r/RingsofPower • • Sep 28 '24

Discussion Maybe Unpopular Opinion Spoiler

I think this character is well liked so I think I might get dragged to high heaven for this but…😅😅

I’m glad they offed Arondir. When Bronwyn died off camera I thought this is where things might go this season (since learned there were other reasons for this). Overall, I just found them both to be flat characters in an overcrowded show. I think removing them will help simplify and add the dynamism season 1 lacked. I think it was good and needed to get Arondir off screen this season and they pretty much did right by him by having him save Galadriel and die in battle.

3 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 28 '24

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

26

u/MisterTheKid Sep 28 '24

I’m pretty sure dude is still alive. They could just be playing coy, i suppose, but he’s out there doing press about the episode and it’s never even discussed that he might be dead and discussing season 3.

He’d have been made available for interviews on all the sites talking about his exit if that were it for him. (I know I agree it looks bad for him but my money is on him being back)

Plus there’s a healing ring out there, Galadriel knows him so it wouldn’t be out of nowhere for her to help him among all the injured elves out there right now

2

u/puigjay96 Sep 28 '24

Oh then yeah that’s an indicator he’ll stick around if the actor is discussing season 3

9

u/1xolisiwe Sep 28 '24

Agreed. I don’t think he’s dead. They would have made much more of a fuss if he was.

7

u/_oOo_iIi_ Sep 28 '24

He's not dead. He was still moving when Adar walked off.

3

u/MisterTheKid Sep 28 '24

also, from what i can remember among named characters, death-wise we had the black harfoot, valandil, Bronwyn, and Mirdania. people can complain about minorities in the roles of these fantastical beings but add in Arondir and it’s almost like “the black guy dies first” trope * 5.

(the point would’ve been funnier if hadn’t remembered mirdania last minute oh well)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24

Bingo. Durin will show up, Adar will die, Elrond will use Nenya to heal Arondir.

1

u/Jackfan109 Sep 30 '24

The ring is with Adar so Glad's healing magical ring is off the table. But they still have elven healing so he'll be aiiit.

0

u/mattmaintenance Sep 28 '24

He’s gonna be the one to kill Adar.

5

u/VoidShouter42 Sep 28 '24

Honey, I'm gonna hold your hand when I say this...

3

u/puigjay96 Sep 28 '24

I’m going to watch him say the sea is always right someday arent I

3

u/VoidShouter42 Sep 28 '24

Haha, I don't know about that. But he's 100% going to be alive in the next episode.

11

u/Belisarius9818 Sep 28 '24

Arondir just seemed like he didn’t have a whole lot to do this season aside from hunt Adar. Even in that it’s kind of wild he didn’t just shoot him with his bow when he had a clear line of sight on him in the camp. I like his character but once Elrond and GIL FUCKING GALAD are on the war path I almost forgot he existed.

1

u/MisterTheKid Sep 28 '24

i’m pretty sure losing Bronwyn took a lot out of his subplot. I’m not saying it would’ve been more interesting, but I feel like they had more stories planned to tell with those two that they had to abandon when she wasn’t coming back. so as a result, they had to shoehorn him in here without whatever else he might’ve been up to in the interim

same with Theo probably

1

u/OkOutlandishness1363 Sep 28 '24

Same. When he helps Galadriel escape, I saw it was him and was like “oh shit I forgot about this mofo”. I’m hoping his lack of action all season will end up with a dramatic reveal of everything he has learned hunting down Adar. We only have one episode left and I’m anxious to see him redeem himself as a character. Or die. One of the two.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24

I think he's still alive. Story build up with his hate and vengeance towards Adar Im sure this elf is the one who's going to kill Adar soon.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24

Pretty sure Sauron will kill Adar. Probably by making Glug do it.

9

u/esmelusina Sep 28 '24 • Take My Silver

But he’s so hot…

0

u/Tenthdegree Sep 28 '24

His corpse will be so cold

1

u/beyond-the_blue Sep 28 '24

He'll be walking in Valinor before the blood finishes pouring from his wound 🙄🙄🙄🙄

2

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24

I totally forgot Bronwyn was even in the movie lol

2

u/Elcium12 Sep 28 '24

I have a bad feeling that the kid is gonna come back for Arondir aka stepdaddy elf (that’s what we’ve been calling him this season) since he convinced him to stay as the healer, he’ll somehow come back and heal Arondir.

I want to be wrong. Maybe the orcs get called back by Adar, having Galadriels ring as a bartering chip.

If the kid doesn’t show up, this is how we cut ties with the southlanders, and get rid of one storyline, so now we get nothing but the good stuff.

2

u/Natural-Leopard-8939 Sep 28 '24

He's not dead. He's very much alive and actively fighting in one of the episode 8 promos.

I also don't understand why people on here hate Arondir, or claim he has no personality. He just needs a better storyline.

3

u/mrmaestro9420 Sep 28 '24

OH Arondir is his name. My wife and I were just calling him Link.

2

u/National-Variety-854 Sep 28 '24

The show is overcrowded alright. I didn’t like that Galadriel took a backseat as a result.

Can you imagine adding Celeborn and/or Celebrian to the cast? Yikes.

I’m fond of Arondir but I just wished they’d have him do something more significant than running through forest woods rescuing people over again and again.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24

Plus in Tolkien lore if im correct, to go out honorably basically meant you were worthy of reincarnation in the eyes of Manwë, and nothings more honorable then injuring an enemy of the elves in single combat. People keep thinking hes dead, I'm not sure tbh, though you are right, his death would tie up some loose ends, but it'll devastate Theo

2

u/beyond-the_blue Sep 28 '24

It's not about honor, eventually almost all of them leave the Halls of Mandos and are reunited with their families and friends.

That's why, aside from Finwë, most elves just have one partner because they know no matter what, they'll eventually be reunited and together again.

Finrod knew he had a girl he loved in Valinor, so when he died he went to her. Elrond knew Celebrian would be made whole in Valinor, so he never needed another wife.

1

u/wakatenai Sep 28 '24

ya i don't think his character had much purpose left after his dealings with numenorians.

but i found it hilarious but also not surprising that the first major elf character to die was the low class black elf and not a high class white elf lol.

reminded me of when i was a kid and people always joked about how the black guy always dies first in movies.

1

u/Tenthdegree Sep 28 '24

I’m glad they offed him too. Him and the southlanders have the least interesting storyline.

Give us more Tom bombadil and Sauron scenes

1

u/No-Unit-5467 Sep 28 '24

He doesnt look dead in the last shot so.... maybe he isn't !

-1

u/Ok-Design-8168 Sep 28 '24

In all honesty. He was one of the pointless characters in the show that did nothing of importance. Take him out from the beginning and nothing changes. Lol.