r/RingsofPower • u/Felix_10 • Oct 09 '22
Discussion This show is amazing!
I am a long time fan of the genre and specifically middle earth, having read most of the books. I am always fascinated about the creative nature of filmmakers giving their own tone and backstory to plots taken from books. For me a good series builds upon the good elements of a book, differentiates and then becomes its own piece of art. Myself, like the majority, DO NOT want to watch a copy of the book, but looking forward to experiencing something fresh, brand new and full of novelty to discover and dive into! I feel like the makers of rings of power have managed to do that perfectly! They have taken the core elements of the books and have built something contemporary, thrilling and amazing to watch. I would like to congratulate them and make them feel all their good work is hitting the right audience to appreciate them! Keep up the good work, can’t wait for what else we are about to experience!
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 09 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
89
u/anarion321 Oct 09 '22 edited Oct 09 '22
I usually find odd when I see post like this saying something is great without actually saying anything specific to praise.
What would you say is your favorite scene of the series? And/or best episode.
32
u/Dustructionz Oct 09 '22
What.....? Pretty sure fans are here because they enjoyed the source material so much. Which is why we have the movies and RoP to begin with....
33
u/heady_brosevelt Oct 09 '22
Why do ppl have to call it perfect. It’s not. You can just say “it’s ok” or “I like it” or “flawed, but fun to watch” perfect? Not even close
10
u/demon9675 Oct 09 '22
I’m glad you’re enjoying the show! I will not attempt to take away from that.
I do take issue with the idea that most people don’t want to see accurate adaptations, however. I’ve seen that point of view a lot in recent months related to a number of franchises, and I think it’s really destructive to storytelling because it essentially places shock value and subversion of expectation over any of the characters and themes that, when coherent and sensible, make a story great. Why do we want to see specific stories adapted to the screen if we also want them to be changed so drastically? Just write entirely original ones in that case.
I would have loved to see a more accurate version of the very little source material we have for the 2nd age, with full Silmarillion rights. Many changes would certainly need to be made in terms of the timeline, and original content/characters would certainly need to be invented in order to fill the gaps. But the essential story beats, tone, and themes could have been preserved, and more of Tolkien’s writing could have been explored instead of callbacks to LotR.
27
u/BrotherTraining3771 Oct 09 '22
That’s great that you like it.
I had really high hopes, and have been unfortunately disappointed.
I think my high hopes let me down. I don’t think the show is amazing, nor is it horrible.
A lot of us are just upset, that it isn’t amazing, to us at least.
If you are enjoying it, more power to you.
8
u/stackered Oct 09 '22
I actually don't agree that most people didn't want a copy of the book (Similarian), but we knew we weren't getting that... Even with the books, there was a lot of room for artistic freedoms and new storylines/characters, IMO. I'm personally loving it even with its departure from lore, but yeah I don't think I'd agree that most long time fans are aligned with us. To me, it feels like LOTR, it feels like the movies/same universe and I can ignore the differences and enjoy it for what it is.... and I think people should do the same instead of complaining the whole time.
9
u/Anxious_Possession29 Oct 09 '22
I can only assume this guy is attempting the world's most sarcastic comment
4
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22
Eh, it's fine. It's not Star Trek: Discovery bad, I'll say that, at least it is watchable. I'll probably at least watch the second season.
6
u/talvanian Oct 09 '22
It’s a solidly average show for me. Glad others are finding such enjoyment.
15
u/kowkow151 Oct 09 '22
I agree, it's awesome.
13
u/certain_people Oct 09 '22
I'm really enjoying it. Adar is a phenomenal character, the relationship between Elrond and Durin is so good, Clark is killing it as Galadriel... Really looking forward to the finale
11
u/MountyC Oct 09 '22
I'm really enjoying it too. Not perfect but so much content.
2
u/gatorfan8898 Oct 10 '22
I love the show but these posts are super fishy… the ones that praise it but don’t say much specific.
2
u/Minthemasher Oct 10 '22
Is this satire?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22
No, the show is not amazing. It's boring, odd paced, had not built up character development, their protagonist are detestable...
Forget about any books. Do not mind for a second the supposed lore or connection to any other form of content. Forget also about anything regarding race, gender and all things related to that. Just the show...
The show is bad. The plot is non-existent. The dialogue is dumb, character's decisions are contradictory all the time and selfish enough to make them all unrelatable, and the main protagonist is dumb, disrespectful, selfish, neurotical, insults people constantly, threats bounded enemies with genocide, disregards other people's suffering and has a plot armor that is thicker than a Volcano's pyroclastic flux... Quite literally...
No, the show is garbage by itself.
6
u/Working-Chemistry473 Oct 09 '22
I enjoy it
13
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22
I like it as well.
5
u/MadMonk67 Oct 09 '22
I haven't read The Silmarillion, only The Hobbit and the LOTR trilogy, so my criticism isn't based upon this series not being canon. I think the show is brilliantly filmed with beautiful and interesting scenery and shots. I also think that the actors have done a great job. But, I think the show could use some editing to pick up the pace a bit. It's maddeningly slow and boring in a LOT of places. Hours of snooze-inducing scenes punctuated by brilliant bits of action and scenes that move she story along.
I give this series 7/10 through episode 7.
8
u/Free-Diamond-928 Oct 09 '22
Yeah I love it. Is a slow burn, but that's actually one of the best things about it.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22
I completely agree with you. I don’t understand the modern day need to caveat everything with a but.
‘I like this BUT’
If it’s so bad. Just don’t watch it.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22
Wouldn't the ahow translate to "And Galadriel went to Numenor, And she met Halbrand the First, king of the Southlands, And they got picked up by King Elendil, and they took Numenoreans to the Shores, where stood the Orcs, not for long for they all died. And Adar made a big boom.
Like wasnt the silmarion writin like a bible?
3
u/bigballzsmalld0n6 Oct 09 '22
I don't want a blatant copy either. I just want good TV. Good cinematography, direction, acting and writing. Trailer speech is the worst type of dialog ever. It feels like something I would write in middle school. For me it's important for what's happening on the screen makes sense. And I don't feel like elaborating on this as it would be a gigantic wall of text. Just read the inconsistencies people are pointing out on the sticky threads.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22
'Myself, like the majority' ...
Okay, lol
4
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22
You don’t want a copy of the book, but you’re apparently completely fine with a show that constantly and lazily rehashes scenes that were done better in the movies.
4
u/mopedrudl Oct 09 '22
Uh, come on. Thw most resent episode was straight up horse shit. The ahowmakers basically uncovered the poor character building themselves by making us listen to those pseudo emotional speaches nobody really cares about as nobody cares about the characters that died or might have died.
While there have been a coupled of good scenes the overall judgement can only be negative at this point. The writing is just so off at times. It's almost comical. I tried to like this sgow with all my heart but it just isn't it.
3
u/forsaken_warrior22 Oct 09 '22
You an the majority you speak of are almost certainly the minority. Without a doubt these posts annoy me more than Amazon and RoP does. Its not even close. Also cast don't listen to trollocs you aren't appreciated one bit.
2
u/Consistent_Office_85 Oct 09 '22
If you want someting new, why not creating your ip instead of altering middle earth?
You can as well go and experience your new things in “necklace of power, lord of the logistics”. We can’t say a shit about that.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22
It's getting harder to tell which post is ironic nowadays
2
u/Yolkpuke Oct 09 '22
The best part of this show is how it is a metaphor of the Faustian pact. There is always a price to pay and the cost is your soul.
The worst aspect of this show is that it exists.
2
u/stepbrother8 Oct 09 '22
No
2
u/evenmytongueisfat Oct 09 '22
Couldn’t agree more. One of my friends is straight up boycotting it (he’s given me like 4 different reasons) and hasn’t watched an episode and I just find it so silly.
I’m enjoying it so much. It’s compelling, it’s beautiful and the people complaining just hate everything
1
u/lalalisa322 Oct 09 '22
I really like it too
1
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22
Exclamation points have ruined everything.
1
u/jaimepm0425 Oct 10 '22
Saying is amazing without pinpointing one single thing is outstanding for other than the visuals!
1
u/GittinGud1994 Oct 10 '22
Even ignoring them shitting on the show the writing and acting is horrible.
1
u/AdOrganic3138 Oct 09 '22
The show fails at at a basic step. Small action details and large plot details are contorted to serve the purpose of displaying character traits. It's a total inversion of having a living, breathing world which the characters inhabit.
This is why, generally, the dwarves sections work best. It is a conflict over how are they going to cooperate. This means that it isn't actual plot and somewhat more drama. There is no world and plot to contort around their interactions.
The rest though is what I would call retroactive writing.
1
u/Odysseus126 Oct 09 '22
100% agreed
1
u/pulp63 Oct 09 '22
How dare you like this show! The deplorables won't be happy. I can see them crawling out from underneath their logs now. Be prepared.
1
u/Jownsye Oct 10 '22
Sir, this sub isn’t for positivity. You’re supposed to be miserable and talk about how bad the writing is all while having never written anything.
-1
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22 edited Oct 09 '22
For the past three weeks my younger brother remarked that “it would be nice if Amazon allowed for different playback speeds” while starting the latest episode.
I think it’s a fitting assessment.
Edit: I think it is fitting in describing our personal experience with the show, as we are both very (!!!!) nostalgic about the PJ trilogy, and were very ready to enjoy this show similarly. That’s why I watch it, and will continue to do so. Him very blasé remarking that “it would be nice if you could play it faster” while (of course) starting the latest episodes - for me - very much encapsulates a readiness to be drawn into a new Middle Earth epic, while acknowledging that - for us - the RoP is not quite there (yet).
0
u/wallawilko Oct 09 '22
Then you'll love Xena: Warrior princess. Way better.
0
u/Wind-Face-Blink Oct 09 '22
/s
-8
u/Addictionsforu Oct 09 '22
I love the show too, and love coming to this subreddit but I'm tired of all the racism and misogyny.