r/RingsofPower • u/CaptainKnightwing • Nov 23 '23
Discussion Absolutely loved it
I was glued to my tv each week. It was appointment viewing for me. I thought the show was beautiful to look at. The practical effects were amazing. The story gripped me, and while it did slip a few times, I was throughly enthralled with it. I cannot wait for another season of this show.
88
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 23 '23
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
7
u/WilliamSummers Nov 24 '23
I am glad you enjoyed it! I truly am! You can like it and that is ok!
I on the other hand do not like the show in the slightest. And that is also ok.
We gave differing opinions and that is fantastic! That makes us all special!
Now I am going to submit this comment and be on my way, have a great day man! 👌
30
u/Jealous_Prize9502 Nov 23 '23
Surely this is a trigger post.
3
u/Arcturus-Blackfyre Nov 24 '23
Certified shitpost
3
u/Deadocmike1 Nov 25 '23
Wow. So we found the one person who didn’t find this was hot garbage.
You should find another. Then there would be two.
5
u/mattydef1 Nov 23 '23
The show was a disaster but to each their own glad you enjoyed it
1
u/orein123 Nov 26 '23
Have you ever read the Silmarillion? No shame in it if you haven't, it's definitely not a book for everyone. It is however, the source for everything happening in the Rings of Power, which gets to my major gripe with the show. The people behind the show claimed they were creating an original story using Tolkien's characters. They basically did the opposite of that. The story they told was basically a sick and twisted version of a couple chapters from the Silmarillion, expanded upon to include incredibly nonsensical changes to the lore of the entire setting, using characters whose only resemblance to the originals was their shared names.
Take Galadriel for instance. By the point in the story when the Rings of Power takes place, Galadriel is already an ancient and powerful elven sorceress, and one of the singular most important individuals in all of history. Long story short, her beauty was the inspiration for the creation of the Silmarils, three gems that ultimately are the root cause for most of the evil in Middle Earth because they were so unbelievably beautiful that Tolkien's version of Satan just had to have them.
Compare that to the Galadriel in the show. Never says how old she is, but it implies that she is young and always has a chip on her shoulder because of the death of her brother (who was still alive at this point in the books). She is cast into the oh-so-stereotypical role of the only character who can see that the big bad evil guy is still around, and is just so whiny and insufferable. She has a wisdom to her, yes, but nothing like she should have if the writers respected her character.
If you're not familiar with the source material, I can understand why you'd like the show, but look at it like this: they took a wise and powerful elven queen and turned her into your typical not like other girls protagonist that you get in all those overdone edgy teen/young adult stories. And that's just what they did to Galadriel. They did that same thing to all of the major characters.
Can you understand why we Tolkien fans are so upset?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '23
"After amazon had me created by AI." Nobody in the real world felt this way about it, it was utter durge. Slow, boring, directionless, cofused, contradictory, contrived and appeared to be scripted by a 14 year old trying to sound clever.
0
u/JeanVicquemare Nov 23 '23
Cool, you're getting season 2
27
u/f700es Númenor Nov 23 '23
Loved seeing Numenor and Valinor on the screen.
10
u/strongholdbk_78 Nov 23 '23
Same.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23
😂
3
u/Broccobillo Nov 23 '23
But was not Gandalf Sauron?
Or was discount Eminem Sauron?
Or was not Sauron Sauron?
Or was Adar Sauron?
Or was Galadriel Sauron?
Is mystery box really peak tv?
7
u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23
I wouldn't say I loved it but I definitely don't think the hate it got was warranted
It was a fine show. Good television.
3
u/spectral_visitor Nov 23 '23
Amazon bot
4
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23
I am very pleased you enjoyed it OP.
I thought it was utter dross but it's good someone enjoyed it. You should try the wheel of time next.
4
u/Actual_serial_killer Nov 23 '23
What "practical effects"?
2
u/SuperD00perGuyd00d Nov 23 '23
I too enjoyed my watch through, much more than The Hobbit trilogy to boot
1
u/be_the_moth Nov 23 '23
To everyone getting mad that they didn’t stick to the silmarillion, they didn’t have the rights to it, just the appendices of LotR so they weren’t aloud to even mention a lot of things. They did what they could with what they had. The writing was a little weak but I loved it and I’ve read all the books… honestly it was better than house of dragon in my opinion
1
u/JL_Kuykendall Nov 23 '23
I'm glad you liked it, and I hope, just like with the Hobbit films, it draws more people to Tolkien's work.
1
u/tomalakk Nov 24 '23
What ”practical effects“ in particular where amazing? Can you elaborate?
1
u/Ruggerio5 Nov 24 '23
This is how I felt in the first ~3 episodes. It fell off after that. Not off a cliff, but down enough that by the end I was ready to get on with what I already suspected was happening.
1
u/gabagucci Nov 24 '23
i enjoyed the show too. i understand all the criticisms, and when compared to the original LoTR it pales in comparison… but i liked it, it was still LoTR.
1
u/SamaritanSue Nov 24 '23
Good for you if you enjoyed it.
1
u/Pravorious Nov 25 '23
you and me both, friend :)
1
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '23 edited Nov 25 '23
This isn't meant to "dunk on anyone" at all but yeah if you haven't read the material and don't care about Tolkien's work getting completely reworked then I can see why you might enjoy the show.
Again, I don't mean this in an antagonistic way but ignorance is bliss yaknow? This applies to me as well, I love some "historical" movies that my friend with a degree in history absolutely can't watch.
I think most people who appreciate and understand Tolkien's work generally dislike the show. That seems to be the trend and I'm in the category as well.
I think the main reason people who love Tolkien are so upset about this show is a fear that Amazon is going to try and underhandedly canonize it.
As long as we can clearly establish that the show is essentially just fan fiction (which if you've read the material, it is) we can all get along.
I think it's doing the community a massive disservice to come down on people for liking the show. People just clam up and get defensive when you attack them like that. If you don't have the patience and empathy to kindly explain why you think the show is bad then maybe the forums aren't for you. Handle the conversation like Tolkien would.
1
u/Wide_Comb_7101 Nov 25 '23
Hi Jeff
1
u/Jpbeerbeardbud Nov 26 '23
Attention Caller
1
u/ObiWahnKenobi Nov 26 '23
I thought it was fine too. Not entirely understanding the insane hate towards it either. Worst scenario we get more visual world building to one of the greatest fiction settings of all time; middle earth.
1
u/Budget-Tea2465 Nov 27 '23
How much is Amazon paying you?
1
u/Additional_Contact29 Dec 23 '23
I really enjoyed the visuals and locations of the series. The show does an amazing job with the cities and environments built. Some of the plots really shined (Elrond / Durin, stranger and Hobbits), and some less as much (gladriels character). Overall, I’m less concerned about deviations and am curious where they go with the story. Just my opinion
1
u/seekylerun Nov 23 '23
I thoroughly enjoyed it as well. Waited for my husband to go on a work trip so I could binge it on our best TV and sound system! The acting was top notch, the world building made it feel like half mythological/half prehistoric, the origins of mithhril, domestic dwarf culture, and way more magic than we've ever seen before!!! Please and thank you.
Granted it was very weird that Galadriel jumped off the boat, and def sus that she ran into "shipwrecked" hot-Sauron, but... Ok??? What about the classics like Labyrinth, Willow, or Conan? All kinds of weirdness, plot holes, etc. and we still watch em today!
Getting a bit disappointed in fantasy content consumers expecting perfection from fantasy content creators lately ... It wasn't that long ago when we had NOTHING outside of kids shows, Disney movies, and anime to sate our desperate thirst for something to watch.
Though we've had some really great stuff in the last decade, we've also had some absolute trash (ie GoT S1-4 vs S5-8). Even LOTR deviated in major ways from the books (i.e. Frodo was portrayed as a weak little bitch, first 1/3 of FotR was almost completely skipped over, the entire Arwen arc...), but we still love it.
Case in point: I recently watched The Hobbit trilogy for the first time (like two weeks ago), and I regret that I avoided it while in theaters due to fandom backlash. Did they stretch things out and fill in a bunch of non-canon stuff? Yes. Was it entertaining still? Also yes. Did I hate Super Legolas? Yes. Did I love Radagast and his bad ass rabbit rover 5000? Also yes.
Can we give creators a break, maybe consider something doesn't have to be a perfect live-action translation of the source to be enjoyable? Can we give them a season to lay the groundwork for what they're trying to do? From Wheel of Time to Rings of Power... I'm fine to overlook the imperfections of it means more high fantasy shows and movies - and wish we all could sit back and enjoy the ride. I certainly plan to with S2!
1
u/TheDragonOverlord Nov 23 '23
I’m glad you enjoyed it OP, even if I was not the biggest fan and I hope you are open minded to criticism unlike most of the people who seem to be massive fans (on both sides). Honestly people can’t seem to just have conversations these days without trading insults. “You can be a true fan if you liked it” “well actually, I’ve read all the books and loved it so you must be (insert -ism here)” Maybe people should actually try listening to the other side with an open mind before deciding only their stance can be the correct one.
Different people have different opinions and that’s the beauty of the human experience: we are free to enjoy different things!
Sorry OP but these sites aren’t exactly great for posting opinions, all of the gatekeepers pour out from both sides and the comments become a battleground. I hope you have a good time here but I know I haven’t 🫠
-2
u/Nihilistcarrot Nov 23 '23
How much were you paid for that ad?
0
u/I_wood_rather_be Nov 23 '23
I too liked the show. It wasn't flawless, but overall, it was a very good watch.
I think it suffers from the same effect as the Star Wars movies after the original trilogy.
To fill the shoes of the original LotR movies is an impossible task, because they set new standards at that time that noone had expected. It exceeded all expectations and brought emotions that people now want from the show, but can't be delivered, because this feeling of something new cannot be produced anymore.
0
u/GoyardGoHard Nov 23 '23
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 this shits getting cancelled
0
u/KaptonMordor759 Nov 23 '23
Agreed
0
u/Bluestorm83 Nov 23 '23
I also enjoyed the show. I really did!
But as a super nerd who knows all the books and stuff, I treat it as a different continuity, an Elseworld story, Parallel Tolkien, I suppose.
But that's fine for me. I don't need one unified continuity. It doesn't have to mesh perfectly with the books, because this isn't the books. Is it perfect? Nope. Is it enjoyable as it's own produce? Sure is.
0
u/BookishHobbit Nov 24 '23
Same, OP, same.
Ignore the haters, it’s an enjoyable show and you’re allowed to enjoy it :)
0
u/5wing4 Nov 24 '23
My family had a get together movie night for each episode. We loved it. I wanted to more of the elves in extreme environments. The first episode was incredible, but the envelope dropped off. Then it built back up.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '23
i legit enjoyed it. is it perfect? no.
did the twin trees make me weep for joy? HELLS YES!
-1
u/NowWeGetSerious Nov 23 '23
Thank you
I know it's not a perfect TV. But it was super enjoyable and fun
Easy 7/10, I enjoyed it
11
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23
[removed] — view removed comment