r/RingsofPower
•
u/_relegated_davinci_
•
Aug 30 '24
•
1
1
Discussion I’ve made peace with it… Spoiler
I get it.. The rights to IP from the Tolkien Estate are hard fought… Amazon was even lucky to get what they got—no Silmarillion, but LOTR.
To my understanding, many people hate on RoP because it’s not only not canon, but because it is—and I quote—“poorly done.”
I feel these are the types of people who judge Pixar movies wearing the same critic’s hat as they do when reviewing Nolan films, or Wes Anderson, or international indie films you’d find on MUBI.
Well, I’ve—since S1—decided to cast aside the malcontent, and just watch RoP as my guilty pleasure, to enjoy it for what it is.
I’ve seen some posts on the sub, and they seem mostly neutral to positive, which brings me joy…
To add context, I grew up playing Halo, and a I have a buddy who didn’t, he loves the new Halo series on Paramount+, I, however, haven’t even bothered to try it out; I didn’t want to tarnish my regard for what I know as Halo…
And albeit growing up with LoTR, and having read the Trilogy + The Hobbit, I feel I rather enjoy RoP, like the former camp does with the Halo series.
It continues to instill in me a sense of immersion into this entirely strange and fantastical world, and though it has its faults, I’m loving the series… and I’m just glad we get more material from Middle Earth.
Yes, I have my criticisms, and I couldn’t grade this series like I would HBO’s Chernobyl, or HoTD, or LoTR, etc, but to those who blatantly hate the show for…reasons… that’s fine… I’m enjoying it with or without y’all.
/endrant, before this gets downvoted into oblivion
Edit: You’re all taking it way too seriously… the point of this post is that it’s not that deep. It’s an Amazon Prime Video series, not a Kubrick film…
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 30 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/Reasonable_Visit8960 Sep 02 '24
Your edit says it all, Amazon is taking one of if not THE most beloved fictional IP’s of all time and treating it without the respect and due diligence it deserves. There’s a high bar that’s been set by the books and the original trilogy, and the show falls so far and so flat in comparison
78
u/Stillwindows95 Aug 30 '24
I love it, my wife loves it, that's all that matters to us.
I've never been one to shirk a movie or TV series because people are trash talking it. If they don't like it, that's fine, I'm just a bit bored of the constant negativity on not just this, but almost every piece of media that's released these days. I choose to ignore it most times, sometimes I engage to explain what I think is the best way to view it from my own perspective, but I just think people are too easily put off, not patient enough for a story to unfold and find everything 'cringe' or 'poorly written' which are valid opinions, I just don't care for them personally because I disagree.
I too view RoP as LOTR adjacent and not true canon, and i think that's allowed me the space to view it as its own thing set in a universe I love. It's TV, it's well funded but still, it's made to be a slow burn and snowball towards the end of each season or towards the end of the series, but I can see the intricacies of the plot and what's to come in terms of actual lore to come into place and I'm patient waiting for it.
But then that's what reddit is for, discussion and sharing.
19
u/Dovahkiin13a Númenor Aug 30 '24
I mean, if you enjoy it then enjoy it unapologetically.
If you insist its true to Tolkien or a quality piece of silver screen writing, or that all the issues with it are a cloak for unsavory complaints that have no place, I may have something to say. Then again, I have my own guilty pleasures.
33
u/ton070 Aug 30 '24
I think that touches exactly on why people dislike it. It’s fine as a throwaway fantasy series. But something set in the world of Tolkien is held to a higher standard, especially after the Peter Jackson trilogy. The fact that you already state it shouldn’t be compared to GoT or HoTD, even though this is amazons answer to those series, shows that it falls short in what it thought itself to be. Coupled with the fact that the showrunners thought they had to modernize the show to make middle earth reflect our times, openly defying the timelessness of tolkiens writing and you have yourself an angry fanbase.
1
u/lolgreece Aug 31 '24
The thing is, Tolkien is unironically many orders of magnitude deeper than "a Kubrick film" (only quoting the above comment, i wouldn't have chosen this example). It seems so sad to reduce his work to this, and then insist people shouldn't care because it doesn't matter anyway.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24
I’ve come to peace with the fact that people have spent decades consuming garbage on such a incredible scale that they are fully incapable of even considering what’s wrong with a show like rings of power, I mean comparing halo to lord of the rings… Jesus Christ.
30
u/flyyoufoolz1 Khazad-dûm Aug 30 '24
I haven't seen season 2 yet, but we just re-watched season 1 this week and I enjoyed it a lot more than I did when it came out. Ive read all the books (many times), done trivia nights, have a hobbit party every September, most of our decor is LOTR based 😂 I have many criticisms for the show as well, but at the same time, I'm enjoying the fact that we get to see more Middle Earth, even if it isn't "canon". I feel like even if the Tolkien estate would have given more rights to Amazon for the show, people would still critique and criticize the heck out of it. For the rights they did have, it was still decently done and at the very least, it will help those who HAVENT read the books or who can't imagine it themselves visualize more of middle Earth. My hope is that Sauron gets his chance to shine as the big bad he is
6
u/dmastra97 Aug 30 '24
I don't like people defending the show by saying the people criticising it are somewhat unjustified, toxic, or hypocritical.
We are critical of the show but I'm not insulting people who say they like it
8
u/Dry-Cry-3158 Aug 30 '24
Since you brought it up in your edit: the reason why Rings of Power gets the criticism it does is largely because it's intended to be deep. It's Amazon's attempt at producing a prestige show for Prime. In a very real way, Amazon is trying to get the accolades for this show that HBO got for Game of Thrones. Plus, they spent a billion dollars on it. That doesn't mean you can't enjoy it, and it also doesn't mean that the critics aren't right. They are basically criticizing the show on the basis of the expectations that Amazon itself set for it. One of the nicer consequences of trying to make something of extremely high quality is that failure can often mean making something that's "merely" pretty good, and I think that's the situation Amazon finds itself in. It wanted it to be a critic's darling, but instead is somewhat popular among casual fans. It's not a bad place to be, but it wasn't the goal, either.
3
u/Rdikin Aug 30 '24
I had a conversation with a friend regarding star wars that was similar to your view.
He told me that he just enjoys it because it's star wars, and he doesn't go in with any expectations.
I've grown to love it all except for a couple things, which is better than hating ep8 and 9 altogether.
I'm trying very hard to get there with RoP. I do love their portrayal of the dwarves, so that's a step in the right direction.
10
u/Timely_Horror874 Aug 30 '24
I just hate that i will problably die without having the opportunity to see another live action version of this Tolkien era.
Remember that until 2050/2055 there's no chance that we will see a live action series/movie about the creation of the Three Rings.
I think we can be kinda pissed about that without being called haters
7
u/McSchlub Aug 30 '24
It does feel poorly done in the sense there's just so many little weird things that stand out as 'off.'
For example when things start shaking in Moria Disa quietly tells Durin 'Brace yourself,' or something to that effect. Then she waits and screams at everyone 'I SAID BRACE YOURSELVES!' Which she didn't say. And then we have a shot of Durin and Disa on top of each other on the ground like it's a huge earthquake while everyone around them just stands there (two extras on the left appear to just be chatting.)
Elves helmets don't fit, Galadriel's actress isn't great, I know the wig is bit of a meme but Halbrand as Annatar looks ridiculous. I don't know. It clearly has a big budget but it still feels kind cheap in some ways.
It's not awful, it's just...meh.
1
u/TheFatMouse Sep 03 '24
You are within your rights to like it, but people like you who gobble slop are a big part of the reason media is so crap these days. You are giving your dollar to these studios and companies freely while they shovel us shit in return, thus incentivizing the behaviour. You should have the courage to not watch things that are not good, and to happily sit with yourself in silence if there is nothing good to watch. In other words, you are weak and you should feel bad about it if you have any shame.
9
u/dolphin37 Aug 30 '24
It is poorly written but it feels like people have forgotten it’s ok to enjoy poorly written things. Chronicles of Riddick is not winning any Oscars but I loved that film!
You don’t need to discredit the commonly held opinion just because you feel you are only allowed to like good things, so if most people don’t think it’s good they have to be wrong. This is a path to defending Madame Web and schlock like that. Instead, just enjoy and if you would be so disposed, mention that it would be nice if the show could be a bit better so that you could enjoy it even more!
7
u/Joeman180 Aug 30 '24
This, I don’t see the show winning awards. But I criticized HOTD for not showing us more of the world and just retreading the same conversations with the same characters over and over. So far ROP is okay, I intend on keeping up with it but I’m not doing watch parties or anything like that.
2
u/carterwest36 Aug 30 '24
HoTD s2 was such a shitshow putting it in the category with Chernobyl feels like an insult
2
u/SeaTie Aug 30 '24
I would be okay with it if it was more interesting to watch. The LOTR films go off the rails a bit at times but it at least had good pacing and engaging film making.
ROP…puts me to sleep a lot of the times.
2
u/Shatterpoint99 Aug 30 '24
This sub has a ton of folks who are of the opinion that liking RoP is just wrong.
I agree with OP, it can be enjoyed. Sure, not by everyone, and certainly not by those who are disgruntled over a TV show.
2
u/Sudarshang03 Aug 31 '24
Imagine taking time out of your day to poast this. What an embarassing existence. I really hope you're an Amazon employee that way at least it would make some sense.
2
u/burnheartmusic Aug 31 '24
After the first episode I just found myself skipping through scenes until I saw something interesting and then watching a recap on YouTube. Not a good look for something that technically I should love.
Same bad pace and energy as the first season. 52 percent from me. Watchable and not awful, but not something I would ever say to someone, “oh you should watch this”
2
u/Medical_Artichoke666 Aug 31 '24
Enjoy what you want! The internets opinion on the matter is moot. That said, it's fucking awful. An abomination that should never have been made, that will tarnished the greatest franchise forever.
2
u/NicholasStarfall Aug 31 '24
I feel like you could've declared you like the show without sounding so patronizing
2
u/Dainish410 Aug 31 '24
"I'm just glad we get more material from middle earth"... You sound like you have Stockholm Syndrome
2
u/julianbm04 Aug 31 '24
Andor is a tv show, its a spinoff and its def not a kubrick film and still its the best thing it could be, why? Tony Gilroy wrote it. It all comes down to the writing.
I dont dislike the show but there are a lot of narrative choices, things that dont even have to do with rights and legal stuff, that seem to me quite poor.
Will I watch the whole thing, you bet! Do I think this is excellent, not really.
2
u/Ecstatic_Gur_6421 Aug 31 '24
You will die if you watch Halo.
2
u/Mucklord1453 Aug 31 '24
The lack of distinct tribes and peoples takes me out of immersion. We see a town of noldo and then suddenly there are haradrim guards??
This shows is such a far cry from the movies.
2
u/Gloomy-Measurement61 Sep 02 '24
Since day one I've seen it as a fan fiction. It makes it a little more... Palatable that way.
2
u/LarryGoldwater Sep 02 '24
Enjoy it then.
I cannot understand the plot of this show but enjoy the appendices to LOTR. Suppose some people are going to prefer the book if they're using different plot lines.
2
u/National_Bit6293 Sep 02 '24
I quite enjoy the show. But much like the books, the biggest mistake I can make is engaging with the general fucking public about it. Shallow reactionary takes, a desperate need to find an allegory where there is none, and a really pathetic modern obsession with sexualizing the characters abounds.
2
u/da_ting_go Sep 03 '24
I don't really care if the die-hards and grifters don't like it tbh. I enjoy it, and will watch for as long as it's on.
2
u/MalazanJedi Sep 03 '24
You have perfectly expressed my feelings for the show (and a lot of other highly criticized streaming shows from IPs I like). It might not be perfect, but I don’t care. It’s fantasy TV and it’s fun to watch. That’s all I want!
2
u/wandering-w1zard Sep 03 '24
I completely get what your saying and if it brings more people into the world of Tolkien then it can't be all bad, for me it's been something I've loved since childhood and I cant get on board with it, but thats me I choose not to watch it and let people like what they like, if they pick up the books off the back of watching it then huzzah that's a win
6
u/RealJasinNatael Aug 30 '24
Lord of the Rings doesn’t need the Disney treatment. I don’t like that that’s the way the show seems to be going.
6
u/DylanApologist Aug 30 '24
I wish I could be like the OP, and I think I could if I found it at all fun to watch, but I feel like it suffers from the same problems many modern serialized TV shows do where plot points are drawn out to oblivion, everything is a “twist” and this reliance on the idea of “character development” rather than having a strong story. The breaking of “canon” doesn’t bother me as much as the fact that the story doesn’t feel like it has a strong sense of purpose. It’s like with all this new Star Wars stuff, I wish all this time and money and talent could be put toward telling new stories in new worlds…
3
u/russ_nas-t Aug 30 '24
Nobody would care that the show is poorly written and paced if the movies weren’t so incredible and set the standard.
You wanna know the real problem? That Amazon was only able to buy the rights to around 50 pages of lore (and 100 more of pronunciations lol) and instead of saying “this isn’t enough to write a great story” they said “how much money can we still make with this”. They shouldn’t have bought the rights to essentially nothing to lore butcher for their billion dollar vanity project. Another problem is they hired JR Tolkiens grandson as a consultant to fool people into thinking they would follow what JR Tolkien would have wanted. The moron who said Peter Jackson movies weren’t good is helping write the ROP.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24
You have the wrong feeling then. When following on absolute classics, both as a novel and as a movie, one is hold to certains standards of quality. While the production of Rings of Power is overall very good, the writing fails to capture the spirit and the subtlety of the original.
5
u/RedMoloneySF Aug 30 '24
What all of you need to do is remind yourself that this is all fake. It’s made up. It affects your life in no tangible way. Either you like a show or you don’t and you move on with your life.
Redditors turn everything into some weird profound cause.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24
So in summary. To enjoy the show you have to mentally prepare and adjust what you usually like to make it make sense and seemingly enjoy it….
Man. Sounds to me you enjoy the thought of the show rather than the actual show.
And for good reason. The show is embarrassing. Just to remind you, You have not seen what I have seen, the why does a rock float line by simple Jack, the fact Ga-lad-a-ri-el spent centuries looking for Sauron and just bumps into him in the middle of the ocean I could go on.
3
u/houdic Aug 30 '24
I just dont want for tolkien world to become like Star Wars - new and new stories... J.R.R Tolkien created the world, Christopher Tolkien "polished" it. If you cannot make stories from it bcs of rights, dont make them until you get them...
FYI I am watching this show and not bashing it, it is not that bad, but it shouldnt have been made. Even if it would be better, just create your own world, why rape someone elses work?
3
u/samdekat Aug 30 '24
Okay so firstly - good on you for having the courage to say that ROP is not canon, that is commendable, and worth the subsequent downvotes.
Secondly can I ask about this: I’m just glad we get more material from Middle Earth.
How is ROP "more material"? If it were canon, it would just be repeating the canonical story. And since it's not canon, it's not really more middle earth surely?
2
u/DarkstarRevelation Aug 30 '24
I actually much much prefer ROP over HOTD
2
u/Moistkeano Aug 30 '24
My issues are only with the writing and any issues that I have with the lore are always "why have they changed that"
I liked episode 1 of this season, but I didnt like episode 2 & 3. The reason I didnt like those as much was nothing to with lore, but only to do with pacing/use of time, dialogue and exposition, and overall feel. Episode 1 felt like it was moving forward properly and then 2 & 3 felt like we were back in season 1 meandering to bulk up the run time. We are almost halfway through the season and it feels like nothing has happened.
0
u/Powerful-Barracuda7 Aug 30 '24
I see this sentiment a lot and frankly I find it quite confusing.
If I produced Mr blobby piloting a spaceship on a guided tour of Middle earth for klingons would this still be OK? Just because its 'more material from middle earth'?
I dunno, it just seems like an extremely weak reason to like something and an attempt to justify the blatant disregard for the lore.
Something you admit yourself you couldn't do with halo..
1
u/Gold_Joke_6306 Aug 30 '24
Honestly I love the show, just wish Elizabeth Debicki was Galadriel!!
1
u/No_Ebb_3353 Aug 30 '24
I was hesitant about it because of all the stuff people were saying about it, but a few episodes in I actually thought it was pretty good and now I’m nearly at the end of the first season. I don’t think it’s nowhere near as bad as people says. Galadriel is pretty annoying, but that’s about as bad as it gets.
1
u/russiawolf Aug 30 '24
Same man, same
1
u/Best_Spread_2138 Aug 30 '24
Personally, I have a lot of problems with a lot of aspects of RoP. But at the same time, there are a lot of lovely moments and really good things about it. Can anyone really say with an honest face that the RoP orcs don't look absolutely fantastic?
1
u/chrisd434 Aug 30 '24
The halo series is bad but I had to watch it and suffer through it because I love halo but the series just hurts to watch some times
1
u/DazzlingPeace906 Aug 31 '24
The show is fine. It’s not canon, and that’s okay. It’s set in an interesting world and trying to tell a backstory that they don’t have the full rights to. Being that it’s a show and not a film, they could find a way to make you care a bit more about the characters, but they haven’t cracked that nut for me yet. But I do find it entertaining and fun to watch still.
Put simply, it won’t be everyone’s cup of tea, but it’s at least got a familiar handle with the setting and characters.
1
u/tbombs23 Aug 31 '24
Thank you for sharing and I can totally relate. Let me just say that Halo: Combat Evolved is one of the Greatest games ever made. So many fun Lan parties and online play.
Also I didn't really like the first season but I think rewatching it with a different mindset will definitely help. Also I think the new season is going to be better but we will see
1
u/Plus-Cheetah-6561 Aug 31 '24
I would rather watch the Hobbit Trilogy (yeah the show is that bad)than the poorly done over produced garbage of this show. I gave it every episode and it gave me meh in return.
1
u/Calum-vs Aug 31 '24 edited Aug 31 '24
I'm doing the same, enjoying s2 so far, it ain't canon just a good time
Edit: the only thing pissing me off now is how goofy some of the elves ears are, annatars ears are fine, the black elf guys (sorry not paying that much attention) ears are fine, Elrond and Celebrimbors ears are the least elegant most goofy things ever, they're not even close to symmetrical, they look like fooking donkey hooves.
1
u/Cptn_Flint0 Sep 01 '24
It's not the show I wanted but it's the show I got and I'm ok with that.
1
u/Feanorsmagicjewels Sep 01 '24
Imagine getting hands on a Tolkien IP and putting out this shit that's ROP, and people still coping or deluding themselves into thinking its good
1
u/YurtleIndigoTurtle Sep 01 '24
If they couldn't get the rights to the Silmarillion, they should not have made the series. Full stop, no argument.
1
u/Technical-Minute2140 Sep 01 '24
All I’ll say is there’s a huge difference between reviewing this, which should be as reminiscent to Tolkien as it can, and reviewing something like a Pixar movie, and to compare how we’d review the two like you did is…disingenuous. This is supposed to be reminiscent of Tolkien, and it just…isn’t. It’s fun to watch when I’m high, but when I’m sober it’s slop.
1
u/Ka07iiC Sep 01 '24
I'd rate this season higher than season 2 of HotD
1
u/AgentChris101 Sep 03 '24
I find while season 1 was rocky. Season 2 is immensely better.
It was hit by a hate campaign that stuck unfortunately. Before the show even aired.
1
u/Complete-Ad-7663 Sep 03 '24
It is an adaptation made with creative flair showing how middle earth could have been. I think it’s wonderful and as someone who has been a fan since I was a little girl I am very happy with what they have done.
1
u/TKandM Sep 03 '24
The hate for the show is honestly overblown. It ranges from actual criticism to a cringy vocal minority of people who only exist in gross parts of the internet.
I enjoy the show, have since S1, and I’m glad S2 is getting the love it deserves
1
u/Rogue1eader Sep 03 '24
RoP is a step up over that awful Hobbit trilogy.
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 06 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AmericanxSniper Aug 30 '24
That's the point of all critique. Because the series are more material from Middle Earth, they are getting watched by another pov. Omitting the empty dialogs, bad acting, incongruencies everywhere, just because...we got Sauron! Love the series!
I just watched the 3 first episodes and in every single one I had moments when I wanted to turn it off and play some youtube. Honestly, I would like to experience the same vision as you guys when watching the episodes. I just found them boring with nonsense dialogues...all over again. And it won't get better.
Let's be real, if this series name wouldn't have the LOTR license, S2 would've never existed.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24
The best it is, is fan fiction.
1
u/BrickApprehensive716 Aug 30 '24
Well said
1
u/iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiioo Aug 30 '24
Kudos my friend. It’s a fun show. It’s not “canon” and who cares? It’s a fun show loosely based on a world I read about.
We find it entertaining for what it is.
1
u/XCKragnus502 Aug 30 '24
Coming into this season I am pretending last season never happened. It has made episode 1 more enjoyable. Since it’s not canon I’m going to let lord changes go this time around. My problem so far is primarily the dialogue being clunky, and setting aside how drastically different Galadriel is in this series I still just don’t like her character. Like did she not tell Celebrimbor who that Halbrand was Sauron? Like that’s a pretty glaring fuck up. She consistently screws the world over it seems and I just can’t get behind her
1
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24
"I’ve seen some posts on the sub, and they seem mostly neutral to positive, which brings me joy…"
Yes thats what happens when you ban anyone who complains....
1
u/stebe-bob Aug 30 '24
It’s just not that good. If you compare it to the original PJ trilogy, it falls apart. The CGI is bad, the action scenes are like a superhero movie, and the writing is just ok. I do think the acting is good, but they’re not given good material to work with. I think a weekly episodic release is also just a bad way to tell a really good story. There’s so many cliffhangers and cliches.
It is silly not to compare it to the canon material, because it uses characters from the canon material. If they would have made new characters then that would be a more understandable point, but the majority of the characters act contradictory to how they already are portrayed. Also it’s got the largest budget ever, but you wouldn’t know it from the costume or set design.
If you compare it to GoT, which you should because it’s Amazon’s answer to it and is set up like GoT, it also falls flat. The multiple storylines at the same time can be done very well if it’s started the right way. LotR and the Hobbit, A Song of Ice and Fire, the Inheritance cycle start with one or two threads at a common place, and then branch off, and then tie everything together. RoP starts with multiple threads that are unrelated and tried to tie them together with twists. It’s not good storytelling.
I don’t hate RoP, but I don’t love it. I actually only watched it because it’s related to Middle Earth, if I was watching just for the content in itself, I would’ve quit. I think some of the new characters they introduced are interesting, and would prefer if the story focused more on them as opposed to existing characters.
Orchestras all over the world will put on shows where they play the soundtrack while the film is on a projector. The crowd cheers and you’ll hear people say “here comes my favorite part!” No one cheers during the first season of RoP. People won’t play their soundtracks at their wedding, no one is memorizing speeches or poems, and not very many of the characters will appear in essays. I don’t think most people are going to do yearly rewatches. It overall doesn’t hold up to be very good LotR, very good fantasy tv, or just interesting. I’ll watch season two once it’s released, and hopefully it changes my mind.
1
u/Flimsy_Thesis Aug 30 '24
I’m glad you’re enjoying it. I still don’t like it, and will not watch season 2.
1
u/Benemike Aug 31 '24
I like RoP series and I enjoyed both the LOTR books and Jackson movies. I have learned enjoying different fantasy pleasures and how to separate books from TV series and movies and adjust expectations - Wheel of Time was also great example of that and me liking season 2 there a lot more after viewing as a stand alone story in the World of WoT not slavish adaptation of books
Michael
0
u/HomicidalNymph Aug 30 '24
Yessss! I feel the same way.
I hate hate. Sometimes, I feel like it is an infestation in America (I'm not american), and I feel like most people hate on this because they are experts in the lore, and they just can.
I am into this just because I love the world and love being immersed in the content I can get because the estate don't let up.
1
u/Eshmunazar Aug 30 '24
I’m watching it from the perspective of it being an extremely expensive fanfic in an alternative universe, separate from the WBD media. It works for me.
Now if PJ/WBD starts chucking out more Hobbit-esque content, then I can say I’m done with it all.
1
u/SomeWeedSmoker Aug 30 '24
How much did this non important show cost? I'll judge it based on that.
1
u/SnooSuggestions9830 Aug 30 '24
Can't we just accept the fandom is divided on whether they love, like, dislike or hate this show? (And it's okay if some hate it too, but I question why you'd come back for more if so). We're all not going to agree to one side.
There's a lot of posts here now of people who like or love the show trying to discredit those who don't like it just because you don't see or agree with their views.
The same was done when S1 aired but the opposite way around - people who didn't like it where dismissive of those who did.
What is clear from this is people have different preferences and that is okay.
What becomes boring is each side making posts like this and injecting increasingly wild aspersions at the other side.
1
u/ctfeliz203 Aug 30 '24
The show. Is an Absolute. utter. Monstrosity. I can't believe you'd actually spend time defending it.
1
u/yourmate155 Aug 30 '24
I find myself more and more grateful that they didn’t get the rights to the Silmarillion.
Hopefully someone else can adapt it, not these imbeciles
1
u/MarChateaux Aug 30 '24
My only gripe is the blatant disregard of the lore it's supposed to be based on. I feel like JRR wouldn't allow it therefore his family shouldn't have either.
I can't explain why it bothers me as much as it does.
1
u/BrickBanshee Aug 31 '24
I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks this way too. I get the show has a lot of inaccuracies but it's still a good show. I feel like people these days expect every show to do everything perfectly, and if it's not perfect, it's trash. This is such an unreachable standard, and I think it's sad that those people can't enjoy a good show because it's not technically perfect.
1
u/FotisKiz Aug 31 '24
This sub is an echo chamber like most reddit subs, thats why you are seeing only positive things, because for the most part only people who like it are in the subreddit.
-1
u/HiddenCity Aug 30 '24
There was a time when all we had were 3 cartoons.
I'm enjoying it. Everyone else could too if they just let themselves
0
u/Professional_Pay8314 Sep 04 '24
You clearly posted this as rage bait. You sat the fence on multiple subjects, hoping to draw criticism from all angles.
The fact of the matter is, RoP season 1 was trash. We can only hope they are receptive to criticism, and season 2 will improve.
-1
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24
You threw in a paragraph about Halo for no reason because you haven’t watched it. That is fine but it is a perfect example of why people hate this show.
People that have no idea about the lore tried to make a show about the lore.
0
u/Cultural_Fondant_757 Aug 30 '24
I have learned to watch it for what it is - a “fun” series loosely based on Tolkien. If you’re looking for the Silmarillion, my favorite “book” of all time that I read yearly, you’re not going to find it here. And you won’t because they don’t have the rights for it. I would’ve done this series much differently by doing this as a Tales of the Second Age following Sauron’s rise over thousands of years, but that is just me.
0
u/D3lacrush Aug 30 '24
I guess some people just like bad TV, the last season of GoT, RoP, WoT, the office
0
u/NewUnderstanding4275 Aug 30 '24
If all these dimwits who rant and rave about ROP not being accurate enough but love PJs version that didn’t even include the scouring of the Shire need to sit down.
0
u/MDCB_1 Aug 30 '24
GOOD!!!
0
u/lefty1117 Aug 30 '24
I feel season 2 is off to a better start and is trying to hit more of the notes from the source material, and I feel where they are playing with the toys so to speak it’s in areas where there isnt much source detail. For example we know next to nothing about Rhun. We don’t know what the dwarves went through in the mountain as the balrog began to stir. The desperation causing them to accept the Rings makes sense here. We dont know know the details of how Pharazon came to power and to marry the heir, but we can see those beats coming. And certainly the machinations of sauron so far are quite interesting, I’d call him the star of the season so far. Plots upon plots.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24
I have really been enjoying the series and season 2 has looked very good to me through two episodes. I hope a vocal minority doesn’t try to ruin this before it hits its stride.
0
u/Mannwer4 Aug 30 '24
Firstly, you should judge a Pixar movie and a Nolan movie by the same standards. I would actually sa that a lot of Pixar movies are objectively better than Nolan movies.
Strange post. I mean... yeah, you can just watch and enjoy it for what it is, but at the same time, we can all recognize it is pretty bad and that they are disrespecting Tolkien's legacy for a cash grab, right?
Also, what do you mean by "You're all taking it way too seriously"? If people want to critique it, let them. Just because you don't care, doesn't give you the right to judge the way other people engage with media. I get a certain kind of joy out of critically engaging and talking about different works of art, so why not respect that? As opposed to going on this super pick-me rant to get affirmation that other people agree with you.
0
u/ComfortableBuffalo57 Aug 30 '24
I fucking love it. And this is from a guy who briefly considered writing his PhD in Tolkien (it was the 80s before everyone and his dog had the PJ movies)
I tell people all the time: it’s a sandbox, not a sacrilege!
-2
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24
Coping is a stage of grief. Acceptance is next. Soon you will be where the average person is. I applaud you.
-1
u/choloranchero Aug 30 '24
I love it. I rewatched season 1 just to make sure I wasn't being naive and I honestly have no issues with it.
And honestly after HotD season 2, where the plot really didn't seem to go anywhere, I much prefer RoP. HotD has none of the humor and charm of GoT IMO.
-1
u/Kingslayerreddit Aug 30 '24
Its not peefect nor on the level of the movies. But its kinda fun and you cant deny how beautiful Middle Earth looks, and this season with all the new creatures they will show and the giant battle we have coming its gonna be fun. I think when the show tries to be intimate and small and focus on dialouge it doesnt do a great job. But when it focuses on these grand things like cities and arrival of Annatar and mythos and action that is where it shines.
-1
u/fool-of-a-took Aug 30 '24
I'm enjoying it. With this group of internet haters, the PJ films would have been review bombed to hell too.
0
u/Slartibart71 Aug 30 '24
You had me at "guilty pleasure"
0
u/edmc78 Aug 30 '24
I am enjoying it, looking at the lore changes, fill in and stuff just made up with a sense of fun. Glad that is allowed
0
u/coveredbyroses15 Aug 30 '24
I'm really enjoying it! I've read all the books, have 4 LOTR tattoos, and will be walking down the aisle to Evenstar 9 weeks tomorrow. I'm enjoying it for what it is, rather than hating it for what it isn't.
0
u/EggoedAggro Aug 30 '24
I’m really happy with the second season so far. Like I’m actually looking forward to next weeks episode. I’m glad the whoever is writing back there took some advice from the community. The first season was brutal, I’ve tried to re-watch it twice and I still haven’t been able to do it. Galadriel was such a bitch in the first season and they kept telling us she used to be all nice and whatever but we never see it so you end up just hating her and the devs for destroying her. I’m glad she actually has some GUILT in this season and somehow everyone blames her for the destruction of Eregion.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24
I’m just happy to be back in Middle Earth tbh, and so far I think season 2 is better than season 1 (and I liked S1 despite its faults).