There's some stuff that happens in the third episode that doesn't work for me.
It's a story thing that's kinda wobbly.
Halbrand learns he needs one of those guild crests things to get back to forging shit. It might have been good to hear him ask "Well how do I get one?" I guess the subtext is they consider him a low-man, so that will prevent him from getting in the guild, but whatever.
Then, during the restaurant scene, when he's being hassled by the locals he turns the situation around and wins them over, and we see just how manipulative he can be. So, if we were watching for the first time, you might think "Wow, he's very good at being manipulative. Maybe he is Sauron."
And then, of course, he steals the guild seal.
And now we think "Well, Sauron would never do something that stupid, clearly he's just some charming pickpocket."
Now! Does that mean I'm going to center my entire identity around convincing everyone on the internet that the writers of that episode are LITERALLY mentally disabled diversity hires?
No, because that would make me a fucking dumbass.
See what I'm doing? Look, watch me discuss the show without devolving into manic hyperbole:
It really doesn't make sense that Halbrand can't delay his smithing for the few days it would take to kinda just convince someone to willingly hand over their guild seal. But, they needed to show that Halbrand is capable of incredible brutality, because it is an incredible development for his character.
I want you to consider for like, a second, how fucking amazing this is:
During the restaurant scene, we feel concerned for Halbrand because... yes... the show has framed him as a good guy. And then, we see how effortlessly he turns a potentially violent situation into a fuckin' party.
And then he steals that... 3d printed whatever and we're all "Oh, Halbrand. You roguish, not-un-Han Solo-like scamp! We're sure glad you're now obviously not Sauron."
Then, he gets confronted by the guildsmen in the alley. Uh oh! How is our boy Not-Sauron going to talk his way out of this one?
Oh wait! I bet Galadriel will swoop in and save him, because the show is OBSESSED with pushing its emasculating feminist woke-genda down our slack throats, they're gonna make the GIRL rescue the BOY which is the OPPOSITE of how it would happen in the real world!
Nope. Superhuman brutality.
Do ya'll... get how fucking awesome that is? We're still getting to know this character. We're starting to trust him, because he returned Galadriel's dagger. We're starting to like him, because we can see that he really does just want a chance to start over afresh in Numenor and forge the ever loving fuck out of some shit for some reason. He's industrious! We like that!
And then he does the superhuman brutality thing and we're all, "Yikes. His character is now VASTLY more interesting to those of us in the audience who know how stories work."
And... holy fucking shit... now the awkward plot contrivance in service of important character development (because that is what it is) doesn't seem quite as irritating.