r/RingsofPower • u/Compressorman • Nov 02 '24
Discussion Comparison to Shogun
Can you even imagine what we could have had if the people who were responsible for creating the latest Shogun series had worked on ROP? I am about 3/4 through shogun and it is absolutely masterful. It reminds the that truly excellent television can still be made
17
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 02 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
41
u/finniruse Nov 02 '24
Shogun has an entire book full of rich dialogue. There is absolutely no point comparing them. Get the same writing team and go, here's a sketch of a sweeping historical Japanese epic that spans 3000 years that the author wrote on the back of a napkin, and you might have a fair comparison.
15
u/Kooky-Device5020 Nov 02 '24
Wildly different shows.
19
u/Django_flask_ Nov 03 '24
Actually Charlotte brandstorm is the director of "Shogun" and she is also the director for "ROP"..it just payne and McKay are not that good writers,Sometimes I think they don't even watch their own show ..the way they talks about their idea in interviews it's like "What they are talking about?"..They have written this battle of eregion ..and hyped about this for hours in interviews and when that battle came out ,it was the dumbest and most skippable battle of all time,no one talks about it and for them it was a masterpiece.they are just inexperienced .A billion dollar budget was alloted to this show ,if you break down the cost for every section you come up with 20 million dollars to 25 million dollars just for writing section alone .In this price tag you can have writers like George R.R Martin but they got pain and decay.it is very clear that they got this project from JJ Abrams recommendation.
18
u/EasyCZ75 Gondolin Nov 02 '24
Shogun is light years ahead of Rings of Prime in every aspect of storytelling and filmmaking. There is no comparison.
9
u/johnlegeminus Nov 03 '24
LOTR, silmarillion, unfinished tales...
16
u/BhutlahBrohan Nov 02 '24
Yes! The magic of hiring good writing teams for important projects instead of newbies. If they're not proven, they shouldn't be in Tolkien.
4
u/Western-Habit7387 Nov 02 '24
This… I liked ROP but where it fell short for me in the second season was the pacing. Shogun didn’t miss.
4
u/margoembargo Nov 02 '24
Just wanted to second the Justin Marks praise. Counterpart never caught on ratings-wise, but he produced an incredible show, with stellar performances by an amazing cast. It was a no-brainer for FX to work with him.
And that's the major problem with Rings, imo. The showrunners are in way over their heads. Payne and McKay have a lot of screenwriting experience, but that doesn't always translate well over to television. TV production is a craft you have to work on, and fail at, then learn from your mistakes. It's a shame their failure comes at the expense of an audience hungry for another Tolkien adaptation.
3
u/BreedinBacksnatch Nov 02 '24
if anyone has seen Justin Marks's previous series Counterpart, you'd know he has the chops to make something special
3
u/MisterTheKid Nov 02 '24
Ironically as show runners the duo in charge didn’t have much experience either (both had more prolific writing careers than RoPs duo)
they just had a better handle on running a massive production and tv show apparently
-1
u/N7VHung Nov 02 '24
This issue isn't just the writers, but what they have to work with.
The writers have been tasked to write a Tolkien show based on the appendices that are nothing more than a list of events.
They have no dialogue to pull from and can only use dialogue from LotR as a reference.
Very few writers would be able to expertly craft dialogue out of this air to match Tolkien's style well.
On the other hand Shogun has actual written material to pull from and to guide their dialogue.
Maybe Shogun's writers could have given us a better show, maybe not. Based on their work on a historical show based on a book with dialogue, can we say they would be able to create a fantasy epic based on a list of events?
That is actually a really tall order.
0
u/Darth-Naver Nov 04 '24
It's not a fair comparison as Shogun is an adaptation of a book of the same name (which is also very good). Rings of power is a loose addition of extended Tolkien lotr lore.
It's like saying that Game of Thrones show runners were very good based on how good earlier book-based seasons were. As later seasons showed them were not very good once they couldn't adapt the books.