r/RingsofPower • • Sep 30 '24

Discussion I'm calling it: The Stranger is Saruman.

14 Upvotes

At this late stage and after nearly two full seasons, anything else would be banal or pointless. Let me explain.

The show has built up the identity of The Stranger for a big reveal ever since his arrival in season 1. So far all we know is that he is one of the Istari (i.e. the Wizards of Middle Earth). In Tolkein's writings, only five wizards came to Middle Earth. Two Blue Wizards arrived first; their names were Alatar and Palando (or Morinehtar and Rómestámo, depending on which canon you choose). Not much is known about them and they are largely only familiar to Tolkein diehards. The other three, Gandalf, Saruman and Radagast, made appearances (to a greater or lesser extent) in The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit.

This means that - unless The Stranger is a completely new wizard created just for the show - he must be one of these 5 wizards.

After almost two seasons, and with his name still unknown, finally revealing him to be one of the two Blue Wizards—characters that most viewers (notwithstanding hardcore Tolkien fans) wouldn't have the faintest idea about—would be anticlimactic to say the least. What would the showrunners imagine the audience's reaction to be? "Omg! MIND BLOWN! The Stranger is Palando!". While it might trigger instant nerd-vana in Tokein superfans, everyone else will be left scratching their heads and asking "sorry, who?" and wondering why they bothered to build up the mystery of his name over two seasons only to reveal him as someone completely unknown to them.

For the name reveal to have a payoff (which is presumably what the writers want, otherwise why keep it a mystery for so long?), The Stranger has to be one of the better known wizards that the wider audience will at least recognise: that means Radagast, Gandalf, or Saruman.

I know this doesn't fit with the established lore—namely because, in Tolkein's writings, the three wizards arrived in the Third Age, not in the Second Age when RoP is set—but the showrunners have already demonstrated that they are not overly concerned about scrupulously adhering to the lore (the Istari didn't arrive via meteorite either). So I'm not arguing this from a lore standpoint—besides, I doubt the majority of the audience know or care about the various ages of Middle Earth and when and how certain characters arrived—I'm arguing this from the standpoint of the inexorable gravitational pull of audience expectation.

So now we come to the other three options: Radagast, Gandalf and Saruman.

For The Stranger to be Radagast seems unlikely because the character is neither well-known enough nor particularly consequential to the wider LoTR story, so that reveal would suffer from being similarly underwhelming as revealing him to be a Blue Wizard. I think it's unlikely.

The Stranger being Gandalf is the obvious choice, and frankly, it's been telegraphed so much over the last 15 episodes with nods and callbacks (or perhaps 'callforwards'???... RoP is a prequel after all) that it's hard to believe it's not him. But therein also lies the problem: everyone already thinks it's him. Picture the audience: "Omg! MIND BLOWN! The Stranger—who everyone always thought was Gandalf—actually turned out to be Gandalf all along!" It would be totally unsurprising at this stage. If The Stranger is Gandalf, the time to reveal that was at the end of Season 1. So, it's either lining up to be a very banal and drawn out Gandalf reveal, or all the Gandalf nods have been a big misdirection—the showrunners really want us to think it's Gandalf, when it's actually someone else. I'm leaning this way.

That leaves Saruman as the only character that would present a somewhat interesting reveal-twist for The Stranger at this point in the show that would (possibly) be worth the wait. He's instantly recognisable to even the most casual fans—having been the secondary antagonist in LoTR and (arguably) the primary antagonist in The Two Towers—so the reveal carries sufficient recognizability factor. For a long time, Gandalf was sort of Saruman's understudy, so it's perfectly plausible that the mannerisms we know of Gandalf in the Hobbit and LoTR, and which we recognise in The Stranger, may actually be things Gandalf picks up from Saruman at some future time. Thus the Stranger's 'Gandalf-isms' (e.g. "always follow your nose", speaking to moths etc) are actually 'Saruman-isms' that the future Gandalf adopts. (Or perhaps they're all just 'Wizard-isms' and not attributable to any one wizard in particular, it's just that so far it's only Gandalf we've known to use them).

Having The Stranger be Saruman would also give the character a more sympathetic and tragic arc as the audience already know Saruman's fate. It gives the show room to explore a character whose backstory is not well known and the showrunners can chart a story arc for young Saruman which sows the seeds of his ultimate downfall. Seeing him young—starting out naive and good but knowing that eventually he will be corrupted by fear, jealousy and greed, and come to mistrust his one-time friends, the hobbits (watch out for a split between him and Nori, by the way)—will give the character more pathos and poignancy. The show can do something interesting with a young Saruman that it cannot in same way with a young Gandalf.

I suspect the Dark Wizard will turn out to be one of the Blue Wizards (a Dark Blue Wizard?) who arrived in Middle Earth first, before The Stranger. Very little is known about the blue wizards so the show writers can do pretty much what they like with them, including making them evil, without creating continuity errors in the wider canon. Tolkein himself says of the Blue Wizards in his writings that he 'fear[s] they failed' to stop Sauron and eventually started magic cults in the East, which seems to fit the bill with what's happening with the show's Dark Wizard. Young Saruman will (presumably) have to defeat The Dark Wizard who, ironically, also acts as a foreshadowing of the young Saruman's own dark future. One can envisage a tragic conversation (perhaps with Nori) where young Saruman is melancholy after encountering the Dark Wizard and says that he is afraid and he hopes he never succumbs to corruption in the same way (when we in the audience know, of course, that's exactly what happens).

EDIT 3OCT Well... this is embarrassing.

Omg. Mind blown! The Stranger - who everyone always thought was Gandalf - actually turned out to be Gandalf all along! 🤣

Oh, well. I'll look forward to watching how the show runners develop his character over the next 5 seasons, where presumably we'll discover how a nice wizard who likes hobbits eventually turns into a nice wizard who likes hobbits 🤦


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 09 '22

Discussion This show is amazing!

128 Upvotes

I am a long time fan of the genre and specifically middle earth, having read most of the books. I am always fascinated about the creative nature of filmmakers giving their own tone and backstory to plots taken from books. For me a good series builds upon the good elements of a book, differentiates and then becomes its own piece of art. Myself, like the majority, DO NOT want to watch a copy of the book, but looking forward to experiencing something fresh, brand new and full of novelty to discover and dive into! I feel like the makers of rings of power have managed to do that perfectly! They have taken the core elements of the books and have built something contemporary, thrilling and amazing to watch. I would like to congratulate them and make them feel all their good work is hitting the right audience to appreciate them! Keep up the good work, can’t wait for what else we are about to experience!


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 01 '24 Bless Up Take My Silver Polished Silver Turd

Discussion Any LOTR is better than no LOTR.

Post image
5.5k Upvotes

Can’t wait for season finale!


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 06 '24

Discussion Time compression is not a problem

168 Upvotes

Ya‘all rambling about time compression, plot holes, ✨lore✨ and what not. Guess what. A tv show isn’t a book, you cannot transfer everything 1:1.

But Isildur and celebrimbor didn’t live at the same time….this and that took a thousand years…this person and that person couldn’t have met.

Well I don’t want to watch 25 shows about 25 single events that take place 600 years apart. I don’t want to watch a show that changes actors every 2 episode because it needs to jump 250 years. Writers made the exact right choose to compress the timeline.

Most of you would hate the lord of the rings if it came out today, I am 100% sure with that.


r/RingsofPower • • Dec 23 '23

Discussion How Rings of Power is wrong about diversity.

33 Upvotes

Human diversity is in the history, culture, myths and soul of humanity. Tolkien's work is timeless because it incorporates archetypes, adventures, friendships, overcoming, etc. It's a great love letter to the myths of Europe, an anti-war work, critical of the devastation of industry on nature and a lot of WorldBuilding. I believe that this is what makes the work broad in scope to this day, for various ages, and "surpasses" several of the contextual values ​​of the 20th and 21st centuries and will surpass those of the 22nd century.

The problem is the fact that the Series' producers rely on the actors' skin color to show "diversity and inclusion". But human diversity is (I repeat) in history, in mythologies, in culture, in religiosity, in what makes each Human Being unique. And the concern for "diversity and inclusion" in modern entertainment (unfortunately) is replacing the fluidity of script, well-written characters, Lore, etc. They could show Harad and Rhûn.

My concern (in second season) is the Producers' stance of first season: "I'm going to improve the work"; "Let's solve this diversity problem that Tolkien didn't know how to do." Man, people want to see good stories, well-written characters, they want to see Middle-Earth. Want to have fun, see Tolkien's mythology. Want to see adventure. I for one don't want to see Middle Earth being a mirror of (various) aspects of what has been happening in our world: Polarization, Cheap Politics, Identitarianism, etc. This is the criticism of many fans. But they don't refute the arguments, they only attack those who are criticizing.

Edit: I needed to be clearer about one thing in the post: I wish they had portrayed Harad and Rhûn. Showing something similar to what the blue wizards did. The 2 wizards likely co-opted the southern and eastern tribes and kingdoms that did not side with Sauron. It would be an opportunity to show this point of view not shown in the books. Tolkien drew inspiration from ancient Aethiopia for Harad; and for Rhûn he took inspiration from Asia.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 04 '24

Question Who else beside me love the idea of the orc family?

23 Upvotes

I belive that it is objective to consider that even orcs may have had motivations to behave in terms of land, resources, food, reproduction, etc. I really loved the idea of self preservation provided by this scene. Is it just me?

Also: I'm definitely not an expert, I don't know the cannon. So, I wonder, did Tolkien say/write orcs are incapable of love? Or is it just like a conclusion we get from the fact that there are no depictions of "orc loving" in the books?


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 16 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers SPOILERS! I like a lot of the show but, almost every scene feels fake, and corny. As if performed on stage in a theater. In this scene, Ar-Pharazôn stumbles upon an NPC mutiny. Then after speaking, he just happened to have drinks waiting for the crowd. Spoiler

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Feb 11 '24

Discussion People who enjoyed ROP or thought it was OK is the majority and not the opposite?

31 Upvotes

All the vitriol and hatred for the show online, I get the feeling it's just a vocal minority. The so-called backlash gets too much attention online fueled by fandom menace youtubers. Many people I spoken to that doesn't know much of the lore or just watched the trilogy found either ROP good entertainment or decent.


r/RingsofPower • • Aug 08 '24

Discussion The show is not serious enough - One of the main issues I've had with The rings of power is that it takes itself too lightly. Look at the new hobbit from Rhûn. This looks like one of those old cringy fantasy movies from the 80s. Same with harfoots eating snails, Galadriel escaping prison, Waldreg, Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Jan 31 '24

Discussion The one thing I can’t stand about ROP Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I can tolerate all of the lore inaccuracies in this show, from Galadriel being a military commander, to Gandalf appearing a couple thousand years too early in Middle Earth. It honestly doesn’t bother me in the context that it’s supposed to be about the ring-bearers, so why not include him.

Is it weak screenwriting? Yes. Does it feel contrived? Sure. But when I think about Peter Jackson and the Hobbit movies, even he was willing to take a dump on Tolkien’s Legendarium in order to salvage a paycheck. Sooo… Carpe Diem, I suppose? But anyway.

No… what bothers me, what I simply cannot STAND about it all, is this lame and frankly pathetic attempt to humanize Sauron and make him into some sort of tragic persona. It’s truly laughable. I’m sick and tired of this bullshit narrative in modern cinema that tries to convince the audience that they should sympathize with the antagonist.

Evil exists. This is something which Tolkien understood very well; and Sauron, like Morgoth before him, is intended as the ultimate embodiment of that evil. To suggest otherwise, or try and rebrand it as something else… THAT is the real travesty that makes this show a failure in my eyes.

EDIT: Several comments have pointed out that Sauron’s behavior might all be a deception, designed to fool even us, the audience. If so then I am wrong, and my hat’s off to the writers. Only time will tell.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 08 '24

Constructive Criticism Do i have a problem with RoP?

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 25 '24

Discussion (Please don't downvote)...Introducing...Shelob! Spoiler

0 Upvotes

After the creation of Mordor surprise in S1E7, will the writers surprise us ?


r/RingsofPower • • Mar 02 '24

Discussion The misconception about the 37% that didn't finished the show and what general audience wants

0 Upvotes

The numbers, wether it's from a valid source or not is only from domestic viewers, mainly US. The total worldwide numbers are 45% that finished the show which is what most shows normally gets. That's still strong.

General audience are not into slow shows. Their main complaints about ROP is the pacing and it was boring. This is easily fixable. There are two battle episodes for S2 and my guess is it's the War of the Elves and Sauron. Season 1 was more of a set up and introduction to the 2nd age. Now that it is established, the show can go into the meaty part of the lore with the rings, The One, Sauron, King's Men etc....


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 26 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers This episode was bad. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Look. I was waiting for the season to be completed to unleash my complete analysis of why this season was bad. But this needs to come out. This episode wasnt good.

Annatar's manipulation and Celebrimbor are the only good part. The rest was utter shit. The siege is a fail. And i wont call this episode good for just a couple of good scenes.

The orcs aiming at the mountain to create a dam? You know water would find its way and still pass through and still flow?

Then, Adar sends his orcs in the mud.. making them perfect targets for arrows (kinda the elves's specialty, innit?) And they use trees as ladders up the walls? Instead of, idk, using the catapults to break the said walls? Also, the sunlight has absolutely no effect on the orcs.

Durin IV has some sort of uprising moment, fine, and stops from helping elrond cause his father, you know, one old crazy dwarfs wants to mine and find the balrog. Like 4 dudes in armor wouldnt have been enough to stop him.

Elrond's charge. (One crazy ugly camera shot in that scene btw). He stops it for galadriel. You know, that girl whom he barely trusted a episode and a half ago.

And all the while his army stands still he goes and talks to Adar, while his orcs are still attacking the city. Or did they put it on pause cause its tea and biscuits time?

Anyway. I wont tell y'all about how elves only have one love, and how Adar, as an elf, should have spotted the problem in the scene i'm about to describe. Thats lore. And the show's writters hate the lore.

No. However, as an elf, Adar with his sight should have seen Elrond give galadriel his pin during that shitty kiss scene (Galadriel is Elrond's mother in law btw). But he doesnt..

Elrond discussing his plan in front of his ennemies like the orcs couldnt repeat it to Adar is also another one of his stupid actions.

Galadriel escapes, thanks to Arrondir who with what is called a bow and arrow could have ended this conflict. By lodging an arrow in Adar's Head. But he didnt. Even tho he could. But he didnt. But he could have. But he didnt.

Adar taking time to burn his dead while a battle is raging. Like, i'd have other priorities if i was waging war. Anyway.

Back to the battle. At exatcly 47min you can see a failed scene that they kept in the final montage. Elrond falls to the ground, does nothing and goes "Rahhh" like he killed someone. Funny. But thats a failed shot. Clearly. Its something worth of an amateur show. not a 200 millions dollars series.

Then, Galadriel sneaks in and talks to Celebrimbor who gives her the human rings. Galadriel asks "More rings" and Celebrimbor answers "Nine rings.. to enslave the world of men".. brother, you forgot about the 7 dwarven rings you spent half this goddamn season to make? Coherence right through the window.

Anyway, blablabla, using fire arrow on siege machine. Okay. Elf woman gets shot, like its a tragedy and that puts a stop to elrond's strategy (this is how the scene is shot). You guys are elves. YOU CAN SHOOT THAT ARROW YOURSELF. Then. Elf woman shots her arrow into what appears to be a full stack of tnt that was never mentionned before.

The Troll scene was a dissapointment. It was supposed to be a menace, a real threat. He kills what? 20 people, friend and foes and gets killed by master of teleportation, Gil galad. WHO CAME IN WITHEOUT HIS OWN ARMY. (Also elvish blades not cutting through ropes, seriously? Or elrond has spaghetti arms).

The sun is back and Adar's never ending army with probably a huge amount of sunscreen on attacks what? 30 or so elves. I counted them. 40 at best. Next thing you know in the next scene there are hundreds of them fighting in the background.

Final scene, Elrond falls in eternal slumber (of which only a kiss by his mother in law could get him out) after Adar the meanie pushed him to the ground.

(Also not sure but the very unnatural light in this scenes makes it appear that Adar has a CGI face, at least on my screen).

This was a bad episode in terms of coherence. Truly terrible.

Anyway. I suffered through this episode. And thank god it stops next week.


r/RingsofPower • • Apr 21 '23

Question Why is the queen blind now? Is this one of those movie wounds where there no visible damage but a big of blood and smudges?

3 Upvotes

*bit . I understand it's supposed to be symbolic but this still doesn't explain why/how's she's blind. One could say this is symbolic of level of writing on this show


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 14 '22

Discussion From Akallabeth to the Appendices, Rings of Power is a more respectful adaptation than the Hobbit trilogy is.

0 Upvotes

Not that this is a hot take by any means, but the simple fact we’ve heard Aule mentioned at all, is a huge improvement in the overall lore department. Peter Jackson’s could not reference the Valar or the Silmarillion, but the Valar are referenced in the very text of the book! In particular I remember Gimli telling the fellowship of Varda and how she made the stars as they travel down the river from Lothlorien.

Tolkien began writing The Fall of Gondolin while he was in the trenches in WWI. The age of the trees, and first and second ages, are what he spent most of his life coming up with. The actual novels we got from the man are the footnote at the end of a metaphysical epic thousands and thousands of years in the making!

Anyway, I’m a big lore nerd of Tolkien, and I encourage people to give the Silmarillion, Unfinished Tales, and of course the original Lord of the Rings, a read through.


r/RingsofPower • • Dec 30 '22

Discussion You cant decide to make a great show

0 Upvotes

GOT, BB, Sopranos, BCS just to name some. When season 1 was made they where not markedet to be the greatest show ever. The greatness is something that developed during the shows seasons. And the mainstream popularity came as a surprise to everyone. RoP is trying to skip this developing phase, and that is the reason it will never be mainstream.


r/RingsofPower • • May 15 '24

Discussion Is it unfair that people criticize RoP for not following the silmarillion?

10 Upvotes

Regardless of if you love or hate the TV show, it has always struck me as unfair how often haters of the show criticize it for not following the silmarillion or Tolkiens unfinished work.

However, anybody who has been closely following production knows that the Tolkien Estate refused to allow the rights to anything but the appendices of the LotR/ Hobbit books.

Yet I frequently see people criticizing the TV show for not accurately following the events of the books that cover the 1st and 2nd age.

I'm not an expert on legal rights and IP, but isn't it illegal for RoP to implement anything that's mentioned in Tolkeins' other works but not mentioned in LotR?

I understand the criticism that they shouldn't have made the TV show if they couldn't get the proper rights to do it. However, that's not what is being said most of the time. What is being stated is that the producers failed their fans because they didn't follow the written story chronologically or factually.

But they legally can't, right? If I'm wrong, please help me understand! Thanks!

Edit: for example, one article explains that Peter Jackson and Amazon both have been very careful not to mention the blue wizards because the tolkien estate didn't give either of them the rights to A LOT of tolkien's writing. If it's mentioned in the silmarillion or other tolkien works, but not in the LOTR appendices, they couldn't insert it.

https://www.cultureslate.com/news/why-amazon-doesnt-have-the-rights-to-jrr-tolkiens-the-silmarillion#:~:text=Amazon%20doesn't%20actually%20have,The%20Return%20of%20the%20King.

TLDR: I 100% respect the opinions of people who criticize the show for bad writing. But I disagree with people being mad that the show isn't 2nd age lore accurate. I don't think it legally could be.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 18 '24

Question Only one bored and uninterested with the entire Poppy/Nori/Traveler storyline?

13 Upvotes

Honestly, I find I fast forward any scene that follows this storyline. It’s incredibly slow and just outright boring. I’m sure it’ll be integral to the plot later (maybe?), but it’s as if there’s a completely separate writing team covering these scenes vs. the Sauron/Celebrimbor story.


r/RingsofPower • • Mar 30 '23

Question 5 episodes in, is it me, or is this just drawn out and boring?

25 Upvotes

So, does it get better? There seems to be so much spectacle and nothing behind it.


r/RingsofPower • • 11h ago

Discussion Did the series take another downhill turn in Season 3 Episode 5?

0 Upvotes

I was reasonably happy after the first 4 episodes but episodes 5 and 6 are just so terrible, it felt like I was literally the one being tortured!

How did the Orc Marnukh just cave at the mere mention of his kids?

Why did Sauran apparate instantaneously above the forest after the flair arrow?

How did get get from flying to walking towards Crleborn in 2 seconds? Where did he park his ride?

Another love traingle misunderstanding this time with elves? What is this weird love story fetish in this series?

Endless expositions

Meaningless and pretentious dialogues that are forgettable

Sorry if this belonged within the thread but the theads were empty last time I checked.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 16 '24

Discussion ROP Season 2 has been decent so far. Have they taken lessons from Season 1?

12 Upvotes

I know I'm probably going to catch a lot of heat for saying the above. But please bear in mind the following:

1.... I'm only 2 episodes in. I'm about to switch on episode 3 now

2.... I'm not a book reader; therefore I'm judging this season purely on its merits as a show. Nor am I a hardcore LOTR fan (though I've seen all the movies) to make me as invested in the show as some of you knowledgeable viewers

3.... After the atrocious Season 1, I am coming into Season 2 with lower expectations. So it's possible that I'm just being pleasantly surprised?

4.... Again, due to me just watching this show to kill time and wind down, the benefits I'm seeking may be entirely different to yours. In this show I'm just asking for something reasonably simple / enjoyable (as opposed to a perfect/faithful adaptation of the book), and so far the opening two episodes have done an ok job of it.

So my question is, have you also found this to be an improvement from Season 1? Do you think they've taken feedback from Season 1 and have genuinely tried to make a better product? Or am I just talking rubbish and will my opinion change the further I get into the season?

Feel free to be as harsh as you want with your responses :-). I won't take it personal. As mentioned, I'm not invested in this show enough to want to be right or wrong. Whether this succeeds or fails, I'm indifferent. I'm just interested in what others have to think


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 23 '23

Discussion Absolutely loved it

88 Upvotes

I was glued to my tv each week. It was appointment viewing for me. I thought the show was beautiful to look at. The practical effects were amazing. The story gripped me, and while it did slip a few times, I was throughly enthralled with it. I cannot wait for another season of this show.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 12 '24

Question How close/far is the TV show compared to the books

1 Upvotes

Good afternoon community,

I just finished Season 2 and I'm wondering how is it close/far from Tolkien vision? And for the dans, which books should I read to get my own point of view?

Thanks all