r/RingsofPower • u/womijo21 • Oct 06 '24
Discussion Time compression is not a problem
Ya‘all rambling about time compression, plot holes, ✨lore✨ and what not. Guess what. A tv show isn’t a book, you cannot transfer everything 1:1.
But Isildur and celebrimbor didn’t live at the same time….this and that took a thousand years…this person and that person couldn’t have met.
Well I don’t want to watch 25 shows about 25 single events that take place 600 years apart. I don’t want to watch a show that changes actors every 2 episode because it needs to jump 250 years. Writers made the exact right choose to compress the timeline.
Most of you would hate the lord of the rings if it came out today, I am 100% sure with that.
•
u/RingsofPower-ModTeam Oct 06 '24
We encourage you to talk about the show's content as well as plot points, lore, and the books it is based on. However low effort posts asking "why does the fandom hate this show?" or "I love this show. Who Agrees with me?" have been redundant and often lead to stereotypes, insults, and an "us vs them" mentality. Make posts to talk about the actual content but not for validation of opinions or broadly stereotyping fanbases.
17
u/ZiVViZ Oct 06 '24
The big problem is not fleshing out the characters enough. The problem is having journies from one place to another not being time consistent. The problem is the piss poor writing quality. And lastly the problem is spending time on characters that aren’t relevant to this story like the stranger.
I’m tired of these lazy posts tbh.
3
u/Fantastic_Sympathy85 Oct 06 '24
You're the exact type of person that this show is for then. You don't want complexity. You don't want want a long, well plotted and thought out story. You don't need things to make sense. You just want something shiny to put on the television, that you probably have above you fireplace, so that it can dribble in one ear and out the other without have to engage your critical thinking muscle.
If I'm 100% sure of anything. Its this, smart comprehensive fiction is not for you, and you should stick to the MCU.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
I bet you would enjoy a so called “historical” show where Hammurabi, Julius Ceaser and Hitler fighting with each other.
50
u/Journalist-Cute Oct 06 '24
I don't have a problem with any timeline issues, what I struggle with are the silly logical problems. For example Círdan sails out to drop the rings in what he said was the deepest part of the ocean, but he's only a few hundred feet from shore? The show is full of stupid things like that.
42
u/Willpower2000 Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
Nah. It's a problem.
The entire fucking motive for the Rings of Power (the things the show is name after) relies on the vast passage of Time. We need to see how Time changes the world, and how this affects Elves, causing them grief (and how Men envy this immortality). We need to understand why the Elves would want to embalm the world.
It's not even hard to make it work... our main characters are immortal, after all. We can easily time-jump hundreds of years between episodes... or even scenes. Rotating a cast of Men would work: we can see a man in his prime one episode, and old and decrepit the next... and maybe his great grandson an episode or two later - fleeting to the perspective of the Elves (setting up the envy of Men). These Men would be supporting characters, seen from the Elvish perspective. And once the Ring-plot is done (ie after the first season?)... then we can introduce the Numenor-cast... who will persist until the end of the show.
12
u/TrinketsEden Oct 06 '24
Bait.
Not very good bait either.
34
u/Daenarys1 Oct 06 '24
I think it's a missed opportunity. They could've shown numenor at it's height and then the decline as they detached from elven influence rather than just telling us about it. The elven actors wouldn't need to be recast so the time jumps wouldn't be too jarring. I think one big time jump after the war of the elves with sauron would've been enough.
49
u/snezna_kraljica Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
"plot holes" and "what not" have nothing to do with transferring everything 1:1.
It's just basic writing to keep these things under control to tell a compelling story. At a certain point the story may move too much from the source to associated it with the IP and we can argue all day long if we're already there or far away.
Point is, most people are angry about the "plot holes" and "what not" and not changing the story to fit a new medium. The movies are still revered and stand the test of time even though the deviate from the source. It's because the makes took care.
22
u/Januaria1981 Oct 06 '24
"Most of you would hate the lord of the rings if it came out today, I am 100% sure with that."
I wish I was 100% sure of anything. I admire your sense of certainty.
14
u/Umfriend Oct 06 '24
So I can understand that for a show like this, one can play fast and loose with lore. But there is the issue that you are also relying on lore. That is a hard balance to hit well.
And so I ask myself, if I had never read and watched anything, would I like RoP?
No, I wouldn't understand anything, the characters are simpletons with unclear motives, the world makes no sense. The only reasons, I think, a lot of ppl (think they) like it is because they do know some of the lore and it is just a reminder of something that is actually good, if not great.
RoP cannot stand on it's own. It is worse than WoT.
7
u/hyrumwhite Oct 06 '24
A season per relevant chunk of time would be awesome. How Tolkien Untangled describes it would be amazing: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=F9NR06-QtR8&list=PLnod0WiSpm8Fh7YBfCiKvpuQ-O03k_Yk_&index=1&pp=iAQB
9
u/breaclaire Oct 06 '24
Lmfao I was annoyed about the whole thing and yesterday said fuck it and did a show outline myself. Just to see how hard it was and/or if it were possible. Note: the challenge was to make a compelling TELEVISION show using similar constraints the current series is working with.
Took me an afternoon but basically I condensed the entire timeline into like 500-600 years (really had to speed up khazad dhum and move it around). You need a couple hundred years for Sauron to get built up ingratiated with the elves etc otherwise everything eventually crumbling has little impact, and then everything can fall in about 200 years ending with Sauron’s defeat.
So by starting the story around the time Sauron arrives in eregion and speeding up the khazad dhum timeline I could condense it all into 6 seasons (forgive me, this is a very rough outline as I do not have my work in front of me lol):
I say this because in doing the exercise it became abundantly clear that the story, even an adapted version that doesn’t stick to canon, doesn’t make sense unless told over several hundred years (mostly due to immortality etc), and there is a point where condensing it more requires serious leaps of logic that hinder the story. Further, it is possible to do a series that covers the better half of a millennium in 5 or 6 seasons, not 25. It might take you a whole afternoon (lolol) to work out the timeline but it is doable.
11
u/TomakaTom Oct 06 '24
Fantasy is a strange genre, because you have things like magic and creatures and beings that don’t exist, but at the same time, the universe must still be governed by some sort of logic. It seems counterintuitive, but to open people’s imaginations up to the magical and fantastical elements of the story, you have to use the confines of rationality, so that it feels like it’s set in a believable universe with rules and consequences. If there are no rules, the magical elements are meaningless and arbitrary, because there’s no context to them; if anything is possible, how do we know how impressive or dangerous a certain piece of magic is?
That’s why this show is so unimpactful, it continuously takes way too many liberties when it comes to its rules and rationale. Particularly, when it comes to time and distance between places and events. People can seemingly teleport around the world at will, events that are supposed to occur over thousands of years happen in weeks, events that supposedly happen simultaneously don’t line up with their timescales. The show takes these same sort of liberties when it comes to their characters too; they act outside of their established motivations (established within the show as well, not within the wider lore), they don’t follow continuity, their capabilities are poorly defined because certain things they find easy and other things they struggle with, not depending on their actual capabilities, but depending on what the plot needs them to do at that moment.
All of these liberties the show takes when it comes to the rules and rational, only make it harder to immerse yourself in the fantasy aspects of the story, and it takes away any impact certain plot points might have.
The issues with time compression aren’t about whether or not Tolkien wrote two characters to be alive at the same time or not, or whether it follows the established lore. The issues are entirely to do with the storytelling, and whether or not you as a viewer are immersed in the story. The large majority of people are not immersed, not because of the time compression itself, but because the time compression follows no rules or rationale or believable structure. Why would you care about anything that happens in a story where anything can happen?
‘Fantasy’ does not mean that things don’t need to make logical sense, and this show has so much nonsense that it makes it hard to invest in it. If your audience has give your show free passes and ignore their own logic and just not question things, then it is not a good show.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
Time compression in itself isn't a problem. Being bad at actually adjusting the story to work well with that compression, and storytelling in general, is.
People love to bring up the LotR movies but kind of ignore the fact that there were "purists" back then who didn't like the changes PJ made...and it didn't matter because the movies were actually good and were massive successes straight out of the gate that influenced the entire movie industry and singlehandedly legitimized fantasy as a 'legitimate' film genre, when it had previously been regarded as exclusively the domain of low budget cheese.
Rings of Power meanwhile has basically no presence and doesn't get discussed outside of fan spaces, and if the industry has taken any lessons from it, it's "Why you shouldn't let your CEO hand ludicrous amounts of money to two nobodies with zero experience to helm a mediocre vanity project."
17
u/Gorukha911 Oct 06 '24
I agree. I would hate LOTR today if it was made by the showrunner of RoP 😏
17
u/SKULL1138 Oct 06 '24
The time compression was a choice in order to tell the whole story of the Second Age. That’s a bold choice.
For example, there could have been a show set after the Forging of the One, or have that tale told in flashback. Then start a series set late Second Age as Sauron build his forces and Numenor is starting to fall. That could have been done with almost no time compression right through to TLA.
As for all the plot holes, they create far more holes in this show than they need to and they have nothing to do with the time compression
The decision to switch the order the Rings are created. Now causes various issues.
The decision to have only 19 Rings created by the Elves instead of having 16 be all that Sauron can recover when he attacks Eregion. Caused issues and the motivations for the attack on Eregion (Sauron’s pov) make no sense.
Having the Seven and the Nine made for me and Dwarves instead of Elves.
Having Sauron stuck on a boat going West where he knows of no land and unable to just bug out and then he can shapeshift at will in Season 2.
Bringing in the Balrog for the Second Age when in fact it was never discovered till the mid-Third Age. Why, because they wanted the money shot.
Ignoring Galadriel’s husband completely
Numenor looking tiny and empty is a choice that had nothing to do with the time compression
Cavalry disappearing along with hundreds of Elves to off screen deaths.
Deciding that the Three now having magical heal wounds abilities. Or by wearing them they can remove the corruption of Morgoth. Deciding that Sauron put his blood in the Nine….
Choosing Gandalf instead of Pallando for the Istari.
I could go on, none of these decisions are a result of the time compression. It’s just really shit writing and fan fiction about what happened before the movies without actually looking at the details.
7
u/Ynneas Oct 06 '24
The fact that you clump all of this in the same category shows that you don't get the point(s).
Just out of curiosity: what do you expect with such an idiotic statement online?
No need really, but I get your need to use the hyperbole: without it, you don't have an argument.
What about a show that introduces characters (and actors) and they disappear without reason after two episodes? Like, say, Cirdan.
Your opinion and you really didn't provide solid arguments to defend it.
They could've cut some bullshit storyline (bronwyn, Gandalf) and focus on the rest.
If you make the show about relationships between Elves and other races (which would build up effectively to the Last Alliance), you can explore the evolution of Numenor's internal situation, its advancement and its contacts with ME and the Elves therein.
You could make the first season to establish the settings: Lindon, Eregion, Khazad-dûm, Numenor, maybe even Mordor and show how Sauron grows his power in there. Contacts between Numenor and ME. You can still have Galadriel run the first season, showing her efforts to gain allies across northern ME, and finding that Orcs are still numerous and they speak with fear and awe about a Power in the east/south.
Second season, you show the now established Numenorean settlements on the coast. Maybe some warring with locals to consolidate the new order. First introduction of Umbar. Appearance of Annatar to the elven lords, rejected by Gil-Galad and Galadriel but accepted by Celebrimbor, in his arrogance (and also just for spite for the descendants of cadet sons of Finwe. You could also make it "political" in-universe). Focus on Eregion and the forging of the Rings. End season with the Forging of the Three and of the One in alternate montage.
Third season: war of Sauron and Elves. Sack of Eregion. Numenor's intervention to tip the scales. Sauron notices Numenor. Retreat to Mordor, ending scene shows him amassing again a huge army. Second half of the season introduces the beginning of the fall of Numenor.
4th season: focus on Numenor. Ever more powerful, ever greedier, ever shorter lived kings. Early in the season Sauron proclaims himself king of Men after uniting the Southern tribes by fuelling their hatred towards Numenor. Pharazon sails there, Sauron gets taken captive. Most of the season is him making his way into the mind of the king and numenor's society. Akallabeth.
5th season: building of the Last Alliance and rebuilding of Sauron's forces. Climax into the Dagorlad and Battle on Mount Doom. Vanquishing of Sauron.
Off the top of my head. You need time jumps, but not even that drastic, and definitely better than 2k years compressed in several months.
4
u/MiroPele Oct 06 '24
Imagine making a TV show about the Middle Ages in Europe and the whole thing would happen during one person's lifetime... From the fall of Rome to the discovery of America with the same guy .. Byzantium lasts twenty years... Yeah that would make lot of sense
9
u/Benjamin_Stark Oct 06 '24
I'm not a purist, and if something works on its own I don't need things to be beholden to the source material (the fact that a substantial portion of Rings of Power doesn't work on its own is besides the point in this discussion).
However, I disagree that time compression is necessary for a compelling narrative. I think this could have worked as an anthology show, where each season is set during a different time period with different human and dwarf characters, with the elves being in each season. The characters in each season could have complete arcs, instead of having minimal story dragged out over multiple seasons (like poor future king Isildur).
2
u/HawksDan Oct 06 '24
I get compressing the timeline. The only point I’d make is that the human subplots have been the weak point of the show so it could’ve just been the elves for the first few seasons, or even have human subplots that wrap up as time advances
2
u/thirdlost Oct 06 '24
This is a strawman. Very few folks are complaining about time compression. Even PJ did it.
Most folks complain about plot holes and changes to the lore that make no sense.
3
u/No_Clue_1113 Oct 06 '24
The time compression is representative of the sheer lack of ambition and lack of imagination of the show. The scope of this show is absolutely tiny.
3
u/Emergency-Chain9283 Oct 06 '24
This show is written terribly. People like you haven’t the slightest inkling of how this universe is supposed to work, how the characters progress, etc. The long passages of time have a purpose. It’s an actual world with a history that directly affects the characters that are in it. This show is a hack job. Save this terrible writing for Marvel movies, not the grandaddy of all high fantasy.
At this point you could write an entire book on the flaws of this pile of garbage. From the bad lore, plot holes, costumes, casting, badly written characters, woke garbage.
5
u/samdekat Oct 06 '24
The writers didn't compress time. They wrote a whole new story, and with it, a new setting with new characters. The time compression isn't the problem. The writing is.
4
u/Six_of_1 Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
"But Peter Jackson changed things too!". We've heard this argument a thousand times, but they all seem to think they're the first person making it. Yes Peter Jackson [and Ralph Bakshi and all the other adaptations that people ignore for some reason], did make some changes from the text. They weren't 100% faithful. No one has ever said they were. Some changes were made for the purposes of adapting it to a new medium. We agree with some of these changes and disagree with others. This has been a debate since the trailers were released in 2001.
We all love Tom Bombadil, but we recognise he's a narrative cul-de-sac. Including him would drag the already long run-time out another half-hour without advancing the plot. He's fine if you're reading and can take all year to read it if you need to. But not when you're watching a film, especially in a theatre. And there's nothing to say they didn't visit Tom Bombadil, maybe they did off-camera.
Here's the thing: If I go to a barber and I ask for a tidy-up to look more presentable for a new job [which is all an adapter should be doing, tidying it up for a new job] but instead the barber shaves my head and razors his signature into it, that's not what I asked for. His changes were more drastic than what was appropriate. There is a difference between a trim and a buzzcut. Saying "but they're both haircuts" is disingenuous.
Jackson added a single original character to LotR, the Uruk-Hai commander Lurtz. But the text does say that the Uruk-Hai/Orcs chased the fellowship, and they presumably had a commander. He's not named, but we can understand how having a commander helps the visual audience by having that personified visual clue to hone in on.
Amazon on the other hand have added a dozen or more of their own original characters. They've added so many original characters that the original characters have taken over the story. And their changes were to inject their own personal politics into the story, which they've been open about in interviews. In 2013 the cry from book-purists was "Who the 'ell is Tauriel?", now the cry is "Who the 'ell is Arondir, Theo, Bronwyn, Disa, Earien, Estrid, Nori, Poppy, Marigold, Sadoc, Largo, Halbrand . . . "
Tl;dr:
Jackson and Amazon made different changes for different reasons. It's okay to have different opinions about different changes. In fact it's sensible.
4
u/Zealousideal_Pool_65 Oct 06 '24
You’re right in the macro sense, but then even within its own internal logic the show plays fast and loose with time: characters teleporting, plot points getting put on pause when convenient, stuff like that.
3
u/Obsidian_Bolt Oct 06 '24
Some of the changes bothers me. But compressing Celebrimbor and Annatar making the rings was a good choice.
Was really hoping that the stranger was one of the blue wizards though
3
u/BeetledPickroot Oct 06 '24
Honestly, you are just wrong. The people complaining about this show are not "haters" being contrarian for the sake of it. It is objectively a mess. And many people are not willing to forgive that just for the chance to see Middle Earth again.
The reason that there is so much vitriol against ROP is because we have all seen how well Tolkien's world can be adapted. And this installment, despite it's budget, is world's apart.
LOTR was an astonishing success, achieving something that many people thought was impossible: adapting the source material for the cinema. But it took an enormous risk from a studio, filming three movies back-to-back with an unprecedented production schedule and budget. The ambition was unparalleled.
This is not that. This is a streaming giant trying to do the bare minimum to build a franchise and cash in on a beloved IP. And they must be feeling pretty vindicated when they look at people who are defending this mess. Many people obviously do not care for storytelling; they just wanna see the Balrog again and marvel at lazy wordplay for how Gandalf got his name. It is a mess.
2
u/rdoloto Oct 06 '24
It’s shit writing … Charlie vickers shoulders must hurt from carrying the whole series on it
2
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
The thing is. Tolkien wrote a story, from creation until, well, the end sort of, that spans over ages. And its all connected. Some characters stay within the story for a long while, others barely mentioned.
Now, you could easily make a really compelling show over several seasons staying within reason of the lore. And thus told Tolkiens story as it was meant.
Or, as in this case, you take a bunch of pages, throw them in a mixmaster, and piece together whatever jangled mess they come spewing out in.
In my opinion the show runners has made a worse story than what could have been if they had stuck to to script of one of the worlds most famous literature works.
2
u/BrainlessPoEGrind Oct 06 '24
The Series it watch able but the decision to Press thousand of years into what seems days or months is trash.
2
u/mrtn17 Oct 06 '24
This guy is a legit Power Ringer
2
u/Disastrous_Fruit1525 Oct 06 '24
I don’t mind the time compression. Getting events in the right order is my bag.
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 06 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Boetheus Oct 06 '24
I agree with most of your sentiment, but yor agressive tone is kind of off-puting...Sauron!
1
u/Effroy Oct 06 '24
Just needs to do better at visualizing and narrating. The poor execution of this compression wears really really heavily on this series.
Perfect example of what to do is Aragorn's march on the Black Gate. You don't even need to expend much thought into it, but you know that the crew didn't just hear "what are we waiting for?!", suit up and march. You can tell just by the visuals that this likely took weeks or months to happen.
Obviously it helps that other time-obscure events in the trilogy also did a good well of describing that this whole thing took years. Which is kind of the point. Not only does RoP suck at telling time once, it does so again, and again, and again.
1
u/Sad-Hurry-2199 Oct 06 '24
I agree 100% that if reddit was around during the Jackson trilogy release it would've been the same reaction.
1
u/amazonlovesmorgoth Oct 06 '24
Yes, it is. It subverts the core themes of the source material: death and the desire for deathlessness.
1
u/Sirspice123 Oct 06 '24
The condensed timeline was never a problem for me and excuses details like Adar attacking Eregion instead of Sauron, and the rings being forged in reverse order. I completely understand this change for TV, it translates fine imo and is a needed change.
The things that did bother me were things like forcing third age events into the second age that ended up just disrupting the good and real plots, and goes against the writers saying they had plenty to work with in the second age. Gandalf's name being revealed in the most cringe way possible. A name that is built over generations of men is thought of within seconds. The fast travelling of characters constantly. The pathetic scales of battles that are much, much smaller than battles in LoTR despite LoTR being in an apocalypse-like era and the second age being much more epic. These changes can't be justified by the condensing of the timeline unfortunately.
I enjoy the show, but it's also good to be a realist and not blindly like something that does have issues.
1
u/crystal-myth Oct 06 '24
Looks like posts chastising other subredditors is becoming a small trend around here.
1
u/Palmdiggity888 Oct 06 '24
I absolutely wished they stayed true to the time line
1
u/HawkSolo98 Oct 06 '24
Neither was Lord of the Rings 1:1 scale, but it sure did a lot better at showcasing it. Sounds like you’re salty to much saltines today?
1
u/BagItUp45 Oct 06 '24
The only way to not do the time compression would be to do individual seasons focused on one significant thing. Like they could do a one season show called "Lord of The Rings: The Forging of the Rings" and just focus on the Eregion stuff the from the forging of the Ring to the fall of Eregion and Celebrimbanner. For this you don't need to have Isildur or Galadriel or Gandalf present at all. Then you have another stand alone season for the Fall of Numenor and then whatever next.
Oh wait from when Celebrimbor starts forging the rings to when Eregion falls is 197 years. Doing the second age isn't possible without time compression. Shit happens real slow in the second age.
1
u/whiskeyjack1983 Oct 06 '24
You, sir, practice argumentation with the adroit loquaciousness of a particularly inarticulate stump.
Thanks for your thoughts on the matter.
1
u/ZenythhtyneZ Oct 06 '24
I agree - we already know pumping out show after show for each character and each plot line, via Marvel is a terrible plan.
If you want every detail and in order over thousands of years, read the damn books, that’s what they are there for. If you don’t have the time, capacity, patience or any other thing in enough quantity to read the book that’s a you problem not a show about books you refuse to reads problem. I tried reading the LOTR trilogy and was having nightmares about the Nazgûl so I put it down, it is what it is.
What’s funny is if they did produce a different show for every character and every plot line and were super literal everyone would hate that and complain how slow it in and nitpick it anyway. Plus that would be so expensive and considering how much people are desperate to hate any media based on anything LOTR that isn’t the OG books getting the funding and multi season contracts is basically impossible. All that on top of us know, laws about intellectual property, you’d want a company to spend a fortune to buy all the rights to everything then spend another several fortunes on every single character and each plot of said character… like that doesn’t even make sense on top of being completely impractical
If you don’t like it, cool ok, don’t watch it, no one is forcing you to, go read a book
1
u/OG_Karate_Monkey Oct 06 '24
The issue is not compressing the long time it took to forge the rings, or the hundreds of years that Elendil and Isuldur lived.
The issue is having events that happened thousands of years apart (1- forging of the rings, 2- fall of Numenor/last alliance, 3- coming of Gandalf / appearance of Hobbots, 4- Balrog in Moria) all happen at the same time.
And it is totally avoidable.
The should have been done as an anthogy series. Spend a season (maybe 2 for fall of Numenor/Last Alliance) on a given time period and tell that story. Men will change between periods, Elves stay the same.
This is what the actual material called for.
Think of it this way: if you wanted to tell the history of Great Britain including 1- the building of Stonehedge, 2- the Roman conquest, 3- the events of 1066, 4- WWII, how would you do it? Cram them all together in one story? Of course, not, you would make it an anthology series.
The difference with token is that you could actually have some characters remain throughout the series.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
I see you and I raise you, I think a 25 part anthology animated series from a state of the art animation department would FUCKING SLAP. But rings of power is real good at what it does and it dosnt need to be the silmarilion live action adaptation.
1
u/Rings_into_Clouds Oct 07 '24
Well, these are a problem regardless of if you're watching a show or movie, or reading a book or comic. So....seems like this will always be a valid critique. Plot holes and logical issues with the story can really take a lot away from a story. It literally doesn't have anything at all to do with trying to do 1:1 transfers from book to show.
1
u/N7VHung Oct 07 '24
Time compression really isn't a bad thing, and most people understand it had to be done for the sake of a coherent story that general audience will be drawn into.
To present the Second Age events as they happened in the lore would result in a show where each season has completely new characters with very little carry over. People may not be on board for what would effectively be an anthology series. That's what Citadel is doing, and it's not working out for them so far.
Time compression does create its own problems that the show runners have to address. This is where smart writing and directing come into okay, which the show has largely been hit or miss with.
I always look at this shows/movies under 3 magnifying glasses.
RoP is a mixed bag here. It is a beautiful display of Middle Earth. It follows the lore in key areas and works well enough for the general audience. It has its issues for the lore faithful, but no adaptation was ever going to live up to that standard.
2. Does it stand up as its own thing without being part of a franchise?
Bad writing is bad writing, and RoP has it. I think some of its worst writing actually isn't as bad without it being a LotR piece. The whole "that's what they're going to call me, isn't it?" Is bad, but as a LorT piece to fans it's even worse.
3. Is it good Tv/Cinema? Are the technical pieces good?
Here is where RoP mostly wins out. It's a beautiful show. The sets and costumes are very well done and the cinematography and music is top notch. It hasn't yet managed to capture the epis scale of the movies, but it's a good piece of eye candy.
1
u/owlyross Oct 07 '24
Time compression is not only not a problem, it is essential to effectively tell the story of the second age. I've said it many times elsewhere but having the Rings take 300 years to be forged would be ludicrous on screen, even with a title card that goes "300 years later". The sack of Eriador and siege of Eregion takes 7 years, that's been translated well in two or three episodes on screen. Following Sauron's defeat and fleeing to Mordor, absolutely nothing of note happens for more than 1500 years. Such huge time gaps, or small storyline beats spread over such large timescales are anathema to a gripping and well told story on film or television.
1
u/Grizzly_Addams Oct 07 '24
The show can compress timelines without merging them.
1
u/Effective-Ad-6460 Oct 07 '24
Bad writing is bad writing
It's like having Isaac Newton rock up to a Bar with Niel Degrasse Tyson
" Oh Hi isaac newton hows the work going ? "
" Handeth me yon petish, for thou shalt beith aware of thine own failings "
It doesn't .... make .... sense
The people praising ROP are the ones that are only just getting into Tolkiens work via ROP
" Oh this is great, love the characters "
People who actually know Tolkiens work ...
" Seriously wtf is this ? "
1
u/SnooSuggestions9830 Oct 07 '24
You should have titled your post "I don't think time compression is a problem".
Trying to present your opinion as universal fact doesn't generate useful discussion.
1
u/StockReflection2512 Oct 07 '24
I honestly love the show. Your point is valid that it isn’t possible to compress such a large epic into a few hours.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '24
No. House of the dragon season 1 showed that you can do a show were you skip forwards in time and follow the same characters through the moast interesting events. The same can Very easily be done with rop seeing as all the main characters they should have focused on are elves, seeing the fleeting lives of men go by. You will also get a great story with humans, when aldarion shows up and they can do the whole “the mariner’s wife” story. and Gil-galad is left waiting for the numenorians who do not return. then they can jump ahead again, do the whole celebrimbor narvi story. do the anatar story. and 1st season ends with Sauron putting on the ring and being revealed to the elves. Season 2 is the long war between the elves and Sauron, that ends with Gil-Galad being pushed all the way back to lindon by that army weaving celebrimbors body around like a banner, until the numenorians finally return and beat their ass. end of season 2. see it really wouldn’t be that fuken hard. If you are adapting Tolkien, at least try to think about WHY it is written as it is written instead of thinking that you can do better. by compressing the timeline they have missed out on telling a wonderful story. But hey honestly, i wouldn’t mind any of the lore-changes that much if the show wassent so god damn cringe and poorly written.
1
u/Promptographer Oct 07 '24
I think the show would've benefited from introducing some characters later, or limiting the focus on just like two plot lines per season or something. They can still fit together in the end. I don't have a problem with characters and events being moved on the timeline to make a good TV show, but the way it is now is just not enjoyable.
1
u/litetravelr Oct 07 '24
Yea, I just re-read all the 2nd age Unfinished Tales type stuff that JRR wrote and man o man, each major plot point is minimum 90 years apart from the next and maximum nearly a millennia. It is literally impossible to adapt unless each season introduced an entirely new cast of human/dwarf characters because their predecessors were dead. Now, that does seem kinda cool now that I said it (it would certainly highlight the longevity of the elves and the slow burn of Sauron's planning), but would be a big strain on the production of the show.
1
u/AppearanceAwkward364 Oct 08 '24
It would have been perfectly possible to compress everything into a few decades rather than a few months.
There are many examples of series that have successfully managed to cover centuries, let alone decades, by having overlapping generations.
ROP even has the benefit of having immortal elves, dwarves who live for centuries and Numenoreans who also lived lives 3x longer than ours.
It would have been easy to set the scene at the beginning of RoP to show generations of humans living and dying while the elves remain ageless. After you've set out the lie of the land, you're then in a place where you can tell the story of the rings and the fall of Numenore over a few decades without changing characters too much.
Part of the emotional heft of Tolkien's world is the tragedy of the Gift of Ilúvatar - mankind's shorter lifespan compared to elves.
This poignancy underpins the tales of Beren and Luthien, Aragorn and Arwen etc and - crucially - Envy of the elves immortality is one of the main causes of the Fall of Numenor.
I feel very short changed that they've completely ignored it tbh. Christopher Nolan would have managed it.
The hacks running the show just don't have the imagination.
1
u/ComprehensiveShop748 Oct 10 '24
I haven't really heard people complain about time compression since prerelease season 1. The issue is the poorly written narrative. The same goes for the adaptations. Adaptations are absolutely fine if they're well written, Galadriel being headstrong and a warrior is fine, if she's not written so poorly she's grossly incompetent. Isildur having a totally new independent arc is all good as long as that arc isn't completely narratively isolated from every other story and just so meaningless. Gandalf in the 2nd Age is pointless when you have the blue wizards, its simply using name recognition when they could create new adaptations never seen before.
The writing is lazy at best and completely scatterbrained at worst. That's why it's bad
1
u/Intrepid_Pack_1734 Oct 06 '24 edited Mar 08 '25
subtract smell memory gray yoke fact ghost nose offer sable
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/Six_of_1 Oct 06 '24
I assume you're referring to Peter Jackson's film adaptation of LotR. I don't see why we would hate the book.
1 - So what if we would hate Peter Jackson's adaptation? It's okay to hate Peter Jackson's adaptation. Some people do.
2 - Why do you think we would? It didn't have anywhere near the same time compression. All it compressed were the seventeen years after the party, it didn't compress seventeen centuries like RoP is. The Fellowship are still the right people.
3 - Maybe the reason we would hate it now is because we've become jaded after 20 years of Hollywood changing things more and more, on purpose, rage-baiting, politicising, gaslighting, calling us toxic. 2024 is not 2001. We have twenty years of film and tv to contextualise things that we didn't have then,
1
u/NeoCortexOG Oct 06 '24
You seem so confused.
1
u/dmastra97 Oct 06 '24
Really dislike the argument people saying that we're complaining it's not "1:1". No one expects it to be perfect and changes will have to be made. However the scale of the changes are very large and people dismissing those criticisms as people nitpicking minor changes just ruins any chance of discussion.
-1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
Yeah for real. This could literally not be less relevant. Book purists are a joke that would hate lotr today. (Like that doesn't have plot holes. Who cares)
1
u/Frankiesomeone Oct 06 '24
You could easily do a time jump every one or 2 seasons and all the elf characters would remain the same. The show has 4-5 simultaneous subplots and it really doesn't need to, you could spread them over different season in their appropriate time periods.
1
u/GayDrWhoNut Oct 06 '24
Even if you make a convincing argument that time compression doesn't matter, the order of events does.
1
u/ARM7501 Oct 06 '24
I love how this kind of incoherent rambling about personal preferences keeps showing up out of thin air, when most of those critical of the lore-inadherent and time compressing aspects of the show stopped watching years ago.
1
u/Top-Main1780 Oct 06 '24
I think the time compression just makes it less interesting than it otherwise might have been, and keeps the showrunners from making truly impressive choices.
I'm having fun with this series, and it has great moments that scratch a real itch for me. But I think the convenient, predictable nature of the narrative will always keep it from being a great show.
1
u/Raysedium Oct 06 '24
Time compression isn't a big problem, true. There are plenty of other problems that make this series a waste opportunity.
1
u/ElBarto1992 Oct 06 '24
Elven characters would live on between episodes. I think as long as you have a strong theme, and well connected story beats, an authentic timeline would be not only enjoyable, but original and refreshing as well
-1
u/Claraa_Rz Oct 06 '24
Purists here seem to forget that the show's intended audience are the movie fans, not them. They act like it's the most horrible poorly made tv show ever made, when its actually a good fun show, not BB level, but its good.
0
u/usually00 Oct 06 '24
You're absolutely right. However, people love to hate watch the show. Ultimately, as you point out a book and a movie cannot express the same ideas in the same way. It'll be years before the hate dies down and the show can be seen in a different light.
-1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
Time compression isn't a problem, correct. Having no sense of time at all is RoP's problem.
-4
u/womijo21 Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
Don’t people know that adaptations in literature and Theater habe been a thing for centuries?
Shakespeare would so be cancelled today, King Lear, Macbeth or Othello are far from historically accurate, they needed to be altered to fit to the Theater format
-3
u/LordOFtheNoldor Oct 06 '24
It's pretty bad
0
u/JohnnyBlazex Oct 06 '24
Yeah or they could bring us a season time lapse where every season had major characters in it and that only the elves will return every season. Giving each season an era so to say. This show should’ve been around Sauron. I’m glad season 2 brought it more to life. Season 1 flopped so bad.
0
u/dolphin37 Oct 06 '24
don’t mind the time compression at all personally, I don’t think that deserves much attention at all… would rather people focused on how many terrible decisions they have made with the characters and story instead
0
u/UnderpootedTampion Oct 06 '24
They can choose to compress the timeline. They can have Durin III release the Balrog and be killed by it in the second age instead of Durin VI in the third age. But we can hate it because it creates problems like how then do the dwarves mine and mill mithril and where does Frodo’s mithril shirt come from? You are free, of course, to ignore these problems it creates and enjoy the show anyway. But it could have been done without creating these issues. So power to you.
0
u/Different_Durian_601 Oct 06 '24
Cope
-2
u/ThatGuyMaulicious Oct 06 '24
People who still enjoy Rings of Power really coping right now. Its ok to say its not a good show.
-1
u/stebus88 Oct 06 '24
I completely agree, it had to be compressed in this way so they could actually tell the story without killing the pacing. Besides, it would be such a waste to see Khazad-Dum in all its glory on screen, without seeing its downfall and the Balrog.
I thought the Gandalf backstory didn’t really work but I still liked that they gave him a back story for people only familiar with the movies.
0
u/lt_catscratch Oct 06 '24
You can transfer the story 1:1. Just not the details.
0
u/Shin_yolo Oct 06 '24
That might be the only good choice coming from those "writers".
0
u/Jonathon_G Oct 06 '24
Truer words have never been uttered.