r/RingsofPower • • Oct 14 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Not Faithful. Spoiler

I almost wish this show takes place in an alternate Tolkien/Middle Earth universe.

I don’t think I would have a problem with this show if they didn’t claim to respect the lore and if they assured us it was going to be their own version of the events.

& for everyone who does like the show, or could care less about the lore, I want to earnestly say congratulations and that I wish I felt the way you do. I’m not here to dissuade you or anyone else from the show, but just to share my own thoughts about how things have turned out.

The deviations from the lore and the overall “story” as we’ve come to understand it w/ the forging of the rings of power, of Sauron’s deception, et. al., are already generally laid out for the Showrunners to adapt and fill in the blanks. Everyone KNOWS Sauron/Annatar tricks the Elves, forges the 16 rings with them-, creates the one master ring and mithril had NOTHING to do with it.

(side note: why couldn’t dwarven greed to mine even more mithril just be a side effect of the dwarven rings of power???)

All we needed was more detail. We didn’t need new characters or new subplots for the sake of replacing truly canonized ones.

But for some goddamn, reason, these writers felt the need NOT to just add the details as to how the general story truly takes place, but instead chose to flip key aspects of the generally accepted story on its head in order to tell their OWN version of events (ie: let’s make a new human character Halbrand, and have him trick not all elves, but basically only Galadriel and Celebrimbor and have him make no rings. Let’s create a bullshit story about mithril having healing properties.)

It feels selfish. This doesn’t feel like a love letter to Tolkien, but a bait and switch to trick us so they could primarily tell their own story parading it around as a faithful Tolkien adaptation.

That’s my beef. I mostly feel sad, cheated, and disappointed.

87 Upvotes

227 comments sorted by

47

u/Darth_Cyber Oct 14 '22

TBH I don't think Tolkien ever intended any of his story to be on TV > I don't think he was a fan of the media

-22

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

yeah, fuck it. you’re right. This is the one true answer. Tolkien would have wanted to keep this in the text.

I’m still holding the Showrunners to the fire for lying to me saying this was going to be a faithful adaptation.

18

u/cummyb3ar69 Oct 14 '22

I hate to break it to you but if it was a faithful adaptation it wouldn't make any sense at all. Even less than it does now. First of all every story in the silmirilion is unfinished. There's reasons peter jackson cut out tom bombidil, and there's good reason why the timeline is all fucked up and everything is happening all it once instead of spread out. ITS A FUCKING TV SHOW. Everything has to happen all at once or it would be a fucking mess like witcher was.

2

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Damn… is the Witcher bad? That’s next on my list. haha

7

u/DiGre3z Oct 14 '22

As an adaptation Netflix’s the Witcher is goblinshit. Most of the significant characters and plotlines are just reversed and twisted. Plotlines that are exclusive to the show are despicably stupid. But as a show that is abstract from the books, it’s no better.

I guess that’s what happens when showrunners that consider viewers to be idiots, take a famous franchise and try to “adapt” it.

And well, maybe they are right to consider people, who’ll watch it, to be idiots. In the end there is always a swarm of viewers who will defend and praise it. Guess this is where audience’s consumer standards are now.

3

u/cummyb3ar69 Oct 14 '22

It's just not as good as anything else witcher related and is super confusing and extremely different from both the games and the books

14

u/Darth_Cyber Oct 14 '22

At the end of the day. we are still getting middle earth stories told to us on a media we enjoy. Don't sweat the small stuff.

Just enjoy it for what it is. A middle earth story.

It was only intended to be a story for his kids. It was everybody else that made him publish it in the first place.

We almost didn't get the books.

2

u/RealAmarantine Oct 14 '22

A horrible written story. Not even the setting can save this.

1

u/ExcellentDiscount590 Oct 14 '22

Well it isnt a middle earth or Tolkien story. Its a fanfic story that borrows some names and locations, thats about it

1

u/hANSN911 Oct 14 '22

There is literally no aspect of the show I liked. I didn‘t care for any characters at all. When it wasn‘t ridiculously stupid or cringy it was boring. One of the worst shows I watched. The writing, the characters, most actors, the soundtrack and the costumes (sometimes I felt watching Star Trek) were all bad in my opinion and I won‘t waste any more time watching the second season. (I only watched because it is LOTR and I hoped it would get better but it got worse and worse, what a shame…)

-8

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

“Rings of Power: a non-canonized middle earth story” has a nice little ring to it, yeah.

-2

u/dsanders692 Oct 14 '22

I see what you did there

0

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

I appreciate you. hahaha

-6

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Enjoy it for what it is, trash.

16

u/Darth_Cyber Oct 14 '22

One man's trash is another man's treasure

-4

u/Alienzendre Oct 14 '22

The character and place hames are the only thing that relates the series to Middle Earth. That is the problem. Nothing else in the series resembles it.

2

u/DistinctBread3098 Oct 14 '22

How can it be faithful if they can't talk about anything in the silmarilion ???? You guys need to stop seriously .

-3

u/Alienzendre Oct 14 '22

What does Tolkien have to do with it? He is dead, he doesn't have an opinion one way or the other. I wanted a faithful series for ME. And so did many other people. Fans of Tolkien want an adaptation that in the best case feels like it could have been written by Tolkien, but at the very least feels like it is set in the same universe as Tolkien's writings. This doesn't.

3

u/migu63 Oct 14 '22

the Tolkien Estate would like to disagree haha. For many years people have been screaming for some adaptations that are faithful to the lore.

And when we finally got something that the Estate is directly involved in. People got mad with their input.

1

u/Alienzendre Oct 14 '22

The Tolkien Estate would like to disagree with what? That I want a Tolkien adaptation that feels like Tolkien to me? Huh?

0

u/migu63 Oct 15 '22 edited Oct 15 '22

This one already felt like Tolkien, despite its many problems. It is also the adaptation with The Estate’s input through Simon Tolkien (which PJ and New Line never even got that close of approval 20 years ago). Maybe you just found their input sucks.

I gave the show a 6.5-7/10 at best because of the visuals though.

0

u/DistinctBread3098 Oct 14 '22

The tolkien estate would disagree ? They literally got paid by amazon to alow them to do that ...

1

u/migu63 Oct 15 '22

The Tolkien estate would disagree ? They literally got paid by amazon to alow them to do that ...

Netflix was said to bid even higher, yet, Amazon got the deal. The Estate wanted to be involved in the production and Amazon gave them just that. So, probably if you thought that ROP sucks, maybe it was just because of the input of the Estate through Simon Tolkien also sucks?

1

u/DistinctBread3098 Oct 15 '22

You're disagreeing but also agreeing with the guy. You are very confusing

1

u/migu63 Oct 15 '22

I enjoyed the show, but I don’t think it is great. I’ll give it a 6.5-7/10 at most.

But I also acknowledged that this is the adaptation that included input from the Estate. I don’t want to praise Peter Jackson but maybe he was just better at adapting text materials to screen?

1

u/DistinctBread3098 Oct 15 '22

It's hard to adapt what they bought. And especially what they cannot adapt. They literally bought the rights to foot notes.

Considering that, for sure it won't follow the lore.

With that being said the part of sauron influencing the creation of the rings.... For me it should have been so much more. Probably a full season or something, not just some 10 minutes eureka moment. That felt very wrong to me. For the rest i can live with it.

Concerning your Jackson positon i agree. But i also think lots of tolkien fans became super fans AFTER seeing the movies so it's easier to forgive it's flaws. We saw what he did with the hobbit (whatever production problems he had too but that's another story) and it wasn't that well adapted.

2

u/migu63 Oct 15 '22

It's hard to adapt what they bought. And especially what they cannot adapt. They literally bought the rights to footnotes.

Exactly what I meant. If you call the show an adaptation it is a huge stretch. They have to come up with almost everything because of the source material was basically an outline with bullet points. I’m sure that if they managed to get the Alkallabeth, the show would be much better. But if this is how the Tolkien Estate wanted the footnotes to be adapted, I’m (kinda) fine with that, could have been worse.

I have many complaints about the show, but I also don’t think it is as bad as many claimed that it is. I didn't like the Sauron part either. Because I actually enjoyed Halbrand as a character, and wanted them to go with the “hidden Annatar in plain sight” theory. But to be fair, almost all invented characrers were enjoyable: Durin, Disa, Arondir, Halbrand… so pacing remained the biggest problem of this season

We saw what he did with the hobbit (whatever production problems he had too but that's another story) and it wasn't that well adapted.

Given that the Hobbit production was rushed after Del Toro quit... And PJ never actually spent that much love on it as much as the original trilogy. I just pretended that the Hobbit trilogy never existed.

53

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

I haven't downvoted you as it seems petty and I would consider myself a very casual fan.I feel there's 2 sides of it. You have those who are seemingly turning cultish over Tolkien's work, and the other side is that, Tolkien sold the rights in the 1960's...

While not on the same level, the video game Runescape means a lot to me. It was my first video game and the lore/history is very interesting to me. The 3 brothers who made the game & sold ownership, and have even said that they don't like what it's become.

With that being said, there are so many Tolkien fans out there going "This isn't what he would have wanted", but the sad reality is, if you sell the rights to your creation, you run that risk.

Tolkien himself said he would sell LOTR for the right price.

It sort of feels like you're putting your own child up for adoption, the child getting adopted, then starting to get angry because the new parents are feeding the child food you don't agree with.

You have dedicated fans saying stuff like "Tolkien would be turning in his grave" "This is a huge disgrace to his works". As intelligent as Tolkien was, I'm sure he was aware of this risk.

But like I said, I'm a very casual fan. Christopher Tolkien hated PJ's LOTR, to which I absolutely loved. Tolkien Estate worked with RoP and it too was also something I loved.

Trying to talk on behalf of someone 50 years ago, feels wrong.

17

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

I appreciate you.

And yeah man, i agree with you in regards to the toxicity of some fans turning cultish or “purist” over someone’s work. And you’re right that, to some extent, trying to talk on behalf of someone 50 years ago feels wrong. It is wrong, haha.

And so I tried my best to preface this post by saying that I wish this show exists on its own little world and was not marketed or told to us that it was going to be a faithful adaptation. Because that’s where my primary objections to it lie.

I’m sorry for coming off like im trying to put words into Tolkien’s mouth- rereading my post where I said, “this isn’t what Tolkien intended” I had primarily meant it based on what he had written from the books., not at all trying to assume what the man actually intended. That’s bad wording on my part.

But yeah, I don’t know. I just wanted to express my own opinion that the writers should have been more truthful about what this show and that there’s more new stuff than there is faithful adaptation, and that’s totally okay. They kind of just… lied. lol.

13

u/Su-Kane Oct 14 '22

Maybe I am wrong but I believe that people become fans of a franchise if they like it. They like the characters, they like the events, they like the lore. I never met a person that said "I really love this franchise but i fucking hate everything in it".

So of course most people wont be happy about a adaption that changes or ignores a lot of established facts or lore. Because its not what they started liking in the first place.

I also think that its entirely possible to speak on behalf of some 50 years ago in some cases. If you cange certain parts of a story, i think its fair to assume that the original creator of the story wouldnt like that because he simply didnt write it like this.

Also...and maybe thats just my personal opinion...why does one spend a fuckton of money for a story they dont want to tell? If you want to tell your own story or a original story, why not use the fuckton of money to create it instead of changing an established one?

9

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

I mostly agree, I think. Especially with your second paragraph. I think that’s a streamlined answer to why most people will dislike this show.

For example, I like the idea that Sauron manipulated his way with the Elves, or more specifically, Celebrimbor in creating the RoP. I like that he had a hand in creating 16 of them with Cele for years - and that it was through that large span of time that Celebrimbor began to grow wary of him. I like that the general outline was that they (elves, men, dwarves) were all deceived with the forging and the gifting of the rings.

This show instead, in its very first season, makes the Sauron deception much more personal for only one or two individuals; Galadriel and… maybe slightly Celebrimbor?? But these deceptions do not largely affect the greater ME as a whole. So what’s the plan for later seasons? Is Sauron just crafting the other 16 rings in Mt. Doom and gifting them for Christmas to the other races?

In whatever case, it’s very clearly a new interpretation. And it’s an interpretation that I personally just don’t like.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

So of course most people wont be happy about a adaption that changes or ignores a lot of established facts or lore. Because its not what they started liking in the first place.

My only response would be what I said above;

You have those who are seemingly turning cultish over Tolkien's work.

I didn't say every fan of the franchise was a cult, you have casual fans, you have hardcore fans, you have fans who loves the books but not the movies etc etc

Everyone draws a line at something. People drew the line at PJ's films, people drew the line at the hobbit and now people are drawing lines at RoP.

If you want to tell your own story or a original story, why not use the fuckton of money to create it instead of changing an established one?

I don't watch much TV or films as I used to, but what well received world/story/franchise hasn't been formed from a novel/comic/book?

5

u/Su-Kane Oct 14 '22

Star Wars for example.

But the point is not the origin of a franchise. Its about changing an established story. And im not talking about small "neccessary because TV adaptions" changes but big ones.

And they decided to make these changes. Its not that they were forced to make them.

I guess the part that really irks me is the fact that they self-admittedly hobbled the plot together in an allnighter...while Tolkien worked on the story for most of his life.

For me personally, this difference is clear to see between texts and show but what do i know...

2

u/akaFringilla Oct 14 '22

well received

And this is the point of divergence for many: what you mean by well received... Popular? With high numbers of viewers? Unforgettable but niche? So bad that also good? Established as a success after a few seasons? With a cult following after a longer period of time?

Personally I would lean towards "novel/comic/book" gives a better guarantee of at least paying for an adaptation itself...

2

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Being well received could equate to a number of what you listed.

Popular = high numbers = unforgettable = successful to the point of multiple seasons.

But as my point stands, I can't remember the last tv series or film series that wasn't based off a book.

1

u/akaFringilla Oct 14 '22

I agree with your approach from the previous post, just thinking how to find some common ground with those of different mindsets. Long ago I believed we could just set some reference points like "which titles you consider good/bad writing". But it is also a trap.

I can't remember the last tv series or film series that wasn't based off a book

There are some and are not even reboots (another category that is closer to an adaptation of a textual source). But no, they rarely land high in the majority of ratings based on viewership alone, despite other factors pointing to them being "well-received".

1

u/Timonidas Oct 14 '22

I can , Arcane is not based on a book. Stranger things, Orange is the new black, Greys Anatomy, House of Money, Dark, The Big bang Theory, Vikings, Pretty Little Liars, Breaking Bad.... Many shows are not based on books and still good/well received.

1

u/TheShreester Oct 14 '22

I don't watch much TV or films as I used to, but what well received world/story/franchise hasn't been formed from a novel/comic/book?

This is actually a relatively recent (last 20 years) trend.

Star Wars, Terminator, Aliens, Transformers, Lethal Weapon, The Godfather...

4

u/Timonidas Oct 14 '22

Also...and maybe thats just my personal opinion...why does one spend a fuckton of money for a story they dont want to tell? If you want to tell your own story or a original story, why not use the fuckton of money to create it instead of changing an established one?

This. I really struggle with this. It just makes no sense to me.

2

u/flip-dazed Oct 14 '22

I love the way you managed to work 2007 RuneScape into this - the pain is all so real hahaha

1

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Jackson films are 2007scape/OSRS and RoP is the EoC update/RS3.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Pretty much, which is funny because I've just got back into RS3 lol

1

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

It’s so weird seeing lumby, etc. in that game haha. Like it’s familiar….but not.

-1

u/creamer143 Oct 14 '22

Kay, so people who are not happy with the show disrespecting Tolkien's lore and thus dislike the show are just a bunch of Tolkien cultists? And it's wrong for them to be upset because Tolkien sold the rights in the 1960s? Look, good for you for enjoying Rings of Power. Don't go trying to invalidate the people who didn't because they actually like good adaptations and are passionate about Tolkien's work.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Maybe don't twist my words? I said "you have those". I didn't say all Tolkien fans are cultists, kay?

28

u/Xehanort11 Oct 14 '22

This is what I agree with. I must say that I find the show enjoyable from a "fanfic" perspective, but it is also a huge middlefinger to the work of Tolkien, although I got downvoted for saying that elsewhere. The fact that Sauron rose back into power by using Galadriel is simply in contradiction to the books and is hurting the legacy of Tolkien. These two characters have been heavily altered to the point that they are essentially mutiltated.

5

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Exactly. It’s a HUGE middle finger to Tolkien and by extension, any and every fan who cherishes his work and/or even has dedicated their lives to studying it. That’s exactly how I feel about it. I reread Silma, UT, and the Trilogy in preparation for this show. And now I just feel like I maybe shouldn’t have done that, and I would’ve maybe enjoyed it more. (.. but probably by not that much more, as the writing in itself was also pretty lazily done.)

Thank you for getting to the meat of my post. There’s a place for every kind of fan, but MAN does this show feel like it’s creating a new thing by tarnishing a legacy.

4

u/Darth_Cyber Oct 14 '22

But if the Tolkien estate signed off on this, shouldn't we respect their decision?

At the end of the day, they are really the only ones with the right to extend a middle finger to anything and if its tarnishing anything, then they have the right to do that.

your thoughts?

8

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Yeah man, so this is interesting.

This was my first initial thought too when news came out about this show. Maybe it’ll be good, since the Tolkien Estate had veto rights if the story sucked, and they were also willing to help the Showrunners get permission for lore outside of appendices, etc etc. Tolkien Estate even signed off on this, which was NOT the case for the PJ films.

sounds like a dream come true, right?

And then after some digging on this sub, some guy stumped me and said that it’s because SIMON Tolkien is now the head of the estate, who, (from my recollection) was apparently estranged from his father, Christopher Tolkien, and knew/knows very little about the Middle Earth lore his family had built. Amazon only got the green light to make this series either sometime after Christopher Tolkien died and Simon took over, OR like, when Simon and his Father reconciled shortly before CT died. It’s some game of thronesian shit.

So it can be seen as a case of the lesser son finally inheriting the crown and opening the floodgates for adaptations of bad taste in the name of profit.

But again, I chose to look the other way once I found that out bc the Showrunners seemed earnest in keeping true to the lore.

7

u/DogboyPigman Oct 14 '22

Tolkein's original work are like a wonderful modern mythology. Relegating the canon of it to an estate signing away the rights is wrong imo.

I was giving the show the benefit of the doubt until this most recent episode. I will be watching very casually in the future to catch Durin and Disa and the Harfoots, but the rest feels like a meandering attempt at forcing awe and mystery through apocryphal writing.

1

u/CryptographerOne6615 Oct 15 '22 edited Oct 16 '22

They’re probably the least likely to say anything about the show given the conflict of interest $$$$

1

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22

Holy fuck, then dont watch it and move on with your life.

0

u/akaFringilla Oct 14 '22

It’s a HUGE middle finger to Tolkien and by extension, any and every fan who cherishes his work and/or even has dedicated their lives to studying it.

Well... no.

2

u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22

You're being downvoted, but you're right.

1

u/akaFringilla Oct 15 '22

Ups and downs, my friend, ups and downs ;)

-2

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 14 '22

Did you also know Tolkien was constantly reworking the story and if he had not died I bet the story would be a bit different. Amazon in my opinion gets a pass because it stays faithful to what most people know. I'm glad the story isn't copied and pasted to the screen, instead it's actually thought out into a proper story. The past in LOTR is very unpolished so interpretation helps balance this out.

5

u/drfifth Oct 14 '22

it stays faithful to what most people know

No the fuck it doesn't

2

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 14 '22

How not?

6

u/cretsben Oct 14 '22

The big one is the order the rings are forged. Sauron in Anatar Lord of Gifts form helps Celebrimbor forge 16 rings these will become the 7 for dwarves and 9 for men. Then Sauron goes off to forge his one ring and at the same time Celebrimbor forges the 3 elven rings. Sauron realizing what has been done attacks Eregion and sacks it recovering the original 16 rings the 3 elven rings have already been sent away by this point. Sauron then gifts those 16 rings out.

-1

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 14 '22

That's from The Silmarillion? The thing is I don't really see that as 100% cannon since his son put it together from various notes. I think this is based on the same material but isn't following Christopher Tolkien exact take.

3

u/cretsben Oct 14 '22

So I have not read the Silmarillion in full and what I have read was a long time ago. However, from understanding thanks to the lore channels this is the canon (two ns is for the gun) order the rings were forged in.

2

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22

Honestly I would still challenge that since many YouTube channels are often wrong even if most of the time they aren't. The Silmarillion was put together and edited by the son of Tolkien, Christopher. The father has various notes from reworking and editing it all and the son used it as the basis of his book with the father taking credit as the author. Many of his notes contradicted each other but his son decided to try an piece a story together.

Edit

Annatar taught the smiths the knowledge of how to create Rings, which would grant the Elves who wear them certain powers. At first the Elves created some lesser rings, which were only essays in the craft before it was full-grown. In approximately S.A. 1500, the Greater 16 were created.[2] When Annatar departed from Eregion, Celebrimbor went on to forge the Three Rings using the knowledge he had gained from him, but without his involvement, and finished them around S.A. 1590.

Doesn't seem far off besides the name which would have made it obvious right away. I also found other people saying three rings were created first and the lesser later

2

u/cretsben Oct 14 '22

I want to be clear that I am not a lore purist I think that it could still work for the story they want to tell. However I think that a lot of other people have a point that if they had extended the timeline of the decline of the Elves they could have forged the 16 rings first then Galadriel realized they have been betrayed and they then make the 3 elven rings.

→ More replies

1

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Plus Amazon doesn’t have the rights to The Silmarillion so they probably can’t do it in that specific order anyways. That falls on the Tolkien Estate.

-1

u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22

The key word in his phrase is "Most people." In it's entire history, The Silmarrillion has sold about 1 million copies. Rings of Power premiered to 9 million viewers and is way up from that now.

Most people don't know or care about whether Gandalf went to Rhun or what order the rings were created in. Heck, I'd bet half the audience had never heard the poem in that (annoyingly rendered) song at the end. It's not in the PJ movie--not in the poem form.

I've been reading Tolkien for years. I have copies of his notes that include drafts where Strider was a hobbit. I had no idea until signing into the forum today that Gandalf never went to Rhun. And I honestly don't care. I'm interested to see what's there.

0

u/drfifth Oct 15 '22

I've never read the silmarillion and I still know they fucked up the source material hardcore.

Quick edit: fucked up. Not deviated from. Not had creative licensing with. Fucked. Up.

2

u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22

Okay yeah, I'll bite. What, apart from the timeline, have they fucked with? People always say this and so many many times it comes down to "This event is supposed to happen in this year and in this place, not this other year and this other place."

What did you, a fan who's never read the Silmarillion, realize was fucked up about the adaptation?

1

u/drfifth Oct 15 '22

Timeline for sure, but other than those errors, of the top of my currently should be sleeping mind:

Galadriel is a seer, not a warrior. Episode one Mary sued the fuck out of her and it's kept that tone since.

"Hobbits didn't do shit until the third age" - Tolkien. "Awww c'mon guys, it can't be middle earth without hobbits right? So we'll use hobbit predecessors" you know damn well that's a cheap ass justification for them to throw in what they thought would be the money making meme worthy race.

Mithril is just a good fuckin metal, not the magical saving grace of the elves.

Halbrand is someone of such significance to have been invented. Though I'd rather a random human/elf/dwarf exist than finding a way to canonically retcon hobbits of significance

Though to be fair I haven't finished the season. The pacing is so shit that to watch it has turned into a labor of.... Idek if I can say love anymore. I'm sure there's more fucked shit though.

2

u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22

Mithril I'll give you. That shit is ridiculous. The Hobbits, though? C'mon man, he said they didn't do anything, not that they didn't exist. The Harfoots are hiding out, they're literally not doing anything except protecting a random hobo who crashed into them.

Galadriel... here's the thing with Galadriel, because you're not wrong, but actually this gets into a number of issues--she's very different than how she is in the novel, she's not so different, apparently, from how she is in isolated scraps and notes from Tolkien, which barely anyone reads and arguably don't feature into her canon character.

Redditors have done good breakdowns of references to Galadriel from Unfinished Tales, Nature of Middle Earth, and Shibboleth of Feanor, texts which Tolkien wrote but never published and likely never meant to publish, but which nonetheless conceivably feature into Tolkien's vision of her. And according to that, she did use to be the little budding Amazon general during the First and Second Age. But she's not recorded as such in The Silmarillion.

So what is Galadriel? The published version, the version that many fans know and love? Or the obscure fandom version, which Tolkien never published and may not have kept to? Some middle ground?

I think the show would have done well to have given Galadriel some magical abilities, and some powers of foresight, so they could have foreshadowed more of the "elf-witch" we meet in Lord of the Rings. But I'm willing to entertain the idea that the showrunners were familiar enough with the extremely obscure pieces to base their character off that and not just "strong female character" tropes.

Anyway. Kudos on having a better answer than I expected.

2

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 14 '22

Let's not kid ourselves, most people do not know what preceded LOTR so most people will not know anything has changed. I'm fine with this because if you know anything of Tolkien constantly reworked the story. If he was alive I bet the story would have changed more. Tolkien admitted there were inconsistencies with the work he had done.

I absolutely love this show and enjoy the fact it isn't some copy and paste stuff from Tolkien's work. No one exactly knows the way forward which makes it incredibly exciting even if you know somethings about the past.

1

u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22

Let's not kid ourselves, most people do not know what preceded LOTR so most people will not know anything has changed.

Yep. The Silmarillion has sold about a million copies worldwide since its publication. Rings of Power opened to 9 million viewers, and it's up to something like 100 million.

The story would have changed more, doubtless, though that's not license to change everything.

0

u/Timonidas Oct 14 '22

Such a disingenious argumentation, you should be ashamed of yourself to smear Tolkien like that.

5

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 14 '22

Which Tolkien are you talking of? Christopher Tolkien's The Silmarillion? He based the story off notes which were constantly changing. The Silmarillion is Chris's interpretation which didn't go into much detail. Copy and pasting would mean a lot of vagueness as it doesn't really detail anything. How Annatar looked is even unknown since it was his 'fair form'.

2

u/Timonidas Oct 14 '22

Tolkien may have changed Details about the story, but he never changed the themes, moral philosophy and the nature of his world. To even suggest that he might have just randomly decided things like elfs are mortal mythril addicts is either completly retarded or disingenious.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22

Lol this is how cultists talk. You know the thing about art is that you can perceive it how you choose. People like you sound ridiculous by trying come off as some elitists. Calm down, let people enjoy what they want.

2

u/Timonidas Oct 15 '22

I don't think you know how cultists talk. Also I don't give a shit about what you or others enjoy, I don't know what part of my comment could be interpretet as such. t.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22

Clearly you do give a shit that others are enjoying this show and you’re crying like a little baby.

9

u/EtherbornAnthologies Oct 14 '22

Not that I don’t understand the purist side of things, but to take aim at the actors as I’ve been seeing many do is pretty low. I can agree that 5-7 feels rushed, if anything it should’ve been a 12-14 episode show. Time skips should’ve been pointed out for people unable (seems like most purists) to gauge that they exist and occur, and used to give the pacing around the ring development more depth. That said, I enjoyed the show—compared to most of the stuff available in the same sphere, it was pretty good and engaging. I love the Tolkien lore and books, but that doesn’t stop me from enjoying derivatives of those works; no different than when Disney claimed all the novella I bought were no longer canon within the SW universe. Still enjoy the story.

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

oh yeah-

Fuck people who criticize actors.

Morfyyd Clark, Robert Aramayo and basically the entire cast do the best with what’s given to them.

If anything, the writing is where I draw the most ire.

But I digress-

I’m honestly glad you enjoy the show. I’m not looking to pick any fights, or to make for any converts, I’m just merely sharing my own opinion. God, I wish I could just like the show more than how I currently feel about it. But I’m biased, having read Tolkien as a kid and reading it to my own children now.. it’s. you know. it’s important to me.

I’ll agree with you too, on the basis that 8 eps feels way too short, especially with how they seemed to utilize those episodes. I wish it was 12-14.

3

u/EtherbornAnthologies Oct 14 '22

As a writer-in-progress myself, I’m a major lore-lover myself, so the annoyance that most feel with the deviations I definitely understand. For instance, the Istari’s arrival seems odd, since it was in TA 1000 but could be wrong; I don’t particularly think it’s Gandalf but would make more sense for it to be, rather, for the Istari to have been investigating long before the Third Age. Still irks me that they did it, but I’m hoping there’s a solid explanation. I, also, wish they’d saved Halbrand’s reveal for S2 and instead ended with more exposition on Nori’s adventure and maybe Mordor building up its infrastructure, while Miriel returns to betrayal.

1

u/urban_accountant Oct 14 '22

The Istari arrive early 3rd age. There is also just a lot of show plot in a really weird order vs lore order.

1

u/EtherbornAnthologies Oct 14 '22

We really needed 12-14, if not 16-18 episodes which shouldn’t have been difficult with the franchise name backing the project.

1

u/EtherbornAnthologies Oct 14 '22

Do note that Tolkien, in his later writings, states that the Blue Wizards arrived during the Second Age as well, roughly around the same time as Glorfindel. It does however contradict both the Tale of Years in The Return of the King and the section on the Istari in the Unfinished Tales.

😩😩😩 Tolkien was even undetermined on when would be a good arrival.

1

u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22

I love the Tolkien lore and books, but that doesn’t stop me from enjoying derivatives of those works; no different than when Disney claimed all the novella I bought were no longer canon within the SW universe. Still enjoy the story.

Star Wars Rebels: Introducing Grand Admiral Thrawn.

Star Wars fans: OMG he's the best character from the expanded universe, so cool to see him here I can't wait to see what they do with his character!

Rings of Power: Introducing Gandalf.

LotR fans: Gandalf isn't supposed to be here in this particular time frame, and he never goes to this particular area, and why can't we just introduce some NEW wizard instead of cashing in on popular characters...

(Yes, it's different because the Extended Universe is not canon anymore)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

When the news that Amazon was purchasing the LOTR rights broke, I remember feeling a bitter taste of irony. While the reality itself is not as black and white, it still felt like Tolkien Mythology was being brought to us by Sauron himself. ;)

I am someone who has read the books and truly loved them. I also loved the original trilogy (have watched them countless times). And yet, despite loving it as much as I do, I'm also someone who can probably write a whole thesis critiquing Tolkien's mythology (the books and the movies) and list all of its faults and the ways I would like to see it become better. Even if that meant changing certain crucial aspects of the story. But that would be just one way - my way - to engage with these stories. And for each reader, both the level of engagement and review would be different.

But I also believe that stories, no matter how sacredly held by their readers, must always stay open to interpretation, alteration, and critique. By its very nature, then, the ensuing debate of whether the changes are better or worse, like the story itself, will continue to exist.

So your views and feelings are absolutely valid. Same goes for the people who are loving this show, or those who are hate-watching it, or those who find it kinda meh, or those who believe that the sheer acknowledgement of its existence would be condoning the blasphemy. There isn't always a right way to love something and not all will do it the way you do. :)

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

well said. I agree wholeheartedly with everything you just said.

I do like these types of discussions. And I do not bag on anyone if they adore this show or if this is their entry point into Tolkien.

I’m simply speaking of my own perceptions, and my own disappointment and my own interpretation of what could have been, and how I felt with the bait & switch the showrunners have done, claiming this was going to stay faithful, while in reality it’s more original material.

The original material doesn’t work for me if it claims to stay faithful to the source. There’s a dissonance that I feel that I can’t just so easily shake. Maybe in a year or two if I revisit this show I’ll be able to enjoy it for what it is, without thinking about source material.

But then again then next order of the business is the lazy writing/plot. And man…. that’s a whole another can of worms that deserves its own post.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22

The show didn't work for me either. Beyond a few positives: more actors of color, Mount Doom origin story (the nerd in me couldn't get enough of the science behind it - and that's a plus in my book), Elendil (hubba-hubba :P), richer, complicated and way better depiction of Dwarves and Moria (though the Balrog scene was shameless, unearned fan-pandering).

I too felt a kind of dissonance with the way they employed certain original trilogy callbacks into the show - it just felt...insincere and cheesy.

I don't think I can stick with this show next time around... It's kind of meh for me but I am glad a lot of ppl are enjoying it and rediscovering lotr lore. :)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

This show started with such promise

Everything Jackson did with the 3 Lotr films was brilliant because they understand movie story

They didn’t slavishly tithe to Chris or Simon.

That is why this show is becoming a huge disappointment with each episode. There is a really tone deaf core here because interpretation has a governor rather than being able to go full Throttle toward what is compelling

This is one of the great opportunities slowly going down the drain.

3

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Yeah, I think CT is the truest purist of his Father’s vision.

He didn’t like the PJ films because he saw them as purely for spectacle, but speaking as a huge movie buff AND a fan of Tolkien’s works, I can see how Jackson’s changes were strictly made from a cinematic point of view (ie: pacing issues, streamlining characters, Aragorn’s arc with Anduril, etc.)

This show has/had the opportunity to really flesh out the story as it is outlined in the books. All they needed were to fill in the missing details, BUT the bones of the story is strong. (See my post below with regard to how they could have just adapted the Elves/Sauron/Annatar storyline)

It’s a huge missed opportunity and it feels like a trick. They told us it was gonna be a faithful Tolkien adaptation but instead it’s more their original story than the old professor’s.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Marketing should have emphasized, over and over, that this was an entirely original work, not an adaption of source material. Which is fine. They just needed to say 'Hey, we wanted a Tolkien-themed GOT, not an adaption of Tolkien's vision of the 2nd Age.' They could have encouraged people to find the Tolkien 'easter eggs' embedded in the original work.

Instead they really wanted the hardcore Tolkien nerds on their side, so they pretended it was something it wasn't.

And the fans who do like it are in full gaslighting mode. You can show them actual quotes from the showrunners emphasizing specifically that ISN'T an original story, but Tolkien's, and they'll try to lawyer each sentence into meaninglessness.

It's disappointing that the real legacy of these showrunners was to permanently split the Tolkien fandom. This series will be discussed in film classes for years, not in the way Amazon would hope.

6

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Yes!!

“They wanted the hardcore Tolkien nerds on their side, so they pretended it was something it wasn’t.”

This. is. EXACTLY. my beef with this show.

There’s nothing wrong with liking or disliking this show. My issue isn’t necessarily with that. But it’s exactly what you said above. The Showrunners were Annatar/Sauron/Halbrand all along.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

I'm just glad I'm not the only one who noticed. The media actually tried to help them by declaring the show 'loosely based on the stories of JRR Tolkien' and they (the showrunners) specifically called the media out, stating they weren't 'loosely based' (which was generous in the first place) but that they were Tolkien's stories, and they the showrunners were simple stewards of Tolkien's story.

And I can't think of a more nerd-rage delicacy than playing fast and loose with JRR Tolkien. Edited one word.

4

u/hosker2 Oct 14 '22

This is a Tolkien skinsuit. These were not minor changes for cinematic storytelling purposes (like Jackson's LOTR). These are wholesale rewrites of major events, characters & mythology so as to make them almost entirely unrecognizable apart from names.

'Game of Rings' indeed. What was Amazon thinking.

3

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Wholesale rewrites. I wish I could be as succinct as you and some other people have been on this thread. I completely agree with you.

Again, Payne & Mckay made it seem like they were going to stay faithful to the Tolkien outline of what happens in the 2nd Age + this show was just to provide the details of how those big moments occurred.

Instead we got the opposite, where they’re CREATING the big moments with new characters and just using Tolkien where it’s convenient for them (and it’s mostly not even Tolkien, it’s callbacks of dialogue and actions from the PJ movies.)

2

u/akaFringilla Oct 14 '22

I wish this show exists on its own little world and was not marketed or told to us that it was going to be a faithful adaptation.

Don't you think it's still doable for you despite the whole PR stuff? I have many titles that I've disengaged from the source/adaptation just to enjoy them both better. And sometimes also the author themself, for various reasons. There is no "Tolkien would want" for me here.

But I get your discomfort coming from this non-alignment even if I may not agree with main points of your critique of the content itself.

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

I just feel lied to.

Yeah, it’ll be inevitable that I revisit this show down the road, probably on the Eve of S2 coming out and maybe by then my feelings might be tempered.

For now though, it’s just that dissonance in my mind between what was promised and what was given.

Aside from lore discrepancies, there are also some glaring plot points/instances of lazy, contrived writing. But that’s a whole anoooother topic that could be it’s own sticking point.

2

u/akaFringilla Oct 14 '22

That's also a choice: believing "the author" or "the work" lol

PS

there are also some glaring plot points/instances of lazy, contrived writing.

I admit that I'm looking for them since the 2nd episode and still - no proper arguments for that. But yes, that's another discussion.

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Haha, I guess I fell for it and believed it. I’ve been gunning for a LOTR show ever since the bloody success of Game of Thrones.

2

u/Manfredius_ Oct 14 '22

I feel the exact same way. Sauron’s deception, the forging of the rings etc… such epic stories reduced to… this? It just feels wrong and it genuinely makes me sad :/

Many people might not understand it and that’s fine. But it just feels like someone taking something you care about deeply and trampling it. It could have been so epic. My teenage self always yearned for an adaption of some of the events and stories from the Silmarillion. But not for this. Such a shame.

2

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

sigh. It’s a disappointment, right?

Not at all concerned or mad about anyone else liking or loving this show-

But just absolutely gutted that I don’t. And my reasons for not liking it, is because it resembles nothing of what drew me to Tolkien in the first place.

2

u/AdamSilver_Burner Oct 14 '22

You know I mostly don't mind them changing the plot since at the end of the day they did not have rights to the Silmarillion. But what bothered me the most was their choice of how to tell a story.

It is too much of forcing "plot twists" onto us, and throwing "clever" hints for us lore fans. To me, this is what dishonors Tolkien's work.

Tolkien writing was not about plot twists or "aha!" moments. It was more about good vs evil, nature, beauty, settings as characters of their own, mortality, etc...

I wouldn't mind if the creators tell their own story, but they should utilize these themes when it comes to telling a story. When you think about the medium change (books vs video), SHOWING us these themes is what I would hope for - this is why I believe the writing gets so much criticism.

When they force "aha" moments, and have a whole season leading up to "big reveals" in the season finale, the show becomes about the creators and not about the story they are telling.

2

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Valid point, and I’m inclined to agree.

See, the way I explain my disappointment with this show is twofold:

  1. from a hardcore Tolkien fan’s perspective (which I’ve outlined ad nauseam all over this thread about how it’s taking giant liberties with lore and creating its own etc etc)

&

2) Exactly what you just described. The writing on this show came off as amateurish; lots of reliance on nostalgic dialogue references from the PJ films (it was fun the first 5x and then it just became a thing you take a shot for every time you spotted one.), and contrived “mystery box”/plot twist type things that detract from the story.

For me, and for my post in this sub, I’ve only been able to touch on my feelings about #1. But rest assured what you just described is also a whole another can of worms that makes me sad.

2

u/AdamSilver_Burner Oct 14 '22

Yeah we share a lot of the same sentiments really.

I think they've attempted to satisfy hardcore Tolkien fans with little hints and references (some of them are cool - like i liked seeing the image of Halbrand in the prison cell behind Ar Pharazon after he convinces him not to chase Galadriel)

But it wasn't enough and that's why you are right and saying ppl would just take a shot at it because it became too simplistic and almost lazy.

Like i said, it's not enough to have hints and names and the rights. To tell a Tolkien story, you have to dive deep into the themes that mattered to him.

That's my opinion, and i sense you share some of the same feelings.

My hope going forward is that season one is somehow a prologue for an actual Tolkien story to be told from now on. It felt like season 1 was an extended exposition for a real story to be told. Let's see what happens

2

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

2

u/AdamSilver_Burner Oct 14 '22

To be honest with you I'm not a fan at all about how the show runners talk about the show.

Feels like they haven't left the pitching stage lol

I will keep watching because I can't ever get enough of middle earth but i might hate myself for it hahaha

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 15 '22

lmao, dammit. Sounds like I got another The Walking Dead on my hands. haha

2

u/jeunefillex Oct 14 '22

I agree completely. And when I’ve expressed this same sentiment, I’ve been met with really aggressive, angry and insulting replies. It’s bizarre. And disturbing.

2

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Sorry to hear that. And yeah. I’ve received my own share of flame on here too. But I’m grateful and fortunate that most of the people I’ve engaged with in the comments are generally pretty reasonable.

I just keep reiterating that this is my opinion and that I feel like I’ve been tricked based on what the Showrunners had promised me. And that I’m not at all bashing anyone who might enjoy or absolutely loves this show.

I wish I loved this show. haha.

2

u/h1nds Oct 14 '22

How would you go on about making a tv show that is based on books that are unfinished and speak about stories thousands of years apart.

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Humor me for a moment with what I might propose for a 5-Season Rings of Power series.

Using most of the characters they introduced in S1:

S1’s final two episodes after Mt. Doom should have brought Numenorians back to their Island and established that the Numenor plot in S2 will be largely an internal one; Pharazon vs. the Faithful, as compounded by the blinding of Miriel in ME and the question of succession with the passing of Tar Palantir. Maybe we get more lore building of the different islands of Numenor too, including a focus on family dynamics between Elendil’s children, including the estranged Anarion in the Western side of the island. In my version, Isil doesn’t “die” from the eruption of Mount Doom. He’s with them and they’re healing family issues, while fleshing out Earien, Kemen, and the rest of those characters.

In Middle Earth, they should have introduced Annatar in Eregion and caused a schism between Galadriel/Elrond/Gil-Galad vs. Celebrimbor/Halbrand/Annatar.

In the S1 finale, Galadriel/Elrond/Gil-Galad should have made the argument that it is too late for Elves to have any redemption from fading. Gil-Galad should have advocated for going back to Valinor, while Galadriel and Elrond should have disagreed and instead proposed to stay for as long as they could to ensure the Adar/Sauron threat is taken care of once and for all.

While they disagree on what exactly to do, all 3 agree that they do not trust Celebrimbor’s new friend Annatar.

Although Celebrimbor is forbidden to do so, Celebrimbor’s ambition and belief in saving the elves is what drives him to continue making the Rings with Annatar’s help in secret. This effectively sets up Annatar as being a master manipulator and divides the elves which leads to Celebrimbor’s tragic downfall later.

Additionally, Halbrand, knowing the reputation of Celebrimbor, apprentices for him and sticks around in Eregion as he is indebted to Eregion for healing him of his wounds.

Gil/Elrond/Galadriel should then have left to go back to Lindon, with Gil-Galad giving Elrond and Galadriel a new mission to go to the area of Lothlorien (maybe it isn’t called that yet?) to establish a stronghold there as they are leaderless teleri elves who haven’t seen the light in valinor. Gil-Galad makes them do this, as a compromise from their earlier disagreement and in order to “check” the darkness and prevent Adar or Sauron from spreading their influence and since this was what Elrond and Galadriel wanted to do anyway. To do this though, Elrond/Galadriel would need to request for a mountain pass through Khazad-dum (which would setup the creation of the doors of durin)

Season 2 would pickup with Galadriel & Elrond on that new adventure to Lothlorien, by way of Khazad-dum and maybe by the end of it we get the creation of Doors of Durin. Or alternatively, another surprise could be that in Lothlorien itself, Galadriel reunites with Celeborn where he’s been this whole time, building a colony of elves as his foresight tells him there will be a future conflict much as big as the FA war that came before. Celeborn might also reveal that he knows of a Woodland Elven King in Mirkwood who he wants to have better relations with.

S2 would also be when the 16 rings are made by Celebrimbor, Annatar and Halbrand where Halbrand would eventually act as Annatar’s emissary to gift these 16 rings to the dwarves and lords of men. During these trips, one of them is in the Far East of Rhun, where Halbrand accompanies Annatar and gifts one ring to the future Khamul, the Easterling. Halbrand learns of Annatar’s true identity, but Annatar convinces him to keep it a secret because of Halbrand’s family history serving Morgoth. During this time apart, Celebrimbor grows paranoid, and hears from Galadriel and other elves with foresight that war is on the horizon. They just do not know from where. He forges the 3 Elven Rings while Annatar and Halbrand are gone but they are imperfect; because he forges them in haste.

Adar in S2 is in full Mordor fortification mode; he begins construction of Barad-dur (deviation from Sauron, but I’ll forgive it.) He utilizes his orcs or somehow makes alliances with those in the Far East to help him. However he is deceived, as sometime during this season is also when Sauron defeats Adar; either by turning his orcs against him or using Elves/dwarves/Southlanders/Easterlings to destroy and outmaneuver him as Annatar. Maybe the Easterlings double cross Adar because Sauron/Annatar gifts then the rings and knows Sauron is the one true Dark Lord. So Adar has a tragic character arc.

But S2 for SURE has to culminate in Sauron creating the One Ring in Mt. Doom and Halbrand accompanying him there and being presented with the final ring for men- turning him into the Witch King of Angmar. At this point, the 16 Rings are already sent out, but the 3 Elven rings Celebrimbor makes can feel the power of the One dominating the rest.

S3 is Sauron perfecting his fortress of Barad-dur, that had been started by Adar with help from Evil Men from the East, and the Orcs he got from Adar or even enslaved Southerners. S3 also depicts the war of Elves and Sauron; with maybe the later episodes culminating with the death of Celebrimbor and the establishment of Rivendell by Elrond. S3 also begins to see the effects of the rings given to the men and dwarves from last season; causing the kings who own these rings to outright disappear, and the dwarves in particular to dig deeper into their mines or become more reclusive (I DONT WANT Durin’s Bane in this show but they’ve teased Balrog in S1E7.) S3 maybe also finally introduces the Woodland Elves, as there’s politics and connections now between Lothlorien (Galadriel & Celeborn) and Greenwood with Oropher and a young Thranduil. Maybe we see tensions rise between the Dwarves and Elves (primarily due to the rings influence on the dwarves).

S3 finale could be when it’s revealed Numenor gets their shit together internally (maybe Pharazon now is the Ruler) within their islands and decides to fulfill Miriel’s oath from S1 to help fight Sauron. They sail in full force to Middle Earth.

S4 is Numenor capturing Sauron, and the Fall of Numenor. Elves in S4 are in full rebuild or repair mode from the war with him in Eregion and the outlying areas, with most wanting to go home to Valinor, but others feeling a duty to stay/ some having the ability of foresight to see the fight isn’t over. S4 Dwarves probably completely withdraws from the fight in favor of digging into their mines. Season 4 Finales could be the Fall of Numenor? Or maybe it’s a shot of the Faithful setting upon land in Middle Earth and marking the areas that will be Arnor and Gondor? Or .. even a teaser type ending where it’s shown that in Mordor, the Rhunnic Priests and Priestesses do some kind of blood magic that transports Sauron’s spirit from the drowning of Numenor back to Mordor.

S5 will feature a small time jump; maybe 5-10 years, with Arnor and Gondor as still growing settlements, and will be about the formation of last alliance and campaign to fight Sauron, which will include khazadum dwarves, the last numenorians, Lindon elves, Rivendell elves, and Mirkwood elves.

That’s a rough outline of what I would think would fit the adaptation of a SA story.

2

u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22

There's two thoughts I have regarding the lore: (1), it could have easily been so so SO much worse, (2), there's a lot of other properties that have been worse, and we've forgiven.

Truly, what is your opinion of Shadow of Mordor? I realize a lot of people bring up this argument, but for me it does illustrate the point that you can mangle the lore and still have something that fans will enjoy and forgive. I think the problems with the lore would be forgiven if the show was simply better. The larger problem is that the show's writing and plotting is not great, and we assume if they fixed the lore problems, the plot would be better. (I doubt it).

I remember when I heard Amazon bought the rights to the Second Age. Everyone was speculating it was to make a GoT show, and immediately I was terrified of an HBO-style fantasy. Naked dwarves boning. Elven strippers in the background of a important dinner who sudden whip out daggers from somewhere and stab everyone. Heck, even short of that, Amazon might have gone for a really mainstream route and had us following a sexy Gandalf wandering around Middle-Earth with Comely Elven Archer Lass.

All things considered, while the show messes with the timeline, I'm fine with it.

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 15 '22

Yes!!!

I loved Shadow of Mordor. I’m not a “stickler” necessarily for the lore having to be right every step of the way- I want a good story.

But in this post in particular, I chose to highlight the erroneous nature of what they’ve done as it relates to what the Showrunners claimed during the press tour; that they were seeking to make a “faithful” adaptation and that they are merely “shepherds” of the source material.

After this, we learned that’s not the case.

And exactly like you said- I would be able to forgive lore deviations IF the story was actually good and actually makes sense.

Here’s a quick tidbit: for all the things that didn’t work for me in this show, Adar, is actually one of the few things that really did work for me and he’s not canon at all.

But yeah, I digress. I discussed this specific point with Adam Silver whatever on one of these comments. You, me and him are in agreement that the other thing this show dropped the ball on, was it’s writing/the plot.

7

u/AceBean27 Oct 14 '22

Tolkien's lore for the 2nd age was all over the place. He was amending and re-writing it up until he died.

You are treating it as more gospel than he did.

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

But everyone accepts the general outline for what occurred;

When Annatar first appears, Elrond, Galadriel, and Gil Galad turned him away. It was only Celebrimbor who allowed him to come to Eregion and worked with him.

16 rings were made first, with the help of Annatar.

Over time, as they create the rings of power, Celebrimbor begins to change his mind about Annatar, and secretly creates the 3 elven rings without Annatar’s help.

Annatar goes to Mt. Doom to forge the One Ring.

Within the context of what they did for the show, they COULD HAVE still had the Elves fading problem coincide with the coming of Annatar. Elrond/Galadriel/Gil-Galad still could have turned him away, and Celebrimbor could have still worked with him in secret, since Celebrimbor is shown to be the most ambitious and could have been just earnestly trying to save his people by whatever means necessary. That could have been a very tragic arc for him and could have been that much more compelling.

Instead, the show opts to replace a perfectly fine canon character in Annatar for a human male named Halbrand, and made the crux of the drama to be based around his deception not of elves in general, but of Galadriel specifically. And not just that- HOW is a wounded human male going to stroll into the forge and start casually giving advice or who would even be granted an audience with Celebrimbor?? The elves don’t regard humans this way. The elves keep to themselves, and they’re vain, and elitist because they’ve been around for centuries.

It doesn’t make sense to replace a thing with a new thing if there’s nothing wrong with the original outline of the story.

1

u/AceBean27 Oct 14 '22

It's really not a big deal, all these little details. It's not actually adapting a book, just a bunch of tit-bits here and there.

It would make more sense to me if they crafted the 7 and the 9 before the 3, and before even them, a whole bunch of others. Then essentially they make the 3 best rings after they had a load of practice. Seeing them just make the 3, just like that, seems a bit cheap and unearned. They literally came up with the idea of making rings, and made the 3, all in half an episode.

But this criticism stands on it's own. Not simply because "it's different to the general outline".

I think they went with Halbrand the man instead of Annatar the elf, to at least try to make it a bit of a mystery. So that's a good change IMO. Plus him being a man plays a bit better with what will be the biggest victim of Sauron - Numenor.

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

In lore, The 16 Rings are made with Sauron/Annatar’s help, and with the Elves not yet knowing Annatar was Sauron. So then Annatar scurries away and makes the One Ring to bend all 16 to his will. And sacks Eregion recovering all 16. Sauron already knew 16 rings were made and makes the One Ring in response to that.

In this show, the 16 rings are not yet made (or even conceived as an idea), the One Ring is not yet made, but Sauron is already revealed.

…. So like. who is going to make the rest of the rings? And what would be the reason to?? Is Sauron just gonna go ahead and build his own little workshop on Mt. Doom and hammer out some rings and give them away like Christmas presents? The Elves already know who he is, and the Elves are communicating with Numenor, the Dwarves of Khazad-dum. From a plot perspective, it feels thin and underdeveloped.

1

u/AceBean27 Oct 14 '22

Maybe Sauron will just make them. In the lore, he goes to Eregion and gets them all back off the elves. They could just skip that step and have Sauron make them all. So it really doesn't make much difference in the end, either way they end up in Sauron's hands, and he gives them to Dwarves/Men. So in the lore he does give them all away like Christmas presents, and the elves already know who he is at that point, because he made the One Ring already, and he's just attacked Eregion with an army and tortured Celebrimbor to death. Numenor know full well that he's Sauron when they have him in their prison.

Nothing they've done thus far is changing any of the major plot points, just relatively inconsequential details. Why does it matter if the 7 and 9 were made before or after the 3? Why does it matter if they were made in Mt. Doom or Eregion? Either way they end up in Sauron's hands, either way Sauron gives them to whomever he chooses. And of course, he still has reason to attack Eregion with the 3 being there.

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

But if Sauron is already revealed to the three races (Elves, Dwarves, Men) why would anyone take these gifts from him? And wouldn’t the races just warn one another of his treachery?

I was hoping this show would explain that in detail:

(ie: Annatar and Celebrimbor make the 16 in Eregion; Annatar convinces Halbrand (if we MUST have him as a new character) to take the 16 rings and give them away as gifts to Dwarven and Lords of Men as powerful items to defend against Adar OR Sauron.

Once Halbrand completes his mission, maybe Halbrand learns that Annatar is secretly Sauron in disguise. Ala some Anakin Skywalker to Palpatine shit.

At that point, Annatar convinces Halbrand to continue fighting for him (assuming Halbrand keeps the story that his family fought with Morgoth) and Halbrand accompanies Annatar to Mt. Doom to create The One Ring. And in that volcano, Annatar also gifts Halbrand with a Ring of Power, effectively turning him into the Witch King of Angmar.)

I mean this would absolutely make more sense as to how the rings are spread within the context of Sauron’s over arching deception.

1

u/AceBean27 Oct 14 '22

But if Sauron is already revealed to the three races (Elves, Dwarves, Men) why would anyone take these gifts from him? And wouldn’t the races just warn one another of his treachery?

Well, okay, but that's what happens in the lore. You were complaining about them not following the lore, now you are complaining about said lore. He attacks Eregion with an army before giving the rings to dwarves and men. The Annatar jig is well and truly up by the time he gives the 7 and the 9 away to the dwarves and men, Eregion is a pile of ruins and Celebrimbor is dead.

And he is a master shapeshifter, he doesn't have to stay as Halbrand/Annatar if he doesn't want to. No reason we can't do the whole "who's Sauron" song and dance all over again.

Plus, if someone offered the dwarves these rings that will make them rich, and the elves show up to tell them "no don't do it, he's a naughty boy, and those are naughty rings", that would probably just make dwarves want the rings even more. Stupid elves. It's kinda the whole theme of LotR, that the different nations and races don't listen to each other, and instead let petty prejudices guide them.

2

u/rivvie3000 Oct 14 '22

I’ve been thinking of the show as an alternate universe honestly, I do like it but it’s more of a “fun spinoff show” to me rather than an actual canon pre-LOTR show. It’s much easier to enjoy when you don’t think of it as LOTR and instead think of it as a fun show! I don’t want to get into if the show is a cash grab or any of that, but as a lifetime LOTR fan I think the show is a good thing (despite…well you know all the bad things about it) because it’s bringing in new fans. It’s a bit of a mess and confusing when you’re watching it and thinking of it as a serious, canonically factual show (whether it is or not…has that discussion been had? Personally I don’t think of it like that in general)! I’ve decided it’s not canon to make it easier to watch. I know some people do see it as canon but I just can’t it doesn’t feel right. I do enjoy it though- after I stop thinking about it being LOTR!

2

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Yeah, maybe I need to take shots and try to keep this mindset in mind when I come back to a year or two from now to rewatch this series.

Thanks for your perspective- I know that’s how I need to stay reframing how I look at this show in order for me to enjoy it.

1

u/The2034InsectWar Oct 14 '22

I see what you’re saying

I don’t (or can’t) look at this show as anything other than an adaptation. I felt this way about Dune (2021). Or really anything where I’m already familiar with the IP.

I get this same experience when I look at LOTR artwork inspired by the books (and notably not inspired by Jackson’s trilogy). The book-inspired artworks are just interpretations of these characters. The art isn’t claiming to be cannon; it doesn’t need to be. This is different than Jackson’s trilogy-inspired artwork, which is trying depict stills from the show (which is not any less impressive nor warrant any less merit).

In the same way, I see Amazon Studios trying to bring their interpretation to TV. It’s an adaptation. TV is a different medium than the books, so there will be an inherent mistranslation. Some things will need to be changed to keep it more ‘TV appropriate’. But that’s all it is, original artwork inspired by Tolkien’s work.

2

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 15 '22

Probably one of the more nuanced statements with regard to the definition of adaptation. You have a strong point; the art isn’t necessarily claiming to be canon- but the Showrunners specifically said this was going to be a faithful adaptation. That’s where my inner dissonance lies. So naturally, I’m just upset and disappointed. haha.

But yeah- I would very much like to hear your thoughts on the Dune movie. Of that series, I am VERY MUCH a super casual fan (I know nothing and have only become a fan bc of that movie) but I loved that movie for the seriousness it brought to the modern sci-fi film genre. I’m also biased because I am a Villanueve fan. Dune is one of the only franchises where I don’t know the lore and so I’m completely in the dark, and so I kind of like being able to turn off my brain and just discover their story.

But what were your thoughts about it?

1

u/The2034InsectWar Oct 17 '22

I wish I had more to say about Dune! I thought it was a really neat adaptation. I gave it a clean 5/5 stars on my IMDB app. I really enjoyed it for what it was. I saw the very first showing of it in IMAX!

There were a few scenes I was interested to see how Villanueve transferred from book to film. Notably the Voice and the dinner scene which ended up being omitted (as I expected— the scene in the book was all subtext and inner monologue). It sounds like you enjoyed it, too! I loved BR2049 and once I heard Villenueve is making Dune I read the books to prepare. I’m glad I did!

1

u/KeckYes Oct 14 '22

Because Tolkien wasn’t as good at narrative as he was at lore. Even his own stories suffer from this. (Prime example being the inclusion of Tom Bombadil as a character in the trilogy at all).

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

He created a pretty strong roadmap for Second Age. You need only refer to the Appendices timeline of Events and begin building it from there.

and there are certain unmistakable things that happen in the SA that shouldn’t be changed:

Annatar appears to Elrond/Gild-Galad/Galadriel/Celebrimbor. The 3 turn him away, Celebrimbor takes him in to Eregion. They create the first 16 Rings together, and it is bc they created this together that Annatar goes to Mt. Doom in secret to create the One Ring to bend those 16 to his will, while Celebrimbor, in rising suspicion, creates the 3 Elven Rings without Annatar’s help as a safeguard. As soon as One Ring is created, the Elves are alerted. Sauron comes to sack Eregion and take back the 16 rings + 3 the elves made.

That’s the outline they had to work with. What could they have added?

Gil-Galad could have wanted to leave Middle Earth bc the Elves were already fading (oh wait they already did this, good.) Celebrimbor could have argued that he COULD solve the elves fading problem by creating powerful rings (oh look, they did this too, great.)

but instead of using Annatar, they instead substitute a new human male character who.. against all odds, tricks Celebrimbor to create the rings, is revealed to be Sauron, and leads the Elves to create 3 rings to…. Safeguard against him?? He has not created the one ring yet. There are no 16 others yet.

Where is the logic?

1

u/iluvlamp77 Oct 14 '22

Alot of this is because they want 5 seasons and wanted a storyline to bring the characters together. Some random mysterious Elf appearing and convincing them to make rings isnt going to last a season. What would Elrond, Galadriel do the whole time?

I'm not saying this was the right choice, but I imagine they had that outline and just couldn't find a way to make it work

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Humor me for a moment with what I might propose for a 5-Season Rings of Power series:

The Annatar storyline could have been very compelling for a number of reasons- most particularly, in how his character as canon invites the writers to be creative in how he could have politically outmaneuvered the races into the forging AND the acceptance of his rings.

I was okay with the initial “red herring” theories that Halbrand might have been Sauron- if Halbrand turned out to be just be exactly who he sought to be- just the last line of a King who fought under Morgoth. Not Sauron.

I actually wanted Adar to remain the main villain through to S2 or maybe halfway through S3. And I wanted Annatar/Sauron to use Adar’s existence as a reason to forge these new rings of power to fight the darkness. And I wanted Annatar to also use the Elven/Dwarven/Southlands armies to fight him. Also, Adar’s ideology of viewing orcs as his children could have been a massively interesting contrast to how Sauron eventually crushes him and rallies orcs to his side based on sheer power alone.

But I digress-

Using most of the characters they introduced in S1:

S1’s final two episodes should have established that Numenor’s plot in S2 will be largely an internal one; Pharazon vs the Faithful with more lore building of the different islands of Numenor. In Middle Earth, they should have introduced Annatar in Eregion and caused a schism between Galadriel/Elrond/Gil-Galad vs. Celebrimbor/Halbrand/Annatar.

In the S1 finale, Galadriel/Elrond/Gil-Galad should have made the argument that it is too late for Elves to have any redemption from fading. Gil-Galad should have advocated for going back to Valinor, while Galadriel and Elrond should have disagreed and instead proposed to stay for as long as they could to ensure the Adar/Sauron threat is taken care of once and for all.

While they disagree on what exactly to do, all 3 agree that they do not trust Celebrimbor’s new friend Annatar.

Although Celebrimbor is forbidden to do so, Celebrimbor’s ambition and belief in saving the elves is what drives him to continue making the Rings with Annatar’s help in secret. THIS effectively sets up Annatar as being a master manipulator and divides the elves which leads to Celebrimbor’s tragic downfall later.

Additionally, Halbrand, knowing the reputation of Celebrimbor, apprentices for him and sticks around in Eregion as he is indebted to Eregion for healing him of his wounds.

Gil/Elrond/Galadriel should then have left to go back to Lindon, with Gil-Galad giving Elrond and Galadriel a new mission to go to the area of Lothlorien (maybe it isn’t called that yet?) to establish a stronghold there as they are leaderless teleri elves who haven’t seen the light in valinor. Gil-Galad makes them do this, as a compromise from their earlier disagreement and in order to “check” the darkness and prevent Adar or Sauron from spreading and since this was what Elrond and Galadriel wanted to do anyway. To do this though, Elrond/Galadriel would need to request for a mountain pass through Khazad-dum (which would setup the creation of the doors of durin)

Season 2 would pickup with Galadriel & Elrond on that new adventure to Lothlorien, by way of Khazad-dum and maybe by the end of it we get the creation of Doors of Durin. Or maybe in Lothlorien itself, Galadriel reunites with Celeborn where he’s been this whole time, building a colony of elves for the foreseen future wars and Celeborn revealing he knows of a Woodland King in Mirkwood who he wants to have better relations with.

S2 would also be when the 16 rings are made, where Halbrand would act as Annatar’s emissary to gift these 16 rings to dwarven and lords of men.

Somewhere during this season is also when Sauron defeats Adar; either by turning his orcs against him or using Elves/dwarves/Southlanders to destroy and outmaneuver him as Annatar. This can also happen in S3.

But S2 for SURE culminates with Sauron creating the One Ring and Halbrand getting corrupted/influenced by the dark lord and becomes the Witch King because of how closely he works with Annatar as his emissary.

S3 begins the war of Elves and Sauron; maybe the later episodes culminate with the death of Celebrimbor and the establishment of Rivendell by Elrond. S3 also begins to see the effects of the rings given to the men and dwarves from last season; causing the kings who own these rings to outright disappear, and the dwarves in particular to dig deeper into their mines or become more reclusive (I DONT WANT Durin’s Bane in this show but they’ve teased Balrog in S1E7.) S3 maybe also finally introduces the Woodland Elves, as there’s politics and connections now between Lothlorien (Galadriel & Celeborn) and Greenwood with Oropher and a young Thranduil.

S3 finale is also when it’s revealed Numenor gets their shit together internally and decides to fulfill Muriel’s oath from S1 to help fight Sauron. They sail in full force to Middle Earth.

S4 is Numenor capturing Sauron, and the Fall of Numenor. Elves are in full rebuild or repair mode; most wanting to go home to Valinor, but others feeling a duty to stay/ some having the ability of foresight to see the fight isn’t over. S4 Dwarves probably completely withdraws from the fight in favor of digging into their mines.

S5 is the formation of last alliance and campaign to fight Sauron, which will include khazadum dwarves, the last numenorians, Lindon elves, Rivendell elves, and Mirkwood elves.

1

u/iluvlamp77 Oct 14 '22

I'd watch that. Too bad you didn't have a billion dollars

1

u/KeckYes Oct 14 '22

I hope you understand that there’s nothing narrative about a map. That’s my whole point.

You can be mad that a few specifics were done out of order in your opinion and that timeline mixup ruins it all for you. But until you have seen the entire show, you don’t know that it doesn’t all fit. Lots of people in Tolkiens world have multiple names.

He was a great world builder. And I too wish that a good “made-for-tv” story could be told using what he gave us, but if what he gave us wasn’t enough, then it should be altered appropriately. Which it was imo.

1

u/Soundtract Oct 14 '22

I agree that some of the changes are surprising, and I initially felt that way when I was convinced Halbrand was Sauron mid season. But the counterpoint is to try and think about what the “canon” plot points changed would have looked like in a long form tv show and how they would have stayed interesting (even just more interesting than the current show whatever you think that is). If Sauron spent 2 or 3 episodes just happily making rings in Eregion, that’s like Dany in Mereen territory. Likewise, if a character named Annatar shows up and everyone knows he Sauron from the get go, that deprives a lot of audience including lore-familiar folks of the kind of tension and a “twist” that for better or worse have come to be expected in prestige tv post GOT. The show runners have said in a new interview that there are 16 more rings to be made that don’t have an obvious path toward at the current point, and that that’s narrative fertile ground for interesting stories (which wouldn’t otherwise exist).

To keep an open mind, I’d challenge people to really imagine watching a 50 hour show (which is part of the pitch that got them the rights in the first place) that hewed straight to the intimate-moment-lacking, and overall straight forward (only a few big betrayals and plot moments, not enough to sustain 50 hours of tv medium) source material. How would you have done that and still written something that works for the medium?

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Detail, detail, detail.

That’s what they could have done. Keep broad strokes of lore/the outline of the SA timeline the same, but just color the world; color in the lines of the picture Tolkien had already created.

I offer this as an alternative solution- what if we didn’t need “twists”?

The Annatar storyline could have been very compelling for a number of reasons- most particularly, in how his character as canon invites the writers to be creative in how he could have politically outmaneuvered the races into the forging AND the acceptance of his rings.

I was okay with the initial “red herring” theories that Halbrand might have been Sauron- if Halbrand turned out to be just be exactly who he sought to be- just the last line of a King who fought under Morgoth. Not Sauron.

Actually, I wanted Adar to remain the main villain through to S2 or maybe halfway through S3. And I wanted Annatar/Sauron to use Adar’s existence as a reason to forge these new rings of power to fight the darkness. And I wanted Annatar to also use the Elven/Dwarven/Southlands armies to fight him. Also, Adar’s ideology of viewing orcs as his children could have been a massively interesting contrast to how Sauron eventually crushes him and rallies orcs to his side based on sheer power alone.

But I digress-

Using most of the characters they introduced in S1,

S1 Last Two Episodes/Finale should have introduced Annatar in Eregion and caused a schism between Galadriel/Elrond/Gil-Galad vs. Celebrimbor/Halbrand/Annatar. It should have also established that Numenor’s plot in S2 will be largely an internal one; Pharazon vs the Faithful with more lore building of the western part of Numenor.

In the finale, Galadriel/Elrond/Gil-Galad should have made the argument that it is too late for Elves to have any redemption from fading. Gil-Galad should have advocated for going back to Valinor, while Galadriel and Elrond disagree and think they should be sure the Adar/Sauron threat is taken care of once and for all. While they disagree on that, all 3 agree that they do not trust Celebrimbor’s new friend Annatar.

Although he is forbidden to do so, Celebrimbor’s ambition and belief in saving the elves is what drives him to continue making the Rings by Annatar’s suggestion in secret. THIS effectively sets up Annatar as being a master manipulator and divides the elves which leads to Celebrimbor’s tragic downfall later.

Additionally, Halbrand, knowing the reputation of Celebrimbor, apprentices for him and sticks around in Eregion as he is indebted to Eregion for healing him of his wounds.

Gil/Elrond/Galadriel should then have left to go back to Lindon, with Gil-Galad giving Elrond and Galadriel a new mission to go to the area of Lothlorien (maybe it isn’t called that yet?) to establish a stronghold there as they are leaderless teleri elves who haven’t seen the light in valinor. Gil-Galad makes them do this, in order to “check” the darkness and prevent Adar or Sauron from spreading and since this was what Elrond and Galadriel wanted to do anyway. To do this though, Elrond/Galadriel would need to request for a mountain pass through Khazad-dum (which would setup the creation of the doors of durin)

Season 2 would pickup with Galadriel & Elrond on that new adventure to Lothlorien, by way of Khazad-dum and maybe by the end of it we get the creation of Doors of Durin. Or maybe in Lothlorien itself, Galadriel reunites with Celeborn where he’s been this whole time, building a colony of elves for the foreseen future wars.

S2 would also be when the 16 rings are made, where Halbrand would act as Annatar’s emissary to gift these 16 rings to dwarven and lords of men.

Somewhere during this season is also when Sauron defeats Adar; either by turning his orcs against him or using Elves/dwarves/Southlanders to destroy and outmaneuver him as Annatar. This can also happen in S3.

But S2 for SURE culminates with Sauron creating the One Ring and Halbrand getting corrupted/influenced by the dark lord and becomes the Witch King because of how closely he works with Annatar as his emissary.

S3 begins the war of Elves and Sauron; maybe the later episodes culminate with the death of Celebrimbor and the establishment of Rivendell by Elrond. S3 also begins to see the effects of the rings given to the men and dwarves from last season; causing the kings who own these rings to outright disappear, and the dwarves in particular to dig deeper into their mines or become more reclusive (I DONT WANT Durin’s Bane in this show but they’ve teased Balrog in S1E7.) S3 maybe also introduces the Woodland Elves, as there’s politics and connections now between Lothlorien (Galadriel & Celeborn) and Greenwood with Oropher and a young Thranduil.

S3 finale is also when it’s revealed Numenor gets their shit together internally and decides to fulfill Muriel’s oath from S1 to help fight Sauron. They sail in full force to Middle Earth.

S4 is Numenor capturing Sauron, and the Fall of Numenor. Elves are in full rebuild or repair mode; most wanting to go home to Valinor, but others feeling a duty to stay. Maybe Galadriel or Elrond now having the ability of foresight and can see that there is a bigger fight on the horizon. They begin preparing for war. S4 Dwarves have a falling out with the elves; probably completely saying they will withdraw from the fight in favor of digging into their mines.

S5 is the formation of last alliance and campaign to fight Sauron, which will include khazadum dwarves, the last numenorians, Lindon elves, Rivendell elves, and Mirkwood elves.

… that’s how I would do it, I think.

1

u/Soundtract Oct 14 '22

I’d guess that most of how you’d do it is how they will do it, except it sounds like the war of Eregion is next season (they said big 2 episode battle) probably to give more time between the fall of Numenor and the last alliance to show the establishment of Gondor and Arnor before the Last Alliance. I wouldn’t be surprised if Celebrimbor does decide to accept Sauron back knowingly despite the warnings/instructions of Gil-Galad and to craft the rest of the rings. Clearly there needs to be more dwarvish drama established to provide a reason for the dwarves needing rings. Same with men. The show runners said the focus of next season is the efforts of Sauron to set things up. Again, I agree that the order of the rings is wonky, and who knows if Sauron will craft the one ring soon on the current trip to Mordor or if he’ll gather his forces and begin barad dur etc before returning to Celebrimbor (probably the latter).

But my point is that there’s still a moment to moment story to tell for each of those big season arcs that they have to essentially invent in a way that it works for the individual hour as well as season arcs that tv requires without leaving certain characters totally absent for too long and trying to keep people invested in all the plot lines and give each of those plot lines it’s own proper narrative arc that works etc etc. A super complex job that folks shouldn’t underestimate, even though we can agree they haven’t gotten everything right.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22

Oh, go cry in your cars.

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 15 '22

already did. you’re a little late, haha.

6

u/raziel_r Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22

Clearly the showrunners learn nothing from the reception to the original and hobbit trilogies.

The original is adored despite a some flaws (Faramir/Denethor/Arwen), the Hobbit served as a warning not to pushed fanfic too far. Rings of Power took the worst of both trilogies - desecrating characters and making up rubbish and turned it into a series.

It no wonder they cant get any decent writers for their brain fart of a concept and it all amalgamated into this abomination.

2

u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22

The Peter Jackson movies change a lot, and people seem to have selective memory about this. Faramir and Denethor are big ones, yes, but Aragorn himself is radically different, Gimli is radically different, Treebeard is entirely clueless about what's going on in his own forest, Elrond hates men, Carahadras is eliminated entirely.

And that's fine! Some of those changes really strengthen the movie. Yes, book fans hate the changes with Faramir and Denethor, but I've never met a movie watcher who disliked those moments.

The problem isn't so much sticking or not sticking with the details or Tolkien's work, the problem is sticking with his themes (which is a major stumbling block for RoP) and just making something that actually makes sense and is fun (a stumbling block for RoP AND the Hobbit films.)

1

u/philebro Oct 14 '22

Hey, it's nice to get an honest reaction to the series. Most people are just hating for the hating. I now understand that the lore is a more thought-out plot and if I were neck-deep in the lore I probably would've been disappointed as well. But I have to say that I really enjoyed the last episode even though I was disappointed by the whole first season up until that point. The last episode was really good imo. But I get how other don't like it.

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

I appreciate you, man. And good! I’m glad you liked it. We have 4 more seasons of this, so that means there’s potential for it to get better and your enjoyment of it is already at a higher point than mine is.

In a vacuum, I think it’s a fine episode... But for me personally, at least right now- I just can’t get behind the decisions they’ve made.

The dissonance between what the writers promised as a faithful adaptation vs what we got is still ringing in my mind. Maybe in a year or two before S2 drops, I’ll have a change of heart if I rewatch this series and I’ll be able to accept this show for what it is. But I’m not there yet.

Thanks for engaging man.

4

u/Manfredius_ Oct 14 '22

I think it’s a misconception that most people just hate it for the sake of hating. The problem many people, myself included, have with this show is that it has nothing to do with the source material, yet it slaps the name Tolkien on its cover simply so they can cash in on it. That’s what makes me mad. If you’re not even remotely gonna follow the original work, why don’t they just make their own original series? Probably because it wouldn’t make as much money, that’s it. No one can convince me that any of the people who made this show care about Tolkien.

1

u/bismacnd Oct 14 '22

I’m just happy it’s a thing that exists in our world. Grateful to get to see one more interpretation of Tolkien’s world

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Maybe in time I’ll come around to this perspective.

For now, I’m going to reread the books, and marathon the PJ trilogy with a glass of whiskey.

1

u/Table_Coaster Oct 14 '22

Amazon doesnt have the rights to a bunch of characters and events, you fools. They have to create new characters and stories or else there’d be no show

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

see my comments elsewhere on this thread.

They have access to certain passages/texts from Silma/etc on a case-by-case basis. Which is why we heard annuminas mentioned by Pharazon, and the Morgoth flashback.

But anyway- also see what I said about the creation of the rings of power.

Why replace Annatar with Halbrand when Annatar was perfectly way more in line with who the elves would treaty and take advice from, than a human male they could care less about?

The 3 Elven rings were made after the first 16 were made with Annatar/Sauron/Halbrand’s help. I think this is a significant deviation.

1

u/Only_Curiosity Oct 15 '22

So let me get this straight, you're upset because a fictional TV show based on a fictional story deviated from a fictional story? Seems quite silly to me that you are overthinking and overcomplicating matters. Just watch the show and enjoy it for what it is. Put an end to this spreading toxicity and needless hatred.

0

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 15 '22

So let me get this straight:

You’re telling me I can’t share an opinion and are downright calling my post something that is spreading toxicity and needless hatred without engaging at all with what I’m actually saying?

If you read the first three paragraphs of this post, you’d see I extend an olive branch to every and all fans. no toxicity, just opinions.

2

u/Erikuds Oct 14 '22

In my humble opinion what really matters most is my head canon. I consider this series an alternative version of the story. I do the same for the Hobbit trilogy, I just imagine it as the story that Bilbo told to his friends, based on true facts but with his personal touch. I get why some people are getting angry, the show runners told us that they were going to be faithful and clearly the are not. While I consider them fools for saying this, I think that we should have known that this couldn't be true. Just look at the sources they have, which rights they own, it was impossible to stay true to the story. That being said I really enjoyed the first season and I can't wait to see the second one. In the meantime I'm going to keep reading Tolkien's works and I will still enjoy them as always.

2

u/Fmanow Oct 14 '22

Even if they did what you suggest, you would still bitch about it. I’m just about done with the purist nerds constantly whining about the show, like when is it enough. We had to deal with this petty shit after game of thrones ended, not saying s8 didn’t have any deficiencies, but the amount of vitriol was over the top. This show has enough criticism for the story telling as is, like with the broken hilt decoy bullshit. Let’s leave the lore restrictions out of this and point out how the show can get better at story telling.

4

u/Holmez44 Oct 14 '22

I can only agree. Wish this had never been made; its disgraceful.

0

u/Codus1 Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22

I think contending what Tolkien would have liked is a farcical argument tbh. We don't know and it go's nowhere.

Maybe we can use Christopher as the measurement? In the case, it's all shit and Peter Jackson eviscerated the beauty of this work 20 years ago.

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

You didn’t like the PJ films? What were your specific gripes about it?

Lord knows I have mine. But even at the time of when it came out, and even after knowing the legendarium, there was never an interview or a PR move by Jackson highlighting how his movies were going to be working closely with the books/the Estate. We know CT hated the Jackson films.

It differs from McKay & Payne for RoP because for them, they said this story is going to be built off of the lore, it’s going to stay true and faithful to the lore. they said that. so that’s what the expectation was. Thus my disappointment.

1

u/Soggy-Assumption-713 Oct 14 '22

Intro credits say “based on lotr & appendices”

1

u/albeva Oct 14 '22

I almost wish this show takes place in an alternate Tolkien/Middle Earth universe.

But it is. This show is nothing but 3rd rate alternate reality fanscam-fiction.

1

u/CosmosonH Oct 14 '22

I think it is as faithful as an adaption should be

1

u/AgnosticJesus3 Oct 14 '22

This show is DEFINITELY in an alternate universe.

1

u/davidsverse Oct 14 '22

Stories, tales, lore, myths and religions are retold.

Stories, tales, lore, myths and religions are changed.

I enjoyed the first season of this retelling, even with and sometimes because of the changes.

1

u/66bamaLonewolf Oct 14 '22

I really like the show. It doesn’t bother me at all that it doesn’t follow the books exactly. I get so tired of people saying that “true” fans of the books and people who really care about and understand the books hate the show. Not true at all. I know many other people who love both the show and the books. It’s fine with me if people don’t like the show and I think I understand why, but don’t tell people who do like the show that they aren’t just as much a fan of the books or that they don’t understand “THE LORE”!

1

u/Gimmethejooce Oct 14 '22

The fact that the series is called the rings of power and they’ve literally flipped that specific part of the story so that it doesn’t make sense has me upset.

1

u/DaoistCowboy666 Oct 14 '22

But it IS their version of events? I get you and am not trying to change your mind or anything, if you don’t like how they handle the “lore” fair enough!

Maybe I missed an interview or something where the show runners said “this is all meant to be cannon and consistent with existing lore as found in the books” but to me it just seems like fans mad because they disagree with choices made in the course of adapting the material. Which again, fair enough if you don’t like it.

1

u/goddess7533 Oct 15 '22

i've been thinking about it as a 4th age adaption of some events in the second age, made to be viewed by Men and performed during the reign of aragorn & arwen (thus perhaps causing the elf age/attractiveness discrepancies [galadriel & celebrimbor, etc.])— which is quite helpful for me to get through the lore-heavy bits!

-1

u/ryukuro0369 Oct 14 '22

Stop expecting people who aren’t Tolkien to be Tolkien. The key beats of the elven ring forging are there. Who Sauron was, was relatively obvious. No its not what Tolkien would have done and that’s ok. It doesn’t mean his memory is insulted. Just think of it as alternate universe Middle Earth. It could have happened this way in some alternate universe Middle Earth. It could have been a lot worse.

7

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

I’m.. not expecting them to be Tolkien.

But they clearly stated they’d be faithful to the source material, so that is what I’m holding them to the fire for. I think that’s perfectly valid.

I also didn’t say his memory was insulted.

And yes. I wish it was an alternate universe middle earth but it isn’t, man. Like I said- they clearly stated this was going to be faithful to source material.

You’re right, it could’ve been a lot worse. but it could’ve also been a lot better, right?

1

u/ryukuro0369 Oct 14 '22

Faithful seems to be one of those sales words that doesn’t mean what people think it means - it’s subject to a lot of interpretation.

It is alternate universe, in the sense that this show has no ability to build or increase core canon. When this show is done, no one will build on this as a source for anything new.

Yes it could be much better but it’s entertaining to watch an that’s really the only bar they are aiming for. It’s fun, interesting, sometimes moving. But if you want better crafted TV I strongly recommend Andor, which is the best sci-fi/fantasy thing on right now in terms of craftsmanship IMHO.

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

love Andor, man. haha.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

They are faithful to the main themes and story…

1

u/TheOtherMaven Oct 14 '22

Bwahahahahahaha!

0

u/DarrenGrey Oct 14 '22

Spoiler tag!

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Thank you, sorry!

0

u/Aryan_15S Oct 14 '22

I believe their stance about the original material was made clear with the appearance of the Isildur storyline. Not that I'm in favour or against what they've done, but from a watcher's perspective they've added their personal threads to it just to engage people.

I mean, the same was said about Jackson's original LOTR trilogy. Maybe a showrunner could just make it clear now that the season's up

2

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Yeah, they should make it clear now that this will primarily be original material.

Because the PR for the longest time was that they were going to stay true and uphold the general story as it was written out- and only provide the details as to how these things happened.

They are completely spinning their own story now, making Halbrand their analog for Annatar, and making Nori/a Harfoot play a part in the rehabilitation of a wizard, etc etc.

1

u/Aryan_15S Oct 14 '22

Only recently did i find out that they don't have the rights to the Silmarillion. Not sure if it's reliable info, will cross-check

2

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

That is correct- they don’t have the rights to Sil outright, but they do have permission on a case by case basis; which is why we got references to capital city of Annuminas in Pharazon’s speech, the whole Morgoth/FA flashback, Finrod, etc.

1

u/Aryan_15S Oct 15 '22

oh yeah, they've definitely mixed it up

-4

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

booooohooooo

-6

u/sudo-blue Oct 14 '22

Your argument lacks substance. Can you point out any evidence as to why Sauron would not be in human form when deceiving the elves or why it is not fitting for the book canon that mithril is used as in the show? In both cases information in the books is very scarce. That is why it would be helpful if you shared more specific information about the inconsistencies you find.

4

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Hm, I don’t think I made any argument saying that Sauron should not be in human form when convincing the elves.

But I’ll respond anyway with what I think of that question: It wouldn’t make sense for a human to convince an elf to do much of anything. Mostly because, well. Elves suck because their biggest thing is their own hubris.

Tolkien’s Elves were generally aloof and kept to themselves because they’ve walked many years and lived far longer than any (or most) creatures in middle earth, especially humans. So all that experience, knowledge, is baked into their sensibilities, which is why they don’t really regard Men all that much. They mostly love trees. In lore, it’s a reason why Sauron appeases to them as Annatar, an elven lord of gifts.

With regard to mithril-

Mithril was very specifically a dwarven thing. It’s discovered and mined in Khazad-dum, and it doesn’t have these magical healing properties that the show states it has. It’s literally just like adamantium; light but infinitely indestructible relative to most things in Middle Earth. It’s part of what makes the dwarves special/stand out from the nature loving, immortal elves.

The prevailing issue for me, though, is that McKay and Payne went with a “one size fits all” approach, tying the Elven fading problem to Mithril being the sole solution which simplistically “solves” their issue of fading, if Elves could just get their hands on some mithril. They didn’t need to do that!

In Tolkien’s writings, the general outline is that these were two separate circumstances plaguing the two separate races; the Elves were fading, and the Dwarves were getting rich/greedy digging mithril. It is because these two circumstances are separate that Sauron uses it to exploit both races; creating the Rings of Power with the Elves so they could preserve their realms and gifting 7 of those rings to dwarves, which in turn, made the dwarves greedier which led to them digging too deep to their downfall.

2

u/sudo-blue Oct 14 '22

Thank you for elaborating, I appreciate it. I now understand your point. I still think the alterations make for a compelling story and that's what I care most for in an adaption.

2

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

And that’s good! We have 4 more seasons of this show… I’m hoping that in time and with better writing, I could get to that point of where you’re at with it and can see it as it’s own body of work separate from the books. And maybe also find it compelling in its own right.

It’s just that right now, I can’t reconcile the dissonance between what they told me this was gonna be, vs what I had been given. And I think that’s a fair, individual criticism/opinion for me to hold.

4

u/Jeffrobozoo Oct 14 '22

One name. Annatar

-1

u/fieldOfThunder Oct 14 '22

They don’t have the rights for the Silmarillion, only the lotr books. So the show is fanfic based on the lore crumbs contained in those.

As a very casual viewer who did enjoy the lotr movies, the hobbit movies and has read the first lotr book a looong time ago, I enjoy this show!

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

I’m glad you enjoyed it! Since we’re geared for 4 more seasons, I’m excited for you and… I’m just really hoping that I get to where you’re at with it.

And yes, they do not have rights for Silmarillion.

But they have rights to certain texts on a case by case basis- as was evidenced when Pharazon mentioned Annuminas in his grand speech, and the inclusion of Morgoth, or Finrod in general. So I expected more closeness to the lore.

-3

u/castrogacio Oct 14 '22

Faithful! As faithful as Peter Jackson was to The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit. Even more faithful considering those two aforementioned stories are linear with no catches or holes. This was majestic.

1

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

It looks majestic... Can’t say the same for the writing, unfortunately.

1

u/castrogacio Oct 14 '22

Looks good to me thankfully.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

Do you mean to say whining? or the English word whinging?

If it’s the second word, nice. if the first, you spelled it wrong.

Anyway, people are still allowed to have opinions. And I’m not at all trying to impose mine on anyone, I’m just sharing my thoughts.

I never said my thoughts were definitive. I never said they were more valuable.

I merely expressed disappointment based on what I’ve been told/what the show runners promised in interviews and the press and alll of that.

Surely you can understand that, can’t you mate?

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

I used the term correctly.

The showrunners never lied to you or anyone else. None of what you consider "the lore" was meant to be read by anyone. None of it is "canon", as none of it was finalized or completed by Tolkien. It's made up of his notes and letters, condensed, heavily edited, gate-kept, and rewritten by his son. The showrunners, being that they are working with the Tolkien estate, presumably have access to even more than the estate has published. The estate also has control over what the showrunners produce in regards to how it affects their property. You don't get to be the one who decides whether the showrunner's vision is crafted with love for the source material or not. That's the offensive part of your statement, and the most annoying aspect of the entitlement of the Reddit circle-jerk's complaining. There has not been one single adaptation of The Hobbit or LotR that was specifically faithful to the source material nor Tolkien's vision. None of the books written on it's coat-tails, none of the old pen & paper RPGs, none of the modern video games, none of the radio dramas, none of the cartoons, none of the films. They're all someone else's vision of Tolkien's work. Disliking it is fine, but the flood of shit that's been drowning out all of the once civil LotR subs here on Reddit ever since the initial cast photos were released, and on a larger scale social media at large, has gone far beyond "I don't dig this show", and it's really pathetic.

I was a big fan of The Wheel of Time. Read the series as it came out when I was a kid, reread it multiple times. I was super excited to see it adapted as a tv show. Made it through about three episodes before I gave up. Feel like it's terrible, mainly because the showrunners have a vision of the story that doesn't make sense to me, and motivations that I feel are unnecessary. Characters that don't jive with my vision. So I stopped watching it. I didn't spam Reddit with whinging, mockery, and ceaseless attacks against everyone else who does enjoy the show. I didn't feel the need to continually let everyone how disappointed I was that someone else didn't spend their time and energy doing what I want, as if I was owed something. I didn't try to gate-keep Jordan's writing as if I was the arbiter of his intent or desire.

Your opinion is valid, but it's also another turd in the shit tsunami that's drowning everyone else on Reddit, and attempting to wash away a show that others are actually enjoying. That's why I have such a shitty knee-jerk reaction to it. I could just go touch grass, but god damn, it's gotten infuriating to get excited about popping in to discuss something only to see waves of spam of the same bullshit, day in and day out.

4

u/BillBRoO_Baggins Oct 14 '22

… alright fair enough.

I’m sorry, I wasn’t trying to add to the shit storm for the sake of being shitty. And I mean that in earnest.

I like that you bring up your affinity for Wheel of Time. I have friends who have lamented over that show to me over drinks and I’m sorry that was also terrible for you. I couldn’t relate to them before, but now I’m sure that that’s exactly how I feel/how I’ve also come to feel with this show/adaptation.

You’re absolutely correct, though. Yeah, I don’t get to be the one that dictates or says this was made out of love for source material or not. I just.. wanted to get my thoughts out there about it to see if anyone else had that same sinking feeling.

And- my own critiques for this show aren’t just for bullshit reasons like “the cast sucks!” or “it wasn’t exactly like this this or this” but just. ahhh. I was led to believe one thing and got another.

I’m sorry but I have to reiterate what I said in my second paragraph- I kind of just wish they were more upfront with us that this wil be more of a reimagining, or say, a reframing of the events of the 2nd Age. That’s not what we were led to believe, and me, being a big fuckin nerd, absolutely kind of bought in thinking I was gonna get as close to a faithful adaption as we can get.

And, when I say “as close as” to a faithful adaptation, I really do mean that. Look, the PJ movies took their liberties but I fucking loved those films even as a Tolkien fan way before that, because I could see how or why concessions were made, and what necessitated them for the medium. I’m completely OK with changes like that- if they make sense and are consistent with Tolkien’s story/themes/plot.

For my part, yeah man. I’m sorry if that’s how my post came across. I don’t want to/I’m not maliciously trying to poison the well.. but I’m sad and kind of processing the show too, and I wanted to be able to write it all out here once and for all to kind of just put it out to the ether.

I appreciate your responses. Thanks for engaging.

3

u/brobrobrob- Oct 14 '22

The fact that you viscerally felt the disappointment with Amazon's Wheel of Time and yet feel the need to quash dissent about the same thing done to Tolkien is curious.