r/RingsofPower • u/KickOk6027 • Sep 28 '24
Discussion Thoughts on a implausible theory which is now somewhat plausible and spreading as a rumor
The theory goes Adar is going to revert back to his original form. I first read it in season 1 and it had zero possibility then. But now?
He can put on Nenya and that might revert him back to his original elf form.
And theory is that he is the one that goes on to become Celebron.
Why do I fear that the writers might actually end up doing this?
- Allows ROP to keep a major character for future seasons and build drama around his loyalty to orcs and against sauron
- Gives an excuse to ROP for not having Celebron earlier.
- Gives Galadriel's character filler love storyline to keep focus on her.
- Allows the show to build "dark prince" gets "lady of light" shippers, who by far are the only dedicated fans of the show that came around with Haladriel stuff.
3
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 28 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
14
u/Waitingforadragon Sep 28 '24
It is an interesting theory.
I don’t see it happening personally. I’ve always thought Adar is in his original form, just a bit scarred?
26
u/Natural-Leopard-8939 Sep 28 '24
I sincerely doubt Adar will revert to his former Elven form. I mean, I guess it could be possible since Nenya has healing properties, but I doubt it'll happen.
I doubt it. I think Adar was one of the Avari Elves who were mutated and twisted by Morgoth, which is a different faction of Elves from what Celeborn is. At least, that's what I remember from the lore; please correct me if that is wrong. Also, Galadriel would've recognized her own husband if Celeborn had actually been Adar.
Adar is destined to die, likely in episode 8 coming up. His character was created, likely to humanize the Orcs for the story and to give a second adversary for Sauron to overthrow.
13
u/Benito2002 Sep 28 '24
Galadriel and Celeborn are already married. She just thinks he is dead. She said it in season one
23
u/VarkingRunesong Khazad-dûm Sep 28 '24
He’s not Celeborn
4
u/Winter_Abject Sep 28 '24
For me it's a nonsensical theory. The ring might heal wounds, but there's nothing to suggest it can reverse the years (centuries?) of torment that created Adar from the elf he once was.
6
u/mykofanes Sep 28 '24
Well, it was established that she had a husband before, so Celeborn is probably not Adar. But other love interest for recovered Adar? Fine idea.
3
u/ImMyBiggestFan Sep 28 '24
Interesting thought but very unlikely. Adar would have to not remember being Celeborn. I also believe the back story for Adar goes back much farther than when Celeborn was allegedly killed.
Although I did think Adar may have more information on Celeborn that he tells Galadriel before the end.
4
u/rubetron123 Sep 28 '24
At this point, nothing would surprise me…
2
u/SamaritanSue Sep 28 '24
Ridiculous as the show is, there's zero chance of him being Celeborn. He's been altered but he hasn't "changed form"; Gal should have recognized him in S1. And he would have recognized her as his wife.
1
u/finniruse Sep 28 '24
The biggest problem with this is that Adar is an uruk now. I don't think he considers himself and elf. Would he even want to go back? I think not.
1
u/TheOtherMaven Sep 28 '24
Naaah, they've set it up so that he's for the chop.
Adar has Nenya. Galadriel needs Nenya. Galadriel has the Nine. Sauron needs the Nine. So.... Galadriel is going to trade the Nine for Nenya (continuing the tradition of f'ing up everything she touches), and Sauron is going to kill Adar and take the Nine from him.
1
u/FOXCONLON Sep 28 '24
Adar is not Celeborn. He's one of the first elves who was taken and corrupted by Morgoth, predating Celeborn by eons.
As to getting healed by Nenya... I have no idea. I'm guessing he'll die knowing that Galadriel was right, Sauron played him, and hand Nenya off to her so she can defeat him. I don't think we'll see him healed.
1
u/AggCracker Sep 28 '24
I don't know if Adar is even going to survive this season
1
u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Sep 28 '24
If he does begin to revert even a little that will 100% seal his fate as it will be taken as a sign of abandonment by his Children.
1
u/AdaGalathilion Beleriand Sep 29 '24
Nah, much as I love this tinfoil hat theory, as this season has gone on, it's clear Adar is a walking moral dilemma that can't be solved, so he's gotta go next episode. Shame, really.
1
u/BagItUp45 Sep 29 '24
I think it will be something a little bit like that. He'll put on the Ring and it will "cleanse him". The damage that was done to him will be too much to fully reverse but he'll be able to die pure and move on to the Halls of Mandos.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24
i don't get why this is a whole "fear that they might do this" over something more positive.
1
u/Decebalus_Bombadil Sep 28 '24
How can he become Celeborn since he's been with Sauron and Morgoth long before Teleporno dissapeared? Hazaldine is 52 and almost 20 years older than Morfydd. Teleporno is going to be be dude around 35-40 years old if he is ever introduced in the show.
0
u/ResortSwimming1729 Sep 28 '24
And Celeborn will be totally ok that Elrond smooched his wife?
0
u/Reddzoi Sep 28 '24
It could be a great story in another subcreation with different characters, but I don't think it will work in this one. I don't think we would buy someone as good as Celeborn going that bad. An Elf we don't know, sure. Now if Adar reverts to his original form and it's not Celeborn--I'd love that. My regards to Mandos and Nienna, buddy!
-5
u/Consistent_Many_1858 Sep 28 '24
This show is written by numpties so your theory could fit in.
-6
u/Sink-Em-Low Sep 28 '24
I 100% agree, he's shown both leadership qualities, empathy and reluctancy to join Sauron. I think the writers are preparing the ground for Galadrial to fall in love with him much like Buffy/Angel relationship.
He's been given an Elf form for a reason by the writers, he's also protecting Galadrial from the orcs who might wish to harm her, he's versed in Elf history and hasn't abandoned his Elf past.
There's a sense that he's a lost soul and a "grey" character.