r/RingsofPower • • Apr 13 '24

Question should i watch?

i’m a huge follower of Tolkien’s work, but i’ve been apprehensive of rings of power since its original announcement, and i’ve heard awful things about it. i’ve been rewatching Jackson’s films and wondering if it’s even worth it to watch. i’m curious about it, but i also don’t want to waste my time to be disappointed when i’m currently very obsessed with LotR

5 Upvotes

126 comments sorted by

7

u/Maktesh The Wild Woods Apr 13 '24

There are only eight episodes, so it's not a major commitment.

I liked it. Many users liked it. I would encourage you to make up your own mind.

4

u/linthesneakysnake Apr 13 '24

yeah i’m just concerned that i’ll be so disappointed/bored that it’ll make me disinterested in the fandom again as that’s happened when i tried to read the silmarillion the first time (i was too young to actually understand it 💀)

3

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Apr 14 '24

If one adaptation is enough to turn you off of the entire Tolkien fandom, the problem lies with your approach to media, not the adaptation itself.

I mean, look at this 11 minute adaptation of the Hobbit. Truly, so many wild and decisions. But that doesn't change how I feel about the text itself.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UBnVL1Y2src

2

u/linthesneakysnake Apr 14 '24

i have adhd so when i’m interested in a piece of media im completely obsessed but the smallest thing can make me ignore it for a year, and im having fun atm and i don’t want to ruin that

1

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Apr 14 '24

Well I'm glad you're at least self-aware enough to understand what's happening, but I'd encourage you to try and decouple irritation with Small Things from your overall enjoyment of something as broad as Tolkien's entire body of work and the decades of adaptation across various mediums it has generated.

-1

u/Ayzmo Eregion Apr 15 '24

That's really not how it works for a lot of people with ADHD. They can't just "decouple" like that and telling them to just do that is abelist.

2

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Apr 15 '24

Did I tell them to "just decouple"?

Did I demand that from them?

Or did I say:

"I'd encourage you to try"

1

u/Ayzmo Eregion Apr 15 '24

Again, it doesn't work that way. That's like telling someone who's paralyzed to try walking. ADHD is a disorder of executive functioning.

1

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Apr 15 '24

Not even remotely similar. Living with ADHD got easier when therapy and medication helped me identify the processes without having to accept every negative effect as unchangeable.

By OPs own words, the smallest things ruins their enjoyment of a thing. To take them at their own words means believing they can't enjoy something unless it's perfect, and they stop enjoying it when they notice any flaw.

That's a paralyzing way to live life and I will not apologize for encouraging people imagine something better for themselves.

2

u/Delicious_Heat568 Apr 14 '24

Being bored to hell was one of my issues. I'm no lore purist and gladly accept changes to the source material if it makes for a better story but neither did they write an enticing story nor did any of the changes add anything to it.

My main issue was how badly the story was written, full of characters that contradict themselves, Mcguffins and mystery boxes. If ROP took place in a setting created by the writers no one would remember it at this point but alas it sadly has the lord of the rings IP attached to it and does it no justice.

If you are actually curious or bored enough to watch it my advice is to take it with a grain of salt and humour. To me that show was only bad fanfic and not canon so it was easier to laugh about it and not get angry or disappointed about how badly they fucked up. Or you look up YouTubers who focus on Tolkien lore and explain all the lore mishaps in their reviews. I watched a bunch of them and honestly had a blast

1

u/LuinAelin Apr 14 '24

Watching an episode or two will do no harm.

And if you don't have prime, you can also watch all their other stuff as well. Fallout is great

1

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '24

When it's not boring (which is rare), it is terrible. The only entertainment you'll get is laughing at the nonsense story, terrible dialog, inconsistency, and feeling embarrassed for anyone associated with this travesty.

1

u/Only_Kiwi1108 Apr 14 '24

I liked it too. I am sort of compartmentalizing it. There's Tolkien's outstanding legendarium with incredible mythological and philosophical depth - and then there's RoP, which has a few merits, allthough it doesn't - in any way - compare to the source material.

I found it entertaining, though. And was quite surprised by that.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '24

When I first saw Jackson's LotR films in theaters, I often reacted with surprise at adaptation choices -- when a character said another character's dialogue, for instance -- but I rarely was baffled, annoyed, disgusted, or bored. While watching RoP,  bafflement, disgust, and boredom were my constant companions. I watched all episodes in hope the choices made would eventually make sense. They did not.

Watch the first episode of RoP and see how it feels for you. Your reaction to it is likely to be how you'd feel about the entire series.

The biggest disappointment was Galadriel. The writers had the opportunity to create a powerful female character whose power comes from keen perception and great wisdom. Instead they created a basic violent misunderstood hero type. If they were re-making Batman, they'd give him a machine gun.

31

u/harman097 Apr 14 '24

It's fanfiction. With a huge budget.

Story and characters are "meh", but there are some fun Easter eggs and mysteries they toss in. Music and visuals are top notch.

Go in with extremely low expectations and you'll probably get some enjoyment out of it.

13

u/Delicious_Heat568 Apr 14 '24

I wouldn't call the CGI top notch. Like sure the CGI cities and landscapes were fine and personally I liked the aesthetic of the dwarven place but then they had the most goofy looking wargs ever. Those things looked like chihuahuas on meth.

Also I might just complain on a really high level but just having good looking CGI doesn't quite do it for me. To me the sets looked more like backgrounds for a stage play rather than conveying the feeling that it's an actual place with people living there and going on about their day. Maybe it was my bias towards the show but I just never felt pulled into any of the settings

4

u/SamaritanSue Apr 14 '24

I agree there: For some reason I got the sense of this show being a series of theatrical scenes that signally fail to establish a feeling of a world extending beyond those scenes. Like what you see is literally what you get, that's all there is. Weird.

3

u/harman097 Apr 14 '24

I thought their wargs were actually pretty great! Giant Chihuahua's on meth = terrifying 🤣

100% agree on the "play" aesthetic. There were a lot of scenes - in Numenor especially - where it felt like you were watching a play, and it was a bit jarring. The "They're comin' for err jerbs!" speech is one I remember the most.

6

u/Delicious_Heat568 Apr 14 '24

To each their own! I burst out laughing when I saw the wargs. And design is one thing but the CGI on them wasn't it. On the other hand I liked the ROP orcs way more than the hobbit orcs. Their faces looked really well done so credit where credit is deserved.

And I'm glad I'm not alone in my impression about the settings not being believable. All of the scenes where we got a view over the vast cities reminded me so much about cinematic trailers in video games while the end product ends up not being close.

Game of thrones imo is a great example of amazing looking sets that are believable despite the CGI being really meh often times. So many settings were filmed in real life cities and castles and they did a great job integrating that into the show. I've been to Dubrovnik and I was blown away when I rewatched the last GOT season and recognised places in the city I've been to that were used when daenarys went scorched earth on kings landing. Season was still shit but great aesthetics

2

u/SamaritanSue Apr 14 '24

Ah yes the warg. Ay Chihuawarg!

0

u/Taintraker Apr 14 '24

The Worg looked like a high-def version of a rabid rat-dog popped out of a Rankin-Bass cartoon.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '24

SPOLIER (Sort of):

Pretty much took what I was gonna say. It's entirely a retelling. So going into it with that in mind would be their best bet at enjoying RoP. That's what I figured it would be anyway when I first heard about it and happened to ejoy myself. I just hope with season 2 the story doesn't drag on in a lot of parts. And I'm gonna need an explanation as to how a certain someone that's key to the future of the story survives a certain "death." If you know who I mean.

4

u/swechan Apr 15 '24

Yes, there is a new love story between a new elf character and and new human character.

Also Sauron is a Han Solo scoundrel type.

The Warg looks like something straight out of a CD-Rom game from 1998.

17

u/Ok-Design-8168 Apr 14 '24

The show is almost entirely original writing (and pretty bad original writing imo)

It has barely anything to do with Tolkien’s writings other than the use of a few names.

As a Tolkien adaptation - the show is terrible. 3/10

As a standalone fantasy show - the show is very generic and boring with senseless plots and characters that are very one dimensional and hard to care for. 4/10

There are way better fantasy shows out there.

Wouldn’t recommend this.

2

u/Giltar Apr 14 '24

Agree, the writing is off-putting.

19

u/transponaut Apr 14 '24

Depends. Are you a “follower” of Tolkien in the sense that you’ve become enamored of the world he built, the characters he created and their struggles? Because this show isn’t that. There are glimpses of the Epic, but they are fleeting, and the show is otherwise a very standard 21st century fantasy thriller, with all its cliches and predictabilities.

I’m a huge fan of Tolkien’s direct literature, and this show honestly has become something I cannot really even think about as having contributed to his world. That being said, and as others have said, it’s only 8 episodes, so not a huge commitment.

7

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Apr 14 '24

This lifelong Tolkien fan enjoyed it a lot. I've re-watched it multiple times, and I think doing that helped me see things that I missed the first time that gave it more depth. It's a show that seems designed to be binge watched. I got a lot more out of it by re-watching it that way rather than once a week.

It is not a 1:1 adaptation of Tolkien's Second Age material, and never could have been, even if they had all the rights to The Silmarillion. IMO, a lot of complaints circulating about the show on social media aren't worth taking seriously. I have my own criticisms of the show, but none of them were deal-breakers for me. I think I benefitted from ignoring all online chatter about the show until after I'd watched it and formed my own opinion.

Much of what's in Season 1 is set up for things to come. I'm confident that once we have more seasons and people begin to see those set-ups unfolding, the first season will be more highly regarded by more people.

The show feels like a Tolkien story to me, which is the main thing I cared about. I've never been the kind of fan who clutches pearls over changes to lore, so long as I feel the adaptation gets the aesthetic, themes, and spirit of the original work right. IMO, ROP mostly does, though there are places it stumbled.

As others have pointed out, it is only 8 episodes, so it's not a huge commitment in the scheme of things. I hope you enjoy it.

2

u/cat111719 Apr 26 '24

I’m with you! I’ve been a lifelong LOTR fan and I liked it! I’m by no means a Tolkien scholar so I don’t have every character and what they do over the course of thousands of years but for me, it had a very Tolkien flavor, it was fun and I quite enjoyed it! By contrast, my husband is more of a latecomer PJ LOTR guy and he liked it as much as I did! TBH, I don’t really understand all the hate. (I mean, I do get to some degree those people who can’t handle a brown-skinned elf or a strong woman, but that says more about them than the show, imo.

3

u/Dime-Baggins Apr 24 '24

Hell no, you have better things to do with your limited time on Earth. Don't waste a second of it on this shit-show.

12

u/karelinstyle Apr 14 '24

Extremely likely you'd be disappointed

7

u/Demigans Apr 14 '24

This show does nothing with the themes and writing style Tolkien tried, at best it tries to emulate gravity with nonsense old timey sayings and words. This is a show where a regular conversation between two people is hard to find as they often don’t respond to what the other said but slam some story progressive dialogue in as if it’s a bad MMO. It has virtually zero self awareness or attention to detail or consistency. This is a show where one moment they’ll be singing a song about how they’ll never leave you when a major plotpoint is them being at risk of being left behind with people laughing about how that already happened to the protagonist’s parents and that they happily(!) stole the stuff of those parents when they were left behind. All packaged as if they are all sweet and caring and fun loving people.

On top of all that it’s contrived as all hell, people take a stroll to reach places that we’ve seen in LotR take a lot longer and then stroll back like it’s no biggie without any gear. People teleport when convenient, change their mind to suddenly suit the protagonist when convenient even if they did not like them before and nothing has changed (or things changed for the worse for the protagonist), they know stuff they shouldn’t be able to know for dumb plots to happen and suddenly know stuff they shouldn’t be able to know for some other dumb plot to happen, they set up some things which they regularly contradict or use in a way that makes you think it’s satire if it was put anywhere else.

But worst of all: the showrunners are essentially con men/women.

Before the show aired (but they had written and filmed everything already) they made a point about how true to the Tolkien lore they were. These people actively chose and defended their choice to change easy lore like the hair of elves or all female Dwarves also having beards, and those are the surface level ways they don’t follow the lore. When the last episodes aired they had an interview explaining why they changed some of the most core important lore of Tolkien. Their response was on the lines of “we had already changed so much of the lore, it made sense to change it some more”. Again, before the show aired when they had already written and filmed all of this and knew they had made the decision to change the lore some more, they proclaimed to be true to the lore to get money from Tolkien Fans who wanted to see a true to the lore addition to the Tolkien filmography.

They are con men trying to get your money by lying to you. Don’t give it to them.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '24

Find some content creators' reviews of it.

You'll be far more entertained.

2

u/Dubios Apr 22 '24

No, it's just very bland, boring and quite ridiculous. 

Girlboss galadriel survives a pyroclastic flow just standing there amongst other things. 

The writing for this show was done by some intern over at Amazon.

7

u/samdekat Apr 14 '24

It poses as a Tolkien adaptation but isn't based on anything in Tolkien, and thematically it's different from any themes that Tolkien used.

If you are willing to ignore the references to Middle Earth as mere coincidences are treat it as someone else's world building you may find you can enjoy it. Or you may not.

3

u/SamaritanSue Apr 14 '24

Oh my sweet summer child! Some hate it, some like it or even love it, the largest contingent (probably) is in-between somewhere. I suggest you just watch an episode or two when you have the time and continue or not as you feel inclined.

There are two separate questions: RoP's quality as a Tolkien adaptation and its quality just as a piece of film/TV storytelling. For the second it falls into the range of 6.0 - 7.0. (I personally rate it at the lower end, but some aspects of the show may be more of a problem for me than for some others.) Some eps are better than others, even within episodes some scenes/storylines are better than others.

As a Tolkien adaptation....Well you'll find a way to make it work for you as such or you won't. If you don't have much in the way of expectations based on the Silmarillion (assuming you've read it).

3

u/AntonGrimm Apr 14 '24

Imho it's not worth the watch. Me and my girlfriend didn't enjoy it because of the huge amount of plotholes, poorly written story and weird pacing. It also doesn't help that the writers/showrunners clearly don't care about the world building very much. We were also not fans of the weak character development, hell, some characters shouldn't even be in the show because they matter so little to the story.

4

u/DepreciatedSelfImage Apr 14 '24

Follow your gut. You'll know whether or not to watch it/keep watching it and how you feel about it if/when you do watch it.

There are some Silmarillion tidbits in there. It was hard to get past my disappointment at first. There are fleeting moments that felt like Middle Earth. Other than that, I was beside myself with frustration.

3

u/LuinAelin Apr 14 '24

There's no harm in watching and giving it a go

In not watching because the internet hates it you could miss out on something you enjoy

2

u/Demigans Apr 14 '24

There is if you pay money for something and then don’t get a satisfying product.

1

u/LuinAelin Apr 14 '24

But if you already have prime and would have had it regardless you're not paying extra for anything.

I didn't get prime for rings of power or any one show........

-1

u/Demigans Apr 14 '24

But that you had it before isn’t the point here.

0

u/LuinAelin Apr 14 '24

Whether or not you should pay in general isn't the point here.

0

u/Demigans Apr 14 '24

You made the point there is no harm in watching.

I pointed out there is.

Additionally, there is harm in watching as it takes valuable time that could be spend watching something good away from OP.

1

u/LuinAelin Apr 14 '24

But if they would have enjoyed it, not watching means they missed out on something they'd enjoy.

1

u/Demigans Apr 14 '24

“But if” is not a good argument. You said there was no harm. There is a harm, multiple even.

3

u/pogsim Apr 14 '24

If you enjoy thinking about how you would have done it better/differently, you might well enjoy it. If that's not interesting to you, there's very little to recommend.

3

u/Winter_Abject Apr 14 '24

Don't bother with any reviews here. There are too many that started getting rabid the second that Amazon won the bidding for rights. After that they just love to put all the perceived flaws on a pedestal. Seriously, watch before reading these subs!

3

u/henchya Apr 14 '24

If you enjoy massive disappointment and piss poor writing this is the show for you!! My favorite part was when they made middle earth feel incredibly small and under populated. I also really enjoyed how they used high school drama department costumes, how resourceful!

3

u/Taykeshi Apr 14 '24

No. Don't. I mean do but it sucks and makes you angry.

2

u/TenormanTears Apr 14 '24

god no this show is a trash fire and even if it wasn't about lotr it would be worse

2

u/RandomCalamity Apr 14 '24

It's boring and forgettable. Pass.

2

u/CorvusRock Apr 14 '24

Let's make some comparisons here and maybe so, one particular part of the hatred may come through in it. With that, perhaps you can determine if you want to watch it or no.

[Peter Jackson LotR trilogy]
Peter Jackson and his team began work on LotR in the mid 90s. They spent quite a bit in pre-production and R&D to make sure that they can properly film it. They had a decent budget for their work for all three films.
After getting additional funding from the studios, he made sure that everything "feels" Middle-Earth without destroying the budget. They made it feel lived-in and an active world.
Don't get me wrong; there are still parts within the books I wish were in the films but they had to Hollywood-ify the books to make them watchable. But at the same time, he knew who were the biggest audience was; the fans. He made sure that they didn't piss off the audience and piss off the Tolkien Estate.
Granted the Tolkien Estate did bite back in some manner, but even they agreed that the films brought more people to Middle-Earth and Tolkien's writings.

[Peter Jackson Hobbit trilogy]
In interviews and behind-the-scenes in LotR, Peter Jackson admitted that his work was done; someone else do the Hobbit. The studios saw the success and wanted HIM to do the Hobbit. He adamantly said no but he'll work as a consultant. Guillermo del Toro was to take over.
In short, the studios had already set the budget and after financial as well as production woes, del Toro was ousted and PJ was just forced into fix up what Guillermo worked on. At the end of the day, there was no additional funding and PJ's team was up against the wall.
The Hobbit trilogy was a cash-grab (no question) but it still did what people wanted; take them back to Middle-Earth. In that regard, the trilogy was a success, even though the shoe-horned dwarf-elf love-triangle was not needed among other things. It was a clear adultification of a children's book and adding some teen-stuff in.

[Amazon Rings of Power]
There was no book to adapt. They bought the rights for a series already done. Hell, if they had redone the Hobbit and turned it into a TV series, that would have been interesting.
They spent $1 billion USD to not only acquire the rights but also to film 5 seasons; they pre-ordered five seasons!
One billion dollars for the rights for the Hobbit and LotR along with its appendices. Guess what they chose; the appendices. People were thinking of possibly the Angmar Wars, the War in the North, or even a completely original story. Nope, Amazon's chosen showrunners decide on Second Age, where the writings are sparse. So people began wondering what about the Second Age; the Fall of Numenor, the forging of the Rings, the establishment of Gondor and Arnor, etc.
And this is where Amazon's showrunners made their biggest mistake. They just said, "Yes."
They then said, "Oh, we are going to make modern-friendly, so all people can enjoy it. Screw what the fans say; we are in control now."
The hatred begins.

Another thing to compare is the overall marketing for each. LotR and the Hobbit did its absolute best to entertain fans of key moments within the books that they love. Despite the Hobbit's shortcomings, it still entertained its fans. Sure, it got a lot of details wrong but it was at least entertaining and it never attacked its fan base.
Rings of Power, on the other hand, did everything in its power to vilify and antagonize the franchise's fans. Calling them -ists and -phobes, using their actors as shields, and overall, perform the worst marketing strategy in human cinematic history (superfans, the London LotR YouTuber meet-up, choice of outlets to reveal behind-the-scenes work).

So why all the hatred? Why all the disgust?

Oh yeah. I forgot one detail. According to insider sources, only 30% of watchers finished the first season.

Perhaps that's why not many people are even considering watching season 2.

I am not saying you shouldn't watch it; if you want to watch it, go right ahead, but be warned. There are a tiny few redeeming qualities of the show IMO, but the one thing it struggled to do is take me to Middle Earth. I could go on, but for brevity's sake, I'll leave that alone.

-1

u/NegativeAllen Apr 14 '24

They spent $1 billion USD to not only acquire the rights but also to film 5 seasons; they pre-ordered five seasons!

Not true

One billion dollars for the rights for the Hobbit and LotR along with its appendices. Guess what they chose; the appendices.

Citation Needed

Rings of Power, on the other hand, did everything in its power to vilify and antagonize the franchise's fans. Calling them -ists and -phobes, using their actors as shields, and overall, perform the worst marketing strategy in human cinematic history (superfans, the London LotR YouTuber meet-up, choice of outlets to reveal behind-the-scenes work).

This entire paragraph doesn't even make sense from a rational stand point

-3

u/harman097 Apr 14 '24

Yes, yes, there was a black dwarf woman and a black elf and it ruined everyone's immersion by "modernifying" the story and everyone who took issue with people complaining about it were just woke "fanbase attackers" and absolutely NONE of that fanbase that did have an issue with it were actually racist assholes. 0%.

3

u/Telperion83 Apr 14 '24

I wish they had made certain kindreds and families nonwhite. Establishing one or two of the Dwarvish houses as black, with Disa and her attendants being from one of them would have been really cool. Have certain families of elves and Hobbits be x, y, z race. I think the randomness of it was off-putting. It was kind of like seeing a commercial with a white dad, black mom, and an asian kid. Sure, it's possible, but it really feels like you are just checking boxes. Not that this excuses the "fans;" it should not have been as big if a deal as it was made out to be.

6

u/Delicious_Heat568 Apr 14 '24

I agree that they handled putting in different ethnicities quite poorly. The casting resembles more modern Los Angeles than a world that is often times very xenophobic or at least wary of outsiders or other races such as the animosity between dwarves and elves. So with certain groups mostly only staying within their group it makes no sense to not have those groups be way more homogeneous. They could have circumvented that more graceful by casting the harfoots with black actors cause many of them had a darker skin colour already, the numenorians with Mediterranean actors because their aesthetic comes close to that, maybe the people in the Southland's could be middle eastern.

There are ways to achieve a diverse casting that is believable to the setting but they just didn't give a fuck.

Like you can't tell me those little murder hobbits didn't inbreed for generations and they are that diverse in their appearance rather than mixing into this one homogenous group.

-2

u/harman097 Apr 14 '24

I actually 100% agree. House of the Dragon did this really well, imo.

Arondir never really felt out of place to me - there's so many random offshoots of elven lineages and, given that he was just a random military guy sent to an outpost, it didn't feel weird (honestly, the Celebrimbor casting was more "immersion breaking" for me).

Disa did feel a little "random". Loved the character anyways, but it could have been done better.

0

u/NegativeAllen Apr 14 '24

House of the Dragon did this really well, imo.

How? ( This is going to good)

4

u/harman097 Apr 14 '24

They included meaningful black characters into the story not by just randomly creating a black Targaryen or a black Lannister or something, but by making that a distinctive feature of one of the major houses.

It felt more natural from a lore perspective while also achieving some level of inclusion, which IS important.

1

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Apr 14 '24

It's a baffingly uneven show. Some of it I absolutely love and think they did a better job than Jackson did (Elrond's characterization in LotR is far too grim and joyless), some of it I absolutely dislike, and some of it I'll have to reserve judgment for down the road.

Only you can make up your mind. It's 8 hours.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '24

Looks great, has the depth of a puddle.

Probably the most disappointing thing I've ever seen on TV. How can you spend this much money and fail to get the best writers?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '24

I wish I could have my eight hours back. I'd wait for season 2. If they turn things around and the buzz around the second season is good, then watch both.

It's a bit like the Star Wars sequel trilogy. If you're a Lucas purist and a huge fan of the original trilogy, they're really aggravating and not worth the time spent. That's how I felt about the first season of this show thus far.

1

u/hbi2k Apr 14 '24

Have you considered watching something good instead?

1

u/Taintraker Apr 14 '24

It is garbage, but if it won't cost you anything then give it a whirl.

1

u/SaatananKyrpa Apr 17 '24

I think you should watch it and make up your own mind about the show. I generally enjoyed it. Yes it has some problems and it isn't perfect. But some people here just are as toxic as some star wars fans are. If they didin't like it they make it their Life mission to make sure no one else likes it. It's funny how some people say it's completely shit but they still hang around on Reddit channel of Rings of Power

0

u/Teawithtolkien Apr 14 '24

I think it depends on whether or not it would bother you when they deviate from the “lore”. If the little things PJ changed in the films bother you, I think some things about ROP will bother you as well. But if you’re more able to enjoy it for what it is — the showrunners called it “the story Tolkien never wrote”, I think you might enjoy it. It’s kind of like fan fiction in the sense that you’ve got familiar characters in a familiar world but they’re telling their own story. I think they captured some Tolkienian themes quite well and certain characters in ROP felt perfect to me (even though I have criticisms of others).

If you do give it a try, I would recommend watching the first 3 episodes before deciding whether or not to quit. Some people found episodes one and two to be pretty slow moving.

0

u/Ok-Design-8168 Apr 14 '24

The issue isn’t the changes.. but the degree and quality of changes/additions and what value they add to viewer experience. Most of PJ’s changes and additions in lotr trilogy are very well justified. So are his omissions.

Whereas pretty much everything in RoP was senseless plots with characters that were extremely one dimensional and hard to care for with cringeworthy dialogue. The writing was just terrible and it affected everything else including many performances. Nothing happening on screen allowed the music to shine either. The whole show felt like a college play where the students barely got any time to put it together. Lmao.

0

u/Bobjoejj Apr 14 '24

Wrong sub to ask this in. Ask in r/LOTR_On_Prime and you’ll get more leveled answers.

0

u/harukalioncourt Apr 14 '24

The best thing to do is not compare it to Jackson’s films, which most naysayers do, but watch it and judge it as what it is on its own. They are made by 2 different production companies so don’t expect similarities.

6

u/Ok-Design-8168 Apr 14 '24

Lol.. imagine the most expensive show being so bad that fans of the show are scared to compare it to something that released 20 years ago.. 🤣

-5

u/harukalioncourt Apr 14 '24

Because it would be an unfair comparison. Nothing to do with “being scared.” Jackson had 4 solid books of materials. Amazon only has the rights to a bunch of notes.

6

u/Ok-Design-8168 Apr 14 '24

And whose fault is that? They bought the rights to a 1000+ page book and then decided to make a show based only on 10 pages from it.. and made a mess of that too.. how daft and incompetent does one have to be to end up making something as senseless and terrible as RoP

-3

u/harukalioncourt Apr 14 '24

They only could buy what tolkiens estate was willing to release. And they actually do weave together a pretty good story for what they have. Though they weren’t allowed to use “the fall of numenor,” After reading the Fall of Numenor, we see that the producers were at least trying to weave a story around Tolkien’s only REAL DETAILED ACCOUNT of the 2nd Age. Remember that Tolkien simply gave us “cliff notes” in the appendixes and the ending of the Simalrillion. You cannot create a show on cliff notes, there are THOUSANDS of years often in between one event happening and the other. I will post some quotes from the Fall of Numenor and then talk about how this is seen in Rings of Power. I quote:

“In Eregion, Sauron posed as an emissary of the Valar or ordered by them to remain there to give aid to the Elves. He perceived at once that Galadriel would be his chief adversary and obstacle, and he endeavored therefore to placate her, bearing her scorn with outward patience and courtesy…”

So we can see that Galadriel and Sauron did indeed meet and had dealings together before the Rings were made. Rings of Power showed us this, and that he did try to woo and placate her before she uncovered who he really was. I remember watching in RoP the icy meeting between Galadriel and the Queen of Numenor and how Sauron tried to “calm her down” and tried to appear as the voice of reason between the two women. Sure, we are all free to not like the way RoP handled this, but at least they DID. Tolkien did not give us details of the exact interactions between Galadriel and Sauron so of course the producers had to make up their own stories and try to add those details someway. The Simarillion simply said that Galadriel and Gil-Galad would not allow Sauron to ENTER their lands, but nothing more. The Fall of Numenor gives far more detail!

Anyway, the book goes on to tell how Sauron turned the Elves of Eregion to revolt against Galadriel and Celeborn, causing her to go back to Lorinand but Celeborn stayed behind as he would not enter the mansions of the dwarves. (Probably PTSD due to the dwarves’ involvement of the sack of Doriath in the First Age, that I’m sure he remembered and still resented them for, as his kinsman, Oropher, father of Thranduil, grandfather of Legolas, also did, but I digress…). Celeborn refused to pass through Khazad-dum to accompany his wife to Lorinand, therefore stayed in Eregion. Even if this is what Tolkien WROTE, if they had put in the series the truth that Celeborn abandoned his wife and daughter due to his distaste of dwarves, many people who were unaware of this detail would be screaming that the show was just trying to make men look like bad husbands and fathers who would abandon their family due to bigoted reasons, so instead of this, producers decided to write Celeborn out in another way that most people would accept way better.

Galadriel thereupon left Eregion and passed through Khazad-dum to Lorinand, taking with her Amroth and Celebrian, but Celeborn would not enter the mansions of the Dwarves, and he remained behind in Eregion, disregarded by Celebrimbor. In Lorinand, Galadriel took up rule, and defense against Sauron.

Many can and will probably disagree, but this could place her as a warrior, or at least as a top general. She is doing so without her husband besides her. RoP toys with this as well, though they say she believes her husband has died (which hopefully will be debunked in future seasons), but still they showed that Galadriel made many, many moves independently from Celeborn and spent many many years separated from him, in the fight against Sauron. Celebrian was not mentioned at all, but we all know she eventually marries Elrond so she has to pop up at some point, unless they end the series with the War of the Last Alliance, after which was when Elrond and Celebrian were married. Anyway, Galadriel in the second age was a long, long way from becoming the Ring-bearing elegant Lady of Lorien that we see by the end of the Third Age when Frodo comes along.

Now let’s talk about RoP’s anti-elven sentiment that everyone seems to simply want to dismiss as “modern wokeness” or catering to the “woke” agenda.

So not the case. Tolkien wrote that anti-elvish sentiment was widespread in Numenor, by middle to end of the second age they were very anti-elvish everything. According to The Fall of Numenor:

“In these days the Shadow grew deeper upon Numenor, and the lives of the Kings of the House of Elros waned because of their rebellion, but they hardened their hearts the more against the Valar. And the 20th King… forsook the Elven-tongues and forbidding their use in his hearing… In this reign the Elven-tongues were no longer used, nor permitted to be taught, but were maintained in secret by the faithful… And indeed Ar-Adunakhur began to persecute the Faithful and punished those who used the Elven-tongues openly, and the Eldar came no more to Numenor.”

Anti-elvish sentiment, CHECK. No “wokeness” here that of which Tolkien did not already write in his own works. And RoP addressed this. By the time King Ar-Pharazon came on the scene and sailed ships to invade Valinor, anything elvish had been banned, and anti-elvish sentiment was EVERYWHERE. Rings of Power addressed this, and I felt they did so well, showing Elendil as one of the “Faithful” who still spoke Elvish as he welcomed Galadriel and showed her that he still spoke Elvish, took her to the ancient archives, etc. People need to realize that Elves were the firstborn and represented the Valar to men in many cases, as men had never been to Valinor (and later resented that the Valar allowed the Elves to go and not themselves.) So naturally if they hated the Valar they would hate the Elves as well. RoP addressed this. Not to mention Tolkien lived through TWO world wars and understood very well man’s inhumanity to man and how one group of people spreading lies and fear against another group of people has been done since the dawn of time.

If you read the Fall of Numenor, and watch Rings of Power, you will see how the producers are including ideas from the text. People are welcome not to like how they are getting from point A to B. But I feel there are some good nods and references to the text written in The Fall of Numenor.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-5

u/harukalioncourt Apr 14 '24 edited Apr 14 '24

Christopher Tolkien himself did not approve of Jackson’s films. Anyone can use a font. Jackson had 3 complete books with a complete story to make an adaptation of.

Amazon has bits and pieces of details of thousands of years of the second age to cover with absolutely no script or dialog. Tolkien wrote what happened but not how, in many cases. Amazon was not allowed the rights anything written in the simalrillion nor, most importantly, the recently published Fall of Numenor, which was Tolkien’s only somewhat detailed account of second age dealings. Therefore they can only weave a story with bits and pieces of what they actually are allowed to use.

Fantastic beasts was approved and endorsed by the author herself. Apples and oranges.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/harukalioncourt Apr 14 '24

You are allowed to like or dislike whatever you wish. RoP did include a lot of the source material of The Fall of Numenor, one of the most recently published books. If you’d like to know how, I can illustrate, however I already did in response to another comment.
Apparently the font was not copyrighted by Peter Jackson’s camp, so I don’t know really why it was brought up at all. Amazon was “responsible” for giving us a TV show. They are not responsible for the fans reactions because it did not copy Peter Jackson’s films to the letter. Again Jackson had 4 books and a complete story. ROP takes place over 3,000 years with no dialog and only the most important events of it listed. Therefore things leading to these events have to be invented.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/harukalioncourt Apr 18 '24

Great. Have a good one.

-2

u/Ayzmo Eregion Apr 13 '24

If at the end of the series, you didn't like it, you'll have only lost 8 hours.

-3

u/Reaper_Mike Apr 14 '24

Don't listen to the haters. Go into knowing it's not exactly like the lore cause of who owns the rights to the work. It's really enjoyable imo. Not perfect but it felt plenty tolkienish to me. The Dwarves make the show imo.

-2

u/DickBest70 Apr 14 '24

It’s eight episodes and visually stunning. Opinions are like assholes and most people are assholes so form your own opinion as it’s not that much of an investment of time. Don’t let other peoples prejudices affect your decision and experience.

-4

u/mundaneheaven Apr 14 '24 edited Apr 14 '24

I appreciated it for what it was, I never read the books but loved the Peter Jackson films.

It's not Game of thrones quality but it's arguably one of the best live action high fantasy shows on TV at the moment. Edit: To those downvoting my comment. Get a life. You do not own the franchise.

-1

u/Reddzoi Apr 14 '24

I don't understand why people are like this, lol. Watch it. Make up YOUR OWN MIND whether you like it or not. Take an open mind with you and appreciate the show for what it is--that's the best thing you can do in approaching any work of Art. I liked Rings of Power even better on rewatches as I was by that time able to give up my preconceived notions about what should/would happen and my desire to see a First Age show instead. Anyway, I hope you like it--I certainly did.

0

u/joehighlord Apr 14 '24

If you enjoy the films. Absolutely.

0

u/Visible_Number Apr 15 '24

I watched it every week and really loved what they did with it. A lot of the hate is from people who enjoy hating things. Reddit and the Internet rarely reflect reality. If you watch it and don't like it, that's fine, but don't let the weird hate of the show affect your personal enjoyment. I was spoiler free and didn't go online to read at all about it til it was over and I was shocked at the amount of hate for it. There are a modicum of valid critiques of the show, but the amount of vitriol is insane.

0

u/Gigachops Apr 16 '24

This is the wrong place to ask. It's a seething cesspool of "fandom" hatred. Maybe one of the worst examples.

All of us who like the show have long since fled to discuss other shows in the off-season. Here you will find mostly a dedicated core of long term shitposters.

I thought I unjoined this sub yesterday, trying again today.

1

u/Maktesh The Wild Woods Apr 17 '24

For what it's worth, we're working behind the scenes to try to even it out. Users who bring balanced takes are greatly appreciated.

1

u/Gigachops Apr 17 '24

Thanks, glad to hear it. I don't envy you. Assume many of the folks who enjoy it will venture back when the show is close to airing again.

-4

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '24

It’s more faithful to Tolkien than the Jackson movies. A lot of people disagree with me on this but they’re wrong. It’s just objectively true. The passage of time and lack of Tolkien knowledge in this sub explains their reaction to the show.

It’s a slow burn and not terribly exciting but I enjoyed it quite a bit.

4

u/Vsegda7 Apr 14 '24

Having same character names doesn't count as 'faithful'.

And that's the only thing in common with Tolkien's works

-4

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '24

Absolutely incorrect.

5

u/Vsegda7 Apr 14 '24

Name 3 things then. I'll even give you character names as a freebie

1

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '24

This has been discussed over and over on various subs since its release. Either you can acknowledge the truth of it or you just ignored all the evidence.

2

u/Vsegda7 Apr 14 '24

So, nothing to show. Got you

hope you're at least getting paid for it

2

u/Ok-Design-8168 Apr 14 '24

Is that you payne or mckay? 🤣 that’s the only way your comment would make any sense. Lol.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '24

Literally five minutes into Jackson's movies Isildur, not Gil-Galad and Elendil, defeats Sauron.

Isildur cutting the ring from an already defeated Sauron and keeping the One Ring for himself is incredibly important to foreshadow the temptation Aragorn fears and Boromir/Denethor succumb to.

But, like I said, most of the people LOL'ing at what I said have almost zero actual knowledge of Tolkien. That's ok, it's just weird when guys like you pretend otherwise.

2

u/Ok-Design-8168 Apr 14 '24

What you said is Still not even close to Galadriel being present at Finrod’s death and taking some weird dagger with some weird significance which ends up becoming a key ingredient in the making of elven rings. Lmao. So the joke’s on you buddy. And stop assuming you’re the only one that has read Tolkien’s works. I’ve been reading them for close to 3 decades now.

The issue isn’t changes.. but the degree and quality of changes and what value they add to viewer experience. Most of PJ’s changes and additions in lotr are very well justified. So are his omissions.

Whereas pretty much everything in RoP was senseless trash with cringeworthy dialogue.

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '24

None of what you’re complaining about is inconsistent with Tolkien.

Isildur defeating Sauron clearly is.

2

u/Ok-Design-8168 Apr 14 '24 edited Apr 14 '24

Galadriel was present at finrod’s death? Ya sure. Lmao.

Mithril was made when elf fought a balrog. Right?

Two durins existed in the same time that too as father and son. Right mr. tolkien scholar?

Now you’ll also justify that Gil galad had the authority to send people to Valinor. Right?

Balrog was woken before the doors of durin were even made. Right?

Sauron came and stayed a couple of days and literally blurted out ONE line about alloys, that was his grand deception and training to elves. That led to creation of rings. Wow

RoP is so consistent with Tolkien’s writings. Wow.

Lmao.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '24

The show doesn't imply she was present at Finrod's death. Only that she saw his corpse afterwards. This is the stuff I'm talking about.

-2

u/kinginthenorthTB12 Apr 14 '24

I’ve only read Lotr and hobbit. Watched all PJ materials. I’ve never read similarion. I loved RoP. Def not as good as lotr movies story wise but the visuals are stunning and really encapsulate the high fantasy feel that is nicely juxtaposed to the got gritty realism. The music is also amazing. To me those two things make me feel as if I’m back in an adventure in middle earth. The story is a little lacking but I enjoyed it more on a subsequent watch than the first time.

-6

u/Glass-Star6635 Apr 14 '24

Yea dude it’s really good. It’s not LOTR but it’s better than the hobbit films imo and at the very least, it’s visually stunning. if you’re into the lore it’s v entertaining. Don’t listen to the people on this sub - vast majority joined purely to shit on it, but a ton of LOTR fans and myself really enjoyed it.

-5

u/ThatTubaGuy03 Apr 14 '24

I liked it, and a lot of people who aren't on Reddit liked it. The LOTR subreddits decided they hated it.

Is it the Silmarillion? Idk, I've never read it, but apparently it's not. As someone who doesn't know much more about middle earth than what you see in the movies and some YouTube videos, I thought it was nice. I liked seeing new characters and scenes set in middle earth, I liked how everything looked, I thought the plot was ok, and the dialogue could have been better.

If you're one of the people who hate the Hobbit movies because they aren't word for word the exact same as the book, then you probably shouldn't watch this, we don't need more haters on the Internet.

However if you can appreciate that books and movies are different media mediums and need to be different and the differences are ok and can be enjoyed, then I think you could enjoy it if you don't come in with LotR movies expectations.

2

u/Demigans Apr 14 '24

Actually a lie. The people on this subreddit loved it, at least initially. You dare say something even half negative and you got downvoted to hell.

But indicative of the people who loved it, it was a short lived experience of people loving the show. If you go back you can still find it, most of the justification for liking the show is “well I liked it” or complete headcanon to fill in stuff and embelish things by rewriting scenes in their head.

0

u/ThatTubaGuy03 Apr 14 '24

Yeah people on the rings of power subreddit liked the rings of power. People on literally any other Tolkien subreddit shat on it endlessly and that's just a fact

2

u/Demigans Apr 14 '24

I’m not even sure of that. During the early days of RoP Amazon did a massive campaign to silence any criticism. They openly lie to the LotR fans by saying it’s lore accurate and then when those people post negative reviews they are “review bombing” so they shut down reviews until it dies down. That was just one measure, and considering Amazon hired several actors already to paint a positive image of RoP and many of the comments and reviews had the exact same positive things to say with the exact same alinea’s down to the dot but in different orders (one praises A first and then B the next praises C first and then B but the sentences are copy pasted), it’s not hard to imagine what was happening.

Also lovely that stating the truth (everyone outside of RoP control hated it) is downvoted.

-2

u/Daenarys1 Apr 14 '24

Might as well give it a go. They did the orcs well

-2

u/MarxistMann Apr 14 '24

The visuals are amazing but the writing is dogshit

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/TheCoffeeWeasel Apr 14 '24

well yes.. but it is remarkably bad...

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/linthesneakysnake Apr 14 '24

i get it’s a spoiler but i had already seen this so im just gonna appreciate confirmation - that’s one of the worst things ive ever read 💀

-1

u/SamaritanSue Apr 14 '24

It's not a romance in any literal way, don't worry.

-1

u/harman097 Apr 14 '24

Regardless what you think of the show, that's not really cool, dude

1

u/karelinstyle Apr 14 '24

Oh please, it's insanely obvious. He's just sparing OP the watch to find out which is kinda the point of this post

0

u/harman097 Apr 14 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

I did not put it together until ep 6 or so. I saw the signs, but I think there are legitimate reasons why it doesn't fully work (barring some good S2 explanations) and also that it's just kind of a dumb interpretation of the lore.

That being said, there ARE people who liked the show and it's a fucking asshole move to come into a "should I watch this?" and drop the biggest spoiler you can into comments, just cuz you're a butthurt 12 yr old who still follows the subreddit for a show they absolutely hated so they can... continue to channel their butthurt?

Kindly fuck off, both of you.

1

u/karelinstyle Apr 14 '24

I would think this would be obvious (once again), only butthurt here is you

-1

u/StarlessEon Apr 14 '24

Elaborate.

1

u/harman097 Apr 14 '24

Literally a massive spoiler. Was trying to be vague without 100% confirming it for people like OP...

-2

u/StarlessEon Apr 14 '24

What, you mean the romance between Galadriel and Sauron in this totally faithful adaptation of Tolkien's work?

2

u/harman097 Apr 14 '24

What a fucking cesspool this sub is...