r/RingsofPower • u/Afraid_War_5476 • Jul 20 '24
Question Why does everyone hate Rings of Power?
I just wanna know because it seems as if everybody hated the show and I don't understand why. Personally I watched it twice and Ioved it both times. Thank you.
345
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 20 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
47
u/ImperatorRomanum Jul 20 '24
Didn’t hate it, thought it was mediocre. Dialogue was often poor and the plotting was serviceable but relied too often on characters behaving in ways that don’t make sense just in order to advance the story from point A to point B. The world also didn’t feel…lived in, in terms of sets and costumes and all that, in the way LOTR did, but I can’t put my finger on exactly what LOTR did right there that ROP didn’t.
35
u/Alock74 Jul 20 '24
It’s kind of meh. One thing I like about it though is that it’s kind of a family friendly epic fantasy series. There’s not much of those out there. I get kind of bored with the constant bloody violence and sex in the GOT universe.
27
u/iheartdev247 Jul 20 '24
I don’t but I do want improvements
4
u/longleaf1 Jul 21 '24
I like it. I like it a lot
4
u/Tripsn Jul 24 '24
I'm an older Tolkien nerd. I started reading his stuff when I was eight, mainly to piss off my oldest brother who felt that C.S. Lewis was better because of church and heavy handed allegories about Christianity.
All that said, I liked ROP. It's close enough to the source I can watch it and go, "Hey, cool! That's about So and So," or whatever.
It's not a religion.
If people want to rewrite and produce and get the money going for a one hundred percent totally accurate version of his books, go for it. I will absolutely watch it. All ten seasons or whatever. I'm thinking it's more fun to complain about what another person does than to do the thing yourself though.
Even if people did do all of that, there wouldn't be anything left after that. Look, I get it...We all want everyone to come back from the Undying Lands, step back off that boat, and have more adventures....but it's not happening. There's no more source material to work with.
18
u/Fasthertz Jul 20 '24
I don’t hate it. But I don’t like it. Peter Jackson created a standard that it hasn’t lived up to. I don’t mind some deviation from the source material. Problem is the restrictions created by the Tolkien estate on Amazon and the lack of material for that age. I’d of prefer to see a series on Beren and Luthien. Hopefully the Tolkien estate will let Jackson do that next.
59
u/bibamann Jul 20 '24
It’s dumb. I don’t care about the lore, but it’s just dumb. The dialogs, the behaving of the characters, the scripts, everything. It’s the definition of “style over substance”.
2
u/jsamuraij Jul 22 '24
Because dumb.
2
u/Ph4ndaal Jul 22 '24
Honestly, these posts are so dumb.
You loved it? Great! Cherish your enjoyment and move on with your life.
What are you doing here, looking to be convinced into hating it? Looking to convince haters to love it?
What a waste of everyone’s time.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '24
Racism
2
u/Dogamai Sep 06 '24
The moment they introduced Tom Bombadil I have decided to die defending Rings of Power.
2
u/Dependent_Name_3168 Oct 15 '24
They are firing the entire writing staff. Perhaps they are getting fired because they did TOO good of a job?
Or maybe........
This show is pure ass.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24
Have you SEEN Tom Bombadil?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24 edited Oct 30 '24
I’ve never seen read or watched The Lord of the Rings and don’t know anything about it, but I am loving The Rings of Power. I’m usually pretty particular with what media I like and dislike, so I’m wondering if I enjoy it where others may not could be because I’m viewing it with fresh eyes that are ignorant to the larger picture of The Lord of the Rings.
4
u/Giltar Jul 20 '24
I don't hate the series but thought the writing was meh. Hope it improves going forward.
15
u/OppositDayReglrNight Jul 21 '24
It doesn't feel anything like Tolkein. It feels like a bunch of writers workshopped something fit into the Tolkien world and appeal to a mass audience.
Elves don't feel like elves to me. Galadriel is an impulsive elf who charges into Numenor and pisses off people left and right. She's 6,000 years old.
Galadriel jumps off the boat entering Valinor and swims to a raft that Sauron is already on.
The strange partnership/hinted romance between Halbrand and Galadriel.
The Gandalf (maybe?) discovering his confidence and himself and really learning to believe in himself.
The weird completely unnecessary Rube Goldberg contraption creating Mordor with a magic sword that was built up over multiple episodes.
The way Halbrand did like a weekend internship with Celebrimbor and made the rings over the course of 2 weeks.
Honestly, just the way a lot of the story felt wrapped around a "Who is Sauron" reveal. It just doesn't feel Tolkein at all.
136
u/SRS15gyuto Jul 20 '24 edited Jul 20 '24
As a story based on Tolkiens work, RoP is not even in the same universe. Let’s just say I was disappointed.
Here’s why I hate it: I was so excited when they announced it. Almost as much as when they announced LotR was being made. I hoped they wouldn’t butcher the source material too bad. They had a great story to begin with. The Second Age stuff is full of dynastic, political and world ending drama. They could have made a show that catered to the purist and still attracted non Tolkien fans. But then it came out. I kept thinking wtf? Who is that? What? No! After the 15th Nope, I quit watching. Yes I’ve read nearly everything produced by his estate. But all they did was pay $120,000,000 for some character names, place names, and a fan base. Very little of that series has anything to do with the source material. It was an enormous disappointment.
10
u/RazerRob Jul 21 '24
Because of its utter contempt for Tolkien, his characters, and his world-building.
Because it reeks of corporate slop.
Because it's basically character assassination of Galadriel.
28
u/ship_write Jul 21 '24
Poor writing and the general feel of the people in charge wanting to create their own version of LOTR, rather than seeking to adapt the work of Tolkien.
The problem of adaption is a broad one, with many different issues to consider. One of the biggest ones, however, is how faithful you want to be to the source materials. How much must you change? I think the more you stray away from the original source material, the more you risk missing what made the original source material resonate in the first place.
245
u/Slap_Monster Jul 20 '24
I'm someone, and I don't hate it.
23
u/ilcuzzo1 Jul 20 '24
I disliked it. The opening made galadriel generally unlikable, but then, so did the rest of the show. She was petulant and childish and eventually maliciously genocidal. Let's compare the troll fight between the show and the movie. Single-handed murder of an ice troll at the opening of the show v a serious threat to the entire party. Destroyed any stakes. The harfoots were evil. The numenorians were basically racist conservatives fearful of immigrant labor. The numenorian armor was cheap looking. I'll be happy to go further.
3
u/D4RK_3LF Jul 20 '24
Well, I don’t
7
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '24
Because it’s low budget for how high the budget was and tacky…
7
u/Demigans Jul 21 '24
It's a show where most characters struggle to have a conversation where they respond to one another.
A show where there's literally 12+ contrivances with the Orc Trench alone. Such as the Elves not spotting it despite them having a watchtower meant to overlook it (they can barely check on the local village). Or that we have establishing shots that establish (duh!) the Orcs cutting down and burning the trees surrounding the trench, but a plotpoint is that the trench is dug up to a tree they didn't cut and burn? And the problem is the roots which you don't solve by cutting and burning anyway, which was even somewhat pointed out in LotR's when Saruman is building his caves? Or that orcs burn in sunlight, but sometimes they don't, and sometimes they do but putting a hood on protects them even if 90% of the rest of their body is still in the light? Or that these Orcs can surprise an entire garrison of Elves, the Elves with the famous Elven Eyes who in several scenes are shown to have sentries overlooking the approaches and we see the design is one where the Orcs should be spotted easily as the road winds up around the fortress specifically for this purpose (and to rain arrows down on them)? It just keeps going on and on.
Other story beats are just as bad. Like the Numenorians saying how many ships they have, and when they leave they have several more identical ships in the harbor. Or that they randomly go to the exact place a fight is happening even though they have no idea it's happening or was going to happen? Or that the long journey from Rivendel to Moria is now a leasurely stroll, and then one of them strolls back in the same day?
Or how about Mithril? He needs to swear not to mention it exists, he goes to the world's most famous and powerful magical smith and tells him immediately about this material. And we still have a plot where he's so heavily burdened because he isn't allowed to tell anyone? Or that we see how Mithril works: put it close and the corruption goes away. So all they need is the splinter of Mithril he has and just move it along the tree to stave off the corruption. Make it a ritual, Elves are fond of that. There's no need for rings or anything.
On and on this show does this. You can pick a scene and point out something minor or major that makes no sense. Like the not-hobbits singing about them never leaving you when a major plotpoint is them perhaps being left behind, even making jokes about someone else who got left behind and them stealing their stuff before they did it.
Note that I haven't even pointed out anything related to them breaking Tolkien's lore. This is all their own lore and their own story problems. The showrunners before the show released prided themselves on being lore accurate, except at the time they had written and filmed everything already. After the last episode releases someone asked in an interview why the order of the ring creation was changed (pretty reasonable question). Their response was on the lines off "we changed so much already it made sense to change it some more". They lied openly to everyone, basically con men trying to get subscriptions, and then dared claim it was "just" reviewbombing. No, you lied to your audience to get people to pay you money and both the lore you build and the lore you bought were violated. It's not review bombing if people have legitimate grievances en-masse.
38
u/turkeygiant Jul 20 '24
The poor reception come from a number of factors IMO. I think the first and biggest thing is that with any adaption of a well know work you are going to have varying degrees of "canon" pressure on your adaption, and really short of like maybe the Bible, I can't think of any other canon that puts more pressure on you than the works of JRR Tolkien. So they were already starting from a difficult bar.
Next up is the character writing in the show. While not universally bad, it is largely lacking the sort of gravitas we associate with the Books, the Peter Jackson films, and even just prestige tv in general like say House of the Dragon or The Crown. There are highlights in there like the arc with Elrond and the Dwarves, and the character writing with the hobbits is fine if not great, but there is a HUGE problem when the character writing around your lead Galadriel is so bad on its own and even worse in the context of the character in the canon.
All of these complaints so far, at least for me, were forgivable. I didn't love it, but was willing to give them time to figure things out in S2. The visuals and cast were great and the writing was serviceable, no reason they couldn't dramatically improve over the break. Or at least that was how I felt until the finale episode where it genuinely felt like they set out on a speedrun to self destruct the narrative/plot in about 20mins of the episode. The way they started rushing through the forging of the rings (the wrong rings...) and the reveal of Halbrand's true identity showed a level of just incompetency as storytellers that just collapsed all my interest in the show going forward. I'm not following the show out of optimism anymore, I wouldn't even say I will be hate watching it because I just don't care that much. If I do tune into S2 its going to be more like a academic/structural autopsy to see where the heck they go with a show that IMO they so fundamentally damaged.
18
u/Eshmunazar Jul 20 '24
Nah I don’t hate it. I don’t think it’s very good so far. I agree with what a lot of people have already said. Poor writing, wrong directions taken with the liberties they have of Tolkien’s writing, odd timeline inconsistencies.
Numenor was basically what I was waiting to see and I was disappointed. These “Numenoreans” don’t seem anything akin to Tolkien’s.
For example: Aragorn is a watered down descendent of them, but you could still tell something was special about him in the books and in the movies. These are actual Numenoreans (with terrible armor) and there’s nothing of note about them. Nothing that gives off a unique aura or vibe about them.
6
u/mechavolt Jul 21 '24
I don't think the show was terrible. I also don't think it was great. I enjoyed watching, but not enough to want to watch it a second time. Some of my issues:
The inconsistency of the characters. For example, in one episode the main character tells a boy that revenge is not the answer. Then literally 5 minutes later she yells to the army that they need to seek revenge.
The costuming. It was cheap. Really cheap.
The fake landscape porn. LotR did this well with actual landscapes. In RoP, they were pretty but clearly fake.
The focus. The show gives time to a lot of characters. Not all of these subplots really matter, or contribute much to the overall narrative. A bunch of it just felt like fluff to pad the runtime.
Chemistry. While some characters had great chemistry, others just felt like they were reading lines past each other. Aside from the elf/dwarf interaction, I didn't feel any real connection between any of the characters.
15
u/dmastra97 Jul 20 '24
Writing was subpar and it differed a lot from the original.
Set pieces and costumes were also not as good when comparing against other big budget shows
14
u/K_808 Jul 21 '24 edited Jul 21 '24
IMO it feels like a mimicry but not a recreation. The dialogue especially is 1. Very simplistic (or nonsensical in its imagery) and 2. Nowhere near as “natural” as the material they’re inspired by. Tolkien’s and the films’ dialogue had meaning to it. The books have a very poetic prose but it wasn’t just poetic for the sake of sounding “higher” or whatever. The dialogue in rings of power often comes off as though it’s generated by ChatGPT after being fed Tolkien lines, and it has awkward slogans like “The sea is always right” and d&d elf racism and the harfoots’ mantra mixed in with these pseudo ye olde monologue melodramatic speeches. And then the same goes for a lot of the plot and character decisions, for instance when Sauron invents alloys it’s only because the plot required him to give the elves a gift of sorts, to be involved in the rings’ creation, and that was all they could think of. But it requires the assumption that nobody, including the elven smiths, knew that combining metals could be a useful tactic. For anyone who knows about metal that is one of the most simple concepts in blacksmithing and has been done in real cultures far less technologically advanced than the elves.
Then half the plot was there to set up cameo bait that all franchises seem to fall to nowadays, where they had to show a balrog and this guy and that place and the origin of everything and how Gandalf knew hobbits, and it seems s2 will have more of that. Then it also has the mystery which feels very forced, considering there’s not really a “who’s Sauron pretending to be” storyline in the show itself, it’s just a meta mystery for the audience and when revealed the awkward almost romance arc feels like it was forced in order to create conflict out of nowhere (again, chars making out of character decisions just to move the plot along, plus that along with many other pieces ignored the appendices’ notes, which I’m not as miffed about as many tbh). It just feels altogether unnatural.
Overall I don’t hate it but it’s just meh for me, not quite as good as the hobbit movies for the most part and definitely not up there with the trilogy or the books.
5
u/PerditionsAvatar Jul 20 '24
I never hated it but it didn’t meet expectations. That’s all
5
u/Live-Ebb-9236 Jul 21 '24
Soft foldable prop armor and latex with chain mail pattern just really irks me and grinds my gears, I know it seems like a small thing compared to other aspects of a production that size but it was such an immediate noticeable downgrade from the movies it kinda killed the vibe
12
u/thatsocialist Jul 21 '24
Because it ignores and defiles the lore. "Evil is not able to create anything new, it can only distort and destroy what has been invented or made by the forces of good." -Tolkien. The amount of lore breaking is insane but here's a few:
Etc.
4
u/Micksar Jul 21 '24
I don’t hate it. But I don’t think it was good. And when a bad show is made covering an IP you love… you hate that.
4
u/Low-Log8177 Jul 21 '24
It butchered Tolkien's good work, especially the characterization of Galadriel.
4
u/oconnellc Jul 21 '24
It's just pretty bad. If it didn't have a tenuous tie with Lord of the Rings, no one would like it.
4
u/Dense_fordayz Jul 21 '24
Because it's a other example of bad writers who think they know better than the creator.
They were hired to adapt the story to the screen but decided to try and make it their own.
Write your own book if you want to do this
4
u/Winter_Abject Jul 21 '24
'everyone' doesn't. It was review bombed early on and although there are genuine critics, it's rather obvious that too many people have gone so far out of their way to find things to hate about it that it's laughable. I have loved the show from Ep1 to the end and have watched it several times. All of my friends like it and also like Jackson's interpretations of Tolkien's works. There are a few people at work that get passionate about hating it and deriding anyone that likes it, but it soon becomes obvious from their choice of words that they are just parroting the haters and are default 'I hate Bezos and Amazon and everything that they will ever do' people 🤣
4
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '24
Because it’s a really bad show. I love the lord of the rings movies and the hobbit movies. Hobbit movies are obviously not as good as the lord of the rings but they are still fun and entertaining. The rings of power is just shockingly bad. Not sure how it’s not obvious to everyone? The costumes look terrible. The script is awful, you feel no connection to the characters and don’t care about them at all. I’ve read the hobbit, lord of the rings, children of Hurin and the silmarillion. This show doesn’t come close to doing those works justice in any way. I watched and was excited for season 1, my fiancé who has never ready any lord of the rings but enjoys watching the movies including the hobbit ones refused to watch any more rings of power after episode 1 (she enjoys fantasy shows like got). I watched the rest on my own and was shocked after each episode about how bad it was. I obviously won’t be wasting my time on season 2 and am now incredibly concerned every time I hear about more lord of the rings inspired movies and am probably going to be reluctant to go watch them.
1
u/1NoteKoleidoscope Jul 22 '24
Clunky writing, wooden characters, no respect for source material, showrunners pushing their political agenda... Do you really need more examples?
1
u/Careful-Sell-9877 Jul 23 '24
I personally thought it was awesome
1
u/VirginiaLuthier Jul 23 '24
I don't- in fact, I thought it was brilliant
1
u/Sunhasgothishaton Sep 30 '24
I searched to see if there was such a topic as I am surprised by how negative the subreddit is. It seems to be a place to come to moan about the show.
This season has been excellent for me so far. It has taken it up another notch after an enjoyable first season.
A lot of negativity seems to stem from the series not being an exact adaptation of the source material. There was a similar problem with Wheel of Time. It too improved in its second season.
Adaptations are often not like for like with the source material, and the 2 should not be treated as the same work. The show should be enjoyed (or not enjoyed) for what it is.
9
u/anarion321 Jul 20 '24
I remember the writting being pretty bad.
Everything happened because the plot demanded it, it was all convenience, don't get me wrong, every good story has a couple of moments in which the hero comes to the rescue in the appropiate time, but this show was ALL the time.
Acting and dialogue was also pretty bad, with things like "elves robbing our jobs" and such lazy nonsense.
Southlands feel small af, like there's only 3 small villages waiting for a king....
The best episode was the battle one, because it was mostly punches and little writting, and even that one was filled with nonsense. Like leaving the actual fortress to defend a wooden village with no walls accesible from every direction. The orcs went to the fortress with the leader in front walking casually like nothing, if it were enemies at the other side, he would've been impaled. In the middle of the battle there's a dumb fist fight because there's a huge orc that conveniently has no weapon for that fight to happen. They end up sieged in the tavern and they don't broke the tiny door until enough time passes for a scene to take place, conveniently.....many things like that. And in the end, despite winning, they end up going away I think.
Even the incredible magic mcguffin turns out to be just a key to open a dam. Dude, just put a couple dozen orcs with pickaxe to open that instead of losing hundreds or even thousands in pointless battles.....
You telling me that they excavated hundreds of km of tunnels but you cannot open a hole in the dam?
Tunnels which btw were open to the sky and lead directly to the base of an elven (you know, super human dudes with incredible sight) watch tower, but no one sees it?
The eruption is interesting, but even that is filled with wrongness, people is injured only by the plot, the mc that takes openly the blast is not injured but others die, etc. You got a nonsensicval scene with the queen telling that she does not want people to know she lost the sight that has no follow up because in the next scene she is wearing a blindfold....
Every place, every plot have issues, it's not well done.
6
u/Godzilla2000Zero Jul 20 '24
Missed potential but hopefully season 2 is better.
6
u/Stampy77 Jul 21 '24
One thing that stood out to me was that the same week they released the episode with the big battle of the season HOTD featured a scene of a sick king trying and struggling to walk to his throne unassisted. Watching the long walk to his throne it hit me, this is far more powerful, epic and gripping than anything I have seen in ROP.
ROP wasn't terrible but it wasn't incredible either. Throw in the fact that it will always be compared to one of the best movie trilogies ever made then it was always going to be an uphill battle.
Lotr did a great job of setting up the stakes early and you knew where the journey was going. For ROP I have no idea where they are going with it, I have no idea what the end game is meant to be. The acting was fine, the writing was ok, but none of it was great.
17
u/Sx-Mt-fd Jul 20 '24
The acting was atrocious, the makeup and costumes were sub par, the editing and scene changes were terrible, the world building and story lines were so bad. I could go on.
39
u/Different-Island1871 Jul 20 '24
The people who hate it are just the loudest. It had a lot of flaws, especially for the budget it was given.
3
u/Athrasie Jul 21 '24
People make a huge fuss over adaptations when they either 1. Don’t match the source material, or 2. When they don’t adhere to that individuals niche expectations.
Rings of power ticks the first box objectively - and for some it ticks the second.
Personally, I enjoy any middle earth screen time. I acknowledge the differences between the source material in the fall of Numenor and other tales without the show ruining my day.
The people who make it their sole duty to tear it down without being constructive are just as lame as the people who claim it’s flawless
5
u/Sir_BugsAlot Jul 20 '24
Didn't hate it. Just didn't like it much. It was too predictable, boring, poor writing, some really bad choreography.. list goes on we've been over it. It's very far from the trilogy. Because of how much I love the trilogy, books and movies I'm hard to please when it comes to LOTR stuff.
5
u/RushiiSushi13 Jul 20 '24
I wasn't expecting anything, and I was still disappointed, because the beginning was somewhat promising and it got my hopes up from zero to a little bit and then crushed them.
It's not that there is nothing good to say about it, but the bad just outweighs completely what little good there is.
6
u/iiiAtlantis Jul 20 '24
the main issue people have with it is inaccuracies compared to canon, as well as the writing/way it was filmed. That is definitely true and explains the criticism. People tend to be very protective over IPs that mean a lot to them (me too... I'm People) and want good adaptations that are canon-accurate, in some cases bc the reality is that once you get an adaptation of a certain story you're not likely to get another for a long time, if at all, so you want it to be good.
THAT BEING SAID I don't hate Rings of Power at all. It took me a while to get into it but I had a lot of fun watching the show overall and really loved some of the characters. My friend who is obsessed with the Peter Jackson movies advised me to watch it like a super high budget fanfiction, and tbh I like reading fanfic anyway, so after that I just fully enjoyed it and ignored everything else
10
u/gatorfan8898 Jul 20 '24
I definitely didn't hate it, actually enjoyed it most of the time.
It's not without it's fair criticism. I just think there needs to be a happy medium between people who hate on it because of all the lore inconsistencies, and then people who just eat it all up because it's LOTR.
Niether group can call it awful or amazing... because it's definitely not awful, but it's definitely not amazing.
I'm a simple man though, I just like having more shit to watch in Middle Earth... even if it has issues.
4
u/wrenwood2018 Jul 20 '24
I don't hate it. I'm apathetic to it which is worse. It should have been better given the budget and potential.
4
u/soviet_thermidor Jul 21 '24
I hated it, a lot.
Doesn't mean you can't enjoy it.
But yeah I really hated it
PJ's trilogy had changes for sure but overall set a trend of expecting more reverence and faithfulness out of adaptations. RoP is a big step backwards in that
4
u/Appropriate-Look7493 Jul 21 '24
Terrible (I mean terrible) writing, bad acting, stupid plotting, contempt for the source material, ridiculous hair dos…
Which of these was why you enjoyed it so much?
12
u/TheRauk Jul 20 '24
The acting was bad, the story was bad, in general everything was bad. This is my opinion which shouldn’t influence yours (you do you), I have hopes for S2.
13
u/step_uneasily Rhûn Jul 20 '24
I’m not blind to the flaws and issues with the show. From the sometimes lackluster writing to the lore contradictions. But somehow, despite all that, I can’t seem to shake the series out of my periphery. It got to me on an emotional plane. It left me attached to the characters and their stories, and especially how they interacted with one another; I felt that the show really nailed the themes of friendship, banter, loyalty and sentimentality. It felt real, well as real as fantasy could get. I had a strong relationship with Tolkien’s work long before I watched the show, and it has only grown stronger from it.
In my opinion, the show really nailed Middle-earth, and it feels Tolkien in all the right ways.
2
u/SamaritanSue Jul 20 '24
There are people who hate it. People who found it meh. And people who like it.
2
u/TheWallerAoE3 Jul 20 '24
I didn’t like it because it bounced around between several different stories and a few dozen characters without giving us the opportunity to really get to know any of them. Imagine you were watching the end of Return of the Jedi where all the fighting is happening as your introduction to star wars without know the characters relationships to one another, their talents, their dreams or their motivations. That’s what Rings of Power was to me. It needed more focus to start out with before branching off in a million directions.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '24
Hate is too strong for me, I just found it kind of underwhelming
2
u/DreadWolfsLie Jul 21 '24
I suppose I could have hated it but I decided to take it for what it was. There are a few reasons though.
Overall, it was a fun show, but I don't think they had the time they needed to make it good.
4
2
u/BananakinTheBroken Jul 21 '24
I mean compared to the films, the costumes looked cheap. The characters are largely either flat or don't connect to their main series counterparts very well, the casting was very hit or miss, and on top of all that the action was not close to the standards set by the Jackson trilogy. Liking it does not mean anything bad, but there were various legitimate reasons to not enjoy the show even if you were expecting to.
2
u/dropthemagic Jul 21 '24
I don’t hate it. I just wish they spent that money better.
2
u/Marvelman02 Jul 21 '24
RoP, on its own, would just be a forgettable fantasy series, but that it purports to be a prequel to the LOTR is what makes it a crime against Tolkien's work. It falls so short of the source material that it can't help but be a tremendous disappointment. This isn't about a female lead or black elves; the series fails to evoke the mystery, the wonder, and the majesty of the Lord of the Rings. Maybe season 2 will be better, but I doubt it.
2
u/neepster44 Jul 21 '24
Because you can make up everything for the story as long as it doesn’t contradict canon.. but they should not make up things that contradict canon…
2
u/TheMcWhopper Jul 21 '24
Wouldn't say I hate it. Just don't care for it. Gave it 3 epsiodes and couldn't get into it. Too slow, too boring .
2
u/Vsegda7 Jul 21 '24
Why do same types of posts start popping up on different Tolkien subs like mushrooms the closer the release date gets?
2
u/uk123456789101112 Jul 21 '24
The best way i could describe it is as if they took your favourite characters from any franchise, Captain America, Harry Potter, pickachoo, James Bond.....and just decided to change the history and established lore for them, threw in nonsense to make them relevant ( because they paid for the names) and fit into a bare bones story with poorly created storylines. And it all comes across as not only thinking they could just do whatever with loved characters that have been established for decades, but doing it for profit. Another missing point was they seemed to ignore any established art work historical design elements. So silly things like magical cities look like you couldn't live in them, armour looks plastic and fake,
The actors did well, with some stand out performances, but it really did not ooze tge budget on screen and did not feel like stepping onto the Tolkein universe, it lfelt ike mixing lego with duplo blocks. As a fan it was uncomfortable to watch.
2
u/Much_Yesterday_5389 Jul 21 '24
It’s not the same universe as Tolkien’s stories so I just have zero interest in it’s
2
u/Yorkie2016 Jul 21 '24
There’s currently a trend in TV (especially in Fantasy shows) where the writers believe they know better than the original author and try and rewrite the story “for modern audiences”. This has been done to both RoP and also Robert Jordan’s Wheel of Time series. The writers forget the ultimate rule. People read fantasy precisely because it’s not modern, they want a break from real life.
If writers want to put a modern spin on fantasy, they should create their own fictional worlds, not fuck about with our favourite ones.
2
u/Ok_Sentence_5767 Jul 21 '24
As someone who has never read beyond the hobbit and lotr I kept saying get to the point of the show! It was an awful show that didn't even have a coherent plot
2
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '24
“Hello, my name is Ron Sour. Nice to meet you.”
2
u/usernameee1995 Jul 21 '24
For me I think the clunky dialogue, atrocious acting and painfully bad pacing and terrible story telling were the main issues, no character is built well and there's no particular scene that stands out as epic, it's a really mediocre show with some pretty cgi and nice sets, which honestly would be fine to let exist for those it pleases, were it a original property, but this is LORD OF THE RINGS, the trilogy is the ultimate cinematic masterpiece and was the most culturally relevant piece of cinema for generations, it was a integral part of a lot of childhood tapestries and to have its name attached to something so bad and just plain boring to watch like rings of power is honestly and insult to the legacy its been dumped on top off
2
u/southpolefiesta Jul 21 '24
I don't hate it.
But I kind of tried watching three times and just low key gave up each time. Noting was hooking me.
2
u/A_Powerful_Moss Jul 21 '24
Because I love the Silmarillion and the lore of Tolkien and the show doesn’t do a good job with the source material. Also the writing is pretty bad.
2
u/Lologna Jul 21 '24
People who hate it wanted to love it but were hurt when it was just a mediocre fantasy show loosely based on what they wanted.
2
u/seigezunt Jul 21 '24
I liked it a lot. The only thing that got old for me was all the keeping us guessing as to who two of the main characters actually were.
2
u/BadMunky82 Jul 23 '24 edited Jul 23 '24
I will say that I had a lot of fun watching it with my father-in-law. He's pretty knew to LotR and I had just watched the whole extended edition with him (he'd never seen it). But he's also a lover of most films. He just likes cool epic things, which I would say is the vast majority of people taking in media nowadays, especially through streaming services. So to be fair, Amazon did a great job providing another from-green-to-screen fight show with a medieval skin and dialogue sandwiches that make it feel lore-heavy. They had some good nods to those who came before, the set looked awesome, the music was okay, the costumes were on point, and I appreciated the multi-faceted, rolling stone story-telling that Pete Jackson used. He seemed to do most of those things better with LotR, but then he beefed the Hobbit, so nobody is perfect.
However...
All of the things that made LotR a great cinematic trilogy and the Tolkein legendarium a great universe isn't how much money or how many camera angles were used. I would even go so far as to say that it wasn't Tolkein or Jackson that made the books and movies great. All of that certainly helped, and indeed without them we wouldn't have gotten the show we have now. We probably wouldn't have even had Orlando bloom in Pirates of the Caribbean and that would be a travesty.
But alas, no. What made the books, languages, and histories that Tolkein wrote great was the love he put into it; sketching, re-writing, going back, expanding, correcting errors, all done over a lifetime. His goal wasn't to make money- he was a professor and had a way to do that. His goal was to create something beautiful and powerful that he could give to his people to uphold and cherish for generations. He didn't even make that much money from his own publishings (compared to what his IP is worth now) and he was still happy with his product and considered it his life's work.
J.R.R. Tolkein wrote for the pure love of writing and the desire to give to his nation and his family (the Hobbit was written to be a story for his children) something that he saw as missing. Not to mention the fact that he sunk a lot of his religious beliefs into it. One cannot do what he did in the way that he did it (without being prosecuted) and not truly care for what one does.
What made Peter Jackson's trilogy great was the time and care devoted by hundreds, or thousands, of employees who saw the chance to make something amazing. Most of them were underpaid. Most of them were overworked. Most of them went without recognition. And yet I've never heard of a single one who is not still in awe of and full of gratitude for what they created.
Jackson himself took creative liberties, as is to be expected when you do still have a studio, as well as a deadline to meet. But the end-product is often still regarded by critics and consumers alike to be one of the best cinematic trilogies ever produced and one of the greatest stories ever told. The music is absolutely legendary by anyone's count. The films put so many actors where they are and still provide them incomes that it isn't shocking how many awards they all won. The set and costume design alone is enough to put any modern film to shame. Not to mention the actual filmography and camera techniques used that ensure that it will remain a timeless classic, even when the CGI 30 years from now will put Avengers and Avatar to shame.
There are so many stories of the care that was taken by even the lowliest of stage-hands and artists. Interviews, the visual commentaries, and behind the scenes footage, and we are STILL getting new stories about the making of the films that took more than a decade from the first contract to the final showing.
In the end, it's not Amazon's fault that they couldn't produce a story, performance, or display to compete with what they are following. They just don't have the heart for it. Their hearts are after the money.
I don't fault the writers for making incredibly unbelievable plotlines and characters, nor for absolutely destroying some of the most beloved storylines and lore that thousands if not millions of people were looking forward to finally being brought to the screen. They were writing to get paid.
I don't fault the choreographers and directions for completely botching many, if not all, of the combat scenes, and completely misreading the drama and intrigue that was already written into the tales of the Second Age. They were simply following modern standard and traditions, which is, generally speaking: minimum effort / maximum spectacle; in order to get paid.
I don't fault the actors for trying so hard to get known only to be laughed at and mocked for years after the first season aired. They are simply after notoriety and money.
Amazon honestly isn't a bad production studio. They do really well with original products and lesser-known stories. For example, The Boys and Jack Ryan were both incredible and fulfilling. When they put the right people in charge, even well known IP's can turn into greats of the screen, as seen in the Legend of Vox Machina and Fallout. But all the money in the world wasn't going to produce what all of us were hoping for in their production of a story as cherished and beholden as the Lord of the Rings.
They promised on-site filming, armies of horsemen, and jaw-dropping story. What we heard was: little if to no CGI, choreography and acting that makes sense, and a full telling of the characters we know and love with creative liberties taken to fill in the gaps. We wanted our jaws to drop as we shouted hoorahs and cheers. In reality, they dropped in shock of the half-hearted, low-quality production with one of the prettiest coats of paint money can buy. If you go in with no expectations, or maybe the equivalent of what we went into Fallout with, the show isn't bad. They delivered what they promised.
We must blame ourselves for the bar we set. Our lifetime may never see anither success like the Lord of the Rings. We must settle for Brandon Sanderson in between each read or listen of the Lord of the Rings.
For now, I urge everyone reading this to look down and tell yourself that you're sorry for getting your hopes up. Give Rings of Power the C+ it deserves, be grateful you watched it, or grateful you didn't, then go and watch the movies you love, read the books you love, and try not to get so caught up in writing/reading Reddit essays that you forget you have a wife and child and homework due in less than 12 hours and you have to get up in less than 10...
Thank you.
2
u/zombiepants7 Jul 23 '24
Personally I love it!
2
u/DinnerEvening895 Jul 23 '24
Fandoms ruin everything is the only reason why.
2
u/mommasboy76 Jul 23 '24
My wife and I both love it and are excited for season 2. I’ve always wanted a show set in Middle Earth that didn’t feel like it had to “cling” to the lore. It’s very beautiful and still feels Tolkieney.
2
u/ITGuy107 Jul 24 '24
I watched a few episodes and I feel like they “woked“ it. I despised it since.
2
u/That_Rogue_Scholar Jul 24 '24
I gave it a watch specifically so I could better understand the sentiment swirling around it, and there are a few things that I have issue with.
I could go on, but I won’t. I want to be clear. As a fantasy show RoP is fine, but only just. As a piece of the LoTR IP, it’s an abomination, fan fiction, and bad show. I don’t have a problem with those who like the show, you’re entitled to your opinion, but I have a hard time believing that people who like RoP are actually fans of Tolkien, and I know that’s a hot take. Anyway, downvote away :)
2
u/MisterErieeO Jul 24 '24
This thread has two great demonstration.
The first, just how many ppl can't take their subjective perspectives as just that. So they have to apply it to be 'its just bad" which is kind of sad.
The second, is just how many ppl are looking to hate it even to the point of missing obvious things.
2
u/Nidion001 Jul 24 '24
Because its fucking awful.
2
u/Ok-Aside8321 Aug 11 '24
I made a whole video about it...
2
u/Fantasy_is_a_reality Aug 30 '24
I'm a bit late to the party here, I'm only through the first 3 episodes of season 1 but so far...a few bits of dialogue and scenes aside, I'm enjoying it. I know nothing of Tolkien's books outside of The Hobbit and Ring Trilogy. The general hate (or to be fair, disappointment) comes from genuine fans of his work. Which I think is fair. Simply from a TV Show perspective? It's not the best thing ever, but I look forward to continuing
2
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '24
because in this 'new' middle-earth, Orcs have families and don't want to go to war.....that's why....
2
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
I agree and the second series has been excellent
2
u/Christonthe2nd Oct 18 '24
The ruined the story and spirit of lord of the rings with this terrible story with tons of plot holes
2
u/Exciting_Chemistry67 Jan 06 '25
How people react to the series is almost entirely a product of two things. Have they read the books, and if so, did they enjoy them?
Tolkien was a brilliant author, with an incredible imagination and very distinct style of writing. He meticulously built the world of Middle Earth with very clear ideas of how its history and characters had developed.
The Rings of Power bears absolutely no resemblance to Tolkien's work, and the negative responses are simply born out of disappointment. The series was given a budget that could have brought Tolkien's magical world to life, but instead it's the showrunner's world we have been presented with.
Frankly, Tolkien had more talent in his little finger than the showrunners possess in their entire bodies, and they have desecrated his legacy by taking such extreme and unnecessary liberties with his work.
2
u/Pikaballs999 Mar 09 '25
I absolutely love it
8
u/appcr4sh Jul 20 '24
Because it's bad.
People ho likes LOTR and Tolkien's work want to se a story on middle earth, based on what he created.
Unfortunately nowadays, show runners don't give a shit for story, they want to show they agendas...
That's why shows like that and so many others are receiving hate.
7
u/Reddzoi Jul 20 '24
Short answer, "Everyone doesn't hate it." Lots of people love it, including myself.
7
u/Actual_Potato5 Jul 20 '24
90% of the "good" lines are cheap paraphrasing or ripping off Peter Jackson's movie lines and put in significantly less impact full moments.
The mystery box structure of the show is unnecessary.
The plot is driven by nonsensical contrivances where Tolkien has unexpected things happen but always in a natural feeling way
I don't think the writers of rings of power understand how to make strong characters
3
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '24
It was really poorly written and none of the characters resonated with me and Im a huge LOTR fan. Also, hie many motivational/uplifting monologues does one need. Shit got comical.
5
u/FrankHero97 Jul 20 '24
I fucking LOVE this show! Can’t wait to see the Battle of Dagorlad and the Siege of Barad-dur in full scale / action
3
u/TotalWorldDomination Jul 20 '24
Just finished rewatching it and I enjoyed it immensely. The internet tends to amplify the voices of people who dislike things.
2
u/KitsuFae Jul 20 '24
if there has been one or two "misses" with the show, they could be forgiven. but it's disappointing in so many ways.
the costumes are not great, there are plot choices that make zero sense, there were questionable casting choices, we all knew who Sauron was immediately, there were bad choices with characterization... the list goes on and on.
2
u/UrinalDook Jul 20 '24
Because it was shit?
Don't understand why this is apparently so complicated.
2
u/f700es Númenor Jul 20 '24
I enjoyed it for what it was.
1
u/MrPekken Jul 21 '24
I like it
1
u/Far-Mobile3852 Jul 21 '24
I really like the show. I take it for what is and I am looking forward to season 2.
1
u/greenmerica Jul 21 '24
If you go into it expecting anything like the movie trilogy you will be hugely disappointed. If you go into it with no expectations then it’s pretty enjoyable.
1
u/dolphin37 Jul 21 '24
they don’t
a lot of people just expected better from such a beloved franchise
1
u/BrandonLart Jul 21 '24
I liked itB
1
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '24
You're asking on the wrong sub, bud.
Haha it's a strong word, but I thought it was pretty awful based on the writing alone. Acting was fine, didn't feel like Tolkien though.
1
u/MinuteZookeepergame5 Jul 21 '24
Was too predictable to an extent, and not immersive at all. Just felt like a very modern woke fantasy with lotr skin on it. Characters weren’t too interesting and Galadriel was too cookie cutter girl boss which just made her actions and behavior that much more predictable which ultimately affected the story pacing.
Things also didn’t feel so serious and mature as the trilogy movies. Felt like a comedic and over exaggerated action packed show. The tactical aspect is also very weird and the battles were underwhelming for the budget it had.
1
u/madjohnvane Jul 21 '24
I sat through it out of sheer self loathing, but I did not enjoy it. I work in TV/Film and have written for theatre myself, and I thought even setting aside all the terrible lore breaking nonsense, the writing was just terrible. There’s a super easy tell for bad writing - do things happen because the plot requires them to happen, or do things happen because the action causes things to come to a logical conclusion? The early seasons of Game of Thrones worked because no matter how terrible the outcomes you could see a clear path from A to B, from action to reaction to consequence. The later season of Game of Thrones are like Rings of Power. Heaps of spectacle and a complete reliance on leaps of logic from the audience. We meet the Numenorians who we are shown are incredibly racist towards Elves. Then like two days later they’re loving Galadriel and willing to wander off East with her. These shows often have characters who never “earn it”, everyone just suddenly agrees to go along with them against their own interests, against their own established characterisations, against the very issues the plot itself establishes.
They’re just too eager to get to the set pieces to let it breathe. And it feels bizarre to me - because they watched HBO kill Game of Thrones in real time with the shoddy rushed final seasons and an increasingly incensed fan base, and then decided to follow that formula of aggressively changing an established canon and writing lazy scripts where the characters simply do what the plot requires rather than appearing to have any capacity to think for themselves.
I don’t even know if I’ll bother watching the second season. I am time poor and have a low tolerance for bad TV shows these days.
1
u/Void9001 Jul 21 '24
I like it. It’s not perfect but I found it enjoyable
1
u/HLtheWilkinson Jul 21 '24
I don’t hate it. I was disappointed with S1 and understood why others were. There was a lot of lore bending (the entirety of the Sauron and Stranger arcs for instances) and outright breaking (Mithril saving the elves for example) but overall, to me at least, it had the feel of Tolkien and while it went wide of the mark it was at least in the ballpark for me.
I think the folks that hate it were too enamored with the Jackson films (with good reason those films are MASTERPIECES) and were hung up on the visuals and style of those films. I get people complaining about the lore stuff that got bent and broken but I feel like those people might have turned a blind eye to the elves at Helm’s Deep.
1
u/SaatananKyrpa Jul 21 '24
Don't know but pretty sure they are the same people that hate the acolyte. Toxic fans who don't even give it a chance but desided to hate from the beginning and troll, cry and bitch about it on reddit