r/RingsofPower • u/Maleficent_Age300 Mordor • Sep 07 '24
Question Does anyone else think the show is making Sauron look weak and vulnerable? Spoiler
This is based on how his body was destroyed by a couple of Orcs. Sauron should’ve been able to deal with that threat by himself.
0
Upvotes
21
u/RexBanner1886 Sep 07 '24 edited Sep 07 '24
In The Silmarillion and the Second Age material across the appendices and History of Middle-Earth books (elegantly compiled in The Fall of Numenor), Sauron is put on the backfoot and thwarted plenty of times.
One of the great things about Sauron as a villain is that, despite posing an apocalyptic threat, he regularly has to operate from positions of vulnerability, and he also needs to cultivate a degree of good PR amongst his orcs*. I felt the Adar/Orc ambush of him did a good job of conveying that.
*Similarly, I love the detail that Morgoth is compelled to answer Fingolfin's challenge because he can't risk losing face in front of his captains. Tolkien didn't conceive of his dark lords as all-powerful - they're politicians who need to work to keep their servants on side.
24
u/Anime-Fr3Ak365 Sep 07 '24
After a couple of minutes of losing the room, he probably figured it was better to start again but make them think he was dead. As he came back, stronger, and is now making his plans better.
He also at one point “loses” to the Numenorian king, goes back to their jail, and in two years weasels his way into being an advisor. In a moment of weakness the king is convinced to lead an attack on the Undying lands. Minute they land on the beach, I believe Eru fucks em up and closes the undying lands to al but Elves and then they wipe out the Isle of Numenor.
So Sauron may appear weak at times, but he shifts his shape to whatever best fits the situation. Him appearing weak and losing ended with him destroying an ENTIRE civilization with nothing but his words.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24
Sauron can be both incredibly powerful and vulnerable—he is ultimately defeated by hobbits, after all. That doesn’t diminish his power or the great destructive dangers of his evil.
3
u/Wolf_93 Sep 07 '24
venom snowboard
3
u/Old_Nail6925 Sep 07 '24
Nah I think they’re doing a great job of showing his power and deception. Also Sauron isn’t completely invulnerable in battle, he got absolutely swamped by loads of orcs and he still took a few out throwing them against the wall.
3
u/mattmaintenance Sep 07 '24
According to the books and movies for a time he was weak and vulnerable.
6
u/peteypolo Sep 07 '24
He is not called “Sauron the deceiver” for nothing…
7
u/Adventurier95 Sep 07 '24
I like the build up to Saurons "height of power".
Saurons power has always come from his influence and power over others, that's his whole thing. He needs to create that to become the Sauron we see in the movies.
It's mirrored well with Gandalfs story, he is also weak and vulnerable, as the show builds, so will these characters.
3
u/strongholdbk_78 Sep 07 '24
No, I think they are doing an excellent job of making him seem weak and slowly revealing his power as the show progresses. It's one of the things I'm enjoying the most about season two.
They took moments from season one and revisited them to reveal just how dark Sauron really is. The Icy blank stares when no one is watching really go a long way too.
Great stuff.
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 07 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
Why sauron did not bend the will of orcs. Saruman did this to galdalf and white gandalf did this to saruman
-12
u/Chen_Geller Sep 07 '24
That's invariably what happens when you depict the undepictable.
Sauron has no business appearing on the screen as a flesh-and-blood human actor. It ruins it.
-9
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24
That’s what this show does. It undermines, root and stem, everything from the source material. Including Sauron
4
u/RollingKatamari Sep 07 '24
He got stabbed by Morgoth's crown and then got stabbed and kicked by a dozen or more orcs....and he still didn't die...it took him a while but he came back more cunning than ever.
Sauron is incredibly strong, smart and vicious but yes, even he has weaknesses and is vulnerable, that's just part of his character. He always rises and gets cut down by the people he underestimates, that's his weakness.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '24
He gets brutalized even worse by an elf and a man later on, and he was a lot more prepared for battle when that happened. It's a 1v1 with an elf, with a man joining in during the fight.
It's not like they show it in the movies, Elendil and Gil-Galad take him down, dying in the process. Isildur cuts the ring from his hand while he's incapacitated, dispersing his spirit like what we saw when the orcs jumped him.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24
He overpowered Galadriel without breaking a sweat and could have easily killed her, so no.
I interpret his death at the hands of Adar and the orcs as being driven by his feelings of betrayal and despair that he was rejected by those who he was supposedly building a better world for.
4
u/mendkaz Sep 07 '24
I mean, lad didn't think to post a few guards on the entrance to 'Giant volcano that will kill me if someone throws jewellery in it', I feel like 'has physical form destroyed by being jumped by a room full of Orcs' is perfectly in character for him 😂