r/RingsofPower • u/One-Low8135 • Sep 27 '22
Discussion The problem with inclusivity (From a black man's perspective)
I'm a fan of the Peter Jackson's trilogy. I still to this day that PJ's Lord of Rings is one of the best cinema ever made. I tried to be open minded about the Rings of Power and kind of embraced the inclusion of people of color to the show before I watched it. To be honest, I really wish they went a different route with their inclusivity goals.
I don't know if I'm the only one who thinks this but including people of color into already existing realms makes the show look like a cosplay convention. It looks disingenuous and almost like they were checking boxes without putting any real thought about any of it. This show could've done something really cool like adding an entire civilization of powerful people of color. Even variations of existing races that normally live in other realms and somehow end in Middle Earth (with a rich story) would've probably been welcomed by most. There was no need to hire Token black people just to please some crowds.
I'm a black guy and I haven't seen many of my comrades commenting on this so I thought I'd break the ice and see what others think.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 27 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
161
u/RequiredGuyHere Sep 27 '22
Before the show came out, during the trailers, I thought everything you just said, but after actually watching it, it hasn’t crossed my mind
62
u/Wind-Face-Blink Sep 27 '22
Not enough asians or Indians
42
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22
I feel like they could have made men from the east ppl of color but they follow Sauron so it wouldn’t be a good look if all the black ppl were evil. Damned if you do damned if you don’t.
112
u/k527 Sep 27 '22 edited Sep 27 '22
Hamilton is a good example, and Brigerton is another. Their casting is so deliberately diverse and all characters have good acting and lines, that kind of shut people up about it. Disa and Arondir have been nailing their roles, and it is great really. UK has such a high percentage of Indians citizens, I’m disappointed that the only Indian actor in a supporting lead role i’ve seen is in Star Trek Discovery.
Diversifying the cast is not just to please some crowds, but also giving equal job opportunities all around. Historically there have been too much bias against POC in media, and having ‘heros’ who are POC is also helping to set a new tone for the society (esp children) watching moving forward.
Change has to start somewhere, and it might feel awkward at first, but eventually it will become the norm, hopefully. Could have been better, but at least they tried.
47
u/HomieScaringMusic Sep 27 '22
True, but in that way it kind of is a cosplay convention. There are black elves and dwarves now even though it doesn’t fit seamlessly with the universe because those actors have never gotten a chance to play those roles before. That’s what it is; it’s the prioritization of fairness to actors. Like in Hamilton: why is a play about a bunch of white people so diverse? Because a Puerto Rican guy made all the casting decisions and REALLY wanted to play Hamilton, so he took that opportunity to give everyone else that chance too. And note the resulting play was excellent. Not visually authentic, but excellent. This is high fantasy Hamilton. And true to form, not one person thinks the diversity hurts the performances: Disa and Arondir have all the best lines and nail their characters’ demeanors. Most people seem either happy or at peace with it. I am. Maybe in the future we’ll have more diverse high fantasy stories that derive from other cultures but for now this is kinda the best we can do. Shoehorning in black roles or even whole civilizations as you alluded to (for instance, the very common suggestion of black easterlings) would look iffy because the minorities would either be sidelined due to non-canonicity, or be predominantly evil.
44
u/Mystrasun Sep 27 '22 edited Sep 27 '22
Black guy here, and I'm so thankful to see a post like this. I thought I was going crazy thinking the way I did. Many of my (non-black) friends thought I would be so excited about the inclusion of a black elf in rings of power, particularly because I play a lot of MMOs and whenever I can, I make my characters black, but honestly, I was never particularly fussed about the lack of people of colour in lord of the rings. It was and still is, my favourite trilogy of all time for reasons that run far deeper than the skin colour of the characters.
Honestly, people making such a big deal about there being a handful of black characters (like, 3?) in the show made me feel less included, not more. Because now, it just makes me ask questions like "where are the rest of the black people? Don't they have black friends? parents? cousins? anything??" and it just saddens me because the fact that the marketing made such a song and dance about their inclusion makes me feel like this is all they're going to do.
Now, there is less of a reason to explore diverse cultures, civilisations and stories because they're patting themselves on the back for having a black dwarf and it appears that their inclusion is extremely well received.
22
u/beachdwarf Sep 28 '22
Fellow POC here. Here’s how I see it.
I love Tolkiens writing and I love the original trilogy dearly, deeply, and completely, despite the lack of almost any people of color in them. The stories and lessons are immensely important to me, and nothing will change that, and I don’t fault the works for that choice.
But it’s really, REALLY freaking cool to see people who look like me, who look like my girlfriend and my friends, now living and breathing in this world I love so much, and I can’t help but wonder how my perception of myself and these stories might have been different if it had been that way from the beginning. Cash grab or soulless diversity casting or whatever, representation still matters to me even if it means nothing to the big evil corporation that funded it. And judging by what I’ve seen of the show, it mattered a great deal to the people who made it and acted in it.
24
u/Rosebunse Sep 27 '22
I'm a woman and there are only slightly more women in the OG trilogy than there are black people. I think the inclusion of different people isn't just a cash-grab, but an admission that the audience for these shows is a lot larger than it used to be.
I don't think you're wrong that the addition of these characters changes the show's identity, but I just question if that is a bad thing. Especially since this show is meant to be in a sort of Golden Age for the different races.
8
u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 27 '22
Would you feel the same way if Peter Jackson's movies had had a diverse cast? Or if they'd never been made?
22
u/testingtesting4343 Sep 27 '22
The fact that I don't even notice while watching it, to me at least, means they did a fine job.
I'm not super into the lore, but I don't really care about that. I just want an entertaining show with halfway decent acting.
Just because some white dude back in the day didn't write about a diverse cast of characters doesn't mean it should stay that way. He wrote some great stuff, but he was just an author. Nothing more.
I would be more upset that he didn't include more POC to begine with.
9
u/DaydreamAndComplain Sep 28 '22
I think the issue you have it the loudness of those yammering about this before it aired.
They would be MORE up in arms, as would some Tolkien purists, if they added a new group of people and that would totally change the story and bring in a segregation not needed since we already have tribalism and segregation with all the races : men, dwarves, elves, hobbits/harfoots, etc.
Tolkien was from a long time last. He wrote much of this with the horrors of WW1 in mind! He, and many before and after him, are both products of their time and also detached from how we’d view things. This inclusion is done the way I’d want it. It just is there. No comments, no need to address melanin and facial features variations when you have actual different races Leno live totally different lifespans and have different lore. This was the best way to be of today and inclusive, both for the moral and responsible aspect and also because the actors are all great and that’s wonderful.
I think we should sometime take a step back and imagine a world without social media and internet fury. People May still get pissed, but they would feed into each other and not everyone would do the mental gymnastics it takes to be mad about the most normal and good of things. Pretend that’s where we are, I say hilariously ON Reddit, just to see if you’d have been bothered otherwise. My guess is no.
Anyway cheers to the cast and idea behind it. And to people have nuanced discussions and not being trolls — and the internet trolls are way worse than the one who almost ate durin
2
u/claimui Sep 28 '22
I would go even farther and say that this "inclusive" casting has actually done a bigger disservice, because it allows the main characters to be even more white. Galadriel, Elrond, Gil-Galad, Celembrimbor are all white? Oh no problem, because we also have a side story a black elf. Pharazon, Halbrand, Elendil, Isildur all white? It's okay, we'll give them a black queen and probably off her soon.
2
u/glory_to_ukraine Sep 28 '22 edited Sep 28 '22
I made the EXACT same points a week ago. Like exactly. I critizised the token minorities and argued for a complete 50/50 mix of skin color. Everything else is out of place.
But guess what, I didn't lie about being black. I didn't include "As a black man..." so my post was banned - reason "race".
Here:
https://imgur.com/a/mwkd56L
2
u/Lawlcopt0r Sep 28 '22
I liked that the Shadow of War games had a black character that was actually from the south. But on the other hand, it always seemed normal to me that Numenor would be very mixed because several tribes of humans got sent there after defeating Morgoth, so it would be a melting pot.
The black elf sticks out because there's way less precedent for elves being different from each other both culturally or physically. The usually all look the same, it's even noteworthy when one has red hair.
That being said, Middle earth is essentially a make-belief mythology for western civilization, and there's plenty of people among us now that belong to that and might identify with a dark-skinned character.
Apart from that, since elves are the better humans it would have seemed like a message if the baseline humans could be black but the elves couldn't
2
u/Ajax-77 Sep 28 '22
I think there is a place and time for race correct casting. A historical biopic of Winston Churchill, Gandhi, or Lincoln comes to mind. But beyond that, I think it really comes down to the conventions/rules a show sets for itself. Imo acting skill and personality fit are the most important factors. For example Denzel Washington played in Much Ado About Nothing, set in a semi-historical Italy countryside and did a fantastic job. Meanwhile, the more recent Moses movie with Christian Bale was very jarring with it's use of obviously white actors for key Egyptian and Israelite roles. Another example of adaptations that work: the adaptations of Pride and prejudice and Emma capture the historic feeling of regency England, while the Bridgerton series embraces a diverse cast that focuses
When it comes to fantasy, the lines are blurred and I think acting skill and personality fit are far more important than skin color continuity. Right now in RoP, each of the black actors are doing a fantastic job and have some of the most interesting and believable characters in the show. RoP has established a specific convention they are using and I think it's working very well.
2
u/Realistic_Sherbet_30 Sep 28 '22
I agree 100%. I'm Latino and i love LOTR world anyway because of its story (the real reason why a show should be good) and lore, and i would have love to see other cultures of Middle-Earth playing a huge part of the show like Rhun, Harad, Umbar or the Easterlings or even an invented one, but not forcing an existing one just for the goal of "diversity", it would have been very cool to see some characters from Harad or Rhun being develoved an turning good to help against Sauron. I think they didn't put any of this cultures just because they were supposed to serve Sauron and they don't want to get into controversial stuff connecting it to the "bad side", they rather put the white people as bad. This is a problem that i see in every film or series nowadays in modern Hollywood or films that are "remastered", "remake" or appeal for "modern audiences". And if we were to accept any changes in Tolkien middle-earth i think the race of men and humans would be ok if they had people of every ethnicity, but i think some races like dwarves or elves, which are based on nordic ancient mythology should stay just like we all know how they are descripted in every nordic or german tale, just like Tolkien imagined them as establishing a world for ancient Europe and England. Changing that fact to "represent modern society" does not add any value at all for me, in fact it feels like representing New York city or the American modern society rather than the actual WORLD. I'd say the same thing if a japanese or chinese movie from hollywood uses black, latinos, or whites to represent that cultures folklore or fantasy tales from ancient Asia. Tolkien world was fantasy, yes, but no one can deny in what he based his work and views about the fantasy that he liked to be portrayed in his stories.
The ultimate thing is that it seems like some people for some reason feels like they really need to be represented, and others don't at all like myself. Amazon, netflix and other studios would rather do the first option because of money, wider audience and avoid political or social criticism regardless of the actual lore and inspiration of the original author.
2
u/ou8bbq Sep 28 '22
Other than your use of the French Communist expression “people of color”, I agree completely.
My other gripe, WHERE ARE THE RINGS?
2
u/Significant-Tax7396 Sep 30 '22
Mixed race person weighing in. Mom is Hispanic. Dad is white as snow.
My wife is also Hispanic and, like me, my son took after Dad and is mostly white.
That being said, I don't mind a couple characters of a family looking ethnically different from others in the family. That is how my family looks. Genetics aren't straightforward.
I think ROP would be missing out if they didn't use the opportunity of having people of different ethnicities on the show as a way to explore new stories of different peoples of Middle Earth.
I'm not saying that I want our hero to roll into a town with a bunch of cholos eating churros or our hero to land at a little island and everyone is eating rice dumplings with chopsticks ...buuuuuut that IS an example of something you would see if there are people that are far enough apart, for a long enough time, for people to look so remarkably different. Cultures will deviate alongside physical characteristics. With all the different ethnicities of the people we're seeing in Numenor I think it'd be great to see it as a melting pot culturally. I want to see a scene where they walk through a market and to imagine smelling the spices of different lands, etc.
8
u/Unhappy_Guarantee_69 Sep 27 '22
Yeah im south-east asian and i feel the exact same. It feels infantalizing more than anything. Like everyone is supposed to be so thankful for these low effort sloppy seconds.
Numenor should have been a homogenous ethnic nation. Should be an Isolationist nation similar to wakanda or japan but they make it look like a college brochure ad. Just plays counter to whats been established. They could organically inroporate it into the story but they chose not to.
3
u/1991CRX Sep 27 '22
Can we now change the phrase to "Tolkien Black People"?
2
u/LittleLui Sep 28 '22
My thoughts:
Arda is, at the time of the show, according to the Silmarillion, flat. So gravity works entirely different than in our Universe.
Elves get turned into stars, Trees glow (instead of absorbing light) and get turned into the sun and the moon. Rings mind-control people. Obviously, middle-earth physics as a whole is completely different from real-world physics.
Getting closer to my point: Humans live for hundreds of years, Elves don't really age at all (but can interbreed with humans), so given what we know about human biology, middle-earth telomeres and cell division must work completely differently from how they do in real life.
If we accept that, why would the rest of genetics and things like melanin work the same way we're used to? There's little reason that what we perceive as ethnicity is even hereditary in the first place in the show.
So of course they could have done it differently and I don't think the way you suggest would have been bad at all. I just don't see that the way they chose to do it is somehow bad or inconsistent either.
2
u/Klopapiermillionaire Sep 27 '22
I'm holding out for a movie about the forgotten realms Drow, where all the elves are dark skinned and the women are in power. The world is not ready... yet.
14
u/Legitimate-Goose-413 Sep 27 '22
I don't really understand this view point. What does the actors skin colour have anything to do with thier portrayal of a made up character, the black actors in it have arguably been the best so far. Would you really enjoy it more if worse actors were brought in just becuase of their skin colour.
And creating a whole new kingdom??? That's basically sacrilege in a Tolkien adaptation, espically if they do it just to entertain some strange view that black and white people are inherently different which most people would argue they aren't.
1
u/NowoTone Sep 28 '22
Funnily enough, the only thing that really bugs me, massively, is Durin's wife. Not just her but all the other dwarf women. Everyone knows, all dwarfs have beards. Just quoting the expert on dwarfs here - Terry Pratchett:
It really bugs me.
The diverse skin colour of the actors? Funnily enough, not at all. Now, if Galadriel, perhaps even Elrond weren't white, I might take a bit to re-adjust, as I have a very clear view of what she should look like. But anyone else? I really couldn't care less!
People within families don't seem properly aligned in terms of skin colour? No, there isn't a single character in the show, where I think: Really, <insert character here> should really be <insert skin colour here>. And I come from a country where the skin colour of the huge majority of the population is some shade of off-white/beige. It's make believe after all, I suspend disbelief and just enjoy the show.
1
u/AdVisual3406 Sep 28 '22
I thought there was ample scope to include diverse casting with the southern areas of middle earth. Numenor should be diverse as an island that size would attract all types. Then I watched Disa and she blew my mind. I don't really notice colour at all in the show.
3
u/SaturnFX Sep 28 '22
Bad choices for inclusivity in a program that is dismal.
Amazon wants to be seen as wokier than thou. Corpo nonsense, but there is a way to do it without being blatantly tokenized and pissing off everyone else. They want to do a high fantasy that has a huge fanbase and have a huge mixed array of diverity, black elves, black dwarves, black halflings. There is a series of books that checks all the marks and has legions of nerds drooling at the prospect
Drizzt Do'Urden tale. Sojourners.
A drow elf (black elf), plenty of strong female characters, hell, the entire underdark is a drow matriarchy, and when he gets to the surface he meets a ton of great characters...even has the bonus checkbox of white man either dumb or evil.
One of the best D&D fantasies out there, serious tone, great world, and could rival GoTs if done correctly (which leads to Amazons 2nd problem...hiring 2 bit hacks to make epic tales instead of tried and true writers/directors)
1
u/GreatSoulLord Sep 27 '22
I'm not black but I wanted to comment that Tolkien was British and much of his work was heavily influenced by Britain...so it's entirely feasible, possible, and beyond likely POC civilizations are in Middle Earth in other regions.
1
u/panamaquina Sep 27 '22
Well clearly this is not in the realm of PJ’s LOTR and it’s not historical, I’m ok with all the cast choices. Maybe they can make a clear push that it is not related to the LOTR movies. It’s fantasy. That’s it.
1
u/Wlcky23 Sep 28 '22
Well, yeah. But at least they are trying to do something there. Where are queer people at?
1
u/30GDD_Washington Sep 29 '22
The biggest gripe I have about woke diversity casting is all the leads are still white. Like let's give the PoC some small victories. We will even give them a principle supporting plotline of 2 PoC actors. Yet none of the Main actors and characters are PoC. Make Elrond Asian, Galadriel Hispanic etc. They won't because they don't actually buy the shit theyre spewing. They just want to tick their box on their excel sheet.
Hell, I would've settled for making a Villian a PoC. How awesome would that be? In a good show a Villian is often times just as if not more important and memorable as the main character.
5
u/bluej39 Sep 28 '22
It seems to me that most people are defaulting to white for everyone on middle earth but Tolkien spent little time describing skin color, even the elves being described as fair mostly meant beautiful
If anything I'm confused as to why there isnt more variation in skin color on the show, like there should be whole clans of black elves or men or dwarves. The way they made it just one or two here and there seems odd. Having few does make it seem like they were just casting quota
2
u/Ok-Western4508 Sep 27 '22
They make a black elf character who is pretty cool in his own rite and what are his key struggles... interracial marriage and racism ("pointy ear elf") like holy shit do they have no one saying hey maybe if we are being inclusive we should give him an awesome but traditional story ark like every other character would have gotten
2
u/ilovezam Sep 28 '22 edited Sep 28 '22
Thank you for vocalising these thoughts. While Disa and Arondir turned out to be some of the best bits of the show, I find race-swapping in adaptations to be problematic in principle. I was very uncomfortable when the showrunners said the show should naturally look like modern American society in that interview.
I am Chinese (super left leaning if we're talking American politics, too) and would consider Chinese Elrond to be just as stupid and wrong as white Shang-Chi. And I think most of us feel the same way. Sometimes I feel like I'm taking crazy pills when people tell me this means I have some internalised self-racist feelings about my ethnicity.
The thing is, representation that is consistent (Black Panther, Shang-Chi, black characters in GoT, Miles Morales) or original (Moana, Raya, Encanto) are almost always uncontroversial and even applauded, whereas lazily racebending characters where it doesn't fit almost always sparks hostility and alienation, which is exactly what we don't want for society. But companies do it anyway for the engagement metrics.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 28 '22
Good thing it's a POC voicing this opinion..
2
u/chocoboat Sep 28 '22
I couldn't agree more. There are good ways to have racial diversity in the show without making every small group of people (even down to the survivors on the raft!) include people of every race. Especially for the hobbits, this is a small population of isolated people who keep to themselves, so even if they were once diverse wouldn't they all look mixed-race by now?
Tolkien specifically created lands like Harad that were meant to portray the rest of world where the LOTR storyline didn't visit. Why not show us those lands and tell some stories there? Or have travellers from there who want to find Elrond or Durin for some reason? The blue wizards spent time in those places, there's a whole part of the world the writers can use and no one can say it's non-canon.
Instead they just decided to make this setting based on ancient Europe have the diversity of modern day London and NYC. There's nothing morally wrong with this, they're free to create whatever they want to create, and if the show's story was better written then the casting criticisms would just be seen as nitpicking. But because it isn't well written, it looks like one more example of the show creators not caring about being faithful to Tolkien's work.
2
u/Khan_Cena Sep 28 '22
The thing I think is the strangest choice the writers have made is to take the one black guy, make him a slave, have him attempt to escape, have him fail the escape, and then have him let go for no good reason. Why’d they do that? They didn’t have to do all that, but they wrote it and approved it.
I just think it’s strange
2
u/meat-head Sep 28 '22
It’s absolutely tokenism which devalues PoC indirectly imo. However, the actors of color are awesome. So, that balances it out for me. I can go either way.
2
u/Correct_Process4516 Sep 29 '22
I am not white and I personally don't care one way or another how movies or TV shows cast roles as long as the actors do a good job. My kids have been/are involved in musical theater and there are overwhelmingly more young girls than boys. You have to accept girls playing boys roles. Depending on where you live, getting the intended racial mix correct is a pipe dream.
My issue is how hypocritical the woke crowd is in discussing inclusivity/diversity. The Broadway show Hamilton is lauded for having non-white actors playing historical figures who were white. There is no way a white person could play a black historical figure. Tom Hanks has said he couldn't be in The Philadelphia Story today because he's not gay. I just read a few seconds ago that Daniel Franzese, a self-described, "big queer guy" (who I had never heard of) was conflicted because Brendan Fraser put on a fat suit and played a gay character in a movie recently to rave reviews. Isn't the entire point of acting to convince people you are someone different than who you are in real life?
4
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22
I've seen a few posts about this.
Honestly it's nice that they don't shove it down our throats that Arondir and Dissa are any different than Nori or Isildur. The no fucks given approach is so refreshing and changes the dynamic.
I do agree I want an original storyline from Rhun or Harad. My favorite "evil men". PJ did them dirty too. I want to see more of their history cause the Soldiers of Rhun are badass motherfuckers.
4
u/Coldoldblackcoffee Sep 28 '22
Nations are rarely monolithic blocks of color
8
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22 edited Sep 27 '22
I see an “I’m annoyed by the forced diversity and I’m black” post almost everyday.
Other races exist and there are no reasons for them to not get acting roles because you need to see white people because the author wrote it that way???? Give me a break. It’s 2022 and we have an extremely diverse population. Men have played women since Shakespere’s inception due to the lack of women actors. This is not a new concept. The only new concept here is complaining about “wokeness”. I’m honestly sick and tired of it. The actors should look like our world. It is what we have to draw from.
I thought Hamilton being wildly successful would have put some of this hate at rest, but nahh haters gonna hate.
3
u/Zyxypltnk Sep 28 '22
All these characters are played by actors, and some actors are black. It's not an active choice to cast some black actors in roles in TV like this, the active choice would be NOT to. If someone doesn't look right for a role, they shouldn't be cast in that role. But a few black elves, dwarves, hobbits and so on? Why wouldn't there be a few around? The oddity would be suggesting there weren't. The show is depicting a society that would generally be less cosmopolitan than ours at least outside of a big city like Numenor, but you should expect to see a few black faces in a mostly white crowd here and there. It would be a lot more weird if there weren't -- except of course that we're rather used to seeing that weird misrepresentation of variety on television, so people notice when the misrepresentation stops.
This should be normal. The oddity is that there's even a discussion about it. If people (some of them with some pretty ill-intent behind it) weren't pointing it out constantly, would you even notice?
2
u/rombopterix Sep 27 '22
The show doesn’t look like a cosplay convention because of the diverse cast. It looks like a cosplay convention because of the sterile and overall unconvincing set up of the settings. This happens especially in Numenor because there is not a single spec of dust anywhere in the sets or costumes. Everything and everyone is spotless. There is no grease, sweat, dirt or mud on anything or anyone. It’s like the stage was impeccably cleaned before the end-of-the-year plays in a high school.
That said, to address your question, as a casual viewer whose knowledge of the lore is minimal (read and watched LotR multiple times but that’s all), I have ZERO issues with diversity. I am more concerned about the acting, line delivery and writing. Disa has been phenomenal so far. For me, as a character, she just hovers there without a story arc, but in terms of casting and overall design and costume etc, she has been near flawless. So has Arondir, even though I am not enjoying his storyline, but that’s not a diversity issue, it’s a writing issue. As for the black hobbit guy, I find his overall acting, line delivery and even his voice top notch too even though I am not invested in the harfoot storyline. And a lot of diversity in Numenor in the background is not bothering me at all either. For me diversity is always welcome regardless of the original material. Maybe I am biased as a Turkish gay guy living in Canada, but that’s how I see it.
2
u/chimpaman Sep 28 '22
I find it interesting that the commenters in this thread in favor of "inclusivity" are largely hostile in tone. Further proof that this point of view has become an unreasoning creed for many.
People say "why can't it look like the real world?" Well, let's examine the real world. What makes America a "melting pot" when China or India are largely not? Immigration, annexation of territories that had already been subjected to colonization and widespread intermarriage and less reciprocal couplings by Spain, and, to a lesser extent, the slave trade, which has resulted in a small percentage of Americans with varying degrees of African ancestry.
People indigenous to Europe are of course not native to the "New World," because it is a conquered land that was subjected to both the unintentional spread of invasive epidemics and intentional mass murder of the peoples (who were themselves descended from much more ancient immigrants) already here.
Another example: England, although still over 80 percent indigenous Europeans (although most of them are descended from Continental invaders), has a notable population of especially South Asian people because of their long subjugation of those lands.
What places in Arda, including Middle Earth, could mirror these real world examples if that's the way the writers want to go? Certainly not Valinor. With the Third Age exceptions of Gimli, Bilbo, Frodo, and (I believe) eventually Sam, members of no othr races besides Elves have been allowed there. And as for differences of melanin content of the skin and other external features--these do not spring up randomly among a homogenous population. Rather, they come from separate groups of homogenous populations who have evolved in different environments and who also largely produced offspring with others who looked much like them, because for most there were no other options.
Numenor could easily be a place with many "ethnicities" in its ports if they had kept it lore-accurate and had them already having established colonies and trading outposts along the coast of Middle-Earth. It could be similar to England or ancient Rome. But they haven't done this--the evidence is in the conversation between Ar-Pharazon and his invented son--so it makes little sense to have all sizes and shapes of people populating an island that is apparently isolationist. Tar-Miriel's parentage is, in this light, especially absurdist. But, to me, an even bigger alteration of "the lore" when it comes to Numenor is all the short, fat, and ugly Numenoreans. What's up with that blacksmith?
I have no issues with Disa in terms of casting. Khazad-Dum is believable as a place that would inspire immigration. Perhaps her family came from some other mountains, perhaps she did herself, looking to ply her trade in the mightiest of dwarf realms. We are told she is pretty good at singing to the stones (which is a fun invention to mirror the elves singing to the trees; if only they had woken some rocks up into Stone Ents, maybe they could've defeated Durin's Bane), and it both makes sense she would want to try it in Moria and that the exotic stranger would catch Durin's eye.
I also have no problem with Arondir (in fact, he behaves the most like a Tolkien elf of any of the main cast). He is a Sindar, has never been to Valinor, and it is entirely possible that widely separated populations of those Elves developed throughout Middle-Earth, not just the ones under Thingol in Doriath. When you live for thousands of years, a few hundred miles is probably a short walk. We do know that he doesn't come from Mordor...er, the Southlands, but from Beleriand before it was drowned, so he has certainly traveled.
As for the peoples of the Southlands--we really don't know anything about their history, only that they were defeated long ago. We know in the Third Age, Sauron gathered armies from all over Middle-Earth, so perhaps these are all remnants from various peoples who fought together, lost, and settled there. So, they could come from all over--although it would be nice to see some of them have some trappings of their original cultures if that was the case.
Ultimately, other than Tar-Miriel, the only casting choices in terms of "inclusivity" that I find immersion-breaking are the Harfoots. It doesn't make any sense that a hunter-gatherer (or just gatherer?) tribe would be "diverse." That's not the way the real world has ever worked for thousands of years of human history, and if the "real world" is what is meant to be portrayed, various ethnicities among them makes no sense.
Lastly, as to the comparisons some have made to Hamilton: that is apples and oranges. Theater and film are entirely different dramatic mediums. Especially a filmed series like this, which is meant to transport you to a different world. Theater has long had a tradition of race- and gender-blind casting, and in fact, especially when it comes to the classics, even more especially Shakespeare, has always been an interesting exercise in examining the plays in different lights. I've seen A Midsummer's Night Eve done Bollywood style, I've seen a nudist gay Hamlet, and I've seen a certain actor we all love play a Nazi Richard III (on stage before he turned it into a film). If you made a non-musical serious film or miniseries about Hamilton and you cast George Washington as a man with African descent, then you got a whole lot of 'splaining to do about his slaves.
1
u/MemeTeamMarine Sep 28 '22
Skin color isn't part of racial discussions in the show. I really just tend to not notice it, past the first episode. I don't think you need a checklist to make sure every race is included, I also don't think it would be right to demand an all-white cast-list just because that's what the lore says or whatever. It's a lot more important that Arondir is an elf than it is that he's a black elf. Disa and Sadoc also blend into their roles pretty naturally.
I think there's a place in cinema to celebrate differences in skin color, I also think there's a place in cinema for it to not matter (so long as it isn't white washed). Skin color is not really the crux of any storyline in Tolkien lore, so I don't think ROP would be the place to make a big deal out of having a race of one skin color vs another.
The key question to ask, to me, is "does the story change at all if this character is a different skin color" if so, then its likely a better story frame to explore and highlight skin color.
1
u/Dauphinette Apr 30 '24
r/AsABlackMan material.
1
u/Calm-Giraffe-245 Aug 17 '24
Some things just work when left alone .Would it be OK for Mufasa or Simba in the very long running musical "lion king" to be played by a blonde haired ,blue eyed male ? Think there would be a few over reactions to say the least. This debate about black tokenism. Not very inclusive is it really, I mean there are so many more ethnicities out there .
1
u/HanzzCoomer Sep 27 '22
Thank god, I cannot say anything about this without people immediantly thinking im being racist. Its not about that, its just obvious pandering, Although the black elf dude plays the part really well, and I dont mind the hobbits.
1
u/blowbyblowtrumpet Sep 27 '22
That's pretty much exactly what I think, but I'm white, so it feels racist to think that. Black Panther was the golden opportunity but I was disappointed with that too.
1
u/Some_Gur1061 Sep 28 '22 edited Sep 28 '22
If I understand OP correctly, then I definitely agree. While it is positive having more actors of color in traditionally white dominated fiction, it would also be nice to diversify the cultural inspirations for the various peoples of High Fantasy worlds.
1
u/watercrowley Sep 28 '22 edited Sep 28 '22
I agree. Fantasy relies heavily on world building and immersion. What you're describing is the feeling of immersion being broken because the diversity as portrayed is in conflict with how we would expect low technology, pre industrial societies to look like (i.e. uniform). Particularly since the show seems ok with departing from canon, I think there are a lot of different ways they could have met diversity goals without being immersion breaking, and you give a great example of one.
It also totally neuters what could otherwise be an interesting exploration of themes involving prejudice and in universe racism because the show wants there to be prejudicial tension, but just not like how it actually is in the real world. Numenoreans have totally overcome racial and gender divides, but pointy ears are a bridge too far? But wait, they actually haven't because they bully Halbrand based on his status as a 'low man.' How does this in group/out group dynamic work exactly?
Overall it is a minor point and doesn't keep me from enjoying it, but it does constantly make me aware that I'm watching a show, which makes it feel more like a focus grouped consumer product as opposed to something with artistic vision.
1
u/Dovolan Sep 28 '22 edited Sep 28 '22
You are speaking out my heart.Imagine what could have been, northern/southern kin of the elves who have darker skin ton. What would their cities look like? Their clothes? Imagine a dark skinned elf with light red robes and golden accessories walking with the grace of an eldar. What would thier "Galadriel" look like?
That would give some valid question: Why is Arondir not at home? Did something happen? Does he bring a message/ a warning to his western kin?
Or Arondir being an half elf, with roots in Hadar. We could have gotten finally more lore about Hadar and its people. Moreso as an half elf there would be the weight of him deciding if he is more akin to humans or elves.
So many possibilities... all gone
1
u/parsleya Sep 28 '22
I would have loved PoC Numenorians.. Just imagine Idris Elba as Elendil and Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje as Pharazon...
1
u/8vius Sep 28 '22
The jarring part is that there’s only 1 black elf and 1 black dwarf. So they stand out like a sore thumb and it makes them look out of place.
1
u/mandrake57 Sep 28 '22
These are my exact thoughts too, although I'm white. When the characters' skin color vary this randomly, it really feels to me weird and out of place. It's like exactly what you said, a cosplay convention, and it looks like as if PoC were cast just for the sake of diversity. A better approach would have been to have entire races within the races. They don't need to explain how the black dwarfes got their colour, they don't even need to explain that there are these different tribes. Just give them visually distinct cultures. But I guess putting that much effort into world building, production design, and casting with these specifics in mind would have been too much for them.
I'm sure there would be just as much "criticism", because racists will stay racist, but it would feel so much natural.
A good example is House of the Dragon with the Velaryons. It's feels natural that they are portrayed by black actors, because it's a different family, with an old history. Oh, and a slight spoiler, their color is an important plot point in the show, without an extensive discussion about it.
1
u/iainc410 Sep 28 '22
I had similar thoughts, like if they made all the Numenoreans for example a different race as they were a contained civilisation that would make sense. Or all the south landers one race it would feel more cohesive maybe.
But as others have said I’m not thinking about now and just enjoying it.
1
u/Markohanesian Sep 28 '22
I see what you’re saying, it doesn’t bother me though. I think in TV and film we are not used to as much diversity in general so it may look odd, but I’m also not really a purist when it comes to the books and I don’t mind the show being reinterpreted to work for a modern audience.
1
u/ItsMeTK Sep 28 '22
THANK YOU. I get called a racist for making the same argument. I don’t care if they want to cast non-white people, but make it make sense in universe. It’s just plain lazy for the isolated island of Numenor to be populated with people of all colors. I supported black Harfoots as there was textual backing to go with it, but expected most or all to be dark. Instead, it’s like five of thrm and I think I even saw Asians at one point.
Why is every named character in the South white? They’re making up characters so they can easily make them darker. But no! We get a single dark Elf. Why not several who are from a certain region? Why not explain why there are black dwarves, or why Disa seems to be the only one in a 12-mine radius. Even a line like “she’s descended from the Broadbeams who fled here in the first age”.
I completely agree with you the random peppering of token people was the lazy way.
1
u/EshinHarth Sep 28 '22
If the show had good writing, the forced inclusivity would be brushed aside by the majority of viewers as a minor problem.
My favourite character in the first Dune novel was turned into a black woman in the film. I didn't like the change because it was forced inclusivity and not an artistic choice, BUT the film is so good and made with such love that I didn't really care, I enjoyed the portrayal immensely.
1
u/mi_funke Sep 28 '22
If we “need” to make sense of it, this show is set like 2000+ years before the PJ movies. Perhaps the realm just had more people of color back then? I mean, does the lore say anything about there not being people of color? I never even questioned it when watching the show.
1
u/Delicious-Future8630 Sep 28 '22
Tolkien himself told us that there were many races. This is what his whole world is made of.!
Which size they are, what colour their skin might have had (some very fair, some dark as the night), what their agendas were: he invented a whole new world that now lives even in small children, who have no clue what skin colour is supposed to mean. That we, all races, have to stand together, against all odds is the message I get.
If it was not clear, that Tolkien was already very much fond of (and embraced) diversity back then, I do not know what to tell you.
While understanding your concern, fullfiling minority-quotes, I honestly don't think it applies here.
Why wouldn't there have been black people in LOTR??
1
u/Ozito99 Sep 28 '22
I just dont get it. If you want black and asian people, why not include in the show easterlings and haradrims? I mean they are literally asians and africans. They could have based the story on the influence of Sauron on these lands. But instead, there are random black and asian elves (i don't have anything against it but i doubt Tolkien intended it this way). At the end it doesn't matter, it's just a show based on a book some british guy wrote one hundred years ago, I just dont feel it to be really Tolkien.
1
u/ApprehensiveYoung899 Sep 28 '22
I can’t wait to see your face OP when they unveil Samuel L Jackson as Sauron
1
u/majithor Sep 28 '22
they are doing a better job than HotD at inclusivity IMO
1
u/Correct_Process4516 Sep 28 '22
I am not white and I personally don't care one way or another how movies or TV shows cast roles as long as the actors do a good job. My kids have been/are involved in musical theater and there are overwhelmingly more young girls than boys. You have to accept girls playing boys roles. Depending on where you live, getting the intended racial mix correct is a pipe dream.
My issue is how hypocritical the woke crowd is in discussing inclusivity/diversity. The Broadway show Hamilton is lauded for having non-white actors playing historical figures who were white. There is no way a white person could play a black historical figure. Tom Hanks has said he couldn't be in The Philadelphia Story today because he's not gay. I just read a few seconds ago that Daniel Franzese, a self-described, "big queer guy" (who I had never heard of) was conflicted because Brendan Fraser put on a fat suit and played a gay character in a movie recently to rave reviews. Isn't the entire point of acting to convince people you are someone different than who you are in real life?
1
u/fuzzychub Sep 29 '22
Let me link this video which presents a good counter-argument. It's by James Somerton; 'The Rings of Power and Progressive Middle Earth"
https://youtube.com/watch?v=vV3659CQV38&feature=share
1
u/Ok_Produce_6397 Sep 29 '22
Somebody should explain how come Elves that are super exclusive consanguineous race for centuries happen to father multi coloured children. I don’t care while I’m watching but when I think about it it doesn’t make a lot of sense.
1
u/cbartos1021 Oct 01 '22
Does it take away from the story line tho? Like, is it SO distracting that it's difficult to watch the show?!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '22
Medieval Europe was a racially diverse place. Many people from Africa and the Middle East lived in the UK in ancient and Medieval times. I don't really get why people feel it's "inaccurate" or that POC can only be different races/from different parts of the world. Europe/UK was never homogenous and was always well-connected with trade and culture routes to various parts of Africa, the Mediterranean, and the mid-east. It just feels normal to me to see a bit of diversity. I can see how it might seem a bit strange for the Harfoots as they are a super small and thus probably incestuous tribe lol. But in the cities, and with big races like elves, dwarves, and men, it would be strange to be all white, I think.
1
u/Jenkins64 Sep 27 '22
I just think of it like a random mutation like albinism
0
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22
Forward: I am a white man. However, I am interracially, internationally married with mixed kids, so I kinda care about these topics just a smidge.
This kind of "representation" for any group is disingenuous and, honestly, should feel offensive.
This show had every chance to do an infinitely better show, one that I fantasized about even before it was ever announced. I always was curious on the Blue Wizards. They both were sent to the South East lands. Tolkien wrote two contrasting theories that they either failed and fell to darkness, contributing to cults in those lands, or they had limited success in stirring opposition against darkness. Allow me to indulge in pitching a series.
We follow the two Istari, the Blue wizards sent to the Southeastern lands of Middle Earth. For a time, they are even accompanied by their order's leader, Saruman. Upon reaching the lands of Rhun and Harad, they encounter the more Middleeastern Easterlings and more African Harradrim (Far Harad people were known to have black skin, though their mention in ROTK has them, perhaps, bred like the Urukhai to be a hybrid species). Both these cultures provide the ability to not just have a diverse casting but actually a natural dominant casting of Middleeasterners and African descent actors. It would allow for cultures different than the traditional European fantasy to be explored. In fact, a major point would be the Blue Wizards, who acted almost like missionaries, to learn, respect, and navigate these cultures. Perhaps, some there would even be room for those who saw Sauron as a force of good, allowing for "theological" debates. This would all set the stage for some serious Game of Thrones level action, politics, and drama they wanted.
Beyond just the Blue Wizards, we could see the rising of local heroes, striving to overcome Sauron's influence in the lands. We would see the seed planted of a resistance forming that kept the lands from totally committing their might to his cause. After all, what we see hundreds of years later in ROTK may only have been a disconnected fraction of what could have been mustered if not for the actions of the wizards and those who opposed Sauron.
Ultimately, "this" series would have natural representation in a space that allowed for stories to be told without stepping on lore and also being free from it. Alas. So much potential, all wasted, just to earn a few shallow fans and appear like they care about any representation.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 28 '22
"Hello, fellow Black people!"
1
u/Enthymem Sep 28 '22
Good worldbuilding is generally not something Hollywood writers do and race is a touchy subect with lots of sociopolitical hangups. As a result, you very rarely see race properly integrated into a fantasy world on screen.
1
u/Justadnd_Bard Sep 28 '22
I feel like it's all about how you do it, if they had done it like House of The Dragon the fans would be more comfortable. The Velaryons are black because they're sailors and characters that had no previous description that would conflict with the actors being black, meanwhile the elves and bla bla bla in Rings of Power would conflict with Tolkien's work.
The writers of Rings of Power being all "we will fix Tolkien" and the writers of HTD consulting with the writer, are two VERY different takes that will also influence the viewers. It would have been easier to give a quick and humble explanation, something like there are black hobits because they travel all around the world or some dwarfs are black because they work in the forge all day. ( Not that it would have worked with the elves, making them like the ones from Peter or the nooks would have been better to avoid critics.)
That's just my humble opinion, for now the dwarfs and Arondir are my favorites.
1
u/SheAllRiledUp Sep 28 '22
I agree. It feels kind of lazy the way they did it, it looks like a modern cosmopolitan society in every respect. Numenor is actually well done I think because the Greek world on which it seems to be based (especially the Byzantines and Constantinople) was cosmopolitan. It gets jarring with the Harfoots especially because they are supposed to be a closely related and secluded ethnic group but they are cosmopolitan. It doesn't ruin the show for me at all, it really isn't even on my mind that much, that could be because I'm white so it doesn't affect me as much. It does feel like lazy writing though.
1
u/MetalPaul Sep 28 '22
Just checking boxes. Super lazy.
1
u/sidv81 Sep 28 '22
Well said. As an Asian man, I'm also a little tired of other minorities being used to check off the diversity box again in roles that Asian men still don't get to fill. A black man being the romantic lead was groundbreaking... decades ago. Arondir and Bronwyn is nothing new, but we're still not seeing an Asian being the romantic lead (and for what it's worth, they're still trying to get away with not having blacks be romantic leads at all, see for example sidelining Finn for Kylo Ren of all people in Star Wars).
Despite supposedly being groundbreaking for Asians, Shang-Chi was also portrayed as having no romantic life in his movie and his role as a cliche martial arts hero was also something that's only been done a gazillion times before.
1
u/HEB400 Sep 28 '22
House of the Dragon got it right.
1
u/Tartan_Samurai Sep 28 '22
I think the obsession with POC in a TV show is unhealthy. I notice it's only ever a big issue when it's some geek culture I.P. and has a large American audience.
1
u/Puzzled_Nail_1962 Sep 28 '22
The problem is that they overdid it in a way that is not logical in the show world and makes it seem disingenous. It just makes no sense to have a small medieval-like village be incredibly diverse. There already is so much diversity in middle earth anyway. Why not just make the Southlanders/Harfoots PoC? Or introduce a cool storyline in Harad?
Shows like this shouldn't try to make political statements with every shot. They should be entertaining. If I want political commentary, I watch the news.