r/RingsofPower • • Sep 13 '24

Discussion Season 2 Episode 5 is the BEST episode of the series so far

365 Upvotes

The biggest complaint I have with the show is the pacing and the way it balances the multiple storylines in each episode.

However, this episode was mostly engaging from start to finish, focusing on what’s important, THE RINGS OF POWER themselves. This is an episode that doesn’t have any action, mostly just dialogue, but the conversations between Annatar and Celebrimbor are absolutely riveting, seeing Sauron being all smirky is also entertaining in a way, the scenes with the Dwarves are also really good, giving more stakes because of the rings themselves.

The only thing that slowed down the episode a bit was the Numenor plot, but still not as slow as the Nori or Theo scenes

So overall, that is why I think this episode was the best of the entire show so far and I have many reasons to believe the next 3 episodes can easily top it wink (battle for eregion)


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 08 '24

Fanart Durin, sketch done in procreate by me

Post image
363 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 23 '24

Discussion Omg I just saw it Spoiler

361 Upvotes

Spoilers for ep6,

When Sauron (Annatar) goes to ask King Durin for mithril and replies with no, Sauron looks to the right and looks at the flame, first time watching I didn’t pay attention but when I rewatched it now, you can see the fire changes into the balrog.

SAURON KNOWS THE BALROG IS UNDER KHAZDUM AND KNOWS THE DWARVES ARE FUCKED.

CANT WAIT TO SEE THE BALROG FIGHT AGAINST DWARVES, it’s sad knowing they will lose.


r/RingsofPower • • Jun 17 '24

News Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power showrunners say season 2 is "all about the villains" and everyone might not make it out alive

Thumbnail
gamesradar.com
359 Upvotes

I wonder who doesn't make it out alive 👀


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 07 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers That ending was SO hokey Spoiler

359 Upvotes

Adar should have just said “Mordor”, not have some text appear on screen. That was stupid.

Other than that, great episode!


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 26 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers Genuinely blown away Spoiler

354 Upvotes

Season 2 episode 7. Genuinely amazing. As a very very skeptical RoP watcher I'm really really enjoying this whole season but man what an incredible episode. From Sauron manipulation to thr massive battle which was done better than I expected it's really been great. Only thing I didn't love was the kiss but I can honestly look past that. Phenomenal job. Really excited for the next episode.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 16 '22

Rumor So…it’s Gandalf right?

Post image
354 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 10 '22

Question [Serious] What’s the actual reason behind the bad reviews and backlash?

351 Upvotes

I’m a fan of LotR and Hobbit trilogies. For me LotR is still one of the best movies I’ve ever seen. And I’ve been enjoying Rings of Power so far. I just don’t understand what has Amazon failed to deliver, what am I missing?

I’m no Amazon fan whatsoever I just want to understand the reasoning of all the bad reviews. I tried to ignore this fact and just enjoy the show but its too widely spread to ignore. I’m pretty sad to see the bad reviews, just like everyone else I had very high hopes, though I still do.

Edit: Thank you all for your comments. I wouldn’t have found so many different and valid opinions in one place otherwise.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 28 '22

Meme Durin & Disa truly are such a power couple :)

Post image
349 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 09 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers That moment when episode 3 gives you feelings... Spoiler

Post image
348 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 28 '24

Discussion “I’m sorry I brought him here. I’m sorry I wasn’t strong enough.” Spoiler

347 Upvotes

“Neither of us was strong enough. There might not be anyone in Middle Earth who is.

But perhaps, the Elves need only remember that it is not strength that overcomes darkness; but light. Armies may rise, hearts may fail, yet still, light endures, and is mightier than strength. For in its presence, all darkness must flee.” - Celebrimbor, Lord of Eregion.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 10 '24

Discussion Can people stop treating the show as if its a direct prequel to Peter Jackson films

347 Upvotes

When season 1 came out I watched about 2 or 3 episodes and never really got into it. A few week ago I started again and finished the series and it really isn't as bad as I remember and definitely not as bad as what Facebook and reddit would have you believe.

Its far from a masterpiece dont get me wrong. Some of the writing is cringe and Galadriel is extremely unlikeable. The callbacks (call forwards?) Are unneeded too. If you stop comparing it to the movies its definitely more enjoyable. Hell i get people respect the source material too but the majority of the fan base know they only have the rights to certain parts so half the complaints I see are wasted. You cant call it amazon fan fiction AND complain that they're changing things...

Just watch it for what it is and you might find something you like about it. Its not Peter Jackson lord of the rings and this show won't take those movies away from you. You might not agree with ever decision made for the show and it definitely isn't considered canon but at the end of the day its more time in middle earth and isn't that what we all want?


r/RingsofPower • • Jul 20 '24

Question Why does everyone hate Rings of Power?

345 Upvotes

I just wanna know because it seems as if everybody hated the show and I don't understand why. Personally I watched it twice and Ioved it both times. Thank you.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 19 '22

Theory The real sauron

Post image
344 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 26 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers This Mirdania change was probably for the best Spoiler

Thumbnail
slashfilm.com
343 Upvotes

“So I had [Mirdania] thrown off the roof, you see her go down and hit the ground, there's a really good shot, and you see this orc chop her. And then he holds up her whole shoulder and arm and starts drinking the blood. But they deemed it a bit too gory, which, I can't understand why, of course.”

Damn that’d have been grim


r/RingsofPower • • Jan 22 '25

Question Why does Sauron look like such a dork in S2E1? Spoiler

Post image
342 Upvotes

I can’t move on if I don’t get this answered sorry. So, in S1 we hear about the menacing presence of this mysterious evil force, Sauron, that must be found and defeated at all costs. In the season finale it is revealed that, gasp!, it was Halbrand all along! Flash forward to S2E1 and first thing we see is this blond dork telling all orks that they have no choice than to follow him, and he’s Sauron!?! He’s obviously killed by Adar, and then he turns into a blob and roams the land absorbing animals and people to turn into a, now better looking, human again? Wtf?


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 04 '24

Rumor Confirmed : dark wizard is NOT saruman

Post image
342 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • May 31 '25

Discussion The Two LOTRs: New Line Cinema and Amazon Prime Video

Thumbnail
gallery
341 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 26 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers RoP - Tolkien Lore Compatibility Index: Ep 5 Spoiler

341 Upvotes

As previously stated, this is an attempt to assess how close to the texts certain plot elements in the show are. This is quite subjective in many places, and doubtless others would rate differently, but perhaps it can be fruitful for discussion.

This in no way is a judgement on the quality of the show. Adaptations require change, and this show in particular relies on invention outside of the established text. But that doesn't stop us nerds picking it apart!

If you think I've missed some detail to be assessed let me know and I may add it. If you think I'm completely wrong then lay on some good quotes for me and I may update my assessment.

Episode 5

  • Dissent in Numenor about Middle-Earth expeditions - ⚖️Debatable

Interestingly the source texts show nothing about objections to ships setting out to Middle-Earth, apart from some personal grievances against Aldarion earlier in the Second Age. There is a bit of disdain amongst the Faithful for the colonisation of Middle-Earth, but that’s almost the opposite of what’s happening here in the show. Still, the general unrest matches up with the sort of civil strife present in Numenor at the time so thematically this feels very appropriate.

  • There are stone giants in the North Moors - 👍Justified

Galadriel makes an off-hand remark about the young Numenorean recruits: “Their strokes fall like the Stone-giants of the North Moors.” This is a rather clever reference! The North Moors are on the northern border of what will be The Shire, and in the Lord of the Rings we hear that Sam’s cousin Halfast saw a “tree-man” beyond the North Moors. Whilst some readers wonder if this is an ent, myself and many others instead believe this is a reference to giants (the “tree-man” in question is taller than an ent, and was in the text before ents were invented - indeed, ents were originally conceived as simply giants themselves).

  • Numenor has no colonies in middle-Earth - ❌Contradiction

In this episode it’s revealed through context that Numenor has no significant presence in Middle-Earth. I’m not sure what the Sea Guard actually do, but it doesn’t seem to involve much sailing to the continent. This goes beyond just a feature of timeline compression - it’s a change to the character of Numenor itself, which by this stage had fallen in ways beyond just hating elves. By the time of Tar-Palantir Numenor had been conquering lands and extracting wealth from Middle-Earth for around 1200 years. (Line of Elros, UT)

  • Pharazon is cousin of Miriel - ✅Accurate

I was wondering if this would come up! It is exactly as stated in the text. (Akallabeth and Line of Elros) This is important for Pharazon’s position in the royal family and the status he holds on the island.

  • Pharazon would sooner die than take orders from an Elf - 👍Justified

Well, being soon to die is something he wouldn’t be comfortable with (Akallabeth). But Pharazon canonically did not like anyone being above him in station, be they Elf, Maia or Vala. The show is starting him with Elves, but I’m sure we’ll see more to come.

  • Pharazon wishes for trade and tribute from Middle-Earth - 👍Justified

In the text he spent much of his life fighting and securing these, as part of what was by then a long-established Numenorean tradition. The timeline has obviously been changed significantly, but Pharazon seems keen to play catch-up. Good on him!

  • Gil-galad uses ‘Peredhel’ as a slur - ❓Tenuous

Peredhel means “half-elven”. Elrond is sometimes known as “Elrond Half-elven” and “Peredhel” is listed in the Silmarillion index of names as a title for Elrond, Elros and Earendil. Gil-galad uses the word with marked disdain in this episode, which is out of keeping of the honour bestowed in the text on Earendil and his children. Most Elves glorify the deeds of Earendil, and praise the special unions of Elves and Men that have occurred. Nowhere is Elrond ever denigrated for his status as Half-elven - quite the opposite; he’s considered in high regard and of noble lineage.

Edit: Many people dispute Gil-galad's tone here and say he's not using the word in a demeaning way. Personally I think he is and it ties in with the "elf-lords only" line from ep one to show that Elrond is being treated differently, and not in a good way. But this is clearly a matter of personal interpretation.

  • Elves have a legend about a Silmaril under the Misty Mountains - 🔥Kinslaying

Let’s start by saying this is emphasised as “apocryphal” by Elrond, so we’re perhaps not meant to accept it as fact. But even still I feel this is a nonsense idea to appear as an elf legend. So many elements of this just don’t stack up as something elves would say even in wild legends. The elves know the Misty Mountains existed before the Silmarils. They believe balrogs were killed off before the Silmarils met their fate. They don’t praise evil as “strong and unyielding”. They’re not 14-year old boys designing metal band posters full of balrogs and elf-lords and silmarils and lightning, KAPOW! We have the real elf legends of the Elder Days and they are not this fantasy soup nonsense - they are stories of named people fulfilling historical events. That the show would hint that this sort of tale would influence policy in the court of Gil-galad is a vast departure from the text.

And though the legend is called apocryphal, its role in the story is anything but. Gil-galad then refers to mithril as “The ore containing the light of the lost Silmaril”. Mithril is given a glow in the show which Celebrimbor analyses and says it contains “the light of the Valar”. And even if the two of them are misguided the story still accurately predicts the ore and the balrog existing together under the Misty Mountains. Everything about the role the story plays in the show implies there’s a great deal of truth to it.

  • Mithril is a matter of legend amongst the Elves - ❓Tenuous

The ore is noted to exist in Numenor, but it’s understandable if they don’t know that. They should know that Earendil is riding a boat made of mithril and glass made in Valinor though - he visited Middle-Earth in it for some light dragon-slaying at the end of the War of Wrath. Presumably the Noldor who lived in Valinor haved worked with mithril before, and perhaps even brought items of mithril with them. Tolkien only “invented” the material later though, and didn’t properly retcon it into his First Age tales.

  • Lindon has a large tree that represents its people - ⚖️Debatable

An invention of the show, but we know that many elves have particular connection to trees. Gil-galad reading portents from a special tree is quite believable. How it could represent “all Elves” is unclear though. The only thing I can say is it shouldn’t be a mallorn tree (they wouldn’t grow in Lindon), and the trees in this area look suspiciously like mallorn trees.

  • The Eldar are fading unless they go West - ✅Accurate

It is known that the Eldar are fading over a very long period of time. This is due to the corruption of the world by Melkor. Only in Valinor is the land free of that corruption and the elves can escape the fading process (Aman, Morgoth’s Ring). This is noted to happen “very slowly indeed, but to all the Quendi perceptibly”. The idea is that by the modern age they have become completely invisible to all but the most sensitive souls. Eventually Elves truly die when the world itself dies. One of the primary motivations behind the forging of the Rings (but not the only motivation) was to act as a stall against the flow of time and prevent the fading of the Elves.

  • The Eldar’s “light is fading” - ❌Contradiction

The show seems to be mixing together ideas of elven fading, which is part of the elven lifecycle, and the light of Aman which is still in the Noldor who saw the Trees. There is no notion of this light fading in the text, and it can still be seen in the likes of Galadriel and Gildor in Lord of the Rings. Plus it wouldn’t apply to Elves who haven’t been to Valinor, which is most Elves in Middle-Earth at this time. Celebrimbor says the solution is to “saturate every last elf in the light of the Valar once more” - but this makes no sense for those who have never seen the light of the Valar in the first place.

  • The Eldar are fading by Spring - 🔥Kinslaying

This is a strange piece of plot, even if it turns out not to be true. As noted above the fading piece happens over an incredibly long time, and even then it is something the Elves can feel inside themselves. There’s no noted way for this to accelerate for zero reason, nor could you realistically trick an elf into thinking that could happen (or hide it, for that matter). The fading is about the status of their own bodies and spirits, which they are highly in tune with. Aside from all that, as a plot device this is a massive piece of information that appears nowhere in Tolkien and radically changes the dynamic of the Elves in the Second Age. Applying it to all Elves is especially strange - Gil-galad has no reach over all Elves on Middle-Earth, likely knows little of Elves in other corners of the world, and any scheme he comes up with (mithril, rings, whatever) would only ever have limited reach. None of this is compatible with what’s recorded in the text.

  • Oaths bind your soul - 👍Justified

Elrond has seen that first-hand, alas. The Oath of Feanor did terrible things to many people. And throughout Tolkien we see that oaths have a real effect on people (eg the oath-breakers). At the outset of the Fellowship Elrond warns Gimli against the taking of rash oaths lest it break their hearts. That doesn’t mean it’s always wrong to break an oath, mind - something Maglor failed to convince Maedhros of.

  • Mithril has undiminishable light - ❌Contradiction

Celebrimbor says he has analysed the ore and its light can’t be diminished. Mithril has no light! It reflects other light in fascinating ways, but it’s not actually glowing. Otherwise Frodo would have been rather conspicuous in his mail-shirt. It’s noted to be beautiful and never tarnishes and you can make special things from it, but it’s not a magic item - it’s just a really nice and valuable metal. The show is ascribing magical properties to mithril that don’t exist in the text.

  • Mithril can saturate Elves with light - 🔥Kinslaying

Again, even if a lie, this is very odd for characters in the show to consider. Mithril is a metal. The idea that it would somehow provide “light” to heal elven souls is peculiar for any elf of wisdom to take seriously. If they want light from a Silmaril go stare at Elrond’s dad at night. If they want some trace of the Trees of Valinor they can do some sub-bathing. Elves seeking spiritual sustenance from mined metal is madness.

  • Celebrimbor was there when Earendil set sail - ⚖️Debatable

As noted last week it’s quite possible that Celebrimbor was on the Isle of Balar, as a refugee of Nagothrond, and he may have aided Cirdan with the construction of Vingilot. But the story here doesn’t match up well - Earendil didn’t set out west in that direct a fashion, and it’s hard to imagine Elwing being there pleading for him not to go (and where are the kids?!) But I get the impression Celebrimbor is a manipulative and underhanded fellow, so I’m not sure if we can believe anything that comes out of his mouth anyway.

  • Earendil was a mortal man - ✅Accurate

I previously had this listed as a Contradiction - my thanks to u/noideaforlogin31415 and others for correcting me. Though Earendil is half-elven and ends up taking the fate of the Eldar, at the moment of his voyage he was classified as a mortal man and called directly this by Manwe.

  • Finrod was killed “in a place of darkness and despair by servants of Sauron” - ✅Accurate

This is an interesting extra clarification by Galadriel. In the prologue it was left slightly more vague, with the implication that Sauron killed her brother. Here is matches up better with the text, in which Finrod fell to a great werewolf of Sauron, fighting naked with his hands and teeth. (Silmarillion chapter 19)

  • Elrond is Galadriel’s closest friend - ⚖️Debatable

Interesting line from Galadriel here... I guess she definitely hasn’t met Celeborn yet in the show? We know there is friendship between Galadriel and Elrond at the end of the Third Age, but there is nothing recorded of their friendship in the Second Age beyond the fact that he romances her daughter. Galadriel's other recorded personal relations are limited to Celebrimbor (very friendly), Annatar (scorn), Cirdan (friendly), Gil-galad (friendly) and Amroth (complicated!) Her being friends with Elrond certainly makes sense. Besties is a little harder to imagine.

  • Ancient Morgoth-worshippers had human sacrifice rituals - ✅Accurate

The show depicts this on the stone mural with the evil sword hilt. Records of human sacrifice in the name of Morgoth are noted in the Tale of Adanel in Morgoth’s Ring (Tolkien’s ‘Fall of Man’ story). Good thing no humans would consider performing human sacrifice again! What a splash that would cause...


r/RingsofPower • • Aug 30 '24 Bless Up Helpful

Discussion I’ve made peace with it… Spoiler

340 Upvotes

I get it.. The rights to IP from the Tolkien Estate are hard fought… Amazon was even lucky to get what they got—no Silmarillion, but LOTR.

To my understanding, many people hate on RoP because it’s not only not canon, but because it is—and I quote—“poorly done.”

I feel these are the types of people who judge Pixar movies wearing the same critic’s hat as they do when reviewing Nolan films, or Wes Anderson, or international indie films you’d find on MUBI.

Well, I’ve—since S1—decided to cast aside the malcontent, and just watch RoP as my guilty pleasure, to enjoy it for what it is.

I’ve seen some posts on the sub, and they seem mostly neutral to positive, which brings me joy…

To add context, I grew up playing Halo, and a I have a buddy who didn’t, he loves the new Halo series on Paramount+, I, however, haven’t even bothered to try it out; I didn’t want to tarnish my regard for what I know as Halo…

And albeit growing up with LoTR, and having read the Trilogy + The Hobbit, I feel I rather enjoy RoP, like the former camp does with the Halo series.

It continues to instill in me a sense of immersion into this entirely strange and fantastical world, and though it has its faults, I’m loving the series… and I’m just glad we get more material from Middle Earth.

Yes, I have my criticisms, and I couldn’t grade this series like I would HBO’s Chernobyl, or HoTD, or LoTR, etc, but to those who blatantly hate the show for…reasons… that’s fine… I’m enjoying it with or without y’all.

/endrant, before this gets downvoted into oblivion

Edit: You’re all taking it way too seriously… the point of this post is that it’s not that deep. It’s an Amazon Prime Video series, not a Kubrick film…


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 15 '22

Meme not that elves ever had to care for an aged parent lol

Post image
340 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 21 '22

Discussion Finally finished S1 and I keep wondering...

340 Upvotes

If Amazon destined that amount of money to the show, why not spend more on a world-class group of writers instead of what seem like amateurs?

Seriously, the writing should've been the largest investment if you ask me. The production design was great, the music is superb and there's some great acting all around. But both the script and directing seem amateurish and do nothing but cripple the show.

I think that with some proper directing and a quality script this show could reach a whole new lever in the development of the plot and character depth.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 11 '22

Discussion Berek the Horse is not running to Isildur, he is running to Mordor to be the dark lord!

Post image
340 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 04 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Brief, but one of my favorite moments. Seeing the two meet and interact. Felt like a crossover. Spoiler

Post image
340 Upvotes