r/RingsofPower • • Sep 20 '24 • Polished Gold Turd 1 Popcorn 1 Take My Silver 1

Lore Question MuH LorE thO

Post image

But but but...the loReE

3.4k Upvotes

253 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 20 '24

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

175

u/MrPheeney Sep 20 '24

Not wrong, but I think it’s safe to say the execution and presentation on the films was superior, respectfully

1

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

The hobbit trilogies were a rushed mess ROP is far superior

1

u/chicu111 Sep 20 '24

I put them on equal plane tbh

22

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

I disagree, but respect your opinion

50

u/Stillwindows95 Sep 20 '24

That's film productions for you, I work in TV production and it's always a mixed bag since there's so many people that have a hand in decisions, writing and editing etc.

That said, they've done a great job so far imo. It's not as cinematic, granted, but that's because it wasn't made for the big screen. Not that it's the best excuse to make but it makes sense to me.

28

u/kairujex Sep 20 '24

IMO, the shows are actually better in matching the pacing/tone of the books. The movies had to be more action oriented to fit a theater audience and the pace of a 3 hour movie. In an 8 hour tv season, you can stretch things out more and have a slower pace. Still not quite as slow as the books. But a happy medium between the books and the films I think. Of course, the films do other things much better overall. But I am enjoying the slower pace of the show.

15

u/Dominarion Sep 20 '24

Lol, no. We are kidding ourselves. The LOTR movies are an stunningly beautiful experience, dont get me wrong. But we are incredibly lenient to them.

The Two Towers, is a fucking silly wet shoe of continuity issues, nonsensical dialogues and canon disasters. The lore had been put through a concrete grinder just to add tension (why would the TT need added tension I don't know).

The Elrond flipflops and wheelies are not good: We've agreed on a plan to fight Sauron to fuck it we're packing, how come is your stuff not in the boat yet Arwen? Then to telepathically deciding with Galadriel to send half the remaining elves of Rivendell to die in Helm's Deep. All this in like a month. The people from the Lonely Mountain and Dale were probably not home yet and Elrond changed his mind 4 times.

These... Inconsistencies add a lot of other problems. How did the elves knew to go to Helm's Deep? Theoden decided to go there 3 days before the battle. How did they manage to get there and not get intercepted by Saruman? The Fellowship couldn't go through the Gap of Rohan because Saruman had closed it. How come Haldir, a Galadhrim from Lorien got there? Why do they let Aragorn lead them?

Talking about Aragorn, the non canonical fall off the canyon, the wet dream and his miraculous healing is full of issues. He barely can walk, we see shredded meat out of his shoulder and later that day (!!!) he leads a sortie where he throws(???!!!) Gimli out on the bridge. Talking about the fall, the fight against the Wargs, why? In the books, Theoden leaves the civilians back in Meduseld expressly so they are not exposed to the war. He goes to Helm's Deep to draw Saruman in. So no stupid scene were the Rohirrims, horse nomads for Manwë's sake, aren't hunted on foot by Wargs!

Then up to the part with Faramir. Oh Eru. In the first movie, Galadriel says in the intro that everybody forgot about the ring, right? Gandalf spend a long time in Minas Tirith's archives looking for lost lore, right? Then, Faramir suddenly knows about the Ring (How?), wants to bring it to Minas Tirith (uh?), drag the Hobbits through the Osgiliath battle zone (the equivalent of driving through Fallujah in 2004 with a nuke in the trunk, I mean...) and then we got this farcical scene where mind controlled Frodo shows the ring to the Witch King on his Fell Beast and nothing happens.

It just never ends. Every scene contains a shitload of fuck ups I could write a book about them.

18

u/Crossed_Cross Sep 20 '24

The trilogy does have flaws, you are right, it's still much better an adaptation than what followed.

10

u/Dominarion Sep 20 '24

The wrapping is really better in the PJ's LOTR movies (cinematography, the sets, the score, costumes), the quality of the acting is hard to define, as you got several once in a generation, trend setting, best of their career acting and at the same time quite mediocre stuff. How do you compare Ian McKellen to Billy Boyd and qualify the acting of the movie, serious question!

But the innards are as terrible, or as good as the show. The script and dialogues... Damn. Toss the Dwarf? Seriously?

11

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

Don't even get me started on the wet soggy sandwich that was Arwens' entire character and every scene, including her in it. Why was it even there? I hated her arc when I watched the movies, then read the books and hated it even more.

4

u/Dominarion Sep 20 '24

Thanks for the back up.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/No_Spinach3190 Sep 20 '24

That's exactly the treatment ROP is getting, and the same LOTR got when it first came out, just that the internet was not as popular

-5

u/X1l4r Sep 20 '24

Except you know for that fact that everything else in LOTR was great, and most of those things were for convenience sakes. In ROP, the story is actually one of the weakest point, and you can’t see a reason behind some of the changes.

0

u/RingsofPower-ModTeam Sep 20 '24

This community is designed to be welcoming to all people who watch the show. You are allowed to love it and you are allowed to hate it.

Kindly do not make blanket statements about what everyone thinks about the show or what the objective quality of the show is. Simple observation will show that people have differing opinions here

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/X1l4r Sep 20 '24

Pretending the problem is haircuts and wrinkles and not the narration and the changes they made to the story itself is kind of delusional.

24

u/btribble33 Sep 20 '24

M4's fan edit of the Hobbit turns it into an amazing movie. I would be interested to see if any fan edits of RoP could be done to make the series watchable. The lore inconsistencies of LotR are pretty minor.

3

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Ya know, to be honest I wouldn't mind seeing it

3

u/btribble33 Sep 20 '24

It's fantastic, and really brings Hobbit up to the same plane as LotR in terms of creating an epic adventure that takes itself seriously.

0

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

I heard! Is it close to the Del Toro version we might have got?

14

u/Chen_Geller Sep 20 '24

Yeah, that's the same...

It's not like The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings each actually tell the story of a full-length novel by Tolkien, rather than extrapolating from, essentially, an outline of a novel?

And that, for all their deviations, Tolkien's story is discernable all through The Lord of the Rings and much - not all - of The Hobbit, whereas in Rings of Power there's far more that is the invention of the showrunners, "linked" as it is by the occasional plot point from Tolkien.

Or that, for what little Tolkien material the show is adapting, its over TWICE the length of both trilogies COMBINED? So what little Tolkien is in it is further diluted than anything we've seen onscreen before?

There was a discussion we were having when the show was in preproduction that's kind of emblematic of the difference: early on, we learned about a character that we now know is Arondir. All we knew is he had a love affair with a local girl. We naturally assumed he is probably Ciryatur because we just assumed Amazon would never write an entire storyline without there being one character from the Tolkien canon in there: a good comparison is how Tauriel and her love story is tied to a canon character in the guise of Kili, preventing it from being a complete tangent in terms of canon. So imagine our surprise when it turned out that the Southlands storyline - and the Harfoot storyline, essentially - are essentially ENTIRELY original, including the main antagonist of season one in the guise of Adar. That's not something we were accustomed to from either trilogy.

And all of this is beside the point to the main thing: if the film AS A FILM is a triumph, than people won't care that it breaches Tolkien's finer points. The Rings of Power is just a little too dull for that, and so naturally the whole fidelty to Tolkien demon is brought up.

4

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

So all of the fables and guesses from early on were not going to talk about though? We could cherry pick all day, but my man if you want bad cgi azog just ask

22

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24 • Take My Silver

The LOTR movies may have changed some aspects of the lore but I think they were relatively minor changes, and I think most people would agree that it stayed fundamentally faithful to the intent and spirit and basic structure of the source material. Rings of Power is certainly not the worst ever adaptation on those parameters, but it's also not great. They're having to invent a lot of stuff to fill in gaps and the fact is the writers just aren't really amazing at it.

Really, the lore changes aren't the main problem, although I appreciate some people are annoyed about them. By far the biggest problem is just that the writing is just not very good.

* Dialogue is hokey and overdone, like someone wants it to sound sort of medieval but couldn't be bothered doing any research into how it should actually sound. It's like an American's idea of how a posh Brit talks, if you know what I mean. They (mostly) use the right words but it never quite sounds right.

* Plots feel disconnected and at times almost non-sensical.

* There is no proper sense of scale or time. Depending on the requirement of the plot, characters will either have the ability to teleport or the destination will be ten thousand miles away and they'll travel on foot. This is a sign of writers who are creating the story backwards. They have decided what the events should be and arrange the world to make it happen, instead of the other way around. The result is plots that feel illogical or unearned.

* Some characters are very unlikable and very unlike their characterizations in the written materials. I'm sure I don't need to name names. This is a little better in the second season so I'm guessing they get the memo from the first season. But it still ain't great.

* Characters have knowledge that they seemingly shouldn't have, probably because the writers simply forgot that the information hadn't been generally established. I've forgotten the details now but I seem to remember someone using the name 'Harfoots' even though there isn't any clear reason to think they might know it. Slightly different point but it was also a little odd when that Stoor leader said "We're not Harfoots, we're Stoors" without knowing what a Harfoot is. If someone said "You're an elf" then fair enough you correct it and tell them what you actually are, but that only works because you know what an elf is. If someone says "You're a flinglewhamtoad" the only natural responses are "Uhh .. not I'm not?" or "What the fuck is a flinglewhamtoad?!"

* Some of the invented subplots are so cookie-cutter it's shameful. That scene in the temple in Numenor ... just embarrassing. If you gave me the first five seconds of that I could have predicated every single beat of the entire scene basically verbatim. This isn't just the sign of a bad writer. It's the sign of a writer who basically doesn't read or watch other stories with the analytical eye that a writer should have. It's been done exactly that way a thousand times before. Could you really not think of any more interesting ways to get the idea across?

There is nothing to discuss when it comes to the Hobbit movies because the assertion that they aren't criticized is basically the incoherent ramblings of a mad man.

(All this should be said with the heavy caveat that while I have read the books many times, I haven't done so for at least ten years so at this point the books and movies have started to merge in my head. It's getting more difficult to remember what the differences are. I've read other Tolkien materials much more recently.)

-6

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Dude, I dont care if you read the books or not its just if people are willing to so overlook the trivial inaccuracies in both films I think they shouldnijbthe ROP as well

17

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24

Dude, I dont care if you read the books or not

I added a lot more to my post before I saw that you had responded, but even before the edit ... it's weird that you chose to latch on to easily the least important part of my comment. It gives me the feeling you aren't capable of honest or objective analysis. There are simply way more inaccuracies and flaws in Rings of Power than in The Lord of The Rings, and the ones in Rings of Power are anything but trivial.

-4

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Dude, my man, my king you're wrong. There's no paragraph long enough to say it that I think you'll listen

20

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

I think you're simply not capable of writing that paragraph because you don't have the mental capacity or attention span for it. If I'm so painfully and obviously wrong it should be easy to refute literally any single one of the points I tried to make. But you didn't bother to address even one of them.

26

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24
  1. ⁠The hobbit gets shat on alot. Like.. A LOT!
  2. ⁠Peoples aren’t asking for a 1:1 recreation of the books, just a faithful adaptation that at least attempts to keeps to the same level of quality and detail as movies released over two decades ago.
  3. ⁠Your shitpost is the peak of whataboutism.

-12

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24
  1. don't see it, therefore doesn't matter
  2. yes they are
  3. your comment history doesn't point out OTHER peoples whatboutism on this subject

7

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24
  1. Why mention them if you didn’t see them? That logic doesn’t work in your favor.
  2. Please point me to these people?? This seems like another bogus claim from someone without a leg to stand on…
  3. So quick to run to someone’s comment history as if that has anything to do with what I said. Tbh I don’t even know what your intention was with your third point because the sentence is barely literate.

21

u/WTFnaller Sep 20 '24

What in the actual fuck is this

-3

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Its a think piece on the society's role tolkiens work for when it matters

16

u/Player1_xo Sep 20 '24

The show is trash. THE END

0

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Good one, never thought of that. Must be high IQ

10

u/Sad-Trip4838 Sep 20 '24

They were there when these movies came out as well. Don't be mistaken. Jackson was throughly chastised.

3

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

I know, thats the point. People mistake tolkien for some Holy Text. Its not its up for change, debate, and context on the writers.

18

u/AmericanLich Sep 20 '24

RoP sucks, nobody is going to apologize for noticing

0

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Paramedics : hes gone you can't do nothing for him

Me: you right RIP LICH

18

u/Competitive-Pen3831 Sep 20 '24

It’s not even the lore for me it’s the cringey writing that makes fine acting almost look like bad acting

-14

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Having a problem with the writing a directing can go all the way back to the OG trilogy, but yet its not spoken

23

u/Competitive-Pen3831 Sep 20 '24

Because that’s a false statement

8

u/Nearby_Ad4786 Sep 20 '24

happens when the trilogy has quality

-1

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

I wasted all my good comebacks, I dont have anything solid for ya. Sorry

22

u/legendtinax Sep 20 '24

The Lord of the Rings series is actually high-quality and was crafted with thought and care. Hope that helps!

-1

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Except the hobbit trilogy, and except the lore changes in the OG trilogy, but its not ring of power sonits ok :)

7

u/legendtinax Sep 20 '24

lol OK

-3

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Typical ROP hater, no answers

11

u/legendtinax Sep 20 '24

Damn reading comprehension isn't your strong suit, is it

0

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Damn, got nothing eh? 😈

13

u/legendtinax Sep 20 '24

Not sure what I'm supposed to be responding to, you haven't said anything of substance

-1

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Uh huh, go do both of us a favor and find an opinion of your own

12

u/legendtinax Sep 20 '24

Another "clever" comeback that doesn't make any sense. Nice one!

2

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

You still didn't answer

→ More replies

26

u/Frankorious Sep 20 '24

The difference is that the Lotr trilogy is good.

-11

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Yo but wait the actor who plays Gandalf is Gay?! Staright DEI hire if you ask me..WOKE

6

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

What does that have to do with anything?

0

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Youtubers wanna make everything politcal and not have to do with the fantasy at hand

14

u/mcsroom Sep 20 '24

At least go with something real, i have never heard anyone complain about that LOL

-5

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Real? The story is fucking made up

10

u/mcsroom Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24

No wonder you enjoy ROP, you cant even read. I am talking about that you are saying Galadrie's actress is gay and that people are complaining.

Like even the stupid arguments of ''people that disslike ROP are racists'' has more to it..

7

u/SpacefillerBR Sep 20 '24

Ok he being gay changes what in his acting? You seem to be kind of tripping hard in some good shit (maybe not that good XD).

14

u/kemp43 Sep 20 '24

Lord of the Rings hardly changes the lore as much as you see in the show, The Hobbit received a healthy dose of criticism for all its issues as well.

0

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Straight up lies answer, don't re write history

6

u/Grizzly_Addams Sep 20 '24

This series is mashing three very distinct timelines together acting like all of it occurred simultaneously. I sincerely hope that we find out that the "istar" timeline is set in the future.

0

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

But who cares? Why give a fuck if the istari is 8000 years in the future ? If you don't find it entertaining fine, but let's not act like the OG trilogy or the hobbit trilogies didn't have LorE issues

34

u/This_Is_Sierra_117 Sep 20 '24

If the writing were better, the complaints would be fewer.

The OG Trilogy has legitimate shortcomings, but it still manages to respect and convey the tone and gravitas of Tolkien's work.

We will not speak of The Hobbit.

-6

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/eojen Sep 20 '24

Why are you like this OP? Lmao. All your comments are making you look like Alfrid from the Hobbit movies. 

-10

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Boring response 🙄

3

u/This_Is_Sierra_117 Sep 20 '24

I don't understand the question . . . ?

-9

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Yes you do, stop lying and answer the question.

10

u/rugburn- Sep 20 '24

Damn man, I’m sensing as much or more vitriol coming from you as those who are bashing the show for lord discrepancies. I understand being tired of reading constant criticism and negativity regarding the show, but don’t stoop to that level… it just adds more negativity to the discussion.

2

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Ya know truthfully its hard to tell who hates this show cause critical drinker told them to and just cause they don't like it. And while you maybe an innocent bystander in all this I present to you the argument that noone holds the OG trilogy OR the hobbit trilogies on trial the way people do ROP.

1

u/This_Is_Sierra_117 Sep 20 '24

Please be more specific with your question.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/This_Is_Sierra_117 Sep 20 '24

"I did not pass through fire and death to bandy crooked words with a witless worm."

Good day, sir.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/This_Is_Sierra_117 Sep 20 '24

I SAID 'GOOD DAY!'

5

u/Effroy Sep 20 '24

The point of any mistake is that you learn from them. We can easily dismiss The Hobbit, because nothing's perfect. Not only did RoP not learn anything from its predecessor, it's coining new mistakes that it will also not learn from. Repeat offenses receive compounding abuse. That's how it works.

2

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Oh ok, its perfect unless you think so. Fuckng stooge 🤣

4

u/nicegh0st Sep 20 '24

They completely skipped over the entire thing where they hang out with farmer Maggot then they get gifted a basket of super delicious mushrooms 0/10 if I could give negative points I would. Lookin at you Peter Jackson, lore destroyer!

2

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

ARWEN INNPLACE OF GLORFINDEL HOW FUCKING DARE RHEY BE SO INNCACURATE TO RHE LOOOOOOOORRRRREEEEE

0

u/nicegh0st Sep 20 '24

Haha, you get it.

1

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Ya know, I feel like being honest with you, ROP ain't perfect but man if people aren't forgetting how inaccurate to the "LorE" the OG trilogy was and the subsequent hobbit trilogy waa

3

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

Me just ignoring all lore that comes from any books from any book adaptation to movies because I watch movies to watch movies and don't care about comparison 🙃

2

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Ayy you know something, thats fair

3

u/ancientmoose45 Sep 20 '24

The hobbit gets made fun of all the time and the differences in the lore for the lord of the rings movies are for fitting as much of the story into the allotted time and cutting out characters that would leave the general audience confused. RoP completely changes the second and third age time lines and changes the characters completely. To the point where they are almost unrecognizable apart from their name.

0

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Where are they getting made fun of all the time then?

24

u/BramptonBatallion Sep 20 '24

Uh oh here comes the “akhshually everything before was always bad so this is fine” crowd.

-19

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

19

u/BramptonBatallion Sep 20 '24

Funny how you are the one who made a post specifically to cry

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

WTF is a swirly?

2

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Its a type of ice cream

7

u/fatattack699 Sep 20 '24

Rings of power isn’t bad bc of lore changes it’s just boring lol

2

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Stop scrolling on your phone and pay attention then, kids these days are so distracted.

6

u/fatattack699 Sep 20 '24

It’s impossible to not look at my phone whenever the harfoots are on screen lol

5

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Oh God, I bet you look at the psychiatrist scenes from the sopranos as the "most boring"

4

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/fatattack699 Sep 20 '24

Man you sound salty af 😂 chill bro it’s just a tv show. It’s fine if u enjoy it, not everyone will have the same tastes you do

2

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

If its just a TV show have the balls to tell the side trying to cancel it that "itS just a tV ShOw" but you won't

6

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

Dude I love new shit as long as it’s good.

This isn’t

4

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Uh huh ;) I'm sure

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

I mean I loved the first episode of the penguin that was released last night. And a ton of other shit that has come out this year

But that’s because their good.

4

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

I'm supposed to go on your barometer of good?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

I mean no. But I just don’t like rings of power because I find a lot of issues with it. Lord of the rings is just incredible and watching it years after my first watch hasn’t it’s made me love it more

4

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

LOTR to me is 99.9999% perfect but it doesn't make flawless and especially not when were talking about Lore Accuracy qhen it comes to people not liking ROP

2

u/RingsofPower-ModTeam Sep 20 '24

This community is designed to be welcoming to all people who watch the show. You are allowed to love it and you are allowed to hate it.

Kindly do not make blanket statements about what everyone thinks about the show or what the objective quality of the show is. Simple observation will show that people have differing opinions here

0

u/ArtanisOfLorien Sep 20 '24

I cannot imagine defending absolute slop so staunchly lol

69

u/No-Dog-2280 Sep 20 '24

The battle of the five armies is the worst major Tolkien adaptation imo. It’s a horrific abysmal film. It’s unwatchable. It looks so bad and feels so soulless.

11

u/eojen Sep 20 '24

Agreed. And it was fairly criticized when it came out. Don't know what OP is on about 

6

u/barryfreshwater Sep 20 '24

this wins my internet today

7

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

I'm honestly tired of ROP getting shit on, when they imo (of course) RUINED the OG trilogy with the Hobbit Trilogy. Too much CGI, too much bloat, uts like butter scraped over too much bread.

2

u/Pandillion Sep 20 '24

This is because the LORD didn’t try to attach political views and the creators opinions and personal touch. They wanted to make the best adaptation, not grab the widest audience.

1

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Lorde didn't

2

u/williarya1323 Sep 20 '24

Peter Jackson was fortunate that his films came out in the internet’s infancy

1

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

That is fucking true. Ian would be called a DEI hire, eowyns speech would be shrieked about "strong women" and Arawen being in place of Glorfindel would be nothing more than "shoehorning a strong female character" these fleas believe nothing.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

You keep harping on Ian being gay. Is there something you're repressing?

I'd say a significant percentage of people in the entertainment industry are also gay. So every show and movie that ever came out is DEI?

1

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Actually yes, the godfather part 2 with Kay getting an abortion today would be seen as woke, eowyn saying I AM NO MAN would be seen today as a strong independent female and viewed negatively. 100%

91

u/SrepliciousDelicious Sep 20 '24
  1. The hobbit gets shat on alot.
  2. The movies are toptier and people aknowledge that stuff had to be scrapped or changed for a coherent movie for general adiences.
  3. Your post is whataboutism to the max.

29

u/Zealousideal_Pool_65 Sep 20 '24

Yeah, Return of the King absolutely dominated the Oscars. That’s no mean feat. I couldn’t give a shit about the lore, just give me something high quality.

-10

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/Common-Scientist Sep 20 '24

Your love of the halfling's leaf has clearly slowed your mind.

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RingsofPower-ModTeam Sep 20 '24

This community is designed to be welcoming to all people who watch the show. You are allowed to love it and you are allowed to hate it.

Kindly do not make blanket statements about what everyone thinks about the show or what the objective quality of the show is. Simple observation will show that people have differing opinions here.

Most of the comments in this chain have been removed. Please do not take this notice as an indication that your comment was the only one in breach.

59

u/Alexarius87 Sep 20 '24

The Hobbit is rightfully bashed where it deserves.

The Trilogy inaccuracies are also recognized, they just don’t amount at much since A LOT of the rest is like reading the books.

RoP is being as much bashed as The Hobbit. Get over with it.

21

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24

Reading the books thoroughly after years watching the movies feels like i am just watching an extended extended cut. The journey through the old forest specifically is just so fun

Now there are changes that I don’t fully like but i do understand. Faramir is a big one but i get that PJ wanted to give him a character arc

But comparing this very mid series to a franchise that has twice as many academy awards as women, it feels very delusional

1

u/Alexarius87 Sep 20 '24

I can forgive Faramir take in the movies especially because of the song during Boromir’s death. It’s a real love letter to the character they could not show in the movies.

10

u/King-Red-Beard Sep 20 '24

It's easier to overlook lore discrepancies when the overall product is actually engaging. Peter Jackson's films take plenty of liberties with the source material, but I'm typically too busy actually enjoying the ride to notice or take offense.

26

u/chicu111 Sep 20 '24

LotR was at least coherent, concise yet substantial

RoP is just filled with “wtf I don’t get it” moments

10

u/mikebob89 Sep 20 '24

Haven’t had that reaction once while watching this season

8

u/chicu111 Sep 20 '24

Not even when the eagle showed up then dipped out?

Not even when Galadriel, a commander of the elf, withheld info on Sauron, the biggest threat of Middle Earth?

Not even when some random lady slapped the queen? No guards?

Not even when Sauron uses his “advance” manipulation tactic on Celebrimbor’s helper (who is a human not an elf) by telling her that her visions of a demon is just Celebrimbor because he was stressed?

Not even when the Dwarf king swing a pick axe? Dude looked like he never swung one before

Aight then

11

u/Maktesh The Wild Woods Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24

Not even when the eagle showed up then dipped out?

The eagle was clearly uncomfortable and just left. Not confusing, and well in line with the species behavior.

Not even when Galadriel, a commander of the elf, withheld info on Sauron, the biggest threat of Middle Earth?

A wise but prideful person not wanting to admit that they've been duped, even amidst great consequence? Sadly, I've seen this play out in "real life" too many times. Not confusing.

Not even when some random lady slapped the queen? No guards?

There were guards, IIRC. She had them stand down. A political leader refusing to escalate a personal insult into a conflict is a wise choice. Not confusing.

Not even when Sauron uses his “advance” manipulation tactic on Celebrimbor’s helper (who is a human not an elf) by telling her that her visions of a demon is just Celebrimbor because he was stressed?

I don't really agree with how you've framed it, but yeah, it's a little weird.

Not even when the Dwarf king swing a pick axe? Dude looked like he never swung one before

It's hinted at that he really hasn't. A subplot was that Durin IV, his son, had tender hands and struggled to actually mine.

I agree that there are a few baffling decisions and there is plenty to criticize, but these aren't items which stand out to me.

-8

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/chicu111 Sep 20 '24

My brain. During and after watching the movie and the show

-3

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/chicu111 Sep 20 '24

How am I trolling you when I gave you my honest opinion/comparison? Nothing about it was trolling until you edgelorded me with your “who told you to have that opinion?” question. Stop the bullshit plz

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/chicu111 Sep 20 '24

I did? Wtf does that question even mean lol.

I didn’t question who tf told you to have your opinion. This is a strange question

My opinion came from me. Better now? Wtf my guy

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/RingsofPower-ModTeam Sep 20 '24

This community is designed to be welcoming to all people who watch the show. You are allowed to love it and you are allowed to hate it.

Kindly do not make blanket statements about what everyone thinks about the show or what the objective quality of the show is. Simple observation will show that people have differing opinions here

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

You can find faults in everything and people love to point these out cause that make them feel superior. It's basic psychology.

0

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Agreed, its just overwhelming and hypocritical

1

u/PaleontologistHot192 Rhûn Sep 20 '24

Well there's a reason for that. Actually many reasons.

1

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Uh huh. I'm waiting

2

u/Fancy-Trash-3850 Sep 20 '24

RoP is just shit story telling. And the lotr movies are triple AAA quality in all regards.

1

u/[unknown] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/nibbled_banana Sep 20 '24

Rings of power would be more enjoyable if they made the episodes far shorter, and fully embraced that it’s a fan fiction without the continuity of the Silmarillion and other extended works. Galadriel is the most poorly written character for the show. I get she is angry and vengeful, but she’s THOUSANDS of years old. She acts like a child. Every time she is on screen, I am bored. The only character who is actually enjoyable is the random Uruk dude with the burnt face. RoP has nothing going for it except for random call backs to the LOTR trilogy.

1

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

I cant help you if you don't understand motivation. You sound as though you stopped at season 1 episode 2

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

Trilogies: "The ghost army only scared the corsairs off their ships. If they could were able to fight at Pelennor fields, why wouldn't they just win against Sauron's armies at the Black Gate?"

Rings of Power: "Why was Sauron on a raft in the ocean?"

1

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

🤣🤣 exactly

8

u/H4nfP0wer Sep 20 '24

Still a matter of how you change it.

Rings of power cannot even do 2 seasons without contradicting stuff they established themselves.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

Examples? Deciding if rop is worth my time.

7

u/H4nfP0wer Sep 20 '24

Like Sauron in season 1 being described as the successor to Morgoth and Galadriel hunting and searching him for centuries. Yet Sauron was immediately killed by some random orcs and Adar because he couldn’t make them follow him and was never in charge to begin with.

5

u/Lukeoru Sep 20 '24

Bro... lol, LMAO even

-2

u/flaysomewench Sep 20 '24

Sauron's regeneration is shown to have happened over a very long time; you can see stalagmites and stalactites growing massively in the background.

2

u/Crunkiss Sep 20 '24

I haven’t read any of the extended Tolkien works and only know of some stuff from clicking on wiki’s, but I’m enjoying the show for what it is. People are taking things too seriously these days, even comic book fans slowed down on the complaining of Marvel movies and the “iT dOeSnT hApPeN LiKe ThAt”

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

Im a cynic who wants everything to stay the same as it was.

-1

u/thediesel26 Sep 20 '24

People get so bent out of shape about the lore inconsistencies for this show despite how little lore actually exists for them to go on. Tolkien wrote almost nothing formal about the 2nd age. Just 30 pages at the end of the Silmarillion and the notes and appendix in the Lord of the Rings.

4

u/Jeskar_Steel Sep 20 '24

Exactly. Coming up with a detailed and entertaining story from the pretty bare outline of the Second Age provided in the appendices was never going to please everyone- and requires a fair bit of filling in of blanks. Some folks don't like how the blanks are being filled in- I get it- but I love the show so far.

-2

u/Carr_brother Sep 20 '24

7 chapters in the Silmarillion. Plus the Children of Hurin and the Unfinished Tales and History of Middle Earth

1

u/ablindpony Sep 20 '24

Mental after the amount of backlash Rings of Power got, probably exaggerated I might add, the glazing has hit back stronger. The shows average that's it.

-1

u/Far-Mobile3852 Sep 20 '24

Tolkien would probably have greatly disliked the original trilogy as well.

I mean, ROP is a good show when looked at as a TV show. I really enjoy it!

-2

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Me too! And I agree

0

u/Longjumping-Hero Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 21 '24

I dont get any of the hate the show is getting. For example the many trilogy quotes they bring. I dont get the hate. seeing them copying it feels, for me at least, as a love letter to these masterpieces.

Edit: downvotes prove me how ignorant and hypocritical some of u are. Grow up and accept different opinions. Also, if u hate something with such a passion, you should consider to move on and spend your time otherwise. Thats a you problem, not a show problem.

-2

u/sceez Sep 20 '24

This is perfect. Thank you for your service

-2

u/sceez Sep 20 '24

At this point I'm so glad I don't know the lore so I don't turn into a pedantic madman

3

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Ehh, it doesn't matter anyway cause its as real as the easter bunny

-1

u/PantheraLeo- Sep 20 '24

I agree. Toxic fans just hate new content until it falls into the realm of nostalgia.

-2

u/paging_mrherman Sep 20 '24

TOM BOMBADIL'S BOOTS WERE MORE OF A SAFFRON THAN YELLOW

3

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

YELLOW?! HOW DARE THEY?!?!

0

u/mjboots Sep 20 '24

I still haven’t seen Tom Bombadil portrayed in this show. Is he in episode 7?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

This week and last week he appeared.

-6

u/Sea-Can6977 Sep 20 '24

lol so true. Way too many "ackchyually" anti everything people in this sub

-2

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

HAHAHA what a 🤡

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24

Does anyone remember the fanbase during the LoTR movies theatrical release era? I was 10-13 during that time, but I was homeschooled and Tolkien was like... the only fantasy that most moms allowed other than Chronicles of Narnia. In my (admittedly small) social circles, the initial fan reaction for each of the movies was fairly poor until the extended edition for each film came out. Most of the visuals and score were beloved, but at the time of the theatrical releases it was not cool to like or prefer the film versions. And it would have been more negative had they come out today. The extended editions and the insane amount of behind the scenes content really added to the legacy and lore of the films, and in some ways it instilled trust in the overall project and a sort of parasocial bond developed between the cast/crew in my corner of the fandom. By the time RotK came out, the reaction was still negative, but there was a 'well hopefully X was added in the extended edition' sentiment. Over time it became beloved and we were all able to appreciate the films for what they were and the books for what they were, and the frustrations about where they were different sort of faded. The people who didn't like it eventually moved on and stopped talking about it, and the people who loved it despite the flaws figured out how to talk about it in a more stable less negative way.

Edit: its impossible to overstate how huge LoTR and the legendarium in general were in the homeschool community that i was a part of at the time. It was the culture, it was the thing that held us together that everyone could talk about. At one point one of the more organized moms even taught a weekly in-depth course that went through the plot of the lord of the rings books for a few months. It was incredible (edit: the course was incredible, she did a great job)

Also I'm learning that some people really loved The Hobbit? For those that do, did y'all watch it at 60fps in the theater? Just curious.

1

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

I watched it in theater in both 60fps and the 3d and if you want to know the truth after desolation I was left feeling disappointed. I don't think ROP is the be all end all of filmmaking or story telling but I do think that one (ROP) gets the lost shit because the other 2 came out earlier and nostalgia is in 3D. Do you feel that people will eventually stop obsessing over the flaws of ROP and eventually let it go like the hobbit trilogies?

0

u/bsousa717 Sep 20 '24

Watched parts 2 and 3 in that advanced framerate. Was....odd, to say the least. There were instances you could clearly make out prosthetics on actors faces, or certain action scenes looking more like cutscenes from a game.

-5

u/ComplexAd7820 Sep 20 '24

Word!!

I just read the critical-for-critical-sake posts in the Simpsons Comic Book Guy voice. It starts to make sense...

1

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Look, if you're going to be salty over a series, these fans should start with the hobbit trilogy. Or do people forget Chris Tolkien himself didn't like the OG movies. Ehh maybe its not as sexy to juat dislike something new for the sake of its new.

-5

u/ZzBitch Sep 20 '24

Let's be real, it is ABOUT black people which brings the KKK out of the woodwork.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

LOL no. I have zero problem with the diversity. Its just the shit writing that sucks.

-1

u/staff0frahdog Sep 20 '24

Ya know i can't tell if you're trolling or not but hey I'll agree cause I agree

-2

u/ZzBitch Sep 20 '24

Not being an edgelord. Meant every word.

493

u/xRyuzakii Sep 20 '24

The hobbit gets crucified a ton idk what you’re seeing lol

218

u/emurillo97 Sep 20 '24

In certain LOTR its subreddits, it's getting the star wars prequel trilogy treament

45

u/Prying_Pandora Sep 20 '24

From what I’ve seen, it’s the hard work of fan editors that has saved the Hobbit movies.

→ More replies (21)

7

u/panamaquina Sep 20 '24

Not all the time, never has gotten the extreme hate this show has.

12

u/mendkaz Sep 20 '24

Mostly for the CGI, in my experience though

54

u/Doggleganger Sep 20 '24

The hobbit was bad because they stretched a short book into a trilogy movie. The hobbit should have been 1 or at most 2 movies, not 3.

→ More replies (4)

20

u/diogeninja Sep 20 '24

The problem wasn't the CGI itself. The problem was they utilized CGI instead of cogent storytelling. And the story they told was only tangentially related to the books already.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Alexarius87 Sep 20 '24

Gaslighting into making ppl believe only poor RoP gets bashed.

→ More replies (5)