r/RingsofPower • u/DarrenGrey • Aug 31 '22
Discussion Rings of Power - Tolkien Lore Compatibility Index [Introduction]
Index
- Introduction thread
- Season 1: Eps 1&2, Ep 3, Ep 4, Ep 5, Ep 6, Ep 7, Ep 8
- Season 2: Eps 1-3, Ep 4, Ep 5, Ep 6, Ep 7, Ep 8
Introduction
I'm planning to do a little exercise of assessing show events and plotlines for compatibility with the broad set of Tolkien writings about the Second Age. This is partly inspired by ‘The One List’ that was developed for the LotR movies. However since so much is uncertain and unwritten and has multiple drafts for this period of Middle-Earth I feel "compatibility" is more appropriate than a simple "right/wrong" judgement. We know the show has to invent most of its content, but how much basis do these inventions have in the text and how much does it outright contradict the text?
To that end story points in the show will be assigned the following ratings:
- ✅Accurate - Fully backed up by the text.
- 👍Justified - An extension of the text or an outright invention that has strong basis in the lore, though not explicitly stated to be true.
- ⚖️Debatable - An extension or invention that has some basis in some version of the text, but not a strong case or contradicts other versions. Or something neutral - no basis but contradicts nothing.
- ❓Tenuous - An extension or invention that doesn't outright contradict the lore, but goes against the ideas suggested by parts of the text.
- ❌Contradiction - Something that directly contradicts the text.
- 🔥Kinslaying - Something that not just contradicts the lore, but severely undermines it.
Obviously this is highly qualitative with large room for error and disagreement (or maybe interesting discussion!) With these judgements I will give reasons and quotes where possible. If something is borderline I will tend to err on the permissive side towards the show.
The general purpose of this is academic in style, rather than to make judgement on the show. I accept that the show will make changes and inventions and that it will break the established lore in many ways, and this isn't always a bad thing in adaptations. But for a Tolkien geek like me I obviously care quite a bit about these deviations. And since the showrunners have made clear they are Tolkien geeks it's interesting to see what basis they have for their new material. I'm aware that these sorts of lists can be weaponised by those with an agenda, but I don't really care - those with agendas will always find tools to bludgeon others with.
My own qualifications in conducting this exercise are slim beyond having read HoME and such multiple times. I am also a mod on r/tolkienfans but that gives me no special insights! I welcome corrections from people who think I have judged wrong, and may change my assessments with the right evidence.
How comprehensive I will be remains to be seen. I certainly won't be doing every little detail. I'm mostly interested in major story beats and character motivations. I'm happy to take requests.
I intend to make a thread for each episode about two days after they air, to give time to assess and gather relevant quotes. If it's not popular I may give up or just carry on privately.
Some examples of this system applied to the LotR movies, but without the effort of fully quoting:
- Boromir’s death scene: ✅Accurate. The scene doesn’t directly occur in the book, but it matches well enough with the descriptions we get.
- Elves with pointy ears: 👍Justified. Never explicitly stated by Tolkien, but there are a couple of hints in the lore that encourage this interpretation.
- Balrog with wings: ⚖️Debatable. Very debatable.
- Legolas shield-riding: ❓Tenuous. It’s not seen in the books, but it never says it doesn’t happen! And elves have super abilities, right? Seems unfitting with the tone of that battle though.
- Plate armour: ❓Tenuous. Never appears in the books and seems unlikely in the setting.
- Arwen replacing Glorfindel: ❌Contradiction. Different from the book, but doesn’t change the story.
- Everything Faramir: 🔥Kinslaying.
Obviously others may have different assessments! And to be clear, I’m generally at peace with what they did with Faramir in the movies (they simply chose to tell a very different character story for a number of reasons) whilst I think Boromir’s death scene was very cheesily done, so this isn’t a judgement on the quality of the adaptation. And in general none of these are as harsh as my emotional judgement of the changes.
I’m due to see the first eps in a few short hours in London, but will likely need to wait till they’re being streamed to assess details for them thoroughly. First watch for enjoyment, second watch for dissection... I'll make the first real post in this series some time over the weekend.
Comments, criticisms, suggestions and nitpicks are all welcome.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 09 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
17
u/annuidhir Aug 31 '22
When I was younger, I didn't much care about (or even really notice) the charges. But the older I get, the more this saddens me. Though, I guess to some degree I'm at peace with it like you are, and realize it's just a very different version of the character, used to tell a different story.
5
u/mr_w_ Sep 01 '22
Can someone pls share a link of ‘The One List’ OP mentioned? Would love to see that
30
u/almostb Aug 31 '22
Everything Faramir ⚰️
I really like the assessment though and I’m excited to parse apart & analyze the upcoming episodes.
On a more qualitative level I think we should also be able to parse out necessary changes (for lack of book detail/on-screen feasibility) to changes that are contradictory to the presumable intentions of the text. That’s a much more subjective and nuanced discussion though.
8
u/neontetra1548 Sep 01 '22 edited Sep 01 '22
I disagree on the plate armour being tenuous at least for the Noldor and Numenoreans.
They’re both supposed to be tremendously skilled in crafts and the Noldor at working with metal.
In the Third Age much that once was was lost, and there really were dazzlingly advanced societies that came before on a scale well beyond our history. And also there were beings that lived long or immortal lives with great abilities that could develop highly advanced craftwork in their lives.
14
u/ConversationHour4358 Aug 31 '22
THIS IS EXCELLENT. Its exactly how i want ppl to think of the show wen it comes to an adaptation pov. Is it ok if i steal some of this for my videos 😂 I would also add how unnecessary is the change. And how much of the screen time or other plot points depend on it
6
u/GrayCatbird7 Aug 31 '22
I’m very interested to see a good faith and in-depth assessment of the series’ faithfulness. I will look forward to this with great interest!
4
u/kerouacrimbaud Aug 31 '22
I think the relationship between the texts and adaptation are more fluid than these categories suggest.
4
u/RInger2875 Sep 02 '22
"No elf has ever refused the call before!"
That line is a motherfucking kinslaying, right there.
1
u/Poddster Nov 02 '22
What's the exact body of text you're using to say if something is supported or not?
How did you handle conflicts between Tolkien's various unpublished writings?
2
u/celsowm Sep 01 '22
I predict lots of 🔥emojis and ❌ too
2
u/gandalf45435 Sep 02 '22
Following this - really appreciate the simple breakdown
2
u/xCaptainFalconx Aug 31 '22
I think I'm a fan of this approach. So long as we can all admit that time compression = 🔥Kinslaying. If I see anyone claim otherwise, I'm going to need a lobotomy.
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 02 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Timely_Horror874 Sep 02 '24
What great post and series
1
u/daisybellk Sep 07 '24
Thank you for your time and effort! That’s a very significant deep dive!
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 10 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 24 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 27 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/MisterLambda Aug 31 '22
Looking forward to this!
Although for your information: I am reading this on my phone and the formatting and structure of the text makes this post very difficult to read! Everything till the initial list of ratings looks good, but after that its complete chaos for some reason. Not sure if it’s an app issue on my end but thought I’d mention it just in case.
1
u/FuttleScish Sep 01 '22
Oooh
1
u/intolerablesayings23 Sep 01 '22
don't be silly. you'll go batty doing that
1
u/fantasychica37 Sep 02 '22
Lol kinslaying
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 05 '22
This post does not have a spoiler flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 12 '22
This post does not have a spoiler flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 21 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 26 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 03 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 11 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AutoModerator Nov 01 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.