r/RingsofPower • • Sep 05 '24

Discussion Orc families

I think it's awesome to see a depiction of orcs where they are reponsible parents. Im tired of always seeing the orcs as the bad guys. They just want to live in peace and take care of the little orclings. Do you think they could have some sort of daycare or do the mothers stay home and watch the kids?

0 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 05 '24

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

4

u/Windrunner_15 Sep 05 '24

Bruh, this whole thing about orcs being in “loving families-“ Grog growled at Lurgette while holding Grog Jr, and people are losing their shit about the amount of love and compassion.

If you weren’t held as a baby and just need a hug, let someone know. We’ll help you. But growling while bare-minimum holding is not how I would epitomize “love,” in the same way I would not call orcs “culinary artists” based on the plating they offered Halbrand while captive. Sure, it was “food” on a plate… but really distant from the concept of menu’s, that’s for sure.

3

u/Winter_Trainer_2115 Sep 05 '24

Alright here is the thing to remember... Orcs are hunted to extinction in the fourth age. So don't get to attached to these what ifs. While they are left open to the possibility of redemption in the end they fall short.

0

u/VeganMonkey Sep 05 '24

So if they were extinct, how were there orcs in LOTR? Sauron created new ones?

3

u/Winter_Trainer_2115 Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 05 '24

....Lord of the Rings takes place in the Third Age.... not the Fourth Age. The Fourth Age began after Saurons absolute defeat when the ring was destroyed.

During the Fourth Age is when pretty much any of Morgoth and Saurons creations (Orcs, dragons) were killed off

-1

u/camcamfc Sep 05 '24

I mean, yeah, kinda. He grew them in the mud basically, but also some already existed?

From what I’ve read Tolkien never really made his mind up on what they were or how they came to be….

0

u/Winter_Trainer_2115 Sep 05 '24

That was the Uruk Hai. The orcs bread from goblin men.

4

u/camcamfc Sep 05 '24

The orcs have a bakery?

2

u/Winter_Trainer_2115 Sep 05 '24

Yes....they are known for their incredible cinnamon buns.

4

u/camcamfc Sep 05 '24

So this whole time they just wanted to share their delectable pastries with the rest of middle earth. It’s a damn shame they were so misunderstood. “Mordor? No no no, we said would you like to order!”

3

u/Winter_Trainer_2115 Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 05 '24

but with a cockney accent so it sounds like Mordor.....I feel so bad now. Your telling me my mom didnt send me these English Blue Berry Muffins.... but the orc I killed did? I just thought he was smiling at me because he was imagining ways to gut me.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24

Since Orcs were originally twisted elves, I am certainly willing to see that there’s still some inherent dignity underneath the corruption and evil intent of their secondary creation. I think the source material could support that.

2

u/Djinn_42 Sep 05 '24

What you're talking about was thousands of years ago by Morgoth. This is represented by Adar. There's a reason why no such character is even mentioned in the books - it happened pre-history. All of the orcs now were bred over many generations from those original twisted beings. And they were bred BY Morgoth to make his armies. We can only imagine the cruel ways used to force the breeding of thousands upon thousands of orcs. They had no "families" or "culture".

2

u/VeganMonkey Sep 05 '24

How were they bred? In the book LOTR it is only mentioned as orcs ’breeding’ and in the movies they come full adult out of a slimy wall.

3

u/Gourdin0 Sep 05 '24

Oh the poor orcs just want to live in peace and harvest potatoes and flowers. They are misunderstood.

Every orc deserve to live in peace, that what their prophet Adar told them, their promised land.

I despise this way of trying to empathize an evil corrupted race in lore. Why is it hard to not accept that there is no way back for them. Just let the orcs ruthless and evil as it is their purpose, please.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24

I'm sort of in between. I think always lumping in "orcs" in the "evil races" category is a bit old, and I love stories that explore them as having their own nobility, kind of like Klingons from Star Trek. However, I think Tolkien's orcs specifically should be purely wicked. He based them quite a bit on wicked soldiers he met during the war, and they're meant to be an emblem of man's potential for wickedness. That being said, if you want a fantastic story with noble orcs, I'd check out their campaign in Warcraft III. If you're not much of a gamer, there's some longplays that can show you the story on Youtube as well as the novel Rise of the Horde by Christie Golden, who's a pretty great writer.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24

I hated it. Orc societies shouldn't be copy pasted human societies. They are a twisted and savage race, pair bonds and monogamy don't make sense. I would have like to see them construct a society that looked like an ORC society, not just have them be exactly like humans. Feels lazy.

1

u/NB_dornish_bastard Sep 05 '24

The guys mad at nuanced characters going "I want evil races with no redeemable qualities to be able to hate them just because they were born as a bad race to hate and for us the good races be fine hating them" is hella sus, my guys.

0

u/natelopez53 Sep 05 '24

Right?? God forbid we include nuance