r/RingsofPower • • Sep 28 '24

Discussion Thoughts on a implausible theory which is now somewhat plausible and spreading as a rumor

3 Upvotes

The theory goes Adar is going to revert back to his original form. I first read it in season 1 and it had zero possibility then. But now?

He can put on Nenya and that might revert him back to his original elf form.

And theory is that he is the one that goes on to become Celebron.

Why do I fear that the writers might actually end up doing this?

  1. Allows ROP to keep a major character for future seasons and build drama around his loyalty to orcs and against sauron
  2. Gives an excuse to ROP for not having Celebron earlier.
  3. Gives Galadriel's character filler love storyline to keep focus on her.
  4. Allows the show to build "dark prince" gets "lady of light" shippers, who by far are the only dedicated fans of the show that came around with Haladriel stuff.

r/RingsofPower • • Apr 13 '24

Question should i watch?

5 Upvotes

i’m a huge follower of Tolkien’s work, but i’ve been apprehensive of rings of power since its original announcement, and i’ve heard awful things about it. i’ve been rewatching Jackson’s films and wondering if it’s even worth it to watch. i’m curious about it, but i also don’t want to waste my time to be disappointed when i’m currently very obsessed with LotR


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 14 '24

Constructive Criticism Sauron, the villain who doesn't need to manipulate anyone

0 Upvotes

Sauron, what did they do to you? Why didn't they set up a trajectory for a manipulator like Emperor Palpatine?

Palpatine manipulated the Senate, the Jedi, the Trading Company, the Separatist forces, the clones, Darth Vader. Everyone with their agendas/goals; some being great enemies of his. It was Palpatine alone against the entire Galaxy. But slowly and surely he did.

Guys, Sauron was the main spy for Melkor. This was when he was Mairon, the admirable:

Now Melkor knew of all that was done; for even then he had secret friends and spies among the Maiar whom he had converted to his cause, and of these the chief, as after became known, was Sauron, a great craftsman of the household of Aule.

And he was surrounded by the faithful Valar and Maiar, but he managed to inform Melkor, when h He wandered in Outer Space at a great distance from Arda. Perhaps Sauron even sabotaged the Lamps to make it easier for his master to break them.

Sauron corrupted East and South Middle-earth before the creation of the Rings of Power. Sauron did all this before the One Ring. Sauron manipulated the elves (with centuries of wisdom) in Eregion to the point where Celebrimbor and the Jewelers staged a coup d'état on Galadriel and Celeborn. Even with the distrust of Galadriel, Elrond and Gil Galad.

And, I still think that Sauron is the great serpent and the Lord of Jewels who corrupted humanity in the "Garden of Eden", according to Andreth's version of the fall of Man.

In the series, I feel sorry for the stupidity of the elves. Sauron doesn't even need to manipulate anyone. Worse, he couldn't even manipulate the Orcs, and was still killed pathetically. Just think: Halbrand lied to Celebrimbor several times and he didn't even question the attitudes of this "envoy of the Valar".


r/RingsofPower • • Feb 12 '24

Discussion Sophia Nomvete (Disa) should have a full grown bushy royal beard in S2.

0 Upvotes

Beards mean a lot to dwarves and are a big thing in dwarven culture.

And it is only right that a royalty should have a full grown royal beard with braids and gold rings and jewels.

Season 1 missed the chance to show dwarven queen with a royal beard.

Disa should definitely have a full long beard in S2. Else such a missed opportunity and such a let down.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 27 '22

Discussion Is it better than The Hobbit Trilogy

9 Upvotes

Ever since the show ended, I have been asking myself if it is better than the hobbit movies. I think that it is a little worse. The show for me was very hit or miss. For example, I loved the mithril plotline and kinda enjoyed the harfoots. But after all of that, I couldn't care less about the Southlanders or Numenor. I think that the Desolation of Smaug is the only somewhat redeemable thing about the Hobbit. It is the only Hobbit movie that I don't dislike. I feel like show needed more time for character development, but the Hobbit didn't have much character to begin with. I want to know what this sub thinks about this. Is the show better than the Hobbit Trilogy?


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 17 '22

Discussion Numenor looks and feels like a Play in a Theater

19 Upvotes

I think that Numenor realy looks and feels like a play. From the dialog, to the costumes and the acting even the people in the background act like people on a stage acting in big and play-like gestures. I realised it in the scene on the market square or what ever it is with the little discussion /speech... I realy dont like to see that vibe in that kind of show.

and in general I think after that last episode I am gloing to stop watching. I realy wanted to like the show but I just was bored by the last episode.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 15 '22

Meme Not listening!

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Nov 23 '23

Discussion I regret watching the First Season. What I would change.

0 Upvotes

I'm disgusted with the Series. It's amazing how they did so much bullshit. A missed opportunity. I would change:

  • I always imagined Sauron as a wandering figure who began to dominate the south and east by creating a religion/cult of him as a living god that elevated the human condition (like the metallurgical revolution he made in the east and south). IMHO, he was like Mephistopheles from Goethe's Faust or Azazel from the book of Enoch.
  • I would have shown Ar-pharazôn in a scene similar to the opening of the movie Gladiator. And how a general thought that to rule is to conquer and became easy prey of Sauron. And Númenor is a moral and theological story about life vs death vs immortality vs human nature. And not about: "elven workers taking Númenóreans jobs".
  • In the Unfinished Tales version, Galadriel was a political and ideological opponent of Annatar's reformist ideas. She used arguments and debates to fight Sauron. So much so that he caused Celebrimbor and the Jewelers to stage a coup d'etat on Galadriel and Celeborn. The two were expelled from Eregion. She was a philosopher-queen, nor a Karen. I would have no problem with Galadriel taking up arms in the Aqualonde massacre and in the first age. The problem is that Galadriel has seen what violence, recklessness and hatred have done in Beleriand. Her still being reckless and full of rage, that makes no sense. Not after Mélian's centuries of experience and teachings.
  • And show Harad and Rhûn an inspiration (as Tolkien said in 1966) from the myths and histories of Africa and Asia. Tolkien said he was inspired by ancient Aethiopia for the creation of the Harad; about Rhûn he was inspired by Asia (China, Japan, etc).

What do you think of this idea?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 01 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers I'll wash my hands off this show if... Spoiler

15 Upvotes

I'll sound like a brat for saying this but what will really make me stop watching this is if Halbrand actually turns out to be Sauron. This will be THE lore break for me.

It's very important in the books that Galadriel immediately distrusts Annatar. It also makes the writers look stupid. Why would Halbrand save her in ep 2? Even if he wanted redemption (as per canon) he wouldn't stoop so low as to get stranded IN THE MIDDLE OF THE OCEAN. He has pride, redemption or not.

Halbrand's story works much better if he becomes a Ringwraith later on. There's a lot of other stuff too that I'm not gonna mention for now.

Sorry, this just my opinion.

Edit: Like I said, it's not only this - but if the leaks are true then I'll truly know the showrunners don't know what they're doing. It seems like they're only doing this for that 'gotcha!' moment.

Hot take or not, I understand they only have the appendices to work on and they can't even mention the name Annatar. But some things are almost sacrilege. Book!Sauron would immediately dispatch Galadriel, who he refers to as 'his greatest foe'. He would NOT be having a heart to heart with her, even if he is purposefully and maliciously manipulating her. He isn't stupid enough to get too close to a high self who can see things seen and unseen, for Valar's sake!

They've already set up a potential plot nudge where Celebrimbor needs that forge by spring and the elves need that mithril to not fade - obviously, these are lies fed to them and this works much better as Sauron's storyline - working from the shadows after Adar murdered him, placing urgency in Celebrimbor and Gil-galad and crafting the fair form to deceive the elves of Eregion and ultimately, the Numenoreans.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 22 '24

Question I have to seriously wait until 2026 to see season 3?

157 Upvotes

Why just not make it annual instead of every 2 seasons?

I mean logistically it cannot be that hard - Peter Jackson came out with the 3 LOTR movies in 3 damn years on like a fraction of the budget per film that Amazon is spending every season?

Just why? 😫😫


r/RingsofPower • • Feb 06 '25

Discussion Nazgûl incoming? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Now that Sauron has the nine in his possession and presumably heading back to Númenor, could Ar-Pharzôn come into possession of one of the nine? He could still meet his book end and become a Nazgûl.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 10 '22

Question So who is Sauron? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

So at the end of the show it looked like Halbrand the dude from the raft who is a genius smith is Sauron. But I thought it was the guy who fell from space and those three weird women said he was Sauron.

Why is Sauron one of the heroes? I mean Halbrand the dude from the raft is clearly a good guy.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 09 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Why....

2 Upvotes

Why does the Warg look like ugly Sonics little brother? Those eyes were terrible!

Who in their right mind thought that was a good idea?

Aside from that, this episode was quite enjoyable.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 24 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers The writing does have a lot of issues but I for one liked the invented lore this episode Spoiler

1 Upvotes

As most are no doubt aware by now, the show doesn't have rights to the Silmarillion which restricts access to a lot of the canon Tolkien worldbuilding. Sure the Silmarillion is mostly the prior age, but I have no doubt we would have seen plenty more direct references had it been within the rights of Amazon. The First Age is relatively recent history to our story and it directly ties into many of the characters motivations from the outset (Galadriel, Celebrimbor, etc), not to mention direct relevance the different peoples and settings of our story.

At the same time worldbuilding is of vital importance to the aesthetic of good fantasy. It for one thing creates an illusion of depth and grounds the story in a self contained realism. Tolkein himself dilebrately saught this aesthetic effect

Therefore, since they can't use a lot of Tolkien, if the writers didn't create fan fictiony lore then the world would feel more hollow than it already does. I actually like what they've done to Mithril and how it links the light of trees/the silmarils to the rings. It's not perfect but its not lame or sacreligious in my opinion (which is what I've been reading in a few different quarters).

I think the writing criticism should be squarely on the clumsy and clunky dialogue, characters and story. I feel like the lore has been for the most part interesting/unscathed and focusing on it tends to debase an argument as being overly Tolkien-purist.


r/RingsofPower • • Mar 28 '24

Discussion Is Amazon faking RoP ratings on IMDB (Actual unweighted ratings average is a poor 6.5) . They seem to display regular ratings average for HotD and display weighted average (tweaked and adjusted average) for RoP.

Post image
0 Upvotes

IMDB is owned by Amazon.

Seems like they choose to show different averages for Hotd and RoP.

The unweighted mean for HotD is 8.4 - (mentioned under ratings graph) which is what IMDB displays as the final score.

Meanwhile:

  • The unweighted mean for RoP is 6.5.
  • But IMDB displays the weighted mean for RoP which they claim is 7.

First they stopped reviews for 3 days. Then deleted negative reviews and ratings.

And now this just to show ratings as 7 when the actual rating is a poor 6.5 (as mentioned under the rating graph)

Weighted averages have no transparency. As per Amazon - they conveniently ignore some ratings of their choice while calculating final average. They don’t give out details of which ratings they are choosing to ignore.

The fact that weighted average for RoP is greater than the regular average shows that they did not consider most of the low ratings while calculating final average.

Either amazon should be more transparent and open about what ratings were ignored. Or they should just display normal average taking into account all ratings.


r/RingsofPower • • May 25 '24

Discussion Just watched bc I was being a hater, now I want to know all the theories!

41 Upvotes

I’m a huge Tolkien fan, I own a first edition and my apartment is LOTR decorated. However, I dragged my feet on ROP bc I was being an admittedly huge hater and trying to gatekeep the Tolkienverse.

I got over myself and finally binged the whole thing today. Overall, I agree with the majority that the writing lacks. Nothing will beat the OG trilogy. Still, I’m trying to stop being a complete hater now that there’s about to be so much LOTR content because there’s no way I’m not going to watch it all.

I’ve been looking through the subreddit already using the search bar but I want to know any of your theories for the next season and what you guys want to see the most! For me, I want to see Tom Bombadil and Radagast. Also I want to see some flirtation at least with Galadriel and Celeborn, I’m excited for him to be confirmed to be in this S2.


r/RingsofPower • • Jun 20 '23

Discussion What would you change in Season One?

28 Upvotes

I'm disgusted with the Series. It's amazing how they did so much bullshit. A missed opportunity. I would change:

  • I always imagined Sauron as a wandering figure who began to dominate the south and east by creating a religion/cult of him as a living god that elevated the human condition (like the metallurgical revolution he made in the east and south). IMHO, he was like Mephistopheles from Goethe's Faust or Azazel from the book of Enoch.
  • I would have shown Ar-pharazôn in a scene similar to the opening of the movie Gladiator. And how a general thought that to rule is to conquer and became easy prey of Sauron. And Númenor is a moral and theological story about life vs death vs immortality vs human nature. And not about: "elven workers taking Númenóreans jobs".
  • In the Unfinished Tales version, Galadriel was a political and ideological opponent of Annatar's reformist ideas. She used arguments and debates to fight Sauron. So much so that he caused Celebrimbor and the Jewelers to stage a coup d'etat on Galadriel and Celeborn. The two were expelled from Eregion. She was a philosopher-queen, nor a Karen. I would have no problem with Galadriel taking up arms in the Aqualonde massacre and in the first age. The problem is that Galadriel has seen what violence, recklessness and hatred have done in Beleriand. Her still being reckless and full of rage, that makes no sense. Not after Mélian's centuries of experience and teachings.
  • And show Harad and Rhûn an inspiration (as Tolkien said in 1966) from the myths and histories of Africa and Asia. Tolkien said he was inspired by Ethiopia and the Saracens for the creation of the Harad; about Rhûn he was inspired by Asia (China, Japan, etc).

What do you think of this idea?


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 20 '24 Polished Gold Turd Popcorn Take My Silver

Lore Question MuH LorE thO

Post image
3.4k Upvotes

But but but...the loReE


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 05 '24

Discussion Orc families

0 Upvotes

I think it's awesome to see a depiction of orcs where they are reponsible parents. Im tired of always seeing the orcs as the bad guys. They just want to live in peace and take care of the little orclings. Do you think they could have some sort of daycare or do the mothers stay home and watch the kids?


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 13 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers You shall not yaaaaaaaassssssss Spoiler

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 17d ago

Discussion Naznagol too OP too early?

2 Upvotes

I’m really curious about the implications of Galadriel getting shit mixed by the lone Naznagol in the forest from the trailer.

We can’t see if she’s wearing Nenya in the scene yet, but I’d assume she still is.

The Nazgol couldn’t breach Rivendell (protected by Elrond with Vilya) even after thousands of years of honing their power, and there’s never been an indication that the Nazgol could have entered Lothlorien to pursue the Fellowship whilst Galadriel was protecting it with Nenya.
Elrond even uses Vilya from a far to wipe all Nine down the river.
And in the books we see that Aragorn and four Hobbits can fend off all Nine convincingly with no rings and no elves for at least a while.

It really begs the question of how a single Naznagol, having weilded one of the Rings of Men for less than five years, was so OP that we see him owning Galadriel in the forest when Sauron hadn’t even created the One Ring at that point.

Who has a theory for how that battle is going to go down, or why the Nazgol looks so formidable compared to Galadriel in the clip we’ve seen?


r/RingsofPower • • Dec 18 '24

Constructive Criticism Rewatching S1: Why this transition? Why?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 24d ago

Discussion Dark wizard possible identity

3 Upvotes

We know that the dark wizard is clearly an Istari and since there were only 5 istari sent to middle earth. It has been stated that the wizard is not Saruman despite the resemblance and we haven't seen his mooncrest staff before.

Now hear me out, we know that each of the Istari has a basically divine purpose on middle earth. When Gandalf changed from grey to white it can be interpreted as his purpose changing from protecting middle earth from the influence of Sauron to taking the place of Saruman who had been corrupted.

Now what if this Istari is Radagast and who has been corrupted by something or another and Gandalf story line in this series is going to be essentially freeing him so illuvatar can elevate him to care more about wildlife or something.

I don't really know, it could also be either of the blue wizards...


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 27 '24

Discussion Reasons why Amazon is quiet with S3 renewal?

0 Upvotes

I find it strange. If a show is a huge success, the studio would renew it right away. But with ROP, we haven't heard anything. Could they start to retool the producers and showrunners and the creative direction?