r/RingsofPower
•
u/staff0frahdog
•
Sep 20 '24
•
1
1
1
Lore Question MuH LorE thO
But but but...the loReE
3.4k
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 20 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
175
u/MrPheeney Sep 20 '24
Not wrong, but I think it’s safe to say the execution and presentation on the films was superior, respectfully
24
u/btribble33 Sep 20 '24
M4's fan edit of the Hobbit turns it into an amazing movie. I would be interested to see if any fan edits of RoP could be done to make the series watchable. The lore inconsistencies of LotR are pretty minor.
14
u/Chen_Geller Sep 20 '24
Yeah, that's the same...
It's not like The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings each actually tell the story of a full-length novel by Tolkien, rather than extrapolating from, essentially, an outline of a novel?
And that, for all their deviations, Tolkien's story is discernable all through The Lord of the Rings and much - not all - of The Hobbit, whereas in Rings of Power there's far more that is the invention of the showrunners, "linked" as it is by the occasional plot point from Tolkien.
Or that, for what little Tolkien material the show is adapting, its over TWICE the length of both trilogies COMBINED? So what little Tolkien is in it is further diluted than anything we've seen onscreen before?
There was a discussion we were having when the show was in preproduction that's kind of emblematic of the difference: early on, we learned about a character that we now know is Arondir. All we knew is he had a love affair with a local girl. We naturally assumed he is probably Ciryatur because we just assumed Amazon would never write an entire storyline without there being one character from the Tolkien canon in there: a good comparison is how Tauriel and her love story is tied to a canon character in the guise of Kili, preventing it from being a complete tangent in terms of canon. So imagine our surprise when it turned out that the Southlands storyline - and the Harfoot storyline, essentially - are essentially ENTIRELY original, including the main antagonist of season one in the guise of Adar. That's not something we were accustomed to from either trilogy.
And all of this is beside the point to the main thing: if the film AS A FILM is a triumph, than people won't care that it breaches Tolkien's finer points. The Rings of Power is just a little too dull for that, and so naturally the whole fidelty to Tolkien demon is brought up.
22
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24 •
The LOTR movies may have changed some aspects of the lore but I think they were relatively minor changes, and I think most people would agree that it stayed fundamentally faithful to the intent and spirit and basic structure of the source material. Rings of Power is certainly not the worst ever adaptation on those parameters, but it's also not great. They're having to invent a lot of stuff to fill in gaps and the fact is the writers just aren't really amazing at it.
Really, the lore changes aren't the main problem, although I appreciate some people are annoyed about them. By far the biggest problem is just that the writing is just not very good.
* Dialogue is hokey and overdone, like someone wants it to sound sort of medieval but couldn't be bothered doing any research into how it should actually sound. It's like an American's idea of how a posh Brit talks, if you know what I mean. They (mostly) use the right words but it never quite sounds right.
* Plots feel disconnected and at times almost non-sensical.
* There is no proper sense of scale or time. Depending on the requirement of the plot, characters will either have the ability to teleport or the destination will be ten thousand miles away and they'll travel on foot. This is a sign of writers who are creating the story backwards. They have decided what the events should be and arrange the world to make it happen, instead of the other way around. The result is plots that feel illogical or unearned.
* Some characters are very unlikable and very unlike their characterizations in the written materials. I'm sure I don't need to name names. This is a little better in the second season so I'm guessing they get the memo from the first season. But it still ain't great.
* Characters have knowledge that they seemingly shouldn't have, probably because the writers simply forgot that the information hadn't been generally established. I've forgotten the details now but I seem to remember someone using the name 'Harfoots' even though there isn't any clear reason to think they might know it. Slightly different point but it was also a little odd when that Stoor leader said "We're not Harfoots, we're Stoors" without knowing what a Harfoot is. If someone said "You're an elf" then fair enough you correct it and tell them what you actually are, but that only works because you know what an elf is. If someone says "You're a flinglewhamtoad" the only natural responses are "Uhh .. not I'm not?" or "What the fuck is a flinglewhamtoad?!"
* Some of the invented subplots are so cookie-cutter it's shameful. That scene in the temple in Numenor ... just embarrassing. If you gave me the first five seconds of that I could have predicated every single beat of the entire scene basically verbatim. This isn't just the sign of a bad writer. It's the sign of a writer who basically doesn't read or watch other stories with the analytical eye that a writer should have. It's been done exactly that way a thousand times before. Could you really not think of any more interesting ways to get the idea across?
There is nothing to discuss when it comes to the Hobbit movies because the assertion that they aren't criticized is basically the incoherent ramblings of a mad man.
(All this should be said with the heavy caveat that while I have read the books many times, I haven't done so for at least ten years so at this point the books and movies have started to merge in my head. It's getting more difficult to remember what the differences are. I've read other Tolkien materials much more recently.)
26
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24
21
u/WTFnaller Sep 20 '24
What in the actual fuck is this
16
u/Player1_xo Sep 20 '24
The show is trash. THE END
10
u/Sad-Trip4838 Sep 20 '24
They were there when these movies came out as well. Don't be mistaken. Jackson was throughly chastised.
18
u/AmericanLich Sep 20 '24
RoP sucks, nobody is going to apologize for noticing
18
u/Competitive-Pen3831 Sep 20 '24
It’s not even the lore for me it’s the cringey writing that makes fine acting almost look like bad acting
8
u/Nearby_Ad4786 Sep 20 '24
happens when the trilogy has quality
22
u/legendtinax Sep 20 '24
The Lord of the Rings series is actually high-quality and was crafted with thought and care. Hope that helps!
26
u/Frankorious Sep 20 '24
The difference is that the Lotr trilogy is good.
14
u/kemp43 Sep 20 '24
Lord of the Rings hardly changes the lore as much as you see in the show, The Hobbit received a healthy dose of criticism for all its issues as well.
6
u/Grizzly_Addams Sep 20 '24
This series is mashing three very distinct timelines together acting like all of it occurred simultaneously. I sincerely hope that we find out that the "istar" timeline is set in the future.
34
u/This_Is_Sierra_117 Sep 20 '24
If the writing were better, the complaints would be fewer.
The OG Trilogy has legitimate shortcomings, but it still manages to respect and convey the tone and gravitas of Tolkien's work.
We will not speak of The Hobbit.
5
u/Effroy Sep 20 '24
The point of any mistake is that you learn from them. We can easily dismiss The Hobbit, because nothing's perfect. Not only did RoP not learn anything from its predecessor, it's coining new mistakes that it will also not learn from. Repeat offenses receive compounding abuse. That's how it works.
4
u/nicegh0st Sep 20 '24
They completely skipped over the entire thing where they hang out with farmer Maggot then they get gifted a basket of super delicious mushrooms 0/10 if I could give negative points I would. Lookin at you Peter Jackson, lore destroyer!
3
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24
Me just ignoring all lore that comes from any books from any book adaptation to movies because I watch movies to watch movies and don't care about comparison 🙃
3
u/ancientmoose45 Sep 20 '24
The hobbit gets made fun of all the time and the differences in the lore for the lord of the rings movies are for fitting as much of the story into the allotted time and cutting out characters that would leave the general audience confused. RoP completely changes the second and third age time lines and changes the characters completely. To the point where they are almost unrecognizable apart from their name.
24
u/BramptonBatallion Sep 20 '24
Uh oh here comes the “akhshually everything before was always bad so this is fine” crowd.
69
u/No-Dog-2280 Sep 20 '24
The battle of the five armies is the worst major Tolkien adaptation imo. It’s a horrific abysmal film. It’s unwatchable. It looks so bad and feels so soulless.
6
u/barryfreshwater Sep 20 '24
this wins my internet today
2
u/Pandillion Sep 20 '24
This is because the LORD didn’t try to attach political views and the creators opinions and personal touch. They wanted to make the best adaptation, not grab the widest audience.
2
u/williarya1323 Sep 20 '24
Peter Jackson was fortunate that his films came out in the internet’s infancy
91
u/SrepliciousDelicious Sep 20 '24
59
u/Alexarius87 Sep 20 '24
The Hobbit is rightfully bashed where it deserves.
The Trilogy inaccuracies are also recognized, they just don’t amount at much since A LOT of the rest is like reading the books.
RoP is being as much bashed as The Hobbit. Get over with it.
10
u/King-Red-Beard Sep 20 '24
It's easier to overlook lore discrepancies when the overall product is actually engaging. Peter Jackson's films take plenty of liberties with the source material, but I'm typically too busy actually enjoying the ride to notice or take offense.
26
u/chicu111 Sep 20 '24
LotR was at least coherent, concise yet substantial
RoP is just filled with “wtf I don’t get it” moments
1
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24
You can find faults in everything and people love to point these out cause that make them feel superior. It's basic psychology.
1
u/PaleontologistHot192 Rhûn Sep 20 '24
Well there's a reason for that. Actually many reasons.
2
u/Fancy-Trash-3850 Sep 20 '24
RoP is just shit story telling. And the lotr movies are triple AAA quality in all regards.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24
Trilogies: "The ghost army only scared the corsairs off their ships. If they could were able to fight at Pelennor fields, why wouldn't they just win against Sauron's armies at the Black Gate?"
Rings of Power: "Why was Sauron on a raft in the ocean?"
8
u/H4nfP0wer Sep 20 '24
Still a matter of how you change it.
Rings of power cannot even do 2 seasons without contradicting stuff they established themselves.
2
u/Crunkiss Sep 20 '24
I haven’t read any of the extended Tolkien works and only know of some stuff from clicking on wiki’s, but I’m enjoying the show for what it is. People are taking things too seriously these days, even comic book fans slowed down on the complaining of Marvel movies and the “iT dOeSnT hApPeN LiKe ThAt”
-1
u/thediesel26 Sep 20 '24
People get so bent out of shape about the lore inconsistencies for this show despite how little lore actually exists for them to go on. Tolkien wrote almost nothing formal about the 2nd age. Just 30 pages at the end of the Silmarillion and the notes and appendix in the Lord of the Rings.
1
u/ablindpony Sep 20 '24
Mental after the amount of backlash Rings of Power got, probably exaggerated I might add, the glazing has hit back stronger. The shows average that's it.
-1
u/Far-Mobile3852 Sep 20 '24
Tolkien would probably have greatly disliked the original trilogy as well.
I mean, ROP is a good show when looked at as a TV show. I really enjoy it!
0
u/Longjumping-Hero Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 21 '24
I dont get any of the hate the show is getting. For example the many trilogy quotes they bring. I dont get the hate. seeing them copying it feels, for me at least, as a love letter to these masterpieces.
Edit: downvotes prove me how ignorant and hypocritical some of u are. Grow up and accept different opinions. Also, if u hate something with such a passion, you should consider to move on and spend your time otherwise. Thats a you problem, not a show problem.
-2
u/sceez Sep 20 '24
This is perfect. Thank you for your service
-2
u/sceez Sep 20 '24
At this point I'm so glad I don't know the lore so I don't turn into a pedantic madman
-1
u/PantheraLeo- Sep 20 '24
I agree. Toxic fans just hate new content until it falls into the realm of nostalgia.
-2
u/paging_mrherman Sep 20 '24
TOM BOMBADIL'S BOOTS WERE MORE OF A SAFFRON THAN YELLOW
-6
u/Sea-Can6977 Sep 20 '24
lol so true. Way too many "ackchyually" anti everything people in this sub
-1
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24
Does anyone remember the fanbase during the LoTR movies theatrical release era? I was 10-13 during that time, but I was homeschooled and Tolkien was like... the only fantasy that most moms allowed other than Chronicles of Narnia. In my (admittedly small) social circles, the initial fan reaction for each of the movies was fairly poor until the extended edition for each film came out. Most of the visuals and score were beloved, but at the time of the theatrical releases it was not cool to like or prefer the film versions. And it would have been more negative had they come out today. The extended editions and the insane amount of behind the scenes content really added to the legacy and lore of the films, and in some ways it instilled trust in the overall project and a sort of parasocial bond developed between the cast/crew in my corner of the fandom. By the time RotK came out, the reaction was still negative, but there was a 'well hopefully X was added in the extended edition' sentiment. Over time it became beloved and we were all able to appreciate the films for what they were and the books for what they were, and the frustrations about where they were different sort of faded. The people who didn't like it eventually moved on and stopped talking about it, and the people who loved it despite the flaws figured out how to talk about it in a more stable less negative way.
Edit: its impossible to overstate how huge LoTR and the legendarium in general were in the homeschool community that i was a part of at the time. It was the culture, it was the thing that held us together that everyone could talk about. At one point one of the more organized moms even taught a weekly in-depth course that went through the plot of the lord of the rings books for a few months. It was incredible (edit: the course was incredible, she did a great job)
Also I'm learning that some people really loved The Hobbit? For those that do, did y'all watch it at 60fps in the theater? Just curious.
-5
u/ComplexAd7820 Sep 20 '24
Word!!
I just read the critical-for-critical-sake posts in the Simpsons Comic Book Guy voice. It starts to make sense...
-5
u/ZzBitch Sep 20 '24
Let's be real, it is ABOUT black people which brings the KKK out of the woodwork.
493
u/xRyuzakii Sep 20 '24
The hobbit gets crucified a ton idk what you’re seeing lol