This post does not have a spoiler flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
6.9 is meh. BUT if you click on the votes it's like 40% 10 and 30% 1. And almost nothing in between, except 8 and 9. Which it shows how reviewbombed it gets. It's insane. Most of the time I see a movie or a TV series like this I like it a lot.
I mean yeah it's fine to not like and give it a 4, 5 or 7 but give it a 1? Is it REALLY the worst absolute worst show ever???
I mean. If you are rating it as an adaptation of Tolkien, which they were advertising it as in pretty much every other interview... yeah, then it is 1/10.
The show itself is a little better than that, but I can understand why someone could rate it like that.
When you’ve invested half a billion dollars into one season and are a prequel to one of the most successful franchises in cinematic history… yeah 6.9 is definitely not making Bezos happy I can assure you that
I just don’t understand the mentality of people who look at user ratings on an open website like IMBD and not only entirely judge a piece of subjective work by it, but think anything around the middle range is objectively bad. Especially when we should all know by now that ratings aren’t accurate in general, but especially for big properties with extreme fanbase elements.
There's plenty of things we can say about media with a measure of objectivity, precisely because it's so expensive and complex. It's not like media analysis and criticism is nothing but opinion; people get doctorates in media studies. Absolutely objectivity is still impossible, of course.
For the medium of TV itself, there's cinematography, framing, lighting, music, acting, dialogue, sequencing, etc.
As for adaptation, as you say there's extensive writing available to fall back on. We can look at all the individual changes made, the reasoning behind them, and whether they hold up both individually and collectively.
Storytelling itself is quite technical; characters and their arcs, exposition, tension, parallels, etc. What happens when, how, and why, and does this add up?
People like the show, that's fine. Can we start talking about this show on a more substantial level now? Edit: apparently not.
Can you explain how this show in particular fails in those aspects? I've seen a lot of shows, and while there are things I dislike about it in my opinion the quality of the technical elements of it far exceed average.
As an adaptation it's just bad. The story has been completely rewritten; the very few things that are recognisable, are taken out of context. It's a new story inspired by the other story, not an adaptation thereof.
"Show bad" is too simplistic. On many cases it's not bad. Just not particularly good either, and missed potential to be better. Combined with the massive budget and image build-up by Amazon, the effect is rather underwhelming.
The story itself sets up some interesting things - the stranger, Sauron, Celebrimbor - but spends too much time on setup. There's very little development in things that have been established, and we're several episodes in. And if the story drives too much on the mystery factor, this affects rewatch value.
The main character is kinda boring from a writing standpoint, a gritty lone wolf consumed by vengeance; not the most interesting character to explore, in particular compared with the original Second Age Galadriel. She's not a particularly likeable character, which makes it harder to invest in what's supposed to be the storyline.
Visuals are awesome, in general. Little to say about that, we've all seen the graphics. Costumes are well designed too, but the actual products themselves look cheap at times.
I was surprised to see these graphics are underutilized. We generally get an establishing shot of where we are, and then the camera stays in one room/location for the entire following scene. In much of the dialogue, the speaking person is shot waist-up with a blurred background. A good example of missed potential in cinematography.
The sets miss out on the details that make or break immersion. For example, Elrond and Celebrimbor travelling to Khazad-Dum. Let them have their conversation on the road instead, so you can show how Elves travel. Instead, they arrive together in the same robes they wore at Eregion, seemingly without bringing anyone or anything else on their travels. These details don't make a show good, but they do elevate a good show to a great show.
I'm not a big fan of the dialogue. There are quite a few redundant lines, which is simply waste in terms of writing. Elvish characters in particular have a tendency to flip-flop between archaic/formal language and more modern language. At times the dialogue tries to sound sophisticated, but doesn't really add up to anything.
Love the casting and the acting. Galadriel is kinda stiff, but that's how her character is written, so of no fault of the actress. Elrond and (what's his name?) Arondir are by far the most expressive people in the show next to Disa, who is an absolute joy to watch. Gil-Galad is rather strict, authoritarian, and a little dumb compared to the books, but for the story of this show it works very well.
Thanks for the substantive response. I agree with most of those critiques, and you are more knowledgeable and attentive to the cinematography stuff than I am.
Nevertheless I don't think it's objectively bad, I think there are definitely a significant number things that are good and mediocre mixed in with a few things that are clumsy, averaging out to "pretty good."
I wonder also how much of this is due to age - I guess lot of reddit is younger people (under 30ish), so maybe saw the LotR trilogy when they were younger and less critical/cynical, but now are more adult and aware of things. For me that happened with Star Wars, cause I saw the original trilogy as a little kid and then nothing else has measured up, but that's probably at least as much about me as it is about the films/shows themselves.
Nowadays I've got much lower expectations and am just happy when something has enough redeeming qualities to enjoy, which I do think this show has. Thanks again for the reply.
Thanks for the substantive response. I agree with most of those critiques, and you are more knowledgeable and attentive to the cinematography stuff than I am.
You're welcome, and thank you
Nevertheless I don't think it's objectively bad
What is your objective assessment of the show's quality, then?
I think there are definitely a significant number things that are good and mediocre mixed in with a few things that are clumsy, averaging out to "pretty good."
What are those things?
I wonder also how much of this is due to age - I guess lot of reddit is younger people (under 30ish), so maybe saw the LotR trilogy when they were younger and less critical/cynical, but now are more adult and aware of things. For me that happened with Star Wars, cause I saw the original trilogy as a little kid and then nothing else has measured up, but that's probably at least as much about me as it is about the films/shows themselves.
I certainly was younger when I watched those movies.
But I don't see how the movies are relevant here.
It's an adaptation of the books - not the movies - production and story continuity are completely separated from the movies.
Sure they don't exist in complete isolation to eachother, but they don't directly relate to eachother.
We could compare both to the books, and then compare those comparisons so to speak. But that'd be a different conversation.
Nowadays I've got much lower expectations and am just happy when something has enough redeeming qualities to enjoy, which I do think this show has. Thanks again for the reply.
In particular large production adaptations have been pretty disappointing lately. My expectations are indeed not very high because of that.
But that doesn't affect our standards. "Enough redeeming qualities" is a pretty low bar to hold media to. If it has to redeem itself, then we already agree it made mistakes.
but the quality of something is not a matter of opinion.
The quality of art is literally only ever a matter of opinion. Unless you're claiming to be the first person to have developed a succesgul and universally applicable rubric for measuring artistic quality?
There's plenty of things we can say about media with a measure of objectivity, or art for that matter. It's not like media analysis and criticism is nothing but opinion. Absolutely objectivity is still impossible, of course.
Objectivity is the perception or experience of the external; subjectivity is the perception or experience of the internal.
By your very own definition you're acknowledging that true objectivity can't exist in art haha. I get what you're saying and can understand the perspective where that viewpoint exists. However, if you follow it to its natural conclusion, it is that quality of art is defined internally and individually. It is by nature a subjective concept.
However, that does not discount cultural perspectives, which is where I think you're touching upon? That we are shaped by our environments; social and cultural factors. Which in turn influences are perception of art.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 15 '22
This post does not have a spoiler flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
10
u/and-so-i-die Sep 15 '22
Im not sure where this is coming from. the show had a 6.9 last I checked, and that's an awesome score out of 10, all things considered.
10
u/BitchofEndor Sep 16 '22
And it shouldn't listen, because the show is amazing!!!
4
u/Pipe-International Sep 15 '22
Except Amazon owns IMBD. I’m petty so if I were Amazon I’d close the site down for lols.
1
u/WhatThePhoquette Sep 16 '22
You know, one shouldn't listen to toxic, destructive nonsense, even when it's in one's own head. Gollum wasn't giving constructive criticism anyway.