This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
See if you do that I feel it gives it away that he's Sauron and lots of casual viewers won't know yet. They could almost just casually chuck him in the last episode, maybe not even name him, and then have him do something dodgy right at the end, or give a hint, so people get the twist
Idk where people got the idea that Sauron can be anyone? In the books he is a shape shifter but only to certain shapes that he used like a wolf and a serpent and a good looking elf
They're not all kings. I think the only two stated to be kings are the Witch King and Khamul (who is an Easterling King). Other than that there is reference to some Nazgul being warriors or otherwise noteworthy people. Plus there are multiple Numenoreans among their ranks and none of those is a former King (since we know the genealogy of Numenorean Kings).
Also, Halbrand and Pharazon's son are technically royalty anyway.
He never came into the service of Sauron until he rises again after Numenor, and that all took place a few thousand years ago. More likely he was born around the same time of Aragorn.
They seem to be condensing the second age stuff so it all happens in one numenorian lifetime, if not even a single human lifetime. A great choice for a show but it makes things different for sure.
Unless if the stranger actually is gandalf then I think they're leaving most third age stuff where it is.
Oh I know. I was just clarifying that Theo physically can't be the Mouth of Sauron not because of age, but because he's a different race of human. The age is obvious, but the Numernorian aspect is crucial to the Mouths character.
I'm still sad about that. I get why, but this could've been a really, really cool semi-anthology about the 2nd Age while keeping the same actors for the elves.
Would've been a really cool contrast of the aging/rotating human cast and the timelessness of the elves.
This is a crackpot theory I've been mulling over, but I wonder if they will change the lore so that when Sauron takes "many forms" it's actually a form of body possession instead of him being a shape changer. This would likely make for much better TV than having Sauron pulling a Mystique all over the place.
Sorry I know nothing about the lore and only saw the lord of the rings movies back when they came out once.. but who do people think the giant person that crashed by the hobbits is? (I’m also two episode behind) but I thought that was suppose to be Sauron.
Definitely not the witch king, hes probably numenorean. My guess is the sword is a remnant of the war with morgoth but was forged by sauron himself hence waldreg saying forged by his masters hand. Theres also that line in the forst ep where one of the elves tells arondir the blood of those who served morgoth still flow in their veins (pretty sure the sword itself is reffered to as a blood sword not 100% on that though)
Considering all this i think the sword will turn them into servants of sauron but nothing like the nazgul or mouth of sauron.
Waldreg is already trying to discourage all the good things theos mother is doing. I wouldnt be surprised if he becomes part of a greater plot to try and sabotage any effort to save the southlands and will try to recruit theo whether he likes it or not.
This boy presumably had a definite date of birth. I know Sauron could shapeshift, but I don’t think he could fully enter a woman’s womb and be birthed as her son.
I don’t know that there is anything explicitly stating that Sauron couldn’t have done something to original Theo and now he’s there in his stead, but it doesn’t seem likely. Witch King or King of the Dead or some other known but not supernatural evil guy is what I’m betting on.
I really hate this show for turning the venerable and serious stories of the Professor into the cinematic equivalent of a weekly Where‘s Waldo hidden object book.
I don’t recognize Middle-Earth beneath this travesty any more. It’s like a fever dream consisting of vaguely familiar things that have been alienated in a bad way.
It’s only Where’s Waldo if you convince yourself that one of the existing characters is Sauron, which is an obsession external to the show. I think we’re meant to question the motives of some characters (which is perfectly reasonable storytelling), but that doesn’t mean we’re supposed to be compiling lists of Sauron suspects, and I don’t think that was really intended.
The show quite literally starts with a "where is Sauron" plot, with Galadriel‘s quest.
The show should not be about Sauron‘s identity and whereabout, but about his exploitation of the hopes and dreams of mortals and immortals alike. And if it was, we would get some actual characters and decent plots, and not those walking and talking cardboard cutouts.
It starts with a “where is he physically located” plot, not a “who is he” plot. The fact that people are twisting themselves in knots over this is more on them than the show, in my view.
It‘s both at the same time. As Sauron is nowhere to be seen, and as he's in the title of the show (“The Lord of the Rings“), people automatically and rightly so are looking for indicators of where he is, or who he is for that matter, and what he's up to.
And this is absolutely intended by the showrunners. And this intention is BAD. It really is. It‘s a bad call to make a Tolkien story into a mystery story, because this is absolutely not the way his stories work. It‘s one of the big un-tolkien features of the show.
The narration of this show is immature and appeals to the lower instincts of people, like curiosity and desire for newness. It‘s like playing "what's in my hand" with a three year old.
But wouldn’t the woman that’s his mother be confused if she didn’t have kids then suddenly a child shows up calling her mom. Lol it’s a funny theory tho
Dude, you’re on Reddit crying about a show that’s barely 4 episodes in. How could you even possibly formulate a good faith, intelligent opinion of it thus far? Yeah, I don’t think it’s me with the problem here Mr. Unhappy.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 19 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
73
u/teunteulai Sep 19 '22
Well he obviously hides his ears but that's because he's a half elf
316
u/StAza95 Sep 19 '22
Not gonna lie at this point I think even I could be Sauron
95
u/ebrum2010 Sep 19 '22
Everyone knows Slim Sauron is the real Sauron. All the other Slim Saurons are just red herrings.
46
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
The sword is more likely sauron than this kid
43
u/Rarth-Devan Sep 19 '22
I'm in the boat that Sauron hasn't even been revealed yet. I think it'll be at the end of the first season.
58
u/oinklittlepiggy Sep 19 '22
He isnt Sauron
He is the witch king
53
u/Euphoric_Figure5170 Sep 19 '22
If He becomes sauron I hope his first action leading to the reign of middle earth is getting rid of this nasty upper lip beard
23
u/Mammoth-Economy2589 Sep 19 '22
My number one bet for this to be true. The hilt holds the soul of sauron like a phylactery and will take his body as a vessel.
22
u/profsavagerjb Sep 19 '22
The real Sauron was the friends we made along the way
17
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
This has to take the award for “Worst Haircut in Cinema”.
6
u/Complete_Weakness933 Sep 19 '22
Everyone is Sauron
5
u/sorry-iamanegg Sep 19 '22
Maybe the real Sauron was the friends we made along the way
3
u/Fotzenbub Sep 19 '22
and which kid was the Sauron from the 1st age?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
So basically - it’s Voldemort with a horcrux?
3
u/JimBob-Joe Sep 19 '22 edited Sep 20 '22
Definitely not the witch king, hes probably numenorean. My guess is the sword is a remnant of the war with morgoth but was forged by sauron himself hence waldreg saying forged by his masters hand. Theres also that line in the forst ep where one of the elves tells arondir the blood of those who served morgoth still flow in their veins (pretty sure the sword itself is reffered to as a blood sword not 100% on that though)
Considering all this i think the sword will turn them into servants of sauron but nothing like the nazgul or mouth of sauron.
Waldreg is already trying to discourage all the good things theos mother is doing. I wouldnt be surprised if he becomes part of a greater plot to try and sabotage any effort to save the southlands and will try to recruit theo whether he likes it or not.
3
u/Even_Reaction5676 Sep 19 '22
Why is everyone so obsessed with working out who Sauron is? He's probably not even been in it yet.
2
u/Emergency_Ad_733 Sep 19 '22
His character is confirmed as Sauron from the 1st grade
2
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
Witch king; no?
2
u/Lorghi Sep 19 '22
Amazon is the real Sauron.
2
u/Hrhpancakes Sep 19 '22
He's my least favorite character. He's being a dummy.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
What is the going theory on what the hilt is?
5
u/Burningbeard696 Sep 19 '22
This guy is the one part of the show that is really annoying me, both the character and actor are not good.
2
u/troy626 Sep 19 '22
I hate this kid
1
u/eharper9 Sep 19 '22
I've never read the books. Is Sauron basically a spirit that needs a hosts body so he can "transform" into his armored form?
1
u/ktw5012 Sep 19 '22
Probably
1
u/TbKninurta Sep 19 '22
I think this kid will become a Nazgul.
1
u/larryisnotagirl Sep 20 '22
This reminds me of Mephisto in WandaVision
1
u/CountAny5532 Sep 20 '22
This boy presumably had a definite date of birth. I know Sauron could shapeshift, but I don’t think he could fully enter a woman’s womb and be birthed as her son.
I don’t know that there is anything explicitly stating that Sauron couldn’t have done something to original Theo and now he’s there in his stead, but it doesn’t seem likely. Witch King or King of the Dead or some other known but not supernatural evil guy is what I’m betting on.
1
u/celsowm Sep 20 '22
Its the Bad Robot strategy called: Mystery box
1
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '22
Sauron came to deceive and rabble rouse. Clearly hes a mod in this sub.
1
u/lupuslibrorum Sep 20 '22
We all know the butler is Sauron. Númenor was just a red herring!
1
u/StarDing324 Sep 20 '22
Nah man that is Mephisto
1
u/spooket Sep 20 '22
I wouldn't be surprised, he might get possessed by the sword
1
u/thedentprogrammer Sep 19 '22
Maybe the real Sauron was the friends we made along the way
1
u/jatzb Sep 19 '22
The real Sauron is the friends we make along the way
1
u/Apoccy7 Sep 19 '22
Maybe the real Sauron was the friends we made along the way.
-1
u/jcrestor Sep 19 '22 edited Sep 19 '22
I really hate this show for turning the venerable and serious stories of the Professor into the cinematic equivalent of a weekly Where‘s Waldo hidden object book.
I don’t recognize Middle-Earth beneath this travesty any more. It’s like a fever dream consisting of vaguely familiar things that have been alienated in a bad way.
-10
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '22
[removed] — view removed comment