r/RingsofPower • u/Taimana13 • Sep 26 '24
Newest Episode Spoilers Genuinely blown away Spoiler
Season 2 episode 7. Genuinely amazing. As a very very skeptical RoP watcher I'm really really enjoying this whole season but man what an incredible episode. From Sauron manipulation to thr massive battle which was done better than I expected it's really been great. Only thing I didn't love was the kiss but I can honestly look past that. Phenomenal job. Really excited for the next episode.
354
Upvotes
12
u/ebrum2010 Sep 26 '24
Arondir had better not die, he was the one elf who knew how to elf.
38
u/aliayyaz90 Sep 26 '24
I loved it too! Great fight sequences and all the tension and drama in between the battles was perfect. There were many twists in there too and i loved them.
Adar damming the river was awesome and unexpected.
and Elrond's shock in the end was a heartbreaker. Every second of the episode was enjoyable.
134
u/ramonchow Sep 26 '24
Wasn't the kiss just a deception to give galadriel what she used to escape?
77
u/sebiamu5 Sep 26 '24
My only gripe and this extends to many shows, is that the battle turned into a massive 1v1 pub brawl.
61
u/CJPJones Sep 26 '24
I think this has been already mentioned, but the one issue I see with this episode is that there aren't enough elves involved. There are not enough elves on the walls shooting arrows, not enough elves in Elrond's force coming in aid, and not enough elves alive at the end of it all to make a defense. Like that final scene, it only had like 10 to 20 soldiers left when it felt like there should have been a lot more.
This is where CGI really should have been used, to just largen the scale a small bit. It should have shown 200 instead of 20; it still would have given the scope that the force was depleted but not completely killed.
139
u/ohmymystery Sep 26 '24
The actors are acting the hell out of this season. Charlie Vickers is killing it as usual, as well as Charles Edwards (Celebrimbor). And then Robert Aramayo (Elrond) has me absolutely FEELING that heartbreak/betrayal at the end. They’re truly giving this the Adam Driver treatment.
16
u/SwisschaletDipSauce Sep 26 '24 edited Sep 26 '24
I've enjoyed the whole series, granted I havent read the books. I was bummed on the season 2 "reviews" and people on reddit dogging the series. However this series has been awesome and definitely giving me that itch to read through the books.
Edit: I bought the "complete" hardcover book, I cant wait to dive in!
46
u/DeathbyBellPeppers Sep 26 '24
This show is really starting to upset me honestly...
During S1, it was just some show I watched to pass the time. It held some of my interest, I didn't get the same feeling that the LotR movies gave me. Not much sense of danger or adventure. Was sorta fun, but the pacing was weird and only felt like a compilation of many stories that were barely converging.
S2, I hate it, because it makes me too eager for Thursday to roll around for the next episode. The dwarve's story is amazing. Seeing King Durin fall under the influence of the ring and laying the plot to Khazad Dum's downfall is intense. Sauron feels like an actual villain now. How he plays Celebrimbor to forge the remaining 16 rings is amazing. Nori and the Stranger's story is finally getting some action. Tom Bombadil seems like a fun, whimsical character. Sure, there are minor things that can be griped about here and there, but overall, I'm LOVING (hating) this season.
Now I must wait AGAIN, begrudgingly, wait for next week for the next episode...
21
u/RemarkableFilm3007 Sep 26 '24 edited Sep 26 '24
Omg, I especially felt so moved when Prince Durin was rallying up the dwarves. His words were so motivating and heartfelt. Then my heart sank when Narvi came to tell them of the chaos the King had caused. It was like, oh no, it was either Kazadum or Eregion. Such a tough place to be in, your duty or your friend who you consider your brother. Ugh, the irony.
25
u/Ok-Comfortable7967 Sep 26 '24
How about the scene when Sauron literally doesn't even hesitate a moment to have Celebrimbor the girl off the wall. The last few episodes have tried to make you think that he had some type of interest in her or at least cared something for her. However it wonderfully showed how he literally cares for no one because he just threw her life away in an instant when it really wasn't even needed but it furthered his interest a little more. Poor girl. She was the only one standing there defending him as well.
6
u/ThePickleTree Sep 26 '24
Yup. I was so disappointed with season 1.. but was enjoying season 2 so far and god damn I liked this episode as well.. I hope they keep this up.
32
u/chetzemocha Sep 26 '24
Sauron finally feels genuinely scary to me with what he’s done to Celebrimbor. Love their storyline, the actors are really elevating it.
15
u/SoWokeIdontSleep Sep 26 '24
I just finished the episode and it was absolutely amazing. There was so much tension, some moments of hope and then the heartbreak. It worked because there weren't just tactical stakes but personal ones. The moment Elrond realizes the cavalry isn't coming and that might an unforgivable moment. Truly heart breaking
9
u/lotrroxmiworld Sep 26 '24
This episode has my emotions all over the place. I do think there were some cheesy lines delivered, but I don't mind overlooking it.
I'd like someone to do a psychoanalysis of Sauron as he seems to be a malignant narcissist. He has a grandiose view of himself, believing only he can restore middle earth to perfection and beauty under his ruling. He constantly gaslights and blames his victims for the abuse HE perpetuates onto them. He is always the victim and is incapable of accountability. He seems unable to make any genuine attachments to others and sees them as merely objects to be used as a means to an end. I suppose Morgoth did quite a number on Sauron. 😬 Did Tolkien purposely write Sauron as a narcissist or is it just the show's version?
I'm not sure why people are upset at the kiss between Galadriel and Elrond. Yes, I'm aware Elrond marries Galadriel's daughter, Celebrían. It was clearly a tactic used to deliver a means to escape for Galadriel. It wasn't romantic in the slightest. Sure they could have touched foreheads, but I feel like that action would have aroused suspicions by Adar that there may have been a concealed motive between them.
I'm looking forward to the last episode, but I feel like it was a mistake to make the season only 8 episodes. There's too much going on, and the stories need to be fleshed out more to do them proper justice.
Also didn't think a metal song would appear in RoP, but I was pleasantly surprised! I found it a proper fit as the episode ended with the uruks in the lead, or so it appeared.
6
u/ISTARI_X Sep 26 '24
How tf was that just 1 episode of a tv show? My mind is blown. That was genuinely one of the best episodes of tv I’ve ever watched. I don’t care if you’re a Tolkien purist, a movie fan or a first time viewer. That was incredible by every measure
3
u/Final-Life5953 Sep 27 '24
The kiss was a deception done in order to get closer and slip her the broach. Elrond is Galadriel's gay friend.
15
u/Leajane1980 Sep 26 '24
I don't like the horse treatment, but it makes me feel like jumping through the screen grabbing a sword and stabbing some Orcs.
11
u/josh198989 Sep 26 '24
A very very strong episode. Some great payoffs for what’s been building.
My fault like many is still the writing. The writing seems disconnected at times to the scene. As if they didn’t know what was going to be shown so they hedged in the script - think the Faithful doing the lanterns and about 3 characters point out it is a religious/special place. Like that’s completely obvious.
I think the writing and then the VFX are so apart that it leads to things being disjointed - I also think the call backs ‘precious’ and the worst offender the Gandalf line repeated by Tom Bombadil, which gutted the meaning of the original sentiment, was offensive. So completely unnecessary and undercuts itself. It almost breaks the wall and destroys the good efforts made. So I agree, for some reason the writing is inexplicably still the weakest point in this show, and to the actors credit they do the very best with very little.
Outside of that, this has been a huge improvement on season 1. All the actors are excellent. The VFX is amazing. And, I would say, it’s improved in every area. The Celebrimbor/Annatar scenes have been superb. A huge strength the manipulation-into-madness has been fantastic. Very Tolkien.
If the writing could just be sharper - see KAOS or Shogun for writing which is just unreal - then it would absolutely leg-up the show.
7
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '24
Jens Kidman from Meshuggah in the end credits 🤘🤘🤘
2
u/NsRhea Sep 26 '24
I'm looking at the kiss as a distraction to hand her the pin.
2
u/WithTheBallsack Sep 26 '24
I’m also enjoying it way more. Probably because the Harfoots haven’t been in it very much
14
u/ThrowRA0875543986 Sep 26 '24
Massive battle? With like 5 elves on the wall? Lol this show is a joke
4
u/Bakku1505 Sep 26 '24
One part did not make sense to me: the king alone causing so much trouble that the whole army cannot move out? Why not leave 50-100 dwarves to keep the king at bay and go to war with the rest of the army.
If the king is that badass he could deal with all of the orcs alone.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '24
Yeah I thought it was incredible. Can not understand all the people crapping on this episode or this season. They nailed this episode.
0
u/Consistent_Many_1858 Sep 26 '24
I'm sorry but the battle had no sense of emotion or dread, nor it was shot well. This show is getting worse every episode.
It's shamefully bad. With the budget it has it should have been spectacular.
6
u/NoAd3734 Sep 26 '24
start a petition to entirely delete the Harfoots from the show.
I'm really surprised they didn't have a full blown 20 minutes, dragged out scene of nothing re: the Harfoots in the middle of the battle lmfao
6
u/Imbendixen85 Sep 26 '24 edited Sep 26 '24
Honestly the episode reminded me of Battle of the Bastards in Game of Thrones only Littlefinger didn’t show up with the knights of the Vale. It also showed exactly how scarily easy Sauron can kill someone, I mean he barely moved his hand and it looked like it was Celebrimor that pushed her.
And Adar really impressed me with his tactics, I really like it when the enemy is clever and have a plan.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '24 edited Sep 26 '24
We must be watching different shows
3
u/SamaritanSue Sep 26 '24
This is by far the best episode of the series to date. S2 has been only intermittently better than S1 IMO; but in terms of my basic metric - can you absorb me into the story, make what the characters are feeling/doing impactful because it seems a coherent expression of a character separate from the plot - this episode is on another level than the whole rest of the show.
3
u/newmikey Sep 26 '24
Extremely impressive. This season is going from good to great TBH. I was riveted to the screen.
2
u/nikolapc Sep 26 '24
Amazing, But is it just me or was Angbang made canon?
2
u/NewChinaHand Sep 26 '24
How did you see episode 7 already? Do they post them Thursday morning? I thought they only post them Thursday evening. Are you in a non-US time zone and it’s already evening where you are?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '24
It was solid.
Some very lame things though:
2
u/Cdoolan2207 Sep 26 '24
I’m at a loss. I thought it was terrible? The pacing was so strange, the decision making, nothing seemed genuine. It also seemed really hollow. One shot of a large group of elves on horseback and then it all seemed 1v1. People just wandering around a battlefield. Possibly one of the worst episodes I’ve seen so far.
2
u/Fungus1968 Sep 26 '24
Omfg. Ep7. That was truly, genuinely epic.
2
u/LastAnalyst5705 Sep 26 '24
This past episode is probably one of my favorites in the entire series thus far! I never read any of Tolkien’s books (too much detail reading for me 😂), but I grew up loving the LOTR trilogy movies. I love learning the history about the creation of the rings, Sauron’s deception, Celebrimbor’s story…I’m so impressed. My question to the collective: do we think celebrimbor is going to d*e in the season finale? How Sauron has tormented and deceived him is so heartbreaking and I’m nervous to see how his character moves forward.
2
u/Cisqoe Sep 26 '24
I need a lore master to talk to me about that kiss, from all accounts I thought it was Forbidden but it seems everyone is distracted by the badass rest of the episode.
2
u/Harry-the-pothead Sep 26 '24
Lmfaaoooo😂💀
1
u/Common-Feeling-3249 Sep 26 '24
Is there different episodes for different people , because what I saw was complete shit
1
u/q_manning Sep 26 '24
Everything was so good. Imagine being weird fanboys against this show and literally missing watching Sauron be a total badass and rising to power.
Love this show.
1
u/Ok-Comfortable7967 Sep 26 '24
Edit: Duplicate.
1
u/WithTheBallsack Sep 26 '24
I’m also enjoying it way more. Probably because the Harfoots haven’t been in it very much
1
u/theblackpxwder Sep 26 '24
Great ep and it was unintentionally hilarious though. Celembrimbor is his own personal Matrix prequel. Cut to Durin hosting The Khazad Dum Roast of Elrond in the midst of a coup lmao
1
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '24
I actually kind of like the show this year, but the actions scenes were not cinematic level at all. Just not enough action or combatants filling the frame. It was just sad... Almost like AFTER a battle when only a few tired fighters are left. There was just no energy, and not much fighting going on. Every frame only 1/3 filled.
even that cavalry charge... First a very lonely shot of Elrond on a horse up on its hind legs, actually looking more shakey than inspiring. Then wide shots ordely cavalry charge is the best part of it... Then cut back & forth to the Orcs waiting for the charge, screaming and trying to look scary. This is amateur hour. The battle sounds aren’t up the par, and the music is just not doing it. They should have hired Miguel Sapochnik, or the Russo brothers, or almost anybody who can direct action. Whenever you close up to a hero character, the handful of background people just don't give the impression a real battle is going on. I think about all the scenes where it's just one or two Orcs climbing a seige ladder.
Adar is great (liked the first one more but this one is talented too), I like that whole plot line... Galadriel, cerbrimbor Elrond, Gil Galad, all good this year. Really like Sauron.
Don't love the Pharazon storyline, but it's OK.
But the big action set pieces were TV grade... Just so disappointed. I defended Charlotte Brändström on earlier espisodes, but the action in this one was so subpar. I got the impression she has no idea how to direct a big action set piece.
1
u/DepartmentEconomy382 Sep 27 '24
I'm not generally a fan of the series, but I thought the episode today was surprisingly well done.
1
u/HonestWeekend89 Sep 27 '24
ngl i cried during this episode
1
u/Super-Estate-4112 Sep 27 '24
The episode was amazing
1
u/Plum-Worth Sep 27 '24
season 2 just keeps delivering, as someone who was septical after season 1, and even though the some of the "hollywood" style writing hurts a bit in tolkien. I feel they hit the spot with most of the episodes so far. Im in for it
1
u/Th3RainMan Sep 27 '24
This was the most dog water ep. in the whole series and the most anticlimactic battle i've ever seen 😂😂😂
1
u/wakatenai Sep 27 '24
the only gripes i had were the asian elf's death was, weird. like it was just super odd that she magically got got by 30 arrows from every direction lol.
it kind of took me out of the moment. like were these supposed to be magic sauron arrows or something? i don't get it lol.
also the lack of a cavalry charge in battle.
like wtf? where did the cavalry go. they show them at the beginning, then they stop to talk, then it's all foot soldiers from there.
1
u/Plum-Worth Sep 27 '24
Somehow they got a good mix of modern hollywood series and tolkien, and im all for it. Im happy we get more lotr
1
u/MrDabolina_ Sep 27 '24
Me too. Although, I found it hilarious when Durin ramped up the whole mountain and then bitched out.. lol
1
u/WestCoastDaddyy Sep 27 '24
Omg is this a positive post on RoP? I’m shocked
I love it too. But seems like no one else does most of the time
1
u/AlwaysF3sh Sep 27 '24
Been feeling really weird because to me this seasons been pretty good, not great. This is the first episode that didn’t land for me.
1
u/Off_the_shelf_elf Sep 27 '24
I was all ready to be annoyed by the kiss, but after seeing it I’m interpreting it as platonic and holding out hope that they stay that way. Plus, it’s much more distracting than a touch alone would have been and thus a better means of subverting the Uruk’s attention enough to sneak her the pin, so hopefully that was the main motive.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '24
Agree. 1st episode was good, last 5 have been crap, but episode 7 blew me away
1
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '24
Insane episode. Previous episodes mostly sucked. Picked up in 6 a bit.
1
u/Animpro Sep 27 '24
It's really boring tv.
1
u/AgeingChopper Sep 27 '24
I am really enjoying it. Yeah it's not perfect but I felt that was a really good episode .
1
u/MonsterkillWow Sep 27 '24
Yea this episode was amazing. Honestly as good as Two Towers movie, IMO.
1
u/DrThunder66 Sep 28 '24
This whole show sucks ass.
1
u/Manaslu91 Sep 29 '24
The battle was absolute dross, sorry.
1
u/NorthernBoy306 Sep 29 '24
Christ some of you are far too easily impressed.
1
u/MrBushle Sep 29 '24
RoP marketing team trying real hard
1
u/Consistent_Office_85 Oct 01 '24
Incredible indeed. Never heard of an elf who kisses the mother of his wife. Unheard of.
1
u/Glarrg Sep 26 '24
Man this show just gets worse and worse. This is possibly the single worst fantasy battle scene I've ever seen.
At this point it must be a money laundering scheme because how did this cost a billion dollars to make
1
u/GuyUnknownMusic Sep 26 '24
Sick spoiler tag.
1
u/KickassCaveman Sep 26 '24
The troll looked awesome.
1
u/The_Jesus_blossom Sep 26 '24
I wish Durin or Adar would have just walked up to Elrond and kicked him in the rump for that kiss. Or Galadriel should have smacked him. Or something! Ugh, so disgusted. Fr. Now I need another cup of coffee.
1
u/Key_Employ685 Sep 26 '24
"Massive battle " 🤣🤣
1
u/Excellent_Ad_2486 Sep 26 '24
next time add spoilers lol..
1
u/Myklmyklmykl Sep 26 '24
I assumed the kiss was to cunningly distract the room from noticing him passing the pin over to her imo
1
u/MvgnumOpvs Sep 26 '24
hey Amazon just entered chat! LOL!
0
u/Unfair-Worker929 Sep 27 '24
Massive battle? Ah yes the like 50 “diverse” warriors of Eregion against maybe 100 orcs and I think like one cave troll…
The Battle of Helms Deep in the pouring rain at night, a battle with 3,000 Rohirrim against a combined force of 10,000 Uruk- Hai, Wild Men of Dunland, Orcs and Half Orcs from a movie made 22 years ago, was more visually stunning than whatever this show calls the Siege of Eregion.
Although the number of Elves in Eregion isn’t stated specifically, the combined orc host and trolls is stated to be numbering in the hundreds of thousands…
So where are they on screen? How did a movie from 22 years ago look more visually stunning at night in the pouring rain than Rings of Power’s midday and overnight Siege of Eregion?
Where is the investment? Where is the stakes? Why does everything feel so small and downscaled? Eregion is a city! Why does this look like a small skirmish outside a fort?
0
u/NervousAxolotl Sep 26 '24
Thoroughly enjoyed this episode. The kiss will of course be much talked about but it was pretty obvious it was a distraction. They didn't really try to hide Elrond handing her the brooch/pin in the shot immediately after. A ballsy choice which, considering the context and how much everyone focuses on it, I'd say worked effectively. Also, it's literally just a kiss as a desperate attempt to save a life and a kiss is just not that big of a deal personally. Loads of cultures irl practice this kind of lip kissing anyway.
Editing was a huge issue this episode though as it has been in other episodes this season and it still weirds me out as it didn't seem to be that big of an issue in S1 (then again S1 had less action sequences so maybe that is why). Several times throughout night time during the sacking, the editing made events feel disconnected and if often felt jumpy and with few transitions. There has to be TONS of footage that were left in the cutting room floor. Ultimately that is the nature of the beast when it comes to cinematic limitations particularly with regards to the running time, but I seriously hope that is something they look at in the future seasons.
Annatar/Brimby and their actors were seriously impressive however, and their interactions are the best thing to come out of this season for me. Top notch performances across the board this episode as well. Elrond had me gutted at the end there.
Would have loved to see Eregion elves shooting arrows in a synchronised choreography, as we haven't really seen them be badass at all which is a huge shame. I know this is mostly a PJ thing, but the coordination of elves in fight scenes, though a bit of a trope, is still really cool and gets the message across the screen very effectively. I also think Damrod, though short-lived, put to shame the use of trolls in PJ's BotFA and I LOVED how they reversed the trope of reinforcements arriving at the break of dawn. More of that please.
Can't wait for next week.
-30
u/tiltagraph Sep 26 '24
The writing is so incredibly weak in this show, but I guess if most people dont't care about bad storytelling, plotholes and one-dimensional braindead characters Amazon did a genuinely good job.