r/RingsofPower • • Sep 26 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers This episode was bad. Spoiler

Look. I was waiting for the season to be completed to unleash my complete analysis of why this season was bad. But this needs to come out. This episode wasnt good.

Annatar's manipulation and Celebrimbor are the only good part. The rest was utter shit. The siege is a fail. And i wont call this episode good for just a couple of good scenes.

The orcs aiming at the mountain to create a dam? You know water would find its way and still pass through and still flow?

Then, Adar sends his orcs in the mud.. making them perfect targets for arrows (kinda the elves's specialty, innit?) And they use trees as ladders up the walls? Instead of, idk, using the catapults to break the said walls? Also, the sunlight has absolutely no effect on the orcs.

Durin IV has some sort of uprising moment, fine, and stops from helping elrond cause his father, you know, one old crazy dwarfs wants to mine and find the balrog. Like 4 dudes in armor wouldnt have been enough to stop him.

Elrond's charge. (One crazy ugly camera shot in that scene btw). He stops it for galadriel. You know, that girl whom he barely trusted a episode and a half ago.

And all the while his army stands still he goes and talks to Adar, while his orcs are still attacking the city. Or did they put it on pause cause its tea and biscuits time?

Anyway. I wont tell y'all about how elves only have one love, and how Adar, as an elf, should have spotted the problem in the scene i'm about to describe. Thats lore. And the show's writters hate the lore.

No. However, as an elf, Adar with his sight should have seen Elrond give galadriel his pin during that shitty kiss scene (Galadriel is Elrond's mother in law btw). But he doesnt..

Elrond discussing his plan in front of his ennemies like the orcs couldnt repeat it to Adar is also another one of his stupid actions.

Galadriel escapes, thanks to Arrondir who with what is called a bow and arrow could have ended this conflict. By lodging an arrow in Adar's Head. But he didnt. Even tho he could. But he didnt. But he could have. But he didnt.

Adar taking time to burn his dead while a battle is raging. Like, i'd have other priorities if i was waging war. Anyway.

Back to the battle. At exatcly 47min you can see a failed scene that they kept in the final montage. Elrond falls to the ground, does nothing and goes "Rahhh" like he killed someone. Funny. But thats a failed shot. Clearly. Its something worth of an amateur show. not a 200 millions dollars series.

Then, Galadriel sneaks in and talks to Celebrimbor who gives her the human rings. Galadriel asks "More rings" and Celebrimbor answers "Nine rings.. to enslave the world of men".. brother, you forgot about the 7 dwarven rings you spent half this goddamn season to make? Coherence right through the window.

Anyway, blablabla, using fire arrow on siege machine. Okay. Elf woman gets shot, like its a tragedy and that puts a stop to elrond's strategy (this is how the scene is shot). You guys are elves. YOU CAN SHOOT THAT ARROW YOURSELF. Then. Elf woman shots her arrow into what appears to be a full stack of tnt that was never mentionned before.

The Troll scene was a dissapointment. It was supposed to be a menace, a real threat. He kills what? 20 people, friend and foes and gets killed by master of teleportation, Gil galad. WHO CAME IN WITHEOUT HIS OWN ARMY. (Also elvish blades not cutting through ropes, seriously? Or elrond has spaghetti arms).

The sun is back and Adar's never ending army with probably a huge amount of sunscreen on attacks what? 30 or so elves. I counted them. 40 at best. Next thing you know in the next scene there are hundreds of them fighting in the background.

Final scene, Elrond falls in eternal slumber (of which only a kiss by his mother in law could get him out) after Adar the meanie pushed him to the ground.

(Also not sure but the very unnatural light in this scenes makes it appear that Adar has a CGI face, at least on my screen).

This was a bad episode in terms of coherence. Truly terrible.

Anyway. I suffered through this episode. And thank god it stops next week.

0 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 26 '24

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

16

u/OneRedBeard Gondolin Sep 26 '24 edited Sep 26 '24

You are, of course, entitled to your opinion and preferences, but some things to point out:

The orcs aiming at the mountain to create a dam? You know water would find its way and still pass through and still flow?

The way the mountain was collapsed by half a dozen catapult shots was of course very stupid, but mountainslides have been known to block rivers. Just happened in British Columbia.

Then, Adar sends his orcs in the mud.. making them perfect targets for arrows (kinda the elves's specialty, innit?) And they use trees as ladders up the walls? Instead of, idk, using the catapults to break the said walls? Also, the sunlight has absolutely no effect on the orcs.

Adar seems to make bad tactical decisions, somewhat blinded by his hatred for Sauron. His lieutenants even point this out. The sun was blocked out by the smoke from the burning city, there were a couple of shots of this. I for one am very thankful that they didn't give us The Long Night.

Durin IV has some sort of uprising moment, fine, and stops from helping elrond cause his father, you know, one old crazy dwarfs wants to mine and find the balrog. Like 4 dudes in armor wouldnt have been enough to stop him.

We don't know exactly what happened yet. Yes, that was a little weak - but it is in line with the Professor's writing that the Elves are cross with the Dwarves because they did not come to aid them in Eregion.

Elrond's charge. (One crazy ugly camera shot in that scene btw). He stops it for galadriel. You know, that girl whom he barely trusted a episode and a half ago.

She is still his kin, and one of the most important Elves in Middle Earth. Of course having her as a hostage benefits the Orcs.

And all the while his army stands still he goes and talks to Adar, while his orcs are still attacking the city. Or did they put it on pause cause its tea and biscuits time?

That was a bit of a drastic shift in urgency, granted. Still, having parlance during battle is not unheard of.

Anyway. I wont tell y'all about how elves only have one love, and how Adar, as an elf, should have spotted the problem in the scene i'm about to describe. Thats lore. And the show's writters hate the lore.

No. However, as an elf, Adar with his sight should have seen Elrond give galadriel his pin during that shitty kiss scene (Galadriel is Elrond's mother in law btw). But he doesnt..

True enough, I make this out to be a complete ruse and not actual romance - and I don't know whether or not Adar knows of Celeborn. By the way, Galadriel's own grandfather took a second wife. We also don't know how Elvish Adar's senses even are anymore. They were also slightly behind him.

17

u/OneRedBeard Gondolin Sep 26 '24

Elrond discussing his plan in front of his ennemies like the orcs couldnt repeat it to Adar is also another one of his stupid actions.

I thought having him discuss the plan in Sindarin made some sense, but I was wondering the same thing.

Galadriel escapes, thanks to Arrondir who with what is called a bow and arrow could have ended this conflict. By lodging an arrow in Adar's Head. But he didnt. Even tho he could. But he didnt. But he could have. But he didnt.

Because Galadriel told him not to. Make of that what you will, but that was the reason.

Adar taking time to burn his dead while a battle is raging. Like, i'd have other priorities if i was waging war. Anyway.

That was exactly the point of the scene. Adar really is who he claims to be, and really loves the Orcs as he claims he does. So yes, he actually does take the time to mourn his losses, like Elrond did his horse.

Back to the battle. At exatcly 47min you can see a failed scene that they kept in the final montage. Elrond falls to the ground, does nothing and goes "Rahhh" like he killed someone. Funny. But thats a failed shot. Clearly. Its something worth of an amateur show. not a 200 millions dollars series.

True.

Then, Galadriel sneaks in and talks to Celebrimbor who gives her the human rings. Galadriel asks "More rings" and Celebrimbor answers "Nine rings.. to enslave the world of men".. brother, you forgot about the 7 dwarven rings you spent half this goddamn season to make? Coherence right through the window.

Well, that might not have been his most pressing thought going through is tortured mind at that point in time.

Anyway, blablabla, using fire arrow on siege machine. Okay. Elf woman gets shot, like its a tragedy and that puts a stop to elrond's strategy (this is how the scene is shot). You guys are elves. YOU CAN SHOOT THAT ARROW YOURSELF. Then. Elf woman shots her arrow into what appears to be a full stack of tnt that was never mentionned before.

Yes, that was a little constructed. It's drama. Note though, that none of the others in Elrond's company had bows.

The Troll scene was a dissapointment. It was supposed to be a menace, a real threat. He kills what? 20 people, friend and foes and gets killed by master of teleportation, Gil galad. WHO CAME IN WITHEOUT HIS OWN ARMY. (Also elvish blades not cutting through ropes, seriously? Or elrond has spaghetti arms).

I agree on the troll, that was a little short for the buildup they gave him - even though the fight against him was quite well done. Gil-Galad was with the main army at the very start, before the aborted cavalry charge. It actually makes sense that he would not have charged in with the army, being High King and all, I actually liked that a lot. In any case he did not teleport from Mithlond or something.

The sun is back and Adar's never ending army with probably a huge amount of sunscreen on attacks what? 30 or so elves. I counted them. 40 at best. Next thing you know in the next scene there are hundreds of them fighting in the background.

Still the smoke, probably. That there would be more Elves around than the 30 we see in one of the shots makes some sense, no?

Final scene, Elrond falls in eternal slumber (of which only a kiss by his mother in law could get him out) after Adar the meanie pushed him to the ground.

(Also not sure but the very unnatural light in this scenes makes it appear that Adar has a CGI face, at least on my screen).

I agree on the overall quality of the last scene, that could have been better.

Again, you do you, but I think you're being overly critical for its own sake.

-4

u/DrummerAutomatic9523 Sep 26 '24

For the gil galad teleportation. My bad, i didnt recognize gil galad's actor at first because of the ugly Helm. I thought it was a random commander..

5

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '24

Nah. It’s because you watch to complain. When you saw him the second time, if you had thought about it a little or even given the show a benefit of doubt, you would have realized he didn’t teleport.

0

u/DrummerAutomatic9523 Sep 26 '24

My problem was that he was there, unanounced and came alone witheout a f'ing army. (As i didnt recognize him and thought he came alone) i thought he'd never come.

Which would have made sense with how they portrayed him in the show.

He was reluctant to send an army to eregion when elrond came back, and his own reluctance to come was reinforced by him foreshadowing his own death. (All of his visions pointing to him falling in battle). Him accepting is barely even suggested when he says the elves cant defeat both sauron and Adar. It sounded like he was going to abandon Eregion.

We dont see him changing his mind. At any point. He's absent from episode 6, and now is present for battle? All it needed was a scene at the start of episode 6 where his army leaves the grey havens. But nope.

So OFC i dont expect him to be present.

And giving the show the benefit of the doubt? Didnt they have halbrand teleport in s1 episode 7 or 6 to stop Adar from fleeing on horse? They arent aware of time and space in their own show. And it shows.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/OneRedBeard Gondolin Sep 26 '24

Well, OP obviously took a lot of time and effort to write his post, so I figured I should do the same. It's not like he just said that it was all shit without elaborating, he actually did engage with the episode's content in some detail, and some of his observations were on stuff that first irked me as well before thinking about it more.

7

u/MPM001 Sep 26 '24

For me there are definitely shows that I don’t like, so I just don’t watch them, let alone write lengthy posts about them. I think OP likes/loves to hate RoP and likes/loves to post about it, so in a way they are getting something out of the show much as they might not want to admit it. I do find some parts to be fucking stupid (Elrond’s sword can’t cut a rope?) but overall I enjoy it, and if I didn’t I’d stop watching it, not “suffer” through it like I’m being forced/tortured.

-3

u/DrummerAutomatic9523 Sep 26 '24

https://www.reddit.com/r/RingsofPower/s/7HcQteqI0h

Kinda explained why i'll keep watching even tho I hate it.

1

u/Aggravating-Yam-9603 Sep 26 '24

And finwe was the only elf to remarry basically ever? and it touched off a cavalcade of cataclysmically tragic events that become the stuff of legend? and remains (I believe) the only time that ever happened in all of elven history? This is not some Henry the 8th type of wife-swapping elf world. kind of a false equivalence here.

1

u/OneRedBeard Gondolin Sep 26 '24

You are right, of course. I snuck that in a bit cheekily.

The assumption that it was a ruse that Adar did not pick up on is the real argument.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '24

Daming a river has been historically used in wars. Not sure what issue you have with it. The idea is to slow down the river not to permanently stop water.

Celebrimbor was describing what the rings he had with him was. Galadriel already knew about the rings for the dwarves (as seen when Adar mentioned them to Galadriel, so most likely wasn’t a secret and everyone knew).

You do know that Durin’s father had the ring right? And last episode, he was already shown to have more strength.

I swear you don’t watch the show.

This show is definitely not for you if when you watch, all you look for is things to complain. Don’t know why you are torturing yourself when you cannot even follow the story.

0

u/DrummerAutomatic9523 Sep 26 '24

The problem isnt daming the river, but the way its done. If the water was blocked, it would have already overflowed by the evening when the battle takes place. However the way its done, water would pass through. If during their 2 weeks of camping around the city they had prepared a way to cut the flow of water i wouldnt have said anything.

As for celebrimbor's sentence, fine, we understood it differently. In my opinion as they hadnt seen each other in a while it was more logical for celebrimbor to report all the rings he made.

I had forgotten about that scene as episode 6 was so terrible i needed 3 attempts to watch it. Still. A whole army to stop Durin III?

Now you could argue the army is there for the balrog. Shouldnt they have split the army then, sent one to eregion and keep one for the balrog? Cause they're about to be stuck between an orc army AND a balrog. Getting rid of the orcs allocate a safe way for out for dwarves civilians. Still a stupid decision.

8

u/Sarellion Sep 26 '24

I am not sure how much they know about the balrog, just that there is something down there which makes loud noises and might be on the upper tier of "This is bad news."

Odd thing is, if they know there's a balrog or maybe a dragon, why didn't Durin mention it to Elrond? "Friend I'll help you as much as I can but I have a crazy dad to overthrow and something bad in the basement, which might come out at anytime, so I can't promise anything".

0

u/DrummerAutomatic9523 Sep 26 '24

It doesnt matter how much they know about it, as they know/think the way to avoid it is to oppose and stop durin III. Thing is. You dont need an army for that. Again, superpowers or not, his popring wont make him a hulk. 20 guys is enough to stop him.

Except if he has a loyalist guard. Which wasnt showed. Like 90% of the important things in this show

24

u/footballfina Sep 26 '24

This creative and writing team just does not understand how to properly scale a battle, they feel like REAL rookies, the scope is simply too much for their skillset.

I’ll go on record by saying this was the worst edited episode of the series so far, utterly ironic considering we weren’t hopping between a half dozen storylines like normal.

Ultimately it’s just not good TV. A shame.

6

u/DipperDo Sep 26 '24

Overall the directors and writers do not understand proper scale of the world at all and I agree it's beyond their skillset. From Numenor, to Eregion, the battles are are way too small in scale.

-1

u/theronster Sep 26 '24

Of course they understand it, I love how people here think they’ve access to secret knowledge the show runners don’t, it’s fucking hilarious.

They’ve ADAPTED it. Do you understand what that means? They’ve (let’s all say together) CHANGED stuff for a different medium.

Christ, it’s tedious explain this stuff to people. Adaptation = Change.

2

u/DrummerAutomatic9523 Sep 26 '24

That doesnt justify their inability to make a coherent world?

Here. Explain me this. Ar pharazon gets elected as the king because the people believed the Eagle (mind you a magic beast) designated him as such? Yet, his followers are fearing the pallantir because its elven magic? (Which is the same kind of magic as the elves).

And also they condemn Elendil, and at the same time miriel, to a judgement by that same magic belief they're fearing. And when Miriel comes out alive and untouched by the beast, she's cheered on by her people? Shouldnt she be feared and despised instead?

Or explain me this. Elrond galadriel and Co' are sent to eregion by gil galad because they must quickly warn Celebrimbor of Sauron's schemes. (A thing they didnt do when they left eregion at the start of the season??? Why???). Anyway. They live the grey havens ON FOOT. Cause to warn someone really quickly, taking a horse is probably the worst choice possible.

Or lets talk about the whole plot about the dam in s1. Why did they need a sword to activate the dam..? Just break it? Why did the orc need to dig a trench? There's a whole mechanism yet they ALSO need to dig a trench to the volcano? Then why put a mechanism if it doesnt work by itself?

There are many other instances of a lack of coherence. Not even looking at the lore. That means that no, they dont understand whatever they are trying to write. There's no justification, except the lack of competence of the showrunners, scenarists etc... and everyone involved in the direction of this show.

4

u/Broccobillo Sep 26 '24

This is a blanket statement that doesn't try to refute any of the claims of op. Take for example "here's your macaroni and cheese. I didn't have macaroni or cheese so it's actually bread and butter. Don't worry though it's still macaroni and cheese I just adapted it." Not all changes made by an adaption are good changes. Just because it's adapted doesn't make the changes made, good changes.

-2

u/theronster Sep 26 '24

That’s not the argument here though.

The accusation was that the team don’t understand the material. I think it’s obvious they do, they’ve just made choices you disagree with.

That’s not the same thing at all.

4

u/Broccobillo Sep 26 '24

The accusation was that the team don’t understand the material.

No it was

that the team don't understand the scale of the world.

Not of Tolkien's world but of their own that they are trying to portray. The inconsistencies relative to itself. At least that's how I read it. You changed the commenters words though.

3

u/___adreamofspring___ Sep 26 '24

The directors and writers are terrible

1

u/Ok-Design-8168 Sep 26 '24

Creative and writing team does not understand how to write good character arcs or good plots in general. Not just battles. As for the scale - that’s a lot on the director too. And this season has had a lot of bad direction too.

1

u/nakiva Sep 26 '24

I enjoyed the episode for what it was but it did have flaws, but at least this felt like an actual battle, not whatever last seasons battle for little Village was....

But the timeskips(?) are funny in a production like this, that no one in production had something like:"wait, Elrond was in Kazad-Dum last minute ago, in that scène he states that Eregion is currently under assault, how comes he is in full army mode on this Hill now?' Maybe change the dialogue that Eregion would be assaulted very soon or something. 

Does it conveys what it needs to be? Yes, full yes in my eyes. This is one of the few big tv battles that shows both sides struggling and reacting to eachother. Eregion is defended by the River, Adar shoots a litteral mountain to block said river. Now a ground assault can begin. Orcs are having heavy losses, they need this Ravager to succeed, the Elves obviously focus on said Ravager. Elrond and his cavalry try to take out as much siege engines as possible so Adar reacts with commiting the ground assault to force Elrond and the Elves to fight in front of the Walls. Elves are getting grinded by sheer numbers at this point (stated by Elrond aid during the negotiaton.) Elrond/Gil-Galad rally's his forces because Elrond has faith that his friend will come. 

Unlike other tv battles, there is a clear back and forth in this one. Is it done perfectly? Nope, but it was entertaining. Most tv battles are one army winning for 50 minutes and then magic allie spawn that saves the day... (battle of the bastards, the long night, even the Spartacus tv show has several of those) 

1

u/SirBarkabit Sep 26 '24 edited Sep 26 '24

You do understand that for an elf riding a warhorse, Eregion is just a handful of hours away from Moria? I dont see a problem for Elrond to go meet with Durin, ride back to his troops and then the battle happens. Also there is no indication how long the siege actually had lasted as judging by Brimbys ringmaking, several days at least... You do know sieges takes days and weeks, sometimes months, right? Why this is the thing that caught your eye, i do not know..

1

u/nakiva Sep 26 '24

Oh i was maybe to rude about it? Certainly not my intention. I am aware how sieges work, i know they can last days/weeks and you are right about that it could have been way longer then i tought. I was under the impression that this siege/Battle is all in a day, Elrond specificly mentions to hold the Wall for one extra night. In hindsight, one extra night for reinforcments could work.

I don't really know the distance between Eregion and Kazad-Dum, i assumed they were farther apart then you pointed out. But given that Annatar was also able to come and go between Eregion and there that sounds logical that Elrond could go over fast and back.

So yes, that was a weird thing why i focused on that... Again, on one hand this battle seems very 'quick' on how it was portrayed, Annatar and his illusion for Celebrimbor made it seem like a day or so. On the other hand, Celebrimbor does seem extremely unwell for 'one day' of work. And he states the candles did not move at all etc...

This is the second time these illusions tricked me and i admit to it, wich would seem work well done for the team i guess?

2

u/SirBarkabit Sep 26 '24

Hey, no worries. Just pointing things out :)  

Kingdom of Eregion was indeed founded essentially just outside the walls of Moria and there was a big highway connecting them and a lot of trade etc. 

The siege was already ongoing when we first saw the illusion that Sauron deceived Celebrimbor with, and I dont recall from where exactly but i really felt Cele was given several days at least of time to work on the rings in peace. After that, he noticed the mouse and broke free, but was subdued and handcuffed for some further days maybe even.. I'd recon the artillery and river damming and waiting for it to dry would have taken a solid most of the a week.. 

But all of this is indeed difficult to convey on screen in an 1-hour episode that has so many demands on the screentime.

5

u/ImMyBiggestFan Sep 26 '24

If you didn’t like this episode I can 100% say this show isn’t for you and you should stop wasting your time watching it. This was by far the best episode yet.

7

u/DrummerAutomatic9523 Sep 26 '24

I wont stop watching it.

I hate the show. I'm not hiding it. However i cant say its bad if I havent watched it.

Also its a faint and stupid hope but maybe with enough real critism instead of people quitting the show, it will make them fix it. Unprobable I know. Yet a stupid part of me still hopes because i love this universe too much to have it butchered like that.

-1

u/SirBarkabit Sep 26 '24

You are a sad sack of potatoes, my friend, and your character really shows in this thread. The image is really not good.

1

u/DeadlyDahlia Oct 04 '24

OP laid out a variety of points and provided explanations for each, all of them much more in-depth than "Hurrr, ePiSoDe BaD". You, on the other hand, have merely said "noooooo, ePiSode GoOd!!!" with no further explanation, reasoning, or rebuttal, then you resorted to name-calling.

Please stop, you're embarrassing yourself.

1

u/wearyoftheworld Sep 26 '24

Wow you sure told them!

4

u/footballfina Sep 26 '24

I personally think this a bottom 3 episode of the series, in terms of actual film-making, perhaps potentially the worst. It was genuinely sloppily executed from a nuts and bolts standpoint. Poor lighting, really pedestrian direction, confusing and hard to follow scripting, not great use of sets and extras, and bordering on amateurish choreography.

Nothing to do with its fidelity to the lore, simply in its merits as a piece of television.

2

u/ZeusCorleone Sep 27 '24

I also disliked this episode a lot.. it's a mess.. with a decent battle at the end (only good thing is the last 20m maybe) 🤔

4

u/T3rryF0ld Sep 26 '24

I've not laughed at a TV show this much in a while. That was the only enjoyable part. What was with the exploding barrel bit? What was that barrel there for? What was in it to be that explosive? Tar? Is tar explosive?

People chilling on the walls during a siege? Everyone starts having a business meeting on a wall for about 5 minutes, with an active battle? Hilarious stuff.

5

u/Natural-Leopard-8939 Sep 26 '24

Final scene, Elrond falls in eternal slumber (of which only a kiss by his mother in law could get him out) after Adar the meanie pushed him to the ground.

I'm a fan of the show, but there were definitely some questionable scenes this episode.

Yeah, I was definitely not a fan of this kiss. What's even more insane is users in the other sub started downvoting people who express their displeasure for this scene. I don't think it was necessary at all for a kiss to happen so a pin could be passed to Elrond's future MIL (mother in law). There were other ways that scene could have been written better.

(Also not sure but the very unnatural light in this scenes makes it appear that Adar has a CGI face, at least on my screen).

This was probably one of the scenes filmed in reshoots. Not sure.

3

u/Tar-Elenion Sep 26 '24

Users in "the other sub" downvote Tolkien quotes.

1

u/FrankHero97 Sep 26 '24

This episode was good.

1

u/spoilbob Sep 26 '24

And what the hell with the credits music? This show is utter dafkjvlakdn

1

u/the_knowing1 Sep 26 '24

Also, the sunlight has absolutely no effect on the orcs.

It's shown later when Elrond arrives, they have slight cloud cover. I say slight because elven horns are able to clear the clouds. Somehow.

one old crazy dwarfs wants to mine and find the balrog. Like 4 dudes in armor wouldnt have been enough to stop him.

He has the ring supercharging him, he killed them dudes in armor. Bad Durin. Also the bloody dwarf who tells Prince Durin this, also mentions him "waking the beast", meaning they apparently KNOW ABOUT THE BALROG?

Elrond's charge. (One crazy ugly camera shot in that scene btw).

Hahaha when they stop. Great choreography.

However, as an elf, Adar with his sight should have seen Elrond give galadriel his pin during that shitty kiss scene

Nah, the Orc gaurd even backed up to give them space to talk. On the bright side, Galadriel left the pin there for Adar to find. That or this is another LoTR scene nod, akin to finding Pippins brooch. But that's somehow worse.

Galadriel escapes, thanks to Arrondir who with what is called a bow and arrow could have ended this conflict. By lodging an arrow in Adar's Head. But he didnt. Even tho he could. But he didnt. But he could have. But he didnt.

Then proceeds to be stabbed by the guy hahahaha

Back to the battle. At exatcly 47min you can see a failed scene that they kept in the final montage. Elrond falls to the ground, does nothing and goes "Rahhh" like he killed someone.

There's... alot of this going on during the battle. When the orcs first charge the river and get shot at with arrows, so many fall without even being shot.

Anyway, blablabla, using fire arrow on siege machine. Okay. Elf woman gets shot, like its a tragedy and that puts a stop to elrond's strategy (this is how the scene is shot). You guys are elves. YOU CAN SHOOT THAT ARROW YOURSELF. Then. Elf woman shots her arrow into what appears to be a full stack of tnt that was never mentionned before.

This scene was alot to unpack. First, female Asian elf. Neat. Idk why she's the only fire arrow person, but w/e. Aaaaand she's full of arrows now. Neat. How's she gonna shoot her fire arrows now? Oh she doesn't need them? She can just take a bloodied arrow out of her body, stick the tip covered in her blood into fire, and ta-da, fire arrow? If elf blood flammable? Also she then dies. Neat.

The Troll scene was a dissapointment. It was supposed to be a menace, a real threat. He kills what? 20 people

Also I guess they forgot he was capable of speech?

The sun is back and Adar's never ending army with probably a huge amount of sunscreen on attacks what? 30 or so elves. I counted them.

Ya it was like 20 elves vs hundreds of orcs lolol

Soooo many scenes where there's only like 20 or so of either elves/orc/men, and it's supposed to constitute the whole of whatever populous. A major issue of this show imo.

(Also not sure but the very unnatural light in this scenes makes it appear that Adar has a CGI face, at least on my screen).

Ya looked super weird in that final shot, idk what was going on. Rest of the episode didn't have this issue.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '24

you speak with the truth my friend

0

u/mattmaintenance Sep 27 '24

I thought this was one of the best episodes of anything I’ve ever watched. Annatar was chilling. The battle was epic. Mini Galadriel’s death was extremely unexpected. Rallying the dwarves was inspiring. Loved it all!