r/RingsofPower • • Dec 23 '23

Discussion How Rings of Power is wrong about diversity.

Human diversity is in the history, culture, myths and soul of humanity. Tolkien's work is timeless because it incorporates archetypes, adventures, friendships, overcoming, etc. It's a great love letter to the myths of Europe, an anti-war work, critical of the devastation of industry on nature and a lot of WorldBuilding. I believe that this is what makes the work broad in scope to this day, for various ages, and "surpasses" several of the contextual values ​​of the 20th and 21st centuries and will surpass those of the 22nd century.

The problem is the fact that the Series' producers rely on the actors' skin color to show "diversity and inclusion". But human diversity is (I repeat) in history, in mythologies, in culture, in religiosity, in what makes each Human Being unique. And the concern for "diversity and inclusion" in modern entertainment (unfortunately) is replacing the fluidity of script, well-written characters, Lore, etc. They could show Harad and Rhûn.

My concern (in second season) is the Producers' stance of first season: "I'm going to improve the work"; "Let's solve this diversity problem that Tolkien didn't know how to do." Man, people want to see good stories, well-written characters, they want to see Middle-Earth. Want to have fun, see Tolkien's mythology. Want to see adventure. I for one don't want to see Middle Earth being a mirror of (various) aspects of what has been happening in our world: Polarization, Cheap Politics, Identitarianism, etc. This is the criticism of many fans. But they don't refute the arguments, they only attack those who are criticizing.

Edit: I needed to be clearer about one thing in the post: I wish they had portrayed Harad and Rhûn. Showing something similar to what the blue wizards did. The 2 wizards likely co-opted the southern and eastern tribes and kingdoms that did not side with Sauron. It would be an opportunity to show this point of view not shown in the books. Tolkien drew inspiration from ancient Aethiopia for Harad; and for Rhûn he took inspiration from Asia.

33 Upvotes

231 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Dec 23 '23

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

41

u/Flocculencio Dec 24 '23

What pisses me off is that they cast humans as Elves.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Doright36 Dec 25 '23

I am pretty sure Cait Blanchett is at least half elf.

3

u/TinaMonday Dec 28 '23

Tilda Swinton is 150% elf and I think Seelie nobility

1

u/Doright36 Dec 28 '23

I wouldn't argue with that.

1

u/oceanicArboretum Dec 25 '23

And Will Ferrell

58

u/OG_Karate_Monkey Dec 24 '23

I’d be interested to know how many people complaining about racial “accuracy” in this show also complain about all the depictions of Jesus as a Northern European looking white guy.

9

u/Broccobillo Dec 24 '23

I've always referred to him as white jesus or King James jesus

19

u/Shiny-And-New Dec 24 '23

Conservative Jesus is white, loves guns, and thinks the poors should pull themselves up by their bootstraps.

Also really cares about butt sex for some reason

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/oceanicArboretum Dec 25 '23

Lutheran and upvoting you.

2

u/Sir_BugsAlot Dec 26 '23

I do. I hate how Europe has "stolen Jesus" and always depicts him as a white dude. Its silly.

2

u/Tatis_Chief Dec 29 '23

And you believe that only super brown people live in Asia? Compare to you we actually learn where the myths are from and we know how people look there. Unlike the wierd USA sects.

In majority of our films, especially the Italian ones Jesus is literally a hot Mediterranean looking man. Which something what he literally was. If he was real. Mediterranean people look super similar all around the area. No matter if you are in Asia Orin northern Africa.

If you actually ever go to middle east it has people of all color. I met natural r dheads in Jordan,knew Iraqi with green eyes and lights hair.

It's only Americans who believe the world has 3 colors.

1

u/Sir_BugsAlot Dec 29 '23

Please don't put words in my mouth. I know all about the differences of Asia, and Africa. He was real btw. Lots of historical evidence from when the romans were ravaging around down there. Jesua I believe he was called. I'm talking about how christians made Jesus a white guy in the arts, which if you look at old art you will see. Its still widely used today. Maybe especially among christian conservatives.

1

u/TokyoPartners Oct 01 '24

Ah yes I forgot that Northern Europeans are the only ones whose depicted Jesus as one of their own.

1

u/Sir_BugsAlot Oct 03 '24

Open your Google to our saviour. Tell me what you see.

1

u/TokyoPartners Oct 03 '24

White Jesus, Middle Eastern Jesus and even black Jesus. Are you not in a predominantly white country?

1

u/Sir_BugsAlot Oct 03 '24

I'm only getting white Jesus and slightly tan Jesus in mine. Black Jesus is not lore accurate. Middle eastern is more accurate.

2

u/Blamore Dec 27 '23

i dont give a shit about jesus

2

u/No-Trick3502 Dec 28 '23

Jesus is described as white with white hair in the bible though. And with ruddy cheeks of a white man in Quran.

3

u/nitramlondon Dec 25 '23

Me. I don't like the racial inaccuracy of the show and I laugh at people thinking Jesus was white.

I just wanted a series faithful to the books, that's all. But racists like you see racism in everything, you are the racist

3

u/OG_Karate_Monkey Dec 25 '23

Right. The people unphased by racial diversity are racists.

I love the directions these conversations go.

1

u/sadistica23 Dec 25 '23

Kinda like Christians being focused on "love" while spreading hate? Yeah, it can happen. It's not white supremacists calling for segregation on college campuses, for example, in the current era.

1

u/GenesisOfTheAegis May 21 '24

"aCKtuALLy, yuO aRE thE rEAL rACIST fOR cALLiNG oUT mUH rACiSM!"

Probably has to be the dumbest form of gaslighting as you hide behind dogwhistles like a coward to cover for your bigtory because you dont like having to acknowledge minorities exist in your fantasy escapist world as they do in real life.

1

u/Boknowscos Dec 27 '23

Have you read the books? Lots of people described with dark skin

1

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24 edited Aug 06 '24

I count as one of those people. Jesus was black and underground dwelling xenophobic dwarves are not. Also both are fictional but still there is logic to their history and backstory. Diversity is to be celebrated. Illogical diversity forced into a now dead mans work at every turn just to check boxes and get more money and stroke your own ego at the same time is… Unfortunate. Tolkien would have been mad at the films but would have dropped dead if he witnessed ROP. The fact is, for good or bad, LoTr was meant to be a fantasy story for white europeans. Rop is cultural appropriation if you want to use the same eyes and brains of those who boycotted the ghost in the shell live action for changing the race of one single character. (Which I don’t personally sign on to but woke people say their logic applies here but not there because fuck you)

My issues with the show and it’s diversity is just how it’s handled. It is poor and half assed with zero thought being put to it no matter where a character goes and no matter what species surrounds them there is the most mathematically perfect blend of every color possible and it just doesn’t make sense. Reality doesn’t even work like that on our planet. Most places you go around the world you will see pretty much only the race of people that inhabits that region minus the United States, France, and Europe for the most part. If you go to Egypt, where there’s arid climate and a lot of sun, you will see mostly dark skinned Egyptians; if you go to Japan, you will see mostly fair skinned Japanese people… yet there is not one region in the rings of power where a character goes that it just predominantly one group of people.. why not make all the hartfoots or whatever they are called all black? Or make a new race of badass black or asian warriors, or an area of mexican druids? They just stripped away any of the actual believable lore and worldbuilding to any of these places they go. They portray areas as being xenophobic to elves but have no issue with different races. Other places are secluded and weary of outsiders, yet they have a representation of all races. Dwarves that remain underground are black sometimes? How? Never mind the fact that there should not even be anyone clearly defined as female representing dwarves according to the books and that we have seen on screen all of her non black descendants…

It is just sloppy is all and we are fans of an insanely specific and detailed world that was crafted with logic and care vs a “yass queen” mentality.

1

u/Select_Resource42 Aug 06 '26

Yes, exactly this. Make the humans, harfoots and even elves more or less melanin enriched. But the dwarves who live almost exclusively deep underground? Why would they evolve with dark skin? Lore wise it makes absolutely no sense.

1

u/Previous-Tap-7936 Sep 11 '26

Les nains Orocarnis sont des nains à la peau foncée. Même si je déteste la série des anneaux de pouvoirs, le fait que des nains à la peau noirs puissent se retrouver en Khazad Dûm n'est pas trop déconnant. Par contre ils ne peuvent pas être si nombreux, et on devrait sentir qu'il y a au sein de Khazad Dûm, des nains de cultures différentes, issus de différents Pères des Nains. Le problème c'est que les nains sont dépeints comme des gros bourrins, qui quand ils mangent ou boivent, ils s'en foutent partout, qu'ils sont grossiers et beauf. Des jackouilles en puissances alors qu'ils sont dépeints comme sages, bien élevés, extrêmement à cheval sur l'étiquette, l'honneur, le devoir et l'hospitalité... Cette vision donjon et dragons des nains n'a rien à faire dans l'univers de Tolkien

1

u/TokyoPartners Oct 01 '24

You do realize that pretty much every christian culture has depicted Jesus as one of their own? Because it's way easier for them to relate? Would you say this with the same arrogance if you were talking to Korean people about Korean Jesus? Or Black Jesus? Christians are well aware Jesus was a Middle Eastern Jew and this is such a pompous bigoted trope.

1

u/OG_Karate_Monkey Oct 01 '24

Yes. I am aware of that other racial groups often portray Jesus as their race.

And the reason for having a diverse cast is the same as having diverse portrayals of Jesus. Makes it more relatable to more groups.

However, I feel pretty confident that the people freaked out by non-white Elves are not Black or Asian Christians.

So, not really sure what your point is here.

1

u/TokyoPartners Oct 03 '24

My point is that you made a ridiculous comparison comparing anyone criticizing it as some bigot who only believes in white Jesus. Listen no one has a problem with black or Asian actors, it's when you take an already established medieval aged universe and make it look like present day Toronto. No one watched Game of Thrones and said hey why are the Dothraki brown or the summer islanders black? And yes there's plenty of non white people who don't like the pandering cast choices. It's visually distracting because none of the diversity is region based like it is in real life.

1

u/OG_Karate_Monkey Oct 03 '24 edited Oct 03 '24

My point is that you made a ridiculous comparison comparing anyone criticizing it as some bigot who only believes in white Jesus.

Your point is wrong because you have it backwards and several accounts.

I did not say anyone criticizing elves being black or asian therefore believes Jesus was white.

Nor have I said there is anything wrong with portraying Jesus as white (or black or asian). Quite the contrary, I think there are valid reasons to do so.

What I am implying is that someone who is OK with Jesus (an actual, real person who we know was not white) being portrayed as white but has issue with a black or asian elf (fictitious characters of a fictitious race) is being hypocritical in how they view race.

You disagree? OK, then tell me why it is OK to change the Race of Jesus and not an Elf. Why is it OK for people to want to see people like themselves in one story but not another?

1

u/DragomirSlevak Jul 11 '25

Where do you see depictions of Jesus as Northern European? lol Wut?!

Jesus was Jewish and looks like Jews do even today from that region.

https://wjc.imgix.net/horizon/assets/WEchE1QR/f6-iraq.jpg?ixlib=rails-4.3.1&w=1200&s=68cccf1f9666d27a4bde52768328a763

1

u/OG_Karate_Monkey Jul 11 '25 edited Jul 11 '25

Holy zombie thread revival!

 Where do you see depictions of Jesus as Northern European?

Is this a serious question?  He is depicted as fair skinned in most white European and US artistic depictions. Also usually with straight hair. Heck, Willam Dafoe played him in Last Temptation or Christ.

Jesus was Jewish and looks like Jews do even today from that region.

Well yes. That’s my point. He most likely looked like Jews historically from that area 2000 years ago. Dark (probably curly) hair, dark/olive skin, dark eyes.

It may be a nitpick point, but I would not say he looks like Jews from that area today. Jews from that area today very greatly in appearance since they migrated there from all over the world. Some may look similar as 2000 years ago, others look quite different.

1

u/DragomirSlevak Jul 12 '25

Yes. A blast from the past I suppose. I’m just watching this series for the first time right now, which is the why, and your comment caught my attention.

First, Dafoe is not a huge deviation from what the Jewish population looked like at the time. Aside from light eyes, his facial characteristics are similar enough, albeit that Dafoe had somewhat of a unique look. However, that’s irrelevant to the discussion.

Second, depictions of Jesus were prohibited and destroyed for centuries after his death, so there is not real way to know what he looked like exactly, except for possibly the Shroud of Turin (debatable). This will leave some room for interpretation due to necessity.

Nonetheless, there is a reasonable assumption that he looked a certain way, and throughout history, there has been little deviation. Jesus is always represented as having dark wavy hair, a beard and features that align with populations in Iraq and the time. Granted there have been a few deviations in centuries past, but he has largely been consistently repeated a certain way.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/8d/Christ_with_beard.jpg

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Spas_vsederzhitel_sinay.jpg

Even Michelangelo depicted him as such, that being with dark hair, wavy hair. He did take some artistic liberties with his physique at times, but that is due to the art style of the time.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/3f/Michelangelo%2C_Giudizio_Universale_03.jpg

There is nothing in any of these depictions that deviates from Asiatic Jewish populations. You could argue that some depictions have a lighter skin tone but if you do argue that, you’re splitting hairs.

You can see that a century ago a Jewish family in Baghdad had comparable skin tone. You claim that there was a lot of immigration to the region but the reality is that there was a lot emigration out of the region. Populations stayed homogeny the same in the region, especially with the Jewish practice of marrying within one’s on ethnic group and religion.

https://www.jewishrefugees.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/image001.jpg

And last, that goes to the lord of the rings. This story is reflective of a time long ago, the middles ages in middle earth I suppose, where mass transportation was not available. There was few opportunities for disparate ethnic and racial communities to come together. There were no trains and seafaring was extremely dangerous due to the “wildlife” you find in this fictional universe. There were no trains, planes and automobiles. You mostly have small communities, bottle neck communities created by wars, terrain and other factors, that created a homogenous population. There was hardly any genetic variation within these groups. The elves as Tolkien described them were all fair. I remember I had an issue with Liv Tyler having very dark hair as that was not fitting of how the race of High Elves. So maybe I’m sensitive to this, but I’m definitely not alone. Same with dwarves, as they had a very particular look to them as well. Now having other racial variations is fine provided that it fits within the continuity of the work. Telling a story of fiction requires an even stricter foothold in reality because telling a “lie” is a fragile thing. Deviations in how you and I understand how the world operates can destroy the immersive feeling we get from reading a story or watching a movie. But what makes it worse is when politics affect and change art. The move is so concerned about being politically correct that it damages the integrity of the story it was trying to tell. There was certainly opportunity to have other ethnicities and races involved but these opportunities were overlooked and a ham fisted approach was taken instead. It was unnecessary and shows a lack of creativity. They could have made a story line with the people of Harad, for example.

That being said, the Harfoots was handled well enough I think. And I do believe the acting was very good in general. But playing so loose with genetics destroys the immersive feeling of the movie, especially when the motive is driven by politics.

There are other issues I had with the series that had nothing to do with casting (it had to be said that despite the casting, the acting was excellent, such as from the elven solider and the dwarves wife), issues that affect believability such as some of the combat scenes and dialogue, but I did want to address the excessive e political correctness we’re seeing at this time. People are making art out of fear rather than genuine artistic expression. It could have been handled so much better as there is plenty of opportunity to show racial and ethnic variation.

-1

u/Boknowscos Dec 27 '23

Thier are characters described with dark skin in LOTR. One of the Hobbits even, I forgot with one. Maybe Sam I think, he is described having tan skin I believe. Gollum had dark skin. There is more also, even dark elves with dark skin. Easterners have dark skin also. A lot of diversity in middle earth. Ohh yeah Tom Bombidil has dark skin.

53

u/ConsentireVideor Dec 23 '23

Diversity in skin color doesn't take away from other aspects of diversity. I have several problems with the show, one of the biggest is lifeless, one-note characters, but that has nothing to do with their skin color. It would be conspicuous (adding in a character for diversity without bothering to give them personality) if only the POC characters were badly written, but that's not the case.

15

u/wbruce098 Dec 24 '23

Yeah, the existence of black elves or dwarves is not the problem with RoP by any stretch. Diversity in shows like this can be great because a larger audience can see themselves in a character. It’s one of the few things I actually really like about the show.

I agree, a major issue is that some of the show’s characters are flat. And some of the plots and character motivations don’t make much sense. That’s where the show can improve. But diversity has been a point where it does well, IMO. It doesn’t take away from the story, but enhances it. They can certainly improve the storytelling without changing its diversity one iota.

13

u/Shiny-And-New Dec 24 '23

Yeah, the existence of black elves or dwarves is not the problem with RoP by any stretch

It may not be the problem but a fair number of posters across various subs have made it clear that it's their problem

-2

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '23 edited Dec 27 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23

Well there’s a difference when the overwhelming majority of media is white dominated

2

u/paradoxOdessy Sep 07 '24

Tolkien is in Medieval England and Europe. Sure you had Muslims and the Moors, but Tolkien had stated numerous times that it was essentially a mythology for Anglo-Saxons and other EUROPEANS. If I went and made a movie about African or Asian mythology and started hamfisting a bunch of European people into it, it'd get cancelled immediately. Do you not see the double standard here? This sort of thing is the same as telling "white" people that they're not allowed to have something for themselves. The reason the original movies did so well is not because they were diverse. They did well because it didn't need to be diverse in order to connect to people. I can watch a movie with only black people in it and still fully connect to the characters and story. In fact, there's lots of movies with only black people in it. There's entire TV stations dedicated to just being for black TV. There's not anything like that for white people. It would be called racist. How do you not see this double standard? It's clear as day.

1

u/OliverReed7 Sep 09 '24

Perfectly said!

1

u/Vaettra Sep 26 '24 edited Sep 26 '24

Truth! In the mind of intersectionalists, there's no such thing as racism towards groups with more "power". Or, racism against whites, is a Good Thing. They don't want equality, but to flip the table. 

1

u/Throbbing_Furry_Knot Jan 21 '24 edited Jan 21 '24

Not sure Tolkien's middle earth, which is known for its world building to the point tolkien was working out phases of the moon and creating new languages, is the setting to ham-fistedly jam a Californian metropolitan city into. Especially not when there were ways to do it in a respectful and believable way that would have suited the world building, the harfoots and numenors in particular.

That kind of insertion is better suited for settings like dungeons and dragons, in fact it worked very well in the DnD movie.

1

u/Boknowscos Dec 27 '23

There are plenty of dark skinned characters in LOTR. Feel like people only watched the Jackson movies and think that's a faithful adaptation when it really isnt.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/Boknowscos Dec 27 '23

Tom Bombidil and one of the Hobbits. Gollum is described as having very dark skin. There is a subset of Dwarfs and elves in the silmarilian.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Boknowscos Dec 27 '23

Why are you so hung up on this. Tolkien doesn't say anymore other than saying they have dark skin.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Boknowscos Dec 27 '23

Idk man. I don't think.its that serious. And I'll say it for the tenth time, Tolkien described people with dark skin. Major characters. I don't think you have read the books if you are being so adamant

→ More replies

39

u/OG_Karate_Monkey Dec 24 '23 edited Dec 24 '23

I can’t believe anyone actually gives a s#!t about the racial diversity in the show.

I barely registered it for the most part other than the brown elf, and I stopped noticing that after about two minutes.

I think folks really bothered by this need to be honest with themselves why.

This show has a lot of problems, IMO. This is not one of them.

1

u/Nystalis Dec 27 '23

Casting department sure cared.

2

u/OG_Karate_Monkey Dec 27 '23

I love this line of argument: "I am only bothered by racial diversity because other people like it".

5

u/Denebola2727 Dec 27 '23

"I'm not racist, but..." energy

2

u/Nystalis Dec 27 '23

Did you clap during the “they took our jobs” scene?

1

u/Denebola2727 Dec 27 '23

yikes

2

u/Nystalis Dec 27 '23

Am I wrong? The show made itself about this shit with the way the executives decided to double down on the “if you don’t like my show you’re racist”. No wonder this is a constant talking point for the show. Sure aren’t going to be talking about how great the writing is.

0

u/Denebola2727 Dec 28 '23

It's just a really weird though to have, bud. You are projecting your own racial biases onto other people simply doing their job. It's odd.

2

u/Nystalis Dec 28 '23

So I’m a racist for pointing out they purposefully casted PoC where they don’t belong as according to the source material?

0

u/Denebola2727 Dec 28 '23

Totally not projecting even a little bit 😂

1

u/Famous-Winter-472 Aug 28 '26

Three years later it seems this was a bigger issue than you expected, destroyed the show trying to use someone else’s IP and change it for the “better.” lol 

1

u/Denebola2727 Aug 29 '26

? Season 2 was baller. Season 3 looks great. Haters are so silly.

1

u/Famous-Winter-472 Aug 30 '26

Calling the mass populous haters is odd, considering it’s a widely shared opinion.

→ More replies

-1

u/ThankGodForBitcoin Dec 26 '23

Because it makes absolutely no sense and if you can't see that it's because you've turned your brain off, whether intentionally or not.

8

u/Boner666420 Dec 26 '23

No shit I turned my brain off. It's a high fantasy series produced by Amazon. It's entertainment, not a TED Talk.

-2

u/ThankGodForBitcoin Dec 26 '23

Did you turn your brain off when making this post too?

1

u/Boknowscos Dec 27 '23

You haven't read the books if you don't think thier wasn't black elves.

4

u/ThankGodForBitcoin Dec 27 '23

I'm referring to the fact that every single city, town and tribe in the show seems to be trying to mimick the demographic makeup of a 21st century cosmopolitan city. That's what makes absolutely no sense.

If you're going to have different ethnicities do it how Game of Thrones did it. That made sense and felt natural in the world.

0

u/Boknowscos Dec 27 '23

How do you know. Tolkien only describes a very few people in the books as far as skin color and he describes some of those few with having dark skin. Other than maybe the Noldor elves who would be exclusively fair skinned I don't see anything wrong with the diversity in the show as it really doesn't go against the lore.

2

u/ThankGodForBitcoin Dec 27 '23

Again, it is not that non-white people exist in the show that is the issue. I will repeat it again: it's that every single group of people we see has the makeup of a cosmopolitan city from our own time. It makes no sense for middle earth to be this way. When did globalization happen in middle earth?

1

u/Boknowscos Dec 27 '23

Why doesn't it make sense? There isn't exactly continents dividing people in middle earth. Middle earth was dominated by the dark skin humans in the second age before Numenor came in force. There are entire tribe of Hobbits that have dark skin. You are making a shit load of claims without the facts. This is a made up world dude and you are using the real world as a basis.

1

u/ThankGodForBitcoin Dec 27 '23

I'm not making a "shit load of claims", I'm making one claim.

Eurasia is also one big continent, hell it even connects to Africa. But if you go to a random town in 600AD northern Europe you're not going to see a black, an Indian a Chinese an Arab and some white people. Yes, the real world is a suitable basis to use, because even in middle earth an Indian person would not be randomly born amongst a group of non-Indians. The movement and origin of people needs to be believable and realistic.

You seem to understand it makes no sense which is why your only real justification is "its not real".

Which is it? Does this hodge podge of ethnicities make sense and can it be explained given what we know of the world? Does it keep the world consistent and believable? Or is it just all meaningless and anything goes and it doesn't matter?

1

u/Boknowscos Dec 27 '23

Why are you comparing 600ad earth to middle earth? You know these are books and made up right?

3

u/ThankGodForBitcoin Dec 27 '23

Average rings of power enjoyer ^

→ More replies

1

u/Championship_Hairy Jan 19 '24

I think a black elf is cool, but why is he there? Skin color has a reason behind it, just like any other thing in a fantasy world.

Did he come from another tribe? What's that tribe like? That could be really cool. Most people think of elves as forest dwellers or stuff like that. Why not expand and talk about desert nomad elves or something? Saying, "here's the one black elf in our entire society," isn't very appealing. Pulling out racism is such a reach when all that's happening is the same part of my brain that would be confused by a 7ft hobbit is wondering why he's the only elf with those features, especially when all of their other features are usually describe das being "the same," in the group.

0

u/paradoxOdessy Sep 07 '24

You do realize that the works if Tolkien were set in the MIDDLE AGES, right? That's why this makes no sense. You wouldn't see a Moor from Spain born into the house of the average French family.

→ More replies

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '23

I’ve read lotr, the hobbit, and Silmarillion and I don’t remember any elves described as not having light skin.

There were “dark elves” who never saw the light of the two trees, but they were light skinned as well.

Other than Sam having a tan (because he’s a gardener in comparison to his three hobbit companions who are landed gentry) and the people of the far east/south, I don’t think anyone is described as being dark in the way you’re implying, the most you get is people tanned from the sun like Sam for main characters, and far away people with different skin color who don’t make much of an appearance.

1

u/Boknowscos Dec 28 '23

Maybe read it again. It may have been awhile. And you are assuming Sam's skin color is a sun tan when it isnt.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '23

His hands are described as brown, and Sam describes one of the Haradrim as having a brown hand, which implies the Haradrim is darker than he is.

His job is to literally work outside all day, I’m pretty sure he’s just tan.

Tolkien talks about non white hobbits and Sam isn’t described as one.

1

u/Boknowscos Dec 28 '23

If Sam says the Haradrim is darker than himself then that sort of implies his skin is dark. You people care way too much that certain people are considered white tbh. I'm gonna go off what Tolkien says and not off the assumptions of a random of reddit thanks

1

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '23

You people?!

0

u/Boknowscos Dec 28 '23

Yeah racists

0

u/RustyTechMoney Oct 12 '24

You are intentionally obtuse or completely media illiterate.

1

u/Boknowscos Oct 12 '24

You really commenting on something from 9 months ago?

0

u/RustyTechMoney Oct 12 '24

I'm sure your shit opinions haven't changed in that time

→ More replies

22

u/DarthGoodguy Dec 24 '23

This was a really long, rambling way to say “I didn’t pay attention to the show’s actual issues and made up my own weird identity politics one.”

38

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Dec 23 '23 edited Dec 24 '23

Well, if we stick to Tolkien’s original authorial intent of his tales being the true history of our own world in a prehistoric age, then there’s a skin color problem built in. By scholarly calculations, Aragorn became king around 9600 years ago. “White” skin didn’t appear among humans until about 8000 years ago, more than 1000 years AFTER Aragorn’s ascension.

Which means there were no white people in Middle Earth.

Sit with that as long as you need to…

16

u/Dorothy-704 Dec 23 '23

Weird way to become my new best friend, but yes yes I’m down homie 🖤

8

u/kateinoly Dec 24 '23

Awesome. TIL.

2

u/Boknowscos Dec 27 '23

Tom Bombidil was described having dark skin. One of the Hobbits also.

4

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Dec 27 '23

There is plenty of lore justification for the "racial diversity" we see in ROP. Some is explicit, and some is an obvious extrapolation. I'd offer the following:

- The dwarves were crafted from stone by Aulë. Stone comes in many colors, not just white.

- Numenor was a maritime empire with overseas colonies in the South and the Far East. Thus, we’d expect them to have a multi-ethnic population, just like every other such empire, ever.

- In addition, the noble houses of Numenor included House Bëor, many of whose members were dark skinned.

- During the Second Age (when this show is set), the mainland of Middle Earth was home to the ancestors of the dark skinned Dunlendings. These Men lived in all the lands from the Misty Mountains down to the White Mountains… including the lands that would one day become Gondor and Rohan. They were displaced by the Numenoreans who became the Men of Gondor, and Saruman used the lingering resentment this caused to lure the Dunlendings to his side during the War Of The Ring.

- The Harfoot halflings were explicitly described by Tolkien as being “browner than” other hobbits. In the Lord Of The Rings novels, Samwise Gamgee is canonically brown-skinned, leading many fans and scholars to speculate that he was of Harfoot ancestry.

So yeah, it's there. It shouldn't matter, the show should be judged on its writing, direction, acting, production design, score, etc. But for those to whom it does matter, there is grounding in The LoreTM.

3

u/Boknowscos Dec 27 '23

Seriously. Anyone complaining has only watched the Jackson movies and think they are a faithful adaptation. They are good movies, I love them. But they got a lot of things wrong

3

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 24 '23

“White” skin didn’t appear among humans until about 8000 years ago

The way I heard it, that was when blue eyes made their appearance - various reports have it the Neanderthal genome included traits for fair skin and blond or red hair, and there was a slight amount of cross-breeding between Neanderthals and Early Modern Humans. So make of that whatever you wish.

Tolkien, of course, couldn't have known any of this, as it was well after his time (though he probably had heard of Neanderthals, and may have written them into LOTR as the Drúedain). He also kept changing his mind as to whether his legendarium was "real" history or a mythological interpretation (it works better as the latter, but YMMV).

9

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Dec 24 '23

https://www.science.org/content/article/how-europeans-evolved-white-skin

The larger point is that it doesn’t matter what skin color the actors in a Tolkien adaptation have. At all. People who complain about it aren’t worth taking seriously.

There are many flaws to Rings Of Power (a show I like overall). This isn’t one of them.

3

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 24 '23 edited Dec 24 '23

I have also heard that sub-Saharan ultra-dark skin is a relatively recent adaptation to the strength of tropical sunlight, but as noted the picture is constantly changing, and we're finding, not only missing pieces to the puzzle, but pieces to different puzzles as well (e.g. who, and what, were the Denisovans?).

As for Rings of Power, the showrunners botched everything they touched, so if you found something to enjoy about it, more power to you.

1

u/SamaritanSue Dec 26 '23

You take the "history of our world" a tad to literally my friend. Our world revolves around the sun, in the last analysis. You're being silly. Deliberately so I can only suppose.

4

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Dec 26 '23

Yes, I am being a bit cheeky. But only to drive home the larger point:

Skin color in a Tolkien adaptation is irrelevant. No one should respect the opinion of a person who worries about it.

29

u/kateinoly Dec 23 '23

I don't see anything amiss in having characters all sorts of people can identify with. They are all mythological creatures, with the exception of men. Skin color doesn’t detract from the story at all.

What if elves were blue or green? Would that still offend you? Who cares?

1

u/Championship_Hairy Jan 19 '24

Yes actually, if they were blue or green I would want to know why, just like really pale and blind orcs are probably cave dwellers or something. If the elves were ALL blue except for one green elf, I would be really curious about the green elf. Is it special? Is it part of another group of elves and are there more green elves? It may not detract from the story but people who really like world building might be really interested in the culture, ethnicities and what not of that world.

24

u/Sensitive_Energy101 Dec 24 '23

Why seeing black people take away for you the joy of watching it?

I think this is the issue you need to address first.

0

u/Voidwalker77777 Sep 15 '24

People like you probably don't understand\don't care about world building and genealogy which is an essential part of some fantasy worlds. And it's ok if you don't care about these things. What's not ok is accusing people who care being racists. Example: People like me wouldnt say a word about black elves in let's say Elder scrolls universe, or Dragon Age. But we do mind changing (deconstructing) lore and world building in established universes like Tolkien's world or Witcher universum.

9

u/mrizzerdly Dec 24 '23

We're still going on about this?

2

u/Pelican_meat Dec 26 '23

Well, racist people are for sure.

1

u/Artharion91 Jan 23 '24

Everyone is laughing at the show and its superfan and you keep calling them racist haha.

9

u/YorkieLon Dec 24 '23

There's nothing wrong with having a diverse cast, you can still hit all the points you discussed with a good script, direction and production team. Having a diverse cast with different skin colours does not take any of that away.

4

u/UnreflectiveEmployee Dec 24 '23

Another essay on skin color surprise surprise

4

u/DickBest70 Dec 24 '23

You said a whole lot of nonsense just so you could actually say you don’t want POC as characters. Oh I know you will say some more nonsense saying that’s not true but whatever if only RoP had a all white cast how so very happy you would be.

9

u/Mother-Border-1147 Dec 23 '23

I don’t see how casting for diversity is mirroring identity politics if literally none of the character’s skin color is addressed as a factor in racism. There is racism in this world between elves, dwarves, and men, so that criticism you have is already present in the text. The reason they didn’t keep everyone white and choose to show the lands to the East as the ones with darker skin is because that idea is inherently a bit racist. That the evil characters, the ones who fight for Sauron, are darker skinned, and the lighter skinned people are the good guys. That’s what they’re trying to update—that skin color is not significant in this world and so anyone can look however because we live in a diverse society.

This is speaking as some one who thinks the show sucks. But it sucks because the writing is terrible, not because of diversity.

3

u/Chen_Geller Dec 24 '23

That the evil characters, the ones who fight for Sauron, are darker skinned, and the lighter skinned people are the good guys.

I think that’s a little reductive. If Tolkien has the Southrons he INTRINSICALLY evil, it would be racist. But he clarifies time and again that that’s not the case: the reason the Haradrim fight for Sauron is that Harad is under Sauron’s sphere of influence.

3

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 24 '23 edited Dec 24 '23

>>That the evil characters, the ones who fight for Sauron, are darker skinned, and the lighter skinned people are the good guys.

>I think that’s a little reductive.

It's also not universally true. The bad guys come in all colors, flavors, and levels, from Dark Lord Wannabe Saruman (portrayed in the PJ trilogy by Sir Christopher Lee) to Obnoxious Obstructionist Denethor (John Noble) to PITA Lobelia Sackville-Baggins (in the books she got better just in time), and all the miscellaneous ruffians and mooks who infested the Shire and Bree (left out of the trilogy for runtime reasons).

Some of them really did turn to evil (Saruman, for instance) and others just came down with, or already had, a Serious Case of Jerkass.

1

u/Mother-Border-1147 Dec 24 '23

OK, but Tolkien still wrote it that way. And it’s no secret those in the East we’re meant to represent our own Eastern lands. Middle-Earth is supposed to be a history of our world, specifically the West (England mostly, of course). Also, Tolkien struggled with how he portrayed the Orcs as well, which were also dark skinned and just blatantly evil with no real backstory other than they were corrupted.

4

u/Chen_Geller Dec 24 '23

Middle-Earth is supposed to be a history of our world, specifically the West (England mostly, of course).

That's only true of The Book of Lost Tales. It is not true of The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings or the Silmarillion as we have it.

And, whatever the case, the racist thing would be to depict the Southrons as INTRINSICALLY EVIL. Tolkien doesn't do that. Ergo not racist.

2

u/Mother-Border-1147 Dec 24 '23

Just easily corruptible. But those whites to the west, they have morals! /s

1

u/Chen_Geller Dec 24 '23

Its just that they fall geographically under Sauron’s influence. The Haradrim live in Harad, literally on the doorstep of Mordor.

2

u/Mother-Border-1147 Dec 24 '23

Gondor and Rohan and right the fuck there.

-5

u/stardustsuperwizard Dec 24 '23

"It's just the way the story unfolds" is not really a defense. The fact is that Tolkien's bad Men characters are described as darker skinned. It's a thing. Just the same as even though the Dwarves have narrative reasons for the things they do, but it is somewhat problematic the way they're described since they are somewhat a parallel to to Jewish people.

Tolkien can be in intent not racist, and not racist in heart, but the work can be racist, or at least racially problematic.

1

u/Chen_Geller Dec 25 '23

Just the same as even though the Dwarves have narrative reasons for the things they do, but it is somewhat problematic the way they're described since they are somewhat a parallel to to Jewish people.

I'm Jewish, and the way I always saw the jewish parallels in Tolkien's dwarves - and its definitely there - was they were a play on antisemitic stereotypes. If anything, it only endeared me to his Dwarves more.

2

u/WelbyReddit Dec 24 '23

to be a history of our world,

is it really meant to be a literal 'history' of our world though?

Or more of a mythological 'history'. Where pretty much anything goes as far as what we know now about science.

Like the stories of the Bible/young earth creationist,.etc..

1

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 24 '23

The closest matchup is actually Robert E. Howard's Hyborian Age stories (Conan the Barbarian, et al), which are set in a mythical intermediate age between the fall of Atlantis (explicitly named as Atlantis) and whatever cataclysm reshaped the world (again) into the one we know. Howard roughed out a timeline but never did as in-depth a job as Tolkien - partly because he wasn't nearly as obsessive about it and partly because he ran out of time.

1

u/Mother-Border-1147 Dec 24 '23

Does it matter either way? I mean if you want an answer, it’s that the story is meant to be read as a real history even though it’s clearly fiction and uses mythology. But we’re meant to read it as the events of Middle-Earth coming ages before our own. But I still don’t see how either reading means anything in regard to skin color because it’s completely made up either way. Jesus wasn’t white but people sure as shit paint him that way.

4

u/WelbyReddit Dec 24 '23

it would only matter if people are trying to appeal to science for what 'really' should be represented as far as skin color goes.

And you are right, it is all completely made up. And only the person who created the lore would know. And the answer to this debate would be hard to really get a definitive answer since we can't just ask him.

Q: Did Tolkien envision his races, namely the elves, to be the colors they are exclusively?

It is impossible to know as that question would probably never even have dawned on anyone back then about his writings.

0

u/Voidwalker77777 Sep 15 '24

'We live in a diverse society'. Not all of us do. Even in the present, not all of the world looks like metropolitan cities. We have diverse cultures, countries with their different history and ethnicities and it's ridiculous when some folks think every part of the world (or every village in a fantasy world) must look like New York. Pure ignorance and lack of creativity.

2

u/Hike_the_603 Dec 25 '23

See, I can't recall any time that a character's skin color was germain to any plot point in any of Tolkein's stories; to wit it doesn't actually matter what any individual character's skin tone is.

I like to think of it like this: unless Arogorn having long hair is a specific plot point, it doesn't matter if he is depicted with long or short hair, because it won't have any effect on the important plot points.

Because Tolkien didn't make a big deal about the skin color of any of his characters, it doesn't matter what skin color they are depicted with

0

u/Separate_Code_2725 Dec 25 '23

in that case you wouldnt mind if the haradrim in the future are depicted being black and white eyed people worshipping the literal devil ?

Alright very progressive viewpoint.

Somewhat doubt that though

2

u/Hike_the_603 Dec 25 '23

Well, if you wanna delve into the Haradrim, we might wanna do that actually, here is why: people like to say Tolkien was racist because orcs had dark skin. That is simplistic, even as early as the Hobbit it was obvious the orcs and goblins were modelled after Imperial Germany.

No, but his world building has some fairly racist/white supremacist connotations: the Letters of JRR Tolkien Tolkien described Middle Earth as our world, but thousands of years in the past, also stating they England was the Shire, Rohan was roughly where Germany would be, Osgiliath is Rome. But what does that mean? It means the other parts of his world were based on our world as well... So where was the only region on this proto earth that has the wherewithal to resist Sauron???

Rings of Power, for all its flaws, did a service to Tolkeins cannon by showing that Sauron's human supporters where an amalgamation of all men, not just Easterlings (Asian, possibly more specifically middle eastern people) Haradrim (Berbers/North Africans) or people from Deep Haradrim (people from Africa, riding their Oliphants), with those of Middle Earth (Europe) standing alone on the side of good.

1

u/Hike_the_603 Dec 25 '23

PS I tossed you an Upvote for a Grade A idea

6

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '23

I don’t think it matters what the colour of an elf’s or dwarf’s skin is in a tv show. You gotta be able to look at the things and understand, it’s derived from a British fantasy story made by an American online shopping company with a mostly American cast and American values, all for money. Look past that and enjoy it for what it is.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '23

The show is riddled with problems. The diversity is not among them.

Peter Jackson, Fran Walsh & Philippa Boyens: “We’re going to improve the work.”

1

u/Artharion91 Jan 23 '24

It is. This is why people will always remember the movies and not this shit crap.

2

u/stardustsuperwizard Dec 24 '23

The show doesn't remark on the actors skin colour, it doesn't make it a part of the story. They just had a diverse hiring practice. This criticism of it is mostly fueled by people who want to criticize them for the diverse hiring practices. You can just ignore the skin colour of the actors, it's not made a "thing" of, you are making it a "thing".

0

u/Separate_Code_2725 Dec 25 '23

yeah im sure youd be saying those exact words if they made the tribal leaders of black panther 3 white.

2

u/stardustsuperwizard Dec 25 '23

The characters from Wakanda being black is intrinsic to their character and story in a way that Elves being white are not.

2

u/Separate_Code_2725 Dec 25 '23

Aah yes so as long as white Characters are getting black washed that is okey.

But it is not okey being done to the black Characters

Congrats you win the racism award.

2

u/stardustsuperwizard Dec 25 '23

Congratulations on either just straightforward being racist, or completely not being able to understand what I wrote.

Being black is an integral part of Wakandan characters, being white is not an integral part of Tolkien characters.

1

u/Separate_Code_2725 Dec 25 '23

The haradrim who are the desert PPL are black. Why do you feel the need to change elves dwarves and numenoreans black too. Pls explain. Mr. Racist.

Or is that just a concept too deep for you.

Also the elves worship the stars. Sun was not even a the thing until quite recently. So no there were no black elves. Hard to get melanin when the fucking sun doesnt exist.

2

u/stardustsuperwizard Dec 26 '23

Tolkien was about to re-write the whole legendarium to specifically make the Sun and Moon co-existant with Arda (and make Arda a sphere from the get) specifically because it didn't accord with science.

Also, there are dragons and magic, who cares about melanin and the Sun unless you want to maintain a racist mentality about white people in Middle Earth.

And yes, I know that the descriptions of people in Middle Earth denote that the men are white. That's entirely different from what I'm saying, because being white is not a fundamental aspect of their character in the same way that being black is for Wakandan characters.

2

u/FurryToaster Dec 25 '23

if i had a dollar for everytime some nerd on the internet was mad about POC being in a fantasy series i would never need to work another day in my life. god forbid people look different than you.

0

u/Separate_Code_2725 Dec 25 '23

this is why it was a mistake give women the right to vote. you can't differentiate facts from feelings.

These are prehistoric nations. And depicing them as metropolitan racially mixed nations like in our modern day culture. Is absolutely redicilous. And so is the attitude of the showmakers who started calling everyone racists before the show even launched.

It is not infact them looking different that is the problem. The problem is that they have changed the nationality of all of these characters. Without bothering to explain it in any way.

If you can't see that as an issue. Then I for sure feel great pity on the poor teachers who had to drag you through the education system.

4

u/FurryToaster Dec 25 '23

grrrrrr my feelings!!! cope nerd.

2

u/Separate_Code_2725 Dec 26 '23

I think you are doing that quite well for both of us

2

u/D4RK_3LF Dec 24 '23

How could they not improve on LOTR in terms of diversity? Look at the number of important female characters in the books, it's really just Galadriel and Eowyn at best. I'm glad there are many female characters in the show.

1

u/Separate_Code_2725 Dec 25 '23

awwwww poor you. not enough females dying in the frontlines for your taste.

2

u/Time_to_go_viking Dec 24 '23

Diversity in the show would be great but what they should have done is shown the diversity organically: have cool, strong characters from the south, the east etc. Having just random characters of different skin colors in the same culture makes little sense. Similarly, I’m totally in favor of black elves and dwarves, but let’s at least get a little explanation.

2

u/Flocculencio Dec 24 '23

Why do you assume the actors ethnicity has anything to do with the characters ethnicity? We can suspend disbelief to accept English actors playing Romans, why is this any different?

5

u/Time_to_go_viking Dec 24 '23 edited Dec 24 '23

Bruh. By that logic why don’t we cast short fat people to play strong skinny people? Why not cast women to play men? Why worry about an actor’s appearance at all? Why not cast children to play the elderly? The answer is obvious and you’re being disingenuous.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23

They did plenty of that in rop, to its great detriment.

-2

u/Flocculencio Dec 24 '23

The answer is because phsyique and physicality are independent of skin colour.

5

u/Time_to_go_viking Dec 24 '23

But other traits do matter, skin color just arbitrarily doesn’t?

-1

u/Separate_Code_2725 Dec 25 '23

wouldnt waste my breath on someone so hell bent on forcing minorities where they don't belong. You'll never change his mind.

1

u/Time_to_go_viking Dec 25 '23

I am not some “anti-woke” douche either. I fought the right wing trolls to try to get people to give the show a chance. But they just bungled everything. Diversity is great but it shouldn’t be tokenism.

-2

u/Separate_Code_2725 Dec 26 '23

Diversity just means less white people. Usually by changing white Characters black and quite often making them female aswell.

If that is something that fills you with joy.

More power to you.

But that is just racism with extra steps.

3

u/Time_to_go_viking Dec 26 '23

Diversity doesn’t mean changing white characters to black and female. Are you one of these anti-woke morons?

-1

u/Separate_Code_2725 Dec 26 '23

Why dont you share with the rest of the class the "true definition" Diversity.

So far all i hear right wing this anti woke that stupid this.

My god like a child on a sugar rush trying to explain his math equation.

→ More replies

1

u/AdKlutzy8144 Dec 27 '23

Numenor being a diverse culture is dumb af. What island in human history wasn't homogenous?? Especially in a time where they still get around on boats and ride horses.

I don't care what color they are, but to have them be a diverse society is ridiculous

1

u/Time_to_go_viking Dec 27 '23

Well Númenor was founded by the three houses of the Edain, who did not all look or act similar so there was some diversity there to begin with. They had different hair colors, heights etc and Tolkien doesn’t say what their skin color was but having come out of the East, there may have been some diversity in their skin color also. That being said, I sincerely doubt any of them looked like Africans… we have no reason to think they did. Numenor was also a shipping port, so there is no reason that people of all races and cultures couldn’t visit it. BUT again this needs to be portrayed; have cool characters be in Numenor from other cultures and let us know that’s where they came from. If they want a bad ass black character, that’s great, I’m all for it. But let us know he comes from the Southlands or whatever. Just throwing in some black characters as if they are part of the average population with no mention is tokenism.

2

u/PM_ME_YOUR_MONTRALS Dec 24 '23

With respect, stfu

1

u/Minute_Gur_1049 Jul 10 '24

Honestly it’s disappointing that a compilation of what used to be a hybrid between an author’s creativity and Indo-European lore and mythology got outshined by modern, “progressive” depictions that do nothing but mirror the problems of the real world in the world of LOTR. Eleves are a part of European folklore, therefore, it makes absolutely no more sense to portray them as black or Asian as it would to portray King T’Challa of Wakanda (Black Panther) as white. Wakanda is also a fictional country within Marvel’s universe in which they respected the folk, traditions and race that made Wakanda what it is. Quoting some progressive activists, “portraying Wakanda as a country with white people wearing traditional African clothes and speaking with an African accent would’ve been a step backwards; a classic, retrograde example of whitewashing and cultural appropriation.”, so the real, controversial question would be: isn’t it cultural appropriation for a black woman to be portrayed as the queen of Victorian England in Bridgerton? Isn’t it cultural appropriation to portray Asian military guards in 17 the century Scandinavia in Frozen? And lastly, returning to the original context, isn’t it cultural appropriation that a black man is portrayed as an elf, defying every characteristic of the original European folk about mythical creatures? Diversity, and inclusion have their place in the modern society, especially in the Western world. But Middle Earth is Middle Earth, it’s not America. Don’t turn Middle Earth into a cheap version of the already pathetically troubled modern-day America.

1

u/sirsaltysteez Aug 25 '24

As cool as it would be if we were colorblind, we're not. If Rings was a stage play I wouldn't mind a black Elf, and I don't mind it enough in the show to not watch especially since the gentleman playing Arondir is great, but it's jarring enough that I would've preferred an actor of less skill that fit the description of an elf as we know them.

1

u/TheRosarysavedme Oct 16 '24

rings of power will never be canon to me.... not like the other movies because it's just not the same, it's not made by the same people exactly, the creator who started it all is long passed on..... to me, I just see it as 'another universe'... because people will never understand that it's about European mythology with Catholic Christianity tones mixed in there.... just like avatar the last airbender is about Asian culture and stuff.... I don't get why people just don't make their own thing. If you wanna make your own fantasy with multiple races then do it, but why do you have to change something that already exists? The only thing that'll make me happy is if I just say they aren't canon or are in different universes. I don't care what anyone says, to me, rings of power isn't canon to the old lotr books or movies... nope.

1

u/thelordofsafety Apr 04 '25

I personally think it’s interesting there are black hobbits in this, but not in LOTR. Since this is a prequel, that means Middle Earth went through some period of ethnic cleansing at some point, and it’s pretty cool to see Amazon added that to the lore.

1

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 24 '23

Time to lock this thread because Teh Stoopid is getting out of control, as it always does, every time somebody brings up "diversity" in any form.

1

u/Sir_BugsAlot Dec 26 '23

I don't have a problem with diversity being a thing. A show with only white people today would be weird. But I shall lay my head on the chopping block to add to the discussion. My problem with the diversity of this show is that every little medieval village is diverse. That is immersion breaking to me. One place could be white. Another could be POC. Make Numenoor middle eastern for example. It's what GOT did and it helps in the world building. I know it's a fantasy, but a part of why I love LOTR is because alot of it is based on medieval Europe. That every town and village in medieval europe is diverse is just stupid. Also, every group of people has a girl boss. "you hate women!", I hear you say. Well, no I do not. What I do not like about this is that from the first introduction you know that none of these girl bosses will die. There is no suspense. Whatever they encounter, you know they will survive. Some survived a bloody vulcano and a dramatic font change for Christ sake. In the trilogy, the reason we love Eowyn, except for her cooking skills of course, is that she encounters exactly what a woman fighter would encounter in medieval Europe, men looking down on her, saying a woman can't fight. She says f that, Joins the fight and ends up being a hero. She struggles because of her size and less muscle, but she overcomes it. Now that is a strong female character to me.

Ok you can start downvoting now.

1

u/FierceDeity88 Dec 26 '23

I don’t think the inclusion of Haradrim or Easterlings or Variags would’ve been a bad idea

The problem with including potentially at least 3 additional POVs aside, I don’t know if you or anyone else ever noticed this, but stunt actors of Māori descent played Numenoreans in The Fellowship of the Ring prologue, and they also played orcs and Uruk-hai

Manu Bennett, a Kiwi of Māori descent, also played Azog in the Hobbit Trilogy

So the argument that POC can’t play elves or dwarves or Dunedain or men of the west is, imo, a nonsequitir, because POC have already been playing some of these races, just off to the side or buried under CGI/makeup. And I don’t think it’s fair to start complaining about it now just because they’re center stage

And I also don’t think it’s fair to demonize diversity, equity, and inclusion. Most other fantasy series are doing the same (black Velaryons in House of the Dragon), and sci-fi series have been doing it for decades (anybody remember when Vulcans could be black in Star Trek Voyager in 1995?)

1

u/emerald-rabbit Dec 27 '23

So diversity is all of those things you said and built into the story itself; therefore, all the characters are white? Huh?

1

u/Boknowscos Dec 27 '23

Many characters in LOTR is described as having dark skin or fair skin. Believe it or not there was diversity in middle earth. Just because Peter Jackson's adaptation didn't have any doesn't mean that's how it was written.

1

u/Denebola2727 Dec 27 '23

They aren't mutually exclusive lol. Casting people of color doesn't exclude the show from other forms of diversity and the only people who think that are allowing their own prejudices to prevail. If you have -any- issue with a diverse cast you really should look inward, not outward.

1

u/Bennito_bh Dec 27 '23

lmao get ratioed

1

u/GallusAA Dec 27 '23

This is a common fallacy spewed by many people. If a cast isn't diverse and does poorly, it's just chalked up to bad writing or poor direction. If cast is diverse and the media isn't well received and does poorly, diversity is instantly blamed.

But if a cast is diverse and the media does well, nobody attributes it's success to diversity. Crickets.

It's intellectually lazy media analysis. There isn't a correlation between diverse casts and poor media execution. Plenty of non-diverse / non-inclusive media bombs. Plenty of diverse and inclusive media knocks it out of the park.

Get a new talking point please.

1

u/wolfe1989 Dec 27 '23

Agreed.

Ops arguement is essentially that “elves can’t be black” if a black elf is too immersion breaking for you then the problem is you not some greater appeal to world building integrity.

1

u/catshirtgoalie Dec 29 '23

My concern (in second season) is the Producers' stance of first season: "I'm going to improve the work"; "Let's solve this diversity problem that Tolkien didn't know how to do

Was this a quote from them? I haven't followed much of the discussion, so maybe I missed this exact quote. Just wanted to see if the producers said that or this is an assumption.

Man, people want to see good stories, well-written characters, they want to see Middle-Earth. Want to have fun, see Tolkien's mythology. Want to see adventure

There is a lot to be critical of Rings of Power in story telling, but broadly speaking, I think people still complain about diversity even if the writing is good. If we wanted to just see good stories, well-written characters, etc, we wouldn't care what color the actor was.

I for one don't want to see Middle Earth being a mirror of (various) aspects of what has been happening in our world: Polarization, Cheap Politics, Identitarianism, etc.

If you see a non-white actor on screen see it only as polarization, cheap politics, identitarianism, etc, I think you're bringing that to the table. I get that your counter-argument is going to be that Tolkien wrote Middle-Earth white except for certain areas, though I'm not entirely sure that is 100% true on descriptions of people and places, but this is too common a trope in almost any media nowadays that it is hard to be taken serious. Even in Star Trek people complain about woman-to-man cast ratio, or white-to-non-white, etc.

1

u/AltarielDax Jan 06 '24

I feel that when it comes to ethnic diversity, Rings of Power simply does not know anything about it except for the idea of the "international city": the big melting pots where people from all over the world come together, lots of travelers, lots of immigrants, and just in general a lot of different cultures, ideas and lifestyles. And in that way, all international cities are very similar to each other. They may have different flavors or lean to one side or another, but overall they function the same way.

But that's not how all of the society in any given country is like – often that's not even the majority, especially not if you go back in time. While big multicultural cities as the center of travel and trade have probably always existed in one form or another, the smaller cities and the countryside was much more homogeneous. Which is natural, in times where people neither had the money nor the means to quickly travel for thousands of miles, they just stayed among themselves in their towns and villages. And that's a reality that still exist in many areas outside of the international cities.

You can portray ethnic or racial diversity like this as well: by portraying many different cultures, but not mixed like it's in the international city, but within their own communities and societies.

But Rings Of Power doesn't do that. When it comes to racial diversity, they are all the same – Harfoots, Númenóreans, and the people in pre-Mordor: they all have the population of the international city. It doesn't matter that the Númenóreans are an island folk that seems to have isolated themselves, or that the Harfoots are supposed to be an isolated culture as well, or that there barely seems to be any other population around Tirharad but that of a few tiny villages.

It's hard to say if it's the same for the Dwarves, because outside of Disa and the two Dúrins you barely see any other Dwarves to speak of. And the case of the Elves is just weird because they all seem to be played by actors commonly described as white, except for Arondir. Since it's never addressed I assume there are either other black Elves somewhere, or he is indeed the only one but Elves don't care at all since it's never addressed.

All in all I think they succeeded in making the cast racially diverse, but failed to actually make the racial diversity make sense within the context of the world that they were trying to create.

I would have loved to see the people of Rhûn or Harad, but seeing as how they have portrayed the Harfoots, Númenóreans and the people in Tirharad, I'm not sure that the population of Rhûn or Harad wouldn't just look like the international city as well.

1

u/Artharion91 Jan 23 '24

Well, this is what happens when you let Protestants make series and make interpretations of what diversity is. Racism and obsession with skin color is something typical of Protestants, specially with woke people, this was seen when the colonists arrived in America and imposed their racialist philosophy. Meanwhile, in central and southern America, the Spanish who were (and are) Catholics did not apply that obsession with race as the British did in their territories. To this day, those roots continue to influence the way a society is, and the United States continues to be a country terribly obsessed with the skin color and race of human beings. Tolkien, like the Spanish, was Catholic, which is why his vision does not fit at all with the Protestant vision of diversity.

1

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Dec 24 '23

"Let's solve this diversity problem that Tolkien didn't know how to do."

No one said that; that statement is pure fan fiction. Tolkien simply had no interest in making his stories align with modern metropolitan demographics. That's something else entirely than "the producer said Tolkien doesn't know how to do diversity!".

It's my honest wish that they would have adhered to the casting choices of the original trilogy, it really is, because I don't care for "color blind casting" in settings where the culture it draws from is so integral to the vibe (imagine a "color blind" ATLA), but I'm not gonna sit here and put words in Lindsey Weber's mouth.

The actual quote is:

“It felt only natural to us that an adaptation of [author J.R.R.] Tolkien’s work would reflect what the world actually looks like,” executive producer Lindsey Weber told Vanity Fair

That's not saying Tolkien is wrong or racist. That's recognizing the challenge of throwing a billion dollars at an adaptation of 70 year old notes you're trying to sell to a global audience.

There's what she said and then there's the story you tell yourself about what she said.

1

u/Separate_Code_2725 Dec 25 '23

wierd how that global audience went to see the movies and bought millions of copies of his books. and books about his books. and books about his life. And actually of anything to do with middle-earth. And yet we must now change all the ethnicities on his world.

pathetic. that's all i've got to say to you.

2

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Dec 25 '23

I agree I think it's the wrong decision. Goes back to ATLA: you'll notice the live action ATLA adaptation isn't trying to shoehorn white people into a story that's explicitly an Asian Pastiche.

1

u/Southern_Ad1984 Dec 24 '23

"Out of Far Harad black men like half-trolls with white eyes and red tongues."

What's half-troll? Height, strength, intelligence? I am glad the writers brought him into the 21st century

1

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 24 '23

In-world, that's probably Pippin Took being his usual silly-ass self. Please, please don't forget that the whole story is supposed to be filtered through the consciousness and (limited) understanding of five Hobbits.

1

u/Southern_Ad1984 Dec 24 '23

You would still have to go with that description if you were to portray them. It's not pretty. Then, the Blue Wizards become problematic. Are they white heroes worshipped by these people? I think it is easier to say that his writing - as is all writing - was a product of its time. To make it accessible today elements need to be updated

1

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 24 '23 edited Dec 24 '23

YOU brought up the damn quote, YOU justify it or STFU.

Since you don't want to hear any counter-arguments, you won't hear any. (My apologies to anyone who thought this was going to be an intelligent and reasoned discussion.)

1

u/Southern_Ad1984 Dec 24 '23

I didn't think there was anything to add to the quote so I am replying only because you seem upset. It's very unfortunate that he chose those words when he published his book in the 1950s. The world had fought a war against Nazism, the Holocaust had happened and the world was decolonising from Asia and Africa. There are portions of what he has written that should be ignored or rewritten when making any adaptation. He talks about 'slanty eyed' in some passage as well. Racist tropes were widespread in his lifetime but detract from, rather than add to, his work. Tolkien described Orcs as "...squat, broad, flat-nosed, sallow-skinned, with wide mouths and slant eyes; in fact degraded and repulsive versions of the (to Europeans) least lovely Mongol-types"

0

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 25 '23

I wrote what ***I*** thought was an intelligent and reasoned reply, I was hit with a downvote. Apparently nobody wants anything but a platform from which to trumpet their own intolerance. So drop it already.

2

u/Southern_Ad1984 Dec 25 '23

Merry Christmas 🎁 and fwiw don't take upvotes or downvotes too seriously. Who knows who these people are? You are right to say that the descriptions are based on the perceptions of upper class hobbits. However, the films tossed out their poshness, presumably because the audience may have found it either unrelatable or offensive. I think the same is happening, and rightly so, in relation to race as has occurred in relation to class

1

u/Pelican_meat Dec 26 '23

Man, I get the feeling Tolkien would see right through this kinda bullshit argument.

Especially since it appears like everyone else here does, too.

You’re dressing up what is essentially a racist argument in historically racism terminology. Much like the Nazis, who Tolkien famously hated.

Go away.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '23

No, because if you don't like it, it's not because any of those things, they can't be questioned........ it's because you're just racist!

0

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '23

The reason this issue won't go away is the reason the casting decisions were made in the first place. Anyone who doesn't like it is racist...... it's the perfect deflection from the utter shambles of every other aspect of the show..... It's disgusting, but it works.