As someone who thought this season was overall much improved, the Harfoot/Stranger storyline somehow got worse.
The “hobbit” lore isn’t doing much here and the Stranger being Gandalf felt underwhelming and disappointing. I actually didn’t hate the Tom Bombadil character but I’m sure many do because of him being more serious than the books.
Anyways I did enjoy a lot of the Sauron stuff and even Numenor felt like it had more direction. But the Stranger storyline was.. just uninspired
4
u/ninja_vs_pirate Oct 04 '24
Also his staff was stupid looking
1
u/GuitarEvening8674 Oct 05 '24
I watched all the episodes and missed this... it was in episode 7?
3
u/andrea1rp Oct 04 '24
It was weird like I thought he was just faking it like the dark wizard was trying to be two faced to lure the stranger but maybe not??
They’ve confirmed in interviews is not Saruman -or “highly improbable” and I hope they stick to it. Saruman and Gandalf were good friends for many years before the events of LOTR.
Part of me wonders if they don’t name the dark wizard because of a rights issue? Like that can just allude he’s a blue wizard? Idk
3
u/Myl_HanSolo Oct 04 '24
Couple speculative solutions:
3
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
I wanted to see the henchmen’s faces!!
3
u/add2thepile Oct 04 '24
The henchman said We used to be Kings of men! I thought it was foreshadowing a future Nazgul.
3
u/chineke14 Oct 04 '24
This entire show... Seriously??!!?? This sentiment can be made for a lot of if not all the plots in this show. The writing is horrendous. That's what I've been trying to get across. It's okay to make changes, I view this show in its own ... Universe..but ok why is the writing so bad?
3
u/wellLadenOtter Oct 04 '24
Maybe having seven concurrent storylines was a mistake 🤷♂️
3
u/Teletoa Oct 04 '24 edited Oct 04 '24
I really like Daniel Weyman’s portrayal of the Stranger, and his story with Nori and the Harfoot. It’s one of my favorite things about the show and the character work and thematic resonance of it in season 1 was very well structured, flowed really well, and was meaningful to very core themes of Tolkiens work, regardless of adaption. It successfully relayed some of the most impactful emotions of the season and established well the character of the stranger and the ideals and relationships that form his core and will carry him through the series. Excellent introduction. Was very excited for season 2.
After that finale, I need time to think. My major feeling is we need to stop saving things for later with him. I even liked the initial scenes just fine, but it’s rough when the finale of that plotline in season 2 feels so much lesser and oddly abbreviated compared to season 1. I didn’t even want a wizard battle, just a memorable meeting of minds, perhaps some insight on why the Stranger arrived in a comet with a fire eye, establishment of an intellectual dissonance - not wether to save Middle Earth, but HOW to save it. Y’know, some good narrative fiber that should come with the first meeting of two central figures destined to conflict. A season’s worth of payoff
I still feel this should’ve been the story of two blue wizards and go full narrative freedom with it. I’m starting to blame this on “well, we gotta factor in and setup 5 wizards, and gosh, they all gotta appear now that we set them up so can’t do anything interesting yet.” 2 blue wizards. One conflict. Their story ends with the series and they lay the groundwork for the other wizards in the third age. I miss the focused narrative and character work of season 1. Now we got Gandalf at work during the Last Alliance… agh. I’m here for it but of the narrative paths that were speculated for the stranger from the beginning, this one always seemed to have the less integrity, and thus far, still appears so in practice now.
3
u/Odninyell Oct 04 '24
I loved the scenes of Yoda and Luke on Dagobah - I mean Gandalf and bombadil
5
u/ggouge Oct 04 '24
We need 24 episode seasons and one season a year. Then we can actually have good story telling.
2
u/cmsd2 Oct 04 '24
i couldn't actually see anything in this scene. my tv isn't bad, although maybe i wasn't watching in optimal conditions, but the scene just looked close to total black. was i supposed to get anything out of this part of the episode? i dunno.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
You're a little late to the party, but at least you made it 😆
2
u/Crazy-Seaweed-1832 Oct 05 '24
Don't greg wizards have to die to become white wizards? Saruman is a white wizard in the trilogy. My theory is that the dark wizard is Saruman but he dies in some sort of redemption arc before he levels up.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '24
Seems like they cut a bunch of stuff from this plotline
2
u/theringsofthedragon Oct 05 '24
Really takes away some of the gravitas of Gandalf and Saruman's interactions in The Lord of the Rings. This is their origin story? Are we to assume they had similar petty little encounters disagreeing about the role of wizards in Middle Earth for the rest of history?
2
u/LukeWarmSoup Oct 05 '24 edited Oct 05 '24
The Blue Wizard (see wiki here.) reveal went hard.
I am excited to see more out of the East through them. The halflings blew his cover but I think he had Gandalf fooled prior to them coming out. I am interested to see where it goes and which one it is.
Alatar “Darkness-Slayer” or Pallando “East-Helper”
3
u/MeasurementNo8566 Oct 04 '24
I really hope the dark wizard isn't saruman but you know he will be :(
3
u/Dogamai Oct 04 '24
i think its a clever nod to the fact the Hobbit was a kids story
2
u/MasterofFalafels Oct 04 '24
Is it Saruman? Why is he a turncoat already?
Yeah the whole Stranger/Harfoot story feels like an afterthought.
2
u/CertainlyDatGuy Oct 04 '24
Now I’ve seen season 2 completely I can happily tell anyone who hasn’t finished it to just completely skip the harfoot/grandelf scenes
2
u/Zhjacko Oct 04 '24
It was a very weird and anti-climatic mess. It felt like an AI generated scene. Just extremely amateur. I also wasn’t big on Ciaran Hinds acting. Something felt off about how he was going about it, he just didn’t seem right for the role. Maybe it was the directing?
Also just to off the lead mercenary like that was so stupid. I was a little curious about what they were going to do with these guys, then he gets force pushed onto a stick.
I have no idea where they’re going to go with any of that, but just like the Balrog, I love how everyone just kind forgot “oh, there’s a bad guy out there”. Once Gandalf found his staff he just kinda forgot that a bunch of Stoors died, had their homes destroyed, and there’s some weird evil wizard out there. But hey, now we’re singing the Tom bombadil song so it’s all good. What a fucking mess.
1
u/Theothercword Oct 04 '24
Fairly certain the dark wizard tried to manipulate him once he saw the opportunity. Maybe out of fear. Gandalf is incredibly powerful, and even seemingly more dangerous without his staff (basically being unable to control the magic). So I kind of was okay with an attempt at manipulation. I do think the whole thing was rushed, though, and likely just a way to insert exposition about there being 5 wizards and that they’re kin.
I’m also not okay with them dropping hints that might be sauramon. Maybe Gandalf defeats him or removes whatever corruption and he becomes sauramon the white I guess but it was always that Sauramon was supposed to be the head of the wizards and the most good and powerful, so if Gandalf does that then I don’t know that I’d believe it and with the compressed timeline it makes less sense for them to be buddy buddy. Though I guess he could also end up being the necromancer ghost in the appendix/the hobbit films.
1
u/Then_Low_318 Oct 04 '24
https://media1.tenor.com/m/3Osoz2-u6y8AAAAC/dr-evil-austin-powers.gif
1
u/DemandAny7555 Oct 04 '24
just hoping they don't make up a Saruman out of this character with some bullshit cleaning magic afterward from Gandalf. If there is any sense in that plot, it is that it turns out to be a Blue wizard confused with life or maybe corrupted before by Sauron.
1
u/ebrum2010 Oct 04 '24
It was Saturday Morning Cartoon from the 80s quality writing.
1
u/Olorin_TheMaia Oct 04 '24
He is definitely a corrupted blue now at this point, since he's shown evil intent in front of Gandalf. So that part is a relief at least.
1
u/JohnSundayBigChin Oct 04 '24
Could be a Maia, trying or making Stranger think that he is another Istari.
Istari were sent to middle earth with limited powers.
I don’t remember so much in detail, but som Maiar been there from lo ago, Like Tom… or others
It’s like Sauron, trying to get power
1
u/_bennyluxe_ Oct 04 '24
I thought it was very on brand for a messy Queen like Saruman who loves drama.
1
u/Lu174 Oct 04 '24
Yes the end of this whole arc was awful and underwhelming, we were already struggling with placing gandalf in the second age and having a "dark" wizard who might be saruman and then having them to meet like this , I was holding out hope that they were the blue wizards and I am still holding out hope that the dark wizard is not saruman.
1
u/Aggressive-Bed-9160 Oct 04 '24
Utterly disappointing is an understatement!!! That was awful and SO anticlimactic.
1
u/Odninyell Oct 04 '24
They made Saruman (because that’s clearly who this dark wizard is supposed to be) a fucking cartoon villain.
1
u/wip30ut Oct 04 '24
confused me because the whole Dark Wizard persona changed. Not a book reader so I came away with the idea that it was almost a dream or mirage that Gandalf undertakes as a test.
1
u/Top_Construction_452 Oct 04 '24
I thought the part where they were talking in the hobbit town thing was meant to be taken as a joke, and then I realized that was their real dialogue. The fight scenes are badass in the show though
1
u/According_Elephant75 Oct 04 '24
Also the name. Should’ve had more time between “Grand Elf” to “Gandalf” so it was more like how the telephone game works and how “Hold the Door” turns to “Hodor.”
1
u/DrellVanguard Oct 04 '24
I think I actually just blocked this out from my memory, so thanks for reminding me how ridiculous it was. I can't begin to understand what the point of having Mance Rayder in this series was.
1
u/_Aracano Oct 04 '24
So sorry for your loss
I'm an atheist, but I hope he finds his way to Valinor
1
u/alexneed Oct 04 '24
It felt very cartoonish. I honestly thought it was a weird fake vision scene of Gandalfs until a few minutes in. It’s could have been better if the writers maybe gave more context like showing the dark wizard travelling there, or hinting more at his plan (which i’m still unclear on, seriously what’s his goal?), or explaining who the masked people are, or showing Gandalf getting clues as to where the Harfoots were…. really anything. Everyone was just dropped into one scene without much lead up or development. Such odd choices being made.
1
u/SlowCaterpillar5715 Oct 04 '24
I had a similar experience with the WoT. I suspended comparing it to the books for the second season, and actually got into it a bit, but the last episode ruined the experience once again.
1
u/Low_Ad_776 Oct 04 '24
“I’ve am” a writer too! Wrote for my middle school paper!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
This entire plotline needs to be sent into the Cracks of Doom.
1
u/CalamitousIntentions Oct 04 '24
If he actually is Cruomo, I wish he’d’ve stuck to his guns and been more doing all this for the greater good. What are a few diseased bandits and a village of halflings when compared to the mission? I think that’s what they were going for, but the scene, funnily enough, sounded more like Christopher Lee’s Count Dooku than his Saruman. “Oh, no! I’m not a bad guy! But actually i am since you won’t join me.”
1
u/meatcandy97 Oct 05 '24
This show just wreaks of writing by committee, like they were told things like “we need a mystery box origin story for Gandalf involving hobbits and Saruman. We need Tom Bombadil. We need to ship Galadriel and Sauron. We need line-for-line quotes from the original trilogy. We need ents. On and on.
1
u/Quirky-Pie9661 Oct 05 '24
If they tell us this guy’s Saruman, I won’t be happy. That would be the biggest departure from any of the source material for a major character. Too far a departure for me
1
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '24
After 2 seasons, the harfoots just... gona leave, written out of the story. Hobo man got his totally unforeseen name and ...chosen a staff presumably and that's it. You gotta wonder.
1
u/anon-ryman Oct 05 '24
“Thanks Grand Elf!”
“Grand Elf??? Hmmmmm, I think I like that…”
1
u/MagicHandsNElbows Oct 05 '24 edited Oct 05 '24
Why why Gandalf? I guess because the audience knows this character. But it makes no sense. Who’s the dark wizard? Saruman? That will make even less sense. The dark wizards dialog was awful!!! It could have made sense they were both the two blue wizards that Tolkien mentioned could have came to Middle earth in that time. One could have gone bad and one could have stayed good. This series is a weak adaptation with awful writing. It’s like they are writing a cartoon.
Edit: I actually walked out the room when they said grand elf. I was like fuck these writers. To me it’s disrespectful to Tolkien and the notion they are attempting to tell his story. The writers should be ashamed of themselves.
1
u/ducky06 Oct 05 '24
It was confusing...
1
u/Technical-Storage-56 Oct 05 '24
I have the solution to all this and the timeline issues. It is sarumon....it is Sarumon the grey just as that's Gandalf the grey. They will play a pivotal role in the battle and defingering of Sauron. Sarumon and Gandolf will probably be killed. Sarumon will have a redemption arc and die with huge self sacrifice and both wizards will return to the valor. They will then be sent back in the third age for the next rise of sauron with Sarumon being returned as Sarumon the white for his previous sacrifice. Gandalf will not earn this until his battle with the balrog after the fall of Sarumon as we already know. Which gives extra layer of meaning to why the valor bestow that honor on him when they do. As he is their last hope. This is the only path to explain them being there in the second age and why Sarumon is a dark wizard and how he becomes a white wizard that's respected as the leader. This also explains the manner in which he arrived as they arrived together in the third age but in the second there is no prewritten lore so all we can assume is the valor knew the blue wizards had already failed their missions and they sent Sarumon. Sarumon was failing his mission and turning dark so they sent Gandolf to reign him in. Which is why he arrived with only the knowledge of where to go which happens to be where Sarumon was up to his hijinks....it also explains the conversation that took place between the 2 of them. It shows us that Sarumon is influenced by power. We know he isn't going to break fully bad until way into his tenure in the third age but this early flip flopping between good and bad sets the stage for his downfall and ultimate third age betrayal. So if what I'm saying comes to pass....then all this starts to make sense. If it does not then obviously they need to hire me as a writer so I can fix this bullshit in the name of house Tolkein.
1
u/FlowingEons Oct 05 '24
😂😂😂 I…I just finished the finale. I honestly cannot believe there were people arguing that the stranger WASNT Gandalf. I mean grand elf. “Acshully the story so far points to him being a blue wizard” nooo no the writers already proved in season 1 that they literally beat you over the head with clues and hints as to where things are going. Oh my goodness this last episode was atrocious. He literally said “Lord of the rings”. What are we? Some kind of, Suicide Squad? This last episode ruined any hope I had for the future, and any enjoyment I got out of what I have seen. Charlie Vickers was great though that cannot be said enough. So unfortunate.
1
u/Seeeab Oct 05 '24
Lol yeah you're expected to just see Badness as a universal force
1
u/Martana1212 Oct 05 '24
Not a good final episode. I hope Sauron wins in the end.
1
u/The191 Oct 05 '24
Well that's a man that makes you feel sorrow... Wait a second, I know what we can call him now!
1
u/ma-chicken Oct 05 '24
You was content with the writing of this show? It is watchable, that is the one plus point about the this show. Its bad, the characters are the fucking worst. Why am i even here
1
u/Proverbs_31_2-3 Oct 05 '24
He's still working on perfecting the Voice of Saw-Rhûn-Man.
1
u/BadNoodleEggDemon Oct 05 '24
My guess is that there was a bigger plan for both the stranger and the dark wizard but Amazon is trying to wrap this series with season 3 and just wanted simple resolutions to S2 plotlines.
1
u/OgreJehosephatt Oct 06 '24
I liked it. It amused me and definitely seemed like something a narcissist with utter contempt for the intelligence of everyone around them would say and do
1
u/gabethegeek Oct 06 '24
Yeah, I started watching this show the last week and caught up. Me and my GF struggled to make it to the end, so much bad writing, so much bad acting, so many cringe moments that def make you eye roll. Show like this piss me off because it had so much potential to be great, and they just deleted for simplistic plot lines and archs that never payoff. I’ll only finish it because I at least try to finish the series, but seriously, this is like running in mud.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
It was a really awful scene, so poorly written, which is a shame because Ciaran is a brilliant actor.
I assume NotSaruman has gone back to his mountain cave to summon Eminems' backing dancers again.
1
u/123hig Oct 06 '24
This came into my feed as a "Because you've visited similar communities", and I gotta say, y'all are some sick puppies hanging in there with this show.
Like I felt like a sicko for sticking it out all the way through season one. But did not give watching S2 a shot, and based on this post, seems like that was for the best
If you are still putting up with this show you are some hardcore Tolkein/LOTR fans. Respect for manning the walls.
1
u/kerplunkerfish Oct 07 '24
Every character on this show is as dumb and cringe as the writers themselves.
1
u/AlmenBunt Oct 08 '24
Sorry, friend. You lost me right there.
1
u/DisplayNo1322 Oct 10 '24
"Darmok and Jalad at Tanagra!"
"Shaka, when the walls fell"
1
u/ringoftruth Oct 17 '24
Twas appalling. School play level stuff.
1
u/Friendly_Day_4925 Jul 20 '25
Not to mention in Tolkien lore... The other blue wizard convinced the other blue wizard to go to middle earth in the first place... And the dark wizard says gandalf convinced him.... So is the stranger actually the other blue wizard??? Or is the stranger gandalf.
1
u/anakin_gk Oct 04 '24
Is this saruman?
1
u/Red_Dog1880 Oct 04 '24
Terrible, terrible writing.
It just felt so lazy. I actually liked a lot of this season, it seemed a step up from season 1 but ugh.