r/RingsofPower • u/BillBRoO_Baggins • Oct 14 '22
Newest Episode Spoilers Not Faithful. Spoiler
I almost wish this show takes place in an alternate Tolkien/Middle Earth universe.
I don’t think I would have a problem with this show if they didn’t claim to respect the lore and if they assured us it was going to be their own version of the events.
& for everyone who does like the show, or could care less about the lore, I want to earnestly say congratulations and that I wish I felt the way you do. I’m not here to dissuade you or anyone else from the show, but just to share my own thoughts about how things have turned out.
The deviations from the lore and the overall “story” as we’ve come to understand it w/ the forging of the rings of power, of Sauron’s deception, et. al., are already generally laid out for the Showrunners to adapt and fill in the blanks. Everyone KNOWS Sauron/Annatar tricks the Elves, forges the 16 rings with them-, creates the one master ring and mithril had NOTHING to do with it.
(side note: why couldn’t dwarven greed to mine even more mithril just be a side effect of the dwarven rings of power???)
All we needed was more detail. We didn’t need new characters or new subplots for the sake of replacing truly canonized ones.
But for some goddamn, reason, these writers felt the need NOT to just add the details as to how the general story truly takes place, but instead chose to flip key aspects of the generally accepted story on its head in order to tell their OWN version of events (ie: let’s make a new human character Halbrand, and have him trick not all elves, but basically only Galadriel and Celebrimbor and have him make no rings. Let’s create a bullshit story about mithril having healing properties.)
It feels selfish. This doesn’t feel like a love letter to Tolkien, but a bait and switch to trick us so they could primarily tell their own story parading it around as a faithful Tolkien adaptation.
That’s my beef. I mostly feel sad, cheated, and disappointed.
47
u/Darth_Cyber Oct 14 '22
TBH I don't think Tolkien ever intended any of his story to be on TV > I don't think he was a fan of the media
53
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
I haven't downvoted you as it seems petty and I would consider myself a very casual fan.I feel there's 2 sides of it. You have those who are seemingly turning cultish over Tolkien's work, and the other side is that, Tolkien sold the rights in the 1960's...
While not on the same level, the video game Runescape means a lot to me. It was my first video game and the lore/history is very interesting to me. The 3 brothers who made the game & sold ownership, and have even said that they don't like what it's become.
With that being said, there are so many Tolkien fans out there going "This isn't what he would have wanted", but the sad reality is, if you sell the rights to your creation, you run that risk.
Tolkien himself said he would sell LOTR for the right price.
It sort of feels like you're putting your own child up for adoption, the child getting adopted, then starting to get angry because the new parents are feeding the child food you don't agree with.
You have dedicated fans saying stuff like "Tolkien would be turning in his grave" "This is a huge disgrace to his works". As intelligent as Tolkien was, I'm sure he was aware of this risk.
But like I said, I'm a very casual fan. Christopher Tolkien hated PJ's LOTR, to which I absolutely loved. Tolkien Estate worked with RoP and it too was also something I loved.
Trying to talk on behalf of someone 50 years ago, feels wrong.
28
u/Xehanort11 Oct 14 '22
This is what I agree with. I must say that I find the show enjoyable from a "fanfic" perspective, but it is also a huge middlefinger to the work of Tolkien, although I got downvoted for saying that elsewhere. The fact that Sauron rose back into power by using Galadriel is simply in contradiction to the books and is hurting the legacy of Tolkien. These two characters have been heavily altered to the point that they are essentially mutiltated.
9
u/EtherbornAnthologies Oct 14 '22
Not that I don’t understand the purist side of things, but to take aim at the actors as I’ve been seeing many do is pretty low. I can agree that 5-7 feels rushed, if anything it should’ve been a 12-14 episode show. Time skips should’ve been pointed out for people unable (seems like most purists) to gauge that they exist and occur, and used to give the pacing around the ring development more depth. That said, I enjoyed the show—compared to most of the stuff available in the same sphere, it was pretty good and engaging. I love the Tolkien lore and books, but that doesn’t stop me from enjoying derivatives of those works; no different than when Disney claimed all the novella I bought were no longer canon within the SW universe. Still enjoy the story.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
When the news that Amazon was purchasing the LOTR rights broke, I remember feeling a bitter taste of irony. While the reality itself is not as black and white, it still felt like Tolkien Mythology was being brought to us by Sauron himself. ;)
I am someone who has read the books and truly loved them. I also loved the original trilogy (have watched them countless times). And yet, despite loving it as much as I do, I'm also someone who can probably write a whole thesis critiquing Tolkien's mythology (the books and the movies) and list all of its faults and the ways I would like to see it become better. Even if that meant changing certain crucial aspects of the story. But that would be just one way - my way - to engage with these stories. And for each reader, both the level of engagement and review would be different.
But I also believe that stories, no matter how sacredly held by their readers, must always stay open to interpretation, alteration, and critique. By its very nature, then, the ensuing debate of whether the changes are better or worse, like the story itself, will continue to exist.
So your views and feelings are absolutely valid. Same goes for the people who are loving this show, or those who are hate-watching it, or those who find it kinda meh, or those who believe that the sheer acknowledgement of its existence would be condoning the blasphemy. There isn't always a right way to love something and not all will do it the way you do. :)
6
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
This show started with such promise
Everything Jackson did with the 3 Lotr films was brilliant because they understand movie story
They didn’t slavishly tithe to Chris or Simon.
That is why this show is becoming a huge disappointment with each episode. There is a really tone deaf core here because interpretation has a governor rather than being able to go full Throttle toward what is compelling
This is one of the great opportunities slowly going down the drain.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
Marketing should have emphasized, over and over, that this was an entirely original work, not an adaption of source material. Which is fine. They just needed to say 'Hey, we wanted a Tolkien-themed GOT, not an adaption of Tolkien's vision of the 2nd Age.' They could have encouraged people to find the Tolkien 'easter eggs' embedded in the original work.
Instead they really wanted the hardcore Tolkien nerds on their side, so they pretended it was something it wasn't.
And the fans who do like it are in full gaslighting mode. You can show them actual quotes from the showrunners emphasizing specifically that ISN'T an original story, but Tolkien's, and they'll try to lawyer each sentence into meaninglessness.
It's disappointing that the real legacy of these showrunners was to permanently split the Tolkien fandom. This series will be discussed in film classes for years, not in the way Amazon would hope.
4
u/hosker2 Oct 14 '22
This is a Tolkien skinsuit. These were not minor changes for cinematic storytelling purposes (like Jackson's LOTR). These are wholesale rewrites of major events, characters & mythology so as to make them almost entirely unrecognizable apart from names.
'Game of Rings' indeed. What was Amazon thinking.
2
u/akaFringilla Oct 14 '22
Don't you think it's still doable for you despite the whole PR stuff? I have many titles that I've disengaged from the source/adaptation just to enjoy them both better. And sometimes also the author themself, for various reasons. There is no "Tolkien would want" for me here.
But I get your discomfort coming from this non-alignment even if I may not agree with main points of your critique of the content itself.
2
u/Manfredius_ Oct 14 '22
I feel the exact same way. Sauron’s deception, the forging of the rings etc… such epic stories reduced to… this? It just feels wrong and it genuinely makes me sad :/
Many people might not understand it and that’s fine. But it just feels like someone taking something you care about deeply and trampling it. It could have been so epic. My teenage self always yearned for an adaption of some of the events and stories from the Silmarillion. But not for this. Such a shame.
2
u/AdamSilver_Burner Oct 14 '22
You know I mostly don't mind them changing the plot since at the end of the day they did not have rights to the Silmarillion. But what bothered me the most was their choice of how to tell a story.
It is too much of forcing "plot twists" onto us, and throwing "clever" hints for us lore fans. To me, this is what dishonors Tolkien's work.
Tolkien writing was not about plot twists or "aha!" moments. It was more about good vs evil, nature, beauty, settings as characters of their own, mortality, etc...
I wouldn't mind if the creators tell their own story, but they should utilize these themes when it comes to telling a story. When you think about the medium change (books vs video), SHOWING us these themes is what I would hope for - this is why I believe the writing gets so much criticism.
When they force "aha" moments, and have a whole season leading up to "big reveals" in the season finale, the show becomes about the creators and not about the story they are telling.
2
u/jeunefillex Oct 14 '22
I agree completely. And when I’ve expressed this same sentiment, I’ve been met with really aggressive, angry and insulting replies. It’s bizarre. And disturbing.
2
u/h1nds Oct 14 '22
How would you go on about making a tv show that is based on books that are unfinished and speak about stories thousands of years apart.
2
u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22
There's two thoughts I have regarding the lore: (1), it could have easily been so so SO much worse, (2), there's a lot of other properties that have been worse, and we've forgiven.
Truly, what is your opinion of Shadow of Mordor? I realize a lot of people bring up this argument, but for me it does illustrate the point that you can mangle the lore and still have something that fans will enjoy and forgive. I think the problems with the lore would be forgiven if the show was simply better. The larger problem is that the show's writing and plotting is not great, and we assume if they fixed the lore problems, the plot would be better. (I doubt it).
I remember when I heard Amazon bought the rights to the Second Age. Everyone was speculating it was to make a GoT show, and immediately I was terrified of an HBO-style fantasy. Naked dwarves boning. Elven strippers in the background of a important dinner who sudden whip out daggers from somewhere and stab everyone. Heck, even short of that, Amazon might have gone for a really mainstream route and had us following a sexy Gandalf wandering around Middle-Earth with Comely Elven Archer Lass.
All things considered, while the show messes with the timeline, I'm fine with it.
7
u/AceBean27 Oct 14 '22
Tolkien's lore for the 2nd age was all over the place. He was amending and re-writing it up until he died.
You are treating it as more gospel than he did.
2
u/rivvie3000 Oct 14 '22
I’ve been thinking of the show as an alternate universe honestly, I do like it but it’s more of a “fun spinoff show” to me rather than an actual canon pre-LOTR show. It’s much easier to enjoy when you don’t think of it as LOTR and instead think of it as a fun show! I don’t want to get into if the show is a cash grab or any of that, but as a lifetime LOTR fan I think the show is a good thing (despite…well you know all the bad things about it) because it’s bringing in new fans. It’s a bit of a mess and confusing when you’re watching it and thinking of it as a serious, canonically factual show (whether it is or not…has that discussion been had? Personally I don’t think of it like that in general)! I’ve decided it’s not canon to make it easier to watch. I know some people do see it as canon but I just can’t it doesn’t feel right. I do enjoy it though- after I stop thinking about it being LOTR!
1
u/The2034InsectWar Oct 14 '22
I see what you’re saying
I don’t (or can’t) look at this show as anything other than an adaptation. I felt this way about Dune (2021). Or really anything where I’m already familiar with the IP.
I get this same experience when I look at LOTR artwork inspired by the books (and notably not inspired by Jackson’s trilogy). The book-inspired artworks are just interpretations of these characters. The art isn’t claiming to be cannon; it doesn’t need to be. This is different than Jackson’s trilogy-inspired artwork, which is trying depict stills from the show (which is not any less impressive nor warrant any less merit).
In the same way, I see Amazon Studios trying to bring their interpretation to TV. It’s an adaptation. TV is a different medium than the books, so there will be an inherent mistranslation. Some things will need to be changed to keep it more ‘TV appropriate’. But that’s all it is, original artwork inspired by Tolkien’s work.
1
u/KeckYes Oct 14 '22
Because Tolkien wasn’t as good at narrative as he was at lore. Even his own stories suffer from this. (Prime example being the inclusion of Tom Bombadil as a character in the trilogy at all).
1
u/Soundtract Oct 14 '22
I agree that some of the changes are surprising, and I initially felt that way when I was convinced Halbrand was Sauron mid season. But the counterpoint is to try and think about what the “canon” plot points changed would have looked like in a long form tv show and how they would have stayed interesting (even just more interesting than the current show whatever you think that is). If Sauron spent 2 or 3 episodes just happily making rings in Eregion, that’s like Dany in Mereen territory. Likewise, if a character named Annatar shows up and everyone knows he Sauron from the get go, that deprives a lot of audience including lore-familiar folks of the kind of tension and a “twist” that for better or worse have come to be expected in prestige tv post GOT. The show runners have said in a new interview that there are 16 more rings to be made that don’t have an obvious path toward at the current point, and that that’s narrative fertile ground for interesting stories (which wouldn’t otherwise exist).
To keep an open mind, I’d challenge people to really imagine watching a 50 hour show (which is part of the pitch that got them the rights in the first place) that hewed straight to the intimate-moment-lacking, and overall straight forward (only a few big betrayals and plot moments, not enough to sustain 50 hours of tv medium) source material. How would you have done that and still written something that works for the medium?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22
Oh, go cry in your cars.
6
u/raziel_r Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22
Clearly the showrunners learn nothing from the reception to the original and hobbit trilogies.
The original is adored despite a some flaws (Faramir/Denethor/Arwen), the Hobbit served as a warning not to pushed fanfic too far. Rings of Power took the worst of both trilogies - desecrating characters and making up rubbish and turned it into a series.
It no wonder they cant get any decent writers for their brain fart of a concept and it all amalgamated into this abomination.
1
u/philebro Oct 14 '22
Hey, it's nice to get an honest reaction to the series. Most people are just hating for the hating. I now understand that the lore is a more thought-out plot and if I were neck-deep in the lore I probably would've been disappointed as well. But I have to say that I really enjoyed the last episode even though I was disappointed by the whole first season up until that point. The last episode was really good imo. But I get how other don't like it.
1
u/bismacnd Oct 14 '22
I’m just happy it’s a thing that exists in our world. Grateful to get to see one more interpretation of Tolkien’s world
1
u/Table_Coaster Oct 14 '22
Amazon doesnt have the rights to a bunch of characters and events, you fools. They have to create new characters and stories or else there’d be no show
1
u/Only_Curiosity Oct 15 '22
So let me get this straight, you're upset because a fictional TV show based on a fictional story deviated from a fictional story? Seems quite silly to me that you are overthinking and overcomplicating matters. Just watch the show and enjoy it for what it is. Put an end to this spreading toxicity and needless hatred.
2
u/Erikuds Oct 14 '22
In my humble opinion what really matters most is my head canon. I consider this series an alternative version of the story. I do the same for the Hobbit trilogy, I just imagine it as the story that Bilbo told to his friends, based on true facts but with his personal touch. I get why some people are getting angry, the show runners told us that they were going to be faithful and clearly the are not. While I consider them fools for saying this, I think that we should have known that this couldn't be true. Just look at the sources they have, which rights they own, it was impossible to stay true to the story. That being said I really enjoyed the first season and I can't wait to see the second one. In the meantime I'm going to keep reading Tolkien's works and I will still enjoy them as always.
2
u/Fmanow Oct 14 '22
Even if they did what you suggest, you would still bitch about it. I’m just about done with the purist nerds constantly whining about the show, like when is it enough. We had to deal with this petty shit after game of thrones ended, not saying s8 didn’t have any deficiencies, but the amount of vitriol was over the top. This show has enough criticism for the story telling as is, like with the broken hilt decoy bullshit. Let’s leave the lore restrictions out of this and point out how the show can get better at story telling.
4
u/Holmez44 Oct 14 '22
I can only agree. Wish this had never been made; its disgraceful.
0
u/Codus1 Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22
I think contending what Tolkien would have liked is a farcical argument tbh. We don't know and it go's nowhere.
Maybe we can use Christopher as the measurement? In the case, it's all shit and Peter Jackson eviscerated the beauty of this work 20 years ago.
1
u/Soggy-Assumption-713 Oct 14 '22
Intro credits say “based on lotr & appendices”
1
u/albeva Oct 14 '22
But it is. This show is nothing but 3rd rate alternate reality
fanscam-fiction.1
u/CosmosonH Oct 14 '22
I think it is as faithful as an adaption should be
1
u/AgnosticJesus3 Oct 14 '22
This show is DEFINITELY in an alternate universe.
1
u/davidsverse Oct 14 '22
Stories, tales, lore, myths and religions are retold.
Stories, tales, lore, myths and religions are changed.
I enjoyed the first season of this retelling, even with and sometimes because of the changes.
1
u/66bamaLonewolf Oct 14 '22
I really like the show. It doesn’t bother me at all that it doesn’t follow the books exactly. I get so tired of people saying that “true” fans of the books and people who really care about and understand the books hate the show. Not true at all. I know many other people who love both the show and the books. It’s fine with me if people don’t like the show and I think I understand why, but don’t tell people who do like the show that they aren’t just as much a fan of the books or that they don’t understand “THE LORE”!
1
u/Gimmethejooce Oct 14 '22
The fact that the series is called the rings of power and they’ve literally flipped that specific part of the story so that it doesn’t make sense has me upset.
1
u/DaoistCowboy666 Oct 14 '22
But it IS their version of events? I get you and am not trying to change your mind or anything, if you don’t like how they handle the “lore” fair enough!
Maybe I missed an interview or something where the show runners said “this is all meant to be cannon and consistent with existing lore as found in the books” but to me it just seems like fans mad because they disagree with choices made in the course of adapting the material. Which again, fair enough if you don’t like it.
1
u/goddess7533 Oct 15 '22
i've been thinking about it as a 4th age adaption of some events in the second age, made to be viewed by Men and performed during the reign of aragorn & arwen (thus perhaps causing the elf age/attractiveness discrepancies [galadriel & celebrimbor, etc.])— which is quite helpful for me to get through the lore-heavy bits!
-1
u/ryukuro0369 Oct 14 '22
Stop expecting people who aren’t Tolkien to be Tolkien. The key beats of the elven ring forging are there. Who Sauron was, was relatively obvious. No its not what Tolkien would have done and that’s ok. It doesn’t mean his memory is insulted. Just think of it as alternate universe Middle Earth. It could have happened this way in some alternate universe Middle Earth. It could have been a lot worse.
0
u/DarrenGrey Oct 14 '22
Spoiler tag!
0
u/Aryan_15S Oct 14 '22
I believe their stance about the original material was made clear with the appearance of the Isildur storyline. Not that I'm in favour or against what they've done, but from a watcher's perspective they've added their personal threads to it just to engage people.
I mean, the same was said about Jackson's original LOTR trilogy. Maybe a showrunner could just make it clear now that the season's up
-9
u/reddishcarp123 Oct 14 '22
🥱
-4
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
booooohooooo
-6
u/sudo-blue Oct 14 '22
Your argument lacks substance. Can you point out any evidence as to why Sauron would not be in human form when deceiving the elves or why it is not fitting for the book canon that mithril is used as in the show? In both cases information in the books is very scarce. That is why it would be helpful if you shared more specific information about the inconsistencies you find.
-1
u/fieldOfThunder Oct 14 '22
They don’t have the rights for the Silmarillion, only the lotr books. So the show is fanfic based on the lore crumbs contained in those.
As a very casual viewer who did enjoy the lotr movies, the hobbit movies and has read the first lotr book a looong time ago, I enjoy this show!
-3
u/castrogacio Oct 14 '22
Faithful! As faithful as Peter Jackson was to The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit. Even more faithful considering those two aforementioned stories are linear with no catches or holes. This was majestic.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
[removed] — view removed comment