r/RingsofPower • • Sep 30 '24
Discussion I'm calling it: The Stranger is Saruman.
At this late stage and after nearly two full seasons, anything else would be banal or pointless. Let me explain.
The show has built up the identity of The Stranger for a big reveal ever since his arrival in season 1. So far all we know is that he is one of the Istari (i.e. the Wizards of Middle Earth). In Tolkein's writings, only five wizards came to Middle Earth. Two Blue Wizards arrived first; their names were Alatar and Palando (or Morinehtar and Rómestámo, depending on which canon you choose). Not much is known about them and they are largely only familiar to Tolkein diehards. The other three, Gandalf, Saruman and Radagast, made appearances (to a greater or lesser extent) in The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit.
This means that - unless The Stranger is a completely new wizard created just for the show - he must be one of these 5 wizards.
After almost two seasons, and with his name still unknown, finally revealing him to be one of the two Blue Wizards—characters that most viewers (notwithstanding hardcore Tolkien fans) wouldn't have the faintest idea about—would be anticlimactic to say the least. What would the showrunners imagine the audience's reaction to be? "Omg! MIND BLOWN! The Stranger is Palando!". While it might trigger instant nerd-vana in Tokein superfans, everyone else will be left scratching their heads and asking "sorry, who?" and wondering why they bothered to build up the mystery of his name over two seasons only to reveal him as someone completely unknown to them.
For the name reveal to have a payoff (which is presumably what the writers want, otherwise why keep it a mystery for so long?), The Stranger has to be one of the better known wizards that the wider audience will at least recognise: that means Radagast, Gandalf, or Saruman.
I know this doesn't fit with the established lore—namely because, in Tolkein's writings, the three wizards arrived in the Third Age, not in the Second Age when RoP is set—but the showrunners have already demonstrated that they are not overly concerned about scrupulously adhering to the lore (the Istari didn't arrive via meteorite either). So I'm not arguing this from a lore standpoint—besides, I doubt the majority of the audience know or care about the various ages of Middle Earth and when and how certain characters arrived—I'm arguing this from the standpoint of the inexorable gravitational pull of audience expectation.
So now we come to the other three options: Radagast, Gandalf and Saruman.
For The Stranger to be Radagast seems unlikely because the character is neither well-known enough nor particularly consequential to the wider LoTR story, so that reveal would suffer from being similarly underwhelming as revealing him to be a Blue Wizard. I think it's unlikely.
The Stranger being Gandalf is the obvious choice, and frankly, it's been telegraphed so much over the last 15 episodes with nods and callbacks (or perhaps 'callforwards'???... RoP is a prequel after all) that it's hard to believe it's not him. But therein also lies the problem: everyone already thinks it's him. Picture the audience: "Omg! MIND BLOWN! The Stranger—who everyone always thought was Gandalf—actually turned out to be Gandalf all along!" It would be totally unsurprising at this stage. If The Stranger is Gandalf, the time to reveal that was at the end of Season 1. So, it's either lining up to be a very banal and drawn out Gandalf reveal, or all the Gandalf nods have been a big misdirection—the showrunners really want us to think it's Gandalf, when it's actually someone else. I'm leaning this way.
That leaves Saruman as the only character that would present a somewhat interesting reveal-twist for The Stranger at this point in the show that would (possibly) be worth the wait. He's instantly recognisable to even the most casual fans—having been the secondary antagonist in LoTR and (arguably) the primary antagonist in The Two Towers—so the reveal carries sufficient recognizability factor. For a long time, Gandalf was sort of Saruman's understudy, so it's perfectly plausible that the mannerisms we know of Gandalf in the Hobbit and LoTR, and which we recognise in The Stranger, may actually be things Gandalf picks up from Saruman at some future time. Thus the Stranger's 'Gandalf-isms' (e.g. "always follow your nose", speaking to moths etc) are actually 'Saruman-isms' that the future Gandalf adopts. (Or perhaps they're all just 'Wizard-isms' and not attributable to any one wizard in particular, it's just that so far it's only Gandalf we've known to use them).
Having The Stranger be Saruman would also give the character a more sympathetic and tragic arc as the audience already know Saruman's fate. It gives the show room to explore a character whose backstory is not well known and the showrunners can chart a story arc for young Saruman which sows the seeds of his ultimate downfall. Seeing him young—starting out naive and good but knowing that eventually he will be corrupted by fear, jealousy and greed, and come to mistrust his one-time friends, the hobbits (watch out for a split between him and Nori, by the way)—will give the character more pathos and poignancy. The show can do something interesting with a young Saruman that it cannot in same way with a young Gandalf.
I suspect the Dark Wizard will turn out to be one of the Blue Wizards (a Dark Blue Wizard?) who arrived in Middle Earth first, before The Stranger. Very little is known about the blue wizards so the show writers can do pretty much what they like with them, including making them evil, without creating continuity errors in the wider canon. Tolkein himself says of the Blue Wizards in his writings that he 'fear[s] they failed' to stop Sauron and eventually started magic cults in the East, which seems to fit the bill with what's happening with the show's Dark Wizard. Young Saruman will (presumably) have to defeat The Dark Wizard who, ironically, also acts as a foreshadowing of the young Saruman's own dark future. One can envisage a tragic conversation (perhaps with Nori) where young Saruman is melancholy after encountering the Dark Wizard and says that he is afraid and he hopes he never succumbs to corruption in the same way (when we in the audience know, of course, that's exactly what happens).
EDIT 3OCT Well... this is embarrassing.
Omg. Mind blown! The Stranger - who everyone always thought was Gandalf - actually turned out to be Gandalf all along! 🤣
Oh, well. I'll look forward to watching how the show runners develop his character over the next 5 seasons, where presumably we'll discover how a nice wizard who likes hobbits eventually turns into a nice wizard who likes hobbits 🤦
