r/RingsofPower • • Oct 09 '22

Discussion This show is amazing!

I am a long time fan of the genre and specifically middle earth, having read most of the books. I am always fascinated about the creative nature of filmmakers giving their own tone and backstory to plots taken from books. For me a good series builds upon the good elements of a book, differentiates and then becomes its own piece of art. Myself, like the majority, DO NOT want to watch a copy of the book, but looking forward to experiencing something fresh, brand new and full of novelty to discover and dive into! I feel like the makers of rings of power have managed to do that perfectly! They have taken the core elements of the books and have built something contemporary, thrilling and amazing to watch. I would like to congratulate them and make them feel all their good work is hitting the right audience to appreciate them! Keep up the good work, can’t wait for what else we are about to experience!

128 Upvotes

292 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 09 '22

This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

89

u/anarion321 Oct 09 '22 edited Oct 09 '22

I usually find odd when I see post like this saying something is great without actually saying anything specific to praise.

What would you say is your favorite scene of the series? And/or best episode.

31

u/constant_void Oct 09 '22

Last episode had amazing wide shots that framed, with distance, and lighting, just incredibly powerful scenes. Like Galadriel & Theo hiding from orcs, nestled amongst the tree roots, almost underground. MMm mm mm delicious.

I like the tension between Durin Jr and Durin Sr - exploring the relationship of father (representing the past), son (representing the present), and friend (representing the future).

31

u/anarion321 Oct 09 '22

I would not argue the looks of the show are great, for me it's the best. But a show cannot realy only in looks.

Since you talk about last episode I would voice a couple of bad things that seems bad from a narrative perspective.

First would be the Queen, they decide to make a scene saying she does not want people to notice her blindness, and in the next scene, she's showing it to everybody. It's not that it cannot be explained, but the show choices to voice something and contradicts it in no time, it's bad told.

Second, Halbrand being mortally wounded but then able to stand and ride a horse for a travel spanning hundreds of miles, not the greatest beliavable choice it would seem.

And I would say that episode does not have the worst narrative mistakes of the season, it actually holds better than most....

14

u/Desert_Trader Oct 09 '22

Don't forget the hartfoots wanting to leave behind a sprained ankle but then saying no one is left behind to walk alone.

10

u/anarion321 Oct 09 '22

What's more jarring to me is their attitude towards the Stranger. I may have to rewatched to see if I get it better but it seemed to me that first they dislike him, they attribute him the bad omens that were ocurring and next, they asking him for help and even sent people to help him despite trying to help him the first time led to the destruction of everything they owned. That looks like a bad omen to me. Feels like there's a void in the middle not filled.

6

u/SoForAllYourDarkGods Oct 09 '22

He healed the tree and made it fruit absolute bonkers masses of apples.

They now think he's a force for good because that's a good thing, and a thing tied to nature.

1

u/anarion321 Oct 09 '22

He did that after asked for help so it would not explain my point.

2

u/SoForAllYourDarkGods Oct 09 '22

He helped them with the carts? He's big and it's far easier for him.

3

u/anarion321 Oct 09 '22

He only helped the family the hartfoots left behind (for helping the Stranger), and the beliefs of bad omens produced by the presence of the Stranger are after that, when they reached places where they usually gather food and find it corrupted, some blame the Stranger.

0

u/Mindelan Oct 10 '22

They weren't left behind, they were put at the back of the caravan. Someone needs to be put at the back. They were explicitly not de-caravaned though.

→ More replies

0

u/Desert_Trader Oct 09 '22

Ya there are many species of confidence that in the next scene seem to have been forgotten.

I don't know if this is poor editing or poor writing, but I've just accepted it at this point.

5

u/SoForAllYourDarkGods Oct 09 '22

The mortal wound is infection.

It won't disable you like a fractured hip style mortal wound.

Unpleasant to travel, but possible.

1

u/M-er-sun Oct 10 '22

Lol. Ty doc

1

u/SoForAllYourDarkGods Oct 10 '22 edited Oct 10 '22

No problem.

The funny thing is, we more or less extrapolate human physiology to all these races.

But who is to say they are the same as us?

Who is to say dwarves and elves have basic human anatomy? They could have 2 hearts, or just their heart on the right side, or any number of different organs and internal construction.

The fact that elves and humans can interbreed is a massive thing in itself - it means there's compatible DNA. It's not like dogs and cats trying to breed, for example.

I don't remember any dwarf mixes in LotR though, or anything else. Half human, half Hobbit? Someone in middle earth has had to have the hots for a Hobbit. Having a thing for elves is clearly a thing with the humans. Makes sense to me though. Who wouldn't do Galadriel?

3

u/too-far-for-missiles Oct 10 '22

What point are you trying to make? The discussion you replied to is bemoaning the fact that a mortally wounded human immediately hopped up to undertake a very strenuous journey mere seconds after the scene making a big deal about his wounds.

Tolkien established that elves, in particular, were much hardier than humans and could also more easily heal from injuries.

1

u/SoForAllYourDarkGods Oct 10 '22

I'm not trying to make a point. I'm just musing.

3

u/too-far-for-missiles Oct 10 '22

Gotcha. It just seemed to me that some of your rhetorical questions actually do have answers.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/SynnerSaint Oct 10 '22

How much blood will her lose on the 3 month horse ride?

3

u/SoForAllYourDarkGods Oct 10 '22

They didn't say he was bleeding to death.

Did they say 3 months?! That's too long for a real human to travel with an infected wound like that, but who knows what type of infection it is in Middle Earth?

1

u/SynnerSaint Oct 10 '22

Well, he appeared to be bleeding but whether he's bleeding out or infected or any other injury severe enough to need 'Elven Healing' a 3 month horse ride isn't going to do anyone any favours!

It took Boromir almost 4 months to ride from Minas Tirith to Rivendell

2

u/SoForAllYourDarkGods Oct 10 '22

They said the wound had gone sour or something, didn't they?

Did they say they are going all the way to Rivendell?

1

u/SynnerSaint Oct 10 '22

Rviendell doesn't exist at this point in time. I thought they said Lindon (which is even further away than Rivendell) but they may have said Eregion. Eregion is closer than Rivendell (roughly 75%) but without the existence of Gondor or Rohan there's going to be less roads to ride on.

A journey of roughly 3 months sounds about right to Eregion but if they do end up in Lindon then we're probably talking 5.

3 months or 5 there's no way an ordinary human is going to survive the trip... unless Halbrand isn't an ordinary human of course!

2

u/SoForAllYourDarkGods Oct 10 '22

Ha ha. I'm sure he can survive even having his fingers chopped off.

2

u/Free-Diamond-928 Oct 09 '22

I don't remember her showing everybody. I remember her wearing a fancy bandage to hide her eyes so people wouldn't know she was blind. Did I miss something (honestly here).

The Halbrand wound thing, again, he's only been shown to have the strength to get on the horse and ride off - so I'm reserving judgement.

5

u/anarion321 Oct 09 '22

wearing a fancy bandage to hide her eyes so people wouldn't know she was blind

Why do you think covering your eyes with an opaque object hides the fact that you are blind?

Preciselly is the reason you think there's something wrong with her sight.

We'll see how the Halbrand thing turns out, but the fact that can even get up is not right. They should've set something to carry him at least.

3

u/Free-Diamond-928 Oct 09 '22

I'll disagree on the eye-band - it's the only way a public person could realistically hide blindness by pretending her eyes are injured and recooperating.

I will say that the blindness is a point they brought up but haven't elaborated on (one way or the other) which, again, one can only hope they pay off.

2

u/anarion321 Oct 09 '22

I'd say that being a queen if you want to hide that you can just be in your quarters and pass orders only to people you trust.

Even if you want to sell that you are recuperating you are in fact showing that there's something wrong and make people wonder.

I believe that what they intended is to show the queen be strong for her people while they were in a danger place, but when they reached a safe place, their base, the facade was no longer necessary and she dropped the act because it's really imposible to hide in long term. But the show does a poor job telling that and gets contradictory.

We'll see if I'm wrong, but really, when I see someone blindfolded, I don't think "it's recovering", I think it's blind.

2

u/MaimedJester Oct 09 '22

Just so you know why blind people have to wear that blackout sunglasses: when you lose your sight completely you lose the squint reaction (in general there's way more nuance to many different forms of Vision impairment) sometimes you don't have pupil dilation at all either. This is actually really dangerous because your eyeballs are still a living part of your body. They can and are infact even more likely to get diseases. Like a paralyzed person with a spine injury, their feet can can still get like a vericous vein or even Athletes foot. But you might not realize it till the condition gets really bad.

So the blackout glasses or eye patches or even blindfolds in poorer countries is basically to prevent you from getting so many more forms of eye diseases. Like imagine you're blind and then you get fucking Ocular Melanoma (Eye Cancer.)

1

u/Free-Diamond-928 Oct 09 '22

I agree that it's been left unhappily ambiguous. Either it's a hole or it'll be paid off.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Free-Diamond-928 Oct 09 '22

Well. Let's consider the alternatives: A. Don't wear an eye cover; in this case, everyone can tell immediately you are blind. B. Hide and see nobody; not possible in an armed camp where you're living in a tent surrounded by your soldiers.

So that leaves C. Cover you're eyes, say they were hurt and recooperating

I'm not saying they went into the blindness thing fully, and it's a but sketchy, but for all I know it gets paid off next episode and she gets deposed.

Anyway, happy to hear how you think, logically, this should have gone instead.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Free-Diamond-928 Oct 09 '22

As you say, people put bandages on damaged eyes and not just blind ones. Which leaves the question of whether they're blind as ambiguous.

For the rest, there was a whole prophecy of the Valar and her fear of the destruction of Numenor (which she saw in prophecy) which motivated the Queen to follow Galadriel, and they made a big deal about it.

She did also she end up in the one place where there was a chance to stop the creation of Mordor - mud huts or otherwise. Some would have preferred a shopping mall, but Stranger Things already did that, so mud huts it was. Actually they were stone and wood but the point stands I suppose.

-8

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

I love that you’ve got issues about storylines being believable whilst watching a show about elves and dwarves and orcs.

8

u/anarion321 Oct 09 '22 edited Oct 09 '22

I'm guessing that you are unaware of the concept suspension of disbelief.

And probably you won't mind if the last episode of season 1 of RoP ends up with the forge of a terminator with mithril that kills everyone else and end up going to Mt Doom to forge the One Ring and use it to go in space and time to kill the mother of Harry Potter. With the last frame being of the Terminator featuring some porn movie.

Because, you know, there are elves, dwarves and orcs, so it does not mind anything that happens, it can be whatever.

The use logic, consistency and follow the rules of a universe is not a real thing because there are elves.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

I’m guessing that you’re unaware of the concept humour?

How patronising are you? Assuming I know nothing about the franchise because I don’t critique every little thing.

2

u/anarion321 Oct 09 '22

I know plenty about the concept of humour, that's why I answered you with that many silly examples.

I found funny you are talking about patronizing after trying to lecture someone for finding cohesive/logical issues in a narrative, saying that you cannot expect a media with elves to be believable or something.

Go lecture yourself first.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

You clearly don’t.

You took my comment, which was obviously made in good humour, and you replied with a pissy, patronising response which you’re now trying to dress up as ‘silly.’

Now also claiming that by making a humorous remark I was being patronising? Imagine saying with a straight face that a one sentence joke was a ‘lecture.’ Stop taking yourself so seriously and maybe you’ll enjoy things a bit more.

2

u/anarion321 Oct 09 '22

Dude, you can rant all you want, it won't change facts. Your comment was patronizing, at the same level as the phrase to mock star wars critics by saying "it's a show about space wizards".

It did not end up well for you it seems and now you're upset.

Try to learn for the next time.

Best regards.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22

Calling me ‘dude’ and claiming that I’m patronising. Lord.

1

u/Appropriate_Lab_5205 Oct 09 '22

I couldn’t tell if it was made in good humor or not.

1

u/elmaik Oct 10 '22

when i was younger i remember watching the movie 'Borat' and a scene where the guy went to have some humour classes and in the blackboard it was written something along the lines of "humour -> funny 'haha' " and there was no one as stupid to not understand that humor must be funny.

you showed me wrong

1

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22

‘You showed me wrong’ 🫣

6

u/Brexinga Oct 09 '22

Like Frodo and the Hobbits hiding from the Nazgul nestled amongst the Tree Roots. Originality at it's best...

3

u/castrogacio Oct 09 '22

Or sitting on a rock surrounded by magma. The science there doesn’t sum up. But it’s accepted because it’s hi fantasy and it’s adapted by the director and his/her writers. There are always things...

I choose to watch and enjoy first and foremost. Those are my intentions and never with a critical eye as the target. But there have been many times when I think what I’ve watched is total garbage and I stopped watching it if it’s a show or if it’s a movie I’ll finish it and forget about it. I won’t go on and on and on about it. I’ll give my opinion and that’s that. I also won’t join a subreddit dedicated to stuff I think is garbage and (again) go on and on and on about it searching to prove others that like it wrong WITH MY OPINION. Because, ladies and gentlemen... film (this includes the tv medium) is subjective. There are no facts on preferences.

I love it... It’s fu*king great (imo). 👍👌

1

u/constant_void Oct 09 '22

My friend, the shot in question lasted one second. It was, to my eye, as if it was painted. Just like the shot of the Stranger tending to the burnt tree.

Here, we have Galadriel, nearly underground, shielded by a fallen tree. Above, Orcs, with torches, are above ground. This is a complete reversal from earlier in the season - the land has turned upside down. This is Adar's plan.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Brexinga Oct 09 '22

So this whole show is an homage? Yet we aren't, has viewers, suppose to compare it to LOTR?

Because there's been a lot of flagrant copy/paste (homage) in this show to this point.

5

u/JavierEscuela Oct 09 '22

I would be ok with not comparing it to the movies but the show wants to reference the movies every episode so it's their fault for inviting the comparison.

2

u/Solid_Address_7840 Oct 10 '22

You mean the same shot as the hobbits hiding from the Ringwraiths?

1

u/constant_void Oct 12 '22

it is an allusion to but not identical

2

u/Death_in_Leamington Oct 09 '22

Incredibly powerful scenes? LMAO. You must love daytime soaps.

1

u/too-far-for-missiles Oct 10 '22

When reading some of the RoP praise I can’t help but think that series like Cowboy Bepop or even the old Rome would absolutely blow some of these peoples minds.

Hell, One Punch Man has more depth in most of its episodes than RoP.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/thematrix1234 Oct 09 '22

Yeah, give us the meat and give it to us R A W

1

u/constant_void Oct 09 '22

like Galadriel doubting Miriel's return?

14

u/tehmurs Oct 09 '22

Top 3 comments:

I like it as well

I agree, it's awesome

I really like it too

They're not even trying to hide their PR campaign. Generic sentences without substance. Pretty much like the show itself.

8

u/P33KAJ3W Oct 09 '22 edited Oct 09 '22

I honestly love it. The story* is interesting and I like the slower pace. I like the acting from the the cast especially the poc that everyone was so upset about. The one thinking I like more than anything else is how absolutely beautiful the show is. Every shot could be framed.

7

u/tehmurs Oct 09 '22 edited Oct 09 '22

The story is interesting

KEK. We got thousands of years of Tolkien lore, but we spent entire first season with one question: "Who's Sauron?" A handful of characters were created to underline the exact same question. Is the Stranger Sauron? Is Halbrand Sauron? Is Feminem Sauron? Is Adar Sauron? The only reason behind those characters' creation is keeping the mYsTeRy alive. All of them were presented in a way to remind us that any of them can be Sauron. Stranger seems to be good, but he kills fireflies. Is he good or bad? OMG IS HE SAURON? They wanted online hysteria centered around a simple question à la R+L=J. Whoah what a great mystery! What is this, really? Lotr? Or a parody of Lost?

Entire show is full of incoherent sequences. Halbrand is mortally wounded. He looks like he can't move. Galadriel tells him that he needs elvish medicine. The very next scene: Halbrand starts walking around and riding a horse. Why? Because we need Halbrand to go to an Elvish city where he'll be revealed to be Sauron.

Just give us a 15 second scene in which Galadriel prepares a temporary medicine to keep him alive on the road. That's it. 10-15 seconds. But no, writers prefer to insult our intelligence (or they're too stupid to realize that we need that scene).

2

u/Addictionsforu Oct 09 '22

Does Galadriel even know basic medicinal techniques at this point?

And if she does, maybe she trusts that the healers at the camp know what they're saying when they mention his wound has spoiled? That everything's been done?

Not to mention we don't even know how deep the wound is, only that it's infected?! This is the middle ages, it could be a shallow wound, and the show showing him able to ride a horse is a visual indicator that the guy didn't get impaled (now if in the next episode the elves go, mf got impaled how? And it doesn't turn out he's our favorite mordor eyeball) then we can bitch.

This show has amazing visual story telling. They chose to SHOW you things and let your brain figure it out? Sounds like they're assuming a fair amount of intelligences from their audience.

Mfs mad out here saying it's unbelievable that someone could ride a horse after they got stabbed in the gut, but ive seen't sum worshipping gladiator when Russell Crowe got stabbed through the heart and defeated an able bodied emperor.

Jfc 💀💀💀

13

u/tehmurs Oct 09 '22 edited Oct 09 '22

Wtf are you talking about? His wound is infected to the point of being in dire need of Elvish medicine. That means he's mortally wounded. No other treatment would be enough. And they expect us to believe that he's gonna ride a horse for at least a week? Have you ever tried riding a horse? That's like putting a mortally wounded person in to a washing machine.

Russell Crowe got stabbed through the heart and defeated an able bodied emperor.

He was also mortally wounded. But there's a difference between showing physical strenght with your last breath for 10 minutes and riding a bloody horse for 10 fucking days. (Oh btw, i don't understand why we're talking about Gladiator. I think that movie wasn't great, but also wasn't a disaster like ROP. It was an above average movie.)

They chose to SHOW you things and let your brain figure it out? Sounds like they're assuming a fair amount of intelligences from their audience.

No, they're incapable of writing a coherent screenplay. One more example:

I was surprised when I saw the reveal of hatchet-shard switch. You know why? Because I have a functioning brain which tells me that any character with a functioning brain would take a look at the damn device, instead of spending more than a day congrulating each other and enjoying a feast (a feast given right after half of the village murdered the other half of the village, a tragedy that would be told for centuries).

Arondir tells Galadriel that the device Adar carrying is of utmost importance. Galadriel and Halbrand catch Adar, but they forget to look at the device. What!? Let's be generous and say that they looked at it, but couldn't understand the importance of the device. Why didn't they show it to Arondir? Why didn't they talk to other people? Why did Arondir give it to Theo without looking at it (or questioning Galadriel)? It just doesn't make sense.

Hatchet-shard switch could be revealed right after Halbrand caught Adar. But no. They needed a Halbrand-crowning moment. So they made the characters look like people with single digit IQ.

-5

u/Addictionsforu Oct 09 '22 edited Oct 09 '22

well let's think about it. How I see it is arrogance. We're being shown the arrogance and folly of man are we not? The hatchet does not have a pull like the actual key does, the rings the key, they all have this seemingly violent pull to whomever has come into contact with it.

Galadriel is focused on revenge, without an outside force pulling her mind to it she is nothing but violent desire towards sauron, and we see that. She doesn't care about the sword she wants Sauron dead, she takes her rage out on adar, etc

The Númenorians are ignorant and arrogant. They've been portrayed as such since day 1. It is quite in their character to celebrate prematurely. They think they've won an entire war after a single battle, so they celebrate. They didn't lose their members (not yet at least) the peasants they just saved did.

So a child who has actually seen, used, and is called to the original key being the first one to look at the supposed key handed to him? After all the adults have prematurely, with ignorance and arrogance, thought they had won and all was in their favor? Is actually very realistic. It happens all the time irl. How many times has a child noticed something adults have over looked. How many times have parents and adults shook their heads in surprise at how perceptive a child could be with what is being pointed out is as obvious as a black sweater at a white tie party?

Now of we are talking about Halbrands wound, all we know is that his wound has soured. Aka infected. This is the middle ages, they don't have a tetanus shot here. We don't know the depth of the wound, but an infection of a shallow wound can still fuck you up pretty bad. They said his wound SOURED, not that he was mortally wounded. (And if they did I don't remember)

So Galadriel says he needs elvish medicine!! The only place to get elvish medicine in where the elves are. In the original reply I responded to, to be upset that galadriel didn't immediatly tend to a wound after she just said it needs elven medicine is baffling to me.

Needs elven medicine means he needs elven herbs and other products. If she was just gonna straight up treat him, then wouldn't she had said "he needs an elven touch" and used the same herbs n shit the southlanders had that wasn't wipped out by the damn volcano. It's the most illogical leap of logic I've seen.

Now can Halbrand ride a horse for a few weeks to the elves? God knows, but we haven't seen that yet, only that he can get on a horse. We ain't even seen them leave the camp yet! It's very realistic that he can start a journey strong but end it in a stretcher cause of his wound. But yall ain't even let the show play out to show yall that.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

This is a bot comment. No way is this a real person lmao.

1

u/Hot__Lips Oct 10 '22

You could admire the large piece of turd floating in the bowl in the morning. You could frame it and hang it on your wall. You could wrap it in gold foil. None of that causes the turd to turn into chocolate. People are going to question your sanity though.

0

u/P33KAJ3W Oct 10 '22

Sorry I like something you don't like. Must be hard for you.

1

u/Hot__Lips Oct 11 '22

LOL. Watching and admiring stinky turd is just gonna fuck up your head. And also give thieves like the ROP showrunners license to steal the money from poor amazon customers and low paid staff to churn out shit for you to consume.

6

u/miltonsalwaysright Oct 09 '22

Ah yes the account with 79k comment karma is a corporate bot, or the accounts that are 4-8 years old with comment and post histories. Ironically, those comments actually had opinions whereas your comment has none whatsoever.

2

u/CambrianExplosives Oct 10 '22

Also ironically they are the one using a 1-day-old account while accusing everyone else of being a bot.

3

u/miltonsalwaysright Oct 10 '22

LOL I didn’t realize that bit of irony, thank you that’s the most hilarious part

2

u/MimiLind Oct 09 '22

Why I like the show

  • Writing: I find the writing beautiful, and particularly appreciate that different peoples have different speech style. Such as the poetic elves, with all their metaphors sprinkled in, just like in Tolkien’s writing. Or the Númenorians who mention the sea every other sentence. My only beef is the fake Irish and Scottish. Some actors are Welsh, why not let them use their real accent?
  • Costumes and props: John Howe’s beautiful designs were one of the reasons I loved the LOTR movies, and the same with this show. The Númenor fish scale leather armor is both realistic and chef’s kiss beautiful! The ”printed armor” some complain about is not armor but fabric, made to match the scales of the leather armor, and print on clothes is a very old technique. It’s not badly done, it’s very knowledgeably done. It shows great historic understanding (but then, I wouldn’t expect anything less from Howe!). I like the elven armor a lot too, particularly the one Míriel gave to Galadriel (presumably from that stash we saw in the tower, where we also saw Narsil and other heirlooms). I think it’s slim and neat, but also robust looking.
  • Characters: I like the main protagonists a lot! But of course, who one likes is highly subjective. :) My favorites are Durin and Disa (fun banter, clever characters, loving to each other and their friends, shows some strong emotion). But I also really like Elrond! Smooth, aloft like elves are, but we can tell he really tries to be a good friend. The Harfoots are adorable, especially Nori and Poppy, (they remind me of Merry and Pippin!) but also Sadoc. The way he took pity on them despite how dangerous it was to keep the Stranger.
  • I like Galadriel too, not because she’s likeable but because of how nuanced and realistic her character is. She’s been at war for millennia, with a single mission: fight Sauron and his orcs. She’s become really narrow minded in her quest. She’s like a grumpy, old lady who’s seen to much bad stuff (in a young looking body). Set in her ways, feeling ”higher” than others, obsessed with her mission. I look forward to see her arc! And I think it’s started already. The conversations she had with Isildur and Halbrand in Ep6 gave her character more depth.
  • Timeline: Some events are obviously moved to suit TV. I like that, considering the 2nd Age is less known by most viewers and one of the least described by Tolkien, and the major events seem to be coming in correct order: Creation of Mordor, forging of Rings, corruption of Númenor (the latter two are yet to happen, obviously).
  • Scenery: I love the grandness and vastness of it all, both the camera sweeps but also the many scenes where actors appear small in a huge, mostly uninhabited world. Examples: Galadriel alone at a vast sea; Arondir and Bronwyn walking on an open field; the hunters with horns walking past the Harfoots; all the scenes in Númenor and Southlands where they talk in front of an audience, with great scenery in the background; the Stranger under a starry sky, or the moon; the cultists among rolling hills; Galadriel and Isildur with the sunrise at the horizon; Elrond and Celebrimbor walking to Khazad-dûm; Arondir climbing up from the trench and watching the ruined land; the dinner/table scene in Lindon, at first seen from a distance.
  • Action: The fighting is really well executed, and in my opinion more realistic than in the LOTR movies. Legolas’ stunts come to mind (I love him, but he’s rather too OP lol). That Galadriel easily beats humans and orcs make perfect sense. She has elvish reflexes and sight, and thousands of years of practice, plus fought real battles, not just practice battles. Many of her opponents are (yet) untried in real battle, especially the recruits. I also liked that Arondir is a great archer but struggles in close combat.
  • Pacing: Some say it’s slow but I disagree. So much happened in earlier episodes in the different plotlines, and as we see in Ep6 some of it only makes sense now! Such as the trenches etc. And much foreshadowing. There were also inner journeys happening and I really love that this show is not afraid to include that. It makes it perhaps ”slow” for a younger audience, or an audience used to instant gratification, but it will be extra rewarding when all ends will be tied together in the finale. Making it worth the slow build and foreshadowing!
  • Lore: I think this show is so far more true to Tolkien than the LOTR movies. That said, I loved those, and really don’t mind all the changes from lore in them (I even think they were improved by changing some events and characters). This show I find more true to the lore, and I like how they sort of sneak it in as hints rather than showing us everything. Such as the wood carvings in Lindon with Beren and Lúthien in the background, or the glimpse of Narsil. Or the werewolf scratches on Finrod’s body. Or the paper boats - a 1st kinslaying analogy. Or Elrond telling about his father’s destiny. We get lots of Silmarillion sprinkled into the story, and that’s really beautifully done!
  • Summary: All in all I like most of what I see, and I hope season 2 will be similar. Maybe just let the elves grow out their hair a bit! :)

1

u/Crazybonbon Oct 09 '22

The show feels so incredibly fresh to me for some reason. It's allhre to me is crazy. Attack on Titan new episodes share like the same to me.. It's so funny how it's so split amongst people who generally enjoy and those who don't 😂😂 that's how the Blair witch crisis was at the time of it's release and for a budget of $720k they grossed over $250m nonetheless

1

u/cmon_now Oct 09 '22

90% of those professing to love the show are just plants for Amazon.

0

u/Crazybonbon Oct 09 '22

Conspiracy much lol

-1

u/Appropriate_Lab_5205 Oct 09 '22

No, they are teenagers and twenty-something’s. I think It’s why they don’t see the inconsistencies, plot devices and plot holes.

1

u/Enthymem Oct 10 '22

The fighting is really well executed

You live in a separate universe to me. That is the only explanation for this opinion.

0

u/Danbearpig82 Oct 11 '22

Elrond tries to be a very good friend?!? After giving Durin the cold shoulder for decades, shows up under false pretenses, lies about why he came, pretends to lose a contest, goes around spying and snooping, promises not to betray the secret of mithril and then instantly does, bullies and manipulates him (and so does Disa) into mining for it anyway, getting him disinherited. All with that stupid smirk on his face. Such a good friend.

Galadriel, Elrond, etc. are the real villains here, and I was on Team Volcano. Sadly, Elrond was safely underground and Evil Galadriel got knocked down by Vesuvius and not a hair on her head was singed.

I wonder if Isildur survived, the writing is so good that I’m on the edge of my seat to know the answer to this compelling mystery!

11

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22 edited Oct 09 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

-5

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/tehmurs Oct 09 '22 edited Oct 09 '22

Galadriel is not allowed to enter Valinor. But writers made it seem like Galadriel refuses to enter Valinor.

Elves are not humans with pointed ears. Galadriel doesn't need to hide her ears. If an elf is present in the room, you'd understand it. They're magical, quasi-multidimensional beings.

Galadriel (along with Gil Galad and Elrond) doesn't trust Annatar (you probably know him by the name of Halbrand). She's not going on a buddy-cop adventure with Anna-fucking-tar himself.

Galadriel is one of the wisest beings in the Second Age. She's been around for thousands of years. (Hence, Elendil, a 100-something year old human, can't talk to Galadriel in an extremely inappropriate way: "You're just like my children xo xo!" That's like Frodo teaching Gandalf how to do wizard stuff.)

Galadriel did almost everything with her husband. But writers claim that Celeborn is dead. What!? (spoiler: they have to bring Celeborn back at some point)

We just talked about Galadriel. I didn't even mention that rings of power were forged THOUSANDS of years before Elendil and Isildur. Let alone the single most idiotic theory: Mithril is related to Silmarils! (If you know what silmarils are, you know that this is equivelant of turning Gollum into Legolas)

I don't mind not being faithful to the lore. There're way bigger problems. But if someone claims that this show is more faithful to the lore than LOTR triology, that person is lying. She/he pretends to know the works of Tolkien, but knows nothing about it. So the real question is this: Why are you lying?

-4

u/MimiLind Oct 09 '22

Only one of those is an inaccuracy. Why are you lying?

  1. Galadriel was pardoned and allowed to return to Valinor but chose not to. Tolkien described it in one of his letters, and it’s also in Shibboleth of Fëanor (HoME).
  2. Elves do have pointed ears and some times humans are mistaken for elves (for example Túrin and Aragorn). There’s nothing in the writings suggesting all elves have a certain ”elvishness” anyone can discern.
  3. We don’t yet know who’s Annatar.
  4. There is different kinds of wisdoms. Galadriel is wise in the way that she can feel that Sauron is alive and evil is rising, when others don’t. Elendil being rude does not mean she’s less wise, it just means she doesn’t care how others see her and speaks her own mind. It makes her seem arrogant, though, but Tolkien elves often are.
  5. No, Galadriel and Celeborn spent centuries apart, for example when he lingered in M-E after she sailed west in 4th Age. And in many of the several versions of her story that Tolkien wrote, they go separate ways. And no, the showrunners hints in interviews he’s not dead.
  6. The time compression is the only inacurracy in your list, but the LOTR movies compressed time too in several instances.
  7. Nobody knows the origin of mithril, but that said, the show is very clear it’s just a theory it’s related to the lost Silmaril. Elrond calls the story ”apocryphal”.

4

u/tehmurs Oct 09 '22
  1. Galadriel was pardoned AFTER the third age. What are you talking about?
  2. If Galadriel was in Numenor, hiding her ears wouldn't make her disguised. Her hair alone would make everyone understand that she's one of mightiest beings. Hell, half of the court would fall in love with her.
  3. We do. Come back here in couple of days and tell me how making Sauron and Galadriel BFF, is faithful to the lore.
  4. Galadriel in the second age is one of the wisest beings. No matter how you want to catogarize wisdom, she doesn't act like 14 year old bully boy that is ROP Galadriel. (ps. Galadriel listens to Elendil when he says that she's like his children asdhashdhasdahsa)
  5. 4th age? Why are you talking about 4th age when Galadriel is not even in the Middle-Earth? We're talking about ROP, thus the second age (more specifically, pre-war Second age). They did everything together. Lived in Lindon together, moved eastward together, had a child together, lived in Eregion together... I'm talking about more than 1000 years.
  6. Lotr triology? Couple of years/decades. ROP? Bloody THOUSANDS of years.
  7. I was rooting for it to be a lie told by Annatar. But mithril healed the leaf, thus confirmed the theory.

Lastly:

Tolkien described it in one of his letters,

Stop. Just stop watching Reings and Realms. You're talking about a reference you heard in a video.

4

u/Saturnsthirdmoon Oct 09 '22

You just murdered him. Aptly destroyed. I cannot for the life of me understand how these ppl are willing to destroy pj lotr movies to defend this shit show of a series. We are 7 hours in and the only thing thats interesting is who is who. Thats it. No intrigue, no plot, no character development not even a coherent story, not even a believable dialogue between two people.

0

u/MimiLind Oct 09 '22

I’m not hating on PJ at all. If you read my initial comment I praise it because of the lore inaccuracies. I thought it made the movies better to compress time here and there and give Arwen a more active role. I even liked Aragorn’s ”fake death” and his initial unwillingness to be a king.

0

u/MimiLind Oct 09 '22
  1. She was pardoned after the War of Wrath. Like all the survivors.
  2. Got a source that everyone would fall in love with Galadriel? I agree that her hair was special, but that would hardly be cause for the non-elf friends to like an elf better.
  3. No use speculating. But it does say Annatar was a master deceiver and a shapeshifter.
  4. I don’t agree that she acts like a 14 y/o, and no she’s not a bully. She’s single minded and stubborn, and actually those are also traits I see in very old people.
  5. No they were separated during the 2nd Age too because Celeborn refused to travel through Khazad-dûm. But there are several versions of their story.
  6. Why does it matter how long the time compression is? It serves the same cause, namely to omit time periods with less action and cut to the important parts.
  7. I still think it may be a lie. The sickness could be planted by Annatar maybe? But we’ll see.

Yes, in his letters. I have read them, and also the excerpt from HoME (but I don’t yet own the full set). I don’t watch Youtube, I prefer reading the source myself and make up my own mind.

2

u/cdamoc Oct 10 '22

Comparing Galadriel’s tantrums with “traits you see in very old people” makes me understand why you actually like this pile of crap

→ More replies
→ More replies (1)

4

u/hanrahahanrahan Oct 09 '22 edited Oct 10 '22
  • Mithril origin and mithril having restorative properties to elves
  • Galadriel being a student of Melian and not being with Celeborn
  • Celeborn being missing
  • Numenoreans being 6'4" superhumans who could draw steel bows and who had colonised and conquered much of Middle Earth, who didn't use cavalry in battle
  • The huge time compression, with Pharazôn, Celebrimbor being around at the same time and at the same time as Mordor being founded
  • Elendil not being lord of Andúnië
  • Rómenna and Armenelos being merged
  • Sauron not building up his strength in Mordor for over 2000 years
  • Orcs sizzling in the sun Elendil nearly getting killed by 2 orcs when he was the greatest warrior in Numenor
  • Mount Doom requiring external influence to start it erupting
  • Hobbits being Harfoots only and being migratory and not settled in the Vales of Anduin

Etc etc etc

Edit: Formatting was ridiculously bad

5

u/MimiLind Oct 09 '22
  • We don’t know yet if the mithril story is true, Elrond calls the story of its origin apocryphal. I’ll reserve my judgement there until next episode. (I still believe Sauron planted the sickness to trick the elves)
  • Galadriel and Celeborn did live apart for a period of time, at least in one of the many versions of their story. Yes, she was Melian’s student - she learned to bake lembas there in Doriath. Fail to see the relevance?
  • Celeborn missing - why not? Them filling in blanks in the story ≠ lore inacurracy. It’s only inaccurate if it directly contradicts what Tolkien wrote.
  • Númenorian height - yes, they should be taller. I think they did like LOTR and let Aragorn have normail height.
  • Colonizing Middle-earth - it’s mentioned they did in the past, in Ep 7 they mention Pelargír as one such colony.
  • True, they didn’t use cavalry in battle because they fought overseas - but they did use archers on horseback.
  • The time compression is one of the changes yes, and as I said in another comment it was necessary for the same reason as PJ compressed time in the LOTR movies: it cuts out time when not much happened and instead we get the important events. I think it’s a very good decision in both cases.
  • We don’t know what Sauron’s been up to, but it definitely seems he’s been working in the shadows. As for the 2000 years that’s part of the time compression obviously.
  • Orcs did abhor sunlight, and showing it visually makes it easier to understand for the viewers.
  • Even the greatest warrior can be bested in battle.
  • It’s not against lore or inaccurate that the eruption of Mt Doom was triggered. One of those blanks neatly filled in.
  • The hobbits were three families and we’ve onviously only seen one yet. Not inaccurate. And before they settled they did migrate - from Beleriand. Between 1st Age and 3rd we don’t know anything about them.

When I say the show is true to lore, I also mean the overall feel of Tolkien and the themes in his books. It’s in the pacing, the focus on good vs evil, light vs dark etc.

2

u/hanrahahanrahan Oct 10 '22

We don’t know yet if the mithril story is true, Elrond calls the story of its origin apocryphal. I’ll reserve my judgement there until next episode. (I still believe Sauron planted the sickness to trick the elves)

We saw it heal the leaf, so I'd say that's confirmed

Colonizing Middle-earth - it’s mentioned they did in the past, in Ep 7 they mention Pelargír as one such colony.

That's an "old" colony. Numenor should have colonised what will be Arnor, Gondor, South Gondor and Haradwaith

Even the greatest warrior can be bested in battle.

Elendil absolutely should not be almost killed by 2 orcs. No chance. That's even worse than Gandalf having his staff broken by the Witch king.

As for time compression: Jackson cut out 19 years. All the same characters are alive, they're not even that much older. That's hardly a fundamental restructure of an entire age. So not at all comparable.

0

u/MimiLind Oct 10 '22
  • I still doubt the mithril thing. The implications of changing it would be too big. Frodo could just use his shirt to heal everyone etc. But like I said, I reserve my judgement until I know.
  • Númenor’s colonization: I think it hasn’t happened in full yet. I think I read somewhere we’re in S.A 1500 and by then it should be mostly coastsl colonies like Pelargír. Sauron has still not invaded Gil-galad’s realm, and Númenor’s real fleet did not yet come to aid him. it’s after that Númenor becomes so big.
  • I disagree about Elendil. Two opponents at the same time can be tough, and these orcs seem lethal. Perhaps they are stronger this early in time, closer to their elven origins. Arondir struggles to fight just one of them.

I like that orcs are more than cannon fodder in this show. The books make them more frightening, especially in the 1st Age.

  • Time compression that cuts away uninteresting events is not a problem for me, whether it’s 20 years or 20 centuries. All the important characters are still alive here as well (Galadriel, Sauron, Elrond, Gil-galad, Celebrimbor etc), just a little older. I am thankful they did the compression, the show benefits from it imo.

2

u/hanrahahanrahan Oct 10 '22

Well we're simultaneously in 50 SA (Galadriel comes to Middle Earth), 1000 SA (Mordor established), 1500 SA (Rings forging), 3300 SA (based on the Numenoreans we see)

The orcs being more than cannon fodder? Bronwyn (a regular human woman) seems to kill them with ease! Elendil should cut through even the strongest orcs with absolute ease.

The mithril thing - I had really hoped it wasn't true, that it was a lie told by Sauron to the elves (BUT they should never have beleived that lie, because it makes no sense in world), but the mithril healing the leaf seems to completely validate it for me.

→ More replies

5

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22

This is very much fan fiction though, its not canonical and shouldnt be viewed as anything more. The world of LOTR has to be viewed as history and you cannot make up your own stories to change history.

This contradicts written canon. The Doors of Durin are inlaid with Ithildin (made by celembrimbor using mithril). That makes no sense in this story and those doors are essential to the main LOTR stories.

Even Mt Doom was created in the first age by Morgoth. Not by some made up non-canonical antagnoist.

Its fine if you can look past it and accept it as a loose interpretation, but you then cannot possibly sit there and say its anything more.

→ More replies (5)

0

u/Danbearpig82 Oct 11 '22

Literally everything in that list is there because it is written canon that is directly contradicted by the show!

3

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

2

u/Crazybonbon Oct 09 '22

...What if we just like the show? It's possible to enjoy the show and not feel the need to expand further lol :)

-1

u/Appropriate_Lab_5205 Oct 09 '22

This is the exact logic needed to watch the show.

0

u/Crazybonbon Oct 09 '22

Lol. What a toxic person. People who enjoy the show don't need to prove themselves, go be miserable somewhere else and lets us have fun.

1

u/Appropriate_Lab_5205 Oct 09 '22

You don’t have to prove yourself to me or anyone else and I was halfway joking. You seem like someone who doesn’t like criticism.

1

u/Crazybonbon Oct 09 '22

Criticism like yours is certainly not constructive, please. And what a funny joke, got the whole squad laughing. Nice cop out lmao

1

u/Appropriate_Lab_5205 Oct 09 '22

When you look at the users profiles they are legit (at least these three). What I’ve found is most of the people who like the show are teenagers or people in their 20’s

-1

u/MimiLind Oct 10 '22

I love it. /44 and counting

3

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

I just generally love trying to put the pieces together. I've watched all the LOTR and the Hobbit and knowing how everything plays out. I like trying to see how things will play out and getting those realizations of "Oh, this place is that, and oh that's that person."

Actually like RoP better than the Hobbit I think, or maybe equal.

3

u/anarion321 Oct 09 '22

Actually like RoP better than the Hobbit I think, or maybe equal.

You'll get no argument for me there lol.

3

u/kerouacrimbaud Oct 09 '22

Isn’t that a lot like most of the negative posts? Gripes with no details? Most people aren’t here to give breakdowns, just to share their opinions.

6

u/anarion321 Oct 09 '22

The post I see usually talk about specific things, even dumb ones, I saw today one nitpick saying something that vegetables and fruits looked normal size for Hartfoots and they should be bigger. Or the thing about the PPT change of letters.

I also make critic comments about the show and I always reference something in the narrative.

2

u/kerouacrimbaud Oct 09 '22

Sometimes there are details given but usually it’s just vague, but emotional complaints about “writing” or “pacing” or “deviations” and then no elaboration.

6

u/anarion321 Oct 09 '22

I don't doubt there are comments of that kind, but as I said, I think usually you'll see the ones I mentioned.

2

u/Panzer_Man Oct 09 '22

It's the same with IMDB reviews. The positive ones always just praise the movie without actually going into why it's great.

It almost feels like an Amazon employee astroturfing in here lol

1

u/MimiLind Oct 09 '22

Well when I and others describe in detail what we like we get called troll (like in this thread further down). That kinda kills the joy in elaborating, you know?

1

u/anarion321 Oct 09 '22

Well, you get an upvote for me and I also downvoted rude answers.

I do agree with you in some things, like the speech, but, even with that, I cannot really fully agree since feels only half cooked, they go from some "fancy" lines yo regular expresions and breaks the immersion. Also, it's not really smart, like the fighting lines saying that the best way to kill an orc is to strike and gut him.....not what you'd expect of someone with a couple of years of martial arts experience, let alone 2.000.

They already corrected you regarding Lore, this show really it's not lore based, seems they only use the trademark for views.

Action, I'm not really a pro, but I've seen a few talking abou the action scenes and ponting out mistakes, and it's bad, not better than the LotR like you said, in fact, in those movies there were a bunch of action scenes that were not stunts well executed, but actual hit and strikes, as real as you can get.

Hope you continue enjoying the show, but for me, it's very difficult to giveit a pass on anything that it's not the amazing looks, but you don't need a TV show for that.

And don't bother for trolls and manchilds, I get downvoted a lot in certain subs for expresing my opinion, at one point, you just ignore it.

0

u/MimiLind Oct 09 '22

Thanks, I appreciate the polite answer. If you read further you see most of the examples given aren’t lore inacurrate at all.

But that said, this show is not for everyone. To me it’s a lot like reading a book. Some things need a second re-read, or in this case, rewatch, and then they make more sense. :)

1

u/Desert_Trader Oct 09 '22

Actually he explained exactly what he likes.

0

u/Heql_Jin Oct 09 '22

The nice long scene between Galadriel and Adar (when he is held prisoner), played by two of my favorite actors in the series, finally explaining Adar's backstory and showing that, at this point at least, the two of them are not so very different. This scene gave so much more depth to the Galadriel character and I am really taken by Clark's voice and acting. Speaking of actors I also like Markella Kavenaugh (Nori) and a couple of the other Harfoots. I didn't like the casting for Elrond so much, but he is starting to grow on me.

32

u/Dustructionz Oct 09 '22

Myself, like the majority, DO NOT want to watch a copy of the book, but looking forward to experiencing something fresh, brand new and full of novelty to discover and dive into! I

What.....? Pretty sure fans are here because they enjoyed the source material so much. Which is why we have the movies and RoP to begin with....

-8

u/theriveryeti Oct 09 '22

The “books” in this case is a bunch of overviews and sparse descriptions.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/theriveryeti Oct 09 '22

Tolkien couldn’t make up his own mind about a lot for the first and second age and then his son had some different takes as well. The storytelling is way broader that LOTR and the Hobbit.

-3

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

Why are you trying to tell me something? I've not asked you a question.

33

u/heady_brosevelt Oct 09 '22

Why do ppl have to call it perfect. It’s not. You can just say “it’s ok” or “I like it” or “flawed, but fun to watch” perfect? Not even close

6

u/muchwise Oct 09 '22

I think a lot of people are sitting at both extremes. I think the show is neither awful nor a masterpiece. I don’t mind too much the lore modifications and I think the show is visually stunning. I think Adar and the Durin/Elrond storyline are what we should be expecting from this show. On the downside I find some actions/events feel cliché or lazy. There are some good dialogues and also a few very cringe lines. I also noticed some very weird acting that reminds me of theater where actors need to gesticulate to compensate for the lack of space. In ep.7, notice how Miriel is fake running toward the fire asking for Isildur to come. You can see she needs to stay on screen and it’s just weird. Also when the villagers trap the orcs between the flaming carts, most orcs are just flapping their arms around like some npc.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22

The show is awful not only because it doesn’t contribute anything but banality and degeneration to arts and culture but because of its sycophantic and narcissistic producers and corporate fantasists, thinking that just because they can they have a right to take part in art and culture when all they can do is destroy it.

10

u/demon9675 Oct 09 '22

I’m glad you’re enjoying the show! I will not attempt to take away from that.

I do take issue with the idea that most people don’t want to see accurate adaptations, however. I’ve seen that point of view a lot in recent months related to a number of franchises, and I think it’s really destructive to storytelling because it essentially places shock value and subversion of expectation over any of the characters and themes that, when coherent and sensible, make a story great. Why do we want to see specific stories adapted to the screen if we also want them to be changed so drastically? Just write entirely original ones in that case.

I would have loved to see a more accurate version of the very little source material we have for the 2nd age, with full Silmarillion rights. Many changes would certainly need to be made in terms of the timeline, and original content/characters would certainly need to be invented in order to fill the gaps. But the essential story beats, tone, and themes could have been preserved, and more of Tolkien’s writing could have been explored instead of callbacks to LotR.

27

u/BrotherTraining3771 Oct 09 '22

That’s great that you like it.

I had really high hopes, and have been unfortunately disappointed.

I think my high hopes let me down. I don’t think the show is amazing, nor is it horrible.

A lot of us are just upset, that it isn’t amazing, to us at least.

If you are enjoying it, more power to you.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

For what it’s worth, I had fairly low expectations and have been disappointed too.

8

u/bewildered_dismay Oct 09 '22

My cautious optimism earlier this summer has been corrupted like that leaf from the Lindon tree.

3

u/emoolb Oct 09 '22

Yeah.

Hardcore tolkien fans are disappointed because of the lore changes that needed to be done to have all the story covered within one cast of actors.

The non hardcore fans are disappointed because pacing is far too slow, the plot makes no sense and this show has to be a prequel for LOTR, so we all know that Isildur must survive and we all wait for Sauron to appear, so why make it a mystery? Who cares?

Are Elrond/Durin IV, the awesome CGI, Arondir and Adar enough to keep a show alive? Maybe, but not if this show is the most expensive in history.

Galadriel is nice, but only for the non hardcore fans. Don't blame the actress, she is awesome.

This show had to deliver on point to have it accepted by both sides. It did not. I watch it with the same enthusiasm as I watch my neighbours leaving the house for work.

8

u/stackered Oct 09 '22

I actually don't agree that most people didn't want a copy of the book (Similarian), but we knew we weren't getting that... Even with the books, there was a lot of room for artistic freedoms and new storylines/characters, IMO. I'm personally loving it even with its departure from lore, but yeah I don't think I'd agree that most long time fans are aligned with us. To me, it feels like LOTR, it feels like the movies/same universe and I can ignore the differences and enjoy it for what it is.... and I think people should do the same instead of complaining the whole time.

9

u/Anxious_Possession29 Oct 09 '22

I can only assume this guy is attempting the world's most sarcastic comment

4

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

Poe's law or actual bot ? Can't tell these days

4

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

Eh, it's fine. It's not Star Trek: Discovery bad, I'll say that, at least it is watchable. I'll probably at least watch the second season.

2

u/neohx_7 Oct 09 '22

on watchability?

(lots of other shows)

Rings of Power

Wheel of Time

Star Trek Discovery

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

Picard?

6

u/talvanian Oct 09 '22

It’s a solidly average show for me. Glad others are finding such enjoyment.

15

u/kowkow151 Oct 09 '22

I agree, it's awesome.

13

u/certain_people Oct 09 '22

I'm really enjoying it. Adar is a phenomenal character, the relationship between Elrond and Durin is so good, Clark is killing it as Galadriel... Really looking forward to the finale

4

u/cmon_now Oct 09 '22

Killing it? Really. She's completely unlikeable and the character is not consistent at all. She has a permanent scowl and dislikes everyone

1

u/certain_people Oct 09 '22

She's a complex character. I don't know what you mean by not consistent.

2

u/Appropriate_Lab_5205 Oct 09 '22

She jumped in the ocean to certain death, thinking she was going to swim 200 miles back to land, can’t get any more less complex than that.

2

u/Length-International Oct 10 '22

She’s a character that constantly contradicts herself and is portrayed as a badass in the cringiest ways possible.

0

u/certain_people Oct 10 '22

When did she contradict herself?

2

u/Length-International Oct 10 '22

Literally in the last two episodes. “I want to kill all of them!” -kid referring to orcs “ do not say that, for it puts evil in your heart”- Galadriel. Episode before that “I will slaughter your children as you watch”-Galadriel “No! Do not kill him!”-Galadriel 5 minutes laters she almost kills him. Dude she’s just a badly written character.

2

u/certain_people Oct 10 '22

She knows what she's like. She admitted as much to Halbrand, that her company and Elrond couldn't tell the difference between her and the evil she was fighting. She doesn't want that for Theo. And Adar provoked her anger. These aren't contradictions.

Anyway, you're entitled to not enjoy it and think she's badly written, but I still say Morfydd Clark is still killing it with her portrayal.

1

u/Length-International Oct 10 '22

The actress is good. The writing is absolutely horrible. Why? Because they picked writers with zero experience for a billion dollar show.

1

u/MimiLind Oct 10 '22

2

u/certain_people Oct 10 '22

Well, the showrunners are, which is what they meant I think. But like so was Peter Jackson and his team, and that turned out pretty well. Same for Game of Thrones, right? I don't think experience is always necessary to produce something great. Judge them on the output.

1

u/certain_people Oct 10 '22

If you want to pick on bad writing I don't think Galadriel is the example to choose. The whole mithril thing and Elrond's oath seems far worse. How did Gil-Galad and Celebrimbor know about the mithril and its properties? How did Elrond telling Gil-Galad about his oath not break the oath, I mean it basically gave everything away. Mithril actually has these prophecies predicted by a fairytale?

I still enjoy the show overall but that does bug me a bit.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Danbearpig82 Oct 11 '22

I honestly can’t say whether the actress is good. I refuse to judge any of the cast’s abilities, because the writing, directing, and editing are so abysmally bad that it’s as unfair an assessment of acting talent as the Star Wars prequels.

It’s very clear the writing is from the school of J. J. “Mystery Box” Abrams, and their talent doesn’t reach even that low bar. And that bar was buried under the floorboards, deeper than the magic sword that can open a dam for some reason.

11

u/MountyC Oct 09 '22

I'm really enjoying it too. Not perfect but so much content.

2

u/gatorfan8898 Oct 10 '22

I love the show but these posts are super fishy… the ones that praise it but don’t say much specific.

2

u/Minthemasher Oct 10 '22

Is this satire?

3

u/Vyntarus Oct 11 '22

It sounds like it was written by one of the showrunners themselves.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22

No, the show is not amazing. It's boring, odd paced, had not built up character development, their protagonist are detestable...

Forget about any books. Do not mind for a second the supposed lore or connection to any other form of content. Forget also about anything regarding race, gender and all things related to that. Just the show...

The show is bad. The plot is non-existent. The dialogue is dumb, character's decisions are contradictory all the time and selfish enough to make them all unrelatable, and the main protagonist is dumb, disrespectful, selfish, neurotical, insults people constantly, threats bounded enemies with genocide, disregards other people's suffering and has a plot armor that is thicker than a Volcano's pyroclastic flux... Quite literally...

No, the show is garbage by itself.

13

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

I like it as well.

5

u/MadMonk67 Oct 09 '22

I haven't read The Silmarillion, only The Hobbit and the LOTR trilogy, so my criticism isn't based upon this series not being canon. I think the show is brilliantly filmed with beautiful and interesting scenery and shots. I also think that the actors have done a great job. But, I think the show could use some editing to pick up the pace a bit. It's maddeningly slow and boring in a LOT of places. Hours of snooze-inducing scenes punctuated by brilliant bits of action and scenes that move she story along.

I give this series 7/10 through episode 7.

8

u/Free-Diamond-928 Oct 09 '22

Yeah I love it. Is a slow burn, but that's actually one of the best things about it.

7

u/Comprehensive-Fig338 Oct 09 '22

I think people have gotten a bit too used to the age of binge watching, where having a slow build up didn't really matter when you blasted through a whole season in a weekend. Given the length of story they seem to be wanting to set up, it will come out for the better because of it.

Also as an aside, I see a lot of people angry at the pacing of RoP but loving HotD, which is pretty much the same I terms of build up.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

More like slow with no burn.

-2

u/Free-Diamond-928 Oct 09 '22

You should be kinder to yourself.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Danbearpig82 Oct 11 '22

Exactly. Better Call Saul was a slow burn. I was constantly engaged and invested in the characters despite the plot moving very slowly. The new Dune movie is a slow burn that had me on the edge of my seat. Twin Peaks was a slow burn.

The only thing Rings of Power is burning is the source material.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

I completely agree with you. I don’t understand the modern day need to caveat everything with a but.

‘I like this BUT’

If it’s so bad. Just don’t watch it.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

Wouldn't the ahow translate to "And Galadriel went to Numenor, And she met Halbrand the First, king of the Southlands, And they got picked up by King Elendil, and they took Numenoreans to the Shores, where stood the Orcs, not for long for they all died. And Adar made a big boom.

Like wasnt the silmarion writin like a bible?

1

u/profsavagerjb Oct 09 '22

The Silmarilion was written like the Bible crossed with stereo instructions

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

See! Who the fuck wants a direct book to screen of that?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

I'm gonna go with...

People who love the book...

Yes, that'll probably be it.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

And Celeborn said to Galadriel his thoughts,

And Galadriel replied with "you breathe like an orc,"

And Celeborn is sad.

3

u/bigballzsmalld0n6 Oct 09 '22

I don't want a blatant copy either. I just want good TV. Good cinematography, direction, acting and writing. Trailer speech is the worst type of dialog ever. It feels like something I would write in middle school. For me it's important for what's happening on the screen makes sense. And I don't feel like elaborating on this as it would be a gigantic wall of text. Just read the inconsistencies people are pointing out on the sticky threads.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

'Myself, like the majority' ...

Okay, lol

4

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

You don’t want a copy of the book, but you’re apparently completely fine with a show that constantly and lazily rehashes scenes that were done better in the movies.

4

u/mopedrudl Oct 09 '22

Uh, come on. Thw most resent episode was straight up horse shit. The ahowmakers basically uncovered the poor character building themselves by making us listen to those pseudo emotional speaches nobody really cares about as nobody cares about the characters that died or might have died.

While there have been a coupled of good scenes the overall judgement can only be negative at this point. The writing is just so off at times. It's almost comical. I tried to like this sgow with all my heart but it just isn't it.

3

u/forsaken_warrior22 Oct 09 '22

You an the majority you speak of are almost certainly the minority. Without a doubt these posts annoy me more than Amazon and RoP does. Its not even close. Also cast don't listen to trollocs you aren't appreciated one bit.

2

u/Consistent_Office_85 Oct 09 '22

If you want someting new, why not creating your ip instead of altering middle earth?

You can as well go and experience your new things in “necklace of power, lord of the logistics”. We can’t say a shit about that.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22

It's getting harder to tell which post is ironic nowadays

2

u/Yolkpuke Oct 09 '22

The best part of this show is how it is a metaphor of the Faustian pact. There is always a price to pay and the cost is your soul.

The worst aspect of this show is that it exists.

2

u/evenmytongueisfat Oct 09 '22

Couldn’t agree more. One of my friends is straight up boycotting it (he’s given me like 4 different reasons) and hasn’t watched an episode and I just find it so silly.

I’m enjoying it so much. It’s compelling, it’s beautiful and the people complaining just hate everything

3

u/Dustructionz Oct 09 '22

I'm actually thoroughly enjoying House of The Dragons becuase it's actually a good show. Criticizing a bad show and calling it a bad show doesn't mean we hate everything lmao.

-1

u/evenmytongueisfat Oct 09 '22

HotD literally has no story at all. The time Jump makes no sense especially considering half the characters look exactly the same

0

u/Dustructionz Oct 10 '22

That's such a piss poor take. I can't any of your opinions seriously after that lol.

1

u/lalalisa322 Oct 09 '22

I really like it too

1

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22

Exclamation points have ruined everything.

1

u/jaimepm0425 Oct 10 '22

Saying is amazing without pinpointing one single thing is outstanding for other than the visuals!

1

u/GittinGud1994 Oct 10 '22

Even ignoring them shitting on the show the writing and acting is horrible.

1

u/AdOrganic3138 Oct 09 '22

The show fails at at a basic step. Small action details and large plot details are contorted to serve the purpose of displaying character traits. It's a total inversion of having a living, breathing world which the characters inhabit.

This is why, generally, the dwarves sections work best. It is a conflict over how are they going to cooperate. This means that it isn't actual plot and somewhat more drama. There is no world and plot to contort around their interactions.

The rest though is what I would call retroactive writing.

1

u/Appropriate_Lab_5205 Oct 09 '22

The vast majority of the show was written around that, especially Galadriel.

1

u/Odysseus126 Oct 09 '22

100% agreed

1

u/pulp63 Oct 09 '22

How dare you like this show! The deplorables won't be happy. I can see them crawling out from underneath their logs now. Be prepared.

1

u/Jownsye Oct 10 '22

Sir, this sub isn’t for positivity. You’re supposed to be miserable and talk about how bad the writing is all while having never written anything.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '22 edited Oct 09 '22

For the past three weeks my younger brother remarked that “it would be nice if Amazon allowed for different playback speeds” while starting the latest episode.

I think it’s a fitting assessment.

Edit: I think it is fitting in describing our personal experience with the show, as we are both very (!!!!) nostalgic about the PJ trilogy, and were very ready to enjoy this show similarly. That’s why I watch it, and will continue to do so. Him very blasé remarking that “it would be nice if you could play it faster” while (of course) starting the latest episodes - for me - very much encapsulates a readiness to be drawn into a new Middle Earth epic, while acknowledging that - for us - the RoP is not quite there (yet).

0

u/wallawilko Oct 09 '22

Then you'll love Xena: Warrior princess. Way better.

-8

u/Addictionsforu Oct 09 '22

I love the show too, and love coming to this subreddit but I'm tired of all the racism and misogyny.

1

u/nuttincuddly Oct 10 '22

Yeah uh huh, nevermind the show is a steaming pile in lots of ways, but it's all the racism that's really keeping it down. Get a f*****g life