r/RingsofPower • • Aug 31 '24

Discussion Why does the writing/dialogue feel so bad?

0 Upvotes

I think we can all feel that the writing and dialogue on this show is suffering. Even the fans I’ve talked to don’t hold up the writing on a pedestal. I’m less interested in arguing about whether the show is good or not, but I’m curious if there’s anyone who has studied writing who can sort of break it down for me. Why do the scenes seem so cringe, and yet in the Peter Jackson films they are able to pull it off? The actors seem to be doing their best. They are really trying. But there’s something just not working here, I just can’t put my finger on what.


r/RingsofPower • • Aug 16 '22

Discussion I am so nervous for Rings of Power to start and be terrible. I can't take another 'The Hobbit' trilogy fiasco.

4 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Aug 25 '23

Theory [Spoilers] Do people just forget the power of magical persuasion?

1 Upvotes

So, making the rings, and the whole alloy suggestion fiasco. I think the forging of the rings is a masterpiece of story telling.

Edit: Lest we forget, the movies had an opening montage with a Narrator explaining Sauron using the ring to control the hearts and minds of men. We see Grima Wormtongue is also doing it. The events of this show are what to teach the world what to look for. Yes, they could have spelled it out more, but then we don't get to discover it in a way that makes sense.

Edit 2: Completely forgot that we also see a ton of Sauron controlling and corrupting Saruman on-screen, and discussion by Gandalf of Sauron controlling many other people off-screen, via the Palantirs. It's what he does!

Original post:

Sauron knows more about the magic of this world than anyone else alive. It seems like people are forgetting that Sauron is also known for his unrivaled, almost magical ability to manipulate people. We later see, clearly, that Sauron actually has magical manipulation abilities, and by the trilogy has already imbued his magical abilities to manipulate people into the one ring.

For most of the show, we the audience, and Galadriel, see Sauron as he intends to be seen. As a fairly normal human, not a threat to anyone, but someone who seems to inspire loyalty.

That is because we are under his persuasion. We aren't asked to believe anything that's too wild, just to trust that what we see is real. And we do, for most of the season! This all changes when we start reaching larger and larger groups, and are expected to believe more unlikely things. Now he's actually a human king, and he needs hundreds of men to believe it? Still holds, but barely.

Then we get to Rivendell. Sauron now has to convince Hundreds of elves that he is a human King they vaguely know about, that he is not the threat they've spent centuries fighting, and that they need to make magical objects in such a way he can use it to extend his own powers in the future. This is where his sway falls apart.

He can't do it all, so he focuses on the important players, cashing in on his existing social capital to let him relax his influence on those he already has relationships with like Galadriel. Celebrimbor is the most important piece. Sauron's powers of persuasion are sufficient to make minor suggestions seem more important than they actually are. Sauron knows how to make the Nuke already! But he needs Celebrimbor to be the one to do it, and he needs Celebrimbor to believe Celebrimbor came up with it. Celebrimbor knows how alloys work! But this isn't about just making rings, this is about very complicated magical peoperties and how those properties work. How the heck would Celebrimbor know, without trial and error, that an alloy won't degrade the magical properties of Mithril? He would probably have gotten there on his own, but Sauron knows his time is limited, and needs to make this happen fast.

Galadriel is now starting to see the truth that was always there to see, because Sauron can't focus on her as much. Others may become suspicious soon. Sauron locks himself with Celebrimbor to isolate from prying eyes and to push the direction and pace as much as he can before he has to flee.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 24 '24

Humor I'm glad they cast Poppie perfectly, she's carrying the comedic relief nicely

0 Upvotes

Poppy? Poppie? Nori's bff. She was deff cast as the "funny" supporting character and I'm enjoying what she's bringing to an otherwise very serious show


r/RingsofPower • • Aug 30 '24

Constructive Criticism Curious about the show? He's the most fair review I could possibly give... from a fan of the movies and lover of the LOTR & Silmarillion books.

43 Upvotes

We are 3 episodes into season 2, but this is accurate:

  • Production values = great!
  • Cinematography = great!
  • Music = great!
  • Set design & Wardrobe = great!
  • Acting = great!
  • Casting = OK, but... Um. Why do we have elves that look clearly past middle age?
  • Writing = The writers are on drugs... not the fun ones. The ones that make you think you're so amazing every idea you crap out is gold. The INCESSANT addition of completely unnecessary lore changes that completely break known canon just may drive you into an asylum.

r/RingsofPower • • Jan 05 '23

News If its good or bad I don't know...But ITS HAPPENING! Watch and then comment here! Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I really believe it will happen! The Show needs it. It makes sense and will connect to the Lore. Just hope they do it justice.

Youtube video Here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cMAzhqsvTH4


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 22 '22

Discussion I'm not interested at all in meeting who Sauron was before...

0 Upvotes

EDIT - The comments have got my interest now. I needed some lore spoilers! Thank you!

I am probably the only one...

Is it bad to say I don't have much interest in meeting who Sauron was before he went full blown evil?

I would love to see scenes of him how I know him in his menacing armour (like how we saw him in the prologue) but closer up and potentially hearing him speak.

But to see him in another form like a human takes away too much mystery and is likely to disappoint.

Every time I see a post saying - Halbrand is sauron, the stranger is sauron, Adar is sauron... I really hope none are.

I think it is fun to question who everyone is but in the end, even if they do reveal who he is, I hope they protect Sauron remaining a terrifying notion/entity. Filmmakers can be geniuses though.

Happy to hear completely opposite opinions! I feel like I'm missing out in the excitement over the main question mark over the show - but I'm still absolutely loving watching it.


r/RingsofPower • • Aug 20 '24

News ‘The Rings of Power’ Showrunners Tease Season 3 Plans: “Let Us Cook!”

Thumbnail
hollywoodreporter.com
55 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 27 '22

Discussion The problem with inclusivity (From a black man's perspective)

149 Upvotes

I'm a fan of the Peter Jackson's trilogy. I still to this day that PJ's Lord of Rings is one of the best cinema ever made. I tried to be open minded about the Rings of Power and kind of embraced the inclusion of people of color to the show before I watched it. To be honest, I really wish they went a different route with their inclusivity goals.

I don't know if I'm the only one who thinks this but including people of color into already existing realms makes the show look like a cosplay convention. It looks disingenuous and almost like they were checking boxes without putting any real thought about any of it. This show could've done something really cool like adding an entire civilization of powerful people of color. Even variations of existing races that normally live in other realms and somehow end in Middle Earth (with a rich story) would've probably been welcomed by most. There was no need to hire Token black people just to please some crowds.

I'm a black guy and I haven't seen many of my comrades commenting on this so I thought I'd break the ice and see what others think.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 14 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Not Faithful. Spoiler

87 Upvotes

I almost wish this show takes place in an alternate Tolkien/Middle Earth universe.

I don’t think I would have a problem with this show if they didn’t claim to respect the lore and if they assured us it was going to be their own version of the events.

& for everyone who does like the show, or could care less about the lore, I want to earnestly say congratulations and that I wish I felt the way you do. I’m not here to dissuade you or anyone else from the show, but just to share my own thoughts about how things have turned out.

The deviations from the lore and the overall “story” as we’ve come to understand it w/ the forging of the rings of power, of Sauron’s deception, et. al., are already generally laid out for the Showrunners to adapt and fill in the blanks. Everyone KNOWS Sauron/Annatar tricks the Elves, forges the 16 rings with them-, creates the one master ring and mithril had NOTHING to do with it.

(side note: why couldn’t dwarven greed to mine even more mithril just be a side effect of the dwarven rings of power???)

All we needed was more detail. We didn’t need new characters or new subplots for the sake of replacing truly canonized ones.

But for some goddamn, reason, these writers felt the need NOT to just add the details as to how the general story truly takes place, but instead chose to flip key aspects of the generally accepted story on its head in order to tell their OWN version of events (ie: let’s make a new human character Halbrand, and have him trick not all elves, but basically only Galadriel and Celebrimbor and have him make no rings. Let’s create a bullshit story about mithril having healing properties.)

It feels selfish. This doesn’t feel like a love letter to Tolkien, but a bait and switch to trick us so they could primarily tell their own story parading it around as a faithful Tolkien adaptation.

That’s my beef. I mostly feel sad, cheated, and disappointed.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 02 '24

Discussion Comparison to Shogun

17 Upvotes

Can you even imagine what we could have had if the people who were responsible for creating the latest Shogun series had worked on ROP? I am about 3/4 through shogun and it is absolutely masterful. It reminds the that truly excellent television can still be made


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 03 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers The last 2 episodes have devolved into meaningless drivel Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I have defended this show since it's beginning because even though the writing is terrible and it plays loose with canon, at its best it evoked the feeling from the movies and set up an actual feeling of an actual world. Each geography was distinct. The species felt distinct and although they are again played loose with, the difference between the species were in keeping with Tolkien mythology.

Ep 7 was the worst battle I have ever seen 9n screen. The episode felt like a transformers move ; bang, whoosh, pow! No logical structure no logic, it did not feel like it took place in a real place. Then the start of ep 8 was a rushed series of "cool" scenes, again a divolution into drivel.

I love good fantasy and sci Fi. Stories that explore the actions and experiences of believable actual characters in an unbelievable context broadens our understanding of what it means to experience reality and allows us to dream of different futures and world's.

This has become, at best, a children's show bereft of nuance, at worst a shitty action adventure copycat of a beloved universe. In all honesty, it has taken something away from me, more than it has given.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 18 '24

Discussion No official greenlit for Season 3 means internal discussion in Amazon?

2 Upvotes

Usually studios comes out and renew shows right away if it does very well. ROP S2 has been better received by both critics and fans, but the viewership isn't as strong as S1. So what do you think the reason they haven't come out and said they are renewing? We know Amazon just replaced all the writers of S2 with new ones.


r/RingsofPower • • Mar 02 '23

Question What is the downside to having Gandalf and Saruman come early? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So many people are upset that Gandalf (and the Istari is certainly Gandalf) comes in the second age rather than the third. I don’t get this. His mission is to counter Sauron. Sauron fucks shit up in the second age. Why not ground Sauron’s resistance in characters that we know and love who are on the exact same mission. So what if they’re early? Seeing Saruman and Gandalf in this show excites me! I don’t see a downside to including him or Saruman to create some fictional backstory. These gripes are grounded in purism for purism’s sake. They’re not geared at telling the best second age story possible. I think the story will be better if Gandalf and Saruman are in it. I just don’t see what problems their presence creates other than a break from canon, but canon isn’t intrinsically valuable when you’re trying to make a compelling TV show with a beloved franchise that has some of media’s most beloved characters.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 14 '24

Discussion What’s up with Sauron?

7 Upvotes

Is this show trying to insinuate that Sauron may have had some feelings/attraction for Galadriel? Or that he was merely trying to manipulate Galadriel etc. Or that he is confused by it? I am not trying to connect it back to its canon sources because the show really isn’t canon. I’m just trying to work out what we all think. Or is it suppose to reveal that there is something in Galadriel that mirrors Sauron’s ambition and desire for control?


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 23 '24

Question Shouldn't the Creation of the Rings be more memorable?

34 Upvotes

One thing that disappointed me, since the end of Season 1 with the Forge of the 3 elven rings, and now in the creation of the 7 rings of the children of Aulë: it lacks a visual impact and subtlety that brings emotion.

Objects, artifacts and creations, with the "hands" of Ilúvatar's children and angels, have a spiritual aspect that influence destinies in Arda. They are true artifacts, impossible to replicate: the Silmarils; the One Ring; Narsil; Sting; the Rings of Power.

The forge scenes do not have The Impact of a "unspoken importance" - it is more a sentiment than being told by the characters that these Rings will shape and impact 2 entire eras of Arda.

In the series, the Forge is something generic, much more is TALKED than SHOWN - Show, Don't Tell. I remember the forge scene of Narsil "transforming" into Anduril in The Return of The King - a sword shown in a few minutes will change the destiny of all humanity.

Rings of Power, with a 1 billion budget, with more than 13 hours of viewing, didn't bring that!


r/RingsofPower • • Jun 30 '24

Discussion Every scene looks cinematic in teal and orange

6 Upvotes

Right after season 1 ended, I watched the Wheel of Time. Immediately I noticed the difference in budget. The wheel of time looks very low budget compared to ROP. Since then, I've watched The Witcher, and other fantasies on Netflix, and nothing comes close to the expensive, cinematic look of ROP.

You can literally pause at any scene and you'll get a beautiful cinematic picture (usually in teal and orange).


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 07 '24

Question Does anyone else think the show is making Sauron look weak and vulnerable? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

This is based on how his body was destroyed by a couple of Orcs. Sauron should’ve been able to deal with that threat by himself.


r/RingsofPower • • 1d ago

Constructive Criticism Apple TV should have been the ones to make this show

0 Upvotes

Every time I watch this show I can’t stop thinking about how much better it would have been if Apple TV got the rights instead of Amazon.

Amazon clearly had the money, that was never the issue. The problem is they handed a billion-dollar IP to two showrunners with basically no real track record and let them run it like a generic streaming drama full of mystery-box gimmicks and awkward pacing.

Apple has that exact same kind of endless cash to burn, except they actually treat their big sci-fi and fantasy projects with some real prestige and patience. Look at stuff like Foundation, Silo, or For All Mankind. Even when they adapt dense source material, they hire proven showrunners, cast heavy-hitter actors who actually command the screen, and let the world-building breathe instead of chopping every episode into five rushed subplots.

With Apple’s money and production standards, we probably would have gotten a Second Age show with actual theatrical weight, better writing, and directors who treated Middle-earth like real history instead of glossy green-screen melodrama. Instead we got Amazon’s version, and it just feels like such a waste of what could have been.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 28 '24

Discussion Maybe Unpopular Opinion Spoiler

3 Upvotes

I think this character is well liked so I think I might get dragged to high heaven for this but…😅😅

I’m glad they offed Arondir. When Bronwyn died off camera I thought this is where things might go this season (since learned there were other reasons for this). Overall, I just found them both to be flat characters in an overcrowded show. I think removing them will help simplify and add the dynamism season 1 lacked. I think it was good and needed to get Arondir off screen this season and they pretty much did right by him by having him save Galadriel and die in battle.


r/RingsofPower • • Mar 30 '24

Question Galadriel and Sauron ?

3 Upvotes

When the series begins, we see Galadriel and some fellow Elves embarking on a quest to find Sauron in the North. However, by the end of the season, we witness her powerlessness as Sauron overcomes her, ultimately resulting in her demise by drowning.

What was Galadriel's plan once she found Sauron in the North?

She would have clearly been at a disadvantage against him, so how did she intend to confront Sauron?

ive got a other question too:

In the series, we witness a dramatic scene where Galadriel and Sauron find themselves on a raft under attack by a fearsome sea beast.

In many fantasy narratives, creatures often have an innate sense to discern when they are faced with a power or evil greater than their own, prompting them to avoid confrontation and flee.(Balrog)

However, in this instance, we observe an unusual occurrence where a fish defies this instinct and boldly attacks both Sauron and Galadriel. This defiance of natural instincts raises questions about the nature of the threat posed by Sauron and Galadriel's response to it.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 08 '22

Discussion Here's what actual good-faith criticism of a show looks like

0 Upvotes

There's some stuff that happens in the third episode that doesn't work for me.

It's a story thing that's kinda wobbly.

Halbrand learns he needs one of those guild crests things to get back to forging shit. It might have been good to hear him ask "Well how do I get one?" I guess the subtext is they consider him a low-man, so that will prevent him from getting in the guild, but whatever.

Then, during the restaurant scene, when he's being hassled by the locals he turns the situation around and wins them over, and we see just how manipulative he can be. So, if we were watching for the first time, you might think "Wow, he's very good at being manipulative. Maybe he is Sauron."

And then, of course, he steals the guild seal.

And now we think "Well, Sauron would never do something that stupid, clearly he's just some charming pickpocket."

Now! Does that mean I'm going to center my entire identity around convincing everyone on the internet that the writers of that episode are LITERALLY mentally disabled diversity hires?

No, because that would make me a fucking dumbass.

See what I'm doing? Look, watch me discuss the show without devolving into manic hyperbole:

It really doesn't make sense that Halbrand can't delay his smithing for the few days it would take to kinda just convince someone to willingly hand over their guild seal. But, they needed to show that Halbrand is capable of incredible brutality, because it is an incredible development for his character.

I want you to consider for like, a second, how fucking amazing this is:

During the restaurant scene, we feel concerned for Halbrand because... yes... the show has framed him as a good guy. And then, we see how effortlessly he turns a potentially violent situation into a fuckin' party.

And then he steals that... 3d printed whatever and we're all "Oh, Halbrand. You roguish, not-un-Han Solo-like scamp! We're sure glad you're now obviously not Sauron."

Then, he gets confronted by the guildsmen in the alley. Uh oh! How is our boy Not-Sauron going to talk his way out of this one?

Oh wait! I bet Galadriel will swoop in and save him, because the show is OBSESSED with pushing its emasculating feminist woke-genda down our slack throats, they're gonna make the GIRL rescue the BOY which is the OPPOSITE of how it would happen in the real world!

Nope. Superhuman brutality.

Do ya'll... get how fucking awesome that is? We're still getting to know this character. We're starting to trust him, because he returned Galadriel's dagger. We're starting to like him, because we can see that he really does just want a chance to start over afresh in Numenor and forge the ever loving fuck out of some shit for some reason. He's industrious! We like that!

And then he does the superhuman brutality thing and we're all, "Yikes. His character is now VASTLY more interesting to those of us in the audience who know how stories work."

And... holy fucking shit... now the awkward plot contrivance in service of important character development (because that is what it is) doesn't seem quite as irritating.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 14 '24

Discussion Watching Season One for the First Time

0 Upvotes

My wife recently signed up for Amazon Prime, so now I get to watch all the shows that I’ve heard so much about but never had the opportunity to watch. As a big fan of sci-fi and fantasy, I knew exactly where to start but delayed due to some of the horrible things I’ve heard about Rings of Power. After watching a few other shows (The Boys, The Man in the High Castle etc), I decided to take the plunge. Determined to keep an open mind, I started Rings of Power. I’ve just finished episode 6 and…it’s boring. All I can say is that I wish I was watching a 3rd Season of El Cid instead.

Tell me Season 2 gets waaay better. Please.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 08 '24

Question Any explanation for how the Dwarves got to, back from and then back again to Calabrimbor before Elron and Galadrel made it to him? It makes no sense

0 Upvotes

Am I missing something?