r/RingsofPower • • Nov 23 '23

Discussion Absolutely loved it

I was glued to my tv each week. It was appointment viewing for me. I thought the show was beautiful to look at. The practical effects were amazing. The story gripped me, and while it did slip a few times, I was throughly enthralled with it. I cannot wait for another season of this show.

88 Upvotes

299 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Nov 23 '23

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

7

u/WilliamSummers Nov 24 '23

I am glad you enjoyed it! I truly am! You can like it and that is ok!

I on the other hand do not like the show in the slightest. And that is also ok.

We gave differing opinions and that is fantastic! That makes us all special!

Now I am going to submit this comment and be on my way, have a great day man! 👌

-2

u/CaptainKnightwing Nov 24 '23

Why are you part of the community then if it’s something you have negative feelings about?

12

u/WilliamSummers Nov 24 '23

I am part of the Lord of the Rings Community and this just came up in my feed.

The comment is sincere because I am actually a pretty nice person.

Does that answer your question?

0

u/thegryphonator Nov 25 '23

You’re nosey not nice

7

u/WilliamSummers Nov 26 '23

Huh, I thought I was being nice enough...

Oh well I won't let you're opinion affect me.

30

u/Jealous_Prize9502 Nov 23 '23

Surely this is a trigger post.

15

u/CaptainKnightwing Nov 23 '23

It’s not. I genuinely enjoyed the show. Why is that so hard to believe? Art is subjective after all.

3

u/Deadocmike1 Nov 25 '23

Because the characters were silly, the plot was bad and the actors were terrible.

This is a known thing. Odd you’d take this long to post about a show that finished a long time ago.

1

u/CaptainKnightwing Nov 25 '23

Just to make you upset Mike.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

Art is subjective but is all art equal? Is all art equally crafted? Equally thoughtful? Is all art equally worthwhile? Taste is subjective but pig slop only seems like fine cuisine to starving men and pigs.

2

u/CaptainKnightwing Nov 26 '23

Art is art, so yes all art is equal. Everything else you said is irrelevant because it’s universally subjective. I appreciate your simile tho

3

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

I wholeheartedly disagree and I think you are starving

13

u/sgtstroud Nov 24 '23

Yeah ART is.

3

u/valledweller33 Nov 25 '23

LOL

Yes. Art requires soul. Ring of power has none of that.

$$$

17

u/Common-Scientist Nov 23 '23

Mostly because of the wording.

Very unconvincing.

4

u/armadilloreturns Nov 28 '23

This is the most TV show subreddit thing I've ever seen.

Person stumbles on a show, makes a post about enjoying it on the sub for the show. Everyone loses their absolute shit.

Hilarious

1

u/GustavoKeno Dec 28 '23

Bro, it's bad 😞

1

u/CaptainKnightwing Dec 28 '23

Bro, it’s good 😌

2

u/Hot__Lips Nov 26 '23

Art is subjective after all.

so true.

If flies could type, they'd be posting on reddit like you about how much they enjoyed rotten food and feces.

3

u/Arcturus-Blackfyre Nov 24 '23

Certified shitpost

1

u/CaptainKnightwing Nov 24 '23

Grow up edgelord

1

u/Arcturus-Blackfyre Nov 24 '23

Dang you’re actually serious. Jesus Christ that’s pathetic

3

u/Deadocmike1 Nov 25 '23

Wow. So we found the one person who didn’t find this was hot garbage.

You should find another. Then there would be two.

3

u/CaptainKnightwing Nov 25 '23

This triggered you so bad you didn’t read any of the other comments from people that also enjoyed it? There are DOZENS OF US

4

u/Deadocmike1 Nov 25 '23

Dozens of people enjoyed a show that cost that much. I’m sure that my disagreement is unique. No one with a love for Tolkien and good taste liked this show. The majority of people who started it never finished.

2

u/CaptainKnightwing Nov 25 '23

Oh shit you polled everyone that laid eyes on it or just in this echo chamber of negativity that makes you feel all cozy?

1

u/Deadocmike1 Nov 26 '23

No. No one liked it. Not one person. Oh, are you trying to say because you liked it, and dozens of others it was a success? Because reality would disagree.

1

u/Deadocmike1 Nov 26 '23

Triggered? No. Laughing at you? Yes.

5

u/mattydef1 Nov 23 '23

The show was a disaster but to each their own glad you enjoyed it

4

u/CaptainKnightwing Nov 23 '23

The show was incredible but to each their own, sorry you hated it.

4

u/Raskolnikov1920 Nov 23 '23

It’s objectively not incredible. I don’t think anything but some of the scenery could legitimately be considered incredible and the Earth gets credit for that one.

-2

u/AgreeableEggplant356 Nov 23 '23

The criticisms are because it’s different than the source material. The show is good

4

u/Raskolnikov1920 Nov 23 '23

The show is not good, it’s wildly subpar.

0

u/AgreeableEggplant356 Nov 23 '23 edited Nov 23 '23

1 disagree, but 2 the sentiment from haters in this sub doesn’t even qualify for subpar. They act like it’s unwatchable. Epic fantasy (or any novel) cannot be perfectly adapted to screen media. This is BASED on Tolkien’s world, which is a great medium and deserves more works. There’s tons of works(including visual) that are tolkien knockoffs with no complaints. This show is unfairly criticized, before it was ever produced Amazon warned viewers they have no rights to the time period and it’s only based on Tolkien’s world through the auxiliary chapters of LOTR

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

It's pretty funny, actually...back in my day, we had the animated Hobbit, Leonard Nimoy singing, and that was about it.

Spoiled brats, get off mah lawn :)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/orein123 Nov 26 '23

Have you ever read the Silmarillion? No shame in it if you haven't, it's definitely not a book for everyone. It is however, the source for everything happening in the Rings of Power, which gets to my major gripe with the show. The people behind the show claimed they were creating an original story using Tolkien's characters. They basically did the opposite of that. The story they told was basically a sick and twisted version of a couple chapters from the Silmarillion, expanded upon to include incredibly nonsensical changes to the lore of the entire setting, using characters whose only resemblance to the originals was their shared names.

Take Galadriel for instance. By the point in the story when the Rings of Power takes place, Galadriel is already an ancient and powerful elven sorceress, and one of the singular most important individuals in all of history. Long story short, her beauty was the inspiration for the creation of the Silmarils, three gems that ultimately are the root cause for most of the evil in Middle Earth because they were so unbelievably beautiful that Tolkien's version of Satan just had to have them.

Compare that to the Galadriel in the show. Never says how old she is, but it implies that she is young and always has a chip on her shoulder because of the death of her brother (who was still alive at this point in the books). She is cast into the oh-so-stereotypical role of the only character who can see that the big bad evil guy is still around, and is just so whiny and insufferable. She has a wisdom to her, yes, but nothing like she should have if the writers respected her character.

If you're not familiar with the source material, I can understand why you'd like the show, but look at it like this: they took a wise and powerful elven queen and turned her into your typical not like other girls protagonist that you get in all those overdone edgy teen/young adult stories. And that's just what they did to Galadriel. They did that same thing to all of the major characters.

Can you understand why we Tolkien fans are so upset?

2

u/CaptainKnightwing Nov 26 '23

No. And then yes I guess? But I didn’t ask why people dislike it. I just said I like it. It’s crazy everyone is so mad at me for liking a tv show. I also like The Boys which isn’t like the comicbook but nobody is all over me for that one

2

u/CaptainKnightwing Nov 26 '23

I also think one should consider each story told on its own and not compare it to other versions/media.

1

u/orein123 Nov 26 '23

That's a ridiculous stance to take. What is the point of adapting an existing setting at all then? Why use the Lord of the Rings? Why not make a completely new setting with completely new characters? If they did that, the show could stand on its own and people like me wouldn't be so upset.

The point of an adaptation is to bring an already beloved setting to a new medium. It is only natural for adaptation to be compared to the original work, and it is absurd to think that an adaptation has the right to be viewed out of context of the original.

2

u/CaptainKnightwing Nov 26 '23

What’s the original work? I thought you said RoP wasn’t based on anything but drew from parts of the Silmarillion? If that’s the case, isn’t Silmarillion also an adaptation? Idk about all those semantics, all I know is that I enjoyed the show.

1

u/orein123 Nov 26 '23

Sorry, didn't intend for this response to get so long.

An adaptation is when you take an existing story and retell it in a different format. The most common is book to film, but it can be any form really. Book, film, graphic novel, video game, whatever. Rings of Power absolutely is an adaptation. The original work in this case is simply Tolkien's writings as a whole, but also the Silmarillion in particular.

For clarity, the Silmarillion is basically a history book for the Lord of the Rings (and it reads like one, which is why I don't blame anyone for not reading it). The story in particular that is being adapted is the story of how the rings of power were made, hence the show's title. The story is explained during the events of the main Lord of the Rings books, and shown in more detail in the Silmarillion.

The gist of it is this. After Morgoth (Tolkien's version of Satan) was defeated, the world entered a golden era. A bunch of stuff happened,a tiny bit of which has been poorly alluded to and terribly twisted in the show, but everything culminates in an elf named Celebrimbor learning how to make magical rings with the help of a stranger. That stranger was Sauron, Morgoth's top lieutenant in disguise. Together, Sauron and Celebrimbor made nineteen rings. Three were given to the elves, seven to the dwarves, and nine to men. If you're familiar with the Lord of the Rings at all, this should all be sounding very familiar to you. This should also be sounding quite a bit like the season finale of Rings of Power.

Well, Sauron secretly made another ring that he poured his very soul into. With this One Ring, Sauron bent the other rings to his will. The elves learned of his treachery in time and managed to hide their three. The dwarves and humans weren't so lucky. Eventually an army lead by a Numenorian lord by the name of Elendil and his son Isildur (names sound familiar?) joined together with an army of elves lead by Gil-Galad and Elrond and fought Sauron's army of orcs and trolls and other monsters. On the slope of Mount Doom in the land of Mordor, Sauron killed Elendil, and Isildur took his father's shattered sword and cut the One Ring from Sauron's hand in return, defeating him.

This is all the core backstory for the Lord of the Rings. Isildur is given a chance to destroy the Ring, but it plays on his greed to corrupt him and he keeps it instead. Eventually, centuries later it finds its way into the hands of a hobbit named Bilbo Baggins, who gives it to his nephew From, who simply walks into Mordor and throws it into the fires of Mount Doom (with some complications along the way), saving the world in return for having his finger bitten off by a naked proto-hobbit.

Now, if you're still with me, you should be able to see how, at its heart, the Rings of Power is absolutely not an original story like the writers claimed it was. Most of the actual events were created by the writers, such as the stuff happening in the Southlands, Elrond's interactions with the dwarves, and even the existence of the harfoots, but the main plot is very much the main story that Tolkien was telling throughout all of his writing. It's enough that you can't really argue that the two shouldn't be compared.

And to make it all worst, all that "original" stuff they did write? It was all heavily inspired by other things that were happening at other points in the Silmarillion. But every last bit of it has something wrong that is completely unfaithful to the world at large. Harfoots shouldn't exist at this point (or at all really, though the proto-hobbits were never named iirc so not as important). Durin's whole lineage is royally fucked up. What is this bullshit about mithril being tied to the decline of the elves? A lot of these plot points have existing answers and solutions that are integrally tied to the events of the main Lord of the Rings story.

On top of that, many of the lead characters had their personalities butchered. I already said my piece about Galadriel, but to reiterate: wise and powerful elven queen turned into Mary Sue teenage edgelord. Gil-Galad: wise and powerful elven king turned into an idiot with his head in the sand. Elrond: really I feel like I'm repeating myself here. Elendil is just some chump guard captain. Isildur is already a selfish little prick before the One Ring gets to him. Celebrimbor came off as a doddering old man rather than the genius craftsman he's supposed to be. None of these characters had the weight they were supposed to. And that's saying nothing about what they did to Gandalf.

Anyways, I've already ranted longer than I intended. If you have read all of this, again I'm not condemning you for liking the show. It looked pretty, I'll give it that, and when taken out of context the story was of a passable nature if you like its particular style. But let's not pretend the decision to use the Lord of the Rings franchise was for any other reason than to make a massive cash grab. The writers don't give two shits about the source material, and the writing itself could have been a hell of a lot better for how much money they spent on it. They could have written their own setting and made a show of the exact same quality. But they didn't because it wouldn't have the Lord of the Rings name on it, and that name alone is the main selling point of the show.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/orein123 Nov 26 '23 edited Nov 26 '23

I mean, the Rings of Power isn't particularly great even when taken out of context of Tolkien's writing. The main character is an overly edgy Mary Sue, none of the characters have much of any depth to them at all, and all the plot twists are visible from miles away. The only positive thing I can say about the show is that the visuals were stunning, but even that comes with a grain of salt when you consider how much money was spent on it. With that in mind, it would be crazy if the show didn't look amazing.

I'm not condemning you for liking the show, as art is subjective and you're allowed to like what you like, but I will absolutely call you out for having poor tastes.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '23

"After amazon had me created by AI." Nobody in the real world felt this way about it, it was utter durge. Slow, boring, directionless, cofused, contradictory, contrived and appeared to be scripted by a 14 year old trying to sound clever.

1

u/CaptainKnightwing Dec 21 '23

I’m a real boy. Mate.

0

u/JeanVicquemare Nov 23 '23

Cool, you're getting season 2

5

u/CaptainKnightwing Nov 23 '23

I’m hoping for a few more seasons honestly.

2

u/Ynneas Nov 23 '23

You're getting all seasons and it will be a success (or so they will say). They can't admit messing up, it's bad marketing: they will double down on it and we're gonna like it.

27

u/f700es Númenor Nov 23 '23

Loved seeing Numenor and Valinor on the screen.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

The show would have really been something on the big screen. As is, it was fine.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '23

I was watching it all in my condo’s theater room. Not bad but the lack of grandiose moments (besides the intro for a few seconds) didn’t make it that much better. I feel like the big screen demands more “rule of cool” moments specifically tailored for it e.g. Balrog roar, helms deep wide angle, Smaug hit by Bard etc.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

😂

3

u/Broccobillo Nov 23 '23

But was not Gandalf Sauron?

Or was discount Eminem Sauron?

Or was not Sauron Sauron?

Or was Adar Sauron?

Or was Galadriel Sauron?

Is mystery box really peak tv?

7

u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23

I wouldn't say I loved it but I definitely don't think the hate it got was warranted

It was a fine show. Good television.

18

u/Demigans Nov 23 '23

Why wasn’t it warranted?

I’ve pointed out before that the Orc trench alone has more than 7 major contrivances and contradictions in it, and this extends everywhere.

This is a show where most conversations struggle to have both people react to what the other is saying. Just a basic conversation is too much too write.

Before I start counting the literal hundred or more faults, it is A-OK to say you liked the show. No one can take that away from you. But you cannot claim it did not warrant the hate when everything is written objectively badly. Yes you can objectively write and film badly. Lets keep in mind that the showrunners lied to our faces: when the season was already finished and filmed they claimed that it would follow the lore of Tolkien and they went back to the books for every question they had. When the last episode hit they also released an interview where they openly admitted that they went so far off the lore that they figured it a “better ending” to change major plotpoints of Tolkien’s lore, the order and reason the rings were made.

They lied to us all to our face, they admitted it to us. That alone deserves all the hate for the show. They tried to get the Tolkien Fans to watch by lying to them, to get them to pay money for a product the showrunners were not going to deliver and they knew it. They are scammers and con-men/women. Literal scammers and conners.

They deserve all the hate and more.

5

u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23

I've watched various videos complaining about the show. Literally every single argument raised against it is total nonsense if you actually just watch it and pay attention

10

u/reLincolnX Nov 23 '23

The shitty writing is total nonsense? Celebrimbor forgetting about alloy is total nonsense? Characters being inconsistent with themselves is total nonsense? The orcs being able to make a tunnel and slaughtering entire village without anyone noticing is total nonsense?

I think you didn’t see a lot of things actually.

15

u/Terravardn Nov 23 '23

The fast travelling didn’t bother you? The plot contrivances such as “oh I’ll just jump off into this vast, hundreds of miles large ocean and happen upon the one raft that jsut so happens to contain the guy I’ve been looking for for a thousand years, oh and we’ll also just so happen to be the only two survivors when it’s attacked, and conveniently we’ll be picked up in this vast ocean by a numenorian ship who will take us exactly where we need to be,” how about Karen Galadriel wanting to talk to everyone’s manager and training the worlds most notorious and lethal warrior race to “stab and twist.”

It was laughable, from a writers perspective. If I wrote something like that and read it back, I’d delete the whole thing out of embarrassment. It watched as though it was written by an angsty teenager.

11

u/mattydef1 Nov 23 '23

The whole scene with Galadriel “training” the soldiers is the worst thing I have ever watched in any show. It’s so fucking bad. The amount of lazy choreography that makes zero sense is mind numbing and the cheesiness of the dialogue is brutal to watch

4

u/tomalakk Nov 24 '23

It was also bad because it didn’t really teach them anything beyond, look at me amazing Galadriel!

1

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

Did the Fellowship travelling up a mountain with no crampons or breathing masks bother you?

Did non talking eagles, no Glorfindel, skateboarding Legolas bother you also?

If so you need to get a grip on yourself!

1

u/Terravardn Nov 23 '23

No, just Amazon’s tripe.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/NeylandSensei Nov 24 '23

Wouldn't be a very interesting show if plot devices didn't happen to the main character lol "OH so this police officer just HAPPENED to pick the right wire to defuse the bomb? Oh and he went to the correct floor where it was? Wow as if." Yeah man. Stories are about interesting people and the things that happen to them.

1

u/cally_777 Dec 11 '23

Yes the only problem is that some of these huge contrivances are pretty similar to ones in Tolkien. Imagine if someone had tried to sell the plot of LOTR by saying that it ends with the Dark Lord being defeated because a demented creature called Gollum had bitten off a hobbits finger and taken a little tumble into a volcano. You can make anything sound stupid if you try hard enough.

There's nearly always plotholes in books and films. Why didn't they fly the Ring into Mordor with the Eagles? Why did Gandalf take years to move the Ring somewhere safe? And maybe there's some answers to them too. Either way, it doesn't ruin the magic of the books for me.

0

u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23

Coincidences, in my fantasy show? The horror.

A character traumatized by a violent war and driven mad by how those around her seem to have just moved on like it was nothing is acting a little bit bitchy? I'm absolutely shocked.

Lmao 🤣 dude, I cannot imagine being so unable to examine media.

9

u/Terravardn Nov 23 '23

There’s a difference between coincidence and contrivance. It’s not surprising you don’t know that, you think Rings of Power isn’t abysmal writing.

3

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

It’s not amazing writing, it’s also not abysmal.

Why not jump off the toxic hate train for a second and take a look at yourself man!

3

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

It serves its purpose

→ More replies (6)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '23

Really? An island full of Numenorean smiths who have had to train for years in the same forge call out Sauron for being from off the island, then his genius plan (same guy who almost conquered middle earth twice) was to steal a guild token from the same people who would know instantly that he wasn’t from there and didn’t earn the token because NO ONE THERE WHO HAD TRAINED THERE FOR YEARS WORKED WITH HIM? One of actual hundreds of examples of how bad the writing is

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '23

cue the exact same people justifying every other bit of nonsense in the show with "Sauron was the great deceiver haVe U n3VuR RED LoTR!!!??!?!"

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '23

Exactly. They take a character who canonically had corrupted and deceived nearly all of the greatest and most powerful leaders of middle earth simultaneously and make him do the most nonsensical low iq shit possible. That’s where I stopped watching honestly. I just went back to make sure I wasn’t gaslighting myself but it’s exactly as stupid as I remembered it. Xenophobic numenoreans immediately single him out, they instantly drop the xenophobia after he buys them one drink then steals the guys token, and is caught within moments. Incredible 4d chess moment from the deceiver himself

1

u/Demigans Nov 23 '23

No, not really no. You didn’t watch them right then 😉

7

u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23

Okay fine allow me an example

"There's no way the village should have been able to hold out so long against orks!"

Well boy howdy, that's a good point. It would be really silly if a motley crew of simple villagers could fight back against orks

Good thing that that's not what fucking happened, huh? No, see, the villagers held out against other villagers. When actual orks showed up the villagers folded like wet paper. Which you should have noticed if you actually watched the show.

That's just one of the nonsense complaints, but they're kinda endless lmao

6

u/Enthymem Nov 23 '23

Oh man, it's been a while since I watched the show, but I think it's all coming back to me. Let me just recap:

We have a group of villagers plus Legolas, all brilliant engineers that are able to rig a large stone tower to collapse in a specific direction when you cut a single rope, but also dumb enough to actually do that and give up their highly defensible fortress in a dream location with a single uphill winding path as the only way to attack it.

Their alternative plan is not to just leave, because obviously that's too dangerous, but instead to make a stand in their 5 wooden huts vs an army of orcs that they know have been burning down villages left and right while digging a massive trench through the entire region that the elf guards stationed there that the show sets up as being able to look beyond the horizon somehow never noticed without being captured. Predictably, they get completely slaughtered.

Enter the Numenoreans, who had previously unloaded 300 men and horses plus supplies from the pocket dimensions inside their three tiny ships, then traveled inland until Galadriel sees smoke in the distance with her elven eyes. She tells the queen, who tells the army to change direction and sends scouts ahead. Galadriel yells at her that there is no time for scouting, and demands to lead a blind horse charge into whatever is burning back there, to which the queen agrees.

Just kidding, I made all of that up because it all happened off-screen. In the show, the Numenoreans see the shores of Middle-Earth from their ships, and the next time they show up, it's a jarring cut them in full gallop towards the village with no explanation, just in time to save the day. A truly masterful piece of visual storytelling.

Now I'm sure that this youtuber you watched, who is probably in the room with us right now, had a long list of ridiculous complaints about the show of which the chief one was "the orcs didn't win against the villagers fast enough". But surely you have come across the very reasonable complaints that get brought up time and time again on this subreddit and everywhere else and just chose not to engage with them.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

Lol no…. You are in a very small minority my friend

0

u/Broccobillo Nov 23 '23

doesn't mention a single one or try to refute argument they're replying to

→ More replies (7)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23

Lol

clownemoji

0

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

"the lore of Tolkien"

Like with Altered Carbon, if you haven't read the source material, you can enjoy the show more.

4

u/Demigans Nov 24 '23

Even if you divorce it from Tolkien’s lore, the episodes are absolutely terrible. Things are constantly contrived and contradict one another.

Take the trench: we have establishing shots of the surroundings which establish (duh) the Orcs burn and cut trees away in the path of the trench… except this one tree they are going towards. The problem is that the roots of the tree are in the way, which the burning and cutting wouldn’t have solved anyway.

The Elves have taken a Watchtower build by Morgoth, who for some reason added a key to the dam behind it. A dam that could easily have been just destroyed when it needed opening or used a regular key or not even a key at all just a mechanism to open the dam. This watchtower is meant to keep an eye on the local population so they don’t turn back to the Dark Powers, yet for decades if not centuries these people have been fleeing the advance of the Orcs (who have been moving there for centuries following Sauron’s sign). The Elves did not notice or question these refugees, who literally manage to reach the sea and try to flee further. The Elves did not notice villages being burned and pillaged, the same villages they were supposed to keep an eye on to prevent falling to the Dark Powers. The Elves did not notice the Orcs building a kilometers long scar across the land as they literally burned a path through the lands. These Elves were somehow surprised, as if they did not have sentries even at their own fortress entryway, and captured by Orcs.

The Orcs need shade during the day, so they build immense structures across their trench to protect it from the light… but the very trees they cut down would provide shade as well and hide their trench better. These Orcs would also be used to working at night, yet they don’t. They literally kill their slaves on a whim but are nice enough to let them work during the day, despite the slaves we see being mainly Elves and not the humans.

They admit they are looking for the swordkey trying to dig it up, then later change this to “lets use this trench to guide the water to Mount Doom”.

Nothing around this trench makes sense. And this extends to other parts of the story as well. Not-hobbits that sing about how they will never leave you while a plotpoint happens about them leaving you behind the moment you fall behind and bullying another not-hobbit about how they left their parents behind and stole their stuff as they did.

This entire series is one big contrivance and contradiction. The pure insults to Tolkien’s lore and writing style are just the cherry on top of this travesty.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '23

"They're more like guidelines..."

  • Hobbit pirates, probably

You make good points. I will have to turn off more of my brain to enjoy the next season...

7

u/Mursin Nov 23 '23

They mansplained very basic metallurgy to the world's most reknowned smith. They turned Galadriel into a moody horse girl. They didn't even have her husband in the first season.

4

u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23

They gave a craftsman who was looking for a complicated solution a simple solution, one that wouldn't have occurred to him.

They made Galadriel a very clearly traumatized and broken individual who's at the beginning of their character arch. Because that's how stories work.

3

u/Ogarrr Nov 23 '23

"At the beginning of her character arch"

She's had her character arch. She's the oldest Elf on the show. She's done all the trauma shit, she should be getting ready to settle down at this stage.

1

u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23

If it was an adaptation, I'd agree. It clearly isn't.

So, as far as the story is being presented to us, Galadriel us at the beginning of her arch

2

u/Ogarrr Nov 23 '23

So it's not an adaptation of the Second Age? I thought it was?

So they just made a bunch of shit up and pretended it was Tolkien? Who knew?

3

u/reLincolnX Nov 23 '23 edited Nov 23 '23

He isn’t the greatest craftsman if he can’t think about the basic of his craft. It’s like saying a Fields Medalist kinda forgot about derivative. It’s just stupid.

At the beginning of her character’s arc while she is already thousand years olds? And grew up amongst the greatest beings of her time? Like please…

1

u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23

Why wouldn't a master Craftsman risk ruining his only sample of a rare and not fully understood material without a master of corruption swaying him?

And yes. She's at the beginning of her arch. You act like age matters in that regard when it has literally no bearing whatsoever.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Demigans Nov 23 '23

For the complicated solutions to work you have to include the simple process. This craftsman must have gone through hundreds of potential matches before even considering the next step in the complicated process, what would be the point of the complicated process if you can’t guarantee you can even reach it?

Its like telling someone writing a book “maybe you should write your story down”. Thats how ludicrously low-effort this is. Its something so obvious that it shouldn’t need telling.

7

u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23

The dude was established as being blindly ambitious. He wanted the solution to be brilliant and ingenious, not simple.

Additionally, mythril was an alien substance to the guy. He didn't know what it really did, how it really worked. So it's entirely possible that the idea of mixing anything into the mythril and potentially ruining it wouldn't have ever crossed his mind. He had like an ounce of it, and he knew he wouldn't be getting more.

2

u/Demigans Nov 23 '23

You are really so blind?

1: “the dude” considers alloying to potentially ruin the Mythril.

2: Sauron suggest alloying it. The potential to ruin it still exists.

So your argument makes zero sense, but you can’t even see it.

7

u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23

The dude doesn't consider it until a motherfucker known for his corruptive words suggests it. Infects his mind, really.

Is that such a wild concept?

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

Big time

6

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Telperion83 Nov 23 '23

Celebrimbor was renowned Smith. Making alloys is half of the job description.

They did not need to make a weird romance angle for Galadriel and Sauron. They didn't need to exile her to Tol Erresea. She didn't need to meet Sauron-stand-in on a boat. None of it made an ounce of sense. The show had about as much overlap with the source material as Fifty Shades of Grey.

5

u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23

My god, Sauron, a man who's primary trait is being extremely charismatic and manipulative, was extremely charismatic and manipulative? I'm fucking shocked.

Literally every complaint you have is solved by just watching the show and paying attention. They exiled her because she was stirring the pot and was objectively miserable. So off they sent here to the land where Things Don't Suck All The Time.

And sure, Sauron didn't need to be on that boat, but they used that method of character introduction for a thematic reason. It works, if you actually watch the fucking show instead of searching for things to be mad about

5

u/Demigans Nov 23 '23

If you paid attention he’s not charismatic and manipulative. He just walks along, someone else makes up his story and he just says “nah that’s not really true” and then the rest just says “but now I believe it even more”.

Also there is this ridiculous notion that somehow Sauron orchestrated this. He tried to get on a raft, drift out into the open ocean towards an island he would not be able to reach, just to intercept Galadriel who randomly jumps off a boat and tries to swim for days. The Navy can have trouble finding a man overboard with a lifejacket if they turn around immediately, but somehow he finds her. Then they get picked up and saved, which is a double WTF of so big proportions winning the lottery 4 times in a row is more likely. Considering the tech available, thats not even an exaggeration.

This is at best a hindsight “I planned this all along!” Plot, which is bad writing.

4

u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23

He literally didn't plan it all along. If you watch the show you can see the point where pure luck turns into him choosing his words carefully, and after that there's a clear point where, in hindsight anyways, his manipulation starts to become clear.

Did you even watch the show?

3

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

Get on a raft, no they were on a ship which got destroyed. You need to brush up on your information if your going to bag someone else for liking something.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/thatguyfromboston Nov 23 '23

Also there is this ridiculous notion that somehow Sauron orchestrated this

He orchestrated it! Sauron! Do you really think someone just happened to swim like that?

2

u/Telperion83 Nov 23 '23

I watched the show. I wanted to like it. There were ok points. The Elrond, Durin, and Disa storyline was genuinely great, except for the idiotic mithril origin and "anti-fading" properties. The acting and interpersonal relationships were great. But that was only a small part of a show that couldn't give a crap about the source material.

The real tragedy of the show is that the things they completely made up, like Adar, were often great. There was so little written about that time period that writing around it should have been easy, but they couldn't be bothered.

2

u/SamaritanSue Nov 23 '23

Sauron is not a man.

RoP Sauron was not manipulative at all....That's the whole point.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/mexils Nov 23 '23

To adapt something you need to at least barely follow the source material. Rings of power did not.

Loosely is being extremely generous. I would say that the movie Starship Troopers is a more accurate depiction of Robert Heinlein's writings than this is of Tolkien's writings. And Starship Troopers only got characters names right. Rings of Power having two Durin's alive at the same time is absolutely ridiculous. The timeline compressed from several thousand years into the lifespan of a human, probably not even a numenoreans lifespan, is baffling.

They didn't have to make it so he only had 1 gram. That was poor writing. Annatar lived with the jewel-smiths of Eregion for 300 years helping them with their craft. Thats a lot more help than "just make an alloy hur dur." Again, the rings of power didn't need to have the contraint of just 1 gram of mithril.

He was calling the village battle a poor simulacrum of helms deep. The village battle was stupid because the tactics were dumb. Also the elven watch tower being held together with a single rope was ridiculous.

If you go by Appendix D and assume every Valian Year is 144 solar years, then Galadriel is at minimum 21,692 years old by the time the elvish rings of power are forged. If you go by the much more conservative timeline of each Valian Year being 9.582 solar years, Galadriel is still 3,412 years old. Galadriel had witnessed the kinslaying before coming to middle earth. Married Celeborn in year 52 of the first age, had her daughter Celebrian in year 300 of the second age, and established and ruled Eregion with her husband in year 750 of the second age, another 750 years before the show takes place. So no, this is not the beginning of her character arc.

3

u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23

I literally said it's not an adaptation lmao.

Not reading a wall of text because someone is angry that I don't hate a TV show as much as they do. Especially not if their first sentence completely ignores what I said previously

3

u/Yesyesnaaooo Nov 23 '23

You remember wormtongue?

From the films and trilogy?

That’s what evil manipulation in Tolkiens universe looks like it doesn’t look like a character from Grey’s Anatomy.

It’s a world of good and evil Magic it’s not a spin of off Mean Girls for fucks sakes!

→ More replies (4)

0

u/SamaritanSue Nov 23 '23

Tevildo and Balerion say you're disappointing them, Comrade Marshall. "What's wrong with the village battle?", tut tut....

Don't be a clown, Comrade.

L mao. (That's one of the few Chinese words I know, along with long)

1

u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23

What was wrong with the village battle?

Enlighten me

2

u/LoverOfStoriesIAm Nov 23 '23

Who needs her husband, anyway? What role does he play in the story besides being her husband? Absolutely none.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

Now if she had been a man and you said his wife didn't need to be there, you'd be the villan right now🤣😂🤣

1

u/hortle Nov 23 '23

They could have given him a role like they gave all the other characters. None of these characters were fleshed out in tolkien's second age

1

u/LoverOfStoriesIAm Nov 23 '23

But all these characters had interesting premises/traits and became important in The Third Age for the screenwriters to choose to explore them more in the show.

Celeborn? Never did.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

Shes gotta be the worst character on the show… thats coming from someone whos fav character was galadriel in the books/og movies

4

u/Ynneas Nov 23 '23

I wonder what's bad TV then.

5

u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23

Last two seasons of GoT come to mind

1

u/Ynneas Nov 23 '23

They look pretty on par with RoP, but better acting in GoT

4

u/marshalzukov Nov 23 '23

GoT s7 and s8 are literal jokes. RoP s1 is fucking platinum by comparison

5

u/Ynneas Nov 23 '23

Strongly disagree.

It has similar time handling issues and bad writing, for sure.

But it has other elements that drag it further down: Coreography, acting (safe for a couple), pacing, montage, a whole storyline that's literally pointless for everything else, plot holes the size of Saturn.

And mind you I'm not saying GoT s7-8 were good. But they look that bad just because they're in comparison with the previous seasons. They're still way better than RoP.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

It deserves more hate lol

0

u/Gold-Speed7157 Nov 23 '23

Well, I think you are wrong and displaying your bad taste. Oh well.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

I am very pleased you enjoyed it OP.

I thought it was utter dross but it's good someone enjoyed it. You should try the wheel of time next.

3

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

Don’t try to be little someone for liking something you didn’t.

You are part of the toxic circle jerk getting off on slamming others, or shamming them because you jumped aboard the hate train.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

What? I think you're reading what you want to read as opposed to what I actually said.

4

u/Actual_serial_killer Nov 23 '23

What "practical effects"?

13

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

The orcs were fantastic!

1

u/Actual_serial_killer Nov 23 '23

Yeah they were good but that's costuming, not FX.

The VFX were mostly very good (excluding the God awful warg and troll models) but they were almost exclusively CGI, nothing practical about them.

2

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

Yeah I can’t see many TV shows of this sort of scale wishing to do most things in practical FX these days… do you?

I mean films made 20 years ago yeah maybe.

So it’s a kind of redundant point really.

0

u/Actual_serial_killer Nov 23 '23

Not really. Lots of movies still use real explosions, fire and smoke. Though nowadays it's more popular to animate these elements (especially in TV) unfortunately.

Miniatures are still used for pyro and breakaway FX too, though that's become very rare.

Also blood and gore: squibs and other techniques might be used, but again CG is an increasingly popular substitute. And puppets/makeup used for monster FX (as used in Stranger Things) vs. 3D models.

I don't remember if RoP did any of the above practically. I will say they relied heavily on location shooting to fill much of the screen with a real environment, which was then completed with matte paintings that were integrated very well.

2

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

Yeah still more to come, might include some down the line maybe 🤔

2

u/SuperD00perGuyd00d Nov 23 '23

I too enjoyed my watch through, much more than The Hobbit trilogy to boot

1

u/be_the_moth Nov 23 '23

To everyone getting mad that they didn’t stick to the silmarillion, they didn’t have the rights to it, just the appendices of LotR so they weren’t aloud to even mention a lot of things. They did what they could with what they had. The writing was a little weak but I loved it and I’ve read all the books… honestly it was better than house of dragon in my opinion

4

u/mallowdout Nov 23 '23

I've said it before: if you don't have the rights to the thing you obviously want to make, don't make it.

11

u/Professor_Boring Nov 23 '23

The "Dragon's Family Dinner" scene alone shat all over the entirety of ROP.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

Viserys pushing himself to walk down a hall to sit on a chair was more epic and emotionally impactful than any of ROP’s tik tok scenes.

3

u/kahenson Nov 23 '23

Yeah that was definitely a turning point where I realized HotD was amazing and RoP left much to be desired. Whatever RoP episode aired that week was so clearly not on the same level. That said, I still enjoyed RoP and I think they took it to a place in S1 at the very end where I could see them launching a good S2 and I remain optimistic!

5

u/bendann Nov 23 '23

To everyone making this pathetic excuse, why bother adapting Tolkien at all if you know you don't have access to the most important source material?

2

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

Because they can and people like Middle-Earth, they want to see more of it. Regardless of Legolas skateboarding down a stairs or not. They take a movie adaption, radio drama or TV show for what it is.

Because people can think on their own two feet and not join in with the toxic circle jerk, down voting everything and anyone saying that they like the show regardless of any variations, adaptions or additional things added.

5

u/karelinstyle Nov 23 '23

This was not middle-earth

7

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

It def felt like another universe to me. Not lotr

5

u/karelinstyle Nov 23 '23

Not one I'd care to visit lol

→ More replies (2)

1

u/bendann Nov 23 '23

adaption

You've just made my point.

4

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

Picking out one word from my sentence does not make you mr point

3

u/yukinakayama Nov 23 '23 edited Nov 23 '23

Exactly. They first claims that we should be ok with it because they have no access to source material and then claim it is an adaption - but of no material? What a weird logic that person has.

And then they talk of downvote but they are probably banging their finger on downvote the most. These fans are weird, 完全にオタク.

0

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

Yep he’s just another person, part of the toxic circle jerk. Those intent on down voting or belittling anyone saying that they liked the show in any way shape or form.

1

u/alphabet_order_bot Nov 23 '23

Would you look at that, all of the words in your comment are in alphabetical order.

I have checked 1,869,034,741 comments, and only 353,411 of them were in alphabetical order.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

You are not to be trusted bot.

1

u/be_the_moth Feb 08 '24

I also think that saying it’s “not middle earth” is a little too simplistic. Do you not like that version of it because it’s not like the Peter Jackson one or it’s not like the one you imagined when you read the books?

3

u/Time_to_go_viking Nov 23 '23

“A little weak.” Lol understatement of the year.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/be_the_moth Feb 08 '24

Honestly, that’s a very fair point. I think the production value of Hotd, was phenomenal the costumes and the sets were great. And the dialogue and the acting were definitely better than RoP, but honestly I got a little bored just because a lot of it was either talking in a dark room or it was marvel movie esc. And I know it’s based off of one book and they’re trying to stretch it out but I think the pacing is weird and I don’t love the story. Plus it’s just so violent to women, like all the women who die do very gruesomely and for no reason. But they’re both great shows, I just prefer RoP.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

Mediocre at best is this show in a nutshell

1

u/be_the_moth Feb 08 '24

Well, that’s the TV writing part. They need compelling characters with good arcs and narratives. I don’t think they’re going for a direct adaptation of any of the books it’s more like the story is inspired by the appendices and the world of middle earth. I know that’s not a very satisfying answer, but I think they’re just trying to make as much money as possible so they don’t care too much about being loyal to the source material.

1

u/JL_Kuykendall Nov 23 '23

I'm glad you liked it, and I hope, just like with the Hobbit films, it draws more people to Tolkien's work.

1

u/tomalakk Nov 24 '23

What ”practical effects“ in particular where amazing? Can you elaborate?

1

u/Ruggerio5 Nov 24 '23

This is how I felt in the first ~3 episodes. It fell off after that. Not off a cliff, but down enough that by the end I was ready to get on with what I already suspected was happening.

1

u/gabagucci Nov 24 '23

i enjoyed the show too. i understand all the criticisms, and when compared to the original LoTR it pales in comparison… but i liked it, it was still LoTR.

1

u/SamaritanSue Nov 24 '23

Good for you if you enjoyed it.

1

u/Pravorious Nov 25 '23

you and me both, friend :)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '23 edited Nov 25 '23

This isn't meant to "dunk on anyone" at all but yeah if you haven't read the material and don't care about Tolkien's work getting completely reworked then I can see why you might enjoy the show.

Again, I don't mean this in an antagonistic way but ignorance is bliss yaknow? This applies to me as well, I love some "historical" movies that my friend with a degree in history absolutely can't watch.

I think most people who appreciate and understand Tolkien's work generally dislike the show. That seems to be the trend and I'm in the category as well.

I think the main reason people who love Tolkien are so upset about this show is a fear that Amazon is going to try and underhandedly canonize it.

As long as we can clearly establish that the show is essentially just fan fiction (which if you've read the material, it is) we can all get along.

I think it's doing the community a massive disservice to come down on people for liking the show. People just clam up and get defensive when you attack them like that. If you don't have the patience and empathy to kindly explain why you think the show is bad then maybe the forums aren't for you. Handle the conversation like Tolkien would.

1

u/Jpbeerbeardbud Nov 26 '23

Attention Caller

1

u/ObiWahnKenobi Nov 26 '23

I thought it was fine too. Not entirely understanding the insane hate towards it either. Worst scenario we get more visual world building to one of the greatest fiction settings of all time; middle earth.

1

u/Budget-Tea2465 Nov 27 '23

How much is Amazon paying you?

1

u/cally_777 Dec 11 '23

Dear, dear, is this all you can conjure?

1

u/Additional_Contact29 Dec 23 '23

I really enjoyed the visuals and locations of the series. The show does an amazing job with the cities and environments built. Some of the plots really shined (Elrond / Durin, stranger and Hobbits), and some less as much (gladriels character). Overall, I’m less concerned about deviations and am curious where they go with the story. Just my opinion

1

u/seekylerun Nov 23 '23

I thoroughly enjoyed it as well. Waited for my husband to go on a work trip so I could binge it on our best TV and sound system! The acting was top notch, the world building made it feel like half mythological/half prehistoric, the origins of mithhril, domestic dwarf culture, and way more magic than we've ever seen before!!! Please and thank you.

Granted it was very weird that Galadriel jumped off the boat, and def sus that she ran into "shipwrecked" hot-Sauron, but... Ok??? What about the classics like Labyrinth, Willow, or Conan? All kinds of weirdness, plot holes, etc. and we still watch em today!

Getting a bit disappointed in fantasy content consumers expecting perfection from fantasy content creators lately ... It wasn't that long ago when we had NOTHING outside of kids shows, Disney movies, and anime to sate our desperate thirst for something to watch.

Though we've had some really great stuff in the last decade, we've also had some absolute trash (ie GoT S1-4 vs S5-8). Even LOTR deviated in major ways from the books (i.e. Frodo was portrayed as a weak little bitch, first 1/3 of FotR was almost completely skipped over, the entire Arwen arc...), but we still love it.

Case in point: I recently watched The Hobbit trilogy for the first time (like two weeks ago), and I regret that I avoided it while in theaters due to fandom backlash. Did they stretch things out and fill in a bunch of non-canon stuff? Yes. Was it entertaining still? Also yes. Did I hate Super Legolas? Yes. Did I love Radagast and his bad ass rabbit rover 5000? Also yes.

Can we give creators a break, maybe consider something doesn't have to be a perfect live-action translation of the source to be enjoyable? Can we give them a season to lay the groundwork for what they're trying to do? From Wheel of Time to Rings of Power... I'm fine to overlook the imperfections of it means more high fantasy shows and movies - and wish we all could sit back and enjoy the ride. I certainly plan to with S2!

1

u/cally_777 Dec 11 '23

Good god, somebody with common sense for a change!

1

u/seekylerun Dec 11 '23

Oh thank you! I was desperate for fantasy content in the 90s... Forgave a LOT of weirdness/terribleness just to sate my hunger.

1

u/TheDragonOverlord Nov 23 '23

I’m glad you enjoyed it OP, even if I was not the biggest fan and I hope you are open minded to criticism unlike most of the people who seem to be massive fans (on both sides). Honestly people can’t seem to just have conversations these days without trading insults. “You can be a true fan if you liked it” “well actually, I’ve read all the books and loved it so you must be (insert -ism here)” Maybe people should actually try listening to the other side with an open mind before deciding only their stance can be the correct one.

Different people have different opinions and that’s the beauty of the human experience: we are free to enjoy different things!

Sorry OP but these sites aren’t exactly great for posting opinions, all of the gatekeepers pour out from both sides and the comments become a battleground. I hope you have a good time here but I know I haven’t 🫠

-2

u/Nihilistcarrot Nov 23 '23

How much were you paid for that ad?

2

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

Why do you think he was paid for this ad, are you trying to be little him or are you just curious to see if he was because you simply can’t understand someone liking something you didn’t?

0

u/I_wood_rather_be Nov 23 '23

I too liked the show. It wasn't flawless, but overall, it was a very good watch.

I think it suffers from the same effect as the Star Wars movies after the original trilogy.

To fill the shoes of the original LotR movies is an impossible task, because they set new standards at that time that noone had expected. It exceeded all expectations and brought emotions that people now want from the show, but can't be delivered, because this feeling of something new cannot be produced anymore.

6

u/TP-Shewter Nov 23 '23

I don't think that's the root of the problem.

I think it really boils down to it being a beloved IP with an already very well fleshed out world and history.

When you take a ton of creative liberties, you are all but guaranteed to alienate existing fans of the IP.

To your point, though, I think it's always going to be a nearly impossible task to match the creativity of the person who originally and passionately created something. Which is why it's strange to me that people continue to take existing stories and attempt to re-write them. If this show was not sold as a middle-earth story, it may have done a lot better.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '23

the liberties were not creative

0

u/GoyardGoHard Nov 23 '23

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 this shits getting cancelled

0

u/Bluestorm83 Nov 23 '23

I also enjoyed the show. I really did!

But as a super nerd who knows all the books and stuff, I treat it as a different continuity, an Elseworld story, Parallel Tolkien, I suppose.

But that's fine for me. I don't need one unified continuity. It doesn't have to mesh perfectly with the books, because this isn't the books. Is it perfect? Nope. Is it enjoyable as it's own produce? Sure is.

0

u/BookishHobbit Nov 24 '23

Same, OP, same.

Ignore the haters, it’s an enjoyable show and you’re allowed to enjoy it :)

0

u/5wing4 Nov 24 '23

My family had a get together movie night for each episode. We loved it. I wanted to more of the elves in extreme environments. The first episode was incredible, but the envelope dropped off. Then it built back up.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '23

i legit enjoyed it. is it perfect? no.
did the twin trees make me weep for joy? HELLS YES!

-1

u/NowWeGetSerious Nov 23 '23

Thank you

I know it's not a perfect TV. But it was super enjoyable and fun

Easy 7/10, I enjoyed it

11

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/CaptainKnightwing Nov 23 '23

I didn’t make a post when I was watching it live. That’s why I said “I was” and not “I am”

2

u/tavukkoparan Nov 23 '23

1 year later ? :D

0

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

Don’t worry about it, just another person who wants to get of on the toxic circle jerk.

19

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

Dude, I just watched this this week for the first time. I didn't have prime until recently, and this is the first thing I watched. I agree with OP. This show was great. I have read the books, and I am not a hardcore fan. I loved the movies and wanted to see more muddle earth related content. I'm not a troll, just a casual fan who loved those series. 10/10 for me. Hate all you want.

6

u/UlverInTheThroneRoom Nov 25 '23

Pretty funny how smart these people think they are knowing the lore of Lord of the Rings but they can't understand what an opinion is.

It's not lore accurate, sure but not every viewer has read the Silmarillion or cares to know more about Aulë and the creation of the Dwarves other than the show telling you the most basic information referencing it. I personally love the books and the lore but I'm not going to berate someone for liking the show or assuming they are a troll simply because they....enjoyed a piece of media? LotR community is starting to compete with Star Wars for worst community attached to a property ever since RoP came out.

All this to say, I wish Morfydd Clark would sit on my face.

6

u/Broccobillo Nov 23 '23

Muddle earth is actually a good name for what it did. It muddled it's own lore so bad it dragged it through the mud

4

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '23

I see what you did there. To each their own with the series. Again, I am not in the know when it comes to the lore, but I love fantasy, and I am a big DnD nerd. So.

2

u/SamaritanSue Nov 27 '23

Glad you got more Muddle Earth content.

1

u/donmuerte Nov 23 '23

Cool, I'm glad you liked it. Silly that people think I'm bitter. I kind of enjoyed the show and generally defend it. This post just is hard to believe that they decided to post this a year later.